Thrills Are Cheap & Love is Divine | Andrew 'Pope' Cody x f!reader
pairing: Andrew & female reader (Craig's friend)
tw: reader is implied to be sexually abused by a parental figure. similar to Renn's backstory if you've seen season 4. nothing super specific or detailed in the fic, but if this is triggering for you, pls protect yourself!!
summary: you run away from home at 18, knowing that anything, even sleeping on the beach and accepting ham sandwiches from Craig, is better than what you're used to. but when Andrew offers you his old bedroom, a life you never thought was possible seems on the horizon
an: I gave readers step father a very Irish sounding last name but this would not be readers last name lol
wc: 9k+
warnings: 18+, tw for implied abuse towards reader, bad parents, reader blames herself for her trauma (Andrew fixes it), reader is 18, Andrew is 26ish, canon typical drug use, violence, and content, smut, protected p in v and other things :)
graphics by: @strangergraphics
Pope notices it first. He hasnât lived at Smurfâs house for a couple of years now, but heâs there often enough to notice that his middle brother is sneaking out late every night after family dinners. At first, he assumed it was just Craig being Craig, sneaking out to go to some girlâs house or a party or to get high in that part of Oceanside most people would avoid. He assumed that addictive gene that consumes so much of Craigâs personality must have come from his motherâs side of the family. It definitely skipped him and so far appeared to have missed Deran, but he was keeping an eye on Craig. He didnât want him to fall into the same fate as Julia.Â
But he quickly realizes Craigâs not just going to some party or hanging out with a random chick, no, because Craig is making sloppily put together ham and cheese sandwiches that are cut down the middle, much to Popeâs disdain, and putting Smurfâs apple pie in a plastic container. Heâs grabbing blankets and bottles of water. Heâs leaving just before midnight and only coming back early enough to take Deran to the beach to surf.
It only takes about four nights until Pope is standing at the gate to the Cody house, standing sentinel and waiting for Craig. The curiosity is driving him wild, and he smirks to himself when he sees Craig practically jump out of his skin when he sees his brother waiting for him.
âChrist man, what the hell are you doing out here?â Craig asks, voice breathy after being scared half to death.
Pope has his arms crossed and sets a hardened stare on Craig. âWhat are you doing?â he asks instead of answering.
Craig shuffles awkwardly on his feet, fighting a losing battle with the blankets and water and food heâs planning on taking with him to the beach. He sighs.
âYou remember my friend?â he asks his big brother, adding your name and a description to jog Popeâs memory. âSheâs been livinâ on the beach.â
Heâs quiet for a moment, thinking of you. âHer dadâs a cop, right?â
At that, Craig sucks his teeth and looks pointedly away from Pope, kicking an invisible pebble on the ground. âStepdad.â
âRight,â Pope nods, imagining you crumbling under the pressure of 8 oâclock curfews and being forcefully dragged to church on Sundays. âSo, she ran away?â
Craig nods solemnly. âLook man, I gotta go. I promised her Iâd bring her another blanket and itâs getting pretty late.â
Pope stares at his brother for another beat, his hazel eyes darkening slightly at the late hour. He nods once and lifts up his hand that was holding his car keys. âWell, letâs go. Iâll drive.â
It doesnât take Craig and Andrew much convincing for you to hop in Andrewâs old pickup and take him up on his offer to sleep in his old bedroom.
âIâve got my own place,â he told you, crouching down to your height. You were certain you looked disgusting after only half-bathing in the cramped public beach bathroom for the past few nights. He had approached you like you were a feral cat; slowly lowering down to your eye level, speaking softly as if you were going to screech and run away. You had only met Andrew a handful of times but it struck you as majorly out of character for him. âSo I never really use my room. Itâs all yours, if you want it.â
Once you're in the back of the truck, ham sandwich half eaten, you flick Craigâs ear from the back seat. âHey asshole, why didnât you tell me you had an empty room?â
âHey!â he snaps at you, grabbing your finger that was by his ear in what could have easily turned into a harsher grip. âIâve kept you fed these past few days, havenât I?â
You roll your eyes at him. You were grateful, he knew that.
Craig Cody had randomly become a close friend after youâd been paired together in a ninth grade science project. He had done absolutely nothing and you were admittedly horrible at science, so you had both failed. Your mother had screamed at you that night when you showed her the giant red âFâ on a rubric she had to sign. She was never so angry, when you were younger. But she also didnât drink that much until she had married your step-father, just years prior. It had just been the two of you for so long, and you hated disappointing her, but you really hated when she took her frustrations out on you. The tears that fell down your face were unavoidable and you practically bolted to your room and cried into your bed.
That was the first night your step-father had laid in bed next to you. For comfort, he told you, before he pressed a kiss to your lips.
After that, you found yourself hanging around Craig. He skipped school more often than not and was usually at least a little high, but you felt safe with him. And when you told him about what was happening at home, he opened his arms to you and wrapped you tight. You had pretty much been inseparable since.
Andrewâs stolid tone broke you out of your reverie. âWhyâd you run away from home anyway?â
Your eyes snapped to Craigâs in the side mirror for a moment before you looked away and sat all the way back in the rear seats. It was a question you should have expected. What eighteen year old with a perfectly good home and two perfectly adequate parents leaves to start living on the beach?
âStep-dads a dick,â you tell him, muttering under your breath.
He nods, looking at your downcast eyes in the rearview mirror. You had been a bit more smiley just moments before. He figured it was a touchy subject. âBeen there,â he added, feeling something tighten in his chest when you looked up, meeting his eyes in the mirror and softening your frown just slightly.
âBaby,â Smurf looked up at you, sickeningly sweet voice grabbing your attention. âGo take these cups outside for me, and ask the boys if they want anything to eat before the guests get here.â
You nodded at her, offering a smile to show you didnât mind being ordered around. She was a different type of mother than you were used to. Overbearing with her boys despite not really caring what they got up to at the same time. She was constantly on Craig, needing to know where he was going and who he was with, but when he dropped out of high school last year, you remember him telling you that his mom didnât even blink at the news.Â
She was also affectionate. The first time you saw Smurf kiss Craig on the lips you froze. Once she left the room, you pulled Craig aside and asked if he was okay. âWe can both leave,â you told him, voice tinged with fear at what you had just witnessed.
He grabbed your hands and looked down at you, face frowning. âNah, itâs not like that,â he told you, shaking his head. âSheâs just, loving. Sheâs always done that, but itâs notâŠâ
He hesitated, not finishing the sentence. âLike me,â you finished for him. Smurf kissed her kids on the lips, but it wasnât like what your step-father did to you.
Since then, you tried not to judge. She seemed to like you enough, though there was definitely something cold in her gaze most of the time, just hidden beneath an easy smile.
âHey,â you called to Baz after you put the cups behind the bar. âHungry? I can fix you a plate.â
You ignored the way his eyes looked you up and down, lingering at your chest. âYeah? I could eat,â he replied, tongue darting over his bottom lip as he pointedly looked at your body and not your face.
You crossed your arms and scoffed. âYeah, Iâm not on the menu, dude.â You walked away from him, middle finger in the air much to Deranâs amusement. Andrew was sitting on a pool chair, black sunglasses on, watching the interaction. âWhat about you? Do you want anything to eat? Weâve got that square bologna, I can make you a sandwich.â
His lenses were dark enough that you couldnât see his eyes, but you could feel the heat of his heavy stare on you. A moment of quiet passed between you two before he spoke up, breath nearly stuttering. âYou donât have to do that,â he told you, that dry tone that seemed so typical in his voice.
âDo what?â
âServe us. Like youâre a maid or something.â
You shrugged at that, looking away from his dark lenses to the concrete beside the pool. âYour mom asked,â you stated plainly. âAnd sheâs letting me stay here for free, no questions asked. If she wants me to clean up sometimes or help set up for a party, I really donât mind.â
You felt the heat of his stare even though you were still looking away from him.Â
âI never said thanks, by the way,â you offered. You can faintly see his eyebrows raise up slightly in question, as if asking for what? âI know it was you who told Craig I could have your room. And I really donât know how many more nights I had left in me sleeping at the beach,â you shuddered at the thought. âI just was desperate to get out, you know? And you both really saved me.â You finish speaking with a shrug and a smile. Youâre just about to turn and walk back into the house when he finally speaks up.
âIf you need anything at all, you let me know, alright?"
You nod at him, fighting the smile thatâs forcing its way to your lips.
Youâve never seen a Cody party in full swing until now and well, itâs something. Thereâs probably a hundred half naked people walking in and out of the house, dripping pool water on Smurfâs formerly pristine floor, eating and drinking and smoking and snorting whatever she has lying around. Somehow, she seems to not care at all.
Craig and Renn are snorting coke off of her couch, Baz is bracketed by two women who had not left his side all night, Deran was jumping from the roof to the pool every five minutes and Smurf was lounging in her chair with sunglasses on and a caftan as if she was the queen of California herself. It was fun, in a way, but it didnât take you long before you were feeling just a bit overwhelmed.Â
You made it down the hall to your temporary room and opened the door, seeing a figure sitting on your bed. It took you half a second to realize it was Andrew.
âOh,â you gasped. âSorry, I just needed to get away from the noise, do you mind?â
Andrew shrugged at you, a beer in his hand that he took a long sip from. âItâs your room,â he told you plainly.
You grinned. âWell, itâs yours, but I appreciate you letting me borrow it.â
âYou donât have to keep thanking me.â
You looked at him again. His tone was so level, so matter of fact that you couldnât argue with him even if you wanted to. He was so different from Craig. Where Craig was emotional and dramatic, Andrew was stoic and steady. His energy was different, but you liked it. You liked how quiet he was even when everyone else was loud. You liked that he didnât waste words on saying things he didnât mean. You liked that when he looked at you, he was really looking at you, deep knowing looks that you swore peered into your soul. It wasnât something you were used to.
You sat down on the bed, giving Andrew a good amount of space between you two. When you laid down on your back and looked up at the ceiling, you were surprised to see him looking down at you.
âI have a job interview tomorrow,â you told him, not exactly sure why you felt the need to share this fact. âI could use a ride, if you arenât busy,â you added, quietly.
You werenât exactly sure why you were feeling so nervous asking him for a favor. Since you had met him, he had taken a bit of a savior role in your life; making sure you had a roof over your head, making sure you felt welcome in his motherâs house, constantly asking after you to see if you needed absolutely anything. It was more than you ever had.
You were still looking at each other, him towering over you, his bulky build making you feel blanketed in a comforting heat. Your mouth went dry when you realized you had been in this exact situation before, laying on the bed while another man, a man who was less kind, less attentive, stared down at you. A man who took what didnât belong to him, what you werenât offering up, before you were old enough to understand what was happening.Â
You blinked away from his gaze and sat up, eyes focusing away from him as blood roared in your ears.
Andrew shifted his weight from side to side on the bed, still fully focused on you but frowning at the sudden cold air that rushed in between you. He didnât understand what happened to make you suddenly avoid his gaze.
âIâll take you,â Andrew muttered from next to the bed, speaking to the back of your head. He meant it; heâd do whatever he needed for you.
Andrew sat in his old pickup outside of the grocery store. The windows were rolled down and he was beginning to see faint beads of sweat on his forearm. You were taking forever. You were interviewing to be a cashier at a grocery store, how many questions could they really ask you? He had half a mind to go in and check on you, but that would be a little weird, he figured. You had been so warm and open with him until last night, where you suddenly froze and avoided eye contact, but then today, you were back to normal, smiling that smile he had become a little bit obsessed with and meeting his intense stare with no qualms. And you looked perfectâa flouncy little dress that skimmed right above your knees and denim jacket on your arms.
He hadnât seen you in anything that was outwardly feminine in the short time he had gotten to know you. Usually you were running around in denim shorts and what he suspected were some of Craigâs old t-shirts. You were always beautiful, shockingly so, but that dress made Andrew feel things he wasnât sure he was allowed to feel.
Your bright smile across the parking lot grabbed his attention. You were practically skipping, and it made his heart beat extra fast.
âHe hired me on the spot!â you squealed, opening the passenger door and climbing in to face him. âItâs only going to be two days a week but Iâm so excited,â you told him, cheeks practically reaching your eyes with how wide you were smiling. âIâve never had my own money before.â You sighed that last part quietly. It wasnât just a grocery store job, it was your entire future, starting right now.
Andrew smiled at you. It was something small that most people probably wouldnât even realize was a smile, but he was starting to realize he was doing that a lot in your presence. You were easy to smile at. âIâm happy for you,â he told you, voice sincere and steady.
âThanks for driving me,â you responded softly, your smile a little less wide but still taking up space.Â
âI told you to stop thanking me.â
Your breath hitched as you stared at him. His arms flexed with a sheen that made something inside you turn molten. His hazel eyes were always so all consuming when he looked at you, but right now, as always, his stare didnât make you feel anything but safe.
âStop doing nice things for me and Iâll stop thanking you,â you told him, voice rasping.Â
His breath caught as he peered at you, eyes looking between yours and down to your lips, a move so subtle you werenât sure if it was real or in your head.
âI donât think Iâll stop,â he bluntly replied. It was curt and to the point, the way he always spoke but there was a layer of softness there that made you melt.
âOkay, Andrew,â you whispered back.Â
And that was that.
Smurf threw another party a week later. You werenât super clear on the details of how Janine Cody made her money, but you knew she didnât leave the house every day to step into an office. You heard the odd conversation when you were walking from the bathroom to Andrewâs old room at night and you had seen a mountain of cash on the kitchen island when you woke up extra early to go for a walk one time. Craig had said things over the years at school and you had heard the rumours, even from your stepdad when he was yelling at you years ago for befriending Craig. But you figured it was none of your business.
You realized how little it mattered to you, if the Codyâs were criminals. They didnât seem like bad guys. After all, they took you in, housed you and fed you. They made you feel safe when your own family did not. So you didnât mind helping with a party to celebrate the success of whatever job they just pulled.
It had been days since you had seen Andrew. He took you to grab ice cream after the success of your interview, and you sat on a picnic table with him, looking at the waves cresting on the shore, talking mindlessly about everything. You loved Craig; he was genuinely your best friend. But Andrew, spending time with him felt different. He was quickly taking a place in your life that was unexplainable and irreplaceable. He made you feel cared for and looked after. This was the longest you had gone without seeing him since you moved in. You were really beginning to miss him.
You were turning in the floor length mirror in Andrewâs old room, looking at yourself from all angles in your new dress. You had only worked your first two days at the grocery store, and it would be another week before you got a pay check, but you could not help yourself from buying the short sundress from a thrift store on the way home last night. You had seen the way Andrew looked at you when he drove you to your interview. You would do anything to have him look at you like that again.
âYou look nice,â Craig told you from the door. You whipped your head around at him, heat crawling up your neck at the compliment.Â
âThanks.â
âYou dressinâ up for someone in particular?âÂ
The question was innocent enough, but you found yourself avoiding his eye contact.
âI donâtâŠâ you let your voice trail off as you braved a look in his direction. âI donât know,â you finished. âIâve never really done this before.â This. Liked someone. Dressed up for them. Flirted.
Craig nodded, walking further into your room and sitting on the edge of your bed until you joined him. He placed a comforting hand on your shoulder and looked down at you.Â
âAre you sure youâre ready for something like that? I mean, after everything that happened with Philââ
That made you tense. âDonât say his name to me. Ever.â
Craigâs blue eyes widened at your sharp tone. He should have known better than to casually mention your step-father and what you went through. âRight, sorry. I just want you to make sure youâre thinking things through. Being patient. Not feeling pressured.â
You relaxed your shoulders at his concerned tone. âYeah, okay,â you nodded. âI appreciate that. I just have never really liked anyone,â you laughed dryly. âI donât know what the protocol is.â
âBut you like Pope?â Craigâs voice was laced with disbelief.Â
You shrugged. âYeah. Is that weird for you?â
He looked at you, hand leaving your shoulder to find its way to his lap. âA bit,â he told you honestly. âPope is⊠Pope. But heâs respectful, you know? Kind of crazy, but good.â He glanced around his big brotherâs room, looking wistfully at some of the photos that still took up space on his old dresser. âHeâs one of the best guys I know.â
When you finally saw Andrew arrive at the party, you smiled, and made a beeline straight for him. You were drinking a cup of fruit punch, making a conscious decision to only drink if he was.Â
âFinally,â you greeted, smiling widely at him. He looked incredibly good, you couldnât help but notice. A grey shirt clung to his broad muscles and he wore a black leather jacket on top of it. The curls in his hair looked delectable, and you idly wondered how they would feel underneath your fingertips. âI was hoping you werenât gonna bail on us tonight.â
Andrew stared at your face for a moment too long without saying anything, before glancing briefly at the short dress you were wearing. His hazel eyes shot back up to yours in what you suspected was pure force of will.Â
âSmurf would flip if I missed it,â he offered, voice calm in its typical rigidity.
âRight,â you nodded at him, taking a sip from your cup. âSo you only came here for Smurf?â You were teasing him, hoping he would take the bait.
âNo. Not only for her.â
You smiled a bit bigger at that. âGood.â You looked down to his hands that were hanging limply at his side. You reached yours out to him. âWanna come with me to grab a beer?â
It felt like ages had gone by as you watched Andrew glance to your open palm, then back to your face, and then down again, before he finally reached his own hand out to yours, and followed you into his motherâs house.
The party was winding down when you and Andrew made your way to your somewhat shared bedroom. You had nursed your singular beer and forced Andrewâs typical scowl at his momâs messy partygoers into a look of what you hoped was serenity towards you instead. You decided you really liked him. Your first crush on someone, maybe ever.
He was older than you and Craigâabout eight yearsâmaking you worried that he wouldnât see you as a real woman.Â
You lit a candle that Smurf had given you earlier in the week. Sandalwood and amber. Then you brushed your slightly clammy hands on your dress while you were still facing away from Andrew, but with the way he watched you, you were certain he still saw the movement.
âSo,â you spoke up, willing yourself to face the man you had not stopped thinking about in a month. âWhere were you this week?â
He shrugged, peeling off that leather jacket to reveal his veiny forearms. You forced yourself to look away. âScopinâ out this warehouse for Smurf.â He glanced at you, surprising himself with the ease he revealed sensitive information about his family. âYou know what we do?â
You brushed off the question, kicking your sandals off before you sat on the edge of the bed, legs folded under you. âI have an idea,â you replied honestly. âBut I donât really feel like I need to know all the details.â It was the truth. The Codyâs may have done bad things to earn their money, but you truly didnât feel like they were bad people.
He hummed at that. âYouâre trusting.â
You scoffed. âI trust Craig. And I trust you. I wouldnât consider myself âtrustingâ,â you rebutted.
Andrew sat on the bed next to you, bringing himself more or less to your eye level. His posture was pin straight, but you watched as he slowly settled his tailbone onto the plush fabric of the duvet cover, some of the tension he seemed to always carry melting off of him.
âI trust you, too.â
Your brows rose at that. âYeah?â
He nodded back at you, body inching a bit closer. âYeah.â
You looked at his eyes, that same intense stare peering back at you. You allowed yourself an indulgent glance to his lips and you found yourself creeping closer into his orbit.Â
âIâm really happy youâre here,â you offered him, voice barely above a whisper. It was the honest truth, though you werenât sure where you found the confidence to speak to him about your feelings.
âReally?â he questioned, body inching even closer to yours. You could feel the heat radiating off of him and it made you shiver.
Your mouth went dry at the look he was giving you and the gravelly tone of his voice. You didnât think you could speak, so you just nodded your head instead.
Andrew took another glance at your lips, licking his own in response. He allowed one of his hands to find the bare skin of your knee, leaning into your space until there was hardly any left between you two. âCan I?â
Your lips parted and you sighed in relief. âYes.â
Andrewâs lips were softer than you expected. Against your own, they felt like firm pillows, moving insistently as he became familiar with your mouth. He was a gentle kisser. For such a stern, and oftentimes severe, young man, you found yourself sighing happily at the delicate way he allowed his lips to move against yours. It was not at all what you were used to.
You instinctively found your hands tracing the veins of his forearms, working your way to his firm biceps, before finally finding their resting place at the strong, developed muscles at his shoulders. His grey t-shirt did nothing to protect him from your wandering hands.
You groaned when he disconnected your lips from his, trailing warm, wet kisses down the side of your neck until he found your collarbone. You gasped at how good it felt, feeling warm coils of want unspooling inside of you at his actions.
âAndrew,â you whimpered out his name, feeling a bit desperate at a particularly cruel nip of your skin, right where your collarbone and clavicle met. âIââ
You werenât quite sure what you had to say to him. Donât stop, Andrew. Feels so good, Andrew. Iâve been touched like this before, but it never felt like thisâ no, you told yourself, donât go there.
Andrew kept nipping at you, large hands feeling their way around your body in a pattern that made your heart beat faster. You tried to get out of your head so you could enjoy what was happening to you. The guy you were really starting to like, touching you in this all consuming way, making you feel like desire could be a good thing, for once. But you couldnât beat those thoughts, and it only took about three seconds for Andrew to realize that you were frozen.
He pulled away from you, eyes slightly glazed over as he blinked himself out of his stupor. He still had his hands on your waist, and he allowed himself to draw what he hoped were soothing circles against your dress clad skin.
âHey,â he called to you, shifting his head to the side to meet your eyes. âWhatâs wrong?â
âIââ your mouth opened and closed like a fish as you tried to find the words to say. You glanced around the room in an attempt to ground yourself. âItâs notââ you cut yourself off again, pressing your lips together in a thin line. âIâm not what you think.â
Andrew blinked at you, restacking his spine to that unnaturally straight position. âWhat do you mean?â
You gently grabbed his hands and placed them on his thick thighs, far away from you. âYou donât want to do this with me,â you told him, standing up and making your way towards the candle that was still burning. You pretended it was that heat that was making the burning tears you felt gather in your eyes. âIâm not good.â
Andrew stood up, nervous energy replacing whatever longing he was feeling while kissing you. âThatâs not true,â he immediately told you, voice sounding more sure than you had ever heard it. His heart felt like it was breaking when he saw you pout at him, eyes shining now with unshed tears.
âIf you knew,â you started, voice cracking, âwhat Iâve done, you wouldnât look at me like that. You would be disgusted by me.â The tears were falling now in thick rivulets down your cheeks. Andrew watched as they gathered into bigger drops, holding for a moment at your jaw before deciding to let go and fall onto the perfect little dress you were wearing.
He frowned at you. âI would never think that.â
You scoffed, your head hanging heavy as you tried to retain whatever little bit of dignity you had left. âYouâre only saying that because you donât know.â
You knew you were sounding downright petulant, but you couldnât help yourself.
Andrew shook his head. He knew there was not a single thing you could tell him that you had done that would make him think you werenât a literal angel sent to this Earth. He was devoted to you, he just realized. After feeling your soft skin against his fingers and your lips against his own, he knew he was obsessed, willing to do whatever he needed to help you and make you happy.
So whatever happened that made you feel like you werenât good enough for him of all people, well that wouldnât stand.
âIâm sorry,â you sobbed, voice watery. âI canât. You need to leave. Y-you canât.â
He fought the urge to reach for your shaking form, to wipe those tears away and tell you he would hurt whoever made you feel this way. But he realized if he did those things, right now, with the state you were in, that you would probably only close in more on yourself.
âOkay, okay,â he lowly called out from his side of the room. Your eyes were shut tight and he still was a bit alarmed that the gorgeous, giggly girl he had spent all evening talking to was now a crumpled mess leaning against his old dresser.Â
You vaguely realized he had called your name. âIâm going to go,â he told you, his heart breaking a bit more at the way your face crumpled at that. âNot because I want to,â he attempted to reassure, âbut because I donât want to scare you.â
He took slow steps as he made his way into your space, the heat radiating off of him made you pop your head up to look him in the eyes. Those hazel pools of warmth softened something inside of you, and Andrewâs frown relaxed a bit when he noticed. He took a risk and reached for your chin between his thumb and index finger, taking an appraising look at the damage from your tears. He felt his heart skip a beat when you didnât pull away.
âIâm here for you,â he softly told you. âYou might not realize how much,â he added, leaving out the Iâd do anything for you, that was resting on the tip of his tongue. âBut I want you to come to me, with anything. Everything.âÂ
He leaned down to be eye-level with you, leaving you with a searing look you werenât quite sure how to interpret just yet.Â
You stood there, weight half supported against the dresser, standing in chilly silence until you finally realized you were alone.
Craig was in his own world, tongue shoved down some girls throat while his other hand was under her shirt. He hardly heard his bedroom door creak open, but he was quickly snapped out of his blissful journey to third base when he felt a heavy hand crack on his shoulder and pull him away from his date.
âOw- hey!â Craig shouted, wondering who the hell was ripping him away from getting laid.
His face fell slightly when he met the angry, pinched look Pope was giving him.
âI need to talk to you,â Pope practically snarled.
Craig wasnât quite sure what was going on with his brother, but that look never bode well.
âHey, uh, sweetheart,â he called to the confused girl on his bed. âCan you give us a second?â
The girl scoffed and muttered asshole under her breath. Pope stared at her until Craigâs bedroom door closed.
âWhat?â Craig whined. âWhat the fuck is so important that you had to come in here, all Pope like and scare my girl away, huh?â
âYour girl?â Pope responded, an eyebrow raised in disbelief. âWhatâs her name?â
They both knew Craig had no clue.Â
âMan whatever. What the fuck is it?â
Pope gestured to your bedroom. âWhat the hell happened to her?â
Craig sighed, jaw ticking as he thought about you. âListen man, itâs not my story to tell.â
Pope huffed at that. âI was just with her and she flipped out. Had a full freakout on me.â His face is still in that habitual scowl he can never seem to relax away from, but the softness in his tone did not go unnoticed by his brother.Â
âShe okay?â
He hesitated. âI donât really know.â
Craig sighed, settling back onto his bed, taking a pull from his beer. His big brother would find out anyway. âItâs her stepdad, man.â
That made him tense. âThe cop?â
Craig scoffed, something disbelieving in the sound. âYeah. The cop. The sickest motherfucker out of all them.â
Pope felt his fingers twitch at his sides. A million horrible things popped into his brain. But there was one that was worse than the rest, and judging by the way Craig picked at the label on his beer to avoid eye contact, he had a feeling that was the case.
âShe told her mom. Like a year ago. The bitch didnât believe her.â Craig shook his head in disbelief. âShe was just living there, Pope. For years. While he fuckinâââ he sighed out something heavy and let his head hang. âShe went to a detective, too,â he added quietly. âThey protected him.â
Andrew was silent, rage bubbling under his skin. The thought of anything like that happening to you, for years, while you asked for help, made him furious.
âWhatâs his name?â It was a question, but the way he said it, Craig knew exactly what was about to happen.
âPhil. McGetrick.â
Pope nodded, just once. Then he stood up and walked out of Craigâs room, leaving him in total silence.
Two weeks later you were back bagging groceries on a late Thursday afternoon. You had seen Andrew, here and there around the house, but you didnât have the nerve to speak to him. Instead, every time he entered a room, you left it, and every time he said hi in that perfectly earnest way of his, avoiding his mossy green eyes looking at you all doe-like, muttering a quick response and scurrying away.
You had never panicked like that before. And in front of Andrew of all people, right when you were about to experience sex for the first time with someone you liked, well that was just embarrassing.Â
Craig attempted to speak to you about it, but you shoved him out of your room.Â
âPlease, donât,â you groaned. âItâs embarrassing enough I was going to do that with you brother,â you sighed, clutching your head. âBut I refuse to talk to you about sex.â
He smirked and mimed zipping his lips. Youâd called him a dork.
And outside of avoiding Andrew every chance you could, things were feeling back to normal. Your manager offered you a few extra hours and you were looking into getting your GED over the summer. Maybe you could find a roommate and ease yourself away from the Cody orbit, if only to not embarrass yourself again.
You were finding a rhythm, bagging groceries, smiling at overtired momâs, laughing at the bad jokes from Dave, the cashier you were working with, and counting down the time until your fifteen minute break. And then you saw her.
Your mother had bloodshot eyes and looked like she hadnât slept in days. Her lips were bitten raw and her normally manicured nails were bitten into little stubs. You were so angry with her; a part of you hated her. But she was your mom and seeing her like this worried you immediately.Â
âMom?â you gasped, stepping away from the line. âWhatâs wrong?â You led her outside, away from Dave and all of your other coworkers.
She shook out her hands, bringing a palm to her mouth to muffle her cries. âItâs Phil,â she sobbed. âHeâs dead.â
Hearing those words stunned you. That man, the disgusting, abusive, pedophile youâd been forced to endure for all those yearsâdead. You werenât sure how to feel.
âHow?â you rasped out.
âMurdered,â she practically shrieked. âIn our home,â she continued, speaking emotionally, gesturing with her hands as she described the last week and all of her grief. How her soulmate had died. âHoney,â she grabbed your attention. âI need you to come home. Please,â she begged.
You cocked your head to the side. âHome? Iâve been homeless for the last two months thanks to you!â It wasnât totally accurate, but you had been homeless before Andrew offered you his old bedroom.
Your mother frowned, eyes trailing up and down your body. âYou look like youâre well fed and clean, honey, Iâm not convinced youâre homeless.â Whatever sympathetic tone she had earlier, the one filled with grief over her piece of shit husband, was now gone, replaced with the cool judgement you were used to.
You shook your head at her in disbelief. âSome people took me in. People who cared that I was sleeping on the beach without food or clean water,â you snapped at her. âNot that you would know,â you tacked on, brows raising. âYou havenât even tried to get in touch with me.â
It was her turn to shake her head at you. âMy God, everything is always about you. Your father is dead, and itâs your own fault you ran offââ
âThat man was not and has never been my father. He was a disgusting pig that you let abuse me for years!â you shouted, not worried about the looks you were receiving from shoppers leaving the store.
âYou have to stop telling these lies,â your mom replied coolly. âPhil was a good man,â her voice cracked on his name. âAnd I donât know which one of your low life friends you told those stories to, but I know you had something to do with his murder.â
You blinked at her. âWhat the hell are you talking about?â
You watched as she dug through her purse, a poorly made fake designer bag she had been desperate to get her hands on a few years ago in an effort to fit in with the wealthier group of Oceanside moms. She handed you a crime scene photo. âYou tell me that this was not your doing.â
The photo was gruesome. Philâs dead body was lying in a puddle of his own blood. There were ligature marks on his wrists, signs of a struggle, you figured, and there was a pool of blood by his groin, just below the edge of the photo. You could only hope that beyond where the photo cut off, his manhood was completely mutilated. You smiled against your will.
âI had nothing to do with that. But I can tell you what,â you spoke to your mom, voice calm amidst the frenzied look on her face. âWhat he got was less than he deserved.â You gripped the photo harder.
Your mom blinked at you, obviously bewildered by your lack of care about her soulmate.Â
âI didnât raise you to be this way,â she gasped out, crocodile tears forming in her eyes. âCruel and heartless. How dare youââ
âHow dare you?â you questioned. âI told you, a year ago, what he was doing to me, what he had been doing. And you knew. Thereâs no way you didnât know,â your voice finally broke, recalling how awful that conversation had gone. âAnd you blamed me. Your child.â You fought back the tears that were trying to escape. You wouldnât let them.
You shook your head and let out a dry laugh. âIâm glad you came here and told me that piece of shit is dead,â you announced. âAnd thanks for the memento,â you added, smirking at her shocked face as you waved the crime scene photo in the air, before sliding it in your back pocket.Â
You turned away from your mother, the biggest disappointment you had ever endured in your life and walked back to the automatic doors in front of the grocery store. For a moment, you hesitated, shifting your weight from side to side, before you turned back around and met her weary eyes one final time.
âDonât ever bother me again.â
And then you left.
Texting Andrew to pick you up from work was a no brainer. Your manager and most of your coworkers had seen the interaction from inside the bagging area at the store, and heâd just offered you a sympathetic look and a âGo home, kid,â before everyone went back to business as usual.
He was there in less than fifteen minutes. You honestly wondered what he did some days, with the way he seemed to be always available when you needed him.
The old, but well taken care of, pickup truck pulling up in front of the loading zone at the store made you smile as you made a beeline for it. You didnât let your grin fall as you hopped into the passenger side and pulled his face in towards yours, placing a searing kiss to his lips.
Andrew wavered for a moment, before reaching his hands to the pack of your head, pressing your lips even deeper to his, savoring what he had been missing for weeks.
âHi,â you giggled when you finally pulled away from him. Your foreheads were still touching and it was almost comical how his eyes looked at you from this close.
âHi,â he rasped out, breaths stuttering as he wondered what exactly got into you.
âWill you take me to your place?â you whispered to him, biting your bottom lip at the implication.
Andrew pulled away from you, just slightly, to get a better look at your face. He was trying to find an ounce of doubt, of fear, of guilt, of something other than the desire he was seeing. He couldnât.
âAre you sure?â
You nodded, leaning back in to press one more kiss to his lips. âPositive.â
Andrewâs condo was exactly what you envisioned. It was small, with real wood floors, and simple taupe furniture. It had a great view of the beach and his cream curtains let in the perfect amount of late afternoon light. And it was clean, like, really clean.
âCute place,â you commented, looking around before you dropped your purse by the door and kicked your shoes off.Â
You made your way to his couch, legs folding under you in that way Andrew wasnât quite sure was comfortable but you seemed to always do. You looked like you were at home, and that made his heart beat a little bit faster.
You dug in your back pocket and fished out the crime scene photo.
âMy mom paid me a visit today,â you told him, watching the way he tensed. âMy stepdad was murdered,â you concluded, dryly.
Andrew sat to face you, peering down at the photo you placed on his coffee table. âLooks gruesome.â
You huffed out a laugh. âYeah. The prick deserved worse.â
He hummed in agreement until you looked at him, inching a bit closer to his face.
âDid⊠did Craig tell you?â
Andrew nodded at you, watching the way your fingers twitched in your lap. âYeah, he did. After that night,â he added, referencing your panic attack. âI was worried.â
You felt yourself relax just a bit at his words. âAnd last week, when you and Craig missed family dinnerâŠâ you let your voice trail off with the implication. âYou wereââ you gestured vaguely to the photo.
âYes.â Andrew immediately cut you off, not allowing you to voice what you had clearly figured out before you texted him. âWhen I told you I would be here for you, for whatever you needed, I meant that,â he added, voice gravelly as he held your gaze. âDo I scare you?â He didnât want to ask, but he had to know.
âNo,â you immediately shook your head. âGod, this is the most anyoneâs ever done for me,â you rasped, eyes brimming with tears. âShit, I feel like Iâm always crying around you.â
Andrew delicately ran his thumbs under each of your eyes to wipe away your tears. You let out a little sigh at the action and reached for his hands, intertwining your fingers with his.
âThank you,â you told him. âNobody has ever wanted to protect me.â
âIâll always do it.â His response was immediate, and you were forced to believe him.
âYeah?â you questioned anyway.
âYeah.â
You werenât sure if you leaned in first or if Andrew did, but before you could think twice, your lips were back on his. This time, when he clutched your waist tightly and you gasped into his mouth, he pressed his tongue against yours, creating a delicious mix of wet sounds and tingling that travelled down your spine.
âAndrew,â you moaned out his name, gasping again when his lips trailed to your ear, placing a quick nip there.
âHmm,â he questioned, feeling somewhat consumed by the feeling of your skin under his.
âTake me to your bedroom?â you asked, voice hitching slightly.
He pulled away from you, searching your eyes for something before settling back on the couch, hands leaving your body, much to your chagrin.
âWe donât have to.â
You shook your head. âI really want to,â you breathed, reaching for his hands again.Â
âLast time, you kinda freaked out,â he bluntly reminded you.
You huffed. âI know. Iâm sorry. I was just a little overwhelmed.â
âYou donât have to apologize to me for that. Not ever.â
You nodded. âThank you,â you murmured, kissing the side of his lips. âIâve never been able to choose,â you whispered. âAnd I choose you, if youâll have me.â
Andrew shivered against you and the soft way you pressed against his body. âYouâyouâll tell me if you want to stop, okay?â he insisted. âAnd if you like something, too,â he added a bit more shyly. âJust tell me everything.â
You giggled, feeling the excitement in his pants. âOkay, yes,â you practically squealed, kissing his lips. âPlease.â
And so he grabbed your hands, shot you a stern look that you saw right through, and walked you to his bedroom.
The same taupe furniture had made its way here, and you were not quite sure if you had ever seen a bed made more perfectly. Every corner was tucked in, the sheets were unwrinkled, and his pillows were fluffed like they were staged for a display at a home goods store. You awkwardly stood at the foot of the bed, sock clad feet shifting as Andrew considered you from the doorway. You held your breath when he walked to you, hands toying with the collar of your work shirt.
âYouâll tell me how youâre feeling, alright?â
You nodded. âPromise.â
He undressed you slowly, making quick work of your three-button polo before he clasped the hem and pulled it off of you. You smiled when he licked his lips at the image of you in your bra. Then, he made his way down to your khaki pants, coming to a kneel as he unbuttoned them and slid down your zipper, softly tugging them past your butt until you stepped out of them. You kicked your socks off yourself.
Andrew placed a kiss between your belly button and the hem of your cotton panties, and sighed out in relief.
âIâm gonna take these off,â he told you, dark eyes looking up to you as you nodded in approval.
âOkay.â
You were half mortified to have him down there, taking in your scent after a long day on your feet and seeing the not so subtle wet patch at the gusset of your underwear. But Andrew was in heaven.
He had been dreaming about what you might smell like, taste like. Being here, so close to your center was pure heaven. He watched as you stepped out of your panties, jaw ticking at the slick he could see on the inside.
âLay down for me, sweetheart,â he rasped out from the floor. You followed his orders so diligently, letting yourself fall back to the bed while you watched him undress.
Youâd seen him at the pool, shirtless with swim trunks on. His torso was shockingly muscular, with broad pecs and the faint definition of a six pack. He looked like he could have been sculpted by Michelangelo and watching him pull down his jeans to reveal tight, black boxer briefs made your mouth go dry. You blinked at him.
Normally, if a woman looked at Andrew this way, he would start to feel a bit shy, maybe even insecure. But your wanton desire made him feel confident.
âHow are you feeling?â he asked, voice tinged with something indecent.
You attempted to imperceptibly rub your thighs together, but Andrew saw everything. âGod,â you groaned. âItâs not fair how good you look.â
That made him smileâsomething private, and just for you.
âYou look better,â he immediately responded. âCan I touch you?â he asked, letting his hand trail against your thighs.
âYes.â
His molten gaze held yours as he climbed in between your thighs, parting them like Moses, as he pressed hot kisses everywhere but where you were leaking.
âAndrew,â you moaned. âPlease do something,â you couldnât help but whine.
And your dutiful man pressed a firm kiss right against your aching clit. He didnât waste anymore time as he dove in, spreading your lower lips with his tongue as he made a journey from your clit, to your hole and then back again. Youâd never felt anything like it.
Between moans of his name and the wet squelching sounds you were making, Andrew knew he was making you feel good.
âI,â you hesitated, letting out another unabashed moan at the feeling. âI thinkâŠâÂ
You couldnât finish your thought because his lips found their way back to your clit and he sucked, hard, giving you your very first orgasm. You shook at the way he hummed into you, gently thrusting against his bed sheets at the way youâre writhing underneath him.
âAndrew,â you called out, gently pressing his head away from your core. âI canât.â Itâs halfhearted; both your attempt to push him away and the way you cry for him to do so, but he finds it in himself to stop. He would always stop if you asked.
Youâre still trying to catch your breath as he trails kisses up your body, working his way back to your face.
âFeel good?â
You laugh in disbelief. âReally, really good. I didnât know you could do that,â you tack on, shyly, attempting to avoid his eyes. The way he grips your chin in his hands is so delicate, like you were made of porcelain, and the way he looks at you holds nothing but longing and pure respect.
âDo you wanna keep going?â
You smile, completely gone for this man. âYeah, I do. Thank you for asking.â
Itâs quiet, the way you add that on, but Andrew knows just how much weight it holds.
He slides down his boxers, a rosy blush creeping up the sides of his neck when he sees you looking at his hardened length. You sit up to take off your bra, and he quickly grabs your hands before you can.Â
âWhatever youâre feeling, I want you to tell me, okay? Donât hold back on me, sweetheart.â
You nod, biting your lip at the overwhelming feeling of gratitude youâre feeling. Andrew takes your bra off himself, relishing in the small shiver you make when you feel his hands unhook the tight band. He brushes his knuckles against your breasts, making your nipples pebble at the action.
You arch your back to press your chest closer to him, an invitation. âYou can, um, touch them more. If you want.â You swear you can feel your face flame at the words.
But Andrew is nothing but devoted, relishing your breasts with the same care he shows everything he values. Taking each nipple into his fingers, toying with them until they reach sharp peaks. Spending time with each one in his perfect mouth while he fondles the other breast so itâs not left out. Youâre quickly becoming a moaning mess at his ministrations.
âIâm ready,â you moan to him, reaching towards his leaking cock. You feel bad that you havenât paid him much attention, but he seemed pleased to be tasting every part of your body. It wouldâve been cruel to take that away from him, you figure.
Thereâs a brief moment of what you think may be hesitation as he considers the gravity of whatâs about to happen, but you watch as itâs washed away, replaced by that private, happy look you saw earlier today.
He quickly rolls a condom over his length and for a moment, you wonder if heâll actually fit. But youâre a leaky faucet at this point.
You grasp at his freckled shoulders as Andrew climbs over you, telling you once again that he wants to hear you, to use your voice, to tell him how youâre feeling. You nod, lips parting in a gasp as soon as you feel the head of his cock breach your entrance.
âOh,â you whimper out, brows furrowing at the feeling of being stretched out by him. Youâre still leaking, and you can feel cool rivulets of your release running down your bum to the sheets under you. It doesnât take much for him to fully enter you.
You clench him tighter when he pulls both of your legs snug against his body, caging him in as he builds up a steady rhythm, carving out a decent sized Andrew shaped hole in your body that could never be replaced by someone else.
âFeel so good,â he manages to rasp out.Â
You pathetically lift your head up to meet your lips to his, craving him in every way, shape and form. All you can think is Andrew, Andrew, Andrew. You want his breath to be shared with yours in between kisses, you want his forehead to keep pressing against your own as he thrusts inside of you, and you want to know what he looks like when he cums.
The pleasure heâs bringing you is almost too much to bear, and you canât help but run your fingers through the curls on his head. The sounds coming from your actions are filling the roomsâwet schlick schlick schlick sounds from where you are joined and the coiling tension in your core is reaching a crescendo that is quickly consuming you in the best way.
You bite your lip at a particularly firm thrust as Andrew practically growls at the feeling.
âCome with me,â you plead to him, only half understanding what youâre really asking for. âSo close,â you mutter.
âFuck,â he grits out, sweat beading across his hairline as he continues to plunge deeper into you.
When he rubs his calloused thumb against your clit, you absolutely lose it.
Itâs a feeling you canât quite explain. You feel your walls clench tightly around his throbbing length, an uncontrollable mewl escaping from your lips at the feeling. Blood is rushing through your ears as he keeps pummeling inside of you, wild moans of pure, unbridled ecstasy are the only noise youâre able to make out. You clutch tightly at his biceps and itâs the only thing you can do to ground yourself as he finishes himself, before falling into a boneless heap on top of you.
Youâre spent, and you both spend a few moments catching your breath, attempting to let the bliss of your late afternoon actions subside.
Andrew gives you a soft look, brushing a bead of sweat away from your hairline delicately before he gives you a quick kiss. You try not to show your discomfort as he rolls away from you and slides out of your center.Â
Thereâs a few more moments of silence, just the quiet sounds of your shared heavy breaths in the room and the faint call of seagulls from beyond the condo. Itâs nice to lay with him.
âWas it,â Andrew breaks the silence, clearing his throat as you look at him. âYou know, like, okay?â
While you arenât quite sure what good sex is, you are certain you just had it with him. âBetter than okay,â you reply easily. You turn to face him, scooching yourself closer to his broad body. âI really enjoyed it,â you added softly.Â
âCool,â he adds.
His boyish tone makes you laugh. Itâs nice to know that under those hulking muscles and that near permanent scowl, thereâs a soft, gentle guy, just wanting to make you happy.
âI really like you,â you comment, closing your eyes and snuggling closer to him.
It nearly makes his brain short circuit, and he holds his breath for a moment, waiting for you to cruelly pop your eyes open and laugh at him or tell him it was all a joke. But you donât.
Youâre already half asleep, winded from everything you had just gotten up to. His quiet, raspy voice is faint when he speaks next. âYouâve got no idea,â he tells you in the quiet of the room.
And that soft kiss he presses to your hair while you start to doze? Well, that just makes you smile.
taglist: @person-005 @momdancingtomcr @intermittentacademic @tubby23 @loftilyviolentthunder @neversleepingever @brandycorso66 @noitnotchappellroan @cowboylover2000












