The Science of Us - Jack Abbot
jack abbot x reader, word count: 3.2k hurt/comfort, miscommunication, breakup/makeup trigger warnings: hospital visit, drink spiking
You were dragging your feet. Actually you were doing more than just that. You were dragging the mood down.
Everything you did felt tragic and as much as you painted on a smile or forced yourself to laugh at your friends jokes you were the buzzkill. The sad girl who couldn't get out of her own head after a breakup.
Your bed had a near permanent indent from where you laid for three days, unmoving except to use the restroom. Your fridge was full of untouched food and your mail was piling up because you couldn't bring yourself to go down to the lobby to collect it. You didn't want to risk running into him or risk running into anyone who knew that you were hooking up with your downstairs neighbor.
And you only felt worse when you remembered that he was doing just fine without you. He was unfazed. He was chugging along just fine. Because that's what Dr. Jack Abbot did.
So of course he was handling the breakup better. He was a professional. He was put together and he could compartmentalize like a champ.
Before him you thought you were the same. You thought you knew how to separate feelings from the tasks at hand. But here you were crying in bed with a mountain of tissues beside you. You were single handedly polluting the city of Pittsburgh with your tissue output and your room was turning into a biohazard.
It was embarrassing how poorly you were taking the breakup. Could you even call it that? You were seeing each other. Feeding each other. Fucking each other. But then you weren't. He stopped answering your calls. He avoided you in the lobby. And most of all he told you it was over when you finally built up the courage to plant yourself outside his apartment.
"I have long hours at work and you should focus on school."
School. He said it like you were some child who had homework waiting for her. You were a PhD candidate studying immunology. You were smart. You were focused. You were capable.
But you were incapable of forgetting the way you felt every time you caught Jack staring at you across the lobby or the way his hand felt on your lower back as he'd guide you into his place. You were intelligent and yet so naive when it came to what you were doing with him.
Your roommates started to grow worried after the first 48 hours. By hour 72 they interfered.
"He's like 50," Alana, your roommate whined. "Do not waste the last few weeks of your 20's sulking over him."
"He's only like 45," your other roommate, Chelsea, said in a hushed manner. "And he was a dilf so let's not shame her for going for an older man."
"Don't you have to have kids to be a dilf?"
You muffled your scream into a pillow before pointing to your doorway and asking, "Can you guys do this somewhere else?"
"Sorry," Chelsea said. "What we meant to say is that you have every right to be sad but he doesn't deserve this much sulking."
"Yeah the sex couldn't have been that good."
"Oh but it was," Chelsea snickered. "Don't you remember the moaning? She sounded like a porn star."
"Enough!"
You were in caffeine withdrawals, your nose and eyes were rubbed raw from the constant crying and sniffles, and your body was sore from lack of movement. The last thing you needed was to relive any prior experiences.
There were only a few days left of your spring break and once it concluded you'd be right back to lab reports and working on your dissertation. Your professors and colleagues wouldn't appreciate you crying into a microscope so you needed to get everything out of your system now.
"The sex was great, he was great, but he called it quits so can you just let me be sad?" you asked, sitting up against your headboard. "I just need some more time to process it."
"It's that bad?" Chelsea asked as she took a seat on the edge of your bed. "It hurts enough that you're not gonna go out tonight?"
It hurt enough that you hadn't eaten since the morning of the breakup. It was a blueberry muffin and you didn't know if that even counted because you ended up emptying your stomach in your bathroom the second you got back to your apartment.
"I know it's stupid, but this hurts more than the breakup with Oscar."
Your ex boyfriend had been with you for five years. You graduated college together, entered your doctoral programs together and you thought you'd have a family with him. And when you sat him down to call off your engagement your stomach felt like it was in your throat, but you picked yourself up by the bootstraps and made it work.
You had a ring on your finger for almost a year and taking it off didn't hurt as much as Jack dismissing you did. Because Jack made you feel like you were some fling that was a distraction rather than the girl he'd pick up from work and cook dinner for on his nights off. In one conversation he had made you feel worthless.
"I don't think Oscar made you feel how Jack made you feel," Alana said as she also climbed onto your bed. "So it's okay, but don't let him ruin you because there will be another guy who makes you feel sexy and smart and all of the things you are." She squeezed at your legs, forcing a laugh out of you.
"I just felt like he got me," you said while brushing away the tears that started to fall. "And after Oscar I thought nobody would get me. I thought I was someone that nobody would ever connect to."
"Okay well Jack did, so that is proof that Oscar was just a dud."
"Or its proof that I found the only person who would put up with me and he just decided he didn't want me anymore."
"He is not the only man in the world who will get you," Alana smiled. "You my love are one in a million. Not him."
***
Downstairs in apartment 1B was a near silent living room. The only sound reverberating through the space was the low hum of an air purifier. Every so often there was also the rumblings of the refrigerator ice maker, but other than that it was quiet.
That was wrong for Jack. He didn't do quiet. He needed exterior noise to tune out all the internal static. It's why he'd sometimes let his police scanner play as he was trying to fall asleep after his shifts.
When he started seeing you he kept it off. He no longer needed it. You were your own type of noise. Your jittery legs vibrated and your near constant smile screamed. Every time you walked into a room you spoke because even in silence your presence was loud.
When you first crossed paths Jack assumed that was a symptom of your youth. You were the cheerful girl from upstairs who was still in school and lived in a two bedroom apartment with three girls. He thought he read you like a book.
That was until you both got locked in the mailroom together one early morning. He was coming back from a tiring shift and you were coming back from pulling an all nighter in the lab.
And with one accidentally nudge of his prosthetic leg into the door stop he sent the both of you into an hour long camp out as you wanted for someone to come let you out.
"Can you call your wife?" you asked after noticing the ring on his hand.
"No, I can't," he said with a light laugh while twisting the band around his finger. "She passed a few years ago, the ring is just force of habit."
"Do you have someone you can call?"
You dropped your bag on the ground, slowly lowering yourself down with it. "I live with aspiring actors who moonlight as waitresses and since it's a weekend they're probably hungover on the couch."
"You're always up early." He noted. "What do you do?"
"PhD candidate in Immunology."
Jack hated it, but he found himself intrigued by you. It was a foreign feeling. He had found some of the travelling nurses attractive and he nearly went out with one of the administrators who passed through the pitt, but he never followed through with it. But you? Being trapped in a small glass box with you somehow didn't even register because he was too enamored.
The same went for you.
The broody guy who you only ever saw in the wee hours of the morning had you wrapped around his fingers as he asked you questions about your dissertation and work.
And when someone finally passed by the mail room neither of you even noticed.
You squinted, studying his face. "You're asking a lot of questions, but not answering any of mine."
"What do you want to know?"
"Which hospital you work at so I can injure myself and have some eye candy while I get patched up."
"Save yourself the injury," he said while reaching for your phone that was sitting in your lap. "We'll grab dinner and you can let me get to know more about how someone decides to study immunology at your age."
Your age.
Maybe that was the real nail in the coffin. You were just at different points in your lives. But you weren't. You were focused on your career. Starting a family felt like it was years away and you thought Jack knew that. You thought he knew you better.
And he thought the same, but when he came to pick you up from the bar one night it all clicked. He didn't know what he was doing with you.
You were lively and full of joy. You moved around every space like the sun. People flocked to you. And you were good at handling that. You were good at talking to strangers.
But when he saw the guys coming up to you, trying to make small talk, he felt like he was keeping you from doing the things that people like you did. You were meant to go out and be lively and get attention of others. You were meant to have your pick of the litter and he simply couldn't imagine being your pick. So he made the choice for you.
So in the quiet of Jack's apartment, there was no real silence because his mind was running a mile a minute. He was replaying that last conversation and how harsh he had been. But nothing was going to change. He was going to grab his bag and head into work because that's what he did best. And nobody would know the difference because he’d never let them.
And you would feel every big emotion that was coursing through your body until you started to worry that your emotions were too much. And everyone would notice the change because when you're someone who brightens every room with your smile it is painstakingly obvious when you're not smiling anymore.
***
That naive part of you that thought that you and Jack could function as a couple was the same naive part of you that thought you would never run into him again. You thought that if you timed your coming and going that you'd avoid any unnecessary interactions. You changed your go to coffee shop, you avoided the mailroom and most importantly you avoided PTMC.
You made a promise to yourself that you would stay clear of Jack Abbot. But Chelsea didn't make that same promise. During one of her late night bartending shifts she collapsed at work and was brought straight into the helpful hands of your ex boyfriend.
"Where is she?" You asked, not even bothering to make eye contact with him as you ran up to the ambulance bay. "Alana said she was brought here so where is she?"
Jack studied you. Your hair was pushed behind your ears and your sweatpants were low on your waist, barely saying up.
"She's inside."
"And?"
"You want me to violate HIPPA for you?" he asked while uncrossing his arms and placing his hands in his pockets.
"I'm her emergency contact," you said with a roll of your eyes. "Go check her file if you don't believe me."
There were plenty of thing he wanted to argue about. Like how thin you had gotten since the last time he saw you or how bloodshot your eyes were, but Chelsea's emergency contact information wasn't one of them.
"EMT’s said she was slurring her words, disoriented, unable to stay awake. We're waiting on lab results but it's looking like someone slipped her something."
You looked past him at the sliding doors. "Can I go see her?"
"Can you promise me that you won't turn your back on any drinks even around the bartenders you know?"
Your shoulder dropped at his comment. You didn’t want to argue. You didn’t have the energy to do that.
"Jack we've had this conversation before."
"And we're having it again."
You tossed your head back. "Out of all the conversations we've had you wanna redo the date rape talk?"
You were in awe of how oblivious he was to your feelings. How couldn't he see how deeply you missed him or how, even in anger, you wanted to feel his arms around you. Because every time you felt overwhelmed or unsteady he was the force that grounded you.
"Listen, it's been a rough few months so if you don't mind I'd like to go check on Chels."
"Is it the lab? Your professor?"
You sighed, "No, Jack," you said, trying to choose your words carefully. "It's been rough because I spend my downtime trying to figure out why the man I love couldn't love me back so save me the lectures about being careful because you have turned me into the most careful and untrusting version of myself."
Your arm brushed against his as you squeezed past him, but he didn't move. He was too busy processing your words. When he broke things off he assumed it was a favor to you—that he would be relinquishing you of the burden of being in a relationship with someone with his baggage. Instead he had given you your own.
Jack handed off Chelsea's care to Dr. Shen the second he snapped himself out of the trance that you put him in. It wasn't a hard ask, but it sent the peanut gallery into action. The night shift was its own beast, but the pitt usually saved the drama and big personalities for the day shift.
There were no butting heads or egos and the drama was only coming from patients. But now Jack had given everyone something to talk about.
They saw the way he looked after his talk with you and they noticed how he kept his eyes on central 6 even though Chelsea was no longer his patient.
And most of all Shen was in charge of her and he was going to get to the bottom of Jack's behavior one way or another.
"So her tox screen came back and it was positive for a pretty high dose of rohypnol which explains why she was reported to be slurring her words and was later found unconscious,” Dr Shen explained to you.
You head was in your hands, your fingers pressing into your scalp. "And what is the treatment for this?"
"Well right now we're just gonna keep giving her fluids and monitor her until she regains consciousness but her blood pressure is good and she's got a clear airway."
You took a beat, trying to translate the information into something digestible and something you could explain to Alana who was already blowing up your phone asking for updates.
"If you have more questions I can always grab my colleague,” he said, motioning out of the room.
You looked over his shoulder out at the nurses station where Jack was staring at the board. "Oh no I think he already got an earful from me."
"You guys know each other?"
You motioned to Chelsea. "We're his upstairs neighbors."
"He's the grumpy downstairs guy complaining that you guys walk too loud, isn't he?" Shen said, a shit eating grin taking over his face. He was only getting breadcrumbs but it would be more than enough to report back to Parker.
"No." You looked down at your hands as you made a late night realization. You had found so many reasons to hate Jack over the last few months but on paper it was impossible. Because other than breaking your heart he was respectable, kind, and caring. "Actually he hasn't ever complained about us."
"I would have lost that bet."
From what you knew about Dr. Shen he lost most of the bets he made, but you kept that to yourself and turned your attention back to Chelsea.
Your eyes didn't leave her—not until you succumbed to your exhaustion and allowed your eyes to fall shut. It didn't take long for Jack to notice your body curled up in a chair, your legs tucked up against your chest and your head propped up by your hand.
You weren't sure how long you were out for for but when you came to there was a blanket covering your body and an iced coffee sitting on the ground beside you.
***
It wasn’t until 10am when Chelsea finally came to and recognized her surroundings and it wasn't until a week later that you got the nerve to knock on Jack's door to address the pitt sized elephant that was occupying your mind.
"Chelsea wanted me to thank you." You rushed out the words, fearing that his door would shut in your face once he saw that it was you interrupting his mid day nap. He was no longer in his scrubs. He had on a thin white teeshirt that had wet spots covering the shoulders from his hair that was still damp and a pair of sweatpants covered his bottom half. “And I wanted to thank you,” you added when he didn’t respond.
"I'm glad she's doing better."
"So am I," you said, taking a step back. "I'll let you get back to it."
"Are you doing better?"
His words halted you. There was no easy way to answer his question. If you ignored him you’d only be adding fuel to the fire and if you answered him honestly you’d be opening up a can of worms.
"Jack, I said enough that day, dont you think?"
He huffed. "But I didn't say enough."
It was too late for kicking the can down the road. It was time to play everything out on the table.
"I called things off because I saw how vibrant your life was when I wasn't around and I didnt want to corrupt you with my night shift nonsense and the gloom and doom of trauma medicine and PTSD,” he said, “and you got so much going for you and I can't be the reason that you dim the spark so I figured it would be for the best if we parted ways."
Nobody had ever described you as having a spark. Oscar said you were hyper and over caffeinated. He said you didn’t know how to turn off the charm and be real. He made you feel like you were a fraud for being who you thought he wanted you to be.
"I'm not sure if you've noticed but I'm pretty sure that vibrancy came from having you in my life," you said, motioning to your current state. Your skin was dull, the bags under your eyes were becoming a permanent fixture and your clothes no longer accentuated your body, they simply just draped over you. "And that is a toxic way to think but I know how I felt when we were together."
"But I saw you when we weren't."
"What does that even mean?"
"It means I saw you when you were out with your friends. You lit up every room, people flocked to you and you just weren't like that when I was with you. It was like I blew out a candle.”
"I was like that when you weren't around because that's how I feel like I have to be. But with you I could drop the fucking act and just exist. I didn't have to be some perfect trophy or the interesting girl with the cool job. I could be whichever side of me I wanted to be and you'd always accept it."
Where Oscar made you feel like a fake and a fraud, Jack made you feel like you were one of a kind. You never had to question if you were being too shy or too excited. You could show up and exist as you were. No questions asked.
"You didn't dim the spark," you said, "if anything you protected it and I'm not asking you to rethink there being an us but I am asking you to at least rethink your hypothesis because it was incredibly flawed and as a scientist it would be unethical for me to not point that out."
He leaned against his doorframe, his arms crossed over his chest. "And if my hypothesis was rejected what would be the outcome?"
You swallowed hard, trying your best to force your feelings down so that they didn't overflow in the middle of the apartment hallway.
"Technically speaking you'd have to provide an alternative hypothesis."
Jack nodded, his eyes focused on the ground. It felt like an eternity before he stood straight. "Would you accept a hypothesis where I'm an idiot who ruins things when they get good because I can't imagine a world where things go right for me?"
You closed the gap, stepping forward and bringing your hands to his face, forcing him to look at you.
"Yeah, I would." You nodded. "But I'd tell you that I'm the same way. The only difference is that I keep telling myself that I ruined things in the past because I was meant to be here and I'm not always right but I really do think I was right when I picked you."














