Okay, I think this entire thing can be summarized by one simple question.
“What was the point of Allura’s sacrifice?”
The problem with Allura’s sacrifice is more on the lines of a writing angle. Allura would sacrifice in that scenario, not the issue problem. The show made sure to establish that as part of her chracter, but when equal options are shown up from a writing and idea perspective, that’s when you know you didn’t get that sacrifice done correctly.
Sacrificing characters, especially main ones, usually has to be done in a way that the audience has to believe to be necessary. A good example of this is The T-800 from Terminator 2.
Based on the scripts own logic, the T-800 had to be destroyed based off of everything the movie laid out. It was the only existing thing that could push for judgement day, and destruction was the only option. It had weight, logic, and emotion. That’s how you do a proper sacrifice.
Allura’s sacrafice was just... poorly written out. When several people bring up, such as @championallura, that there were options, that’s bad writing. When you have options that seem plausible, that means you overall didn’t convince your audience to believe in the sacrifice.
I can honestly believe that just using the Lions would do the same job and have just as much, if not more emotional weight. I could also believe that Team Voltron with their Lions making the sacrifice as a whole. It doesn’t matter if those are ideas are worse or better than Allura’s sacrifice, the fact that I can believe that as a plausible alternative means there’s something wrong with the show’s own logic.
Let’s think about this for a few questions:
1. Did the character’s death leave any impact to the story that no other sacrifice could have done?
2. Did those changes overall improve or worsen the show? If so, why did it have that impact?
3. What other alternatives could been done in that situation?
Apply those questions to the T-800 and you will find very little wiggle room to question the sacrifice.
Apply these question’s to Allura and you have A LOT of things that can be discussed,(hence this discussions existence to begin with)
Which brings me back to my original question.
What was the point of Allura’s sacrifice?