The departure of Samira Mohan and some of the responses to it can really boil down to a few salient points. All of which are... not informed, to say the least.
"She's a senior resident, of course she's leaving next season."
It's been confirmed for just about as long as we've known the show was getting renewed that season three would be a smaller time jump than between seasons one and two. That means, the time jump will be less than ten months. Which means that Samira Mohan will still be an R4.
There are residency programs that allow you to finish early if you complete all of your program's requirements ahead of time, but all of them are promote-in-place programs. Which means that even if Samira finished her residency early, she would need to be an attending at PTMC.
"But she's applying to a fellowship. It makes sense that she won't be there."
You cannot do a fellowship in a subspeciality without being at least board-eligible for your specialty. Samira will not be board-eligible until she finishes her residency on June 30, 2027.
"Her entire story has been about how she's not fit for emergency medicine."
Categorically, no. Samira Mohan's story has been about how she is the person that Robby transfers all of his fragmented parts of self onto. He does not see Samira Mohan. He sees the younger, more idealistic, more empathetic version of himself. When he is triggered and one of those younger parts surfaces, he lashes out at her.
By destroying her confidence and sense of self, that is what her story has become.
In season one, Samira Mohan's storyline was about how she had a grounded sense of self through the creation of stable priorities, values, and ethics as an emergency medicine physician. It was about how she may see things differently than her colleagues, but that does not make her any less valuable to the emergency department at PTMC. It was about how she can in fact, both take her time and be thorough with her patients to ensure they receive proper care and treatment, and flourish in an MCI situation with limited time and resources.
"Samira's storyline is just over, that's all. We'll see it wrapped up in the final episodes."
From Supriya's interview with Collider after episode 10:
You mentioned Mohan wanting a letter of recommendation from Robby, and there is a moment in this episode where she mentions she was hoping to circle up with Abbot to ask him for one. Her decision about what kind of specialty she wants to pursue has been hovering over her storyline this season. Do you feel like she's any closer to deciding what she wants to do than before, or is this question going to continue even heading into Season 3?
GANESH: If she starts the day with that question, it's very likely she's going to end the day with that question. If we wanted to push things along like that, things wouldn't be interesting. So I definitely think that she's asking for the recommendation because she would like to stay, but I don't know if that's something that initially gets resolved.
"Samira is being written off because Supriya Ganesh is going to medical school."
We literally don't know that. And taking their responses to questions out of context from a Teen Vogue interview that was conducted back in February isn't helpful.
"But Samira wants to leave PTMC."
Not according to Supriya Ganesh's interview with Collider:
"Robby's consistently hot and cold with her. It's a very paternal type of dynamic where you're not sure whether it's going to be a good day or bad day, especially with that type of fraught relationship. For her, she just wants to continue to impress him and feel... especially because she's looking for a place at PTMC next year, and she's a little like, "Okay, should I ask him for a recommendation?" She just wants to be on good terms with him, so she isn't really picking at him in the same way as he does in the following hours. I definitely think she's hoping she can get back on his good side."
From a television show that has fumbled the seriousness of a shoulder dystocia, how mandated reporting works in cases of suspected child abuse, and the proper HR protocol of re-integrating Langdon into the workplace.
Is it realistic for season 3 to be Samira's day off, or that she's at an away elective in New Jersey moving her shit out of her mom's house, or that she (or someone else!) finally reported Robby to HR for his treatment of her, and now they can't be on the same shift? Sure. Fine.
"It's just a storytelling decision."
And who is telling that story? Who are the executive producers? Who is the showrunner? Who are the lead writers?
Who made this decision to cut her out of season three, when Supriya Ganesh was still talking to the media pretty recently about her excitement about getting the script for season three, since Samira's arc in season two did not wrap up neatly, did have loose ends, and did need resolution. Who made the decision to write off Heather Collins? Who made the decision that it was Kiara's day off, that Gloria wouldn't get involved with the cyber attack?
areudirty
ellievsbear
yousharknotpass
