JOURNAL // UTILITARIANISM VIDEO
Watch the Biola Ethics video and reflect about Utilitarianism. Explain the Utilitarian responses to these situations. Comment about the difference of foreseen and unintended vs. intended. What would you do? (Why?)
In the video we watched in Bible class, the man gave us a few situations of difficult choices to make. The first situation was the one about the trolley car rapidly approaching five children sitting on the tracks of the train, there was an option to pull the lever and change the track to another pathway to avoid. However the other situation the speaker brought out that particularly stood out to me was about getting a knee injury and going to the hospital. When you go to the hospital it just so turns out that 5 other people are looking for transplants and you are the perfect match.
Through these situations, the professor points out all the flaws in utilitarianism. He shows that inevitably, people will get left out. Using the first one as an example, the fat man is not happy in this situation because well, he is dead. He also shows us how quickly the tables are turned in different situations, like the hospital one. Technically, it would be the most beneficial to everyone if you were to die because you could donate your organs but it's simply not fair.
The one thing that stood out to me the most was that the intention matters quite a bit in this situation. He uses abortion as an example. In typical abortions, women do it INTENDING to terminate the baby. However, if the baby's birth has complications and could potentially cause the death of both the mother and the child it is justified because you are not intending to kill the baby.
If I were to be in this situation, I hate to say it but I think I would shove the man in order to save the children. The man has lived his life but those five children have their whole life ahead of them. However if I was the patient with knee surgery I would definitely not let them take my organs and botch my surgery. Yes, it would be most beneficial but I don't know those people and those people could be horrible people. I know it’s not a very good excuse but hey it’s all I have.













