I actually don't mind POC Luis hcs at all. I just hope that fans extend the same protecting to actual poc who face racism in fan spaces. There are a lot of people who hate characters like Ada, who is canonically a woc and some of them are Luis fans. And I think that if you are going to hc Luis as a poc, then it is very important that you are speaking about racism actual characters of color face.
I'm a little bit confused OP. "Actual characters of color face" Do you think people who "hc" Luis as POC for funsies? Spain has many ethnicities, just because it's part of Europe, doesn't mean all Spaniards are white. You're basically white-washing other poc that exist within Spain no?
I'm not sure what corner of the community you are im, but I've seen a lot of people protecting Ada, and just as Ada gets a lot of hate and racism, Luis and Carlos receive the same.
If these Luis fans are being racist against Ada, they need to be called out directly of course, but that does not take away from Luis being poc? Like why are we gatekeep poc, coming from an actual poc myself.
I'm also POC and also hc Luis as POC. I'm mostly talking about things I and other poc, especially spanish poc (like Romani, MENA and Muslim poc in spain) have just been noticing about fandom racism discussions, especially with regards to how characters of color in RE are treated. when it comes to conversations of fandom racism, luis mostly dominates those conversation rather than characters like carlos or ada, and it makes it difficult. esp in twitter spaces, where ada faces a lot of racialized misogyny. and luis tends to get more visibility than ada and carlos as well.
I don't think people hc him as poc for funsies, because even I hc as poc and it's not for funsies. but luis is from from an extremely xenophobic and racist town in spain, that is extremely, religious hostile to outsiders. they've let no one in or out for many many years, while i hc him as poc, to me it canonically screams white. esp since i've been subjected to racism from people like that in spain.
I've been to spain and have spoken to people who look like luis, and who are darker than luis, and called me anti-black slurs. i've been cursed out in italy and spain for being dark skinned. a muslim woman and i were called slurs in spain by people who were the same shade as luis. i got kicked out of an air bnb in spain by people who look like luis. i've seen people who look like luis call romani people in spain slurs.
sure, luis might be poc but i just don't see him as such canonically. and i'd rather spend my time protecting actual, confirmed characters of color from racism and erasure in fandom racism discussions.
also there are tons of discussions about in on twitter and these people actually explain it quite well. i linked it for you.
and i mean, there are ACTUAL people of color leading these conversations, not just white people. in fact, it's not white people at all. Here is another post as well.
@choccy-sippy
















