#1: Chloe’s “Damnation Arc” That Was Totally Planned From the Start
Time to talk about one of the most infuriating anecdotes of Astruc, and it shows how chaotic the production of Miraculous Ladybug is.
Chloe Bourgeois the resident mean girl you see in a lot of cartoons and shows with a school setting in general. She’s the daughter of the mayor of Paris, so she tends to get her way a lot. And her callous personality has left several people emotionally vulnerable, which is how Hawkmoth creates his minions of the week, Akumas. Of the 26 Akumas in the first season, Chloe has contributed to 12 of them becoming akumatized through bullying, insulting, and publicity humiliating them.
In the first season, Chloe was the kind of character who you loved to hate. She was someone who served as a minor threat in the civilian lives of the main characters, and she would usually get her comeuppance at the end of the episode.
There was effort into giving Chloe character development, don’t get me wrong, with six episodes between Seasons 2 and 3 dedicated to it. But for every moment of heroism Chloe got, it was always negated by the end, having her go back to her old self and learning nothing in the process. This was because of a strange idea Astruc has. For some reason, he wants the status quo to be the same so new viewers can jump in at any time. While that may work for a show like SpongeBob SquarePants or The Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy, but not for a story driven show like Miraculous Ladybug. So Chloe’s “character development” was an unfortunate case of one step forward, two steps back. This ended up disappointing fans, who were really hoping for Chloe to get a proper redemption arc. What’s important to remember was that Astruc claimed that he planned for everything that’s about to happen from the start, when you’ll see that it couldn’t be further from the truth.
Even after getting an entire trilogy of episodes focusing on her “development”, Chloe didn’t really grow as a person. The only thing that changed was Ladybug would occasionally loan her the Bee Miraculous because of how good she is as Queen Bee. They tried mixing things up in Season 3 when Ladybug said she couldn’t be Queen Bee anymore because her identity was public and it would be too dangerous… rather than how rude she is to everyone she meets, and is overall irresponsible with her powers (In her first appearance, she sabotaged a train so she could pull a Syndrome and save it herself, and it was quickly swept under the metaphorical rug). So throughout the third season, we’d get snippets of Chloe saying “Queen Bee could handle this if you let her!” whenever she was on screen. This culminated in the season finale, where she got fed up of waiting, and willingly sided with Hawkmoth to get back at Ladybug.
And when fans were naturally miffed at all this time wasted on a character arc that went absolutely nowhere, guess how Astruc responded?
I find it ironic that Astruc is saying fans shouldn’t insult the writing team or other fans because they didn’t like the twist… while insulting fans who didn’t like the way Chloe’s character arc went. Astruc could have easily turned down the idea of a Chloe redemption arc, or find some way to compromise instead of whatever we got. But even if he didn’t, why does he have to be so callous about it?
Even if you don’t like Chloe, this still screams bad writing. Why focus so much on a character’s development so much if you’re going to just throw it out the window? There were several times where Marinette was scolded for saying she couldn’t change, and that she needed to see the good in Chloe, and now you’re just turning back on it? If she was irredeemable the whole time, why dedicate so much time to her “damnation arc”, as Astruc puts it? Why not focus on getting to know other characters and their relevance to the story like Master Fu? Why not focus on writing more interactions between Marinette and Adrien? You know, the two leads whose relationship is the main focus of the show?
And it wasn’t just here. Before the season finale, whenever people talked about how they loved Chloe and fanfics showing her growing as a person, Astruc just shut them down. If someone tries to reason with Astruc the importance of being kind to others, he’ll just say something like “That doesn’t matter, Chloe sucks!” Because that’s a good lesson to teach kids, right? People can never change, so why bother?
It’s not just those characters either. The last decade we got characters like Weiss Schnee, Pacifica Northwest, and Amity Blight. These were all mean girls who weren’t just one-note caricatures of bullies, but characters who actually grew as we got to know them the longer their shows went on.
The thing is, Chloe has all the pieces necessary for a redemption arc, and there are fans and writers alike who want her to get a proper one. But because of Astruc’s own stubborn beliefs, he refuses to let anything interesting happen. Change is possible, some of the most interesting characters in fiction are those who genuinely want to be better (Just take a look at all those examples I used earlier, and I’ll show more if I need to).
And when someone pointed out that character development is a thing?
I mean, it’s not like there was any evidence in the show that made it look like Chloe was trying to be a better person—OH WAIT.
And then, that same person pointed out the redundancy of having two mean girls to antagonize Marinette in her civilian life, relying on the stereotype that all girls do is fight over cute boys instead of actually finishing the redemption arc the writers set up, as well as showing a screenshot of a Tumblr post that perfectly summarizes my feelings on Chloe’s character development.
What does Astruc have to say in response to these valid criticisms? Nothing. Absolutely nothing.
That’s literally all he said to this person. He didn’t refute anything that person said, he didn’t defend any of his writing choices, he basically plugged his fingers and his ears, and went “LALALALALALA, I’m not listening! I’m not listening!” Dude, you chose to open this Twitter account and take questions, so expect a little criticism thrown your way. But what should I know, according to him, he already planned this for years!
But the main question remains: If you didn’t want Chloe to develop or grow as a person, Astruc, why did you even get our hopes up in the first place?
annaxmalina
titsay
yousharknotpass
germansingergirl
theartofmadeline
romaincrisis
blakekathryn
baratheonpilled
