Things Meatloaf Would and Would Not Do for His Lover According to the Song "I'd Do Anything For Love (But I Wont Do That)" (1)
1. Help her move
2. Perform magic
3. Give her items to take home
4. Build her a sand castle
5. Hose her down were she to get too hot
Coming from someone who's recently moved I can confirm this first promise is worth at least $600 USD, depending on distance traveled and the degree to which he's insured and or licensed/bonded. Magic, on the other hand, gets him nowhere and if she's not into it could easily backfire. Items: these can go either way, but generally speaking, women like stuff so I'm going to say this is a net positive. Sand castles are good and imply beach access. Hosing her down if/when she gets too hot has a wide range of applications. Meatloaf really needs to exercise restraint here as an unwanted sex act could tip the balance against him.
1. Forgive himself if they didn't have intercourse immediately
2. Concede that it may be time to move on
3. Do a better job making love to someone else
4. Make love to another individual for a longer period of time than he does with her
So it turns out that what Meatloaf promises NOT to do implies a steady stream of future lovemaking and self-delusion. Although these promises seem to come from a place of genuine concern, they're deeply selfish. For this reason, it's my recommendation that Meatloaf focus on what he would do, as opposed to what he wouldn't.
(1) This is an edited and expanded version of a rejected McSweeney's submission from the summer of 2006. I have clearly failed in my attempt to write more often.