My mother offered HP books when I was 14 years, i've been in this fandom for something for like one years and the sexisme/racism is so wild. I tried to talk with a HP blogger about racism, here the worst part of their post:
"Europe’s historical systems of hierarchy have primarily been class-based. And what we see represented in Harry Potter is much closer to a caste or class system among different kinds of wizards than to a racial one."
-----> I'm a black girl from an European country and this one was shocking because most European country are colonizers. Let's see other post:
"So yes, I’m white. But I’m also considerably more informed and educated than you are. "
----> More than me, who experienced racism
"I’m sorry, but you come across as a complete idiot; either you’re USAmerican, or you’ve completely swallowed USAmerican cultural discourse without questioning it for a second. I’m sorry that you’ve been so thoroughly indoctrinated, but it’s not my fault that your education system and your general level of historical and political literacy are so poor."
"You don’t get to assume that anyone who disagrees with you and isn’t POC doesn’t know a thing That’s especially ironic when you’re lecturing someone whose own family was persecuted by a fascist dictatorship across multiple generations. So maybe drop the condescending lectures about systemic persecution. You’re not talking to someone who’s unaware of how oppressive regimes work. You’re talking to someone whose family history has been shaped by one. And also I have a double degree in Law and Politics so educate yourself first and then start to talk."
As a Black girl, I see what happened to muggleborn as something racist in the context of HP world. This blogger, while being a Snape fan, will do everything to make him look like a victim of oppression while hating on Lily for cutting him. This blogger will complaining about classism in Snape's defense but would assume every US people (black?) are stupid and she knows better because she was victim of a fascist gouvernment. I have nothing against Snape,but in my opinion, on a social scale he held a lot of privileges.
I think, this is really above HP world and it's insane that no one call out this blogger out for the shit they write?!
https : // www. tumblr. com / inthemoodforblastt / 824306212581539840 / so-yes-im-white-but-im-also-considerably-more ? source = share
ok so I'm sorry I haven't answered this yet... its a little hard to answer this honestly because I was in the hp fandom for a long time. I'm sorry you're dealing with this harrassment. I first started reading the books around your age about 14ish. But back then we didn't know everything about JKR's transphobia and I wasn't online where they were discussing her racism.
For your benefit since I know you've attempted to contact us twice... please for the love all marginalized communities that JKR has screwed over stop reading the harry potter books. I'm not going to assume that all JKR fans are racist but I spent YEARS talking about the racism in the movies and the rarity of people of color in speaking roles in the books/movies. At this point there's nothing new under the sun in that fandom. JKR culturally appropriated and was extremely racist in her hp universe. More than that she took credit for Black Hermione which was just an accident of her bad writing. (The curly hair the tan are canon its true but I don't think its worth it to be in that fandom just for Black Hermione).
I'd rather now point you to a better series of books Amari and the Night Brothers https://www.thriftbooks.com/w/amari-and-the-night-brothers_bb-alston/28575768/
Now I know you're gonna say that you love harry potter because you've already read them but please please listen there's nothing in HP that's worth your time. Really. But I've read Amari and the Night Brothers and I'm eager to finish the series. Even if the next books are half as good as the first I think you'll like them too.
The only thing I think that I wish I could convey to you is that I wish I could gift you these books but I'm broke myself. Harry Potter is just not worth the real world harm it causes trans people. And that includes trans people of color.
mod ali













