The Public Needs to be Educated on Protein Supplementation...Correctly
Recently on a different social media site, a person close to me posted an article talking about the dangers of protein supplementation, how dangerous milk protein is, and how people need to convert to plant based proteins.
I was incredibly disappointed at the misinformation that was provided in the article. It was obvious to me, while reading the article, the information was incredibly biased. The article was written by a man who had formerly been in body building and is an advocate for vegan diets among athletes. His arguments against protein supplements were based from a body building culture in which excessive protein consumption is encouraged, and so are periods of dehydration (to make weight). Excessive protein consumption and dehydration make for a very dangerous combination to the kidneys. Like I've said in previous blog posts, more protein is not better. However, consuming protein supplements is not going to cause organs to fail, though extreme consumption of protein may produce negative effects on organs.
The vegan author also assaults whey protein (based on his nutritional habits, not surprising). However, the reason for the popularity of whey protein is not unfounded. Whey protein contains branch chain amino acids which are essential amino acids and tend to be used the most of any proteins for energy. If these amino acids are not available then specific protein synthesis may be stopped.
The author also makes protein supplements seem completely irrelevant. Though extra protein has no performance benefit on well-nourished individuals, there is purpose to the madness, so to speak One of the purposes behind protein shakes or supplements is to most effectively utilize the 'golden hour' following exercise in which maximal synthesis of protein occurs. Protein re-synthesis is most effective immediately following exercise because exercise increases specific enzyme activity.
The author made statements in the articles such as, "Consider these questions the next time you think about buying powders made from cow secretions for proper nutrition." I understand, his opinion, however, consuming adequate amounts of essential amino acids can be tricky on a vegan diet. Plant sources are lower quality proteins and have fewer amino acids. Therefore, vegetarian and vegan athletes must take great care into ensuring they are consuming adequate amounts of all the essential amino acids.
Regardless of your stance on this particular issue, I believe it is necessary for everyone to be properly educated before allowing opinionated articles shape their beliefs on nutrition. With all the fad diets, popular 'information' out there, consumers need to base their nutrition beliefs in research and validity. Therefore, I believe education in this area is critical.
I've posted the article here, if your interested in reading it.
http://nutritionstudies.org/no-whey-man-ill-pass-on-protein-powder/