A/N: Part one here. Second part of the request from @mooneeeee ! I know that I said that there might be a part three to this but I think that I’m satisfied with just two parts, so I hope y’all still enjoy regardless! Song lyrics from Just A Little Bit of Your Heart by Ariana Grande.
I know I'm not your only, but at least I'm one
I heard a little love is better than none
Just a little bit of your heart
Just a little bit of your heart
Just a little bit of your heart is all I want
Just a little bit of your heart
Just a little bit of your heart
Just a little bit is all I'm asking for
You were drifting into a light sleep when you felt a dip of the mattress, and arms wrapping around your waist. Lips and facial stubble brushed against the crook of your neck and jawline, hot breath on your skin. You hummed in pleasure as you turned over onto your opposite side.
“I didn’t know that you were coming over.” You said as you observed Sonny laying beside you.
Sonny kissed your lips, his breath smelling like scotch. “I wanted to see you.”
“How sweet.” You smiled, kissing him back.
Sonny started to kiss you more aggressively, his hands beginning to roam further down your body. You pulled away and he looked offended.
“Not tonight, I’m tired.” You yawned.
Sonny didn’t argue with you or try to change your mind, just sighed and turned over to lay on his back. As soon as he did, you made yourself comfortable on his chest. The longer you laid there, the more you smelled something specific on his shirt. Body spray? But it couldn’t be Sonny’s, it smelled too feminine. Maybe he was with his mom or his sisters?
“Did you visit your mom today?” You asked, breaking the silence.
“You smell like perfume. Just wondered if you saw your mom or your sisters and the scent rubbed off on you.”
“Are we really gonna do this again, Y/N?” Sonny snapped, sitting up.
You sat up as well so that you could face Sonny. “Do what, Dom? I was just asking a question!”
“You’re interrogating me again, just like the last time that I was over!”
“Why do you get so angry at me just for asking about your day? Am I not allowed to do that either?”
“I get angry because you don’t ask about my day just for the sake of asking. You ask about my day because you’re looking for things. Things that you’re not gonna like when you discover them.”
You stared at Sonny for a moment. You were surprised at what you were hearing and still couldn’t understand where he was coming from.
“So why are you hiding things from me in the first place?” You asked him.
“Because we’re not in a relationship, Y/N! You’re not my girlfriend! We fuck, we go to sleep, and then in the morning one of us leaves, and we do it all over again whenever we feel like it. You and I have no relationship beyond that. I don’t have to tell you anything!”
You could feel yourself starting to tear up. You knew that you and Sonny weren’t in a relationship but you didn’t realize how little he thought of you, and it hurt to hear. You could tell that the things that Sonny knew you weren’t going to like had to do with whatever kind of relationship he has with Amanda. There’s no reason why he would lash out like he does unless it was something important to him that he didn’t want you to know about.
“So.. this whole time, you’ve never had feelings for me at all?”
Sonny didn’t respond. He stared blankly at you as you waited for a response.
You wiped your eyes as you could feel the tears falling. “So this whole time, you’ve had some sort of thing going on with Amanda, and when you’re done with her for the day, you come to me just for a quick fuck?”
Sonny sighed. “Y/N, it’s not like that.”
“Then tell me what it is like, Dom. Because you get texts while you’re with me, and then all of a sudden you have to leave. I ask you who the text was from or why you have to leave and you lash out at me. You come over to see me, and you smell like women’s perfume. I ask you who you were with or why you smell like that and you lash out at me. I’m surely not as stupid as you think I am, Sonny.”
“What the hell do you expect me to do then, huh? Confess my feelings for you, ask you to be my girlfriend, and then we live happily ever after? Is that what you want?”
“That’s exactly what I want! Don’t you get it? I’ve had feelings for you for as long as we’ve known each other, Sonny! I knew going into this that it was casual but I had hope that maybe things would change. That I’d become more to you than just some quick fuck. I stuck around for you, Dominick,” More tears started to fall from your eyes and this time you didn’t care. “And… this whole time… all you’ve wanted is somebody else.”
Sonny wiped tears away from your cheek with his thumb before tucking your hair behind your ear so that it was out of your face. He took a deep breath before speaking.
“I care about you, Y/N. I really do. And if things were different, maybe I’d be able to give you what you want. But right now, I can’t do that. Amanda… she’s special to me. Really special. I can’t let that go. I can’t move on from that without knowing what all could’ve happened between her and I. There’s so much potential there and I can’t choose you over her. I just can’t.”
The two of you stayed silent for what felt like forever. You were hurt, disappointed. You didn’t know what else to say to Sonny. You just wanted to forget that this had ever happened. You wanted to be able to move on.
After a while, Sonny got up off of the bed, bending over to kiss your forehead as you sat on the mattress. “I’m sorry that things had to end like this.”
You watched as Sonny walked out of your bedroom and down the hallway, like he had done countless times before. Except this time, he wasn’t coming back.