hot takes on AOC saying that the United States government is operating concentration camps:
WARNING: This post contains references to gruesome human rights violations. It is not for everyone.
76 people in a cell designed for 12.
155 people in a cell designed for 35.
900 people total, or or more than seven times the 125-person capacity of the El Paso Del Norte immigration processing center.
If it werenāt for the white boxes shielding the faces of dozens of men and women stuffed into the overcrowded cell, it would be difficult to count the people in the photograph, since their overlapping limbs make it impossible to see where one body ends and another begins.
Standing room only cells, where people are held for weeks. Limited access to showers and clean clothes, resulting in those held wearing soiled clothing āfor days or weeks.ā
People standing on toilets just to find air to breathe. 24 deaths while in ICE custody.
Johana Mediana LĆ©on, 25 years old. Transgender. Passed away four days after release from custody after complaining of chest pains.
Mergensana Amar, 40 years old. Removed from life support after committing suicide in custody.
Efrain De La Rosa, 40 years old. Committed suicide in custody by self-inflicted strangulation.
Roxana Hernandez, 33 years old. Transgender. Passed away in custody after experiencing cardiac arrest.
300,000-500,000 individuals per year in custody. Acting ICE director Mark Morganās response? Plans to increase large scale raids.
Theyāre not ācenters.ā Theyāre not āfacilities.ā Theyāre not āprocessing areas.ā Letās call them what they are.
The United States government is operating concentration camps. And we must act.
Memos surfaced by journalist Ken Klippenstein revealed that Immigration and Customs Enforcementās failure to provide medical care was responsible for suicides and other deaths of detainees. These followed another report that showed that thousands of detainees are being brutally held in isolation cells just for being transgender or mentally ill.
Two weeks ago, the Trump administration cut funding for classes, recreation and legal aid at detention centers holding minors ā which were likened to āsummer campsā by a senior ICE official last year. And there was the revelation that months after being torn from their parentsā arms, 37 children were locked in vans for up to 39 hours in the parking lot of a detention center outside Port Isabel, Texas. In the last year, at least seven migrant children have died in federal custody.
Itās certainly been helpful for the Trump Administration that nobody has called them concentration camps until this week, when Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez came under great fire for doing so.
It may well be a testament to the media machine that is the Trump administration. Look away! He wore an ill-fitting tuxedo to meet the Queen! Look away! He wonāt acknowledge that the Central Park Five are exonerated! Look away! He fired pollsters for giving him numbers that he didnāt like!
Itās helpful to the President that the media covers these human rights abuses intermittently instead of as what they actually are: proof of a racist administration, unchecked by the law. Itās helpful that thereās so much else to look at right now. But more than anything else, itās helpful that the places where these people are being tortured and left to die are hidden. Theyāre locked away from the eyes of journalists and concerned members of the public. Theyāre misleadingly named.
Thatās what a concentration camp is. And the immediate outrage to AOC calling them that is the right response. Hearing that the government is running concentration camps is something one should feel scrupulous towards. A concentration camp isnāt the same as a death camp. We donāt have those yet. But when Hitler ran his, they started as the former, extending to the latter.
Hannah Arendt, imprisoned by the Gestapo and interned in a French camp, wrote about the levels of concentration camps. Extermination camps were the most extreme; others were just about getting āundesirable elements ā¦ out of the way.ā All had one thing in common: āThe human masses sealed off in them are treated as if they no longer existed, as if what happened to them were no longer of interest to anybody, as if they were already dead.ā
Is that not what we were doing?
I hesitate to speak for my own ancestry, for my family members killed at Neuengamme camp along with more than 43,000 others. But I canāt hesitate long enough to sway my thinking away from confirming what AOC already said.
Itās easy to think of the Holocaust only in terms of the final outcome. But there was a beginning.
Donāt look away. It started with fear mongering. It started with ghettoization. It started with hidden camps. Then, the pogroms. Then, the extermination camps.
Mass detention isnāt new. But this president has made it a centerpiece of his rhetoric and his agenda. Heās perfected the extreme language that dehumanizes immigrants. At a rally in Florida last month, Trump was bemoaning migrantsā legal protections when someone in the audience suggested they should be shot. The president laughed and made a joke.
Through overcrowding and dehumanization, concentration camps became self-fulfilling prophecies. The culture of abuse leads to frustration and violence, thus ājustifyingā their incarceration after the fact. Other citizens become desensitized to the dehumanization of a group of people and thus implicitly give approval for concentration camps by our lack of pushback.
