Okay, I finally decided to take this asexuality quiz that has been so popular in the ace tag, mostly because I suspected it was going to be...bad...and it was exactly what I suspected.
So for starters, here's my results and an explanation of each area so we can all be on the same reference page:
I'm going to address these points in order, for the sake of clarity:
Lack of sexual attraction. Literally the only actual defining point of asexuality, and even that is a spectrum under the asexual umbrella. And yet, not only is the vast majority of the spectrum just outright omitted, but the examples given have nothing to do with sexual attraction. Sure, lack of attraction CAN manifest that way, but the more honest example is "do you look at a person and actively think 'damn, I wouldn't mind having sex with *them*'?" No? Then congrats, you're not sexually attracted to them. If that's the same with literally everyone, you're probably acespec. If that's the case with MOSTLY everyone or everyone* *terms and conditions may apply, then congrats, you're probably acespec. Turning attraction into defining it by actions is both inaccurate and invalidating to the wide array of asexuals who DO have fantasies, desire engaging in sexual activity, and/or are not averse to sexual behavior.
Lack of romantic attraction. This is allo/aromanticism. This is irrelevant to the asexual spectrum. This is like having a wedge of this graph referring to someone being nonbinary.
Absent libido: not a factor in asexuality. Whether or not you experience libido a lot, a little, or never is completely irrelevant to your asexuality. You can experience 0 sexual attraction ever and have a high libido and you're still asexual. You can experience sexual attraction rarely/after certain criteria are met and have no libido ever and you're still asexual. Your libido is not tied to or indicative or your attraction.
Aversion to sexual behavior. SEX FAVORABLE ASEXUALS EXIST. Hell, sex indifferent asexuals exist! Being sex repulsed is NOT A REQUIREMENT TO BE ASEXUAL. This is just flat out exclusionary. And yes, I realize it says "some", but it shouldn't even be included in this quiz. That "some" feels like a handwaved "oh yeah, and non sex repulsed people exist too, I guess, ANYWAY-" If someone wants to make a sex favorability quize that's an entirely seperate topic.
Again, this is not relevant. YES, some asexuals have sexual trauma that caused their asexuality. Some asexuals have sexual trama BECAUSE of their asexuality. Some have no trauma. Some, like me, have sexual related trauma that is entirely divorced from my asexuality in every way (mine's religious trauma). Not only is trauma once again an irrelevant point here, the quiz specifically focuses on sexual trama that caused asexuality. If you experienced sexual trauma in any other context, your experience is not considered or counted here.
Estrangement from Sexual Culture. This is entirely focused on sex repulsed aces. The questions are exclusively talking about feeling estranged because you aren't interested in or experiencing the same thing. There is no room for or consideration of those of us who may feel estranged not because we don't have/want sex, but because we DO, but in a way that is different from what's portrayed in society. We have represention for "I'm asexual, I don't fuck" and we have endless representation for "I'll allosexual, I love to fuck", but there's no representation for "I'm asexual, I love to fuck", let alone the countless ways that can manifest. This quiz doesn't account for that at all. Either you're sex repulsed, or you must not feel estranged from sexual culture, OBVIOUSLY (that last sentence is sarcastic).
Overall my experience with this quiz is that it's made with an incredibly narrow view of what makes up asexuality, and anyone who is not a sex repulsed asexual who either has sexual trauma that made them asexual or has no sexual trauma at all simply isn't considered in any way. I think there ARE ways to make a quiz like this that could be helpful for someone in understanding their sexuality, but the way both the questions and the categories are written is solely considering one ace experience, which is really unfortunate.