We interrupt your regularly scheduled programming with this important alert... I saw something at the grocery store this weekend that was truly disturbing, upsetting, and important enough that I really must share.
Waiting in line as the cash register is boring. Like many mindless consumers, I like to pass the time scanning through the trashy tabloids and celebrity magazines. This week, something jumped out at me (besides Oprah being on the cover of EVERY single one of her OWN magazines): "Seventeen Fitness." Now for those of you who were not at some point teenage girls, or were not fortunate enough to have your very own teenage girls, "Seventeen" is a popular magazine among the tween set featuring celebrity gossip, tips on how to kiss boys, and (of course) half-naked pictures of Zac Efron. Girls use this magazine and other similar weeklies - whether consciously or not - to form their perceptions of how women are supposed to think, act, and (the highlight of this feature) how they look.
Now I'll spare you the ranting against too-skinny runway models and anorexic celebrity divas. This is what their careers entail, they made the choice to live that way, and - while I personally believe their physical image is unattractive and represents a false, unrealistic, and unhealthy picture of the female body - they are entitled to do what they wish. However, it is important to note that these women are not claiming to be "fit." I'll let them slip by with my own private rage and disapproval. That said, I absolutely MUST take issue with a publication promoting itself as a "fitness" magazine that depicts extremely skinny women who by NO means represent the way that a truly "fit" female body can and should look.
I recognize that I have a clear bias here, and I am not afraid to wear that on my sleeve. As a CrossFitter, aspiring powerlifter, and lifelong female athlete I have a very particular personal perception of what "fitness" means. I think the easiest way to explain it is first by identifying what fitness is NOT. Fitness is NOT how skinny you are. It is NOT how big your boobs are. It is NOT the size of your ass or how good you look in a bikini. These are all aesthetic measures of "fitness," and in reality they have no bearing on how "fit" an individual actually is. Sure you can starve yourself, get a boob job, spray tan, and whatever else it takes to look like that girl on the cover. You are skinny, and perhaps you are pretty by conventional standards. But you are NOT fit.
I read a few articles recently about body types for CrossFit women, physical ideals for men, and the health (or lack thereof) of fitness models. I've posted them all below in case you'd like to read further (which I highly recommend as they are excellent articles). But essentially what they say is that the standards and ideals placed before the average person every day are unrealistic, unattainable, and, in many cases, unhealthy. Fitness models and body builders literally dehydrate themselves to the point of hallucination prior to performance to get the optimum level of muscle definition during a competition or shoot. The muscles may be large and toned - and I am in no way degrading the amount of work they put in to get there - but the fact is that walking around the street every day that is NOT what they look like. They can't. It's not possible. Before you start protesting with the "but I've seen guys in daily life with awesome abs" comments, you don't have to tell me that. Believe me, I'm as aware as every other straight woman, gay man, and gym rat on the planet. But also believe me that if you took their picture, they would NOT look like that guy on the cover of "Men's Health," which is a product of dehydration, starvation, good lighting, and PhotoShop in addition to many hours at the gym.
Before I get totally sidetracked on models in general, let's refocus on the issue at hand: "Seventeen Fitness." As you can see from the cover posted above, there is a very lovely and skinny girl on the cover (aka Vampire Diaries star, Nina Dobrev - yes, I had to look that up). This is the same 22-year-old actress who, in the cover article, proclaims: "I’m comfortable in my own skin, and I do what I need to do, to feel good, but I’m built the way I am... I've realized skinny isn’t necessarily attractive. Guys like girls with curves." Now take another look at that picture up there (or at the ones in the link below). Does this look like a curvy girl who needs to convince herself that guys like her just the way she is? Forgive me for my immediate superficial judgement, but no. While I appreciate her feel-good message, I can't help but wonder what kind of other messages this is sending to young readers. Of COURSE she's comfortable! Wouldn't you be if you looked like that? She's also famous, which certainly helps her self-esteem I'm sure. Sidenote: She also claims she looks this way due to yoga 3-4 times a week. No, I do not believe her, and I think it's ridiculous to purvey that as a means of fitness. Nothing against yoga, but you're not going to look like that just from doing yoga every other day.
And the cover shot is just one example of this idealistic - and extremely skinny - body image. The magazine is rife with images of super skinny girls in bikinis - ribs and hips jutting out of orange-bronze skin - side-by-side with tips on "how to get a cute bikini butt" and "best ways to cut calories in the summer." Am I the only one who sees a problem with this? It's horrifying and deeply upsetting to me that this is the image we are giving our daughters, sisters, nieces, friends. No wonder so many girls - and not just teenage ones - have issues with self-esteem and body image. We can expect nothing less when this is what is put in front of us every day.
If you want to make a magazine about fitness, make it about true fitness. Functional strength, toned muscles, flexibility, movement, coordination. If you work toward that, beauty will come along with it. Fitness is about so much more than having a magazine-cover beach bod; it's about being in tune with your body and being strong enough, both physically and mentally, to take on whatever comes your way. I think Coach K says it best, "Knowing your body will change, and knowing things will start to fit differently, understand this is a natural part of the process. Understand that sometimes being athletic means your clothes may change "Shape" on your body. What we see is an amazing and beautiful woman. What we see is power, speed, strength all wrapped up into an awesome package. We may notice you are looking more lean, or more powerful or heck, even stronger, but that is our way of noticing you are getting the results you have been after."
So with that, I will end my rant. Please feel free to comment back via tumblr, facebook, or twitter (@ktmajew). At the very least, I would love to spur some conversation. And at very best, I hope this conversation can spur change. Thanks for reading!
Links for further reading:
1. CrossFit Women's Physique: http://crossfitsalvation.typepad.com/coaches_corner/2010/12/dispelling-the-myths-women-in-crossfit-and-strength-training.html
2. Impossible Physical Ideals for Men: http://goodmenproject.com/ethics-values/wealthy-handsome-strong-packing-endless-hard-ons-the-impossible-ideals-men-are-expected-to-meet/
3. "Health" in Fitness Modeling: http://www.express.co.uk/posts/view/175179
4. More pix from the "Seventeen Fitness" shoot with Nina: http://www.fitness-diet.becomegorgeous.com/celebrity_diets/nina_dobrev_covers_seventeen_celeb_fitness_issue-4429.html