garrett graham âď¸ house law.
pairing â garrett graham x reader summary â deanâs ex was meant to be off-limits. garrett has several problems with that. warnings â suggestive content, heated kissing, sexual references, situationship tension, arguing, strong language, dean being possessive-ish, party/alcohol setting notes from me â loosely based on this ask!! thank u for sending it through babe! xx word count â 8.9k
navigation â masterlist | taglist
The first time she realises Garrett Graham might actually be a problem, heâs sitting on the playersâ bench after practice with damp curls, flushed cheeks, and a towel slung around the back of his neck, talking about leadership like he hasnât spent the last forty minutes making half the men on the ice look mildly unemployable.
The rink has that post-practice emptiness to it now, all scraped-up ice and cold metal and fluorescent light, the air still carrying the sharp wet smell of snow, rubber, and boy sweat no amount of ventilation has ever fully defeated.Â
The rest of the team has already filtered out in waves of noise, sticks clattering, showers starting somewhere down the hall, somebody yelling something obscene about Loganâs tape job from the locker room. Garrett had stayed behind because sheâd asked for a few more minutes, and because being captain also meant being professionally accommodating to journalism majors with deadlines and a possibly self-destructive interest in his forearms.
Sports journalism was, allegedly, her actual academic focus. This was supposed to be clean. Useful. A feature piece on Briar hockey culture through the lens of the captain everyone on campus already had some opinion about.Â
Garrett Graham, projected pro prospect, Bruins interest, team leader, annoyingly handsome campus fixture with a smile that had almost certainly caused several GPA drops across the student body.Â
She had come prepared with questions. She had her recorder running on the bench between them, her notebook open across one thigh, her pen uncapped and ready in her hand like a woman with purpose and professional integrity.
Then Garrett started answering properly, and that had become its own issue. He was good at being smug, obviously. That part was easy. Garrett carried arrogance like some men carried cologne, lightly applied but immediately noticeable.Â
But when she asked him about being captain, about what it felt like to have younger guys looking to him, about whether the Bruins pressure changed the way he saw the rest of the season, he leaned forward with his elbows on his knees, one hand turning a roll of tape between his fingers.Â
He spoke with this unexpected care that made it annoyingly difficult to remember she was meant to be extracting quotes and not just sitting there watching his mouth form words.
âI donât know,â he says, eyes moving briefly to the rink like the ice might have an answer written somewhere under all the skate marks. âPeople act like captain means youâre the guy with the loudest voice in the room. Sometimes it is, sure. Sometimes you gotta call shit out. But most of itâs just⌠paying attention. Knowing which freshman needs to get his ass kicked in practice and which one needs you to pretend not to notice heâs about to puke from nerves before a game.â
Her pen hovers.
Garrett huffs a little laugh, looking down at the tape. âThat makes me sound nicer than I am.â
âIt really does,â she says, without thinking.
His eyes flick back to her, amused. âWow.â
âNo, I meanââ She laughs, because his grin has gone sharp now, pleased and teasing and very aware heâs caught her somewhere. âI mean, itâs a good answer. Annoyingly good. Like, Iâm going to have to cut some of it down or people will start thinking youâre emotionally intelligent.â
He presses a hand dramatically to the centre of his chest. âThat would ruin me.â
âCompletely. Your whole brand gone overnight.â
âMy brand is very layered, actually.â
She raises an eyebrow. âIs it?â
âYeah. Hot, talented, emotionally unavailable but, like, in a charming way.â
She snorts before she can stop herself, and Garrettâs grin widens like her laugh is something heâs earned and plans to be unbearable about.
The thing is, he keeps doing this. Slipping between real and ridiculous so smoothly she never has time to brace for either version. One second heâs making some dumb comment about Logan being held together by athletic tape and poor decision-making, the next heâs talking about pressure in a voice low enough that the empty rink seems to lean in around them.Â
He talks about the Bruins carefully, not like a boy pretending not to care, but like someone who cares so much heâs had to teach himself not to flinch every time someone says the word future near him.
âItâs there,â he says, after she asks whether the scouting attention ever messes with his head. His hand stills around the tape. âEven when Iâm trying not to think about it. Itâs there. People talk like going pro is this finish line, right? Like once somebody wants you, youâre supposed to just be grateful and shut up. But itâs weird. Itâs a lot of people having plans for your body before youâve even finished using it where you are.â
She forgets, for a second, to breathe normally. Thereâs no tragic little performance, no athlete pretending vulnerability because it looks good in a profile. Simply Garrett, sweat drying at his temples, towel loose around his neck, saying something true because she asked the right question and he trusted her enough to answer it.
Her pen hasnât moved in at least thirty seconds. Garrett notices. His eyes drop to her notebook, then lift again slowly to her face, one brow rising. âAre you supposed to be writing this down?â
For one horrible second, she just blinks at him. Then she looks down at the blank stretch of page beneath her last half-written sentence and makes a sound so undignified it bounces off the empty seats. âOh, fuck. Yes. Shit. Sorry.â
Garrett bursts out laughing.
âDonât laugh,â she says, already scribbling so fast the words are barely forming. âYou said something good and I got distracted.â
âYou got distracted?â
She gives him a look without lifting her head, though the effect is slightly ruined by the fact that she is smiling like an idiot. âBy the quote. The quote was good.â
âSure.â
âIt was.â
He shrugs. âI believe you.â
âYouâre being smug.â
He laughs again, softer this time, and when she glances up, heâs already watching her. His elbows are still on his knees, shoulders rounded forward, the tape forgotten between his hands. His smileâs faded into something smaller, warmer, almost private, and the look of it moves through her body in a way that makes the cold rink air feel suddenly useless.
Her fingers tighten around the pen. Garrettâs gaze drops, briefly, to her mouth.
The silence shifts. Loud in all the places neither of them is touching. She can hear someone in the locker room bark out a laugh, distant and echoing, but it might as well be happening in another building.
Then Garrett clears his throat and looks away first, jaw flexing once like heâs physically pulled himself back from the edge of something. âSo,â he says, voice just rough enough to betray him. âYou need more captain wisdom or can I go shower before I become part of the rink?â
She looks down at her notebook because it is safer than his face. âI think Iâve got enough wisdom for one day.â
âSmart. Too much and youâll fall in love with me.â
Her laugh comes out too quick. Too exposed. âYeah, God forbid.â
He stands, and even thatâs irritating: the size of him unfolding beside the bench, broad shoulders, hockey thighs, damp curls, all that casual physical confidence men get when theyâve never once had to question whether their body works in their favour. He grabs his gloves and stick, then pauses at the gate.
âSame time Thursday?â
She nods. âFor the follow-up.â
âRight,â he says, and his mouth does that slow, dangerous little curve. âThe follow-up.â
Then he walks away before she can decide whether to throw her pen at him or herself.
By the time Garrett drops into the chair beside her in the cafeteria two days later, she has one hand buried in a bag of chips, half a sandwich abandoned on a napkin, and fourteen open tabs on her laptop because higher education is mostly just creating new and inventive ways to make Google Docs feel judgmental.
âJesus,â Garrett says, leaning sideways to peer at her screen. âYou writing an article or hacking the Pentagon?â
She doesnât look up immediately. âBoth. Donât tell anyone.â
âHot.â
That gets her eyes off the screen. Garrettâs already grinning, backwards cap low over his curls, hoodie sleeves shoved up to his forearms. He has a tray in front of him loaded with the deeply alarming quantity of food hockey players treat as a casual lunch, and he looks far too pleased with himself for a man who has interrupted her academic suffering with one word and too much eye contact.
She fights the smile. Loses. âDo you just sit wherever you want?â
âYeah.â
âThat tracks.â
âThis seat taken?â
âYouâre already sitting in it.â
âGreat. Love when stuff works out.â
She rolls her eyes and reaches for her iced coffee, mostly so her hands have something to do that isnât immediately stupid, like touching the bit of hair curling out from under his cap. âDonât you have captain things to do?â
âI am doing captain things.â
âYouâre eating fries next to me.â
âTeam morale starts with carbs.â
âYouâre such an inspiration.â
âI get that a lot.â
He steals one of her chips without asking, which should be annoying but is somehow just familiar now, another one of those tiny domestic trespasses theyâve started building between them without ever discussing it.Â
He asks about her other assignment, some feature for a media ethics class that has made her want to walk calmly into a pond, and then actually listens while she talks. He leans back in his chair, chewing thoughtfully, asking questions that are annoying only because theyâre good.
âSo basically,â he says after she explains the whole thing, âyour professor wants you to prove journalists shouldnât be assholes.â
âMy tuition dollars at work.â
âCouldâve saved you a semester. Donât be an asshole. Boom. Done.â
She points a fry at him. âThatâs a devastatingly Briar hockey interpretation of media ethics.â
âYouâre welcome.â
âIâm not thanking you.â
âYouâre thinking about it.â
She laughs, and it happens too easily now. Garrett makes laughing feel like slipping. Like she can brace all she wants and still end up somewhere warmer than where she started. He keeps looking at her like heâs delighted by the exact shape of her thoughts, like he wants to be around for whatever she says next, even when what she says next is technically an insult.
Across the cafeteria, someone calls his name. Garrett doesnât look away from her. That does something embarrassing to the back of her neck.
âSo,â he says, picking up his drink. âYou gonna quote me in this ethics thing too?â
âOnly if I need a source on moral decline.â
He grins, biting softly at the inside of his lip. âMean.â
âAccurate.â
He opens his mouth, probably to say something unbearable, when Deanâs voice cuts across the cafeteria with the clean sharpness of a puck hitting glass.
âG.â
Garrettâs expression changes so quickly she almost misses it. The humour doesnât disappear, but it gets filed away. His shoulders tense by half an inch. He turns, and she follows his gaze to where Dean and Logan have just come through the cafeteria entrance, Logan with a smoothie in one hand and the relaxed posture of a man whoâs wandered accidentally into tension he fully intends to enjoy.
Dean, on the other hand, looks pissed. He stands there in a jacket that probably costs more than her laptop, blond hair messy, jaw tight, eyes moving from Garrett to her and back again with something sharp underneath.
Garrett exhales through his nose. âIâll talk to you later,â he says, already pushing his chair back.
She looks between them, trying to keep her face normal. âYeah. Sounds good.â
He grabs his tray, then hesitates, turning back like heâs remembered something he very much doesnât want to leave unsaid. âHey,â he says. âYou going to Beauâs mask thing?â
âThe masquerade party?â She feels Deanâs stare from across the room like a physical object, which is absurd and irritating and makes her sit a little straighter. âItâs after the game, right? Yeah, Iâll be there.â
Garrettâs grin comes back just enough to make her stomach dip. âSweet. See you there.â
She tilts her head, trying to sound light even though the air has gone weird around them. âYeah. Or not. Because of the masks.â
He nods solemnly. âNo, totally. Could be anyone. Real mystery.â
âVery mysterious.â
âGuess Iâll have to use my detective skills.â
âYou have those?â
âNo,â he says. âBut Iâm hot, so people help me.â
She laughs, and he smiles like heâs taking that with him.
Then Dean says, louder, âGarrett.â
Garrettâs jaw moves once. âYeah, man, Iâm coming.â
He walks away from her table and over to them, and for a few seconds she tries very hard to return to her laptop like she hasnât just become fascinated by the worldâs stupidest male summit happening beside the salad bar. It doesnât work. Her eyes keep cutting over, catching pieces.
Dean talking low and fast, one hand moving once in a sharp, irritated gesture. Garrett looking away, then back at him, expression shut down into something stubborn. Logan standing just behind them, eyebrows slightly raised, smoothie straw at his mouth, looking like he would pay actual money for popcorn if the cafeteria stocked it.
Deanâs gaze flicks back to her. She looks down too late.
The whole thing sits strangely under her skin after that, a small ugly pebble in the shoe of an otherwise normal afternoon. Dean has no reason to look at her like that. Dean has no reason to chew Garrett out over sitting with her at lunch, unless Garrett has told him something, unless sheâs misread the last few weeks completely, unless the reason Garrett keeps getting close and then stopping is not because he doesnât want her, but because Dean somehow still thinks he gets a vote.
The thought irritates her enough that she closes three tabs too hard, as if her laptop deserves consequences.
âYouâre kidding.â
She looks up from where sheâs sitting on the bench near the rink entrance, one skate half-laced, the other sitting on the floor like a weapon designed by sadists. âIâm not kidding.â
Garrett stares at her. âYouâve never skated?â
âNo.â
âEver?â
âNo.â
Garrett gestures loosely. âLike, not even badly at a birthday party when you were twelve?â
âI grew up near tennis courts, not ice rinks, Garrett. We had other hobbies.â
He makes a wounded sound. âYouâre writing a piece on hockey.â
âIâve watched hockey.â
âThatâs not the same.â
She tilts her head. âIâve also interviewed hockey players.â
âStill not the same.â
âI watched you practice for three weeks.â
âStill,â he says, pointing at her with his stick, ânot the same.â
She bends back over the skate, tugging at the lace with the kind of aggression that suggests the boot has personally wronged her. âIf this is about journalistic integrity, Iâll put a disclosure at the bottom. The author has never voluntarily placed herself on a knife shoe.â
Garrett laughs, then crouches in front of her before she can fully process the movement. One second heâs standing there, being tall and smug and irritatingly warm in a Briar hoodie, and the next heâs on one knee between her feet, taking the laces out of her hands like this is a thing his body has decided is allowed.
âHere,â he says. âYouâre doing it wrong.â
Her mouth goes dry in a way that feels deeply inconvenient. âIâm tying shoes wrong?â
âYouâre tying skates wrong.â
âDifferent sacred art?â
âVery different.â His headâs bent, curls falling forward as he works the laces with quick, practiced hands. âYou want them tight through the ankle or youâre gonna fold like a lawn chair.â
âComforting.â
âIâm a great teacher.â
âYou just compared me to outdoor furniture.â
âA beloved piece of outdoor furniture.â
She bites her lip around a smile and watches his hands instead of his face because his face is worse. His fingers are broad and nicked in little places, tape residue near one knuckle, nails cut short.Â
He tightens the skate with firm, efficient pulls, one hand briefly wrapping around the back of her ankle to hold her steady, and the touch is so normal, so practical, that her body has absolutely no business reacting to it like heâs slid his palm under her shirt.
Garrett glances up. She looks away immediately, which is subtle in the way a car alarm is subtle. He says nothing, because heâs learned mercy in one or two isolated categories, and finishes tying the second skate.
Getting onto the ice is an act of public humiliation, except thereâs no public, thank God, just Garrett, which might actually be worse. He steps on first with the careless ease of a person whose body understands frozen water as a workplace, then turns and offers both hands.
She grips them immediately. âIf I die, Iâm haunting you.â
âYouâre not gonna die.â
âYou donât know that.â
âI kinda do.â
âYouâre too confident.â
He laughs, pulling her gently forward. âOkay. One foot.â
The first skate touches the ice and immediately slides an inch in a direction she did not approve. âNope.â
âYes.â
She frowns. âNo, Garrett.â
âYouâre fine. Both feet, come on.â
She gets both feet onto the ice and grabs his hands so tightly he huffs a laugh, but he doesnât tease her as much as he could. Thatâs another thing about Garrett, one she hates more than the smugness because itâs harder to protect against. He knows exactly when to push and when not to.Â
He grins, sure, but his hands stay steady around hers, thumbs warm over the backs of her fingers, his skates braced wide enough that she knows without question he could hold her up if she fully lost it.
âThere you go,â he says, softer. âSee? Youâre doing it.â
âIâm standing.â
âStanding is part of skating.â
She grips his hands tighter. âIâm incredible.â
âGenerational talent.â
She laughs, then immediately squeals because the laugh disrupts whatever fragile treaty her ankles had formed with physics. Her legs straighten wrong, the skates slip, and she pitches forward straight into him.
Garrett catches her like itâs nothing. She hits his chest with a breathless little sound, hands landing on his biceps, his hands coming to her waist fast and firm. The impact knocks a laugh out of both of them, and for a second theyâre just there, tangled and stupid, her skates sliding uselessly while Garrett holds her upright with the kind of casual strength that makes several parts of her brain quietly resign.
âHi,â he says.
She looks up at him. His face is close. Too close for any version of this thatâs still pretending to be about skating. His cheeks are pink from the cold, curls messy under the rink lights, grin fading as his eyes move over her face.Â
His hands are still at her waist. Hers are still wrapped around his arms, and holy fuck, his arms. Solid under her fingers, warm through his hoodie, steady in a way that makes leaning into him feel less like a choice and more like gravity having a point for once.
âHi,â she says back, and it comes out smaller than she intended.
His throat moves. The rink is quiet around them. Huge and cold and empty, boards rising white around the ice, old skate cuts beneath their feet, one distant machine hum somewhere behind the walls.Â
She can feel his breath against her cheek now. She can feel the tiny adjustment of his fingers at her waist, like heâs reminding himself not to pull her closer and doing a bad job of it.
She tilts her face up. A question more than a move, her mouth parted slightly, her eyes dropping to his lips because sheâs tired of pretending not to want the thing theyâve both been standing too close to for weeks. Garrett goes still. Completely still, except for the rise of his chest under her hands.
Her eyes flutter shut. His hands tighten once at her waist. Then he pulls back.
Itâs not far, barely an inch. But itâs enough to let cold air rush between them, enough to make her eyes open and her stomach drop with the ugly, immediate heat of embarrassment.
âI canât,â Garrett says, voice low.
She blinks at him. âWhat?â
His jaw works. He looks genuinely pained, which would be more flattering if she didnât currently want to throw him into the boards. âI canât.â
âWhy?â
âBecauseââ He glances away, breath coming out through his nose in a hard little huff. âBecause of Dean.â
The name lands wrong. Wrong in her body, sour and metallic. She loosens her grip on his arms. âWhat about Dean?â
Garrettâs eyes cut back to hers. âCome on.â
âNo, donât come on me.â She shifts back on the skates, immediately wobbles, and grabs the boards beside them with one hand because anger, while energising, isnât an adequate substitute for balance. âWhat about Dean?â
âYou guys dated.â
âWe barely dated.â
âYou were together for, what, three months?â
âWe hooked up for three months,â she says, sharper now. âSometimes. When we were both free. It wasnât a great tragic love story. We hung out at parties and occasionally made out in laundry rooms.â
Garrett winces. âI really donât need the visual.â
âThen donât bring him up while Iâm trying to kiss you.â
His eyes flash at that, heat cutting through the restraint for half a second before he shuts it down again. âYou think I want to be bringing him up?â
âI donât know what you want, Garrett, because every time I think youâre finally about to do something about the fact that you keep looking at me like that, you suddenly remember friendship law.â
âFriendship law?â
âBro code, house code, whatever the fuck you guys call the sacred little pact where nobody is allowed to touch anyone someone else once had mediocre sex with.â
His mouth twitches despite himself, then immediately flattens. âIâm trying not to be a dick to my friend.â
Her eyes flash. âYouâre doing a great job being a dick to me instead.â
âIâm not trying to be a dick to you,â he says.
âNo? Because it feels pretty dick-ish from here.â
He drags a hand through his hair, turning away for half a second like he needs the rink to help him survive the conversation. His skates shift on the ice with a clean scrape. âJesus Christ.â
âWhat?â
âDean put a rule down, okay?â
The whole world narrows. Her fingers tighten around the top of the boards. âWhat rule?â
Garrett looks back at her and immediately seems to realise, too late, that heâs opened the wrong door.
She steps toward him, or tries to. The skates slide. She catches herself, furious enough that fear of the ice has temporarily become background noise. âGarrett. What rule?â
His shoulders sink. âHe said you were hands off.â
For a second, she just stares at him. The rink noise fades into a thin ringing at the edge of her ears. Her face goes hot first, then her chest, then the backs of her hands, a spreading flush of disbelief so sharp it feels almost cold underneath. âHe said I was what?â
Garrett rubs a hand over his mouth. âHockey house is hands off. Thatâs what he said.â
âHockey house is hands off,â she repeats, slowly, because maybe if she says it back, the words might become less insane. They do not. They get worse. They sit there between them, stupid and male and possessive in a way that makes her want to start swinging one of his sticks around until something expensive breaks.
âItâs notââ Garrett starts.
âNo.â
He stops.
âNo, donât do that. Donât soften it. Donât try to translate asshole into something prettier.â Her laugh comes out once, bright and humourless. âDean put a no touching rule on me?â
Garrettâs face has gone sheepish now, which, unfortunately for him, only makes him look guilty by association. âI didnât make the rule.â
âBut you followed it.â
His jaw tightens. âHeâs my teammate. Heâs my friend.â
âAnd Iâm a couch he called dibs on?â
Garrett flinches. âThatâs not how I see you.â
âBut itâs how he talked about me, and you all just what? Nodded? Took minutes? Filed it under house law?â
âNo.â He skates closer, hands half-lifted like he wants to steady her and knows better than to touch. âNo, it wasnât like that.â
âThen what was it like?â
He opens his mouth. Closes it.
She gives a short, furious nod. âRight.â
Then she turns toward the exit. Badly. The skates immediately betray her.
Garrett moves on instinct, catching her elbow before she can eat shit in the middle of the ice. âHeyââ
âDo not hey me!â
âIâm just trying to stop you from breaking your ass.â
âMy ass and I are leaving.â
âYou canât storm off in skates.â
She huffs. âWatch me.â
âYou physically cannot.â
âI will crawl.â
âJesus,â he mutters, skating backward as she clings angrily to the boards and inches toward the gate with all the dignity of a newborn deer seeking vengeance. âCan I at least help you?â
âNo.â
âYouâre going the wrong way.â
She shoots him a look. âI know where Iâm going.â
âYouâre heading toward the penalty box.â
âMaybe I belong there.â
He lets out a breath that almost sounds like a laugh and immediately thinks better of it when she looks at him.
By the time they get her off the ice and out of the skates, her anger has focused into something clean and bright. Garrett follows her out of the rink with her bag over one shoulder and the expression of a man walking behind an active bomb heâs personally helped assemble.
âYou donât have to do this right now,â he says as she shoves her feet into her boots.
âYes, I do.â
âMaybe cool off first.â
She looks at him. âYou think Iâm going to cool off about being declared untouchable by a guy who once texted me you up? at one in the morning with a typo?â
Garrettâs mouth presses together.
âDonât laugh.â
He shakes his head. âIâm not.â
âYou want to.â
âI really donât.â
âYou do. Youâre just scared of me right now.â
âA little,â he admits.
âGood.â
The hockey house door swings open before Garrettâs even finished taking his keys out of the door, because God wants Logan to have front-row seats. Logan looks from her face to Garrettâs face to the fact that Garrett is holding her skate bag like a guilty chauffeur, and his eyebrows go up with immediate, delighted dread. âOh, this feels like something I should not be in the doorway for.â
âWhereâs Dean?â she asks.
Loganâs eyes widen slightly. âKitchen.â
âGreat.â
She steps past him.
Garrett follows. âMaybe we donâtââ
âNo, youâre coming too.â
âYeah,â Logan says, shutting the door behind them with the dazed cheerfulness of a man blessed by entertainment. âYouâre definitely coming too.â
The house smells like takeout, laundry detergent, and whatever tragic candle Tucker keeps lighting in a hopeless attempt to make four athletes living together seem less like a public health concern.Â
Somewhere upstairs, music thumps faintly. The living room is half-clean in the deeply male way, meaning thereâs no visible trash on the floor but several cups have been abandoned on flat surfaces with the confidence of people who believe dishes migrate naturally.
Deanâs in the kitchen with Tucker, leaning against the counter with a bowl of cereal at nearly six in the evening because money, talent, and good bone structure havenât made him any less fundamentally ridiculous.Â
He looks up when she walks in. Then he sees Garrett behind her. Then he sees her face.
âOh,â Tucker says quietly from beside the fridge. âShit.â
Dean straightens. âWhat?â
She stops on the other side of the island, hands flat on the counter because otherwise she might start pointing and never stop. âDid you tell the entire hockey house I was hands off?â
Deanâs eyes cut to Garrett. âSeriously, man?â
Garrett lifts one hand. âDonât look at me like that. I didnât issue a royal decree over her body.â
âThank you,â she snaps, then points at Dean. âYou. Answer.â
Dean sets the cereal bowl down slowly. âIt wasnât the entire hockey house.â
Logan, arriving behind Garrett with exactly the expression of someone entering a theatre late but thrilled, says, âIt was kind of the entire hockey house.â
âLogan,â Dean warns.
âWhat? Iâm pro-transparency.â
She stares at Dean. âYou put a rule on me.â
Deanâs jaw tightens. âIt wasnât like that.â
âOh my God, does every man in this house get issued that sentence at orientation?â
Tucker coughs into his fist. Garrett looks at the floor.
Deanâs face flushes, irritation rising fast now that he has an audience and no graceful exit. âI told them not to mess with you.â
âWhy?â
âBecause.â
âBecause what?â
âBecause I didnât want them to.â
She laughs once, so sharp Tucker actually looks toward the sink like he might find somewhere safer to stand. âThatâs not an answer. That is something a toddler says about a toy truck.â
Deanâs mouth opens, then closes. He drags a hand through his hair, annoyed and cornered and visibly trying to decide how much honesty he can survive in front of Logan, Tucker, and Garrett. Not much, judging by the colour in his face.
âYou and I had a thing,â he says.
âWe hooked up.â
âWe hung out.â
âYes, Dean, thatâs generally how hooking up more than once works. Sometimes thereâs a couch involved. Maybe a movie nobody watches.â
Logan murmurs, âEducational.â
Dean points at him without looking. âShut up.â
She leans forward over the counter. âWe were casual.â
âMaybe to you.â
Deanâs face changes as soon as he says it, like the words have come out uglier and more vulnerable than he planned. Garrett stills behind her. Tuckerâs expression softens by a fraction. Logan stops smiling quite so much.
Dean swallows hard, then doubles down because vulnerability has made him defensive. âI liked you.â
Her grip on the counter loosens, then tightens again. âDean.â
âNo, donât Dean me. I did. I liked you, and you didnât like me back.â
âI liked you fine.â
âYou liked me fine,â he repeats, voice going high with disbelief. âGreat. Awesome. Thatâs exactly what every guy wants to hear.â
âWe werenât in love.â
âI didnât say we were in love.â
âYouâre acting like I left you at the altar.â
âIâm acting like maybe it sucked watching you giggle with my best friend for three weeks after you decided you were too busy to text me back.â
Garrett winces. âOkay, letâs notââ
She turns her head. âYou stay quiet.â
Garrett shuts his mouth.
Dean lets out a humourless laugh. âYeah, good luck with that, G.â
She points back at Dean immediately. âDonât redirect because youâre embarrassed.â
Dean shrugs. âIâm not embarrassed.â
âYou should be. You made a house rule about me like Iâm a disputed parking space.â
Deanâs face twists. âI didnât want to watch my friends go after you.â
âThen say that to me like an adult.â
âI didnât think I owed you a fucking press release.â
She smacks her hand down on the counter. âYou owed me basic dignity.â
Deanâs mouth shuts, and for one tiny second he looks less like Briarâs rich blond menace and more like a twenty-one-year-old guy who handled hurt feelings with the political structure of a frat basement.
Then, because heâs still Dean, he recovers poorly. âWell, sorry I didnât want Garrettâs tongue down your throat two months after mine.â
Garrettâs head snaps up. âHey.â
âOh, fuck off,â she says, loud enough that even Loganâs eyebrows jump. âYou donât get to act wounded and crude in the same breath like that makes you honest.â
Deanâs eyes flash. âYou think Iâm making it up? You two have been doing this little interview foreplay thing all over campus like everybody doesnât see it.â
Garrett mutters, âJesus Christ.â
She feels heat hit her face but refuses to look away. âMaybe if you had an issue, you couldâve talked to me instead of telling half the hockey team they needed permission to touch me.â
Dean scoffs. âI knew you liked him.â
âYes, Dean. Congratulations. Your powers of observation survived your personality.â
Logan makes a strangled sound behind his smoothie. Dean points at her, the hurt cracking fully into the argument now, messy and oddly sincere under all the stupidity. âYou didnât look at me like that.â
âNo, because you hooked up with someone else the same night you hooked up with me.â
Dean throws both hands out. âBut I liked you more!â
The entire kitchen goes silent. Tucker closes his eyes. Garrettâs lips part in actual disbelief. Logan whispers, âThat is an insane defence.â
She stares at Dean for one long second, then says, âAre you medically okay?â
Dean groans, dragging both hands down his face. âThat came out wrong.â
âDid it?â
âYes.â
âBecause from here, it sounded like you were asking for emotional credit for ranking me first in a rotation.â
Garrett mutters, âHoly shit,â under his breath, and she cannot tell whether itâs horror or admiration.
Dean drops his hands. His face is red now, properly red. âI know I was shitty. I didnât handle it right. You were⌠I donât know. You were cool, and fun, and you didnât need anything from me, and then you were gone. And I was a dick about it.â
She watches him for a second, her pulse still hot in her wrists. Dean looks back at her with more honesty than he probably meant to bring into the kitchen, and that makes it harder to stay perfectly furious.Â
âYou donât get to be a dick by making rules about me,â she says.
His jaw tightens, but he nods once. âYeah.â
âIâm serious.â
âI know.â
âNo, I donât think you do.â She steps around the island, close enough now that Deanâs eyes drop briefly like heâs checking whether she plans to slap him. She doesnât. She wants to, a little, but personal growth and witness presence both intervene. âYou can feel weird. You can be hurt. You can tell Garrett you donât love it. You can even privately sulk like a blond little prince in your room if thatâs what your healing journey requires.â
Logan whispers, âBlond little prince.â
Dean says, âShut the fuck up.â
âBut you do not get to decide what Iâm allowed to do because your feelings arrived late and badly dressed.â
Tucker nods once, like this is fair. Dean looks at her, then at Garrett, then back at her. His mouth twists. âFine.â
âTake the rule off.â
He stiffens. âNo.â
Her eyebrows lift. âExcuse me?â
âNo.â
She glares at him. âDean.â
âI said I know it was shitty. I didnât say I wanted to watch it happen.â
Garrett rubs the back of his neck. âManââ
Dean points at him. âDo not man me. Youâve been waiting for this vote.â
He scoffs. âI have not.â She turns slowly to Garrett. He pauses. âNot⌠exactly.â
âOh my God.â
Garrett winces. âBad timing?â
âTerrible timing.â
Dean crosses his arms. âSee? This is why the rule exists.â
She whips back around. âDean Di Laurentis, take the fucking rule off.â
âNo.â
âTake it off.â
âNo.â
âDean.â
He looks at her stubbornly. âWhat?â
âTake. It. Off.â
The kitchen holds its breath. Deanâs jaw works. For a second she thinks he might keep arguing, might dig himself even deeper because male pride is a tragic renewable resource. Then his gaze flicks past her to Garrett, and whatever he sees there makes his shoulders drop slightly.
Garrettâs not smiling now. He looks uncomfortable, yes, and guilty, and still maybe like part of him wants to put his head through a wall. But thereâs also something earnest in his face, something quiet and clear and not even aimed at Dean, not really. Itâs aimed at her. Like heâs waiting for permission he doesnât want to need, and hating that heâs needed it anyway.
Dean sees it. She knows he does, because his mouth tightens with the final little pinch of someone losing a fight he probably should have surrendered ten minutes ago.Â
âFine,â Dean says.
She points at him. âSay it.â
He stares. âSeriously?â
âYes. Make it official.â
Logan perks up. âI can witness.â
âNobody asked you,â Dean says.
âIâm witnessing anyway.â
Dean exhales hard, looking at the ceiling like he has been personally victimised by consequences. Then he drops his gaze back to her. âThe rule is off.â
She waits.
Deanâs eyes narrow. âWhat else?â
âItâs decreed or whatever.â
Tucker presses his lips together.
Deanâs face goes flat. âYou want me to say decreed?â
âYes.â
âNo.â
âDean.â
He stares at her. She stares back. Finally, with the exhausted dignity of a man being executed in his own kitchen, Dean says, âItâs decreed.â
Logan lifts his smoothie. âHouse law.â
Tucker nods solemnly. âHouse law.â
Garrett looks like he wants to laugh and die at the same time.
She smiles without warmth. âGood.â
Then she turns and walks out of the kitchen, past Garrett, past Logan, through the living room, and out the front door without looking back.Â
She hears Garrett say her name once behind her, but she keeps going, because if she turns around too soon, she might either kiss him in the driveway or scream again, and neither feels like a strategic exit.
Beauâs holiday house is the kind of place that makes absolutely no sense as a college party venue unless someoneâs parents have too much money and not enough concern about upholstery.
It sits just outside town, all big windows and pale stone and a deck wrapped around the back like the architect had been asked to design somewhere specifically for rich kids to make terrible decisions under flattering lighting.Â
By the time she arrives after the game, the whole place is glowing gold from inside, music spilling out every time someone opens the front door, the lawn packed with cars, the porch crawling with people in masks and party dresses and button-downs worn by men who think rolling their sleeves up counts as formalwear.
The masquerade part has been loosely interpreted, obviously. Half the masks look expensive and intentional, feathered or black satin or glittering at the edges; the other half look like they were purchased from a party store by someone already drunk.Â
Someone near the stairs has a full plastic wolf mask pushed onto the top of his head. Someone else is wearing sunglasses and insisting it counts. Briar, as an institution, remains deeply unserious.
She finds Garrett in less than five minutes. Which is ridiculous, given the whole point of masks, but Garrett Graham is impossible to misplace. Heâs standing near the back doors with Logan and Tucker, broad shoulders under a black button-down, sleeves rolled to his forearms, dark mask cutting across the upper half of his face in a way that should look stupid and instead makes him look like someoneâs bad decision dressed up as a theme.Â
His curls are still a little damp from the post-game shower. Thereâs a tiny mark near his jaw from the game, a scrape or bruise starting to come up, and he looks unfairly alive, flushed from the win and the noise and whatever arrogant chemical floods the bloodstream of men who score in the third period.
He sees her at almost the exact same time. She knows because his body goes still. A pause in the middle of whatever Tucker is saying, drink half-lifted, head turning. His gaze moves over her once, fast and then slower, from the tiny silk halter dress skimming high on her thighs to the ribbon of her mask tied at the back of her head, to the heels she had worn with the full awareness that they werenât practical and the private satisfaction that she would not need them to be for long.
The look hits her low in the stomach. There are no rules now. The thought should feel silly. Theyâre adults, technically. No one should need Dean Di Laurentis to revoke a house decree before two people can act like theyâve been wanting to act for weeks. But her body doesnât care about the politics of it. Her body only knows that Garrett is looking at her like heâs run out of reasons not to.
She walks toward him, weaving through a cluster of girls by the kitchen island and one guy arguing loudly with someone about whether masks are classist, actually. Garrett says something to Logan without looking away from her, and Logan turns, notices her, then immediately smiles like an asshole.
âTucker,â Logan says, patting him once on the chest. âWeâre needed elsewhere.â
Tucker glances over, sees her, then gives Garrett a look that is equal parts warning and amusement. âTry not to start another legal dispute.â
Garrett doesnât even look at him. âGo away.â
âRomantic,â she says when she reaches him.
His mouth curves. âYou like it.â
âI like a man with manners.â
âBullshit.â
She laughs, and his gaze drops to her mouth. It lingers there, and the noise of the party seems to press in behind her, warm and muffled and irrelevant.
âGood game,â she says, because some part of her brainâs still committed to sports journalism even while the rest of her is busy mentally dragging him upstairs.
Garrettâs smile deepens. âYeah?â
âMhm. That assist in the second was disgusting.â
His brows lift behind the mask. âDisgusting?â
âComplimentary.â
âGood.â He leans a fraction closer, voice lowering just enough that she feels it under the music. âBecause I was trying to impress you.â
Her breath catches. Just a little. âYou were?â
âYeah.â He takes a sip of his drink, casual in the way men only are when theyâre doing it on purpose. âHad to. Big sports journalist in the stands.â
She tilts her head. âIs that what you were thinking about during the game?â
âAmong other things.â
âLike what?â
His eyes move over her again, slower this time, and his jaw shifts like heâs physically stopping himself from saying the first answer. âYou sure you want that list?â
Her skin warms under the dress. The party keeps happening around them. Someone screams laughing near the stairs. A bottle drops in the kitchen and shatters, followed by a chorus of deeply unhelpful cheering. The music changes to something louder, bass shaking faintly through the floorboards. Garrett doesnât look away from her once.
She steps closer, because she can. Because Dean said decreed. Because Garrettâs hand is flexing at his side like he wants to touch her and is still, idiotically, waiting to be invited.
âSo,â she says, looking up at him through the mask, âdoes house law have anything else to say tonight?â
Garrettâs grin comes slowly. âHouse law can go fuck itself.â
She pouts. âThatâs very disrespectful to the institution.â
âThe institution caused me a lot of personal suffering.â
âPoor thing.â
âYeah,â he says, and his voice drops again, rougher now. âYou have no idea.â
For a second neither of them moves. She can feel her pulse under the thin straps of her dress, in her throat, behind her knees, all of her suddenly aware of the distance between his hand and her waist like itâs a measurable failure of the room.Â
Garrettâs eyes hold hers, dark behind the mask, the smile fading into something hungrier. Want, clean and badly restrained, finally allowed to exist in the open.
He sets his drink down on the nearest table without looking. âUpstairs,â he says.
She nods once. Garrettâs hand comes to the small of her back immediately, warm and broad and sure, guiding her through the crowd with a kind of focus that makes people move before they consciously decide to. They pass Dean near the bottom of the stairs, because the universe has comedic timing and a cruel streak.
Dean sees them. Sees Garrettâs hand. Sees her dress. Sees the direction. His mouth tightens for half a second. She lifts her eyebrows at him.
Dean looks at Garrett, then at her, then rolls his eyes toward the ceiling with the suffering grandeur of a man whoâs made peace with a lawless society. âUse a room with a lock,â he says.
Garrett points at him without stopping. âThat was almost mature.â
âDonât make me regret personal growth.â
âToo late,â she says sweetly, passing him.
Dean mutters something that sounds like unbelievable, but thereâs no real heat in it now. Not enough to stop anything. Not enough to matter.
The upstairs hallway is darker, warmer, the party noise blurring as Garrett leads her past a bathroom with a line outside it and a half-open door where two people are already making a terrible attempt at discretion. He finds an empty bedroom near the end of the hall, pushes the door open, checks once, then pulls her inside.
The door shuts. For half a second, they just stare at each other.
It should be funny, maybe. All that build-up and now a quiet guest room with somebodyâs auntâs decorative pillows on the bed and a framed beach print on the wall. It should break the tension, but it does the opposite.Â
The sudden privacy makes the weeks behind them arrive all at once: the rink bench, the cafeteria, his hands tying her skates, the almost-kiss, the kitchen argument, every look he swallowed because someone else had written a rule neither of them agreed to.
Garrett steps toward her. She steps toward him at the same time, and they meet in the middle with no grace at all.
His mouth is on hers hard and immediate, one hand at her jaw, the other at her waist, walking her back against the door with enough force to make the wood thud behind her shoulders.Â
She gasps into him, and he takes it like heâs been waiting weeks for the sound, kissing her deeper, hotter, his body crowding hers until thereâs no space left to manage. Her hands go straight into his hair, knocking the mask slightly crooked, and Garrett groans low in his throat when her nails scrape over his scalp.
âFinally,â she breathes against his mouth.
He laughs, but it sounds wrecked. âYeah, no shit.â
He kisses her again, and it goes messy fast. Garrett kisses like he knows exactly what heâs doing and is still a little pissed he had to wait to do it, mouth confident, tongue sliding against hers, teeth catching lightly at her bottom lip until her fingers tighten in his hair. His hand slides from her waist to her thigh, finding bare skin under the hem of the dress, and she makes a small sound that seems to go straight through him.
âFuck,â he mutters, pulling back just enough to look at her. His thumb moves once along her jaw, like he needs to see her face properly and cannot tolerate the mask hiding any of it. âTake this off.â
âYou take yours off.â
âGladly.â
He reaches behind her head for the ribbon, but she gets impatient and pushes his hand away, tugging at his mask first. It catches briefly in his curls, and he hisses.
âJesus, easy.â
âSorry,â she says, not sounding sorry at all.
âYouâre violent.â
âYou like it.â
âI really do,â he says, and then her mask is gone too, Garrett pulling it free and dropping both onto the floor like they have personally offended him.
The next kiss feels different with their faces bare. Hotter somehow, more exposed. His hand cups her cheek for one strangely tender second, thumb brushing near the corner of her mouth, and that small softness nearly undoes her more than the door had.Â
His eyes flick over her face, the cocky edge shifting into something warmer, more careful, before she drags him down by the front of his shirt because tenderness is lovely but she has limits.
He laughs into her mouth and lifts her. Hands under her thighs, her legs wrapping around his waist automatically, the movement so easy for him it makes her stomach flip. He carries her toward the bed while still kissing her, which is both impressive and deeply obnoxious, and when her back hits the mattress she pulls him down with her by the collar.
The bed bounces. Somewhere downstairs, the party roars at something completely unrelated. Garrett settles over her, one knee between her thighs, forearm braced beside her head, his other hand sliding up her side over the silk of her dress. His eyes are dark, mouth swollen, curls a mess from her hands.
âYou good?â he asks.
Itâs low, almost rough, but thereâs no performance in it. The little practical care tucked inside all that heat. It makes something in her chest go soft and aching before the rest of her body can vote against it.
She nods. âVery good.â
His grin returns, slow and devastating. âVery?â
âDonât get smug.â
âToo late.â
She pulls him down again, and his laugh disappears into the kiss. His weight settles more fully over her, warm and heavy in a way that makes her whole body go bright beneath him. The silk of her dress rides higher under his hand.Â
Her fingers work at the buttons of his shirt with increasingly poor coordination, and Garrett lifts enough to help, grinning against her lips when she huffs in frustration. âJournalism major canât handle buttons?â
âShut up. Iâm under pressure.â
âPerformance issue?â
She bites his bottom lip. Garrettâs sound is immediate, low and pleased and a little startled. âOkay.â
âStill want to be annoying?â
âIf you do that again? Kind of.â
She laughs, breathless, and he kisses the laugh right out of her, mouth moving down to her jaw, then the side of her neck, slow enough to make her squirm and deliberate enough to make her understand he notices.Â
His hand slides down her thigh, thumb pressing into the soft skin there, and she arches into him before she can pretend to be composed.
âGarrett,â she says, half warning, half something else.
He lifts his head, eyes on hers. âYeah?â
For a second, all the stupid jokes fall away. The room narrows to his face above hers and the warmth of his hand on her thigh and the fact that thereâs no rule anymore, no Dean in the doorway, no rink air between them, no cafeteria table, no almost.Â
Only Garrett looking at her like heâs still checking that sheâs here with him, not because someone decreed it, not because heâs finally been allowed, but because she wants this too.
She reaches up and smooths her thumb over the little mark near his jaw from the game. âYou really were trying to impress me?â
His smile softens around one edge. âBaby, Iâve been trying to impress you for weeks.â
Her stomach turns over. âYeah?â she says, quieter.
âYeah.â His thumb moves once on her thigh. âItâs been brutal. I had to talk about my feelings and everything.â
A laugh breaks out of her, warm and helpless, and Garrettâs face does something unbearably pleased at the sound. âThat mustâve been so hard for you.â
âYou have no idea.â He dips down, brushing his mouth over hers once, twice, not quite kissing properly yet. âI almost quoted a book.â
âYou read?â
âOccasionally. Under supervision.â
She smiles against his mouth. âHot.â
âYeah?â
âMhm.â
He kisses her again, slower this time, and it turns heated almost immediately because slow with Garrett isnât gentle so much as dangerous in a different direction. His mouth drags over hers like he has all night and not nearly enough patience for it.Â
Her hands slide beneath his open shirt, over warm skin and hard muscle, and Garrett exhales sharply against her cheek when her nails trail down his ribs. âFuck,â he says softly. âYouâre killing me.â
âGood.â
âMean.â
âYou like mean too.â
He lifts his head and looks down at her, grin gone lazy and bright and so Garrett it makes her want to laugh and bite him at the same time. âIâm learning a lot about myself tonight.â
She hooks one leg higher around his hip. âGlad I could contribute to your education.â
His eyes drop, tracking the movement, and the humour in his face goes darker. âYeah,â he says, voice rough. âIâm feeling very academically supported.â
She laughs again, but it thins into a breath when his mouth returns to her neck and his hand slides higher under the edge of her dress, all warm palm and careful pressure and that infuriating confidence heâs earned.Â
Outside the room, the party keeps going, loud and bright and masked and stupid, but inside the guest room everything has shrunk to the bed, the silk twisted at her hips, Garrettâs open shirt under her hands, his mouth at her throat, the low sounds he keeps making like every inch of her is something he has been denied on principle and now plans to appreciate with interest. Someone starts chanting for reasons that almost certainly involve alcohol.
Garrett pauses with his mouth against her jaw. âYou think thatâs about us?â
She snorts. âIf it is, Iâm transferring.â
âCanât,â he says, kissing the corner of her mouth. âArticleâs not done.â
âOh, right. My journalistic duty.â
âMhm. Very important piece.â
âOn Briar hockey.â
âAnd its captain.â
She looks up at him, pretending to consider this while his thumb moves distractingly over the bare skin above her hip. âI might need another interview.â
Garrettâs grin spreads, slow and wicked and warm enough to make her toes curl against the sheets.
âYeah?â he says.
âExtensive follow-up.â
His mouth brushes hers. âBaby, Iâm available whenever you need me.â
âď¸ âď¸ âď¸
taglist ââşâ âââ . @xlinxdax0704 | @snowtargaryen | @goodbyetuesday | @staystrongsoa | @dadshirrt | @miya-111 | @softburrow | @darlinglux | @waitingforsmartpeople | @seon9yeonie | @laceyvt3 | @sunny747 | @cosmoh0lic | @blackgurlieee | @matchieee | @loomiz | @corvusmorte | @erin-alice | @cloudsxcherriesx | @lolskunk | @elizabeth123456767 | @purplerainx1 | @pinkgiraffebeach | @lucyysthings | @outpostsworld | @s0ftdr1nks | @maybankslover | @instantplaiddream | @droppedyourhnd | @bsenpai | @urfavadi | @em1ly57 | @parker-barnes-af | @violyn20 | @bootyliciousbutterfly | @bloomingflower13 | @rexit-mo | @tpwkmera | @cherryrry581 | @stevesxwhore | @solapeachtea | @giuliaasstuff | @pamacs-macs | @loonylosworld | @alice07ea | @hitting-euphoria4 | @tessf13 | @canupourme14theroad | @jayda12 | @kmc1989 | click here to be added to the taglist!


















