You can have all the skill in the world, but without an idea—something that delights or challenges the mind—it probably falls short of being art.
Those two people might be just as skilled as the artists they copied. These people can paint anything. Not easy! But they have all the skill, and no ideas. It’s tragic, but not unusual. You know the guitarists in the Rolling Stones cover bands are always more skilled than Keith Richards, right? I would bet the most virtuosic guitarist on earth is currently playing with a Jimi Hendrix cover band in Reno, Nevada. Skill, yes, but no ideas...
Six hundred years ago, the kind of drawing and painting you can do, Cricket, would have been enough. People would consider you one of the most talented draftsmen walking the earth. But now, in the twentieth century, there are maybe fifty thousand people in the world who can do what you can do. Not exactly what you do, but they can achieve a likeness like you can. They can draw accurately. Some with great feeling, too. Just like that woman back there. But it’s not enough. You have to marry that to some idea. Something more...
“The one thing that will always be true, though,” he said, “is that the idea matters. You can have all the skill in the world, but without an idea—something that delights or challenges the mind—it probably falls short of being art.” He winced, then turned to Cricket and Jed. “Right?”
— Dave Eggers, Contrapposto: A Novel (Knopf, June 9, 2026)
discoholicmusic
areudirty
jacobvanloon
