I fell in love head over heels with your writing! There's so few people writing about the nightbrothers (at least more than just Maul) and I feel like you get them SO WELL!! I specially love how you interpret Icarus and Savage! ❤️✨
What are your thoughts about a poly-Nightbrother situation? Do you see any of them up to share a SO? Or would they be against it or accept it begrudgingly?
You’re so sweet! thank you!🖤I feel like they are a part of me at this point lol I think about these guys A LOT!
About your request! This is only and I repeat ONLY between nightbrothers who are NOT related in any way. Didn’t plan for this to be nsfw but it somehow went there. Im sorry in advance if you didn’t want that. I hope you enjoy it! 🖤
The Nightbrothers - when you ask to be in a poly relationship
Includes: Darth Maul, Savage Opress, Icarus, Scorn
Surprisingly vulnerable about the whole thing. When you tell him you’ve been thinking about trying a poly relationship with him and another Nightbrother, he becomes almost unrecognizable for a moment. He listens to you patiently without interrupting once. It’s unsettlingly quiet coming from him. Maul is usually sharp, intense, always vocal about his thoughts, but this time he simply watches you speak, eyes fixed on you the entire time like he’s studying every shift in your expression, every twitch in your body language.
And when you finally finish talking, nothing could prepare you for the question he asks.
“Tell me the truth,” he says quietly. “Is it because of the way I am from the waist down?”
The vulnerability in his voice hits immediately. You take his face into your hands right away and tell him “No, absolutely not. That has nothing to do with this at all.”
He goes silent for a moment after hearing you out. Maul has deep trust issues, and is a pretty paranoid person overall, so accepting reassurance does not come naturally. But he loves you. More than that, he wants you happy, even if the idea unsettles him in ways he refuses to fully admit out loud. And if this is something you truly want, he would rather be included than risk losing you to somebody else entirely. At least this way he can keep you close, keep you protected, make sure you’re cared for properly.
For a while after the relationship actually begins, Maul becomes noticeably more sensitive. He needs reassurance more often than he’d ever openly ask for, and he dislikes seeing you spend too much time alone with the other Nightbrother. Still, he tries. He’s surprisingly respectful toward both of you once he accepts the dynamic, even if possessiveness still slips through every now and then.
Ironically, the other Nightbrother ends up falling for Maul almost as hard as he falls for you. It takes Maul much longer to emotionally warm up to him, but eventually a strange kind of loyalty and attachment forms between them too.
The sex between all three of you is insanely good though. Something strange happens to Maul, suddenly he starts being more kinky and kind of gets more into impact play. Maybe it’s his way of lowkey punishing you for being so greedy, or maybe he’s trying to claim more of your attention to himself. He has the other nightbrother hold you down while he spanks you, sometimes he’ll use a cane if you were extra bad. And when you whine to him about your bruises and ask him to kiss it better, he’ll try his best to hide it but it quite literally makes him feel like the luckiest man alive. Starts treating the two of you as his pets and sometimes makes you wear dog collars and bark for him. :3
Absolutely hates the idea. The moment he realizes where the conversation is going, he cuts you off before you can even fully explain yourself. His reaction is immediate and explosive. Raised voice, pacing, yelling over you without even meaning to. Savage is emotional by nature, and this hits every insecurity and possessive instinct inside him all at once.
He gets physical with his frustration too. He shoves you away from him in the heat of the moment, slams his fist into the wall hard enough to crack it, starts angrily wiping tears from his face while insisting he’s “fine” when he very obviously isn’t. It becomes a full scene almost instantly.
And when you try to calm things down with a rushed “forget it, I didn’t mean it seriously,” he doesn’t believe you for a second.
That conversation stays in his head for weeks afterward.
He keeps bringing it up at random moments, asking why you even thought about wanting someone else in the first place. Starts eyeing every Nightbrother around you suspiciously, especially the ones you’re close with. He picks fights over nothing, creates painfully awkward tension in group settings, and becomes openly territorial whenever another man gets too comfortable near you.
Savage simply is not built for sharing someone he loves. He cannot emotionally separate love from possession, and the idea that he would not be the only person in your heart genuinely devastates him.
Even in some alternate situation where he forced himself to agree to trying it, the relationship would become messy very quickly. His jealousy would eat him alive. He would start acting out in passive aggressive ways, trying to make you jealous back by flirting with other women or giving them attention just to prove a point. Completely misses the actual meaning of a poly relationship and has little to no interest in bonding with the other Nightbrother involved. At best, he merely tolerates his existence because you asked him to.
Realistically, this kind of dynamic would end up hurting both of you more than anything else.
Not exactly the sharing type, still, he actually lets you explain yourself fully before reacting. In fact, the moment you bring it up, he becomes strangely attentive. There’s this almost desperate curiosity in his eyes while he listens to you speak, like he’s trying to solve a problem in real time.
Has he been too emotionally distant?
What exactly is missing here that makes you want a third person involved?
The concept genuinely does not click with him at first. Not emotionally, anyway. So instead of immediately rejecting it, he starts asking questions. A lot of questions. Calm, analytical ones that slowly become more personal the deeper the conversation goes. He wants specifics. Wants honesty. Wants to understand the psychology behind it completely before he forms any real opinion.
At some point he probably asks to see your datapad logs too, because to him this is not some casual little fantasy or passing thought. This is serious. He needs to know you’re being truthful with him, especially if the relationship itself is potentially changing shape.
Still, through all of it, he remains calm. Very deliberately calm. Even when certain answers visibly sting him a little. He keeps his emotions contained for the sake of healthy communication, partly because he genuinely wants to understand you, and partly because he knows that if he reacts too harshly, you might shut down and stop being honest with him altogether.
Realistically though, Icarus could never truly handle a poly relationship emotionally. Not because he’s possessive in the same way someone like Savage is, but because he simply cannot love multiple people romantically at once. His attachment style is intense and singular. Once he gives someone his heart, that space is permanently occupied by them and them alone. You are the center of his emotional world, and there is no room for another person beside you in that sense.
What he would not mind, however, is keeping it strictly in the bedroom.
He’s far more comfortable with physical intimacy than emotional vulnerability, especially the darker or more taboo sides of it. The idea of occasionally involving another Nightbrother purely in bed does not threaten him nearly as much as actual romantic attachment would. If anything, part of him is fascinated by that hidden side of you. The side that craves experiences like that, the side willing to admit desires most people would bury out of shame. Feels like the type to keep one hand firmly around your throat or jaw while the other Nightbrother is kissing down your neck or touching your thighs. He’d constantly reposition you too, tilting your chin toward him while someone else is making you lose focus, keeping eye contact like he enjoys watching you fall apart under the attention.
He’s also very possessive with subtle touches. Holding your waist from behind while the other guy is in front of you, fingers digging slightly into your hips whenever you react too strongly. I can also see him gripping your wrist and pinning your hand against his chest absentmindedly while the other Nightbrother touches you somewhere more sensitive, almost like he wants you grounded to him specifically no matter who else is involved.
However, like I said, this only works in a form of a casual threesome now and then. It would never translate into your relationship.
Initially gets a little thrown off by the suggestion. Not offended exactly, just surprised. He needs a moment to process it because it genuinely never crossed his mind before. But, he doesn’t immediately reject the idea either. He listens to you carefully, asks a few quiet questions, and mostly just wants to understand what this would mean for the two of you emotionally before anything else.
And honestly? Once he actually experiences being in a poly relationship, he ends up adapting to it shockingly well.
Scorn is naturally affectionate, emotionally open, and deeply physical in the way he expresses love, so instead of viewing the other Nightbrother as competition, he slowly starts treating him as part of the relationship too. He gets attached before he even fully realizes it’s happening. One moment he’s cautiously testing the waters, and the next he’s making sure both of you ate properly, checking in on everyone’s feelings, pulling the two of you into his arms at the same time like it’s the most natural thing in the world.
He becomes extremely protective over the dynamic itself. More than anything, he wants it to feel safe, healthy, and genuine for everyone involved. Communication matters a lot to him, comfort matters a lot to him, and he pays attention to even the smallest emotional shifts between the three of you. If one person feels left out, he notices immediately.
He’s probably the Nightbrother most capable of making the whole arrangement feel warm instead of tense.
And yes, he absolutely fulfills the “two boyfriends who kiss” fantasy without even making a big deal out of it. It happens naturally with him. Casual affection, shared touches, kissing one of you while the other is curled up against him, pulling both of you close at the same time without hesitation. There’s something strangely soft about the way he loves once he fully lets himself settle into the relationship. The type to always have his hands on somebody. One arm wrapped around your waist pushing you deeper down on his cock, while he kisses the other guy, then immediately turning back to pull you into it too like he wants all of you tangled together at all times.
Kisses you while the guy is pressed against your back, smiling a little whenever the two of you start getting shy or hesitant around each other. Scorn likes the feeling of everybody wanting everybody. Instead of seeing love as something that has to be divided, Scorn treats it like something that simply grows larger the more of it he gives away.
thank you for letting me use your beautiful artwork @edjo0424
janainaart
areudirty
origamiaround
gummygunk
prguitarman
germansingergirl
blakekathryn
snowghoul
jacobvanloon
theartofmadeline
