Deconstructing the Myth of Robespierre the Dictator
This video took forever to make, but I’m glad I made it... It’s a topic that gets rehashed to death, to the point that Robespierre gets called a dictator more often than some actual dictators.
The standard story is familiar. Robespierre seized power, ruled through terror, then fell when the people had had enough. The blade dropped, and the Terror ended.
That version is tidy and easy to digest. It’s also historically dishonest.
This video goes back to the actual structure of government during Year II. We look at what the Committee of Public Safety could and couldn’t do, who else held power, what Robespierre’s role actually was, and why Thermidorian deputies were so invested in isolating blame onto one man.
The conditions that produced “the Terror”
Who was Robespierre and what did he fight for?
The real function of the Committee of Public Safety
Why the idea of “Robespierre the dictator” only gained traction after his death
The political utility of scapegoating
What the primary sources actually say, including his speech on “virtue and terror”
This isn’t about defending Robespierre. It’s a refusal to accept Thermidorian propaganda as historical fact.
Hervé Leuwers, Robespierre, Fayard, 2014.
Peter McPhee, Robespierre: A Revolutionary Life, Yale University Press, 2012.
Albert Soboul, “Robespierre ou les contradictions du Jacobinisme,” Annales historiques de la Révolution française, No. 231, 1978.
Jacques Goulet, “Robespierre, la peine de mort et la Terreur,” AHRF, No. 251, 1983.
J. Thompson, “L’organisation du travail du Comité de Salut Public,” AHRF, No. 59, 1933.
Yannick Bosc, “Robespierre libéral,” AHRF, No. 371, 2013.
Hervé Leuwers, “Maximilien de Robespierre, élève à Louis-le-Grand,” AHRF, No. 371, 2013.
Peter McPhee, “Crises politiques, crises médicales dans la vie de Robespierre,” AHRF, No. 371, 2013.
Marc Belissa & Julien Louvrier, “Robespierre dans les publications françaises et anglophones depuis 2000,” AHRF, No. 371, 2013.
Michel Biard & Philippe Bourdin (dir.), Robespierre: Portraits croisés, Armand Colin, 2012.
Michel Biard & Hervé Leuwers, Visages de la Terreur, Armand Colin, 2014.
Albert Mathiez, excerpts from Robespierre terroriste and The French Revolution: A History.
Michel Biard, “Introduction: « Je vous laisse ma mémoire... »”, AHRF, No. 371, 2013.
stormborns
titsay
jbbartram-illu
yousharknotpass
janainaart
