sorry i haven't been here for so long the rdr2 hyperfixation is trying to kill me.
BUT ! that does mean that i keep thinking about a wild west malev au. or even better a rdr2 and malevolent crossover.
JUST PICTURE IT: arthur lester having a conversation with arthur morgan. it's nice, normal, maybe arthur morgan is messing with arthur lester. overall i think they'd get along just fine. but this also means that john doe and john marston are conversing too
personally i think that john and john would kill each other or really *really* want to. if they're not arguing, they're both talking about completely separate things but they both think they're talking about the same thing and that the other just doesn't Get It like they do.
maybe in a perfect world, jack marston and faroe lester would be friends.
PUT OSCAR IN A ROOM WITH REVEREND SWANSON!!! PLEASE!!! god they both make me SICK. also detective noel and dutch would be an interesting conversation. i feel like their energy would bounce off each other. but like early dutch like chapter 2 maybe 3
i actually need arthur (lester, hereby known as larthur) to play cards with multiple people in the van der linde gang. bonus if det. noel is there too. also bonus if noel knows about john (doe) and nobody else does and also this is john still being in arthur's head. oururgrghh john making their eyes look in directions that might not make complete sense, larthur reacting to things late, the sort of stuff not many people would notice BUT SOMEBODY LIKE HOSEA WOULD.
also i think oscar having a day out fishing with hosea would be so awkward for oscar at first but ultimately fix him
also also i need javier and larthur to play something (music wise) together. even if they dont necessarily play the same genre i need jarthur to have to go with the van der linde gang for some reason and then they find out larthur used to be a pianist and he finds a piano somewhere or something and plays for the gang. something like that
it would make sense if he denied to play at first too honestly but also im wondering if he would play as a way to distract a bit / make him seem more honest as more suspicion about what he's not telling the gang rises.












