In one of your older q&a's you've mentioned listening to creepypastas I believe. Do you have a favorite? Mines Ted the Caver and that one godzilla creepypasta.
Oh wow, this takes me back, god, must be fifteen years how. I mostly read them, rather than listened, though I did enjoy some of the early Youtube creepypasta narrators and the OG NoSleep podcast.
The thing that always tickled me about the whole creepypasta thing was that because they were generally done by younger writers (and in many cases actual kids) you could never tell whether any given story was going to end on a genuine chill or devolve into campy "and then on the radio they said AH NO THEY ARE EATING MY FACE AND EYES AHH." You had to engage with each one earnestly, and the inconsistency of quality and the unpolished, often clumsy, prose actually helped the ones that worked to really hit.
So, let's see, the ones that still linger in my mind:
Candle Cove: Just an all-time banger. Absolute best of the "creepy TV" subgenre and always hits. Ending reveal is nothing groundbreaking, but very-well executed.
The Russian Sleep Experiment: Maybe the first one I encountered and sticks with me - it had that good urban legend flavour and managed to (mostly) avoid goofiness.
The Rake: I love a good monster, and the fragmentary, slightly documentarian style of this one actually makes a virtue of its disjointed style to give it a bit of verisimilitude.
The Disappearance of Ashley, Kansas: Dunno if you've noticed, but I have a fondness for inexplicable-geography-based horror and this one scratches that itch. The ending's a little bit goofy, but the rest of it slaps.
Various Slender Man blogs: Relatively early in the development of the meme-character Slenderman, back when he was still The Slender Man, there were a bunch of different faux-blogs that all did live-update first person stories about being stalked and (in some cases) finally taken by The Slender Man. The quality was inconsistent and many dragged on too long, but the ones that were good were real good.
WHO WAS PHONE: Well? Who was?