Everyone who says Alina made the wrong choice when she picked Mal needs to learn basic reading comprehension.
Itâs fine to say that you donât ship Malina. To be honest, I didnât really ship them at first. But to say that Alina would have been better off with Nikolai or the Darkling is just inaccurate.
From the beginning, we see Alina reject power for Mal. She refuses to be tested so she wonât have to leave Mal. And even when sheâs taken to the little palace, she never forgets about her best friend.
And when she starts to gain power, it terrifies her. She hates what she becomes when sheâs with the Darkling. Alina is a fairly straightforward person and so is Mal. She is completely out of her element with all these manipulative men. Itâs only with Mal that she can be herself.
And now letâs see what each man offers her. The Darkling offers her unlimited power as the Sun Summoner. He offers her complete control over Ravka. Nikolai does pretty much the same.
But Alina never once shows interest in politics. All her life, she has only wanted one thing: A peaceful life with Mal. And when Mal offers her nothing but himself, of course she accepts. Because Alina has spent most of her life being manipulated by powerful people. And Mal, the most straightforward man in her life, does nothing but offer her unconditional love. He doesnât give her anything that can be held against her. And he even gives her a way out, if she doesnât feel the same way.
The fact that most people seem to completely disregard Alinaâs character to use her as a self-insert for their fantasies is, unfortunately, not shocking. And even worse, they degrade her character.
Alina rejecting power to live a fulfilling life with the man she loves is not anti-feminist. If anything, Alina going against powerful men and a manipulative society to choose her own life was the most empowering decision she could have made.