Marine Parade - A unique identity
Marine Parade is a estate with rich history and also the highest number of elderly residents aged 65 and above in Singapore, according to the Department of Statistics in 2012. Marine Parade used to be just by the coast and most of it lies on reclaimed land. I did a visit to explore the spaces and facilities that are provided for elderly residents there and to assess if these were highly frequented spaces.
These are the precincts in Marine Parade. Before I went down, I realized that there were few green park spaces; most common areas were plazas, playgrounds and fitness corners.
I started my walk from Block 1 Marine Terrace where immediately I was greeted by the first of many playgrounds in this estate. There were a few elderly doing exercises but I observed that more people were crossing the overhead bridge over to East Coast Park.
This was one of the few things I enjoyed during my walk - the themed playgrounds. This first one was a dinosaur themed playground with the pebble path (commonly used by elderly to massage their bare feet). I saw more children and parents rather than elderly using these facilities. Nonetheless, it was a unique common space.
This fitness corner is surrounded by several blocks and its location can be considered to be at the heart of this precinct. Yet, it was empty and I guess this may be either because it was not well shaded (see photo directly above), or that these exercise equipment may not be well liked by elderly residents here. Such a prime location but yet an underwhelming response and use of this site.
The market was where all the activity was at on this Sunday morning. I found interesting that this pebble path was incorporated into the market space, possibly to encourage elderly to use it when they visit the market. It also has a shape resembling seaweed which is very apt for a coastal estate that Marine Parade is. However, despite these wonderful facilities being provided, I realized that nobody was using it for its purpose, and elderly were more likely to sit on the benches in the shade instead.
The two pictures above show ample public spaces meant for use as community gathering spaces but I only saw one middle aged man under this pavilion. The surrounding blocks look down onto this central space, forming a shared view for everyone who lives around this space. A space is always underwhelmed without the activities that are meant to take place in it.
I think Marine Parade has a distinct identity and these little spaces bring out the character of this estate. The little details such as wave-like railings and wave-like walkway roofs and floor patterns make this estate an enjoyable one to walk through.
Above, we have an outdoor amphitheater of sorts. It has a wonderful view of the blocks lined up in rows and is rather shady on a weekend morning - perfect for exercise. But once again, nobody was around :(
Another sheltered pavilion with a cool canopy but nobody again
FINALLY, ONE UNCLE EXERCISING! He was alone and blasted loud chinese music while he used the equipment that was provided in this fitness corner. This was located at the outskirts of the estate so it was not a central space with blocks surrounding it. Perhaps since it was quieter and more private, the uncle chose to do his exercise here.
The blocks closer to Marine Parade CC are arranged more in a parallel slab block layout. Thus, there are many long green spaces between blocks. This one here is a large grass patch with large trees which can become an interesting precinct park.
Perhaps it was just too hot for exercise..
Another pebble pathway designed for elderly but I haven’t actually seen a single elderly using it in my life.
A F T E R T H O U G H T S
I think that the government and town council has done a marvelous job at creating an identity for Marine Parade and providing ample common spaces for the ageing community here. However, evidently, these spaces are not used on a supposed ‘peak hour’ on a weekend morning. The possible reasons for these observations could be:
1. It was too hot (32 degrees in the morning at 8am??!)
2. Spaces with blocks onlooking could be too public such that it may discourage elderly from bringing their radios to blast loud music while they exercise. They may wish to shy away from the public eye. (as observed from solo uncle at a quieter exercise corner)
3. The equipment may be too “man made”. I gather from previous site visits in larger parks that elderly frequent spaces where nature is lush and trees and plants create the landscape. In a housing precinct, common spaces are often very man made -- the disconnect from nature is very apparent and this may thus discourage elderly from choosing these spaces if they can simply walk over to ECP.
4. There is probably little neighbourliness when it comes to exercise. When planning a space for group exercise activities, there needs to be 2 things: 1. the space and 2. self-initiative by individuals/groups to start exercising. In this case, I saw that there were definitely ample spaces, so perhaps the lack of neighbourliness was the reason why people keep to themselves and decide not to exercise in their housing estate. That being said, the market at Marine Terrace, is overflowing with neighbourliness. I observed strangers bonding over table space and food. Wouldn’t it be great if this friendliness from the market could take a step further and turn into regular exercise groups?
Moving forward, I think it would be interesting to get residents from the market to imagine what their ideal precinct community spaces should be like. Can’t wait to go back again next week!