Gotta rant about Edgar Valden rq
Cause seriously, his character is so cool to me. Like, you have the basic rundown. Rich kid ran away from home because he was dissatisfied with his life there. But then, all of that ends up just being a red herring. The âdissatisfactionâ which always came off as him just being in his own head and looking down on others because he thinks heâs better than them gets flipped on its head with his 3rd letter. All of his trash talk makes so much more sense. He wasnât just saying he didnât care about other peopleâs opinions or money or fame because he was super self absorbed. He was saying that because he knew first hand the damage chasing money, fame, and power can cause. Really thinking about it, his father basically killed his entire family for status. And then, the slight implication that Edgarâs dad knew what Sarai was doing to Edgar the whole time. Now, itâs vague about what Sarai did to Edgar, but it was obviously bad enough to deteriorate his mental health to the point of having hallucinations. All that, and his dad never got rid of Sarai. Never fired him. Nothing. Which makes sense, because having a super talented artist in the family looks good for status, why would his dad care. He couldnât care enough to let his wife rest to get better from her illness, or to actually look for his youngest child when she went missing.
For the little we do know about Sarai, we know he taught Edgar that praise is the highest form of love. Again, playing into the idea that Edgar was brought up to try and appease others and try to get status and fame. This is even kinda hinted at in his very first letter when he tells Ella that heâs going to become a famous artist, a goal he ends up feeling disillusioned to by. The fact he still kept painting even after no longer wanting fame and recognition shows his love for painting was rooted in something much deeper than that. Then, referencing back to his deductions where he says that life is beautiful and the brush can preserve that beauty, shows exactly what it was that keeps him going with art. He thinks life if beautiful. A simple reason, but a lovely one nonetheless. He cherishes the beautiful moments like the time he had with his mother or Ella.
This also could change what he even meant by looking for inspiration when going to the manor. When he talks about how he finds no inspiration in his home, itâs not something as simple as everything is just boring. He talks about how the culture of the aristocracy is just straight up draining for him. The greed. The constant push for more money and status, even at the cost of loved ones. The shallowness. Thereâs no beauty in it, he canât find inspiration in it. Even as he signs off his farewell letter, he implies he would never go back home. Heâs not just running off on some little trip to find inspiration and go home right after. He was straight up cutting off the life he once knew because it wasnât really a life at all. As he puts it, he was just another decoration for his dad. For most of his life, he was kind of treated as less than human. More like a party trick for his dad to show off and gain their family more status.
And while we donât know much about his role in game 5, the context of the game makes him stand out a lot. Outside of the fact Edgar wasnât in a faction at the start and the only character truly confirmed dead, his goals are also completely different from the rest of the group and he thematically differs from the others. Every other character is in some way trying to fix some âissueâ with themself to try to assimilate into a group they were ostracized from. Chloe trying to become Vera to be accepted, Jose trying to get his first officer title back and rejoin the aristocracy (or his alcoholism in order to maintain his station as a first officer in the first place), Kevin trying to prove to himself that heâs reached a point where he couldâve protected Angelina so he can face her tribe, and Patricia trying to rid herself of her curse in order to be accepted into her motherâs village. Meanwhile, thereâs Edgar who was wanted by his community, but not taken care of by them. All five of them have a similar goal, to get some form of community and support, but Edgar is in a much different position from the rest of his team since he is more confident in himself and who he is. Itâs never been called into question, and I donât think thatâs a negative trait either since every time someone in game 5 tries to correct their âflawâ it causes more harm than good. From Chloe killing her sister who was innocent, to Jose accidentally poisoning Kevin who he viewed as innocent, Patricia killing Edgar even though he didnât do anything to her, and even Kevin being self destructive in drinking the poison. Not to mention three out of four of them feel regret and unfulfilled after they do it (and the one Iâm not counting is Patricia because itâs not fully confirmed, but tbh there are things that foreshadow her not feeling fulfilled either so you could make it four out of four). Edgar, at least on the surface, didnât internalize that there was something wrong with him that made the people around him treat him like trash.
If I really wanted to get into the internalizing thing tho, Iâd probably say his willingness to sacrifice himself probably comes fromâŚ
1. Being so used to getting treated like a tool his entire life he thinks itâs the standard to a degree (hence why heâll complain about having to play hero roles but still gets them regularly anyway)
2. Being unable to truly repent to Patricia because he canât bring himself to apologize for killing Sarai (and he shouldnât tbh, especially considering that was like his first act of true autonomy)
3. And lastly, just not really having anywhere to go after the manor. His goalpost ended at the manor while the other four saw it more as a stepping stone to get to other places.
And thatâs not even getting into his overall lore relevance because letâs not act like he didnât imply the Deross family are family friends of the Valden family in his 3rd letter. PLUS he has ties to Barriere.
Heâs always got this slightly hopeful air to him, like heâs always looking up. Itâs honestly just a really nice breather from the usual doom and gloom of idvâs storyline (granted his story is still depressing asf, but for idv standards itâs pretty happy). Even in the end, he gets the ending he wanted. He finds the inspiration he was looking for, but tbh I donât think it was death that he was trying to achieve. His deaths are always portrayed as sacrifices specifically. Itâs usually not something he really wants to do. Runaway didnât want to risk his life and put himself in danger with mir, but he does it because he doesnât want to abandon the followers to a cult. Censer didnât want to die, he still really wanted to see his creatorâs wish come true, but he accepts death if it will bring it closer to coming true. Even in his experiment file, Orpheus says Edgar accepted it at the end, so he decides to accept it at the end of the game. Most likely for some greater goal that hasnât been revealed yet since Orpheus was hella vague in his experiment file.
I could honestly go on and on about how well executed his whole character is too. With how well they played into double entendres with his words and used a lot of art metaphors to sort of hide his actual character so on the surface you wouldnât clock it immediately. Or the carefully picked art references they used in his trailer that all tie into his character really well (I still think he has one of the best trailers to date). To even the way his birthday letters are released, and keeping his perspective on game 5 hidden despite probably having the most reliable account, instead having other characters describe him to play into the misdirection.
I could literally talk for hours about Edgar Valden, he is the idv character of all time and I love him sm
discoholicmusic
kianamaiart
tangentwithtanner
stormborns
annaxmalina
baratheonpilled
ellievsbear
