What about writing a The Quarry "police statement" ending with the counselors just like Until Dawn based on your playthrough (who died, important actions, choices etc)
Gods, I had so much fun writing this ! Thank you for this ask ! I watched a lot of let’s plays before having my own run, so basically it was an everybody lives + all evidence found (and Dylan kept his hand !). It was better to have to write all the counselors say something, so it’s cool.
Anyways, here are my version of The Quarry’s ending, because it should have been like this.
𝗧𝗵𝗲 𝗰𝗼𝘂𝗻𝘀𝗲𝗹𝗼𝗿𝘀 𝗽𝗼𝗹𝗶𝗰𝗲 𝗶𝗻𝘁𝗲𝗿𝘃𝗶𝗲𝘄, 𝗨𝗻𝘁𝗶𝗹 𝗗𝗮𝘄𝗻 𝘀𝘁𝘆𝗹𝗲
NORTHKILL POLICE DEPARTMENT - MORNING OF AUGUST 23
[START OF THE TRANSCRIPTION]
NORTHKILL PRECINCT - ROOM 1
[OFFICER] : Young man, we need your help on this. Don't you remember anything?
[N. FURCILLO] : I- I told you. This... animal it- it attacked me and Abi. In the woods. It bit me in the leg-
[OFFICER] : Where, exactly ? You don't have any scratch on you.
[N. FURCILLO] : I can assure you- it- it- it was bleeding so much! I just- I remember feeling weird after. I think I said mean stuff to Abi... I- pushed her? Wait, is she okay?! Where is-
[OFFICER] : Sir, answer our questions. What happened next?
[N. FURCILLO] : As I told you before, I. Don’t. Remember. A. Single. Thing.
NORTHKILL PRECINCT - ROOM 4
[J. CUSTOS] : Look man... I don’t understand shit to what happened, okay? Whatever you’re searching for, it’s the Hackett’s. They’re fucking crazy! Trapped me in some sicko cage- if it wasn’t for Ryan and that girl freeing me I’d still be down there-
[OFFICER] : So you’re stating that Mr. Erzahler and Miss Kearney were at the Hackett’s house around 1:30AM ?
[J. CUSTOS] : I- yeah I guess, but don’t you hear what I’m saying? I almost got shredded by that creepy ass animal, I’m telling you it’s not human- and it’s not all, those freaks covered me in what I think is blood!
[OFFICER] : Sir, can you describe the animal?
[J. CUSTOS] : Uh... animal isn’t the term man... it had some kind of- of human form? But like... long. Bloody. Just... I just want to forget it.
NORTHKILL PRECINCT - ROOM 5
[L. KEARNEY] : No, no FUCKING way. I am NOT dealing with bastards cops again!
[OFFICER] : Lady, I’m gonna need you to calm down. Don’t make me use force. The other counselors said that you weren’t there during the camp. explain me how you disappeared for two whole months.
[L. KEARNEY] : Are you deaf? We were kidnapped by that damn cop because we stumbled into the Hackett’s fucking cursed family issues-
[OFFICER] : Speaking of the Hackett’s. We found the bodies of Constance Hackett and Christopher Hackett shot dead. You have agreed that you were at their house with Mr. Erzahler, what do you have to say about that?
[L. KEARNEY] : Listen. I didn’t do shit. It’s the old hag’s own fault that she got shot. If you had taken one look at her, you’d see she deserved it. As for Chris, he was trying to fucking kill us! Ryan saved everyone in the room by shooting him-
[OFFICER] : So you’re saying Mr. Erzahler murdered Mr. Hackett?
[L. KEARNEY] : I- no- I mean, yes but- don’t twist it like that you!- I...
NORTHKILL PRECINCT - ROOM 7
[OFFICER] : So, you found a possible working car at the Hackett scrap yard. Why leave it to go back?
[K. KA] : I told you, we almost got mauled to death! Dylan knocked it out temporarily by dropping the car, we weren’t gonna take our chances with it. We went back to the lodge.
[OFFICER] : The lodge, right. We have found the deceased body of Caleb Hackett there, do you have anything to say about that?
[K. KA] : Wh- who? Wait, you mean Mr. H’s son? What the fuck was he doing th- Oh- oh...
[OFFICER] : He was shot, and you were the one with the shotgun in the morning. Miss, did you shoot Caleb Hackett?
[K. KA] : What?! No! What I shot was a fucking monster who was going to brutally kill Dylan and me! It wasn’t a guy, I’m telling you!
[OFFICER] : You and your coworkers keep talking about creatures and monsters. We have found alcohol bottles around the fire pit. Did you take any other kind of drug before the events of the night?
[K. KA] : Fucking hell, we only drank a beer! We were totally sober, it wasn’t some kind of hallucinations, you- [redacted].
NORTHKILL PRECINCT - ROOM 2
[E. MOUNTEBANK] : Instead of interrogating me, you should be investing. There is some serious shit going on at Hackett’s Quarry. I bet you don’t believe me. Go see in the treehouse for yourself.
[OFFICER] : We already did. All we found was Mr. Brinly there, not a single “creature”.
[E. MOUNTEBANK] : Brinly, as in the-counselor-who-didn’t-show-up Max Brinly? The girl, Laura’s boyfriend ? Wait, so that means... Mr. H...
[OFFICER] : Yes, him. What about Mr. Hackett?
[E. MOUNTEBANK] : I- nothing.
[OFFICER] : Miss, if you’re withholding informations-
[E. MOUNTEBANK] : I am not. Besides, I got proof. If you just give me my damn phone back, I got a picture of it-
[OFFICER] : Your phone will be looked through. Where were you at about 4AM?
[E. MOUNTEBANK] : I had other preoccupation than the damn time- ugh. I think it was when Abi and I were in the basement, or when we climbed into Mr. H’s office. The doors were locked, but you know that.
[OFFICER] : Right. Why were you hiding?
[E. MOUNTEBANK] : We were’t hiding- I mean, well- we were trying to stay alive. It was the only place the- the... things could not hurt us.
NORTHKILL PRECINCT - ROOM 8
[OFFICER] : We are being serious here, Mr. Lenivy. As of now, three dead bodies have been found-
[D. LENIVY] : Wait, three-?! Who are they- is it- is Ryan okay?
[OFFICER] : Mr. Erzahler is alive. It seems he was wounded but he will survive. The bodies all belong to the Hackett family.
[D. LENIVY] : Ah, great- I mean, no! Not great, definitely, uhm-
[OFFICER] : Sir, do you confirm being in the lodge around around 4AM with Miss Ka?
[D. LENIVY] : Uh, yeah. Not so much “being” as “hiding for my fucking life”.
[OFFICER] : Miss Ka has admitted to have shot Caleb Hackett. Is it true?
[D. LENIVY] : It’s true that she saved my goddamned life, yeah. Wait, rewind a bit- Caleb Hackett? It was him? Never mind, Kaitlyn is a fucking hero and I really don’t like the way you seem to... implicate otherwise- you’re not accusing her are you?
[OFFICER] : Look, we have dead bodies on our hands. They didn’t kill themselves. Now, about Kaylee Hackett, do you-
[D. LENIVY] : Nope. No, no, not telling you anything.
[OFFICER] : Sir, you have to-
[D. LENIVY] : I don’t have to nothing. I have the right to a lawyer, and I want one. You’re not getting anything else from me.
NORTHKILL PRECINCT - ROOM 3
[OFFICER] : Miss, please. I need you to tell me what happened.
[A. BLYG] : I- it’s just so messy. So confusing... I...
[OFFICER] : How about Mr. Furcillo. He said that you were in the woods before you got attacked. Is that right?
[A. BLYG] : It is, yeah... just because of that stupid game, God it’s my fault, if I hadn’t run away then-
[A. BLYG] : He wouldn’t have gotten bit. That’s when it all started to go south. There was so much blood, the wound was so big... I tried to help, I really did, I swear-
[OFFICER] : What happened next, miss?
[A. BLYG] : He wasn’t the same. I spent two months with him, I just know that wasn’t Nick- he became so agressive, I had to! He would have killed me otherwise! It’s my fault he died-
[OFFICER] : Mr. Furcillo isn’t dead. We found him in the forest at dawn. Do you have any idea how he might have got there?
[A. BLYG] : He’s- he’s alive? I- woah- uh-... No sir, so I don’t have any idea. He just- left... after... yeah.
NORTHKILL PRECINCT - ROOM 6
[OFFICER] : Mr. Brinly, do you have any recollection of the night?
[M. BRINLY] : Where is Laura?
[OFFICER] : Sir, please answer-
[M. BRINLY] : No. Where is Laura? I’m not telling you anything before you tell me if she’s alright.
[OFFICER] : Laura Kearney is fine and is at the precinct. Now, she claims that you two were held hostage by Travis Hackett, is it true?
[M. BRINLY] : Yeah it is. That asshole kept us locked.
[OFFICER] : So, after this you escaped and went to Hackett’s Quarry. Why go there and not flee?
[M. BRINLY] : It’s.. complicated to explain. We had business to take care of.
[OFFICER] : What kind of business?
[M. BRINLY] : You wouldn’t understand. Heck, you wouldn’t even believe it.
[OFFICER] : Why don’t you try and give me your version. Your statement of the night.
[M. BRINLY] : ...I’m telling you. It’s messed up... so fucking messed up...
NORTHKILL PRECINCT - ROOM 9
[OFFICER] : Look, sir. We need you to collaborate. We can’t figure it out if you won’t tell us.
[OFFICER] : You realize that your silence isn’t helping your case.
[OFFICER] : We have several witnesses placing you at the Hackett’s house at the time of death of Constance and Christopher Hackett.
[OFFICER] : You are currently the lead suspect for those murders, don’t you have anything to say about that, Mr. Erzahler ?
[OFFICER] : Okay, we are clearly getting nowhere with this.
[END OF THE TRANSCRIPTION]