THE HUNGER GAMES & THE CHRISTIAN METANARRATIVE
I came across an interesting article recently, one that was posted in the Washington Times by Donald L. Brake, Sr. After analyzing his experience watching The Hunger Games with his granddaughter in theatres, he concludes, “Maybe we don’t need to work so hard to make [the Bible] relevant by viewing movies as a basis for Bible studies and dissecting the theology of every movie or book.” I will tell you I was greatly distressed by this statement and I wholeheartedly disagree with Mr. Brake’s conclusion. Granted, we don’t need to “try hard” to make the Bible relevant, God did a more than sufficient job of ensuring His Word would never lose its relevancy, but should we give up “dissecting the theology of every movie or book”? My answer is no! A thousand times no! (a little reverse quote there for you P&P fans) The problem plaguing Christianity and the world today is the same problem that plagued the nation Israel in Hosea, how’s that for relevancy? Consider the Lord’s word to them in Hosea 4:6a “My people are destroyed for lack of knowledge…” Too often we are guilty of “just reading to read,” “just listening to listen,” and “just watching to watch.” We are no longer being taught or exhorted to interact with music, books, and movies. We have become passive consumers who feast on whatever is laid before us, never taking the time or care to read the nutrition labels of our entertainment meals. Yet, everything we consume has a theology. So Mr. Brake, you do a great disservice to a culture that is perishing for lack of knowledge when you make erroneous statements such as you do in your article. I urge you reader, please dissect everything.
Now, I would like to turn your attention to The Hunger Games Trilogy by Suzanne Collins. This post is entitled, “The Hunger Games and the Christian Metanarrative.” Metanarratives are embedded in every story. At its simplest definition, the word, metanarrative, could be defined as the "big story," or the comprehensive explanation of many little stories. The Bible appears to be a collection of many different stories, but on a higher level, we see a unity present in the Scriptures, an overarching theme: Creation, Fall, Redemption. This is the Christian metanarrative and it is present in every story. Put another way, you could write is as: Origin, Conflict, Resolution. I would argue that to write a story sans these components, the author would have to go to great lengths to do so. But why is this important? This is important because people like Mr. Brake are a dime a dozen nowadays. Brilliant writer D.P. Teague explains this tragedy, “[Postmodern] people do not believe in metanarratives. They feel that there are no grand stories which give meaning to all of life and which define what is true. Jean-François Lyotard (1924-1998), the postmodern philosopher, said: ‘Simplifying to the extreme, I define postmodern as incredulity towards metanarratives.’ Opposition to metanarratives is the defining characteristic of postmodernism and its followers. We must reject this belief and continue to engage and look for the metanarratives so present in all that we read, watch, or listen to.
So, what is the relationship between The Hunger Games and the Christian metanarrative? First of all, I would like to say that one of my dear friends introduced me to these books and they are fantastic reads! *SPOILER ALERT* Granted, I was very upset with some deaths in the series, namely, Cinna and Prim, Suzanne, why?? But, to continue I will say after finishing the series and having some good talks with a friend and serious reflection on the theology present in the books, I have made a conclusion. The first book was intriguing, the second, thrilling, and the last, disappointing. I finished Mockingjay feeling kinda blah (to put it in serious theological terms). I would say I felt kinda unfinished, dissatisfied, frustrated, and a little let down. Why did I feel that way? I mean, even though I am totally Team Cinna :) the guy got the girl, Suzanne even gave us a nice little epilogue so we could get a little more on their happily ever after, and the villain was defeated. So why did I feel this way? What more did I want (besides Cinna and Prim to be alive)? And here it is… religion, God, anything of that sort is completely absent and removed from The Hunger Games Triology. So how does this story relate to the Christian metanarrative? Well, granted it has everything, origin/into, conflict, and resolution, it does lack something still, something powerful enough to make you feel unfinished, blah, after concluding the series. What Suzanne Collins has done, either on purpose or not, is something brilliant when noticed. She asks and answers the question, what does redemption look like in a world without God? Or, what does redemption look like in a world without a redeemer? If there is no Creator, no God, how do we as humanity recover from our terrible fall? The fall is present in this story. You see the utter depravity of man showcased brightly through the games. It bears strong similarities to the Lord of the Flies, in that regard. Yet, when all is recovered, repaired, redemption takes place, you get the feeling that things will still never be the same. If you remove the Cross from history, you remove humanity’s hope. So even when things are “repaired” even the repair is just not that great. Redemption is just not as sweet. The boy gets the girl, the villain is destroyed, they live happily ever after, but how happy? How free? Blah is the sentiment of redemption and the characters and we, the readers, are forced to settle with that.
This of course, is all just my opinion. I would love to hear your thoughts! Even if you totally disagree with me, I do hope that you will take the time thoughtfully reflect and seriously dissect whatever you choose to read, watch, or listen to. SOLI DEO GLORIA friends.