Oh, this!! Yarn snobbery is the worst and always comes complete with, at minimum, classist overtones.
I am privileged in that I can afford to drop money on that fancy skein of indie dyed sock yarn that I have been eyeballing for months and that I want rather than need.
I am also a fat girl. You know what I can’t do? I can’t knit a sweater out of indie yarn. Because it will set me back a good £100 ($125) for a fingering weight* sweater and at least half that again if I’m buying DK weight.
So I buy cheap yarn**. I buy acrylic mixes. I mix cheap yarn with the fancy stuff I buy on destashes (great way to get indie yarn cheaper, though comes with a hefty warning of be careful who you buy from).
So knit with your big brand store yarn. Make things out of acrylic. And don’t let anyone shame you or tell you that it somehow makes you less of a knitter, because that’s bullshit.
If you’re knitting? Congratulations, you’re a knitter!
* Assuming 5 skeins fingering/4-ply weight yarn at £20 a skein which was the price I paid a few months ago for a skein of sock yarn I had been lusting over for months.
N.B. Yarn prices for yarn from indie dyers have jumped recently in the UK with changes to VAT rules, meaning most dyers now have to charge an extra 20% tax.
** If anyone’s curious, I tend towards the following companies:
- Garnstudio Drops - reasonably priced yarns including wool and alpaca. Have at least 1 big yearly sale where their yarns become insanely cheap. Have, in the past at least, been associated with claims of pattern plagiarism, though I’m stuggling to find sources to confirm this right now, and they’re far from the only brand to do this. A fingering weight sweater for me comes in at between £20 & £40, and that £40 is for an alpaca/silk blend, the wool blends top out at about the £30 mark at full retail prices.
- Womens Institute Yarn - yes, that Women’s Institute. Only available in the UK as far as I’m aware, but is one of the nicest acrylics I’ve worked with. They’re starting to branch out now in terms of yarn weights and colours, and it’s nearly always on 3 for 2 at Hobbycraft. Does have issues with labelling yarn weights - their 4-ply is 270m per 100g, which to me is a sport weight not a fingering. But a fingering weight sweater for me still comes in under £20 and that’s before any discounts.
- West Yorkshire Spinners - slightly more pricey and have, in the past, had some issues with some colours not matching up to the quality of others, but they make a good sock yarn in basic & striped colours and their heavier yarns are supposed to be good too. A fingering weight sweater for me comes in at about £36.
Other options include Opal (primarily sock yarn, great colour options but not the softest wool in the world), Cascade (averagely priced, soft and nice to work with, have some dubious political affiliations which I’ll leave the individual to google and make their own judgement about the company), Rico (tends towards baby yarns and cotton but very reasonably priced if you don’t mind hunting for what you want) and KnitPicks (hard to get anyway in the UK and also comes with a hefty tax & processing fee when shipping in from the US - makes it much less budget friendly).