Hope you've all had a wonderful time during the holidays. For something new, I decided to review all of the Christmas-themed movies and shorts that were made by director duo, Arthur Rankin Jr. and Jules Bass, both making Rankin/Bass Productions.
So, Rankin/Bass is rather interesting as theyâre known for making several stop-motion movies mainly revolving around Christmas, many becoming some of Americaâs favourites. Starting from the sixties, the specials have been viewed through countless generations. Not only that but they've made an impact across the holidays with merchandise and parodies across media such as Elf, SpongeBob, South Park and many more.
While I can tell that a lot from America has grown up with these specials, I can't say the same; in case you don't know, I'm from over the pond in the United Kingdom, where I was lucky to have found them on reruns on Cartoon Network or Boomerang back in the day. Out of those I managed to see, they were Rudolph's Shiny New Year, The Wind in the Willows, Frosty's Winter Wonderland, The Last Unicorn and the Lord of the Rings specials.
However, those were rare occurances.
With some history of the studio, they would base their specials on classic songs with the screenplays by Romeo Muller. They focused on the same formula of the misfit protagonist bringing joy to a miserable situation, where the villain attempts to deter them, only to stop and normally reform by the end. In today's standards, many can agree that they're dated as heck, mostly due to their animation budget being so incredibly low along with the voices not matching the lip movement; this is due to the studio shipping their models to Japan, where various studios animated them.
So, in a way, you could label Rudolph and Frosty as anime.
I'm sure that these are also remembered for having an incredibly random point that normally doesnât play any huge role in the story. However, from what Iâve seen, people watch them every year as thereâs some charm to find in these classics.
Why not start here with the one that began the whole legacy of these stop-motion Christmas specials overall? When this came out in 1964, it was everywhere and then ranked amongst the greatest Christmas specials of all time. Making its 50th anniversary in 2014, it maintained its impact across the globe and ended up beloved by children and adults who got a chance to watch this back then and with newer generations during reruns. It received countless merchandise, made its mark on stamps, as well as spawn a few sequels and spin-offs.
A disclaimer which Iâll add that this was never part of my childhood at all, so I was probably not the right audience for this.
Based on the song we all know the lyrics to, Rudolph is a young fawn whose born with a red nose, which disturbs his father, Donner. He then becomes the laughing stock to all of the other reindeer. In another subplot, an elf called Hermey doesnât want to make toys but become a dentist, so he chooses to run away after his boss criticises him. The two eventually meet up and become fast friends, before going on their own adventure while meeting some colourful characters along the way.
So, let me get this out of the way that I donât dislike this special at all. In fact, I see how itâs a classic and why people have this as a special place in their hearts. This may not be a good first impression, but Iâm not really a fan of this special, which is a shame because I really do want to love this to bits considering the impact and history this had. This is the first film where the subject Rankin-Bass comes up and Iâve heard that a lot of people had huge nostalgia over this.
The story mainly revolves around the typical misfit premise where two of them are shunned by society and find immediate friendship in between each-other. This is also followed up by involving more misfits that add towards their story, which isn't exactly a well-told one. Sometimes, it relies solely on inconveniences happening before other side-characters are either pushed away before they're suddenly brought back in. For example, there is a whole shift where Rudolph ditches his friends and then time passes where he is all grown up, but it never seems to effect any of the other characters.
I think what bothers me the most was the execution of the message overall. I donât think it really holds up to this day, where its about I never judging a book by its cover, but itâs executed in such a weird manner. Basically, when Rudolphâs nose is exposed, all ridicule him and make a big deal out of it, which I find honestly far-fetched. Even more so, the other fawns still bully Rudolph when he returns as an adult, but once he finds a purpose, they then accept him. I know that the intention was harmless but this wasnât the best way to tell it. I mean, they do apologise for misjudging him but then you have the dad saying that he knew that Rudolphâs nose would have been successful in the future and I didnât buy that one bit.
I know that this may be a biased criticism but this special didnât have the best way of handling it. Another line that could spark some controversy was Donner refusing the mother to join him, citing his duty as âmanâs workâ, which was a big product of the time, so letâs leave it at that.
Itâs not just the animation where, of course, itâs dated in todayâs standards but still bares that old-fashioned charm to it. Those background sets looked innocently-decent and itâs an overall pleasant experience to witness. We all know Rankin-Bass is known for its choppy animation, where they had to outsource the models to Japan, but still bared that devoted charm. Characters like Rudolph and Hermey are innocent enough while larger monsters like the Bumble was just horrifying with bulbous eyes and rows of teeth.
I mainly preferred the soundtrack over the aspects as the songs brought a nice aroma to its premise. The main song was a delight to listen to, Silver and Gold was calming and sweet, We Are Santaâs Elves was annoyingly-catchy, but my favourite would be Weâre a Couple of Misfits for utilising itâs concept. Other songs mainly jumped out of nowhere but theyâre overall harmless.
The characters are basic, one-dimensional figures and are what the fans remember and love; the main leads are Rudolph as the misjudged kid who wants a purpose as one of Santaâs reindeer, where the special really wants you to care for him. What makes this character work was the impressive voice work of Billie Mae Richards, adding an aroma of a sheltered, nervous child.
Along with Rudolph, there is Hermey the elf who wants to be a dentist so of course these two become fast friends. With him baring a chipper personality with slightly sassy moments, he works as a nice companion and focus of the story's main formula. He was voiced by Paul Soles, who would use this snarky voice work for the 1960's Spider-Man series.
Other characters include Clarice the standard love-interest, adding a gentler tone to console the rejected Rudolph. My personal favourite would be Yukon Cornelius the eccentric prospector with a high energy and a motive for silver and gold. Everytime he attempts to lick his pickaxe from screaming "YAHOOO" added a large element of joy, where you can tell that Larry Mann was having the time of his life voicing this rambunctious character.
I really loved Burl Ives as the snowman narrator, Sam, for having that welcoming presence and overall feeling like a grandfather telling children a story. He was a great choice at both telling the story of Rudolph's dilemma while softly singing the titular songs.
Thereâs also the misfit toys who look up to Rudolph as they all bare a minor fault in their form that are seen as anchors weighing them down. However, when looking back, I honestly donât see half of them as proper âmisfitsâ, such as the doll, spotted elephant, train with square wheels on the caboose and even a Charlie in the box. Many of them are seen as âimproperâ but their flaws can be easily overlooked, especially with those that can be changed within a second.
The main antagonist is revealed to be a disturbing-looking yeti called the Bumble who still creeps me out to this day from his overall design, but nothing could top that strained bellow. Eventually, the Bumble reforms, but there is a disturbing part that involves his lack of teeth by the end; without them, does that means he has to eat his food through a straw?
Then, thereâs Santa Claus whoâs actually an aloof douchebag in this short as he pretty much rebuffs everything. Itâs interesting to see such a mean-spirited Santa where he criticises the elf chorus and even Rudolphâs nose, while not even standing up against the bullying, until it comes to fruition by the end.
Another character that I liked was the elf boss, who would become a meme at one point by screaming; âWHY WERENâT YOU AT ELF PRACTISE?!â
Depends which version youâre watching, there were quite a few rebroadcasts of the special where the original ending was altered from the elf dropping presents to the misfit toys, due to viewers complaining that Santa Claus never kept his promise. I wasnât sure if I was on board with this all the way through as while itâs nice to see that Santa had a heart, I recalled the bird toy lamenting that he couldnât fly. However, in a comic book story, its revealed that the toy can glide. Also, itâs nice to see Yukon receive a satisfying conclusion rather than left as a lunatic.
Iâve also noticed that you never see the designs for Rudolph and Santa Claus in the rest of the Rankin-Bass movies, so Iâm going to take a rough guess that they got themselves lost in the blizzard and were never found. In reality, they changed their animation style and overall character designs, some even getting lost in fires and few recovered and sold. I personally think it's for the best as I preferred Santa Claus in the successors rather than this one.
So, all in all, itâs not my thing and never will be, where I wasnât sure if I would really label this as âoverratedâ. It didn't help that I never grew up with this special at all and only discovered it as an adult. However, I will totally understand why people do love this, as other perspectives intrigue me.
Personally, I think it's fine, even if I don't really like it as a whole; its soundtrack I preferred, plus some neat ideas and charm, but most of it fails for me.
What about you? Did you grow up with this movie? Let me know your thoughts in the comments.