Fantasy Baseball 2011 - Early Rankings: OF Edition
I've been putting off this post for a while because there are a ton of outfielders to do, and there's also been some shifting around as of late (trades and such). Regardless, outfield much more of a shallow position than you'd think this year, so it's important to nab at least one good one before you're stuck with a bunch of question marks.
DAN'S TOP 20 OUTFIELDERS FOR 2011
1. Carl Crawford
2010 Stats: 110 R / 19 HR / 90 RBI / .307 BA / 47 SB
Carl Crawford had a great year last year, and while his speed was down (not that 47 steals is bad), his production was up, posting career highs in runs, home runs, and RBIs. Now he moves into an even more potent offense, where he'll bat 3rd once again. The result is that not only does Carl Crawford remain a safe bet for great production, but he also has the possibility to improve even further on his fantastic 2010. A little tidbit to keep in mind: even though he's been around forever, Carl Crawford is only 29--right in the midst of his prime.
2. Ryan Braun
2010 Stats: 101 R / 25 HR / 103 RBI / .304 BA / 14 SB
In what seemed like a very down year for the Brewers offense as a whole, Ryan Braun still managed to put up respectable, 1st-2nd round pick numbers. However, he had a pretty significant dip in power, making his season appear all the more lackluster. He's still young, so I'd write it off as more of a fluke than a downward trend. Expect the Brewers offense to bounce back, and Braun's numbers will rise accordingly. The potential and the upside are all there, and we've seen it happen before.
3. Carlos Gonzalez
2010 Stats: 111 R / 34 HR / 117 RBI / .336 BA / 26 SB
The potential was always there for Cargo, but it was just a matter of playing time in a very crowded outfield. Finally, he was given a shot and he exploded--perhaps beyond expectations--with an MVP caliber season. It's hard to say that he can get any better than he did, and so we might have seen the ceiling for Cargo already, but he's young and he plays in Coors Field. Don't draft him expecting any better than what he did last year, but don't be surprised if he exceeds expectations once again.
4. Josh Hamilton
2010 Stats: 95 R / 32 HR / 100 RBI / .359 BA / 8 SB
Josh Hamilton has the potential to be an absolute monster at the plate, but it's not a question of "can he produce" so much as it is "can he stay healthy." So far, that's really only been one season, but even missing about 30 games last year, he still put up numbers that dwarfed most others and netted himself an MVP in the process. The batting average probably won't be quite as high, but if he can stay healthy for the whole season, expect huge RBI numbers and very possibly 40+ home runs.
5. Matt Holliday
2010 Stats: 95 R / 28 HR / 103 RBI / .312 BA / 9 SB
Matt Holliday is very boring. He's a good kind of boring because he constantly produces, but at the same time you know exactly what you're getting when you draft him--something very similar to those stats listed above. Unlike the other Top 5, he doesn't have the promise of high power, speed, or some thrilling mix of the two, but he sits consistently in the above-average range in almost every category. I almost feel that he gets overlooked for this very reason, but if you're looking for a safe, sure-thing at the OF position, look no further.
6. Nelson Cruz
2010 Stats: 60 R / 22 HR / 78 RBI / .318 BA / 17 SB
Nelson Cruz has a whole lot of upside, but like his teammate Josh Hamilton, he has a ton of problems staying healthy. He's yet to put up a full season in his career, but even in limited time he's been extremely productive, particularly in power and speed. Just two years ago he put up a 33/20 season in only 128 games--a full year of him and his boomstick can very likely post 40/25. His speed might start to diminish, though, with the constant injuries to his leg last year, but the power potential still remains.
7. Matt Kemp
2010 Stats: 82 R / 28 HR / 89 RBI / .249 BA / 19 SB
2010 was a strange year for Matt Kemp, whose production took a sharp dive, most notably in batting average. The Dodgers as a whole were in shambles last year, but Matt Kemp in particular seemed to be suffering the most from this, dealing with vague, random disciplinary problems. With all the McCourt stuff sorted out, look for the Dodgers to sort things out, but until I see a return to form from Kemp, I'd be very wary when drafting him.
8. Shin-Soo Choo
2010 Stats: 81 R / 22 HR / 90 RBI / .300 BA / 22 SB
Shin-Soo Choo is sort of like the Korean version of Matt Holliday. He's very consistent and contributes moderately across the board. Choo's problem isn't so much a lack of upside, though; instead, it's being cursed by a horrible, horrible team. On any other team, Choo would easily be in triple digits in both runs and RBIs, and with his speed he'd likely be closer to Matt Holliday in value. For now, though, he's stuck on the Indians. Also, if you weren't aware, avoid him in keeper leagues, as the lingering issue of his required Korean military service remains.
9. Justin Upton
2010 Stats: 73 R / 17 HR / 69 RBI / .273 BA / 18 SB
After a very promising-looking 2009 in which he posted 26/20 with a .300 BA, Justin Upton put up a big stinker of a 2010. There were flashes of brilliance here and there, but in the end Upton ended with very plain numbers. That said, he's only 23 years old and the upside is plentiful, but just keep in mind that you're drafting a player who still has lots of development to do. If he can get it together again, he'll be quite a solid power/speed player, but again, that's an if.
10. Ichiro Suzuki
2010 Stats: 74 R / 6 HR / 43 RBI / .315 BA / 42 SB
At this point in Ichiro's career, you should be drafting him for purely corrective purposes. He's sure to steal bases, and he's guaranteed to hit anywhere from probably .305-.350. Unfortunately, he no longer has any value outside of this. He was on base over 250 times last year, and he only scored 74 runs. How is this even possible? Oh, right, he's the only semblance of offense on the Mariners. Dear lord.
11. Andrew McCutchen
2010 Stats: 94 R / 16 HR / 56 RBI / .286 BA / 33 SB
If Shin-Soo Choo is Matt Holliday-lite, then Andrew McCutchen is Carl Crawford-lite. He's still batting leadoff, so the RBI opportunities won't necessarily be there, and most of his team is awful regardless, but nevertheless, he has lots of upside (24 years old) and has shown some promise. I'm high on him as opposed to, say, Justin Upton primarily because he's shown improvement in his limited time in the majors thusfar. He's got the tools to improve even more, so he's certainly worth taking a chance on.
12. Jayson Werth
2010 Stats: 106 R / 27 HR / 85 RBI / .296 BA / 13 SB
Jayson Werth had a monster 2009 and a pretty good 2010; his reward was a long-term deal with the Washington Nationals. Yikes. That said, they're actually a pretty good offense, but they're no Philly. Werth will probably be batting either cleanup or 3rd right next to Ryan Zimmerman, so the opportunities will certainly be there, and Nationals Park is a pretty hitter friendly field. It's very possible and likely for him to put up last year's numbers (sans the batting average--I'd expect .270-.280), but one thing to note is his declining speed, going down from multiple 20-steal seasons to 13. Just a heads up.
13. Alex(is?) Rios
2010 Stats: 89 R / 21 HR / 88 RBI / .284 BA / 34 SB
Is Alex Rios alive again? It's tough to say. After falling off the map after two All-Star seasons, Alex Rios was pretty much left for dead, especially when he got moved to Chicago and put up terrible numbers. Then suddenly last year, Vintage Alex Rios returned, posting career highs in RBIs and stolen bases. The talent has always been there, and Chicago's offense has only gotten better with the addition of Adam Dunn, so there's no reason not to believe he can't repeat or improve on last year's production. At the same time, if he went back to underperforming, I wouldn't be at all surprised.
14. Jason Heyward
2010 Stats: 83 R / 18 HR / 72 RBI / .277 BA / 11 SB
Jason Heyward made a huge splash in his rookie debut, but as evidenced by his numbers, his year wasn't quite as good as people seem to make it out to be. He struggled with consistency throughout the year, even going homerless in July and hitting below the Mendoza line in June. However, what he did show was that he has a ton of talent--he is, after all, only 21 years old. His second year looks to have nothing but upside, and he'll likely be batting in or near the 3-hole. The little speed was a nice bonus, as well. Temper your expectations going into this year, and target him in keeper leagues for when he finally breaks out.
15. Andre Ethier
2010 Stats: 71 R / 23 HR / 82 RBI / .292 BA / 2 SB
Like most of the Dodgers, Andre Ethier had a bit of a down year, as evidenced by his numbers. He wasn't quite as bad off as they show, though, as he missed about 30 games. It's hard for me to really say anything else about Ethier other than that I'd expect him to rebound a bit. He's got power potential, with 2009's 31 homers probably being a good estimate, possibly more.
16. Hunter Pence
2010 Stats: 93 R / 25 HR / 91 RBI / .282 BA / 18 SB
I've never particularly liked Hunter Pence. He's sort of a middling player on a poor offense, and frankly he looks really goofy. But 2010 was a career year for him, and suddenly he has legitimate relevance. I don't think he really has the upside to exceed those numbers, but his speed has been steadily increasing over the past few years, so 20 bags might be a reasonable estimate. I guess in a way he's kinda like Jayson Werth, so a random power surge could also be in the making, but for now draft him for what he is, not what he might be.
17. Jay Bruce
2010 Stats: 80 R / 25 HR / 70 RBI / .281 BA / 5 SB
One of these days. Jay Bruce has all the makings of a future fantasy stud, but the key word is "future." He's only 23, and for someone whose best asset is power, that typically doesn't translate until a little later on on the career. That said, there's lots of upside here, though you'd think that in the Reds' above-average offense, he'd be producing a little more. I'd chalk it up to bad luck for now and hope for better this year. I'd project maybe 30 dingers this year with the potential for more, but I know I'm not the only one hyped up about him, so don't overpay for unrealized potential.
18. Jacoby Ellsbury
2010 Stats: 10 R / 0 HR / 5 RBI / .192 BA / 7 SB
A horribly ugly stat line for Ellsbury, but keep in mind he was hurt for the vast, vast majority of the season after being assassinated by Adrian Beltre. The good news is that not only is he rehabbing well thusfar, but also Adrian Beltre isn't on the team anymore to kill him again. Anyway, if healthy, expect him to kind of be what Ichiro is, obviously without the high batting average upside (though he does have a .291 career average). He'll steal a ton of bags, actually score runs, and hit a few homers here and there. Just make sure he is in fact healthy before drafting him, since, as evidenced by last season, that injury is highly detrimental to his game.
19. Mike Stanton
2010 Stats: 45 R / 22 HR / 59 RBI / .259 BA / 5 SB
Here's the difference between Jay Bruce and Mike Stanton. One guy clearly still needs time to develop. The other guy would've been on pace to hit ~35 home runs in his rookie year. At 21 years old. There's no question as to whether or not Mike Stanton can hit for power, and so I'm almost tempted to move him up higher. What's holding me back is that our sample size thusfar is limited. While I wouldn't doubt Mike Stanton could hit any less than 30 homers next year, I'm also concerned about his batting average. If he hits .259 again, then that's not so bad. But it's more than likely he'll have some kind of regression, and so if he hits .220 instead, suddenly that's a problem. Don't forget that Mike Stanton also struck out 123 times in limited at bats as well, so this is certainly a possibility. Jay Bruce, on the other hand, is the more complete and experienced player, and so I'd feel safer going with him and his upside than Mike Stanton's possible upside and downside.
20. Chris Young
2010 Stats: 94 R / 27 HR / 91 RBI / .257 BA / 28 SB
It's kind of sad that Chris Young posted a career high batting average last year, but alas, that's just the kind of player he is. He's essentially the new Curtis Granderson with a bit more production potential and a much lower batting average ceiling--in 2009, he hit .212. Like all batting average risk players, if you're going to make a stab at Chris Young--or Mike Stanton, for that matter--just make sure that you have an Ichiro-type ready to correct your inevitable problems.