An incomplete list of thoughts on the Gilmore Girls revival
1. Start with Richardâs deathâ well, not quite.
First, give us a day in Starâs Hollow, a winterâs festival with Taylor freaking out and Luke grumbling and Miss Patty flirting and Kirk toting around his pigâ I loved his pigâ and Laneâs band playing in the gazebo. Rory, visiting, just got that article published, and itâs on the back of Lukeâs menus. Get all of the nostalgia out of the way, in this whirlwind of things going right.
We need that reunion, certainly, that reminder of how much we love this tiny, crazy town and the people who live there. Send Rory, Luke, and Lorelei home down familiar streets, to the house she and Luke rebuilt together, strung up with Christmas lights Lorelei definitely made Luke hang while she ate leftover Halloween candy and called critique from below.
Everything is good. Lorelei woke up that morning smelling snow. Rory is pulling tater tots out of the freezerâ âDidnât you have enough fried nonsense at Kirkâs fried nonsense booth?â âFried Oreos, not fried potato shreds.â âNONSENSE.â
And then we get the call from Emily, about Richard.
Give us joy, reminders, a setting we recall and loveâ but then give us plot.
If you look at the bones of the four episodes, Richard haunted all of it. He should, but we shouldnât have to bury down to the bones to realize that. Start with thatâ frame it. With Richardâs death set up as a catalyst, rather than backstory, Roryâs erratic behavior makes more intuitive sense throughout that year. The ghost of him is in the forefront of our minds. We watch those happy first few minutes shake, and the things that our kids were only pretending were stable start to fall apart.
The funeralâ with Luke playing handyman out of discomfort and a desire to help, with Lorelei staying behind to support her mom and instead getting cornered, drunk and grieving, asked to say something simple and positive about a relationship that was complicated at its bestâ is now our plot starting to roll forward, as Lorelei and Emily have their falling out. Rory goes home and cancels the lease on her apartment, because sheâs hardly ever there, right? When was the last time she was in Brooklyn? It just doesnât make sense, right? Nothing makes sense anymore.
And everything slowly starts to unravelâ Michel is thinking about leaving. Rory goes to London to meet with River Song about the book, and falls into bed with Logan. Her job talk keeps getting pushed back, and when it actually happens they ask about her future and present projects and she stumbles over her tongue. Emilyâs words ringing in her ears, Lorelei starts looking into having children again, unsure who wants what or why or when.
This is a story about finding out who you are, and I liked thatâ the three Gilmore girls, who always thought they knew what they were doing, finding themselves adrift in the aftermath of loss and change.
Is Lorelei supposed to be a mother again? Are she and Luke doing this rightâ is this what love is supposed to look like, nine years in? Is her inn too small, her ambitions too quietâ if she does not reach for more, will she lose everyone she built this with, one by one? What does she want?
What is Emily supposed to with this empty house? With this portrait looming wall-sized over everything? With the things they had built together because they had wanted them togetherâ what is she supposed to do now?
And Rory, the smart one, the pretty one, the last best hope of the Gilmore clan, the pride of Starâs Hollowâ every accomplishment is expected, every failure is âout of character.â The worldâs been bending itself to Roryâs will all her lifeâ not even her will, exactly. The world loves herâ it protects and favors her but it also pushes things onto her and always has. Her grandfather dies, her book deal falls apart, the website turns her downâ who is she supposed to be now?
2. I would have loved to see more of that with our minor characters, tooâ change, and conflict. Itâs been nine years, and it should look like thatâ I thought that was well done with Paris, with Dean, with Michel. But a lot of other people seemed in frozen in time.
2a. Laneâs gone from infants to prepubescents, and the band looks the same. Have her and the band be writing the spring musical for the elementary school and teaching kids how to strum electrical guitar. Have them have dropped their dreams of touring in exchange for making YouTube videosâ nothingâs gone viral, but they have a following and they do weekly Q&Aâs while their kids frolic in the background. While Rory paces about Logan or her mom or her grandfather, have Lane be freaking out about turning into her mother after one of her kids has a tantrum about not wanting to go to music lessons. Have Lane be involved and present in her own life. You donât lose doubts and stress just because you have something that looks like a picket fence. You donât stop moving.
2b. What the hell is up with Logan? What happened in the last nine years to regress him back to that level of adulterous immaturity? Iâm sad to say I believe it of Rory. But the Logan who grew through seasons 6 and 7? I donât, I really donât. Either explain it or give us a different story.
Even something just as much asâ he and Odette decided on an open relationship, because this is obviously a âdynastyâ match by Mitchum. Odetteâs in love with a Parisian pastry chef, she and Logan are happy partners in crime, and Roryâs sense of self can still grate at being not quite âthe other womanâ but definitely Loganâs âdirty little secret.â
2c. And the Life and Death Brigade! Like, I can absolutely believe they stagnated, but Iâd have loved some mention dropped that one of themâto his GREAT SHAMEâhas fallen in love with accounting and works a nine to five. In a cubicle. And he doesnât even hate it.
And maybe one of themâs fallen in love with a Californian sculptor who doesnât put up with his shit, and heâs absolutely loyal, barely manages to flirt with anyone all night. They have a Great Dane, out in their home in Monterey, and he walks the pup along the foggy coast every morning before he goes home and makes breakfast for his still-asleep girlfriend.
3. Where did the second half of Parisâs arc go? I wanted her to figure out it wasnât the marriage that was the problem, it was the stairs, and sell the house. I wanted her and Rory to get drinks every season, while Rory stressed about the eighteen article pitches she had in the fire (did she write anything in those twelve months except a book Lorelei asked her not to?), and Paris tore apart Doyleâs latest script with language slightly kinder than what she used to his face. Â
4. There are plenty of things to keepâ keep the relationship Jess and Luke have grown into, where Jess makes Luke take a break and sit down and talk when he can tell somethingâs wrong, where he rips out Lukeâs wireless router as a gesture of love, and steals his ballcap.
4b. Keep Lorelei going out to hike the Pacific Crest Trail because she read a book and she wants an epiphanyâ keep the fact that she never ends up hiking anywhere, and keep her phone call to Emily behind a closed roadside diner, when she tells her the story about her father that she hadnât been able to give Emily at the funeral.
4c. Lord, keep Emilyâs adopting Bertaâs whole family and moving to Nantucket and frightening children with gleeful stories of whale murder. Itâs not that her life with Richard, as society wife and DAR leader, wasnât a full and fulfilling and true oneâ itâs just that that life was theirs, and he is gone. She needed to find something that would give her joy, and she did.
4d. Keep Lukeâs Diner unfranchised, and, yes, absolutely, give Lorelei the inheritance for the Dragonfly. She has always been the empire builder.Â
4e. Keep Rory turning down Loganâs key. For all I found the details of the arc with Logan absurd, I loved the end of it. That conversation, full of affection and respectâ he will be there if she needs him, but she needs not to need him, and heâs gonna let her go. And her going to her grandfatherâs study, writing at his deskâ I think that was right, too. It went full circle, and I liked that. Rory and Richardâs friendship remains important to me, in his absence or not.
Though Roryâs relationship with grief was much subtler than Emilyâs or Loreleiâs (and maybe should have been less subtleâŠ), her grandfather shaped so much of her. She was running for so much of this story, graspingâ leaving boxes here and there. She wouldnât be who she was without Lorelei, but she also wouldnât be the same without Richard and Emily.
5. But as much as I lovelove the desk, Rory sitting there with the blue light of her Mac lighting up her face in her grandfatherâs inner sanctumâ Iâm pissed she wrote the book.
I was so damn proud of Lorelei for telling Rory âno.â I wanted Rory to respect that, not to talk about how she needed it. I wanted Lorelei to get the boundaries she asked for. It became, as it often does in this show, first about Roryâs desiresâ not even her needs, just her wants.Â
And, more than thatâ Rory counters Loreleiâs desire for privacy with the argument that this book is the only thing that inspires her right now, the only thing thatâs easy. Uh, okay? Why is your ease more important than your motherâs ownership of her own story? Iâm a writer, so maybe this pisses me off more than your average viewerâ but writing is work. This is not about easy and hard. Writingâs something you pour time and effort into. You write when youâre inspired, when youâre not, when you love the words and when you hate themâ you put things down on paper.
And Roryâs not just a writerâ sheâs someone whoâs trying to make a living as a journalist and/or non-fiction author. How on earth is she paying her bills? Did she write a single article that whole year? My god, childâ write about lines in NYC. Become a staff member on the website thatâs begging for youâ and go into your interview with pitches, like a goddamn professional. Did she forget she had to earn things? Rory has this tendency to have things handed to her, and I can never tell if the show knows. Take notes on River Song, the eccentric feminist academicâ ask questions instead of doodling. There was a book there, absolutely, but Rory wasnât putting in the work.
And when Lorelei tells you she doesnât want her story told, Rory, you listen.
I wanted Rory at that desk, face lit up in the dim light, comfortable in her grandfatherâs legacy and love, but I wanted her to be writing something else.
Write about Starâs Hollow, this absurd cast of lovely characters and public shenanigans. There are books and books thereâ imagine the stories Miss Patty could tell.
Write about Richard, or go up to Nantucket and ask Emily about her life, her loves, her successes and failures and triumphs. In high school Rory once made a piece on asphalt seem fascinating; she can handle pulling some interest out of decades of backstabbing and intrigue in New England upper crusts, especially with Emily âIâll say bullshit all I likeâ Gilmoreâs help.
Be a goddamn professional, Rory Gilmore. And buy some underwear.