this is detective mark hoffman. i am an esteemed detective at [redacted] Police Department. iâŠ. donât know why i made this, but itâs here.
i donât mind dms or asks, so go ahead.
Interview Vampire Daily
Lint Roller? I Barely Know Her
todays bird

shark vs the universe
Sweet Seals For You, Always
Fai_Ryy
đ©” avery cochrane đ©”
official daine visual archive
I'd rather be in outer space đž
The Stonewall Inn
tumblr dot com
taylor price

Origami Around
"I'm Dorothy Gale from Kansas"

#extradirty

ellievsbear
Keni
art blog(derogatory)

bliss lane
Color Me Curious
seen from United States
seen from United Kingdom

seen from Germany
seen from Poland

seen from United States
seen from United States

seen from Nepal

seen from Lithuania
seen from United States

seen from Venezuela
seen from United States

seen from United States

seen from Qatar
seen from United States

seen from United States

seen from France

seen from Malaysia
seen from Poland

seen from Canada
seen from Venezuela
@hoffmans-trap
this is detective mark hoffman. i am an esteemed detective at [redacted] Police Department. iâŠ. donât know why i made this, but itâs here.
i donât mind dms or asks, so go ahead.
Hello friends....
Enemies...
The name's mark and i am officially open to questions. Comments. That kind of stuff
I love personal questions. In fact, i'm a very honest person.
I can take some pretty wild questions. Maybe i'll get a good laugh outta them đ€Ł
Send me questions people! What are you waiting around for! Come on! Im bored at work and i refuse to do my job LOL
hoe ffy
hey, it's me, Zeke Banks. you know, Zeke Banks.
why did i make this? no idea. seemed fun i guess?
send me asks about anything, i'm open to answering anything! well, almost everything. not answering creeps.
heyyyy i'm the modddd!!
this is not my first rp blog, trust me....
send literally any asks! i'm very welcoming to answering anything, especially because not many people like spiral. would love to see some people send asks for zeke!
tags:
-zeke post = zeke/in character post!
-mod post = mod post!
-zeke answer = zeke/in character answers!
-mod answer = mod answers!
" you have given people the news that they're going to die soon. "
hello. I'm Lawrence Gordon, or doctor Gordon.
I downloaded this app for no real reason.
feel free to send any types of asks, I don't really care...
HAIII ! I'm the owner/admin of this blog :)
uhh not much to know about me other than my preferences !
i do ship chainshipping more than other Lawrence ships, just in case. any types of asks are ok since Lawrence is an adult!
tags :
âą lawrence post = post in character
âą ooc post = admin post
âą lawrence answer = lawrence answers to asks
âą ooc answers = admin answers
While I'm not busy being the world's most devastatingly handsome jigsaw survivor, I like to unwind by sneaking stray cats into my apartment to check them for fleas and give them something to eat without my landlord noticing
âGame overâ
Peter walked into the station holding a laptop bag and a big silver cup of coffee. It was very obvious he didn't get much sleep, like usual.
[ - @detstrahm ]
[ ooc text : i've never done an rp on tumblr so sorry if this starter sucks !!! ]
Mark Hoffman stands near his desk, eyes narrowing as Strahm enters the room. He takes in the sight of the tired detective, the coffee in his hand, and the laptop bag slung over his shoulder. Hoffman straightens slightly, his face betraying no emotion as he watches Strahm move to his desk.
"You look like you haven't slept in days, Strahm. Tiredness isn't a badge of honor. Itâs a weakness."
He leans back in his chair, his arms folding across his chest, his gaze unwavering as he watches Strahmâs every move.
"If youâre planning to continue running on fumes, itâs only a matter of time before it catches up to you. You should know better than anyone what happens when you lose focus."
His tone is harsh, but there's an edge to it, as if he's quietly daring Strahm to respond, or perhaps waiting for a crack in the other man's usually composed demeanor.
[NO I LOVE IT!! LMK IF THIS IS TOO MUCH HEJEEJEJEJ]
"Not that it's any of your concern, but I'm fine."
Strahm stopped walking as he spoke, looking back to Hoffman over his shoulder with a cold gaze that could definitely kill him if looks really could kill.
"Your snarky comments aren't going to affect me, I'm not a child."
His voice was firm yet calm, making it obvious that he wasn't trying to cause a scene this early into his shift. It was so hard to do anything with Hoffman just a couple steps away from him.
Hoffman smirked to himself, tapping his pen idly against a stack of paperwork before finally dragging his gaze up to meet Strahmâs glare.
"You sure about that?" His voice was slow, almost amused. "Because Iâve seen you get flustered over a lot less."
He leaned back in his chair, letting the words settle, watching for the inevitable reaction. Hoffman raised a brow, the corner of his mouth twitching like he was resisting the urge to really twist the knife. "Not that itâs any of my concern, of course."
And just like that, he went back to his paperwork, acting like the conversation was already over, though he was more than ready for whatever Strahm had to say next-- almost if in anticipation.
Peter took a deep breath as he walked over to Hoffman's desk, leaning over to whisper in his ear instead of yelling. It seemed like the most mature choice.
"Listen here, asshole. I am in no mood to deal with your shit today."
His tone was sharp as if he was an angry dog barking back at Mark. No matter how hard he tried to ignore Hoffman, he always came up with something to say that just pushed his limits.
He tugged on the collar of the other male's shirt, pulling him closer so his mouth was almost touching his ear.
"Leave me the fuck alone, Hoffman."
He growled in Mark's ear, pushing himself away from him with a stern look on his face.
Hoffman barely reacted as Strahm yanked him closer, his breath hot against his ear, voice laced with frustration. The smirk that tugged at the corner of his mouth was slow, deliberateâbecause this was interesting.
For a moment, he didnât say anything, just let the tension settle between them. Then, in a voice just low enough for only Peter to hear, he finally spoke.
"Careful, Strahm." Smooth, almost teasing. "You keep getting this close, people might start talking."
His gaze flickered downâjust brieflyâto where Strahmâs fingers had gripped his collar. Then, just as lazily, he reached for the cup sitting next to him. It wasnât the usual station sludge, but something sweeter, something indulgent, the faint scent of caramel mixing with the deeper, familiar notes of his cologneâcedarwood, leather, something subtly sharp beneath it all.
He took a slow sip, his smirk deepening just slightly as he finally met Strahmâs glare again.
"But heyâmessage received." His tone was light, almost amused. But there was something else beneath it, something unreadable.
[not me sprinkling in some hoffman hcs lol.]
The more Mark spoke, the more it seemed to anger Strahm. He hated how easy it was for Mark to anger him with just a tone of voice or a simple sentence.
"God, fuck off." Peter basically stormed off to his desk, throwing himself into the chair. As he logged into his computer to actually start working, he couldn't stop thinking about Hoffman.
Usually, that would be normal. Today it was different though. Instead of thinking about how much he hated him, he started thinking about these small details about him. Like how his hair looked more brushed through then normally, or how the scent stuck on his body was weirdly calming.
It was weird, but he couldn't stop thinking about it.
It's like Hoffman put a spell on him.
Hoffman watched Strahm go, lifting his cup to his lips again, taking an unhurried sip. The taste of caramel lingered, mixing with the sharper bitterness beneath it.
That was too easy.
Strahm could throw himself into his chair all he wanted, could scowl at his screen and pretend to focus, but Hoffman knew. He knew. Because that reaction? That wasnât just anger. That was something else, something tangled up in frustration and confusion and whatever the hell was flickering behind those glares.
He swirled the drink absently in his cup, gaze flicking toward Strahmâs desk. Then, without looking directly at him, he spokeâjust loud enough to carry across the room.
"You sure you want me to fuck off, or do you just like telling me what to do?"
Hoffman smirked against the rim of his cup, taking another slow sip, letting his pursed lips linger on the rim. Letting the words settle.
Peter's hands froze and his computer as he took a moment to let himself process what Mark just said. Instead of freaking out, or yelling, or even getting out of his seat, he responded calmly. He hated to egg Hoffman on with his emotions.
"Do your damn work, Hoffman. Might do you some good."
Strahm placed his head in his hands for a moment to recollect himself before continuing to work in silence, using his screen to hide from looking at anyone even near him.
He didn't understand this feeling. It was a strange mixture of so many things and emotions he hasn't felt since early college. Whatever it was, Hoffman was enjoying using it against him.
The teasing worked, but god he wish it didn't.
Hoffman finally, finally turned his attention to the files on his desk, though his focus was shot to hell. His eyes moved over the words, but they barely registered. The conversationâthat look Strahm had given him before burying himself in his screenâwas still fresh, playing in his mind like a puzzle he hadnât quite solved yet.
He tapped his fingers against the desk, considering. There was something satisfying about watching Strahm try so hard to keep himself in check, to act like none of this was getting to him. Hoffman knew better.
The corner of his mouth twitched as he flipped a page, not bothering to hide the smirk creeping in. He took another sip of his drink, the sweetness coating his tongue, lingering.
Maybe he should get back to work.
Or maybe he should push just a little moreâjust to see how long Strahm could keep pretending.
Strahm tapped his pen on his desk to a rhythm he had just made up in his mind since that seemed to be the only thing that could replace his thoughts about Hoffman.
Everything reminded him of Mark, it's like he couldn't escape him. He couldn't even focus on his work, which really bothered him. Usually, his work was the one distraction that always worked, but clearly not today.
Peter sighed before standing up and dropping his pen down onto his desk. He ran his hands down his outfit before walking away to the bathroom with his head down the whole time.
He needed an escape. He needed a way to get away from Mark, even just for a couple minutes.
He opened the door to the bathroom, making sure nobody was in there before walking to the sink and turning on cold water. Strahm collected a small amount of water on his hands and splashed it on his face, staring at himself in the mirror. Why was this happening now?
Hoffman didnât look up right away, but he felt the shift. The absence. The way the air around him suddenly felt⊠quieter.
Strahm was gone.
No presence lingering just a few feet away, no rhythmic tapping of a pen, no barely restrained exhale of frustration. The space he left behind felt noticeable in a way Hoffman didnât care to dwell on.
His fingers drummed idly against the desk as he stared at the open file in front of him. He wasnât reading it. His focus was elsewhere, stuck on somethingâor someoneâthat wasnât even in the damn room anymore.
Hoffman sighed, rolling his shoulders before forcing himself back to his work. Strahm would be back.
And when he was, Hoffman wasnât sure if heâd say anything at allâjust that heâd be aware, too aware, of the moment Strahm walked back through that door.
Strahm continued to stare at himself, a look of confusion forming on his face as he stared.
Who was he right now?
He could normally focus on his work with no struggle, but today was just so different. The tension that formed drove him mad. It didn't make any sense, he didn't feel these things last week, so what's so different now?
Peter began to get angry at everything, especially his thoughts. The water still running, the footsteps outside, the talking of his coworkers, the door to the females restroom opening and closing, everything.
He couldn't take it. Strahm punched the bathroom counter, turning the sink off before storming out of the bathroom and back to his seat.
He tried so hard to get on task but with Hoffman around, it would be hard.
The sound of Strahmâs chair scraping against the floor pulled Hoffmanâs attention before he even meant to look at the other man.
Back already.
He didnât watch himânot openly, at least. Whatever that little break had been, it clearly hadnât helped.
Hoffman finally, finally turned his attention to the files in front of him, though his focus was still half elsewhere. He flipped a page, then spoke, his tone casual.
âYou see the new evidence on the Jigsaw case yet?â A beat. Then, with a glint of playfulness in his eyes, he added, âLooks like our guyâs getting smarter.â
Strahm coughed, opening one of the many files on his desk and writing something quick down in pen. "I heard they found a small strand of hair at a scene. They sent it in to get it tested and a DNA read." He sighed. "Seems useless though. It's a strand of hair that was next to a victim, it was probably theirs."
He wasn't doing very well at trying to seem like he calmed down. Peter never denied small things like this unless he was just talking to talk.
He didn't understand how Hoffman was so casual right now. Does he not feel the tension right now? is he really that dumb?
Hoffman didnât look up right away. He turned a page in his file, scanning the words like they mattered more than Strahmâs obvious frustration. âCould be useless,â he said, almost offhandedly. âOr it could be exactly what we need.â
There was no real argument in his toneâjust something thoughtful, maybe even knowing, like he wasnât as dismissive of the lead as Strahm was.
He finally shifted, glancing at Strahm as if noticing him for the first time since he sat back down. His gaze flicked over him brieflyâtaking in the tension still lingering in his shoulders, the way his grip on his pen was just a little too tight.
And then, something caught his attention. The way the dim overhead light hit just right, outlining the sharp line of Strahmâs jaw, the faintest crease between his brows. Had he always clenched his jaw like that when he was thinking? It wasnât just irritationâit was focus, frustration, something deeper that Hoffman couldnât quite pin down.
For a second, he nearly forgot what he was about to say. He forced himself to look back down at his file, masking the moment with an easy shrug.
âLong morning?â His voice was low, almost conversational. But there was something in the way he said itâsomething that made it impossible to tell if he was just making small talk or if he already knew the answer.
Strahm aggressively wrote stuff down in the files, taking small breaks to collect his thought before continuing to write.
"Bad traffic. Bad night." His tone was firm and aggressive, but not on purpose. He spoke quickly which made it obvious it was a lie to get off the topic of anything but work.
He glanced up at Hoffman and froze, using this moment to soak in everything about him. The way he looked so calm while focused on his work, the way his hand gently pushed the pen down on the paper, the way his lips looked when he was focused...
Peter bit down onto his bottom lip roughly, definitely leaving small teeth marks on his lip. Simply looking at Mark made him anxious.
Hoffman didnât react right away. He let Strahmâs words sit between them, as if deciding whether or not to be snide.
He kept his focus on the file in front of him, but his mind was elsewhereâstuck on something he couldnât quite shake. The way Strahmâs voice had that edge to it. The way his pen practically carved into the paper, like he needed the distraction.
Then, in his periphery, he caught itâStrahm biting his lip, hard.
Hoffmanâs grip on his pen tightened for a fraction of a second before he forced himself to relax, dragging his eyes back to his work.
He exhaled through his nose, pretending to stay focused on his paperwork, but his mind was already elsewhere. The way Strahm bit his lipâthat sharp press of teeth against skinâwasnât something he shouldâve noticed.
Wasnât something he shouldâve cared about.
But he did.
His jaw tensed as he forced his attention back to the file in front of him, masking any sign of distraction. After a beat of silence, he finally spoke, his voice lower than before.
"Yeah⊠not like sleep does much good anyway."
"I stayed up practically all night trying to put together why they would test that fucking-" He took a deep breath, looking down at his papers. "that damn strand of hair. It just doesn't make much sense."
As much as he tried to focus on his papers, he couldn't. The way his jaw tensed just drew in his attention even more as if it was magic.
Peter continued to bite at his lip, feeling an impending doom for what Hoffman would say next. His voice was just so smooth, it felt like torture in the best way possible.
He tried to pretend to do his work, but it was hard when his eyes couldn't get off of Mark. He felt helpless in this moment and he hated it.
He was supposed to have all the power.
Hoffman didnât need to look up to know Strahm was still watching him. He could feel itâthose damn eyes, like heat searing into the side of his face, making it almost impossible to focus on anything else.
"Yeah," Hoffman murmured, his voice gravelly but calm, "doesnât add up, does it?"
He wasnât just talking about the case. The frustration in Strahmâs toneâit hit something deeper, something Hoffman didnât feel like addressing, not right now.
He finally looked up, his gaze meeting Strahm's, but only for a brief moment. "But thatâs the thing with this case, Strahm. Sometimes itâs not about making sense." His words carried an almost unsettling weight, though he wasnât sure if Strahm would catch on.
His hand paused mid-motion as he noticed Strahmâs biting, that subtle, almost unconscious action. Hoffmanâs brow furrowed slightly, but he quickly dismissed the thought, shaking it off. He had work to do.
"Try to stay focused," he added, his tone unexpectedly softer, though he meant it more to himself than Strahm.
Strahm let out a deep sigh, closing his eyes and swinging his head back for a moment. This was his best attempt at clearing his mind.
"I just hate when they do things without running it past me or Perez first." He whispered, picking his pen back up and beginning to actually work on the case.
He felt like a idiot. For once, he didn't want to be at work. He regretted coming in today, especially because Lindsey wouldn't be here because her family was in town and wanted one day with them.
Peter picked back up the rhythm from earlier with his pen, tapping it more aggressively than before without realizing. At this point, he was just trying to drown out any of his thoughts, even about work.
Hoffman let the comment hang in the air, though something shifted in his posture at the mention of Lindsey. He didnât outwardly show it, but the thought gnawed at him for a split second.
He leaned back in his chair, the sound of Strahmâs aggressive pen tapping filling the otherwise quiet space. The irritation in Strahmâs actions wasn't lost on Hoffman, but the mention of Lindsey caught him off guard. It wasnât like him to care, not like this.
"Youâre right," Hoffman said, his voice controlled, though there was a slight edge to it, "Youâd think they'd at least consult you. But," he paused, the faintest of smirks pulling at the corners of his lips, "youâre better off without distractions anyway."
He didnât know if Strahm would pick up on the shift in his tone, but Hoffman had a feeling his partner wouldn't miss the faint jealousy that had crept in. He wasnât sure why it bothered him, but it did.
His eyes flicked to Strahm for a brief moment, then back to the file in front of him, trying to focus.
"Guess youâre stuck here with me," he added, his tone slipping just enough to hint at something more personal beneath the professional surface.
Peter suddenly stopped tapping his pen at the last comment Mark added, pausing everything he was doing. Something with the tone he used made him feel something different. Something he hasn't felt yet today.
He couldn't sit here with Hoffman with those words just replaying in his head, he had to escape somewhere.
"I'll be back." Strahm said, his words slightly slurring together. He shot up from his seat, speed walking back to the bathroom. There was one other person in there, but he could care less at the moment.
Peter paced back and forth in the bathroom while waiting for the other man to leave the restroom. Luckily, the pacing must've rushed him out. He continued to pace around, pinching at the bridge of the nose.
There's no way Mark hasn't noticed his weird behavior, there's just no way. He didn't understand why he couldn't just suppress his emotions like he normally did. He has been hiding his emotions with ease for years, so what was so different today?
Hoffman stood up by the windowsill, his back leaning against the cool glass, eyes staring at the outside but not really seeing it. His mind kept drifting back to Strahm, and the way heâd snapped, his frustration practically hanging in the air. There was something about it, something that felt... off. He couldnât quite put his finger on it, but it bothered him.
He rubbed a hand over his face, sighing, trying to clear the thoughts clouding his head. His gaze flicked back to Strahmâs empty deskâ God, why was it so unsettling?
Mark didnât let distractions get to him. He wasnât someone who let emotions or anything else interfere with the job. But thisâwhatever this wasâ was messing with his usual routine.
The door creaked slightly, and his eyes darted toward it, but no one was there. Mark was surprised by how much heâd noticed Peterâs absence. He shifted uncomfortably, his fingers curling into a fist around the edge of the windowsill. What the hell was wrong with him? It wasnât like Strahm to just leave like that, and it wasnât like him either to feel... unsettled by it.
âJust focus,â Mark muttered to himself, but his gaze lingered on the door a second longer than necessary. He hadnât realized how much he had started to notice the little things about Strahmâhis sharp movements, his short temper, the way his jaw tensed when he was angry. And then the way heâd left, so abruptly, like he couldnât even get out of the room fast enough.
Mark rubbed the back of his neck and shook his head, pursing his lips in thought.
He wasnât someone who gave a damn about these things. But today felt... different
And that made him uneasy.
Peter leaned up against the bathroom wall, placing his face in his hands. He wanted to stay in the bathroom until he died but sadly, he knew he couldn't. Strahm continued to bite down on his lip until he tasted blood.
"Fucking hell..." He whispered, taking his hands off his face to wipe his lip. He stared down at his hand, looking at the blood that covered a small part of the side of his hand.
Strahm walked over to the sink and rinsed his hand off, watching the water turn a slight red before slipping down the drain. It was a weirdly calming sight.
He soon left the bathroom, avoiding looking at Hoffman the best he could. "I'm going to refill my coffee." Strahm said firmly as he reached for his cup, rushing away from his desk before he could even hear a response.
If he was being completely honest, he was embarrassed. He was embarrassed that he couldn't hide his feelings this time. It was such a weird thing to feel something other than anger or calmness.
Peter grabbed the old coffee pot from the staff room, filling his large silver cup up with the lukewarm coffee. He hated how he couldn't confront Mark about these feelings.
Hoffman noticed it immediatelyâhow Strahm wouldnât look at him, how his movements were just a little too quick, like he couldnât get away fast enough.
He grabbed his cup and rushed off before Hoffman could so much as blink.
He didnât know what heâd expected, but it wasnât⊠that.
For the first time, something about Strahmâs reaction made him hesitate. He knew how to read peopleâhe had toâbut this wasnât the usual sharp-edged frustration he was used to prying out of Strahm. This wasnât Strahm picking a fight or snapping back. It was avoidance.
And for some reason, Hoffman didnât like that.
His fingers drummed against the desk, watching the spot Strahm had just vacated. Part of himâsome small, stupid partâwondered if heâd actually hurt him. The thought unsettled him more than it should have.
He let out a quiet exhale, dragging his focus back to his paperwork. It was nothing. It had to be nothing.
So why did it sit so strangely in his chest?
Peter took a deep breath in the small but strangely calming staff room. Why couldn't he just man up and go do his work? Why was Hoffman such a distraction? There were all these whys in his head with no answer.
He took a swig of the lukewarm coffee, swishing it around his mouth as he let his mind wander some more. He felt so stupid for avoiding Mark. For some strange reason, he felt bad for avoiding Hoffman.
Strahm looked at the shut door and debated ever leaving this room, but sadly he knew he had to. He had to face his problems.
Peter left the staff room with his head up this time, trying his best to look put together and confident. As he walked to his desk he wondered if everyone else in the building could tell he was breaking on the inside.
Hoffman didnât acknowledge Strahmâs return, keeping his eyes trained on the file in front of him. He wasnât really reading itâhis focus was shot to hell.
He was letting his body speak for him in ways he couldnât control. His leg bounced beneath the desk, a steady, impatient rhythm. His fingers tapped soundlessly against the edge of his paper, the only betrayal of his restlessness.
He wanted to look at Strahm. Watch for any flicker of emotion. See if there was still tension in his jaw, if his lip was still raw from biting down too hard. But he didnât. Not yet.
He just waited. If Strahm wanted to pretend nothing happened, fine. But if there was a crackâany sign of itâHoffman would be there, ready to catch it.
Strahm coughed as if trying to warn Hoffman he was back in his seat, pulling open a completely new file to maybe try and focus on something new.
He read every word on the paper, but nothing made sense in his head at the moment. It was weird, but it felt strange without Hoffman's eyes on him. If he was being honest, he missed being looked at from a distance.
"So, have you heard anything about the Jigsaw case?" Peter asked with his face still buried in the case files on his desk. The silence became too much for him to handle and he needed to break it.
He eagerly waited for a response as if his life depended on it, nervously biting his lip once again and continuing to tap his pen to a different rhythm from before.
Hoffman exhaled slowly, dragging his eyes from his paperwork like he was indulging Strahm by giving him attention.
"Nothing new," he said, his voice even. "Just the same dead ends."
He finally glanced at Strahm, taking in the way his lip was caught between his teeth again, the quick, restless tapping of his pen.
He leaned back slightly, studying Strahm a little longer than necessary before forcing himself to look away. As Hoffman finally looked at him, his gaze snagged on something small but noticeableâthe faint trace of dried blood at the corner of Strahmâs lip. It was barely there, but it was enough.
Hoffmanâs fingers twitched slightly, his grip on his pen tightening before he forced himself to loosen it. He shouldnât care. Shouldnât even be looking. But the sight of it made something uneasy settle in his chest. Had Strahm bitten down that hard?
His jaw tensed as he dragged his eyes away. His breath hitched before he could stop it.
The sight of itâsubtle, unintentional, self-inflictedâsent something sharp and hot running through his veins. His fingers curled around his pen, gripping it just a little too tight. He shouldnât be reacting to this. Shouldnât feel the way his pulse quickened, the way his body betrayed him with that sudden, insidious heat curling in his gut.
His composure threatened to slip.
Hoffman exhaled through his nose, his jaw clenching as he forced his expression to stay neutral. His gaze flicked away, back to his paperwork, even though the words on the page were meaningless now.
âWhy?â His voice came out steadyâthankfullyâbut just a fraction lower than before. âYou onto something?â
He kept his head down, pen skimming over the paper in a weak attempt at normalcy, but the damage was already done. He felt it. And worseâhe liked it.
"Not yet. It's getting annoying how we can't get any new leads..." Strahm put his pen down onto his desk, leaning his head back as he let out a long sigh of exhaustion.
Suddenly, he had gotten an idea. Something that would probably calm down the thoughts about Hoffman in his head, but would probably be seen as weird.
At this point, that was the least of his concerns.
"Hey, wanna go somewhere for lunch? We can discuss the case some more." Peter said, his voice was low with a hint of embarrassment. He didn't want to give Mark any ideas of what he actually meant but instead an idea that he actually cared about the Jigsaw case at this moment.
Strahm held his breath while waiting for a response, keeping his eyes focused on the papers on his desk rather than Hoffman to seem relaxed.
He really hoped he was pulling off the whole 'chill' act...
Hoffman didnât answer right away. He sat with it, rolling the idea over in his head, his pen idly tapping against the desk.
Lunch. Alone. With him.
It was easy to pretend that was a normal suggestion. Just two law enforcement officers talking shop. But Strahm had hesitated before asking, and that hesitation stuck with him.
His eyes flicked toward the other man, watching the way he stayed locked onto the papers in front of him like they held the answer to something more than just their case. His fingers curled around his pen a little tighter.
Hoffman wasnât sure why that detail bothered him.
He exhaled through his nose, feigning indifference. âYeah, sure.â His voice was steady, neutral. As if he hadnât spent the last minute overthinking this.
He leaned back in his chair, stretching his legs out, the tension in his muscles betraying his otherwise relaxed posture. His knee bounced once before he stilled it. He didnât like feeling caught off guard.
He finally looked at Strahm again. âWhere?â It wasnât an enthusiastic acceptance, but it also wasnât a rejection. It was something in between.
Peter let out a quiet sigh as soon as Mark answered, gripping at the bridge of his nose as he tried to think of a place nearby that was nice enough to take Hoffman to, but not too nice.
"Well, I heard there's this nice sandwich place that recently opened... we could go there." Strahm suggested, pulling himself out of his work to actually make eye contact with Hoffman.
He noticed small details very quickly. The way a couple strands of hair fell out of his styled hair, the way his eyes were naturally tired looking in such a good way, the way his hand gripped onto his pen, the way he had to stop his leg from bouncing... everything was so perfect it made him sick.
He tried to pull his eyes off of Mark, but he just couldn't. For once, he had an actual excuse to stare at Hoffman. He shouldn't have been as grateful as he was.
Hoffman let a beat of silence pass before tilting his head slightly, finally meeting Strahmâs eyes with something that almost resembled amusement.
âA sandwich place, huh?â he said, tapping his fingers idly against the desk. âDidnât peg you as the type to branch out. Thought you survived purely off burnt coffee and spite.â
There was a slight smirk at the corner of his mouth, but his tone was just casual enough to keep Strahm guessing. It wasnât an outright challenge, but it wasnât nothing, either. Just enough to test the watersâto see if Strahm would roll his eyes, snap back, or keep looking at him like that.
His leg bounced once before he forced it still again, fingers tightening around his pen.
Peter's breathing quickly became regular as soon as Hoffman made eye contact with him, causing him to stumble over his words.
"Well- I-" He paused, collecting his thoughts. "I mostly survive off of cheap burnt coffee, but I'm switching it up for once." A slight smile appeared on his face for the first time today once he realized if he just kept up this calm, non-angry act up, he might survive this shift.
Or, at least he'll try to keep it up. It's hard when he's around Mark.
Strahm reached into his pocket and searched for his card, flipping through random twenties and tens before finally finding it. "I heard it's pretty cheap so I might as well pay for yours." He said, not even noticing how nice he was being.
He was never nice to anyone other than Lindsey really, so this must've been a rare sighting to anyone listening in to the conversation.
"But I'm only paying because it's cheap. I'm not trying to be all nice and shit, so don't get that idea." Of course, he had to ruin the one moment he seemed slightly kind.
Hoffman let out a quiet chuckle, shaking his head as he watched Strahm fumble with his wallet. There was something oddly endearing about itâhow he offered without thinking, only to immediately try to walk it back. It wasnât often that Strahm let something slip through the cracks.
"Generous and cheap. Quite the combination," Hoffman murmured, his voice dipping into something almost warm, almost teasing. He let the words hang between them for a moment before exhaling, running a hand down the sleeve of his jacket as he stood.
His gaze lingered on Strahm just a little longer than necessary, taking in the way he still wouldn't quite meet his eyes. There was a rare ease in the moment, a shift from the usual sharp edges they threw at each other. Hoffman felt it more than he wanted to acknowledge.
"If youâre so insistent," he said, his tone softer now, something almost amused beneath it, "Iâll let you buy me lunch. Just donât expect me to be nice about it."
It wasnât a joke, not really. But it was something. A quiet acceptance, an unspoken truce. And when he stepped just a little closerâjust enough to catch the faintest tension in Strahmâs shouldersâhe couldn't quite fight the smirk that ghosted across his lips.
"Letâs go before you change your mind."
Strahm nodded in agreement, shoving his wallet back in his pocket before standing, straightening out his top with his hands. It was so weird that he suddenly felt a need to look... cleaner around Hoffman.
"Do you want me to drive?" He asked as he began to walk to the front door of the building, reaching a hand into the opposite pocket of his wallet to grip onto his keys, ready for an answer to his question.
Peter tried to walk slightly fast, trying to avoid anyone really seeing him walk outside the building while having an active and normal conversation with Mark.
He didn't want people to think he suddenly grew fond of Hoffman because, if he was being completely honest, he didn't really like the thought of beginning to grow fond of him.
Peter spent all of these years hating Mark just for that to change from one interaction. It felt stupid to him. He felt stupid.
Hoffman followed steadily, letting Strahm put some distance between them. It wasnât hard to pick up on the way Peter was rushing. Like it meant something.
Hoffman didnât call attention to it, but he noticed. He noticed the way Strahmâs fingers curled tightly around his keys, the way he held himself just a little straighter, as if heâd suddenly started caring about how he looked. It was subtle, but it was there.
And for some reason, it was... alluring.
There was a new kind of tension in Strahm, not the usual barely-contained aggression Hoffman was used to. This was something else, something more restrained. He wasnât sure what to make of it yet, but he had the patience to figure it out.
âIâll let you drive,â he finally said, watching Strahm with something just shy of amusement. His voice was even, casual, but his smirk gave away more than he probably intended. He let the moment stretch just a little longer before adding, âJust try not to kill us before we get there.â
A joke, but one that carried weight. A small push. A test.
He walked ahead of Strahm and put a hand in his pocket as he walked.
"I'll try, but it might be hard with you in the car." Peter said, hiding back a smirk as he spoke. He pulled the keys out of his pocket, gripping them tightly in his hand as if someone was going to steal them from him.
As he entered the cold weather outside, his whole body tightened. Strahm had always hated the cold.
He unlocked his car, quickly shoving himself in to try and escape the weather. He switched on the heat in his car before blowing warm air into his hands, waiting patiently for Mark to say something that gave him the idea he was ready for him to start driving.
Peter really hated driving with a person in his car. His road rage usually killed any good energy moving throughout his car in a matter of seconds. Sure, Mark has seen him angry, but not the type of anger he gets while driving.
Plus, he'd really hate to ruin what they had going on at the moment...
Hoffman let out a short chuckle at Strahmâs response, low and almost under his breath. There was something oddly satisfying about the way Peter shot back without missing a beatâlike he was starting to get comfortable with this, whether he wanted to or not.
The cold bit at his skin as he followed Strahm outside, but he barely registered it, too focused on watching the other man move. The tension in his shoulders, the way he practically threw himself into the car to escape the chillâit was little things like that that made Hoffman feel like he was getting a read on him.
He slid into the passenger seat with an easy, unbothered motion, his gaze settling on Strahm as the heat kicked in. The way Peter hunched over his hands, rubbing warmth back into them, was oddly... humanizing. A rare moment where he looked like more than just a sharp edge waiting to cut.
Hoffman leaned back, making himself comfortable before finally breaking the silence. âYou gonna warm up before we get moving, or do I have to listen to you bitch about the cold the whole drive?â His tone was teasing, but his eyes lingered a little too longâtaking in the way Strahmâs lips were still slightly parted from the rush of warm air, the way his fingers flexed against his palms.
Another small test. Another moment to gauge how far this push-and-pull would go.
Strahm smiled, pulling his hands away from his mouth. "You'll have to hear me bitch about a lot during this car ride. The traffic is bad right now." He said as he put his hand on the steering wheel, gripping it tightly.
He started to drive, his attention suddenly going to the road with a straight, serious face. He always took driving very serious, for some strange reason.
Peter tried to seem calm with Mark in the car, but seeing all the cars lined up in the street already made his blood boil. He didn't want to yell at all, but he just knew that would be hard.
"Holy fuck, that's a lot of cars..." He commented, speaking in a low voice that seemed like a grumble or a growl. His voice always sounded so demanding or angry, no matter what mood he was in.
Hoffman settled into his seat, letting his gaze drift lazily over the dashboard before inevitably landing on Strahmâs hands. He had a firm grip on the wheel, fingers tense, knuckles just shy of turning white.
Hoffman had seen Strahmâs hands in plenty of different settingsâclutching a gun, flipping through case files, clenched into fistsâbut there was something about watching them now, wrapped around the wheel with that quiet intensity, that held his attention a little too long.
The way his fingers flexed slightly every time he muttered under his breath, the subtle tremor of agitation when traffic didnât move fast enoughâit was strangely captivating. It made Hoffman wonder, just for a second, how that tension would feel if it werenât directed at the steering wheel.
âTry not to take it personally,â he said finally, tearing his gaze away and shifting in his seat. âPretty sure the traffic isnât out to get you.â His tone was light, almost mocking, but his fingers tapped idly against his own thighâlike he was keeping himself from saying something else.
"It's just so annoying. If people actually knew how to drive then we-" He suddenly stopped himself from talking, giving himself a moment to collect his thoughts. He couldn't go on a stupid rant about people driving. At leastânot in front of Mark.
His eyes slowly drifted towards Hoffman's fingers tapping against his thigh, picking up on the rhythm in his head quickly. He watched as if it was a mind blowing thing, like something he's never seen before. Obviously, he wasn't focused on the rhythm, he was focused on Mark.
The way he tapped so calmly like he was waiting to say something, the way his focus was on the grip of his hand, the way he was somehow so calm and collected on the outside, everything. All of it just seemed so perfect. Too perfect.
Peter soon snapped out of it as soon as he realized the cars around him were moving, and soon became fixated back on the road.
"This place better be good. If I drove in this traffic for no reason, I'll be pissed." He said, beginning to quietly tap the rhythm Mark had been tapping, using it as a way to calm down.
Suddenly, it hit him. He was driving Mark Hoffmanâthe guy who has been driving him insane all dayâout to eat with him. Sure, it wasn't fancy, but it was still something. The thought of this made him go back to biting his lip, leaving a dent over the previous one that just started going away.
Hoffmanâs fingers kept up their steady rhythm against his thigh, but his focus wasnât really on it anymore. His eyes had drifted back to Strahm, watching the way his jaw tensed, the way his grip tightened on the steering wheelâand most of all, the way he kept biting his lip, almost absentmindedly.
He let the moment stretch for a beat longer than necessary before speaking, voice smooth but just pointed enough to be intentional.
"Didn't take you for a nervous habit kind of guy, Strahm. Be careful there."
The words hung in the air, but the way Hoffmanâs gaze lingeredâjust for a secondâmade it clear heâd noticed. He settled back against the seat, watching for a reaction, wondering if Strahm would brush it off or if the slight shift in energy would throw him off course.
Strahm stopped tapping his fingers, looking over to Mark with a confused expression. It took him a moment to realize he was biting down on his lip. Again.
He quickly corrected himself, wiping his lip to see more blood transfer onto his hand. "Fuck..." He whispered to himself, staring down at the wipe of blood on the side of his hand before sighing and simply putting his hand back onto the wheel.
Peter never understood why he did stuff like this knowing it would later on hurt. And he especially didn't understand why he was doing it even more than usual. Normally, he would bite his lip while checking out a crime scene, or holding a gun, but never while simply being around a person.
He soon realized how much power Hoffman held when it came to himself. He could simple say something cocky and it would mess up his whole shift, or even the rest of his day.
"God fucking damn it." He said as he punched the steering wheel, causing his car to honk to the car in front of them.
Great, he did the one thing he was trying not to do. Get mad over a simple thing while in the car.
Hoffmanâs smirk faltered. Just for a second.
He hadnât expected that reactionâhadnât expected Strahm to actually hit the wheel like that. The sharp sound of the horn rang in his ears, but it was the frustration in Strahmâs voice that really caught him off guard.
For all the ways he liked to push, this wasnât what heâd been aiming for.
Hoffman shifted slightly, pulling his gaze away, tapping his fingers against his thigh againâbut this time, it wasnât intentional. It was just something to do. Something to focus on instead of the way Strahmâs knuckles were going white against the steering wheel.
"Forget it," he muttered, quieter than before. "Didnât mean anything by it."
For once, he let the moment pass without another remark. No teasing, no smug little comments. Just silenceâsave for the hum of the car engine and the faint, rhythmic tapping of his fingers.
Was this guilt? He felt guilty for that remark, and Hoffman rarely cares about others like that.
He suddenly felt anxious. He tried to remain suave but his hands shook ever so slightly as he loosened his tie. It was getting slightly hard to breathe.
Strahm had gone completely silent at this point, taking all his anger out by gripping the wheel. If he knew that he would've fucked up the stuff they had going, he would've tried to prevent it.
But he couldn't.
He soon saw the sandwich shop, realizing it was closed. He went through all of this for it to be closed. He sighed and turned into the parking lot anyway, parking the car to think of another place they could go to.
"So... the shop is closed today, I guess." Peter said, his voice quiet and low as if he was confessing something. He felt somewhat bad. He felt bad for taking Hoffman out of work just to find out their plans wouldn't even end up working.
"We could... go somewhere else. Or go back." He paused as he thought of more ideas. "Or we could sit here and talk about the case." He said as a last choice.
Instead of looking over to Hoffman, he stared down at his lap. It didn't feel right to look at him after what just happened. He felt... embarrassed in a way. He knew that if he reacted to something with anger, it would've changed everything. Yet, he did it anyways. He just let it happen.
Hoffman stayed quiet for a moment, letting his eyes settle on Strahm. Really looking at him.
The way his shoulders were still tense, the way his fingers flexed against the steering wheel like he was holding himself back.
Hoffman tapped his fingers one last time before letting his hand still in a gentle grasp against his thigh. He wasnât in a rush to speak.
Instead, he just watched.
There was a strange feeling in Hoffmanâs chest, something he didnât quite have the words for.
After another beat of silence, he finally spoke. "Well," he drawled, tilting his head slightly, "weâve already wasted this much time. Might as well make it worth it."
His voice was even, but there was an edge of something unreadable in it.
Hoffman wasnât sure what he expected Strahm to say next. But he was sure of one thingâhe wasnât ready to leave yet.
"Mhm.." Peter hummed in response, taking his hands off the wheel to try and seem more calm and relaxed. His attention turned to Mark very soon, his eyes hovering over his whole body before meeting his eyes.
He had a strange feeling in his chest every time he looked at Mark. It suddenly felt heavy and felt it got harder to breathe.
The tension in the car was so much more in the office. The way they were much closer than before, the way they had no where else to look but each other, it was all too much. Peter removed his jacket, folding it neatly before setting it down in his lap. Though, he never broke eye contact.
"Have you got anything about the case? Any suspects, any leads, anything? Have you heard anything from the DNA test yet?" Peter decided it would be best to ask a good amount of questions. Then, it would be easier for him to seem less.. awkward and nervous.
Work seemed to be the only thing keeping him sane right now.
Hoffman didnât miss the way Strahm folded his jacketâcareful, deliberate, like he needed to keep his hands occupied. It was almost amusing, the way he tried to seem at ease when everything about him screamed tightly wound.
He let the moment stretch, saying nothing at first. Just watching.
âCouple of things,â he said finally, voice level, unreadable, clearing his throat. âDNA test came back inconclusive. No solid matches.â
Hoffman let that sit between them, waiting to see how Strahm would react.
Mark shifted in his seatâ just enough to take up more space, his arm settling on the center console. Closer.
âThereâs one lead,â Hoffman continued, deliberately unhurried. âGuy who fits the profileâex-con, history of violence, used to work in mechanical engineering.â
Another pause. Then, finally, Hoffman turned his head, meeting his gaze fully.
âYou all right, Strahm?â His voice was smooth, casual, but he knew exactly what he was doing.
Hoffman could feel itâthe tension, the weight pressing down on the space between them. And he liked it.
At first his maintained eye contact, but that proved to be too much for him so he backed off, clearing his throat again.
âIâm not trying to make you nervous.â A lie, and also deflecting some of his own feelings.
"What? I'm fine. I'm not nervous at all, Hoffman." Peter responded, his words sharp and aggressive. He didn't realize until now how tense and nervous his body language was. He shoulder tensed, his jaw clenched, his hands always forming a fist, everything was not normal.
He hated the power Mark held over him. It made him so angry to the point of nausea. Every time Mark did anything better than him, he got jealousâangry. Every time Mark looked at him, he got nervous. He hated the way he just let this happen.
Strahm took a deep breath, placing his arm right next to Hoffman's. "Well, at least we've got something. It's better than what we had before." He said, his voice was very monotoneâdry even.
"I should probably call Perez soon and tell her about this..." Peter said, tapping his finger to a different rhythm than before. It was more aggressive and repetitive, showing both his anger and anxiety in one rhythm.
The way his and Mark's arms were so close made him feel something he couldn't explain. It made it hard to breathe, as if someone were to suck all the air out of his lungs.
[ ooc text : i wrote the second part of this while listening to jealousy, jealousy by olivia rodrigo. feels important to share. ]
Hoffman watched him carefully, his expression unreadable. Strahmâs words were sharp, but they didnât match the way his body was betraying himâso tense he looked ready to snap. Hoffman could practically feel the heat radiating off him, the way his energy buzzed with something dangerously close to frustration. Or something else.
His eyes flicked down to their arms, barely a breath apart. It would take nothing to close that distance. To shift just slightly and press against him, just to see what Strahm would do.
Then Strahm mentioned Perez.
Hoffmanâs fingers, which had been resting idly against his thigh, curled inward before he abruptly moved his arm away, leaning slightly toward the car door. His expression didnât change, but something in his body language didâsomething colder.
"Yeah," he muttered. "You probably should."
Hoffman clenched his jaw, staring straight ahead as if the windshield suddenly held something more interesting than Strahm beside him. The mention of Perez shouldnât bother him, but it did. He knew how much Strahm trusted herâhow easily they worked together, how she could read him in ways Hoffman couldnât.
He didnât like it.
His fingers twitched against his leg, resisting the urge to match Strahmâs rhythm like before. Instead, he let the silence stretch, letting the distance he created sit heavy between them.
âWant some space to call her?â
Strahm noticed how Hoffman tensed as soon as he mentioned Perez, a look of confusion quickly forming on his face. Why did Mark get so weird every time he mentioned Lindsey? Why did he act so weird whenever she was at his desk? It made no sense.
He looked down to see his arm moved away, a feeling of defeat washing over him. They were so close, it was perfect. But clearly, he messed something up to changed the tension they had going for them.
"Uhm, no... I'll just call her later today. She's probably busy anyway, and I don't want to interrupt her." Peter said, slowly removing his arm and placing it onto his lap. He stared at Hoffman, noticing how he would rather stare at nothing then stare at him. Why did it change so quickly?
He coughed, trying to stop the silence between the two. "What should we do?" He asked, trying to use a tone that suggested that he was open to anything, work related or not. At this point, he'd be willing to do anything to get out of this uncomfortable situation.
Strahm started to pick at the sides of his fingernails, messing up his already rough looking fingers. He watched as a small amount of blood formed on his finger once he peeled some skin off, watching it build up but not drip.
It was better to watch than continuing to watch Mark stare out the windshield as if it was much more interesting.
Hoffman exhaled, letting the tension ease from his shoulders as he settled back into his seat. His arm found its way back to the consoleânot quite touching Strahmâs, but close enough that it wasnât a full retreat anymore.
"Alright," he said, tilting his head slightly as if considering their options. "We could hit up that shitty diner a few blocks over. The one with the terrible coffee but decent fries." He shot Strahm a sideways glance, a ghost of a smirk tugging at his lips. "Unless youâre too good for a place that serves their food on plastic trays."
It wasnât just about food anymore, and they both knew it. Hoffmanâs posture was more open again, his voice lacking the sharp edge from earlier.
"And hey," he added, his smirk sharpening just slightly, "maybe if you're lucky, the waitress will think weâre on a date and give you the check. Since, y'know, you were so eager to take me out in the first place."
It was a joke, but not a denial. And the way he looked at Strahm when he said itâsteady, watching for a reactionâmade it clear he wasnât just filling the silence.
âOr maybe one of us can flash our badge and make her feel bad.â He winked. A soft, brief action.
A smirk appeared on Strahm's face, looking up from his hand and back to Hoffman. "I'm fine with the shitty diner, I guess." He said with a hint of sarcasm in his voice at the end.
"And I think we should go with the second idea. Flashing our badges is better than her thinking we're a gay couple." Peter said as he began to start driving, but this time only with one arm. Keeping his arm next to Mark's felt... right.
He began driving out of the parking space, making a promise in his mind that he wouldn't get visibly angry at the people on the road. He would hate to ruin the tension for the hundredth time today. Peter bit down on his lip slightly, mainly doing it to keep his focus on the road.
Peter took a deep breath as soon as he got on the road, trying to seem like he didn't even care about the traffic, but he did. He really did. He actually cared about everything right now. The traffic, the way Hoffman's arm was right next to his, the fact he was driving him to a diner, everything. It all was so much more than it would normally be, but he stayed calm.
At least, he tried to stay calm.
Hoffman stood just outside the diner's entrance, the neon light flickering against his skin, casting him in a glow of red and gold. He flexed his fingers at his sides, still feeling the lingering warmth from where their arms had brushed in the car. It was stupidâinsignificant, really. But it had made something stir deep in his chest, something he wasnât ready to acknowledge.
He glanced over his shoulder, watching Strahm still sitting in the driverâs seat, his fingers tapping against the wheel. For a moment, Hoffman just⊠looked at him. The usual irritation was there, sure, but it was layered with something else, something heavier. He exhaled, shaking his head to himself before rapping his knuckles lightly against the glass door.
"You coming?" His voice was lower than he intended, softer, almost coaxing. He hesitated, then let a smirk tug at his lips. "Or do you just like staring at me from a distance?"
He turned before he could catch Strahmâs expression, stepping inside the diner. The scent of coffee and fryer grease wrapped around him, familiar and grounding. Still, that warmth from the car lingered, settling deep in his chest. As much as he tried to ignore it, deny it, there was no shaking the truthâsomething between them had shifted. And for once, Hoffman wasnât sure if he wanted to fight it.
Peter sighed before slipping his coat on, finally leaving his car. He made sure to lock his car before walking over to the diner with the neon flickering lights. This is not where he exactly wanted to take Mark, but guess that's what he had to deal with for now.
He stepped inside, walking past Hoffman to a small booth all the way in the corner of the diner. He sat in the seat against the wall, waiting patiently for Mark to sit across from him.
It was weird to think about. Taking the man he hated out to get food. Sure, he invited him to talk about 'work' , but they both knew that wasn't going to actually happen. At least, not the whole time.
"I don't really know if I'll eat anything here. Hell, they probably cook dead rats into the food based on what people say about it." Peter said, looking around to see most employees sitting on their phones or talking. Sure, this wasn't ideal, but it would work just fine.
After all, he didn't want things to seem romantic. Peter didn't like Mark that way.
At least, that's what he told himself.
Hoffman leaned back against the cracked vinyl seat, drumming his fingers against the tabletop as he glanced over the laminated menu. It was sticky. Of course it was. He barely looked at the options before setting it aside.
"Dead rats or not, Iâm getting a shake," he said, flagging down a half-interested waitress. "Chocolate. Extra thick." His voice was smooth, deliberate, like he was making a point. He didn't care if the place was a dumpâhe was here, and he was going to enjoy something.
Once the waitress walked off, he leaned forward slightly, resting his forearms on the table. His gaze flicked over Strahm, taking in the tension in his shoulders, the way he was still pretending like this wasnât something. It was almost endearing.
"You know, if you keep looking that uncomfortable, people are gonna think I dragged you here against your will." His smirk was slow, knowing. "Or worse, that this actually is a date and you're just playing hard to get."
He let that sit between them, watching for the reaction. Strahm always had a tell, no matter how much he tried to hide it. And Hoffman? He lived for it.
Peter hummed in response to Mark, quickly shaking his head once the waiter looked at him with a look of boredom and impatience, waiting for an order. He sighed as soon as the waiter walked off, shutting his eyes for a moment before opening them to meet Mark leaned more towards him.
"I would way rather have them think you kidnapped me or something. I don't want people to think we're on a date. Or that I'm gay." As soon as he spoke those last four words, it hurt something in him. He didn't understand why though. He wasn't gay. That's what he's been telling everyone for years.
These feelings were so confusing. He hated Hoffman, he knew he did. Something was... different. Usually, he would be tearing his hair out by nowâbut it was different now. He was less angry.
Strahm tried to relax his shoulder, but failed. He hated how much he seemed so nervous and shut off when he wanted to seem relaxed. He wanted to seem more normal, but that was hard when he wasn't normal even when hating Mark.
Hoffman let out a quiet snort, shaking his head slightly as he leaned back again, giving Strahm just a bit more spaceâbut not much.
âRelax, Strahm,â he muttered, voice low and edged with amusement. âNo one in here gives a shit about what you are.â His fingers drummed idly against the table as he watched the way Peterâs shoulders stayed locked in place, the tension rolling off of him in waves.
That reactionâthat was interesting. It wasnât just irritation or the usual disdain that Strahm carried whenever he was around him. This was something else. Hoffman bit his lip in thought.
Hoffman tilted his head slightly, his eyes scanning Strahmâs face, catching the way his mouth pressed into a tight line, the way his fingers curled against his thigh like he was trying to hold something back.
He could push. It would be easy. A well-placed comment, a teasing smirk, just enough of a prod to see what would happen if he hit the right nerve.
But, for once, he didnât.
Instead, he exhaled, shaking his head as he reached for his glass of water, taking a slow sip before setting it back down. âBesides, if I did kidnap you, Iâd make sure you at least got something better than a damn sandwich out of it.â
The words were casual, thrown out with just enough humor to make it unclear whether he was joking or not. But underneath, it was a testâa different kind of test. Would Strahm push back? Laugh it off? Or would he keep unraveling right in front of him?
Peter felt like he was melting away. He was so focused on what other people around him thought. People he would most likely never even see again. The idea of a random stranger thinking something that wasn't true made him freak out. What if he actually saw them again and they thought he was something he wasn't? What if that made people avoid him? He hated it.
"Yeah. Sure." He mumbled, looking over Mark's shoulder for a second to scan the whole diner and all the workers. Another habit he had to avoid a situation. This time, the situation was right in front of himâstaring with a smirk that showed that he was clearly interested by Peter's reactions to things.
He looked down at his lap, fixing the previous creases he made in his pants from gripping them. It was weird, he felt a sudden need to look nice. Normally, if he was at work, he never cared. It was just work after all. Today thoughâit was different. Very different.
"Oh, so if you were to kidnap someone, you would cook them a full meal?" Strahm asked with a hint of sarcasm in his voice, trying to come across as more calm and relaxed. His tone was calm, but his body language was completely different. His body language resembled a stray cat whenever you try to pet it. Tense, intimidating, aggressive.
He didn't mean to come off like this, but it was better than coming off nice, or worseâromantic. Which sucked, because deep down there was something going on. Something other than hate or anger. But different from what he felt around Lindsey...
Hoffman let out a low chuckle, shaking his head as he leaned back slightly, arms crossing over his chest. âWhat, you think Iâd half-ass it?â His smirk remained, but his gaze was steady, watching every nervous shift, every flicker of hesitation in Strahmâs expression.
Hoffman tilted his head slightly. âIâm just saying, if I were the kind of guy to kidnap someone, Iâd at least put in the effort. Full meal. Maybe some wine. Make it a whole experience.â His voice was even, casual, but the weight behind his words lingered in the space between them.
He let the thought settle for a moment before reaching for his drink, taking another slow sip. âNot that youâd appreciate it,â he added, tone bordering on dry amusement. âYou strike me as the type to complain about the wine pairing.â
He was still testing, still pushingâjust enough to see how Strahm would react.
"Well, I believe that it would be a bit stupid to make a full meal. You don't want the person you kidnapped to get attached to you. That'll just cause so many more problems." Strahm said as if he had experience in stuff like this. Obviously, he didn't. It was more of the fact that he's dealt with multiple situations like this.
Peter's voice was less aggressive, finally showing that some of the tension and stress had left his body. It felt like heavy sandbags being lifted off his shoulders, giving him the ability to finally seem a bit more confinement rather than stuck in his own skin.
"Of course I complain about wine pairing. It's basically everything when it comes to a nice meal! Tell me, would you pair a glass of Pinot Noir with a steak? No. You would pair something like Cabernet Sauvignon." It was obvious he was good at this subject. Which you probably wouldn't guess by getting one simple look at him.
Peter checked his watch, quickly looking back up to Mark. "We should probably head back soon." He said, putting his coat over his arms as quickly, basically preparing himself to leave in a quick amount of time.
Hoffman raised an eyebrow, watching Strahm with something between amusement and intrigue. The shift in his demeanor didnât go unnoticedâhis voice had lost some of that earlier edge, his posture a little less rigid. It was subtle, but it was there.
âDidnât take you for a wine guy,â Hoffman mused, tilting his head slightly. âThatâs a real specific take for someone who spends most of his days running on burnt coffee.â His smirk lingered, but there was something else in his gaze nowâsomething considering.
He didnât know why it was so damn fascinating, watching Strahm loosen up, even just a little. Maybe it was because he knew how rare it was. Strahm was all sharp edges and tension, always coiled like a spring. Seeing him talk about something so mundane, something he actually seemed passionate about, was... different.
Hoffman exhaled through his nose, glancing at his own watch before rolling his shoulders back. âYeah, wouldnât want anyone thinking we actually enjoyed this.â The words were teasing, but there was an undertone to themâsomething unspoken but lingering.
As Strahm pulled on his coat with that same urgency, Hoffman just watched him for a moment before finally moving to stand. He didnât rush. He didnât need to. Strahm was already rattled enough without him adding to it.
But still, as they stepped outside into the cold, he let the silence settle just long enough to make Strahm wonder what he was thinkingâbefore finally breaking it with a low, amused murmur:
âYou talk a big game about wine pairings, but next time, Iâm picking the place.â
He paused for a moment, thinking if he should even offer but he did, anyways: âWant me to drive the way back?â He asked, staring ahead.
"Really? I'm a pretty big wine guy. Me and Perez tend to talk about it a lot, I guess you just don't hear us." He found himself bringing up Lindsey again. He knew that it wasn't a good idea. He knew that everything would shift once again after bringing her up. Yet, he still did it.
He sighed before walking over to the waiter, putting down a random ten dollar bill from his wallet before walking outside into the cold with Hoffman. The cold hit him like a punch, causing him to exhale a deep breath.
"Well, I wasn't going to bring you to a place where they pair wine to discuss work, Mark." The comment was supposed to come off playful, but instead came off harsh. He always struggled to control his tone, which was the reason he spoke with such a monotone, bored voice.
Peter unlocked the car doors, looking over to Mark. "Yeah, sure. It'll be better for you to drive anyway." He said, getting in the car before discussing anything else. He would rather die than stand a moment longer in the cold weather.
Hoffmanâs jaw tightened at the mention of Perez. Of course, Strahm had to bring her up. He always did, like it was some kind of reflex. And every time, it hit Hoffman the same wayâan irritating little twist in his gut that he couldn't quite shake.
He didnât say anything right away, just let his eyes linger on Strahm as they stepped out into the cold. The wind bit at his skin, but he barely registered it. He was too busy watching the way Strahm hunched his shoulders, the way he exhaled sharply like the cold was trying to rip the breath from his lungs.
Hoffman scoffed at the comment about work, catching the way Strahm avoided looking directly at him. Yeah, sure. You werenât gonna bring me to a place like that for work. But youâd bring Perez, wouldnât you?
He didnât voice the thought. Instead, he followed Strahm into the car, sliding into the driverâs seat with a little more force than necessary. The second he started the engine, the heater kicked on, filling the space with warmthâbut Hoffman still felt that simmering irritation sitting low in his chest.
He glanced at Strahm. Something about him made his fingers tighten on the steering wheel. âYou talk about wine like some expert, but I bet if Perez were here, youâd have some bullshit poetic thing to say about it,â he muttered, keeping his voice level, but there was an unmistakable sharpness to it.
He wasnât sure what he wanted out of that commentâmaybe just to see Strahmâs reaction, to make him squirm the way Hoffman felt himself doing internally. Because for all his control, for all his carefully placed remarks, something about Strahm had a way of slipping under his skin. And it pissed him off. Well, he didn't know if he was more pissed off at that or the fact that he didn't understand why he was pissed off in the first place.
Peter put his hands between his knees in an attempt to warm them up, staring down as he did. He couldn't bring himself to look at Mark. He couldn't bring himself to even quickly glance at him. He already felt everything shift as soon as he brought up Lindsey.
Just as he was in his thoughts, Mark spoke.
The words stabbed him, causing his stomach to turn. Not out of anxiety, but rather anger. It made him so angry knowing that Hoffman hated Perez for no real reason. It made his blood boil. She wasn't a bad detective, she was kind, she never came off as aggressive, she was so perfect. Yet, Mark found a way to hate her.
"What do you mean, Hoffman? What is that supposed to mean." The first time was a question. The second time was in demand. A demand for answers. He was tired of how he always found a way to get mad at Lindsey when she has never done anything to him.
Strahm still avoided eye contact, but it was clear that he was angry. Even without the look of rage and hatred in his eyes, anyone could still tell he was angry. The way his words became sharp and intense again, the way his body tensed up when he spoke, the way his hands turned into fist in seconds.
It was all too obvious.
Hoffman didnât answer right away. He just drummed his fingers against the steering wheel, exhaling through his nose as if Strahmâs reaction wasnât exactly what he was hoping for.
But it was.
The sharpness in his voice, the way his body locked upâHoffman knew that anger well. He knew how it made Strahmâs breath come a little quicker, how it made him grip at things too tightly. And maybe it was fucked up, but he liked knowing he could pull that reaction from him so easily.
âWhat do I mean?â Hoffman repeated, dragging the words out slow, testing the weight of them on his tongue. His gaze flicked toward Strahm, watching the way he kept his eyes pointed anywhere but at him. Coward.
âI mean exactly what I said. You donât talk about me the way you talk about her.â His voice was even, but there was something under itâsomething Strahm wasnât going to like if he looked too closely.
His grip on the wheel tightened. âAnd donât pretend like you donât know what I mean,â he added, lower this time, but more pointed. âEvery time she comes up, you get allââ He waved a hand vaguely, knowing Strahm would get it. âLike sheâs so perfect. Like she can do no wrong. So yeah, maybe I donât like her, Strahm. Maybe I donât like the way you talk about her.â
His jaw clenched. He hadnât meant to say that last part, but now it was out there, sitting in the space between them. And for once, he was the one who looked away first.
Peter's breathing was quick and heavy, as if he was holding back so many things. Which, he was. Instead of yelling, he let Mark finish. He let him finish his ranting while holding eye contact. His eyes were angry, hateful, and disappointed. His eyes held a look that was almost unreadable, yet so readable at the same time.
He hated hearing these words. He hated hearing about someone not liking Lindsey. He hated listening to someone not thinking she was perfect. He hated hearing that Mark hated her. He hated Mark.
He felt his head began to hurt from the rage and all the thoughts piling up at once. He couldn't keep them hidden much longer. He had to express them somehow.
"What's the true reason you can't handle me talking about someone else? What is it, Hoffman? What makes you, a grown man who I haven't known most of my life, crave the attention I give to someone else? What makes you feel the need to act like an angry pathetic dog who craves attention? What is it?" He spoke, his words spilling out. He couldn't stop now.
"Why would I need to talk about you the way I talk about her? Do you believe you are more important than Lindsey in my mind? Do you truly believe you are better than her?" He thought for a moment, collecting his ability to breathe before continuing.
"I talk about her that way because she is perfect. She does no wrong. When has she ever wronged you? When has she wronged me? When has she wronged anyone? You can't think of a single example, can you? That's because she hasn't wronged anyone. You have no real reason to hate her other than jealousy, which doesn't even make sense because I could've sworn you hated me just yesterday. Why are you suddenly so jealous over someone I've known for years?"
He stopped himself, but his body language showed how angry he still was. His eyes, his hands, his shoulders, everything. It just showed how angry he was. Even then, that didn't do it justice.
Hoffmanâs grip on the steering wheel was so tight that his knuckles were white, the leather groaning under his fingers as he tried to force the anger back down. The air between them was thick with the tension, and it only got worse as Strahmâs wordsâsharp, biting, full of that damn righteous angerâsettled in the car, suffocating everything else.
Every word from Strahm twisted something inside him, but it wasnât just anger. It was jealousy.
Hoffman could feel the heat radiating from him, the sharpness in his voice, his body practically vibrating with the intensity of it. Jealous of Lindsey. Thatâs what it was, isnât it? But no. He couldnât admit that. Not out loud. Not even to himself.
His jaw locked so tight that it hurt, and it was taking all his self-control not to lash out. But as much as he hated admitting it, he wasnât just angry. No, it was more complicated than that.
"Really, Strahm?" Hoffmanâs voice was low, too low. It felt like it came from somewhere deep inside him, almost like he was letting something slip without meaning to. âYou wanna act like Iâm just throwing a fit, like Iâm jealous?â His words came out rough, but there was something else thereâsomething softer. A pull, just beneath the anger. âYou think I care about her more than you?â
He took a slow breath, still staring at the road, forcing himself to focus on the sound of his heartbeat. It wasnât enough to calm the storm inside him. His eyes flickered briefly to Strahm, watching the way he held himself, how tense and wound up he was. That tightness in his jaw, those clenched fists. Hoffman hated it. But he also liked it. Too much.
âIf I cared about her that much,â Hoffman continued, his voice a little quieter now, almost to the point where Strahm had to lean in to hear him, âI wouldnât be here. Wouldnât be here with you, would I?â
His pulse quickened as he said it, that same rush of heat climbing up his neck. He hated how it soundedâtoo much like he was admitting something, too much like he was being vulnerable when heâd never let anyone see that side of him.
His hands tightened on the wheel again, but it wasnât just anger this time. His thoughts were swirling, clouded with the weight of what he couldnât say. Couldnât admit.
He glanced at Strahm again, eyes narrowing, but this time it was different. He couldnât look away. There was something else there nowâsomething raw, something almost intimate in the way Strahm looked at him.
âIs that what you want, Peter?â Hoffmanâs voice was softer now, barely a whisper, a challenge. âYou really think Iâm jealous of her? Or is it that you just canât handle the idea of me being here instead of her?â
His heart thudded in his chest, the words spilling out before he could stop them. His stomach twisted. Why couldnât he stop? Why did it feel like something had shifted, like the whole conversation was moving toward something else entirely?
The silence between them stretched out, the only sound the hum of the engine and the beating of their hearts. Hoffman wasnât sure if Strahm could feel it tooâthe way the air had thickened with unspoken words. The way it felt like they were suddenly standing at the edge of something they werenât quite ready for.
But it was too late. The tension was already there, and Hoffman knew, without a doubt, that it wasnât just about Lindsey anymore.
And he hated himself for that.
Peter suddenly felt the tension for once, actually backing off. Something told him he needed to back off this situation before he said anything else or anything worse. He suddenly, for some reason, felt bad. It didn't make sense though. He shouldn't feel bad. He had a point, Mark did seem jealous of Lindsey. But did he maybe take it too far?
He took a breath through his nose and out his mouth. "Mark, I'm not saying you're jealous, I'm saying it seems like it. Every time I mention Lindsey, you act like it's the end of the damn world. You get all tense and angry as if you hate her for simply being in my life."
He spoke as if he hated the idea of Hoffman being jealous, but he really didn't. He enjoyed the idea of how he could ruin someones mood just by simply bringing up one person.
"All I want to know is why. Why does your mood change? Why do you get so tense? Why do you hate the idea that I think she's perfect?" Strahm poured out his words as if his mouth was a faucet for his brain.
The air between them was too much. It was thick, it was overwhelming. It drove him so insane how angry they both were. All he could hear was his own heartbeat in his ears.
"I just need to know. Why don't you like Lindsey?" He wasn't demanding anymore. He was pleading. He wanted to know why because he couldn't handle watching how he looked at her with such anger and jealousy every time they spoke at work.
Hoffmanâs grip on the steering wheel was relentless as Strahmâs words hung in the air, thick and heavy, pressing down on him like a weight he couldnât shake off. The space between them felt suffocating, as if every word Strahm said was just making the tension worse. But something in the way Strahm spoke caught him off guardâthere was a vulnerability there, a softness to his tone that Mark wasnât used to. Pleading. It had always been anger before, but now it was something else. Something that made Hoffman feel like he was walking a razorâs edge.
"You really wanna know, Peter?" Hoffmanâs voice was low, rough with something that wasnât anger anymore. It was too much to admit, too much to say, but it was right there, clawing at the back of his throat.
He took a breath, feeling the heat of Strahmâs words pressing into him. Mark wasnât ready to give in, not yet. He couldnât be. But damn, it was hard to ignore how his chest tightened when Strahm spoke with that tone. Pleading, vulnerable, asking for answers he couldnât give. Hoffman couldnât explain it, but there was something in Strahmâs eyesâthe way he looked at him, the way his words tangled up like a question and a challenge all in oneâthat made him want to say everything. To tell him the truth, to finally admit what had been gnawing at him all this time.
Markâs eyes flickered to Strahm, a quick glance that lingered too long. He tried to look away, but couldnât. He just... couldnât.
âI donât hate her,â Hoffman finally muttered, voice laced with frustration, but there was something deeper in it too. Something that was hard for him to articulate. âItâs not about her. Itâs not about her at all.â
The words came out harsher than he meant, but it wasnât about Lindsey, was it? It was about Peter. And that was something Hoffman wasnât ready to face.
âYou wanna know why my mood changes when you talk about her?â Hoffmanâs voice dropped even lower, almost a growl. âItâs because Iâm hereâwith youâand I hear you talk about her like sheâs some saint. Like sheâs perfect. Like sheâs everything you need, everything you want. And I canât stand it.â
The words slipped out before he could stop them, raw and unfiltered. His chest heaved, and his heart was beating too fast, like it was trying to escape. He could feel the shift, the intensity of the moment pulling them both into a place neither of them were ready for. But Hoffman couldnât help it. He couldnât keep it in any longer.
He turned his head slowly, eyes locking with Strahmâs, searching for somethingâanythingâin his face that would tell him he was still in control, that he hadnât just said too much.
âYou think Iâm jealous of her? Maybe... maybe Iâm just jealous that she gets to have you, and I donât.â
There it was. The words that were always just beneath the surface. He could feel the heat rising in his face, the tightness in his chest, and the way his hands were trembling ever so slightly. He hated how weak it made him feel, how vulnerable.
âBut you donât get it, do you?â Hoffman continued, his voice almost a whisper now, the anger simmering just beneath the surface. âI donât care if sheâs perfect, Peter. Itâs you. Itâs you I canât stand when you talk about her like that. Because itâs not about her. Itâs about... us.â
The words hung in the air, fragile and heavy. He hated how much they revealed, how much of himself he had just let slip. But there was no taking them back now. And as much as he tried to hold it all together, his chest still ached with that unspoken truthâhe had crossed a line he wasnât sure he could walk back from.
The silence stretched between them, thick and suffocating, until it felt like they were both drowning in it. Hoffman wasnât sure what came next. He wasnât sure if he wanted to know. But it was too late to pull back now.
Strahm stared blankly at Hoffman, his angry gaze soon becoming soft. Instead of cutting him off, he listened quietly. He didn't react in any form, though. It didn't feel right. Even a simple nod felt wrong. That would make it seem like he agreed with his feelings, but he didn't. He hadn't connected those feelings inside him just yet.
He wanted until he was silent and the silence was basically drowning the both of them before finally speaking. "Mark... I- I don't know what to say." He said, his mind not fully grasping everything that was said. It still hung in the air, driving him to insanity every second. He wasn't gay. He knew it.
"I'm not... well, I'm not gay. And Lindsey doesn't have me, no one has me." His words came off more aggressive than he wished. "Not even you, Hoffman. You don't have me." Those words weren't supposed to come out. He didn't want to come off as mean. The emotions were just too much to handle, though. Too much to care about how his words came across.
"There is no us. The only us we have going on is a work situation, Mark." He hesitated saying his name. "There can't be any of us. I'm sorry, but that's not who I am. And I'm not going to lead you on and pretend that's who I am. I clearly already lead you on enough..."
The last part came out as a whisper, like he was ashamed. Embarrassed even. He never felt bad, but he did this time. He didn't know why, but he did. He felt horrible, actually. It sat so uncomfortably in his stomach he couldn't help but almost gag. Why did he feel so bad?
Why did he regret everything he said?
Hoffmanâs chest tightened as Strahm spoke, each word hitting him like a physical blow. He hadnât expected Peter to say any of thatâhe hadnât expected any of it, really. But the sting of the words, the sharpness in Peterâs voice, felt like a blade to his gut. He hadnât thought that hearing Peter reject him would hurt this much. But it did. It hurt more than he ever thought possible.
When Strahm said those words, âIâm not gayâ, it felt like the ground beneath Mark's feet shifted. It felt like everything he had just laid out, all the things he had been thinking, sayingâfeelingâwas being slammed down in front of him like some hard truth he wasnât ready to hear.
And then the next partââNot even you, Hoffmanââstung deeper. The way Peter said it wasnât meant to be cruel, but it felt like it. Markâs hand clenched into a fist on the steering wheel, knuckles white, as if the tension in his body might somehow find an outlet through sheer force.
But it didnât.
He felt the weight of Peterâs words sitting heavily in the car between them, suffocating him, making him feel smaller than he ever had before. He didnât know what to say to thatâhow to fight back against something so⊠absolute. So final.
Still, there was something in Peterâs tone that shifted, something quieter, something almost⊠regretful. Embarrassed.
Hoffmanâs heart slammed in his chest as Peter whispered the last part, âI clearly already lead you on enough.â
For a moment, Mark couldnât breathe. It was like the air itself had been sucked out of the car, and he was left grasping at whatever was left.
No, Peter didnât want him. He didnât want this.
But there was that whisper of regret that stayed with Hoffman, swirling in his mind. He could see it in Peterâs eyesâthe way they shifted away from him, unable to meet his gaze. And the way he apologized, despite not wanting to admit anything, despite the layers of denial. There was something there. Something Mark wasnât sure if he wanted to understand, but he had to. It ate at him.
He slowly turned his head, his jaw clenching as he held Peterâs gaze, searching for the truth beneath his words.
âI donât need you to lead me on, Peter,â Hoffman said, his voice softer, almost gentle in a way that didnât quite fit the angry edge he usually carried. âIâm not asking for that. But you canât just pretend like I donât see whatâs going on. You donât get to throw this all away just because itâs easier for you.â
The words came out before he could stop them, and though they werenât meant to sound desperate, something in his voice cracked. Something in him trembled under the weight of what he was saying.
âIâm not gonna lie to you, Peter.â He paused, trying to catch his breath, his chest tight. âI... I donât know what the hellâs going on either. But I know Iâm not just some... work colleague to you. Not anymore.â His voice dropped lower. âI see it in the way you act around me. I feel it. Hell, Iâve felt it for a while now.â
He hesitated, staring out the windshield, before glancing back at Peter. His eyes were darker now, a fire simmering beneath them. He couldnât stop himself. He was burning up inside.
âIâm not perfect either, Peter,â he continued, the vulnerability creeping in. âBut donât sit there and pretend like thereâs nothing between us. Youâre not as cold as you think you are.â
It was out before he could stop it, his voice barely above a whisper, but there was a finality to it that lingered in the air.
The silence hung between them again, but this time, it was different. It wasnât just an empty, suffocating thing. It was charged. And as much as Mark hated to admit it, the way Peter wouldnât meet his eyesâthe way he avoided him nowâtold him everything he needed to know.
Peter stared down at his lap, picking at his cuticles to try and distract himself. That was working until Mark said the words. The words that killed everything inside of him. The words that stabbed him in the stomach. The words that made his blood boil.
' You donât get to throw this all away just because itâs easier for you. '
These words pained him. But not in a way that upset him, but in a way that angered him. He wasn't throwing anything away. He tried being nice, but clearly that didn't work. He wasn't gay.
"Listen, Hoffman. I've already told you, I'm not gay. I've never been gay, I've never though I was gay, I'm not gay. I'm not going to let yourself continue to believe that I am. It's not only hurting me, but also hurting you. At this point, it feels like you're leading yourself on."
The words came out in a harsh tone, his words aggressive and mean. He barked back like a dog. In this situation, he was like an angry, lost dog. A dog who needed comfort deep down.
He didn't want to make the situation worse, but it was hard with everything Mark said. the words ' But donât sit there and pretend like thereâs nothing between us. Youâre not as cold as you think you are. ' echoed throughout his head, causing his blood to just boil more.
Soon, he got to a point in anger where he wasn't even angry at Mark as much anymore, it was mostly anger towards himself.
He looked up to look out the windshield, sighing before opening his mouth to speak. His words came out in a low whisper as if he was checking in with himself.
"I'm not gay..."
Mark's eyes locked onto Peter's face, searching for somethingâanythingâto tell him that this wasnât over. But it was clear Peter wasnât giving him anything, just sitting there, picking at his cuticles, trying to hold it all together. The tension in the air was suffocating, and Mark could feel every inch of it tightening around him, his chest growing heavier with each passing second.
When Peter spoke, his voice was sharp, the words like a slap to the face. âIâm not gay. Iâve never been gay, Iâve never thought I was gay, Iâm not gay.â The rapid fire of it made Mark flinch, even though heâd expected it. But it still hurt, hearing Peter say it like that. Like it was something to be ashamed of.
Hoffmanâs jaw clenched, and he leaned forward slightly, his voice low but cutting. âIâm not asking you to be anything youâre not, Peter. But you canât sit there and act like thereâs nothing between us when you know damn well there is.â
Peterâs wordsâthe harshness in his tone, the way he barked back, like a wounded animalâhit a nerve that Mark didnât know existed. But then something else shifted in Peterâs voice, something softer, quieter, that Mark almost didnât catch. Peter looked out the windshield, and Mark could see the way his shoulders slumped slightly, like the anger was draining out of him, replaced with something else. Something less certain.
Mark leaned back in his seat, eyes narrowing, not willing to let Peter get away with this. "Youâre not fooling me, Strahm. Youâre not as cold as you act. You can say all you want that youâre not interested in meâIâm not stupid, I get it. But donât act like I donât see whatâs going on when you look at me like that." His voice cracked with frustration, but he didnât stop. He couldnât. "Youâre running from something. And I donât know what it is, but I see it in the way you pull away, in the way you shut down every time we get close." His eyes flickered toward Peter. "Youâre lying to yourself, Peter. And itâs not just about me. Itâs about you."
The silence that followed was heavier than anything before it, thick with unspoken words and tangled emotions. Mark's heart was hammering in his chest, but he didnât know what to do with it. He wanted to reach over, shake Peter, make him see the truth, but he couldnât. He wasnât sure if Peter was even listening anymore, if the words were getting through to him.
When Peter finally spoke again, his voice was a whisper, almost as if he was saying it more to himself than Mark. "Iâm not gay..."
Markâs eyes softened at the quiet admission. There was a crack in Peterâs façade, a fracture that Mark hadnât expected to see. Heâd seen the anger, the cold detachment, the resistance. But thisâthis was different. This was something raw. Something that made Markâs heart stutter, even if he didnât want it to.
âYou donât have to keep telling me that,â Mark said quietly, his voice surprisingly gentle, as though trying to reach something inside Peter. He leaned forward again, just a little. âI know. I know youâre not âgay,â Peter. But thatâs not what Iâm asking for.â His voice caught on the last word. âIâm asking you to stop running. From me. From whatever the hell it is thatâs scaring you.â
There was a long pause as Mark let the words settle in the air between them. He didnât know what would happen next, or if Peter would even listen. But there was no going back now. He had to say it. He had to give Peter the chance to decide. Whether they could move past all of this or if it would just tear them apart.
Peter still wouldnât meet his eyes, his gaze fixed on the windshield, but Mark didnât look away. He couldnât. Not when there was still a chance. Not when the weight of everything between them was still there, waiting for a spark to set it off.
Strahm felt himself breaking, but hid it. He hid it to the best of his abilities. But if you looked closely, very closely, you'd see a wounded man with glossy eyes. Eyes that weren't helping hide the fact he was upset. Eyes that held so much more emotion than his own words. Eyes you would see on an animal being hunted. Eyes that held fear.
"I'm not-" His voice cracked, but he quickly covered it with a cough. "I'm not running. I'm not scared of anything." No matter how much he tried to hide how he was really feeling, you could still slightly see it. His hands were now shaking and his leg began to bounce up and down quickly, making a faint but noticeable tapping sound.
"I'm not hiding from you." He said, but something in his mind told him he was hiding from Hoffman. Something told him he was hiding from everything. It had gotten to a point that he couldn't hide his feelings anymore. His whole body was tensed up as if protecting himself from words, his eyes fixated on the cars ahead of them more than anything, his leg continued to bounce but at a faster pace, and finally, his lip. He hadn't even noticed, but his lip began to drip blood again. This time though, he didn't wipe it away. He didn't want any hands near his face, even his own.
"And I shut down when we're close because I don't like you, Hoffman. You do nothing but-" He stopped himself, realizing what he said. It was too late. He can't just go back in time and stop himself. These words were stuck in the car.
All of their words were stuck in the car, along with his heart.
Mark could feel it, the tension in the air thick and almost suffocating. Every breath Peter took seemed heavy, labored, and every movement of his hands, his leg bouncing, told Mark something was wrong. The words caught in the air, stuck between them like a wall, and Mark was starting to feel like he was trapped on the other side of it.
Peterâs voice cracked, and Markâs heart skipped. He saw it. The way Peterâs hands shook, the way his leg tapped frantically, the slight gloss in his eyes that Peter tried so hard to hide. Peter was on the edge of breaking down, but he was doing everything in his power to keep it together, to keep his walls up. Mark knew that feeling. He recognized it. It was the same one he wore every damn day.
When Peter spoke, his words were harsh, almost defensive, but Mark could hear the cracks underneath. "I'm not running. I'm not scared of anything." But Mark saw it. That wasnât the truth. The shaking, the trembling lip, the way Peterâs eyes kept avoiding him. The truth was slipping through the cracks in his defenses.
Peter said he wasnât scared, but Mark could hear it in his voice, see it in the way his body tensed up. He could almost smell itâfear. Fear of something bigger than either of them could handle.
âIâm not hiding from you,â Peter said, and the words didnât even make it out like they were supposed to. Mark could hear the hesitation. The vulnerability. Peter was lying to himself. But Mark wasnât about to call him out on itânot yet, anyway. Heâd been there before, too. He understood what it was like to keep those walls up, to lock everything inside until it made you want to suffocate.
But then Peter spoke again. His words cut through the thick air like a knife, too sharp to ignore. "And I shut down when we're close because I don't like you, Hoffman. You do nothing but-"
Peter stopped himself, and Mark felt the weight of the words that hadn't been finished. The ones that lingered like a shadow, threatening to reveal something deeper than just anger or confusion. Something that could change everything.
Markâs pulse raced. He wanted to push him further, demand to know what Peter had really meant, but he knew better than to rush it. It wasnât the time for that. Still, the words hung in the air, heavy, suffocating. You do nothing but... what?
Markâs eyes softened just slightly as he watched Peter's lip, the blood starting to drip again. Peter didnât wipe it away, didnât even move his hand. It was like he wanted to bleed, wanted to feel it. Wanted to show Mark that he wasnât as cold as he kept pretending to be.
Mark knew the feeling too well. It was a strange sort of comfort to know that Peter was hurting, too. As fucked up as it sounded, it was a relief to know Peter wasnât the stone wall he tried so hard to be. And maybe, just maybe, Mark could find a way in. Even if it scared the hell out of him.
âPeterâŠâ Markâs voice was softer now, almost hesitant, as if he was treading carefully through the words. He didnât want to break Peter any more than he already was, but he couldnât stand watching him fight this on his own.
Mark reached out by putting his arm on the centre console, just slightly, his fingers brushing the air near Peterâs hand, though he didnât touch him. He wasnât sure if Peter would pull away or not. He wasnât sure if Peter even wanted him near.
But the words that followed from Peter hit Mark like a punch to the gut. âI donât like you.â And it stung more than anything Mark could have expected. He knew Peter wasnât ready for anything else, but that hurt. Hurt more than he wanted to admit.
Mark leaned back in his seat, his heart pounding in his chest. He couldnât let Peter see the effect those words had on him, but it felt like a thousand knives had pierced through his chest all at once.
âRight.â Markâs voice was tight, holding back something deep inside. No, Peter. You donât just shut down and say you donât like me and expect me to walk away.
But Mark didnât say that. He didnât push. He couldnât. Not yet. The words Peter had left unfinished were eating away at him, though. The silence was deafening.
And in that silence, Mark could feel itâthe shift, the crack in Peterâs armor. Peter might not have been ready to admit anything, but Mark could see it now. He could see the truth bleeding through, and he wasnât going anywhere.
Not yet.
They drove in silence for a few more moments, the tension between them almost unbearable. Then, finally, they pulled into the parking lot of the station. The headlights cut through the night, casting long shadows across the concrete. The sound of the engine slowing to a stop filled the car, but neither of them made a move to get out immediately.
Mark just sat there for a second, his eyes still on Peter. He could feel the weight of the moment hanging between them, almost like it was going to shatter if either of them spoke again.
After what felt like an eternity, Mark exhaled quietly and opened the door. "Weâre here," he said, his voice barely above a whisper. He didnât know what else to say. He didnât know how to fix what had been broken, or if it could even be fixed at all. All he knew was that he wasnât leaving yet.
Peter noticed his arm on the center console, moving his arm away quickly. Quicker than he'd ever moved away from Mark. His movements were like a scared injured animal. Quick to escape the touch that could save him. The touch that could fix him.
Strahm completely dissociated, staring out to the cars. The blood continued down his chin, reaching the bottom before he finally wiped it off with a quick movement of his arm. The arm farthest from Mark. Seeming like he was trying to hide he could move at all.
He stayed in his thoughts, trying his best to breathe through his walls finally breaking. They couldn't break. He couldn't let a new person into his mind, anything could happen.
His brain flooded with thoughts. They were all about Hoffman. What if he was starting to hate him? What if he was right? He's only trying to help. For once, he's being a good person and I just can't soak it in. Maybe I'm just a horrible person. He's probably beginning to hate me now. He probably-
Suddenly, Mark's voice pulled him out of the thoughts.
He looked at Hoffman and quickly nodded, leaving his car and locking it before speed walking to the office. As soon as he made it inside, he packed up everything at his desk he brought in. He had to leave, and he had to leave now.
Hoffman sat there for a second, watching Strahmâs back as he disappeared inside. He could still see the tension in his posture, the way his shoulders curled in like he was trying to shrink himself down, trying to vanish into the walls.
Mark exhaled, shaking his head as he rubbed his hand over his mouth.
This was spiraling. Fast.
He should just let him go. Let Strahm run himself ragged, let him pack up, let him storm out of the office and pretend none of this ever happened. Itâd be the easy thing to do. Itâd be the smart thing to do.
But Mark was shit at doing the smart thing when it came to Peter.
With a grunt, he pushed open the car door and got out, walking toward the building. His steps were heavy, purposeful, his jaw set as he shoved through the front doors.
Strahm was already at his desk, movements frantic, throwing his stuff into his bag like he was trying to outrun something. Maybe himself.
Mark lingered in the doorway for a moment before finally stepping forward.
âYou leaving or running?â His voice was level, but there was an edge beneath it.
Mark scoffed, stepping closer. âYou text me, drag me over here, and now youâre bolting? What the hell was this, Peter?â
He wasnât even sure what he wanted Strahm to say. He just wanted him to say something. Anything.
Mark clenched his jaw. Fine. If Strahm wanted to run, let him. But Mark wasnât going to stand there like an idiot, waiting for an answer that would never come.
âForget it,â he muttered, turning on his heel to leave.
Strahm put his bag over his shoulder, rushing to stand next to Hoffman. "Listen... I want to talk to you about.." He thought about how to word what they had going. "This. About me running. Just follow me so we can get it over with."
Peter said as he pulled a cigarette out of his pocket, placing it in my mouth as he searched for a lighter while he walked. He never smoked. He hadn't smoked in awhile, actually. He always just... carried one around. It was a habit from years ago he never let go.
As soon as he stepped out, he lit the cigarette.
What was he going to say? Sorry for being confused? Sorry for letting his anger get the best of him? Sorry for being the man Hoffman fell in love with? He couldn't wrap his head around an idea.
He stood with his jaw clenched in the cold as he waited for Mark who soon followed behind him. It was time to confront his emotions for once in his life.
For once, he almost felt in control of his emotions.
Hoffman watched Strahm fumbling for a lighter, his movements sharp, tense. He never smokedâMark knew that. At least, not anymore. So why now?
With a sigh, Mark reached into his jacket pocket, pulling out his own cigarette and lighter. He flicked it open, the flame casting a small, flickering glow between them. Instead of lighting his own first, he held it out toward Strahm, his gaze steady.
âHere.â.
The small gesture felt heavier than it should have, almost like a truce.
Mark lit his own cigarette next, inhaling deeply before exhaling a slow stream of smoke into the cold night air. He leaned against the hood of a nearby car, watching Peter through the haze.
âSo,â he exhaled. âTalk.â
His voice was even, but there was something else beneath itâsomething unreadable.
Mark shuffled in place, taking a long drag like the nicotine would give him the words he couldnât find. His fingers twitched slightly as he held the cigarette, the cold air making the smoke curl around them like a ghost of something unspoken.
He wasnât going to let Peter run from thisânot this time.
Peter took a long drag of the cigarette that was just handed to him, longer than he should have. He began to cough, smoke coming out of his mouth as smoothly as he prayed his words would.
Once he calmed down he sighed, staring down at his lit cigarette like it was the most interesting thing in the world at the moment.
"Mark, I..." He felt his face get hot despite the freezing weather they were standing in. "I don't know why I'm running from this. From you. I spent years after college building the person I am today that it hurts to break my walls. I've been trying so hard to change from how I was so many years ago that I can't even try to go back." He took a moment, taking another long drag from his cigarette.
"The person I was years ago wasn't... accepted." He said, hoping Hoffman would somehow catch onto what he was saying. "I don't want to run from you, but it feels like I need to." Peter's voice began to crack, which he tried to cover with a cough.
"I don't... hate you. I don't know how I feel about you. I know that it isn't hatred, though. I know it's something far different from that."
He took a moment before speaking again, hoping the silence would speak the words he couldn't.
"I haven't hated you in years..."
Mark watched him, really watched him. The way his fingers trembled slightly around the cigarette, the way his shoulders curled inward like he was trying to make himself smaller, like he didnât want to be seen. It was a look Mark recognized. A feeling he understood.
He exhaled slowly, letting the cold night air carry the smoke away before he spoke.
"You donât have to explain yourself to me, you know." His voice was softer than usual, lacking its usual sharpness. "Not if youâre not ready."
Mark hesitated for a moment, then stepped closerânot enough to crowd him, just enough that the space between them wasnât so cold.
âI get it,â he continued, voice steady but gentle. "Trying to outrun the past... trying to be something different. Something people expect you to be. Itâs easier than letting yourself go back to something that hurt.â
âIâm not gonna push you," Mark said. "You donât owe me some big confession. But I want you to knowâwhatever this is, whatever youâre trying to figure outâyou donât have to do it alone."
Mark took another slow drag, watching the way the streetlights cast shadows over Peterâs face. He wanted to reach out, wanted to do something, but he didnât. Not yet.
Instead, he just said, "I havenât hated you in years either."
And he let the words settle, giving Peter the space to decide what he wanted to do with them.
Peter let out a quiet sigh of relief, his breath shaking as he did. He felt so much... lighter. Like the weight of a boat was just lifted off his shoulders. He could finally relax. He could finally slowly start breaking down the wall he kept around himself.
He watched Mark step closer, his eyes widening slightly. He took a moment before stepping closer to him.
Their arms were touching. Fully this time.
Strahm took one last drag of the cigarette before dropping in on the ground, stomping it out with the front of his foot. The look of the dark red turning into different shades of grey made him calm down a bit.
He soaked in Hoffman's body warmth, his body warming up shortly after their bodies made contact. He wished for more. He hoped for more. He... prayed for more. Something other than a simple arm touch.
"Just saying, I don't think I'll ever hate you the way I hated you before again. If that means anything." You could hear it in his voice that he was smiling, and the fact that he was trying to hide it.
For once, he felt like himself.
Mark huffed out something that almost sounded like a laughâsmall, quiet, barely there.
âYeah?â Mark murmured, the corner of his mouth twitching up, though he still kept his eyes forward. âGuess Iâll have to live with that, then.â
He didnât move away. Didnât pull back like he usually might have. Instead, he let Peter lean in, let their arms stay pressed together, let the warmth between them settle.
It was stupid how much it affected him. How much he wanted to close the last bit of space between them. But he didnât push. Not yet.
And for once, Mark didnât feel the need to ruin it.
He took one last drag from his own cigarette before flicking it to the ground, crushing it under his boot.
âMeans something,â he admitted, his voice quieter now.
It was the closest heâd get to saying it means everything.
Peter chuckled with Mark, trying to seem like he wasn't freaking out mentally due to the touch. It drove him insane, but not in a bad way like before.
Usually, he would pull away and get defensive, but this time, he was grateful for the touch he was getting.
He slightly leaned his head onto Mark's arm, staring out to the few cars driving past. He hoped this would drive Hoffman insane, make him stay up thinking about this the way the simple thought of Mark kept him awake at night.
It probably wouldn't give the same effect, but a man can just simply hope.
Peter coughed before moving away, crossing his arm before finally making eye contact with Mark for the first time since before they left the building. "I should probably head home..." He said, smiling for the first time in awhile.
This time, it was a real smile.
Mark felt the weight of Peterâs head against his arm like a brand, something small but searing, something that would linger long after Peter walked away. He stayed still, barely breathing, as if moving too much would break whatever fragile thing had settled between them.
Peterâs warmth left him too soon, and Mark almostâ*almost*âreached to pull him back. But he let him go, watching as Peter crossed his arms, as he finally looked Mark in the eye.
And *smiled.*
A real smile. Not one laced with bitterness, not one meant to cut. Just *him.*
Mark exhaled, slow, measured. Forced himself to smirk like this wasnât wrecking him inside.
âYeah,â he said, voice rougher than he meant it to be. âProbably should.â
But he didnât move. Didnât step away.
Instead, he let his eyes linger on Peterâs face, taking in the way the cold flushed his skin, the way his shoulders looked just a little lighter than before.
âTry not to overthink this too much, huh?â Mark added, softer now. âWouldnât want you losing sleep over me.â
It was a lie. A blatant one. He *wanted* Peter to lose sleep over him. The way he lost sleep over *this.*
Peter started at Mark just a minute longer before sighing, tightening the grip around his work bag that settled on his shoulder. He didn't want to leave this moment yet. It hurt knowing he had to leave.
"Oh, trust me. I would never lose sleep over you." He said with a slight smile, a hint of teasing in tone. Such a light and small detail that no one would notice if they weren't intensely paying attention to every single one of his words.
Strahm made it to his car, immediately driving away. He didn't want Hoffman to notice him just silently sitting there. He already expressed all of his bigger emotions, he couldn't show his small ones already.
"Oh my fucking god." He said to himself, chuckling at the situation like a maniac. He couldn't believe that it finally happened. Mark knew he wanted him and he knew Mark wanted him.
Yet, something held him back. Something deep inside of him.
Mark watched Peter go, hands shoved deep into his pockets, his fingers curled into fists. He didn't move until Peterâs car disappeared down the road, its headlights fading into the night. Only then did he let out the breath heâd been holding.
He ran a hand down his face, over his mouth, trying to ground himself. What the fuck just happened?
Peter had teased him. Smiled at him. Leaned into him like he wanted to be there.
And then he was gone.
Mark shouldâve expected it. Shouldâve known that Peterâprickly, stubborn, infuriating Peterâwould take one step forward and then hesitate, would pull away just when things started to crack open.
But fuck, it still stung.
He pulled out another cigarette, rolling it between his fingers instead of lighting it. His pulse was still racing, his mind still tangled up in the way Peter had looked at him before leaving.
Mark let out a rough chuckle, shaking his head to himself.
âYeah,â he muttered under his breath, staring at the empty space where Peterâs car had been. âYou keep telling yourself that, Strahm.â
Then, against his better judgmentâagainst every damn thing in him that told him to let it beâhe pulled out his phone and typed out a message.
Sleep well, Peter.
And for once, he hit send.
Peter walked into the station holding a laptop bag and a big silver cup of coffee. It was very obvious he didn't get much sleep, like usual.
[ - @detstrahm ]
[ ooc text : i've never done an rp on tumblr so sorry if this starter sucks !!! ]
Mark Hoffman stands near his desk, eyes narrowing as Strahm enters the room. He takes in the sight of the tired detective, the coffee in his hand, and the laptop bag slung over his shoulder. Hoffman straightens slightly, his face betraying no emotion as he watches Strahm move to his desk.
"You look like you haven't slept in days, Strahm. Tiredness isn't a badge of honor. Itâs a weakness."
He leans back in his chair, his arms folding across his chest, his gaze unwavering as he watches Strahmâs every move.
"If youâre planning to continue running on fumes, itâs only a matter of time before it catches up to you. You should know better than anyone what happens when you lose focus."
His tone is harsh, but there's an edge to it, as if he's quietly daring Strahm to respond, or perhaps waiting for a crack in the other man's usually composed demeanor.
[NO I LOVE IT!! LMK IF THIS IS TOO MUCH HEJEEJEJEJ]
"Not that it's any of your concern, but I'm fine."
Strahm stopped walking as he spoke, looking back to Hoffman over his shoulder with a cold gaze that could definitely kill him if looks really could kill.
"Your snarky comments aren't going to affect me, I'm not a child."
His voice was firm yet calm, making it obvious that he wasn't trying to cause a scene this early into his shift. It was so hard to do anything with Hoffman just a couple steps away from him.
Hoffman smirked to himself, tapping his pen idly against a stack of paperwork before finally dragging his gaze up to meet Strahmâs glare.
"You sure about that?" His voice was slow, almost amused. "Because Iâve seen you get flustered over a lot less."
He leaned back in his chair, letting the words settle, watching for the inevitable reaction. Hoffman raised a brow, the corner of his mouth twitching like he was resisting the urge to really twist the knife. "Not that itâs any of my concern, of course."
And just like that, he went back to his paperwork, acting like the conversation was already over, though he was more than ready for whatever Strahm had to say next-- almost if in anticipation.
Peter took a deep breath as he walked over to Hoffman's desk, leaning over to whisper in his ear instead of yelling. It seemed like the most mature choice.
"Listen here, asshole. I am in no mood to deal with your shit today."
His tone was sharp as if he was an angry dog barking back at Mark. No matter how hard he tried to ignore Hoffman, he always came up with something to say that just pushed his limits.
He tugged on the collar of the other male's shirt, pulling him closer so his mouth was almost touching his ear.
"Leave me the fuck alone, Hoffman."
He growled in Mark's ear, pushing himself away from him with a stern look on his face.
Hoffman barely reacted as Strahm yanked him closer, his breath hot against his ear, voice laced with frustration. The smirk that tugged at the corner of his mouth was slow, deliberateâbecause this was interesting.
For a moment, he didnât say anything, just let the tension settle between them. Then, in a voice just low enough for only Peter to hear, he finally spoke.
"Careful, Strahm." Smooth, almost teasing. "You keep getting this close, people might start talking."
His gaze flickered downâjust brieflyâto where Strahmâs fingers had gripped his collar. Then, just as lazily, he reached for the cup sitting next to him. It wasnât the usual station sludge, but something sweeter, something indulgent, the faint scent of caramel mixing with the deeper, familiar notes of his cologneâcedarwood, leather, something subtly sharp beneath it all.
He took a slow sip, his smirk deepening just slightly as he finally met Strahmâs glare again.
"But heyâmessage received." His tone was light, almost amused. But there was something else beneath it, something unreadable.
[not me sprinkling in some hoffman hcs lol.]
The more Mark spoke, the more it seemed to anger Strahm. He hated how easy it was for Mark to anger him with just a tone of voice or a simple sentence.
"God, fuck off." Peter basically stormed off to his desk, throwing himself into the chair. As he logged into his computer to actually start working, he couldn't stop thinking about Hoffman.
Usually, that would be normal. Today it was different though. Instead of thinking about how much he hated him, he started thinking about these small details about him. Like how his hair looked more brushed through then normally, or how the scent stuck on his body was weirdly calming.
It was weird, but he couldn't stop thinking about it.
It's like Hoffman put a spell on him.
Hoffman watched Strahm go, lifting his cup to his lips again, taking an unhurried sip. The taste of caramel lingered, mixing with the sharper bitterness beneath it.
That was too easy.
Strahm could throw himself into his chair all he wanted, could scowl at his screen and pretend to focus, but Hoffman knew. He knew. Because that reaction? That wasnât just anger. That was something else, something tangled up in frustration and confusion and whatever the hell was flickering behind those glares.
He swirled the drink absently in his cup, gaze flicking toward Strahmâs desk. Then, without looking directly at him, he spokeâjust loud enough to carry across the room.
"You sure you want me to fuck off, or do you just like telling me what to do?"
Hoffman smirked against the rim of his cup, taking another slow sip, letting his pursed lips linger on the rim. Letting the words settle.
Peter's hands froze and his computer as he took a moment to let himself process what Mark just said. Instead of freaking out, or yelling, or even getting out of his seat, he responded calmly. He hated to egg Hoffman on with his emotions.
"Do your damn work, Hoffman. Might do you some good."
Strahm placed his head in his hands for a moment to recollect himself before continuing to work in silence, using his screen to hide from looking at anyone even near him.
He didn't understand this feeling. It was a strange mixture of so many things and emotions he hasn't felt since early college. Whatever it was, Hoffman was enjoying using it against him.
The teasing worked, but god he wish it didn't.
Hoffman finally, finally turned his attention to the files on his desk, though his focus was shot to hell. His eyes moved over the words, but they barely registered. The conversationâthat look Strahm had given him before burying himself in his screenâwas still fresh, playing in his mind like a puzzle he hadnât quite solved yet.
He tapped his fingers against the desk, considering. There was something satisfying about watching Strahm try so hard to keep himself in check, to act like none of this was getting to him. Hoffman knew better.
The corner of his mouth twitched as he flipped a page, not bothering to hide the smirk creeping in. He took another sip of his drink, the sweetness coating his tongue, lingering.
Maybe he should get back to work.
Or maybe he should push just a little moreâjust to see how long Strahm could keep pretending.
Strahm tapped his pen on his desk to a rhythm he had just made up in his mind since that seemed to be the only thing that could replace his thoughts about Hoffman.
Everything reminded him of Mark, it's like he couldn't escape him. He couldn't even focus on his work, which really bothered him. Usually, his work was the one distraction that always worked, but clearly not today.
Peter sighed before standing up and dropping his pen down onto his desk. He ran his hands down his outfit before walking away to the bathroom with his head down the whole time.
He needed an escape. He needed a way to get away from Mark, even just for a couple minutes.
He opened the door to the bathroom, making sure nobody was in there before walking to the sink and turning on cold water. Strahm collected a small amount of water on his hands and splashed it on his face, staring at himself in the mirror. Why was this happening now?
Hoffman didnât look up right away, but he felt the shift. The absence. The way the air around him suddenly felt⊠quieter.
Strahm was gone.
No presence lingering just a few feet away, no rhythmic tapping of a pen, no barely restrained exhale of frustration. The space he left behind felt noticeable in a way Hoffman didnât care to dwell on.
His fingers drummed idly against the desk as he stared at the open file in front of him. He wasnât reading it. His focus was elsewhere, stuck on somethingâor someoneâthat wasnât even in the damn room anymore.
Hoffman sighed, rolling his shoulders before forcing himself back to his work. Strahm would be back.
And when he was, Hoffman wasnât sure if heâd say anything at allâjust that heâd be aware, too aware, of the moment Strahm walked back through that door.
Strahm continued to stare at himself, a look of confusion forming on his face as he stared.
Who was he right now?
He could normally focus on his work with no struggle, but today was just so different. The tension that formed drove him mad. It didn't make any sense, he didn't feel these things last week, so what's so different now?
Peter began to get angry at everything, especially his thoughts. The water still running, the footsteps outside, the talking of his coworkers, the door to the females restroom opening and closing, everything.
He couldn't take it. Strahm punched the bathroom counter, turning the sink off before storming out of the bathroom and back to his seat.
He tried so hard to get on task but with Hoffman around, it would be hard.
The sound of Strahmâs chair scraping against the floor pulled Hoffmanâs attention before he even meant to look at the other man.
Back already.
He didnât watch himânot openly, at least. Whatever that little break had been, it clearly hadnât helped.
Hoffman finally, finally turned his attention to the files in front of him, though his focus was still half elsewhere. He flipped a page, then spoke, his tone casual.
âYou see the new evidence on the Jigsaw case yet?â A beat. Then, with a glint of playfulness in his eyes, he added, âLooks like our guyâs getting smarter.â
Strahm coughed, opening one of the many files on his desk and writing something quick down in pen. "I heard they found a small strand of hair at a scene. They sent it in to get it tested and a DNA read." He sighed. "Seems useless though. It's a strand of hair that was next to a victim, it was probably theirs."
He wasn't doing very well at trying to seem like he calmed down. Peter never denied small things like this unless he was just talking to talk.
He didn't understand how Hoffman was so casual right now. Does he not feel the tension right now? is he really that dumb?
Hoffman didnât look up right away. He turned a page in his file, scanning the words like they mattered more than Strahmâs obvious frustration. âCould be useless,â he said, almost offhandedly. âOr it could be exactly what we need.â
There was no real argument in his toneâjust something thoughtful, maybe even knowing, like he wasnât as dismissive of the lead as Strahm was.
He finally shifted, glancing at Strahm as if noticing him for the first time since he sat back down. His gaze flicked over him brieflyâtaking in the tension still lingering in his shoulders, the way his grip on his pen was just a little too tight.
And then, something caught his attention. The way the dim overhead light hit just right, outlining the sharp line of Strahmâs jaw, the faintest crease between his brows. Had he always clenched his jaw like that when he was thinking? It wasnât just irritationâit was focus, frustration, something deeper that Hoffman couldnât quite pin down.
For a second, he nearly forgot what he was about to say. He forced himself to look back down at his file, masking the moment with an easy shrug.
âLong morning?â His voice was low, almost conversational. But there was something in the way he said itâsomething that made it impossible to tell if he was just making small talk or if he already knew the answer.
Strahm aggressively wrote stuff down in the files, taking small breaks to collect his thought before continuing to write.
"Bad traffic. Bad night." His tone was firm and aggressive, but not on purpose. He spoke quickly which made it obvious it was a lie to get off the topic of anything but work.
He glanced up at Hoffman and froze, using this moment to soak in everything about him. The way he looked so calm while focused on his work, the way his hand gently pushed the pen down on the paper, the way his lips looked when he was focused...
Peter bit down onto his bottom lip roughly, definitely leaving small teeth marks on his lip. Simply looking at Mark made him anxious.
Hoffman didnât react right away. He let Strahmâs words sit between them, as if deciding whether or not to be snide.
He kept his focus on the file in front of him, but his mind was elsewhereâstuck on something he couldnât quite shake. The way Strahmâs voice had that edge to it. The way his pen practically carved into the paper, like he needed the distraction.
Then, in his periphery, he caught itâStrahm biting his lip, hard.
Hoffmanâs grip on his pen tightened for a fraction of a second before he forced himself to relax, dragging his eyes back to his work.
He exhaled through his nose, pretending to stay focused on his paperwork, but his mind was already elsewhere. The way Strahm bit his lipâthat sharp press of teeth against skinâwasnât something he shouldâve noticed.
Wasnât something he shouldâve cared about.
But he did.
His jaw tensed as he forced his attention back to the file in front of him, masking any sign of distraction. After a beat of silence, he finally spoke, his voice lower than before.
"Yeah⊠not like sleep does much good anyway."
"I stayed up practically all night trying to put together why they would test that fucking-" He took a deep breath, looking down at his papers. "that damn strand of hair. It just doesn't make much sense."
As much as he tried to focus on his papers, he couldn't. The way his jaw tensed just drew in his attention even more as if it was magic.
Peter continued to bite at his lip, feeling an impending doom for what Hoffman would say next. His voice was just so smooth, it felt like torture in the best way possible.
He tried to pretend to do his work, but it was hard when his eyes couldn't get off of Mark. He felt helpless in this moment and he hated it.
He was supposed to have all the power.
Hoffman didnât need to look up to know Strahm was still watching him. He could feel itâthose damn eyes, like heat searing into the side of his face, making it almost impossible to focus on anything else.
"Yeah," Hoffman murmured, his voice gravelly but calm, "doesnât add up, does it?"
He wasnât just talking about the case. The frustration in Strahmâs toneâit hit something deeper, something Hoffman didnât feel like addressing, not right now.
He finally looked up, his gaze meeting Strahm's, but only for a brief moment. "But thatâs the thing with this case, Strahm. Sometimes itâs not about making sense." His words carried an almost unsettling weight, though he wasnât sure if Strahm would catch on.
His hand paused mid-motion as he noticed Strahmâs biting, that subtle, almost unconscious action. Hoffmanâs brow furrowed slightly, but he quickly dismissed the thought, shaking it off. He had work to do.
"Try to stay focused," he added, his tone unexpectedly softer, though he meant it more to himself than Strahm.
Strahm let out a deep sigh, closing his eyes and swinging his head back for a moment. This was his best attempt at clearing his mind.
"I just hate when they do things without running it past me or Perez first." He whispered, picking his pen back up and beginning to actually work on the case.
He felt like a idiot. For once, he didn't want to be at work. He regretted coming in today, especially because Lindsey wouldn't be here because her family was in town and wanted one day with them.
Peter picked back up the rhythm from earlier with his pen, tapping it more aggressively than before without realizing. At this point, he was just trying to drown out any of his thoughts, even about work.
Hoffman let the comment hang in the air, though something shifted in his posture at the mention of Lindsey. He didnât outwardly show it, but the thought gnawed at him for a split second.
He leaned back in his chair, the sound of Strahmâs aggressive pen tapping filling the otherwise quiet space. The irritation in Strahmâs actions wasn't lost on Hoffman, but the mention of Lindsey caught him off guard. It wasnât like him to care, not like this.
"Youâre right," Hoffman said, his voice controlled, though there was a slight edge to it, "Youâd think they'd at least consult you. But," he paused, the faintest of smirks pulling at the corners of his lips, "youâre better off without distractions anyway."
He didnât know if Strahm would pick up on the shift in his tone, but Hoffman had a feeling his partner wouldn't miss the faint jealousy that had crept in. He wasnât sure why it bothered him, but it did.
His eyes flicked to Strahm for a brief moment, then back to the file in front of him, trying to focus.
"Guess youâre stuck here with me," he added, his tone slipping just enough to hint at something more personal beneath the professional surface.
Peter suddenly stopped tapping his pen at the last comment Mark added, pausing everything he was doing. Something with the tone he used made him feel something different. Something he hasn't felt yet today.
He couldn't sit here with Hoffman with those words just replaying in his head, he had to escape somewhere.
"I'll be back." Strahm said, his words slightly slurring together. He shot up from his seat, speed walking back to the bathroom. There was one other person in there, but he could care less at the moment.
Peter paced back and forth in the bathroom while waiting for the other man to leave the restroom. Luckily, the pacing must've rushed him out. He continued to pace around, pinching at the bridge of the nose.
There's no way Mark hasn't noticed his weird behavior, there's just no way. He didn't understand why he couldn't just suppress his emotions like he normally did. He has been hiding his emotions with ease for years, so what was so different today?
Hoffman stood up by the windowsill, his back leaning against the cool glass, eyes staring at the outside but not really seeing it. His mind kept drifting back to Strahm, and the way heâd snapped, his frustration practically hanging in the air. There was something about it, something that felt... off. He couldnât quite put his finger on it, but it bothered him.
He rubbed a hand over his face, sighing, trying to clear the thoughts clouding his head. His gaze flicked back to Strahmâs empty deskâ God, why was it so unsettling?
Mark didnât let distractions get to him. He wasnât someone who let emotions or anything else interfere with the job. But thisâwhatever this wasâ was messing with his usual routine.
The door creaked slightly, and his eyes darted toward it, but no one was there. Mark was surprised by how much heâd noticed Peterâs absence. He shifted uncomfortably, his fingers curling into a fist around the edge of the windowsill. What the hell was wrong with him? It wasnât like Strahm to just leave like that, and it wasnât like him either to feel... unsettled by it.
âJust focus,â Mark muttered to himself, but his gaze lingered on the door a second longer than necessary. He hadnât realized how much he had started to notice the little things about Strahmâhis sharp movements, his short temper, the way his jaw tensed when he was angry. And then the way heâd left, so abruptly, like he couldnât even get out of the room fast enough.
Mark rubbed the back of his neck and shook his head, pursing his lips in thought.
He wasnât someone who gave a damn about these things. But today felt... different
And that made him uneasy.
Peter leaned up against the bathroom wall, placing his face in his hands. He wanted to stay in the bathroom until he died but sadly, he knew he couldn't. Strahm continued to bite down on his lip until he tasted blood.
"Fucking hell..." He whispered, taking his hands off his face to wipe his lip. He stared down at his hand, looking at the blood that covered a small part of the side of his hand.
Strahm walked over to the sink and rinsed his hand off, watching the water turn a slight red before slipping down the drain. It was a weirdly calming sight.
He soon left the bathroom, avoiding looking at Hoffman the best he could. "I'm going to refill my coffee." Strahm said firmly as he reached for his cup, rushing away from his desk before he could even hear a response.
If he was being completely honest, he was embarrassed. He was embarrassed that he couldn't hide his feelings this time. It was such a weird thing to feel something other than anger or calmness.
Peter grabbed the old coffee pot from the staff room, filling his large silver cup up with the lukewarm coffee. He hated how he couldn't confront Mark about these feelings.
Hoffman noticed it immediatelyâhow Strahm wouldnât look at him, how his movements were just a little too quick, like he couldnât get away fast enough.
He grabbed his cup and rushed off before Hoffman could so much as blink.
He didnât know what heâd expected, but it wasnât⊠that.
For the first time, something about Strahmâs reaction made him hesitate. He knew how to read peopleâhe had toâbut this wasnât the usual sharp-edged frustration he was used to prying out of Strahm. This wasnât Strahm picking a fight or snapping back. It was avoidance.
And for some reason, Hoffman didnât like that.
His fingers drummed against the desk, watching the spot Strahm had just vacated. Part of himâsome small, stupid partâwondered if heâd actually hurt him. The thought unsettled him more than it should have.
He let out a quiet exhale, dragging his focus back to his paperwork. It was nothing. It had to be nothing.
So why did it sit so strangely in his chest?
Peter took a deep breath in the small but strangely calming staff room. Why couldn't he just man up and go do his work? Why was Hoffman such a distraction? There were all these whys in his head with no answer.
He took a swig of the lukewarm coffee, swishing it around his mouth as he let his mind wander some more. He felt so stupid for avoiding Mark. For some strange reason, he felt bad for avoiding Hoffman.
Strahm looked at the shut door and debated ever leaving this room, but sadly he knew he had to. He had to face his problems.
Peter left the staff room with his head up this time, trying his best to look put together and confident. As he walked to his desk he wondered if everyone else in the building could tell he was breaking on the inside.
Hoffman didnât acknowledge Strahmâs return, keeping his eyes trained on the file in front of him. He wasnât really reading itâhis focus was shot to hell.
He was letting his body speak for him in ways he couldnât control. His leg bounced beneath the desk, a steady, impatient rhythm. His fingers tapped soundlessly against the edge of his paper, the only betrayal of his restlessness.
He wanted to look at Strahm. Watch for any flicker of emotion. See if there was still tension in his jaw, if his lip was still raw from biting down too hard. But he didnât. Not yet.
He just waited. If Strahm wanted to pretend nothing happened, fine. But if there was a crackâany sign of itâHoffman would be there, ready to catch it.
Strahm coughed as if trying to warn Hoffman he was back in his seat, pulling open a completely new file to maybe try and focus on something new.
He read every word on the paper, but nothing made sense in his head at the moment. It was weird, but it felt strange without Hoffman's eyes on him. If he was being honest, he missed being looked at from a distance.
"So, have you heard anything about the Jigsaw case?" Peter asked with his face still buried in the case files on his desk. The silence became too much for him to handle and he needed to break it.
He eagerly waited for a response as if his life depended on it, nervously biting his lip once again and continuing to tap his pen to a different rhythm from before.
Hoffman exhaled slowly, dragging his eyes from his paperwork like he was indulging Strahm by giving him attention.
"Nothing new," he said, his voice even. "Just the same dead ends."
He finally glanced at Strahm, taking in the way his lip was caught between his teeth again, the quick, restless tapping of his pen.
He leaned back slightly, studying Strahm a little longer than necessary before forcing himself to look away. As Hoffman finally looked at him, his gaze snagged on something small but noticeableâthe faint trace of dried blood at the corner of Strahmâs lip. It was barely there, but it was enough.
Hoffmanâs fingers twitched slightly, his grip on his pen tightening before he forced himself to loosen it. He shouldnât care. Shouldnât even be looking. But the sight of it made something uneasy settle in his chest. Had Strahm bitten down that hard?
His jaw tensed as he dragged his eyes away. His breath hitched before he could stop it.
The sight of itâsubtle, unintentional, self-inflictedâsent something sharp and hot running through his veins. His fingers curled around his pen, gripping it just a little too tight. He shouldnât be reacting to this. Shouldnât feel the way his pulse quickened, the way his body betrayed him with that sudden, insidious heat curling in his gut.
His composure threatened to slip.
Hoffman exhaled through his nose, his jaw clenching as he forced his expression to stay neutral. His gaze flicked away, back to his paperwork, even though the words on the page were meaningless now.
âWhy?â His voice came out steadyâthankfullyâbut just a fraction lower than before. âYou onto something?â
He kept his head down, pen skimming over the paper in a weak attempt at normalcy, but the damage was already done. He felt it. And worseâhe liked it.
"Not yet. It's getting annoying how we can't get any new leads..." Strahm put his pen down onto his desk, leaning his head back as he let out a long sigh of exhaustion.
Suddenly, he had gotten an idea. Something that would probably calm down the thoughts about Hoffman in his head, but would probably be seen as weird.
At this point, that was the least of his concerns.
"Hey, wanna go somewhere for lunch? We can discuss the case some more." Peter said, his voice was low with a hint of embarrassment. He didn't want to give Mark any ideas of what he actually meant but instead an idea that he actually cared about the Jigsaw case at this moment.
Strahm held his breath while waiting for a response, keeping his eyes focused on the papers on his desk rather than Hoffman to seem relaxed.
He really hoped he was pulling off the whole 'chill' act...
Hoffman didnât answer right away. He sat with it, rolling the idea over in his head, his pen idly tapping against the desk.
Lunch. Alone. With him.
It was easy to pretend that was a normal suggestion. Just two law enforcement officers talking shop. But Strahm had hesitated before asking, and that hesitation stuck with him.
His eyes flicked toward the other man, watching the way he stayed locked onto the papers in front of him like they held the answer to something more than just their case. His fingers curled around his pen a little tighter.
Hoffman wasnât sure why that detail bothered him.
He exhaled through his nose, feigning indifference. âYeah, sure.â His voice was steady, neutral. As if he hadnât spent the last minute overthinking this.
He leaned back in his chair, stretching his legs out, the tension in his muscles betraying his otherwise relaxed posture. His knee bounced once before he stilled it. He didnât like feeling caught off guard.
He finally looked at Strahm again. âWhere?â It wasnât an enthusiastic acceptance, but it also wasnât a rejection. It was something in between.
Peter let out a quiet sigh as soon as Mark answered, gripping at the bridge of his nose as he tried to think of a place nearby that was nice enough to take Hoffman to, but not too nice.
"Well, I heard there's this nice sandwich place that recently opened... we could go there." Strahm suggested, pulling himself out of his work to actually make eye contact with Hoffman.
He noticed small details very quickly. The way a couple strands of hair fell out of his styled hair, the way his eyes were naturally tired looking in such a good way, the way his hand gripped onto his pen, the way he had to stop his leg from bouncing... everything was so perfect it made him sick.
He tried to pull his eyes off of Mark, but he just couldn't. For once, he had an actual excuse to stare at Hoffman. He shouldn't have been as grateful as he was.
Hoffman let a beat of silence pass before tilting his head slightly, finally meeting Strahmâs eyes with something that almost resembled amusement.
âA sandwich place, huh?â he said, tapping his fingers idly against the desk. âDidnât peg you as the type to branch out. Thought you survived purely off burnt coffee and spite.â
There was a slight smirk at the corner of his mouth, but his tone was just casual enough to keep Strahm guessing. It wasnât an outright challenge, but it wasnât nothing, either. Just enough to test the watersâto see if Strahm would roll his eyes, snap back, or keep looking at him like that.
His leg bounced once before he forced it still again, fingers tightening around his pen.
Peter's breathing quickly became regular as soon as Hoffman made eye contact with him, causing him to stumble over his words.
"Well- I-" He paused, collecting his thoughts. "I mostly survive off of cheap burnt coffee, but I'm switching it up for once." A slight smile appeared on his face for the first time today once he realized if he just kept up this calm, non-angry act up, he might survive this shift.
Or, at least he'll try to keep it up. It's hard when he's around Mark.
Strahm reached into his pocket and searched for his card, flipping through random twenties and tens before finally finding it. "I heard it's pretty cheap so I might as well pay for yours." He said, not even noticing how nice he was being.
He was never nice to anyone other than Lindsey really, so this must've been a rare sighting to anyone listening in to the conversation.
"But I'm only paying because it's cheap. I'm not trying to be all nice and shit, so don't get that idea." Of course, he had to ruin the one moment he seemed slightly kind.
Hoffman let out a quiet chuckle, shaking his head as he watched Strahm fumble with his wallet. There was something oddly endearing about itâhow he offered without thinking, only to immediately try to walk it back. It wasnât often that Strahm let something slip through the cracks.
"Generous and cheap. Quite the combination," Hoffman murmured, his voice dipping into something almost warm, almost teasing. He let the words hang between them for a moment before exhaling, running a hand down the sleeve of his jacket as he stood.
His gaze lingered on Strahm just a little longer than necessary, taking in the way he still wouldn't quite meet his eyes. There was a rare ease in the moment, a shift from the usual sharp edges they threw at each other. Hoffman felt it more than he wanted to acknowledge.
"If youâre so insistent," he said, his tone softer now, something almost amused beneath it, "Iâll let you buy me lunch. Just donât expect me to be nice about it."
It wasnât a joke, not really. But it was something. A quiet acceptance, an unspoken truce. And when he stepped just a little closerâjust enough to catch the faintest tension in Strahmâs shouldersâhe couldn't quite fight the smirk that ghosted across his lips.
"Letâs go before you change your mind."
Strahm nodded in agreement, shoving his wallet back in his pocket before standing, straightening out his top with his hands. It was so weird that he suddenly felt a need to look... cleaner around Hoffman.
"Do you want me to drive?" He asked as he began to walk to the front door of the building, reaching a hand into the opposite pocket of his wallet to grip onto his keys, ready for an answer to his question.
Peter tried to walk slightly fast, trying to avoid anyone really seeing him walk outside the building while having an active and normal conversation with Mark.
He didn't want people to think he suddenly grew fond of Hoffman because, if he was being completely honest, he didn't really like the thought of beginning to grow fond of him.
Peter spent all of these years hating Mark just for that to change from one interaction. It felt stupid to him. He felt stupid.
Hoffman followed steadily, letting Strahm put some distance between them. It wasnât hard to pick up on the way Peter was rushing. Like it meant something.
Hoffman didnât call attention to it, but he noticed. He noticed the way Strahmâs fingers curled tightly around his keys, the way he held himself just a little straighter, as if heâd suddenly started caring about how he looked. It was subtle, but it was there.
And for some reason, it was... alluring.
There was a new kind of tension in Strahm, not the usual barely-contained aggression Hoffman was used to. This was something else, something more restrained. He wasnât sure what to make of it yet, but he had the patience to figure it out.
âIâll let you drive,â he finally said, watching Strahm with something just shy of amusement. His voice was even, casual, but his smirk gave away more than he probably intended. He let the moment stretch just a little longer before adding, âJust try not to kill us before we get there.â
A joke, but one that carried weight. A small push. A test.
He walked ahead of Strahm and put a hand in his pocket as he walked.
"I'll try, but it might be hard with you in the car." Peter said, hiding back a smirk as he spoke. He pulled the keys out of his pocket, gripping them tightly in his hand as if someone was going to steal them from him.
As he entered the cold weather outside, his whole body tightened. Strahm had always hated the cold.
He unlocked his car, quickly shoving himself in to try and escape the weather. He switched on the heat in his car before blowing warm air into his hands, waiting patiently for Mark to say something that gave him the idea he was ready for him to start driving.
Peter really hated driving with a person in his car. His road rage usually killed any good energy moving throughout his car in a matter of seconds. Sure, Mark has seen him angry, but not the type of anger he gets while driving.
Plus, he'd really hate to ruin what they had going on at the moment...
Hoffman let out a short chuckle at Strahmâs response, low and almost under his breath. There was something oddly satisfying about the way Peter shot back without missing a beatâlike he was starting to get comfortable with this, whether he wanted to or not.
The cold bit at his skin as he followed Strahm outside, but he barely registered it, too focused on watching the other man move. The tension in his shoulders, the way he practically threw himself into the car to escape the chillâit was little things like that that made Hoffman feel like he was getting a read on him.
He slid into the passenger seat with an easy, unbothered motion, his gaze settling on Strahm as the heat kicked in. The way Peter hunched over his hands, rubbing warmth back into them, was oddly... humanizing. A rare moment where he looked like more than just a sharp edge waiting to cut.
Hoffman leaned back, making himself comfortable before finally breaking the silence. âYou gonna warm up before we get moving, or do I have to listen to you bitch about the cold the whole drive?â His tone was teasing, but his eyes lingered a little too longâtaking in the way Strahmâs lips were still slightly parted from the rush of warm air, the way his fingers flexed against his palms.
Another small test. Another moment to gauge how far this push-and-pull would go.
Strahm smiled, pulling his hands away from his mouth. "You'll have to hear me bitch about a lot during this car ride. The traffic is bad right now." He said as he put his hand on the steering wheel, gripping it tightly.
He started to drive, his attention suddenly going to the road with a straight, serious face. He always took driving very serious, for some strange reason.
Peter tried to seem calm with Mark in the car, but seeing all the cars lined up in the street already made his blood boil. He didn't want to yell at all, but he just knew that would be hard.
"Holy fuck, that's a lot of cars..." He commented, speaking in a low voice that seemed like a grumble or a growl. His voice always sounded so demanding or angry, no matter what mood he was in.
Hoffman settled into his seat, letting his gaze drift lazily over the dashboard before inevitably landing on Strahmâs hands. He had a firm grip on the wheel, fingers tense, knuckles just shy of turning white.
Hoffman had seen Strahmâs hands in plenty of different settingsâclutching a gun, flipping through case files, clenched into fistsâbut there was something about watching them now, wrapped around the wheel with that quiet intensity, that held his attention a little too long.
The way his fingers flexed slightly every time he muttered under his breath, the subtle tremor of agitation when traffic didnât move fast enoughâit was strangely captivating. It made Hoffman wonder, just for a second, how that tension would feel if it werenât directed at the steering wheel.
âTry not to take it personally,â he said finally, tearing his gaze away and shifting in his seat. âPretty sure the traffic isnât out to get you.â His tone was light, almost mocking, but his fingers tapped idly against his own thighâlike he was keeping himself from saying something else.
"It's just so annoying. If people actually knew how to drive then we-" He suddenly stopped himself from talking, giving himself a moment to collect his thoughts. He couldn't go on a stupid rant about people driving. At leastânot in front of Mark.
His eyes slowly drifted towards Hoffman's fingers tapping against his thigh, picking up on the rhythm in his head quickly. He watched as if it was a mind blowing thing, like something he's never seen before. Obviously, he wasn't focused on the rhythm, he was focused on Mark.
The way he tapped so calmly like he was waiting to say something, the way his focus was on the grip of his hand, the way he was somehow so calm and collected on the outside, everything. All of it just seemed so perfect. Too perfect.
Peter soon snapped out of it as soon as he realized the cars around him were moving, and soon became fixated back on the road.
"This place better be good. If I drove in this traffic for no reason, I'll be pissed." He said, beginning to quietly tap the rhythm Mark had been tapping, using it as a way to calm down.
Suddenly, it hit him. He was driving Mark Hoffmanâthe guy who has been driving him insane all dayâout to eat with him. Sure, it wasn't fancy, but it was still something. The thought of this made him go back to biting his lip, leaving a dent over the previous one that just started going away.
Hoffmanâs fingers kept up their steady rhythm against his thigh, but his focus wasnât really on it anymore. His eyes had drifted back to Strahm, watching the way his jaw tensed, the way his grip tightened on the steering wheelâand most of all, the way he kept biting his lip, almost absentmindedly.
He let the moment stretch for a beat longer than necessary before speaking, voice smooth but just pointed enough to be intentional.
"Didn't take you for a nervous habit kind of guy, Strahm. Be careful there."
The words hung in the air, but the way Hoffmanâs gaze lingeredâjust for a secondâmade it clear heâd noticed. He settled back against the seat, watching for a reaction, wondering if Strahm would brush it off or if the slight shift in energy would throw him off course.
Strahm stopped tapping his fingers, looking over to Mark with a confused expression. It took him a moment to realize he was biting down on his lip. Again.
He quickly corrected himself, wiping his lip to see more blood transfer onto his hand. "Fuck..." He whispered to himself, staring down at the wipe of blood on the side of his hand before sighing and simply putting his hand back onto the wheel.
Peter never understood why he did stuff like this knowing it would later on hurt. And he especially didn't understand why he was doing it even more than usual. Normally, he would bite his lip while checking out a crime scene, or holding a gun, but never while simply being around a person.
He soon realized how much power Hoffman held when it came to himself. He could simple say something cocky and it would mess up his whole shift, or even the rest of his day.
"God fucking damn it." He said as he punched the steering wheel, causing his car to honk to the car in front of them.
Great, he did the one thing he was trying not to do. Get mad over a simple thing while in the car.
Hoffmanâs smirk faltered. Just for a second.
He hadnât expected that reactionâhadnât expected Strahm to actually hit the wheel like that. The sharp sound of the horn rang in his ears, but it was the frustration in Strahmâs voice that really caught him off guard.
For all the ways he liked to push, this wasnât what heâd been aiming for.
Hoffman shifted slightly, pulling his gaze away, tapping his fingers against his thigh againâbut this time, it wasnât intentional. It was just something to do. Something to focus on instead of the way Strahmâs knuckles were going white against the steering wheel.
"Forget it," he muttered, quieter than before. "Didnât mean anything by it."
For once, he let the moment pass without another remark. No teasing, no smug little comments. Just silenceâsave for the hum of the car engine and the faint, rhythmic tapping of his fingers.
Was this guilt? He felt guilty for that remark, and Hoffman rarely cares about others like that.
He suddenly felt anxious. He tried to remain suave but his hands shook ever so slightly as he loosened his tie. It was getting slightly hard to breathe.
Strahm had gone completely silent at this point, taking all his anger out by gripping the wheel. If he knew that he would've fucked up the stuff they had going, he would've tried to prevent it.
But he couldn't.
He soon saw the sandwich shop, realizing it was closed. He went through all of this for it to be closed. He sighed and turned into the parking lot anyway, parking the car to think of another place they could go to.
"So... the shop is closed today, I guess." Peter said, his voice quiet and low as if he was confessing something. He felt somewhat bad. He felt bad for taking Hoffman out of work just to find out their plans wouldn't even end up working.
"We could... go somewhere else. Or go back." He paused as he thought of more ideas. "Or we could sit here and talk about the case." He said as a last choice.
Instead of looking over to Hoffman, he stared down at his lap. It didn't feel right to look at him after what just happened. He felt... embarrassed in a way. He knew that if he reacted to something with anger, it would've changed everything. Yet, he did it anyways. He just let it happen.
Hoffman stayed quiet for a moment, letting his eyes settle on Strahm. Really looking at him.
The way his shoulders were still tense, the way his fingers flexed against the steering wheel like he was holding himself back.
Hoffman tapped his fingers one last time before letting his hand still in a gentle grasp against his thigh. He wasnât in a rush to speak.
Instead, he just watched.
There was a strange feeling in Hoffmanâs chest, something he didnât quite have the words for.
After another beat of silence, he finally spoke. "Well," he drawled, tilting his head slightly, "weâve already wasted this much time. Might as well make it worth it."
His voice was even, but there was an edge of something unreadable in it.
Hoffman wasnât sure what he expected Strahm to say next. But he was sure of one thingâhe wasnât ready to leave yet.
"Mhm.." Peter hummed in response, taking his hands off the wheel to try and seem more calm and relaxed. His attention turned to Mark very soon, his eyes hovering over his whole body before meeting his eyes.
He had a strange feeling in his chest every time he looked at Mark. It suddenly felt heavy and felt it got harder to breathe.
The tension in the car was so much more in the office. The way they were much closer than before, the way they had no where else to look but each other, it was all too much. Peter removed his jacket, folding it neatly before setting it down in his lap. Though, he never broke eye contact.
"Have you got anything about the case? Any suspects, any leads, anything? Have you heard anything from the DNA test yet?" Peter decided it would be best to ask a good amount of questions. Then, it would be easier for him to seem less.. awkward and nervous.
Work seemed to be the only thing keeping him sane right now.
Hoffman didnât miss the way Strahm folded his jacketâcareful, deliberate, like he needed to keep his hands occupied. It was almost amusing, the way he tried to seem at ease when everything about him screamed tightly wound.
He let the moment stretch, saying nothing at first. Just watching.
âCouple of things,â he said finally, voice level, unreadable, clearing his throat. âDNA test came back inconclusive. No solid matches.â
Hoffman let that sit between them, waiting to see how Strahm would react.
Mark shifted in his seatâ just enough to take up more space, his arm settling on the center console. Closer.
âThereâs one lead,â Hoffman continued, deliberately unhurried. âGuy who fits the profileâex-con, history of violence, used to work in mechanical engineering.â
Another pause. Then, finally, Hoffman turned his head, meeting his gaze fully.
âYou all right, Strahm?â His voice was smooth, casual, but he knew exactly what he was doing.
Hoffman could feel itâthe tension, the weight pressing down on the space between them. And he liked it.
At first his maintained eye contact, but that proved to be too much for him so he backed off, clearing his throat again.
âIâm not trying to make you nervous.â A lie, and also deflecting some of his own feelings.
"What? I'm fine. I'm not nervous at all, Hoffman." Peter responded, his words sharp and aggressive. He didn't realize until now how tense and nervous his body language was. He shoulder tensed, his jaw clenched, his hands always forming a fist, everything was not normal.
He hated the power Mark held over him. It made him so angry to the point of nausea. Every time Mark did anything better than him, he got jealousâangry. Every time Mark looked at him, he got nervous. He hated the way he just let this happen.
Strahm took a deep breath, placing his arm right next to Hoffman's. "Well, at least we've got something. It's better than what we had before." He said, his voice was very monotoneâdry even.
"I should probably call Perez soon and tell her about this..." Peter said, tapping his finger to a different rhythm than before. It was more aggressive and repetitive, showing both his anger and anxiety in one rhythm.
The way his and Mark's arms were so close made him feel something he couldn't explain. It made it hard to breathe, as if someone were to suck all the air out of his lungs.
[ ooc text : i wrote the second part of this while listening to jealousy, jealousy by olivia rodrigo. feels important to share. ]
Hoffman watched him carefully, his expression unreadable. Strahmâs words were sharp, but they didnât match the way his body was betraying himâso tense he looked ready to snap. Hoffman could practically feel the heat radiating off him, the way his energy buzzed with something dangerously close to frustration. Or something else.
His eyes flicked down to their arms, barely a breath apart. It would take nothing to close that distance. To shift just slightly and press against him, just to see what Strahm would do.
Then Strahm mentioned Perez.
Hoffmanâs fingers, which had been resting idly against his thigh, curled inward before he abruptly moved his arm away, leaning slightly toward the car door. His expression didnât change, but something in his body language didâsomething colder.
"Yeah," he muttered. "You probably should."
Hoffman clenched his jaw, staring straight ahead as if the windshield suddenly held something more interesting than Strahm beside him. The mention of Perez shouldnât bother him, but it did. He knew how much Strahm trusted herâhow easily they worked together, how she could read him in ways Hoffman couldnât.
He didnât like it.
His fingers twitched against his leg, resisting the urge to match Strahmâs rhythm like before. Instead, he let the silence stretch, letting the distance he created sit heavy between them.
âWant some space to call her?â
Strahm noticed how Hoffman tensed as soon as he mentioned Perez, a look of confusion quickly forming on his face. Why did Mark get so weird every time he mentioned Lindsey? Why did he act so weird whenever she was at his desk? It made no sense.
He looked down to see his arm moved away, a feeling of defeat washing over him. They were so close, it was perfect. But clearly, he messed something up to changed the tension they had going for them.
"Uhm, no... I'll just call her later today. She's probably busy anyway, and I don't want to interrupt her." Peter said, slowly removing his arm and placing it onto his lap. He stared at Hoffman, noticing how he would rather stare at nothing then stare at him. Why did it change so quickly?
He coughed, trying to stop the silence between the two. "What should we do?" He asked, trying to use a tone that suggested that he was open to anything, work related or not. At this point, he'd be willing to do anything to get out of this uncomfortable situation.
Strahm started to pick at the sides of his fingernails, messing up his already rough looking fingers. He watched as a small amount of blood formed on his finger once he peeled some skin off, watching it build up but not drip.
It was better to watch than continuing to watch Mark stare out the windshield as if it was much more interesting.
Hoffman exhaled, letting the tension ease from his shoulders as he settled back into his seat. His arm found its way back to the consoleânot quite touching Strahmâs, but close enough that it wasnât a full retreat anymore.
"Alright," he said, tilting his head slightly as if considering their options. "We could hit up that shitty diner a few blocks over. The one with the terrible coffee but decent fries." He shot Strahm a sideways glance, a ghost of a smirk tugging at his lips. "Unless youâre too good for a place that serves their food on plastic trays."
It wasnât just about food anymore, and they both knew it. Hoffmanâs posture was more open again, his voice lacking the sharp edge from earlier.
"And hey," he added, his smirk sharpening just slightly, "maybe if you're lucky, the waitress will think weâre on a date and give you the check. Since, y'know, you were so eager to take me out in the first place."
It was a joke, but not a denial. And the way he looked at Strahm when he said itâsteady, watching for a reactionâmade it clear he wasnât just filling the silence.
âOr maybe one of us can flash our badge and make her feel bad.â He winked. A soft, brief action.
A smirk appeared on Strahm's face, looking up from his hand and back to Hoffman. "I'm fine with the shitty diner, I guess." He said with a hint of sarcasm in his voice at the end.
"And I think we should go with the second idea. Flashing our badges is better than her thinking we're a gay couple." Peter said as he began to start driving, but this time only with one arm. Keeping his arm next to Mark's felt... right.
He began driving out of the parking space, making a promise in his mind that he wouldn't get visibly angry at the people on the road. He would hate to ruin the tension for the hundredth time today. Peter bit down on his lip slightly, mainly doing it to keep his focus on the road.
Peter took a deep breath as soon as he got on the road, trying to seem like he didn't even care about the traffic, but he did. He really did. He actually cared about everything right now. The traffic, the way Hoffman's arm was right next to his, the fact he was driving him to a diner, everything. It all was so much more than it would normally be, but he stayed calm.
At least, he tried to stay calm.
Hoffman stood just outside the diner's entrance, the neon light flickering against his skin, casting him in a glow of red and gold. He flexed his fingers at his sides, still feeling the lingering warmth from where their arms had brushed in the car. It was stupidâinsignificant, really. But it had made something stir deep in his chest, something he wasnât ready to acknowledge.
He glanced over his shoulder, watching Strahm still sitting in the driverâs seat, his fingers tapping against the wheel. For a moment, Hoffman just⊠looked at him. The usual irritation was there, sure, but it was layered with something else, something heavier. He exhaled, shaking his head to himself before rapping his knuckles lightly against the glass door.
"You coming?" His voice was lower than he intended, softer, almost coaxing. He hesitated, then let a smirk tug at his lips. "Or do you just like staring at me from a distance?"
He turned before he could catch Strahmâs expression, stepping inside the diner. The scent of coffee and fryer grease wrapped around him, familiar and grounding. Still, that warmth from the car lingered, settling deep in his chest. As much as he tried to ignore it, deny it, there was no shaking the truthâsomething between them had shifted. And for once, Hoffman wasnât sure if he wanted to fight it.
Peter sighed before slipping his coat on, finally leaving his car. He made sure to lock his car before walking over to the diner with the neon flickering lights. This is not where he exactly wanted to take Mark, but guess that's what he had to deal with for now.
He stepped inside, walking past Hoffman to a small booth all the way in the corner of the diner. He sat in the seat against the wall, waiting patiently for Mark to sit across from him.
It was weird to think about. Taking the man he hated out to get food. Sure, he invited him to talk about 'work' , but they both knew that wasn't going to actually happen. At least, not the whole time.
"I don't really know if I'll eat anything here. Hell, they probably cook dead rats into the food based on what people say about it." Peter said, looking around to see most employees sitting on their phones or talking. Sure, this wasn't ideal, but it would work just fine.
After all, he didn't want things to seem romantic. Peter didn't like Mark that way.
At least, that's what he told himself.
Hoffman leaned back against the cracked vinyl seat, drumming his fingers against the tabletop as he glanced over the laminated menu. It was sticky. Of course it was. He barely looked at the options before setting it aside.
"Dead rats or not, Iâm getting a shake," he said, flagging down a half-interested waitress. "Chocolate. Extra thick." His voice was smooth, deliberate, like he was making a point. He didn't care if the place was a dumpâhe was here, and he was going to enjoy something.
Once the waitress walked off, he leaned forward slightly, resting his forearms on the table. His gaze flicked over Strahm, taking in the tension in his shoulders, the way he was still pretending like this wasnât something. It was almost endearing.
"You know, if you keep looking that uncomfortable, people are gonna think I dragged you here against your will." His smirk was slow, knowing. "Or worse, that this actually is a date and you're just playing hard to get."
He let that sit between them, watching for the reaction. Strahm always had a tell, no matter how much he tried to hide it. And Hoffman? He lived for it.
Peter hummed in response to Mark, quickly shaking his head once the waiter looked at him with a look of boredom and impatience, waiting for an order. He sighed as soon as the waiter walked off, shutting his eyes for a moment before opening them to meet Mark leaned more towards him.
"I would way rather have them think you kidnapped me or something. I don't want people to think we're on a date. Or that I'm gay." As soon as he spoke those last four words, it hurt something in him. He didn't understand why though. He wasn't gay. That's what he's been telling everyone for years.
These feelings were so confusing. He hated Hoffman, he knew he did. Something was... different. Usually, he would be tearing his hair out by nowâbut it was different now. He was less angry.
Strahm tried to relax his shoulder, but failed. He hated how much he seemed so nervous and shut off when he wanted to seem relaxed. He wanted to seem more normal, but that was hard when he wasn't normal even when hating Mark.
Hoffman let out a quiet snort, shaking his head slightly as he leaned back again, giving Strahm just a bit more spaceâbut not much.
âRelax, Strahm,â he muttered, voice low and edged with amusement. âNo one in here gives a shit about what you are.â His fingers drummed idly against the table as he watched the way Peterâs shoulders stayed locked in place, the tension rolling off of him in waves.
That reactionâthat was interesting. It wasnât just irritation or the usual disdain that Strahm carried whenever he was around him. This was something else. Hoffman bit his lip in thought.
Hoffman tilted his head slightly, his eyes scanning Strahmâs face, catching the way his mouth pressed into a tight line, the way his fingers curled against his thigh like he was trying to hold something back.
He could push. It would be easy. A well-placed comment, a teasing smirk, just enough of a prod to see what would happen if he hit the right nerve.
But, for once, he didnât.
Instead, he exhaled, shaking his head as he reached for his glass of water, taking a slow sip before setting it back down. âBesides, if I did kidnap you, Iâd make sure you at least got something better than a damn sandwich out of it.â
The words were casual, thrown out with just enough humor to make it unclear whether he was joking or not. But underneath, it was a testâa different kind of test. Would Strahm push back? Laugh it off? Or would he keep unraveling right in front of him?
Peter felt like he was melting away. He was so focused on what other people around him thought. People he would most likely never even see again. The idea of a random stranger thinking something that wasn't true made him freak out. What if he actually saw them again and they thought he was something he wasn't? What if that made people avoid him? He hated it.
"Yeah. Sure." He mumbled, looking over Mark's shoulder for a second to scan the whole diner and all the workers. Another habit he had to avoid a situation. This time, the situation was right in front of himâstaring with a smirk that showed that he was clearly interested by Peter's reactions to things.
He looked down at his lap, fixing the previous creases he made in his pants from gripping them. It was weird, he felt a sudden need to look nice. Normally, if he was at work, he never cared. It was just work after all. Today thoughâit was different. Very different.
"Oh, so if you were to kidnap someone, you would cook them a full meal?" Strahm asked with a hint of sarcasm in his voice, trying to come across as more calm and relaxed. His tone was calm, but his body language was completely different. His body language resembled a stray cat whenever you try to pet it. Tense, intimidating, aggressive.
He didn't mean to come off like this, but it was better than coming off nice, or worseâromantic. Which sucked, because deep down there was something going on. Something other than hate or anger. But different from what he felt around Lindsey...
Hoffman let out a low chuckle, shaking his head as he leaned back slightly, arms crossing over his chest. âWhat, you think Iâd half-ass it?â His smirk remained, but his gaze was steady, watching every nervous shift, every flicker of hesitation in Strahmâs expression.
Hoffman tilted his head slightly. âIâm just saying, if I were the kind of guy to kidnap someone, Iâd at least put in the effort. Full meal. Maybe some wine. Make it a whole experience.â His voice was even, casual, but the weight behind his words lingered in the space between them.
He let the thought settle for a moment before reaching for his drink, taking another slow sip. âNot that youâd appreciate it,â he added, tone bordering on dry amusement. âYou strike me as the type to complain about the wine pairing.â
He was still testing, still pushingâjust enough to see how Strahm would react.
"Well, I believe that it would be a bit stupid to make a full meal. You don't want the person you kidnapped to get attached to you. That'll just cause so many more problems." Strahm said as if he had experience in stuff like this. Obviously, he didn't. It was more of the fact that he's dealt with multiple situations like this.
Peter's voice was less aggressive, finally showing that some of the tension and stress had left his body. It felt like heavy sandbags being lifted off his shoulders, giving him the ability to finally seem a bit more confinement rather than stuck in his own skin.
"Of course I complain about wine pairing. It's basically everything when it comes to a nice meal! Tell me, would you pair a glass of Pinot Noir with a steak? No. You would pair something like Cabernet Sauvignon." It was obvious he was good at this subject. Which you probably wouldn't guess by getting one simple look at him.
Peter checked his watch, quickly looking back up to Mark. "We should probably head back soon." He said, putting his coat over his arms as quickly, basically preparing himself to leave in a quick amount of time.
Hoffman raised an eyebrow, watching Strahm with something between amusement and intrigue. The shift in his demeanor didnât go unnoticedâhis voice had lost some of that earlier edge, his posture a little less rigid. It was subtle, but it was there.
âDidnât take you for a wine guy,â Hoffman mused, tilting his head slightly. âThatâs a real specific take for someone who spends most of his days running on burnt coffee.â His smirk lingered, but there was something else in his gaze nowâsomething considering.
He didnât know why it was so damn fascinating, watching Strahm loosen up, even just a little. Maybe it was because he knew how rare it was. Strahm was all sharp edges and tension, always coiled like a spring. Seeing him talk about something so mundane, something he actually seemed passionate about, was... different.
Hoffman exhaled through his nose, glancing at his own watch before rolling his shoulders back. âYeah, wouldnât want anyone thinking we actually enjoyed this.â The words were teasing, but there was an undertone to themâsomething unspoken but lingering.
As Strahm pulled on his coat with that same urgency, Hoffman just watched him for a moment before finally moving to stand. He didnât rush. He didnât need to. Strahm was already rattled enough without him adding to it.
But still, as they stepped outside into the cold, he let the silence settle just long enough to make Strahm wonder what he was thinkingâbefore finally breaking it with a low, amused murmur:
âYou talk a big game about wine pairings, but next time, Iâm picking the place.â
He paused for a moment, thinking if he should even offer but he did, anyways: âWant me to drive the way back?â He asked, staring ahead.
"Really? I'm a pretty big wine guy. Me and Perez tend to talk about it a lot, I guess you just don't hear us." He found himself bringing up Lindsey again. He knew that it wasn't a good idea. He knew that everything would shift once again after bringing her up. Yet, he still did it.
He sighed before walking over to the waiter, putting down a random ten dollar bill from his wallet before walking outside into the cold with Hoffman. The cold hit him like a punch, causing him to exhale a deep breath.
"Well, I wasn't going to bring you to a place where they pair wine to discuss work, Mark." The comment was supposed to come off playful, but instead came off harsh. He always struggled to control his tone, which was the reason he spoke with such a monotone, bored voice.
Peter unlocked the car doors, looking over to Mark. "Yeah, sure. It'll be better for you to drive anyway." He said, getting in the car before discussing anything else. He would rather die than stand a moment longer in the cold weather.
Hoffmanâs jaw tightened at the mention of Perez. Of course, Strahm had to bring her up. He always did, like it was some kind of reflex. And every time, it hit Hoffman the same wayâan irritating little twist in his gut that he couldn't quite shake.
He didnât say anything right away, just let his eyes linger on Strahm as they stepped out into the cold. The wind bit at his skin, but he barely registered it. He was too busy watching the way Strahm hunched his shoulders, the way he exhaled sharply like the cold was trying to rip the breath from his lungs.
Hoffman scoffed at the comment about work, catching the way Strahm avoided looking directly at him. Yeah, sure. You werenât gonna bring me to a place like that for work. But youâd bring Perez, wouldnât you?
He didnât voice the thought. Instead, he followed Strahm into the car, sliding into the driverâs seat with a little more force than necessary. The second he started the engine, the heater kicked on, filling the space with warmthâbut Hoffman still felt that simmering irritation sitting low in his chest.
He glanced at Strahm. Something about him made his fingers tighten on the steering wheel. âYou talk about wine like some expert, but I bet if Perez were here, youâd have some bullshit poetic thing to say about it,â he muttered, keeping his voice level, but there was an unmistakable sharpness to it.
He wasnât sure what he wanted out of that commentâmaybe just to see Strahmâs reaction, to make him squirm the way Hoffman felt himself doing internally. Because for all his control, for all his carefully placed remarks, something about Strahm had a way of slipping under his skin. And it pissed him off. Well, he didn't know if he was more pissed off at that or the fact that he didn't understand why he was pissed off in the first place.
Peter put his hands between his knees in an attempt to warm them up, staring down as he did. He couldn't bring himself to look at Mark. He couldn't bring himself to even quickly glance at him. He already felt everything shift as soon as he brought up Lindsey.
Just as he was in his thoughts, Mark spoke.
The words stabbed him, causing his stomach to turn. Not out of anxiety, but rather anger. It made him so angry knowing that Hoffman hated Perez for no real reason. It made his blood boil. She wasn't a bad detective, she was kind, she never came off as aggressive, she was so perfect. Yet, Mark found a way to hate her.
"What do you mean, Hoffman? What is that supposed to mean." The first time was a question. The second time was in demand. A demand for answers. He was tired of how he always found a way to get mad at Lindsey when she has never done anything to him.
Strahm still avoided eye contact, but it was clear that he was angry. Even without the look of rage and hatred in his eyes, anyone could still tell he was angry. The way his words became sharp and intense again, the way his body tensed up when he spoke, the way his hands turned into fist in seconds.
It was all too obvious.
Hoffman didnât answer right away. He just drummed his fingers against the steering wheel, exhaling through his nose as if Strahmâs reaction wasnât exactly what he was hoping for.
But it was.
The sharpness in his voice, the way his body locked upâHoffman knew that anger well. He knew how it made Strahmâs breath come a little quicker, how it made him grip at things too tightly. And maybe it was fucked up, but he liked knowing he could pull that reaction from him so easily.
âWhat do I mean?â Hoffman repeated, dragging the words out slow, testing the weight of them on his tongue. His gaze flicked toward Strahm, watching the way he kept his eyes pointed anywhere but at him. Coward.
âI mean exactly what I said. You donât talk about me the way you talk about her.â His voice was even, but there was something under itâsomething Strahm wasnât going to like if he looked too closely.
His grip on the wheel tightened. âAnd donât pretend like you donât know what I mean,â he added, lower this time, but more pointed. âEvery time she comes up, you get allââ He waved a hand vaguely, knowing Strahm would get it. âLike sheâs so perfect. Like she can do no wrong. So yeah, maybe I donât like her, Strahm. Maybe I donât like the way you talk about her.â
His jaw clenched. He hadnât meant to say that last part, but now it was out there, sitting in the space between them. And for once, he was the one who looked away first.
Peter's breathing was quick and heavy, as if he was holding back so many things. Which, he was. Instead of yelling, he let Mark finish. He let him finish his ranting while holding eye contact. His eyes were angry, hateful, and disappointed. His eyes held a look that was almost unreadable, yet so readable at the same time.
He hated hearing these words. He hated hearing about someone not liking Lindsey. He hated listening to someone not thinking she was perfect. He hated hearing that Mark hated her. He hated Mark.
He felt his head began to hurt from the rage and all the thoughts piling up at once. He couldn't keep them hidden much longer. He had to express them somehow.
"What's the true reason you can't handle me talking about someone else? What is it, Hoffman? What makes you, a grown man who I haven't known most of my life, crave the attention I give to someone else? What makes you feel the need to act like an angry pathetic dog who craves attention? What is it?" He spoke, his words spilling out. He couldn't stop now.
"Why would I need to talk about you the way I talk about her? Do you believe you are more important than Lindsey in my mind? Do you truly believe you are better than her?" He thought for a moment, collecting his ability to breathe before continuing.
"I talk about her that way because she is perfect. She does no wrong. When has she ever wronged you? When has she wronged me? When has she wronged anyone? You can't think of a single example, can you? That's because she hasn't wronged anyone. You have no real reason to hate her other than jealousy, which doesn't even make sense because I could've sworn you hated me just yesterday. Why are you suddenly so jealous over someone I've known for years?"
He stopped himself, but his body language showed how angry he still was. His eyes, his hands, his shoulders, everything. It just showed how angry he was. Even then, that didn't do it justice.
Hoffmanâs grip on the steering wheel was so tight that his knuckles were white, the leather groaning under his fingers as he tried to force the anger back down. The air between them was thick with the tension, and it only got worse as Strahmâs wordsâsharp, biting, full of that damn righteous angerâsettled in the car, suffocating everything else.
Every word from Strahm twisted something inside him, but it wasnât just anger. It was jealousy.
Hoffman could feel the heat radiating from him, the sharpness in his voice, his body practically vibrating with the intensity of it. Jealous of Lindsey. Thatâs what it was, isnât it? But no. He couldnât admit that. Not out loud. Not even to himself.
His jaw locked so tight that it hurt, and it was taking all his self-control not to lash out. But as much as he hated admitting it, he wasnât just angry. No, it was more complicated than that.
"Really, Strahm?" Hoffmanâs voice was low, too low. It felt like it came from somewhere deep inside him, almost like he was letting something slip without meaning to. âYou wanna act like Iâm just throwing a fit, like Iâm jealous?â His words came out rough, but there was something else thereâsomething softer. A pull, just beneath the anger. âYou think I care about her more than you?â
He took a slow breath, still staring at the road, forcing himself to focus on the sound of his heartbeat. It wasnât enough to calm the storm inside him. His eyes flickered briefly to Strahm, watching the way he held himself, how tense and wound up he was. That tightness in his jaw, those clenched fists. Hoffman hated it. But he also liked it. Too much.
âIf I cared about her that much,â Hoffman continued, his voice a little quieter now, almost to the point where Strahm had to lean in to hear him, âI wouldnât be here. Wouldnât be here with you, would I?â
His pulse quickened as he said it, that same rush of heat climbing up his neck. He hated how it soundedâtoo much like he was admitting something, too much like he was being vulnerable when heâd never let anyone see that side of him.
His hands tightened on the wheel again, but it wasnât just anger this time. His thoughts were swirling, clouded with the weight of what he couldnât say. Couldnât admit.
He glanced at Strahm again, eyes narrowing, but this time it was different. He couldnât look away. There was something else there nowâsomething raw, something almost intimate in the way Strahm looked at him.
âIs that what you want, Peter?â Hoffmanâs voice was softer now, barely a whisper, a challenge. âYou really think Iâm jealous of her? Or is it that you just canât handle the idea of me being here instead of her?â
His heart thudded in his chest, the words spilling out before he could stop them. His stomach twisted. Why couldnât he stop? Why did it feel like something had shifted, like the whole conversation was moving toward something else entirely?
The silence between them stretched out, the only sound the hum of the engine and the beating of their hearts. Hoffman wasnât sure if Strahm could feel it tooâthe way the air had thickened with unspoken words. The way it felt like they were suddenly standing at the edge of something they werenât quite ready for.
But it was too late. The tension was already there, and Hoffman knew, without a doubt, that it wasnât just about Lindsey anymore.
And he hated himself for that.
Peter suddenly felt the tension for once, actually backing off. Something told him he needed to back off this situation before he said anything else or anything worse. He suddenly, for some reason, felt bad. It didn't make sense though. He shouldn't feel bad. He had a point, Mark did seem jealous of Lindsey. But did he maybe take it too far?
He took a breath through his nose and out his mouth. "Mark, I'm not saying you're jealous, I'm saying it seems like it. Every time I mention Lindsey, you act like it's the end of the damn world. You get all tense and angry as if you hate her for simply being in my life."
He spoke as if he hated the idea of Hoffman being jealous, but he really didn't. He enjoyed the idea of how he could ruin someones mood just by simply bringing up one person.
"All I want to know is why. Why does your mood change? Why do you get so tense? Why do you hate the idea that I think she's perfect?" Strahm poured out his words as if his mouth was a faucet for his brain.
The air between them was too much. It was thick, it was overwhelming. It drove him so insane how angry they both were. All he could hear was his own heartbeat in his ears.
"I just need to know. Why don't you like Lindsey?" He wasn't demanding anymore. He was pleading. He wanted to know why because he couldn't handle watching how he looked at her with such anger and jealousy every time they spoke at work.
Hoffmanâs grip on the steering wheel was relentless as Strahmâs words hung in the air, thick and heavy, pressing down on him like a weight he couldnât shake off. The space between them felt suffocating, as if every word Strahm said was just making the tension worse. But something in the way Strahm spoke caught him off guardâthere was a vulnerability there, a softness to his tone that Mark wasnât used to. Pleading. It had always been anger before, but now it was something else. Something that made Hoffman feel like he was walking a razorâs edge.
"You really wanna know, Peter?" Hoffmanâs voice was low, rough with something that wasnât anger anymore. It was too much to admit, too much to say, but it was right there, clawing at the back of his throat.
He took a breath, feeling the heat of Strahmâs words pressing into him. Mark wasnât ready to give in, not yet. He couldnât be. But damn, it was hard to ignore how his chest tightened when Strahm spoke with that tone. Pleading, vulnerable, asking for answers he couldnât give. Hoffman couldnât explain it, but there was something in Strahmâs eyesâthe way he looked at him, the way his words tangled up like a question and a challenge all in oneâthat made him want to say everything. To tell him the truth, to finally admit what had been gnawing at him all this time.
Markâs eyes flickered to Strahm, a quick glance that lingered too long. He tried to look away, but couldnât. He just... couldnât.
âI donât hate her,â Hoffman finally muttered, voice laced with frustration, but there was something deeper in it too. Something that was hard for him to articulate. âItâs not about her. Itâs not about her at all.â
The words came out harsher than he meant, but it wasnât about Lindsey, was it? It was about Peter. And that was something Hoffman wasnât ready to face.
âYou wanna know why my mood changes when you talk about her?â Hoffmanâs voice dropped even lower, almost a growl. âItâs because Iâm hereâwith youâand I hear you talk about her like sheâs some saint. Like sheâs perfect. Like sheâs everything you need, everything you want. And I canât stand it.â
The words slipped out before he could stop them, raw and unfiltered. His chest heaved, and his heart was beating too fast, like it was trying to escape. He could feel the shift, the intensity of the moment pulling them both into a place neither of them were ready for. But Hoffman couldnât help it. He couldnât keep it in any longer.
He turned his head slowly, eyes locking with Strahmâs, searching for somethingâanythingâin his face that would tell him he was still in control, that he hadnât just said too much.
âYou think Iâm jealous of her? Maybe... maybe Iâm just jealous that she gets to have you, and I donât.â
There it was. The words that were always just beneath the surface. He could feel the heat rising in his face, the tightness in his chest, and the way his hands were trembling ever so slightly. He hated how weak it made him feel, how vulnerable.
âBut you donât get it, do you?â Hoffman continued, his voice almost a whisper now, the anger simmering just beneath the surface. âI donât care if sheâs perfect, Peter. Itâs you. Itâs you I canât stand when you talk about her like that. Because itâs not about her. Itâs about... us.â
The words hung in the air, fragile and heavy. He hated how much they revealed, how much of himself he had just let slip. But there was no taking them back now. And as much as he tried to hold it all together, his chest still ached with that unspoken truthâhe had crossed a line he wasnât sure he could walk back from.
The silence stretched between them, thick and suffocating, until it felt like they were both drowning in it. Hoffman wasnât sure what came next. He wasnât sure if he wanted to know. But it was too late to pull back now.
Strahm stared blankly at Hoffman, his angry gaze soon becoming soft. Instead of cutting him off, he listened quietly. He didn't react in any form, though. It didn't feel right. Even a simple nod felt wrong. That would make it seem like he agreed with his feelings, but he didn't. He hadn't connected those feelings inside him just yet.
He wanted until he was silent and the silence was basically drowning the both of them before finally speaking. "Mark... I- I don't know what to say." He said, his mind not fully grasping everything that was said. It still hung in the air, driving him to insanity every second. He wasn't gay. He knew it.
"I'm not... well, I'm not gay. And Lindsey doesn't have me, no one has me." His words came off more aggressive than he wished. "Not even you, Hoffman. You don't have me." Those words weren't supposed to come out. He didn't want to come off as mean. The emotions were just too much to handle, though. Too much to care about how his words came across.
"There is no us. The only us we have going on is a work situation, Mark." He hesitated saying his name. "There can't be any of us. I'm sorry, but that's not who I am. And I'm not going to lead you on and pretend that's who I am. I clearly already lead you on enough..."
The last part came out as a whisper, like he was ashamed. Embarrassed even. He never felt bad, but he did this time. He didn't know why, but he did. He felt horrible, actually. It sat so uncomfortably in his stomach he couldn't help but almost gag. Why did he feel so bad?
Why did he regret everything he said?
Hoffmanâs chest tightened as Strahm spoke, each word hitting him like a physical blow. He hadnât expected Peter to say any of thatâhe hadnât expected any of it, really. But the sting of the words, the sharpness in Peterâs voice, felt like a blade to his gut. He hadnât thought that hearing Peter reject him would hurt this much. But it did. It hurt more than he ever thought possible.
When Strahm said those words, âIâm not gayâ, it felt like the ground beneath Mark's feet shifted. It felt like everything he had just laid out, all the things he had been thinking, sayingâfeelingâwas being slammed down in front of him like some hard truth he wasnât ready to hear.
And then the next partââNot even you, Hoffmanââstung deeper. The way Peter said it wasnât meant to be cruel, but it felt like it. Markâs hand clenched into a fist on the steering wheel, knuckles white, as if the tension in his body might somehow find an outlet through sheer force.
But it didnât.
He felt the weight of Peterâs words sitting heavily in the car between them, suffocating him, making him feel smaller than he ever had before. He didnât know what to say to thatâhow to fight back against something so⊠absolute. So final.
Still, there was something in Peterâs tone that shifted, something quieter, something almost⊠regretful. Embarrassed.
Hoffmanâs heart slammed in his chest as Peter whispered the last part, âI clearly already lead you on enough.â
For a moment, Mark couldnât breathe. It was like the air itself had been sucked out of the car, and he was left grasping at whatever was left.
No, Peter didnât want him. He didnât want this.
But there was that whisper of regret that stayed with Hoffman, swirling in his mind. He could see it in Peterâs eyesâthe way they shifted away from him, unable to meet his gaze. And the way he apologized, despite not wanting to admit anything, despite the layers of denial. There was something there. Something Mark wasnât sure if he wanted to understand, but he had to. It ate at him.
He slowly turned his head, his jaw clenching as he held Peterâs gaze, searching for the truth beneath his words.
âI donât need you to lead me on, Peter,â Hoffman said, his voice softer, almost gentle in a way that didnât quite fit the angry edge he usually carried. âIâm not asking for that. But you canât just pretend like I donât see whatâs going on. You donât get to throw this all away just because itâs easier for you.â
The words came out before he could stop them, and though they werenât meant to sound desperate, something in his voice cracked. Something in him trembled under the weight of what he was saying.
âIâm not gonna lie to you, Peter.â He paused, trying to catch his breath, his chest tight. âI... I donât know what the hellâs going on either. But I know Iâm not just some... work colleague to you. Not anymore.â His voice dropped lower. âI see it in the way you act around me. I feel it. Hell, Iâve felt it for a while now.â
He hesitated, staring out the windshield, before glancing back at Peter. His eyes were darker now, a fire simmering beneath them. He couldnât stop himself. He was burning up inside.
âIâm not perfect either, Peter,â he continued, the vulnerability creeping in. âBut donât sit there and pretend like thereâs nothing between us. Youâre not as cold as you think you are.â
It was out before he could stop it, his voice barely above a whisper, but there was a finality to it that lingered in the air.
The silence hung between them again, but this time, it was different. It wasnât just an empty, suffocating thing. It was charged. And as much as Mark hated to admit it, the way Peter wouldnât meet his eyesâthe way he avoided him nowâtold him everything he needed to know.
Peter stared down at his lap, picking at his cuticles to try and distract himself. That was working until Mark said the words. The words that killed everything inside of him. The words that stabbed him in the stomach. The words that made his blood boil.
' You donât get to throw this all away just because itâs easier for you. '
These words pained him. But not in a way that upset him, but in a way that angered him. He wasn't throwing anything away. He tried being nice, but clearly that didn't work. He wasn't gay.
"Listen, Hoffman. I've already told you, I'm not gay. I've never been gay, I've never though I was gay, I'm not gay. I'm not going to let yourself continue to believe that I am. It's not only hurting me, but also hurting you. At this point, it feels like you're leading yourself on."
The words came out in a harsh tone, his words aggressive and mean. He barked back like a dog. In this situation, he was like an angry, lost dog. A dog who needed comfort deep down.
He didn't want to make the situation worse, but it was hard with everything Mark said. the words ' But donât sit there and pretend like thereâs nothing between us. Youâre not as cold as you think you are. ' echoed throughout his head, causing his blood to just boil more.
Soon, he got to a point in anger where he wasn't even angry at Mark as much anymore, it was mostly anger towards himself.
He looked up to look out the windshield, sighing before opening his mouth to speak. His words came out in a low whisper as if he was checking in with himself.
"I'm not gay..."
Mark's eyes locked onto Peter's face, searching for somethingâanythingâto tell him that this wasnât over. But it was clear Peter wasnât giving him anything, just sitting there, picking at his cuticles, trying to hold it all together. The tension in the air was suffocating, and Mark could feel every inch of it tightening around him, his chest growing heavier with each passing second.
When Peter spoke, his voice was sharp, the words like a slap to the face. âIâm not gay. Iâve never been gay, Iâve never thought I was gay, Iâm not gay.â The rapid fire of it made Mark flinch, even though heâd expected it. But it still hurt, hearing Peter say it like that. Like it was something to be ashamed of.
Hoffmanâs jaw clenched, and he leaned forward slightly, his voice low but cutting. âIâm not asking you to be anything youâre not, Peter. But you canât sit there and act like thereâs nothing between us when you know damn well there is.â
Peterâs wordsâthe harshness in his tone, the way he barked back, like a wounded animalâhit a nerve that Mark didnât know existed. But then something else shifted in Peterâs voice, something softer, quieter, that Mark almost didnât catch. Peter looked out the windshield, and Mark could see the way his shoulders slumped slightly, like the anger was draining out of him, replaced with something else. Something less certain.
Mark leaned back in his seat, eyes narrowing, not willing to let Peter get away with this. "Youâre not fooling me, Strahm. Youâre not as cold as you act. You can say all you want that youâre not interested in meâIâm not stupid, I get it. But donât act like I donât see whatâs going on when you look at me like that." His voice cracked with frustration, but he didnât stop. He couldnât. "Youâre running from something. And I donât know what it is, but I see it in the way you pull away, in the way you shut down every time we get close." His eyes flickered toward Peter. "Youâre lying to yourself, Peter. And itâs not just about me. Itâs about you."
The silence that followed was heavier than anything before it, thick with unspoken words and tangled emotions. Mark's heart was hammering in his chest, but he didnât know what to do with it. He wanted to reach over, shake Peter, make him see the truth, but he couldnât. He wasnât sure if Peter was even listening anymore, if the words were getting through to him.
When Peter finally spoke again, his voice was a whisper, almost as if he was saying it more to himself than Mark. "Iâm not gay..."
Markâs eyes softened at the quiet admission. There was a crack in Peterâs façade, a fracture that Mark hadnât expected to see. Heâd seen the anger, the cold detachment, the resistance. But thisâthis was different. This was something raw. Something that made Markâs heart stutter, even if he didnât want it to.
âYou donât have to keep telling me that,â Mark said quietly, his voice surprisingly gentle, as though trying to reach something inside Peter. He leaned forward again, just a little. âI know. I know youâre not âgay,â Peter. But thatâs not what Iâm asking for.â His voice caught on the last word. âIâm asking you to stop running. From me. From whatever the hell it is thatâs scaring you.â
There was a long pause as Mark let the words settle in the air between them. He didnât know what would happen next, or if Peter would even listen. But there was no going back now. He had to say it. He had to give Peter the chance to decide. Whether they could move past all of this or if it would just tear them apart.
Peter still wouldnât meet his eyes, his gaze fixed on the windshield, but Mark didnât look away. He couldnât. Not when there was still a chance. Not when the weight of everything between them was still there, waiting for a spark to set it off.
Strahm felt himself breaking, but hid it. He hid it to the best of his abilities. But if you looked closely, very closely, you'd see a wounded man with glossy eyes. Eyes that weren't helping hide the fact he was upset. Eyes that held so much more emotion than his own words. Eyes you would see on an animal being hunted. Eyes that held fear.
"I'm not-" His voice cracked, but he quickly covered it with a cough. "I'm not running. I'm not scared of anything." No matter how much he tried to hide how he was really feeling, you could still slightly see it. His hands were now shaking and his leg began to bounce up and down quickly, making a faint but noticeable tapping sound.
"I'm not hiding from you." He said, but something in his mind told him he was hiding from Hoffman. Something told him he was hiding from everything. It had gotten to a point that he couldn't hide his feelings anymore. His whole body was tensed up as if protecting himself from words, his eyes fixated on the cars ahead of them more than anything, his leg continued to bounce but at a faster pace, and finally, his lip. He hadn't even noticed, but his lip began to drip blood again. This time though, he didn't wipe it away. He didn't want any hands near his face, even his own.
"And I shut down when we're close because I don't like you, Hoffman. You do nothing but-" He stopped himself, realizing what he said. It was too late. He can't just go back in time and stop himself. These words were stuck in the car.
All of their words were stuck in the car, along with his heart.
Mark could feel it, the tension in the air thick and almost suffocating. Every breath Peter took seemed heavy, labored, and every movement of his hands, his leg bouncing, told Mark something was wrong. The words caught in the air, stuck between them like a wall, and Mark was starting to feel like he was trapped on the other side of it.
Peterâs voice cracked, and Markâs heart skipped. He saw it. The way Peterâs hands shook, the way his leg tapped frantically, the slight gloss in his eyes that Peter tried so hard to hide. Peter was on the edge of breaking down, but he was doing everything in his power to keep it together, to keep his walls up. Mark knew that feeling. He recognized it. It was the same one he wore every damn day.
When Peter spoke, his words were harsh, almost defensive, but Mark could hear the cracks underneath. "I'm not running. I'm not scared of anything." But Mark saw it. That wasnât the truth. The shaking, the trembling lip, the way Peterâs eyes kept avoiding him. The truth was slipping through the cracks in his defenses.
Peter said he wasnât scared, but Mark could hear it in his voice, see it in the way his body tensed up. He could almost smell itâfear. Fear of something bigger than either of them could handle.
âIâm not hiding from you,â Peter said, and the words didnât even make it out like they were supposed to. Mark could hear the hesitation. The vulnerability. Peter was lying to himself. But Mark wasnât about to call him out on itânot yet, anyway. Heâd been there before, too. He understood what it was like to keep those walls up, to lock everything inside until it made you want to suffocate.
But then Peter spoke again. His words cut through the thick air like a knife, too sharp to ignore. "And I shut down when we're close because I don't like you, Hoffman. You do nothing but-"
Peter stopped himself, and Mark felt the weight of the words that hadn't been finished. The ones that lingered like a shadow, threatening to reveal something deeper than just anger or confusion. Something that could change everything.
Markâs pulse raced. He wanted to push him further, demand to know what Peter had really meant, but he knew better than to rush it. It wasnât the time for that. Still, the words hung in the air, heavy, suffocating. You do nothing but... what?
Markâs eyes softened just slightly as he watched Peter's lip, the blood starting to drip again. Peter didnât wipe it away, didnât even move his hand. It was like he wanted to bleed, wanted to feel it. Wanted to show Mark that he wasnât as cold as he kept pretending to be.
Mark knew the feeling too well. It was a strange sort of comfort to know that Peter was hurting, too. As fucked up as it sounded, it was a relief to know Peter wasnât the stone wall he tried so hard to be. And maybe, just maybe, Mark could find a way in. Even if it scared the hell out of him.
âPeterâŠâ Markâs voice was softer now, almost hesitant, as if he was treading carefully through the words. He didnât want to break Peter any more than he already was, but he couldnât stand watching him fight this on his own.
Mark reached out by putting his arm on the centre console, just slightly, his fingers brushing the air near Peterâs hand, though he didnât touch him. He wasnât sure if Peter would pull away or not. He wasnât sure if Peter even wanted him near.
But the words that followed from Peter hit Mark like a punch to the gut. âI donât like you.â And it stung more than anything Mark could have expected. He knew Peter wasnât ready for anything else, but that hurt. Hurt more than he wanted to admit.
Mark leaned back in his seat, his heart pounding in his chest. He couldnât let Peter see the effect those words had on him, but it felt like a thousand knives had pierced through his chest all at once.
âRight.â Markâs voice was tight, holding back something deep inside. No, Peter. You donât just shut down and say you donât like me and expect me to walk away.
But Mark didnât say that. He didnât push. He couldnât. Not yet. The words Peter had left unfinished were eating away at him, though. The silence was deafening.
And in that silence, Mark could feel itâthe shift, the crack in Peterâs armor. Peter might not have been ready to admit anything, but Mark could see it now. He could see the truth bleeding through, and he wasnât going anywhere.
Not yet.
They drove in silence for a few more moments, the tension between them almost unbearable. Then, finally, they pulled into the parking lot of the station. The headlights cut through the night, casting long shadows across the concrete. The sound of the engine slowing to a stop filled the car, but neither of them made a move to get out immediately.
Mark just sat there for a second, his eyes still on Peter. He could feel the weight of the moment hanging between them, almost like it was going to shatter if either of them spoke again.
After what felt like an eternity, Mark exhaled quietly and opened the door. "Weâre here," he said, his voice barely above a whisper. He didnât know what else to say. He didnât know how to fix what had been broken, or if it could even be fixed at all. All he knew was that he wasnât leaving yet.
Peter noticed his arm on the center console, moving his arm away quickly. Quicker than he'd ever moved away from Mark. His movements were like a scared injured animal. Quick to escape the touch that could save him. The touch that could fix him.
Strahm completely dissociated, staring out to the cars. The blood continued down his chin, reaching the bottom before he finally wiped it off with a quick movement of his arm. The arm farthest from Mark. Seeming like he was trying to hide he could move at all.
He stayed in his thoughts, trying his best to breathe through his walls finally breaking. They couldn't break. He couldn't let a new person into his mind, anything could happen.
His brain flooded with thoughts. They were all about Hoffman. What if he was starting to hate him? What if he was right? He's only trying to help. For once, he's being a good person and I just can't soak it in. Maybe I'm just a horrible person. He's probably beginning to hate me now. He probably-
Suddenly, Mark's voice pulled him out of the thoughts.
He looked at Hoffman and quickly nodded, leaving his car and locking it before speed walking to the office. As soon as he made it inside, he packed up everything at his desk he brought in. He had to leave, and he had to leave now.
Hoffman sat there for a second, watching Strahmâs back as he disappeared inside. He could still see the tension in his posture, the way his shoulders curled in like he was trying to shrink himself down, trying to vanish into the walls.
Mark exhaled, shaking his head as he rubbed his hand over his mouth.
This was spiraling. Fast.
He should just let him go. Let Strahm run himself ragged, let him pack up, let him storm out of the office and pretend none of this ever happened. Itâd be the easy thing to do. Itâd be the smart thing to do.
But Mark was shit at doing the smart thing when it came to Peter.
With a grunt, he pushed open the car door and got out, walking toward the building. His steps were heavy, purposeful, his jaw set as he shoved through the front doors.
Strahm was already at his desk, movements frantic, throwing his stuff into his bag like he was trying to outrun something. Maybe himself.
Mark lingered in the doorway for a moment before finally stepping forward.
âYou leaving or running?â His voice was level, but there was an edge beneath it.
Mark scoffed, stepping closer. âYou text me, drag me over here, and now youâre bolting? What the hell was this, Peter?â
He wasnât even sure what he wanted Strahm to say. He just wanted him to say something. Anything.
Mark clenched his jaw. Fine. If Strahm wanted to run, let him. But Mark wasnât going to stand there like an idiot, waiting for an answer that would never come.
âForget it,â he muttered, turning on his heel to leave.
Strahm put his bag over his shoulder, rushing to stand next to Hoffman. "Listen... I want to talk to you about.." He thought about how to word what they had going. "This. About me running. Just follow me so we can get it over with."
Peter said as he pulled a cigarette out of his pocket, placing it in my mouth as he searched for a lighter while he walked. He never smoked. He hadn't smoked in awhile, actually. He always just... carried one around. It was a habit from years ago he never let go.
As soon as he stepped out, he lit the cigarette.
What was he going to say? Sorry for being confused? Sorry for letting his anger get the best of him? Sorry for being the man Hoffman fell in love with? He couldn't wrap his head around an idea.
He stood with his jaw clenched in the cold as he waited for Mark who soon followed behind him. It was time to confront his emotions for once in his life.
For once, he almost felt in control of his emotions.
Hoffman watched Strahm fumbling for a lighter, his movements sharp, tense. He never smokedâMark knew that. At least, not anymore. So why now?
With a sigh, Mark reached into his jacket pocket, pulling out his own cigarette and lighter. He flicked it open, the flame casting a small, flickering glow between them. Instead of lighting his own first, he held it out toward Strahm, his gaze steady.
âHere.â.
The small gesture felt heavier than it should have, almost like a truce.
Mark lit his own cigarette next, inhaling deeply before exhaling a slow stream of smoke into the cold night air. He leaned against the hood of a nearby car, watching Peter through the haze.
âSo,â he exhaled. âTalk.â
His voice was even, but there was something else beneath itâsomething unreadable.
Mark shuffled in place, taking a long drag like the nicotine would give him the words he couldnât find. His fingers twitched slightly as he held the cigarette, the cold air making the smoke curl around them like a ghost of something unspoken.
He wasnât going to let Peter run from thisânot this time.
Peter took a long drag of the cigarette that was just handed to him, longer than he should have. He began to cough, smoke coming out of his mouth as smoothly as he prayed his words would.
Once he calmed down he sighed, staring down at his lit cigarette like it was the most interesting thing in the world at the moment.
"Mark, I..." He felt his face get hot despite the freezing weather they were standing in. "I don't know why I'm running from this. From you. I spent years after college building the person I am today that it hurts to break my walls. I've been trying so hard to change from how I was so many years ago that I can't even try to go back." He took a moment, taking another long drag from his cigarette.
"The person I was years ago wasn't... accepted." He said, hoping Hoffman would somehow catch onto what he was saying. "I don't want to run from you, but it feels like I need to." Peter's voice began to crack, which he tried to cover with a cough.
"I don't... hate you. I don't know how I feel about you. I know that it isn't hatred, though. I know it's something far different from that."
He took a moment before speaking again, hoping the silence would speak the words he couldn't.
"I haven't hated you in years..."
Mark watched him, really watched him. The way his fingers trembled slightly around the cigarette, the way his shoulders curled inward like he was trying to make himself smaller, like he didnât want to be seen. It was a look Mark recognized. A feeling he understood.
He exhaled slowly, letting the cold night air carry the smoke away before he spoke.
"You donât have to explain yourself to me, you know." His voice was softer than usual, lacking its usual sharpness. "Not if youâre not ready."
Mark hesitated for a moment, then stepped closerânot enough to crowd him, just enough that the space between them wasnât so cold.
âI get it,â he continued, voice steady but gentle. "Trying to outrun the past... trying to be something different. Something people expect you to be. Itâs easier than letting yourself go back to something that hurt.â
âIâm not gonna push you," Mark said. "You donât owe me some big confession. But I want you to knowâwhatever this is, whatever youâre trying to figure outâyou donât have to do it alone."
Mark took another slow drag, watching the way the streetlights cast shadows over Peterâs face. He wanted to reach out, wanted to do something, but he didnât. Not yet.
Instead, he just said, "I havenât hated you in years either."
And he let the words settle, giving Peter the space to decide what he wanted to do with them.
Peter let out a quiet sigh of relief, his breath shaking as he did. He felt so much... lighter. Like the weight of a boat was just lifted off his shoulders. He could finally relax. He could finally slowly start breaking down the wall he kept around himself.
He watched Mark step closer, his eyes widening slightly. He took a moment before stepping closer to him.
Their arms were touching. Fully this time.
Strahm took one last drag of the cigarette before dropping in on the ground, stomping it out with the front of his foot. The look of the dark red turning into different shades of grey made him calm down a bit.
He soaked in Hoffman's body warmth, his body warming up shortly after their bodies made contact. He wished for more. He hoped for more. He... prayed for more. Something other than a simple arm touch.
"Just saying, I don't think I'll ever hate you the way I hated you before again. If that means anything." You could hear it in his voice that he was smiling, and the fact that he was trying to hide it.
For once, he felt like himself.
Mark huffed out something that almost sounded like a laughâsmall, quiet, barely there.
âYeah?â Mark murmured, the corner of his mouth twitching up, though he still kept his eyes forward. âGuess Iâll have to live with that, then.â
He didnât move away. Didnât pull back like he usually might have. Instead, he let Peter lean in, let their arms stay pressed together, let the warmth between them settle.
It was stupid how much it affected him. How much he wanted to close the last bit of space between them. But he didnât push. Not yet.
And for once, Mark didnât feel the need to ruin it.
He took one last drag from his own cigarette before flicking it to the ground, crushing it under his boot.
âMeans something,â he admitted, his voice quieter now.
It was the closest heâd get to saying it means everything.
Peter chuckled with Mark, trying to seem like he wasn't freaking out mentally due to the touch. It drove him insane, but not in a bad way like before.
Usually, he would pull away and get defensive, but this time, he was grateful for the touch he was getting.
He slightly leaned his head onto Mark's arm, staring out to the few cars driving past. He hoped this would drive Hoffman insane, make him stay up thinking about this the way the simple thought of Mark kept him awake at night.
It probably wouldn't give the same effect, but a man can just simply hope.
Peter coughed before moving away, crossing his arm before finally making eye contact with Mark for the first time since before they left the building. "I should probably head home..." He said, smiling for the first time in awhile.
This time, it was a real smile.
Mark felt the weight of Peterâs head against his arm like a brand, something small but searing, something that would linger long after Peter walked away. He stayed still, barely breathing, as if moving too much would break whatever fragile thing had settled between them.
Peterâs warmth left him too soon, and Mark almostâ*almost*âreached to pull him back. But he let him go, watching as Peter crossed his arms, as he finally looked Mark in the eye.
And *smiled.*
A real smile. Not one laced with bitterness, not one meant to cut. Just *him.*
Mark exhaled, slow, measured. Forced himself to smirk like this wasnât wrecking him inside.
âYeah,â he said, voice rougher than he meant it to be. âProbably should.â
But he didnât move. Didnât step away.
Instead, he let his eyes linger on Peterâs face, taking in the way the cold flushed his skin, the way his shoulders looked just a little lighter than before.
âTry not to overthink this too much, huh?â Mark added, softer now. âWouldnât want you losing sleep over me.â
It was a lie. A blatant one. He *wanted* Peter to lose sleep over him. The way he lost sleep over *this.*
đȘ Stream or DieâMAKE YOUR CHOICE đȘ
Hey horror fans, Saw fanatics, and first-time playersâdo you want to play a game? My Discord server is hosting a Saw (2004) movie night next week, and youâre invited!
𩞠Whatâs happening? Weâre streaming the first Saw movie together in voice chat!
đ When? 3/15 @ 5pm PT
đ Where? My Discord server (DM for the invite link!!)
If you love Saw, have been meaning to rewatch, or want to experience it for the first time with a fun group, nowâs your chance! Feel free to reblog and spread the word. đ©ž
Peter walked into the station holding a laptop bag and a big silver cup of coffee. It was very obvious he didn't get much sleep, like usual.
[ - @detstrahm ]
[ ooc text : i've never done an rp on tumblr so sorry if this starter sucks !!! ]
Mark Hoffman stands near his desk, eyes narrowing as Strahm enters the room. He takes in the sight of the tired detective, the coffee in his hand, and the laptop bag slung over his shoulder. Hoffman straightens slightly, his face betraying no emotion as he watches Strahm move to his desk.
"You look like you haven't slept in days, Strahm. Tiredness isn't a badge of honor. Itâs a weakness."
He leans back in his chair, his arms folding across his chest, his gaze unwavering as he watches Strahmâs every move.
"If youâre planning to continue running on fumes, itâs only a matter of time before it catches up to you. You should know better than anyone what happens when you lose focus."
His tone is harsh, but there's an edge to it, as if he's quietly daring Strahm to respond, or perhaps waiting for a crack in the other man's usually composed demeanor.
[NO I LOVE IT!! LMK IF THIS IS TOO MUCH HEJEEJEJEJ]
"Not that it's any of your concern, but I'm fine."
Strahm stopped walking as he spoke, looking back to Hoffman over his shoulder with a cold gaze that could definitely kill him if looks really could kill.
"Your snarky comments aren't going to affect me, I'm not a child."
His voice was firm yet calm, making it obvious that he wasn't trying to cause a scene this early into his shift. It was so hard to do anything with Hoffman just a couple steps away from him.
Hoffman smirked to himself, tapping his pen idly against a stack of paperwork before finally dragging his gaze up to meet Strahmâs glare.
"You sure about that?" His voice was slow, almost amused. "Because Iâve seen you get flustered over a lot less."
He leaned back in his chair, letting the words settle, watching for the inevitable reaction. Hoffman raised a brow, the corner of his mouth twitching like he was resisting the urge to really twist the knife. "Not that itâs any of my concern, of course."
And just like that, he went back to his paperwork, acting like the conversation was already over, though he was more than ready for whatever Strahm had to say next-- almost if in anticipation.
Peter took a deep breath as he walked over to Hoffman's desk, leaning over to whisper in his ear instead of yelling. It seemed like the most mature choice.
"Listen here, asshole. I am in no mood to deal with your shit today."
His tone was sharp as if he was an angry dog barking back at Mark. No matter how hard he tried to ignore Hoffman, he always came up with something to say that just pushed his limits.
He tugged on the collar of the other male's shirt, pulling him closer so his mouth was almost touching his ear.
"Leave me the fuck alone, Hoffman."
He growled in Mark's ear, pushing himself away from him with a stern look on his face.
Hoffman barely reacted as Strahm yanked him closer, his breath hot against his ear, voice laced with frustration. The smirk that tugged at the corner of his mouth was slow, deliberateâbecause this was interesting.
For a moment, he didnât say anything, just let the tension settle between them. Then, in a voice just low enough for only Peter to hear, he finally spoke.
"Careful, Strahm." Smooth, almost teasing. "You keep getting this close, people might start talking."
His gaze flickered downâjust brieflyâto where Strahmâs fingers had gripped his collar. Then, just as lazily, he reached for the cup sitting next to him. It wasnât the usual station sludge, but something sweeter, something indulgent, the faint scent of caramel mixing with the deeper, familiar notes of his cologneâcedarwood, leather, something subtly sharp beneath it all.
He took a slow sip, his smirk deepening just slightly as he finally met Strahmâs glare again.
"But heyâmessage received." His tone was light, almost amused. But there was something else beneath it, something unreadable.
[not me sprinkling in some hoffman hcs lol.]
The more Mark spoke, the more it seemed to anger Strahm. He hated how easy it was for Mark to anger him with just a tone of voice or a simple sentence.
"God, fuck off." Peter basically stormed off to his desk, throwing himself into the chair. As he logged into his computer to actually start working, he couldn't stop thinking about Hoffman.
Usually, that would be normal. Today it was different though. Instead of thinking about how much he hated him, he started thinking about these small details about him. Like how his hair looked more brushed through then normally, or how the scent stuck on his body was weirdly calming.
It was weird, but he couldn't stop thinking about it.
It's like Hoffman put a spell on him.
Hoffman watched Strahm go, lifting his cup to his lips again, taking an unhurried sip. The taste of caramel lingered, mixing with the sharper bitterness beneath it.
That was too easy.
Strahm could throw himself into his chair all he wanted, could scowl at his screen and pretend to focus, but Hoffman knew. He knew. Because that reaction? That wasnât just anger. That was something else, something tangled up in frustration and confusion and whatever the hell was flickering behind those glares.
He swirled the drink absently in his cup, gaze flicking toward Strahmâs desk. Then, without looking directly at him, he spokeâjust loud enough to carry across the room.
"You sure you want me to fuck off, or do you just like telling me what to do?"
Hoffman smirked against the rim of his cup, taking another slow sip, letting his pursed lips linger on the rim. Letting the words settle.
Peter's hands froze and his computer as he took a moment to let himself process what Mark just said. Instead of freaking out, or yelling, or even getting out of his seat, he responded calmly. He hated to egg Hoffman on with his emotions.
"Do your damn work, Hoffman. Might do you some good."
Strahm placed his head in his hands for a moment to recollect himself before continuing to work in silence, using his screen to hide from looking at anyone even near him.
He didn't understand this feeling. It was a strange mixture of so many things and emotions he hasn't felt since early college. Whatever it was, Hoffman was enjoying using it against him.
The teasing worked, but god he wish it didn't.
Hoffman finally, finally turned his attention to the files on his desk, though his focus was shot to hell. His eyes moved over the words, but they barely registered. The conversationâthat look Strahm had given him before burying himself in his screenâwas still fresh, playing in his mind like a puzzle he hadnât quite solved yet.
He tapped his fingers against the desk, considering. There was something satisfying about watching Strahm try so hard to keep himself in check, to act like none of this was getting to him. Hoffman knew better.
The corner of his mouth twitched as he flipped a page, not bothering to hide the smirk creeping in. He took another sip of his drink, the sweetness coating his tongue, lingering.
Maybe he should get back to work.
Or maybe he should push just a little moreâjust to see how long Strahm could keep pretending.
Strahm tapped his pen on his desk to a rhythm he had just made up in his mind since that seemed to be the only thing that could replace his thoughts about Hoffman.
Everything reminded him of Mark, it's like he couldn't escape him. He couldn't even focus on his work, which really bothered him. Usually, his work was the one distraction that always worked, but clearly not today.
Peter sighed before standing up and dropping his pen down onto his desk. He ran his hands down his outfit before walking away to the bathroom with his head down the whole time.
He needed an escape. He needed a way to get away from Mark, even just for a couple minutes.
He opened the door to the bathroom, making sure nobody was in there before walking to the sink and turning on cold water. Strahm collected a small amount of water on his hands and splashed it on his face, staring at himself in the mirror. Why was this happening now?
Hoffman didnât look up right away, but he felt the shift. The absence. The way the air around him suddenly felt⊠quieter.
Strahm was gone.
No presence lingering just a few feet away, no rhythmic tapping of a pen, no barely restrained exhale of frustration. The space he left behind felt noticeable in a way Hoffman didnât care to dwell on.
His fingers drummed idly against the desk as he stared at the open file in front of him. He wasnât reading it. His focus was elsewhere, stuck on somethingâor someoneâthat wasnât even in the damn room anymore.
Hoffman sighed, rolling his shoulders before forcing himself back to his work. Strahm would be back.
And when he was, Hoffman wasnât sure if heâd say anything at allâjust that heâd be aware, too aware, of the moment Strahm walked back through that door.
Strahm continued to stare at himself, a look of confusion forming on his face as he stared.
Who was he right now?
He could normally focus on his work with no struggle, but today was just so different. The tension that formed drove him mad. It didn't make any sense, he didn't feel these things last week, so what's so different now?
Peter began to get angry at everything, especially his thoughts. The water still running, the footsteps outside, the talking of his coworkers, the door to the females restroom opening and closing, everything.
He couldn't take it. Strahm punched the bathroom counter, turning the sink off before storming out of the bathroom and back to his seat.
He tried so hard to get on task but with Hoffman around, it would be hard.
The sound of Strahmâs chair scraping against the floor pulled Hoffmanâs attention before he even meant to look at the other man.
Back already.
He didnât watch himânot openly, at least. Whatever that little break had been, it clearly hadnât helped.
Hoffman finally, finally turned his attention to the files in front of him, though his focus was still half elsewhere. He flipped a page, then spoke, his tone casual.
âYou see the new evidence on the Jigsaw case yet?â A beat. Then, with a glint of playfulness in his eyes, he added, âLooks like our guyâs getting smarter.â
Strahm coughed, opening one of the many files on his desk and writing something quick down in pen. "I heard they found a small strand of hair at a scene. They sent it in to get it tested and a DNA read." He sighed. "Seems useless though. It's a strand of hair that was next to a victim, it was probably theirs."
He wasn't doing very well at trying to seem like he calmed down. Peter never denied small things like this unless he was just talking to talk.
He didn't understand how Hoffman was so casual right now. Does he not feel the tension right now? is he really that dumb?
Hoffman didnât look up right away. He turned a page in his file, scanning the words like they mattered more than Strahmâs obvious frustration. âCould be useless,â he said, almost offhandedly. âOr it could be exactly what we need.â
There was no real argument in his toneâjust something thoughtful, maybe even knowing, like he wasnât as dismissive of the lead as Strahm was.
He finally shifted, glancing at Strahm as if noticing him for the first time since he sat back down. His gaze flicked over him brieflyâtaking in the tension still lingering in his shoulders, the way his grip on his pen was just a little too tight.
And then, something caught his attention. The way the dim overhead light hit just right, outlining the sharp line of Strahmâs jaw, the faintest crease between his brows. Had he always clenched his jaw like that when he was thinking? It wasnât just irritationâit was focus, frustration, something deeper that Hoffman couldnât quite pin down.
For a second, he nearly forgot what he was about to say. He forced himself to look back down at his file, masking the moment with an easy shrug.
âLong morning?â His voice was low, almost conversational. But there was something in the way he said itâsomething that made it impossible to tell if he was just making small talk or if he already knew the answer.
Strahm aggressively wrote stuff down in the files, taking small breaks to collect his thought before continuing to write.
"Bad traffic. Bad night." His tone was firm and aggressive, but not on purpose. He spoke quickly which made it obvious it was a lie to get off the topic of anything but work.
He glanced up at Hoffman and froze, using this moment to soak in everything about him. The way he looked so calm while focused on his work, the way his hand gently pushed the pen down on the paper, the way his lips looked when he was focused...
Peter bit down onto his bottom lip roughly, definitely leaving small teeth marks on his lip. Simply looking at Mark made him anxious.
Hoffman didnât react right away. He let Strahmâs words sit between them, as if deciding whether or not to be snide.
He kept his focus on the file in front of him, but his mind was elsewhereâstuck on something he couldnât quite shake. The way Strahmâs voice had that edge to it. The way his pen practically carved into the paper, like he needed the distraction.
Then, in his periphery, he caught itâStrahm biting his lip, hard.
Hoffmanâs grip on his pen tightened for a fraction of a second before he forced himself to relax, dragging his eyes back to his work.
He exhaled through his nose, pretending to stay focused on his paperwork, but his mind was already elsewhere. The way Strahm bit his lipâthat sharp press of teeth against skinâwasnât something he shouldâve noticed.
Wasnât something he shouldâve cared about.
But he did.
His jaw tensed as he forced his attention back to the file in front of him, masking any sign of distraction. After a beat of silence, he finally spoke, his voice lower than before.
"Yeah⊠not like sleep does much good anyway."
"I stayed up practically all night trying to put together why they would test that fucking-" He took a deep breath, looking down at his papers. "that damn strand of hair. It just doesn't make much sense."
As much as he tried to focus on his papers, he couldn't. The way his jaw tensed just drew in his attention even more as if it was magic.
Peter continued to bite at his lip, feeling an impending doom for what Hoffman would say next. His voice was just so smooth, it felt like torture in the best way possible.
He tried to pretend to do his work, but it was hard when his eyes couldn't get off of Mark. He felt helpless in this moment and he hated it.
He was supposed to have all the power.
Hoffman didnât need to look up to know Strahm was still watching him. He could feel itâthose damn eyes, like heat searing into the side of his face, making it almost impossible to focus on anything else.
"Yeah," Hoffman murmured, his voice gravelly but calm, "doesnât add up, does it?"
He wasnât just talking about the case. The frustration in Strahmâs toneâit hit something deeper, something Hoffman didnât feel like addressing, not right now.
He finally looked up, his gaze meeting Strahm's, but only for a brief moment. "But thatâs the thing with this case, Strahm. Sometimes itâs not about making sense." His words carried an almost unsettling weight, though he wasnât sure if Strahm would catch on.
His hand paused mid-motion as he noticed Strahmâs biting, that subtle, almost unconscious action. Hoffmanâs brow furrowed slightly, but he quickly dismissed the thought, shaking it off. He had work to do.
"Try to stay focused," he added, his tone unexpectedly softer, though he meant it more to himself than Strahm.
Strahm let out a deep sigh, closing his eyes and swinging his head back for a moment. This was his best attempt at clearing his mind.
"I just hate when they do things without running it past me or Perez first." He whispered, picking his pen back up and beginning to actually work on the case.
He felt like a idiot. For once, he didn't want to be at work. He regretted coming in today, especially because Lindsey wouldn't be here because her family was in town and wanted one day with them.
Peter picked back up the rhythm from earlier with his pen, tapping it more aggressively than before without realizing. At this point, he was just trying to drown out any of his thoughts, even about work.
Hoffman let the comment hang in the air, though something shifted in his posture at the mention of Lindsey. He didnât outwardly show it, but the thought gnawed at him for a split second.
He leaned back in his chair, the sound of Strahmâs aggressive pen tapping filling the otherwise quiet space. The irritation in Strahmâs actions wasn't lost on Hoffman, but the mention of Lindsey caught him off guard. It wasnât like him to care, not like this.
"Youâre right," Hoffman said, his voice controlled, though there was a slight edge to it, "Youâd think they'd at least consult you. But," he paused, the faintest of smirks pulling at the corners of his lips, "youâre better off without distractions anyway."
He didnât know if Strahm would pick up on the shift in his tone, but Hoffman had a feeling his partner wouldn't miss the faint jealousy that had crept in. He wasnât sure why it bothered him, but it did.
His eyes flicked to Strahm for a brief moment, then back to the file in front of him, trying to focus.
"Guess youâre stuck here with me," he added, his tone slipping just enough to hint at something more personal beneath the professional surface.
Peter suddenly stopped tapping his pen at the last comment Mark added, pausing everything he was doing. Something with the tone he used made him feel something different. Something he hasn't felt yet today.
He couldn't sit here with Hoffman with those words just replaying in his head, he had to escape somewhere.
"I'll be back." Strahm said, his words slightly slurring together. He shot up from his seat, speed walking back to the bathroom. There was one other person in there, but he could care less at the moment.
Peter paced back and forth in the bathroom while waiting for the other man to leave the restroom. Luckily, the pacing must've rushed him out. He continued to pace around, pinching at the bridge of the nose.
There's no way Mark hasn't noticed his weird behavior, there's just no way. He didn't understand why he couldn't just suppress his emotions like he normally did. He has been hiding his emotions with ease for years, so what was so different today?
Hoffman stood up by the windowsill, his back leaning against the cool glass, eyes staring at the outside but not really seeing it. His mind kept drifting back to Strahm, and the way heâd snapped, his frustration practically hanging in the air. There was something about it, something that felt... off. He couldnât quite put his finger on it, but it bothered him.
He rubbed a hand over his face, sighing, trying to clear the thoughts clouding his head. His gaze flicked back to Strahmâs empty deskâ God, why was it so unsettling?
Mark didnât let distractions get to him. He wasnât someone who let emotions or anything else interfere with the job. But thisâwhatever this wasâ was messing with his usual routine.
The door creaked slightly, and his eyes darted toward it, but no one was there. Mark was surprised by how much heâd noticed Peterâs absence. He shifted uncomfortably, his fingers curling into a fist around the edge of the windowsill. What the hell was wrong with him? It wasnât like Strahm to just leave like that, and it wasnât like him either to feel... unsettled by it.
âJust focus,â Mark muttered to himself, but his gaze lingered on the door a second longer than necessary. He hadnât realized how much he had started to notice the little things about Strahmâhis sharp movements, his short temper, the way his jaw tensed when he was angry. And then the way heâd left, so abruptly, like he couldnât even get out of the room fast enough.
Mark rubbed the back of his neck and shook his head, pursing his lips in thought.
He wasnât someone who gave a damn about these things. But today felt... different
And that made him uneasy.
Peter leaned up against the bathroom wall, placing his face in his hands. He wanted to stay in the bathroom until he died but sadly, he knew he couldn't. Strahm continued to bite down on his lip until he tasted blood.
"Fucking hell..." He whispered, taking his hands off his face to wipe his lip. He stared down at his hand, looking at the blood that covered a small part of the side of his hand.
Strahm walked over to the sink and rinsed his hand off, watching the water turn a slight red before slipping down the drain. It was a weirdly calming sight.
He soon left the bathroom, avoiding looking at Hoffman the best he could. "I'm going to refill my coffee." Strahm said firmly as he reached for his cup, rushing away from his desk before he could even hear a response.
If he was being completely honest, he was embarrassed. He was embarrassed that he couldn't hide his feelings this time. It was such a weird thing to feel something other than anger or calmness.
Peter grabbed the old coffee pot from the staff room, filling his large silver cup up with the lukewarm coffee. He hated how he couldn't confront Mark about these feelings.
Hoffman noticed it immediatelyâhow Strahm wouldnât look at him, how his movements were just a little too quick, like he couldnât get away fast enough.
He grabbed his cup and rushed off before Hoffman could so much as blink.
He didnât know what heâd expected, but it wasnât⊠that.
For the first time, something about Strahmâs reaction made him hesitate. He knew how to read peopleâhe had toâbut this wasnât the usual sharp-edged frustration he was used to prying out of Strahm. This wasnât Strahm picking a fight or snapping back. It was avoidance.
And for some reason, Hoffman didnât like that.
His fingers drummed against the desk, watching the spot Strahm had just vacated. Part of himâsome small, stupid partâwondered if heâd actually hurt him. The thought unsettled him more than it should have.
He let out a quiet exhale, dragging his focus back to his paperwork. It was nothing. It had to be nothing.
So why did it sit so strangely in his chest?
Peter took a deep breath in the small but strangely calming staff room. Why couldn't he just man up and go do his work? Why was Hoffman such a distraction? There were all these whys in his head with no answer.
He took a swig of the lukewarm coffee, swishing it around his mouth as he let his mind wander some more. He felt so stupid for avoiding Mark. For some strange reason, he felt bad for avoiding Hoffman.
Strahm looked at the shut door and debated ever leaving this room, but sadly he knew he had to. He had to face his problems.
Peter left the staff room with his head up this time, trying his best to look put together and confident. As he walked to his desk he wondered if everyone else in the building could tell he was breaking on the inside.
Hoffman didnât acknowledge Strahmâs return, keeping his eyes trained on the file in front of him. He wasnât really reading itâhis focus was shot to hell.
He was letting his body speak for him in ways he couldnât control. His leg bounced beneath the desk, a steady, impatient rhythm. His fingers tapped soundlessly against the edge of his paper, the only betrayal of his restlessness.
He wanted to look at Strahm. Watch for any flicker of emotion. See if there was still tension in his jaw, if his lip was still raw from biting down too hard. But he didnât. Not yet.
He just waited. If Strahm wanted to pretend nothing happened, fine. But if there was a crackâany sign of itâHoffman would be there, ready to catch it.
Strahm coughed as if trying to warn Hoffman he was back in his seat, pulling open a completely new file to maybe try and focus on something new.
He read every word on the paper, but nothing made sense in his head at the moment. It was weird, but it felt strange without Hoffman's eyes on him. If he was being honest, he missed being looked at from a distance.
"So, have you heard anything about the Jigsaw case?" Peter asked with his face still buried in the case files on his desk. The silence became too much for him to handle and he needed to break it.
He eagerly waited for a response as if his life depended on it, nervously biting his lip once again and continuing to tap his pen to a different rhythm from before.
Hoffman exhaled slowly, dragging his eyes from his paperwork like he was indulging Strahm by giving him attention.
"Nothing new," he said, his voice even. "Just the same dead ends."
He finally glanced at Strahm, taking in the way his lip was caught between his teeth again, the quick, restless tapping of his pen.
He leaned back slightly, studying Strahm a little longer than necessary before forcing himself to look away. As Hoffman finally looked at him, his gaze snagged on something small but noticeableâthe faint trace of dried blood at the corner of Strahmâs lip. It was barely there, but it was enough.
Hoffmanâs fingers twitched slightly, his grip on his pen tightening before he forced himself to loosen it. He shouldnât care. Shouldnât even be looking. But the sight of it made something uneasy settle in his chest. Had Strahm bitten down that hard?
His jaw tensed as he dragged his eyes away. His breath hitched before he could stop it.
The sight of itâsubtle, unintentional, self-inflictedâsent something sharp and hot running through his veins. His fingers curled around his pen, gripping it just a little too tight. He shouldnât be reacting to this. Shouldnât feel the way his pulse quickened, the way his body betrayed him with that sudden, insidious heat curling in his gut.
His composure threatened to slip.
Hoffman exhaled through his nose, his jaw clenching as he forced his expression to stay neutral. His gaze flicked away, back to his paperwork, even though the words on the page were meaningless now.
âWhy?â His voice came out steadyâthankfullyâbut just a fraction lower than before. âYou onto something?â
He kept his head down, pen skimming over the paper in a weak attempt at normalcy, but the damage was already done. He felt it. And worseâhe liked it.
"Not yet. It's getting annoying how we can't get any new leads..." Strahm put his pen down onto his desk, leaning his head back as he let out a long sigh of exhaustion.
Suddenly, he had gotten an idea. Something that would probably calm down the thoughts about Hoffman in his head, but would probably be seen as weird.
At this point, that was the least of his concerns.
"Hey, wanna go somewhere for lunch? We can discuss the case some more." Peter said, his voice was low with a hint of embarrassment. He didn't want to give Mark any ideas of what he actually meant but instead an idea that he actually cared about the Jigsaw case at this moment.
Strahm held his breath while waiting for a response, keeping his eyes focused on the papers on his desk rather than Hoffman to seem relaxed.
He really hoped he was pulling off the whole 'chill' act...
Hoffman didnât answer right away. He sat with it, rolling the idea over in his head, his pen idly tapping against the desk.
Lunch. Alone. With him.
It was easy to pretend that was a normal suggestion. Just two law enforcement officers talking shop. But Strahm had hesitated before asking, and that hesitation stuck with him.
His eyes flicked toward the other man, watching the way he stayed locked onto the papers in front of him like they held the answer to something more than just their case. His fingers curled around his pen a little tighter.
Hoffman wasnât sure why that detail bothered him.
He exhaled through his nose, feigning indifference. âYeah, sure.â His voice was steady, neutral. As if he hadnât spent the last minute overthinking this.
He leaned back in his chair, stretching his legs out, the tension in his muscles betraying his otherwise relaxed posture. His knee bounced once before he stilled it. He didnât like feeling caught off guard.
He finally looked at Strahm again. âWhere?â It wasnât an enthusiastic acceptance, but it also wasnât a rejection. It was something in between.
Peter let out a quiet sigh as soon as Mark answered, gripping at the bridge of his nose as he tried to think of a place nearby that was nice enough to take Hoffman to, but not too nice.
"Well, I heard there's this nice sandwich place that recently opened... we could go there." Strahm suggested, pulling himself out of his work to actually make eye contact with Hoffman.
He noticed small details very quickly. The way a couple strands of hair fell out of his styled hair, the way his eyes were naturally tired looking in such a good way, the way his hand gripped onto his pen, the way he had to stop his leg from bouncing... everything was so perfect it made him sick.
He tried to pull his eyes off of Mark, but he just couldn't. For once, he had an actual excuse to stare at Hoffman. He shouldn't have been as grateful as he was.
Hoffman let a beat of silence pass before tilting his head slightly, finally meeting Strahmâs eyes with something that almost resembled amusement.
âA sandwich place, huh?â he said, tapping his fingers idly against the desk. âDidnât peg you as the type to branch out. Thought you survived purely off burnt coffee and spite.â
There was a slight smirk at the corner of his mouth, but his tone was just casual enough to keep Strahm guessing. It wasnât an outright challenge, but it wasnât nothing, either. Just enough to test the watersâto see if Strahm would roll his eyes, snap back, or keep looking at him like that.
His leg bounced once before he forced it still again, fingers tightening around his pen.
Peter's breathing quickly became regular as soon as Hoffman made eye contact with him, causing him to stumble over his words.
"Well- I-" He paused, collecting his thoughts. "I mostly survive off of cheap burnt coffee, but I'm switching it up for once." A slight smile appeared on his face for the first time today once he realized if he just kept up this calm, non-angry act up, he might survive this shift.
Or, at least he'll try to keep it up. It's hard when he's around Mark.
Strahm reached into his pocket and searched for his card, flipping through random twenties and tens before finally finding it. "I heard it's pretty cheap so I might as well pay for yours." He said, not even noticing how nice he was being.
He was never nice to anyone other than Lindsey really, so this must've been a rare sighting to anyone listening in to the conversation.
"But I'm only paying because it's cheap. I'm not trying to be all nice and shit, so don't get that idea." Of course, he had to ruin the one moment he seemed slightly kind.
Hoffman let out a quiet chuckle, shaking his head as he watched Strahm fumble with his wallet. There was something oddly endearing about itâhow he offered without thinking, only to immediately try to walk it back. It wasnât often that Strahm let something slip through the cracks.
"Generous and cheap. Quite the combination," Hoffman murmured, his voice dipping into something almost warm, almost teasing. He let the words hang between them for a moment before exhaling, running a hand down the sleeve of his jacket as he stood.
His gaze lingered on Strahm just a little longer than necessary, taking in the way he still wouldn't quite meet his eyes. There was a rare ease in the moment, a shift from the usual sharp edges they threw at each other. Hoffman felt it more than he wanted to acknowledge.
"If youâre so insistent," he said, his tone softer now, something almost amused beneath it, "Iâll let you buy me lunch. Just donât expect me to be nice about it."
It wasnât a joke, not really. But it was something. A quiet acceptance, an unspoken truce. And when he stepped just a little closerâjust enough to catch the faintest tension in Strahmâs shouldersâhe couldn't quite fight the smirk that ghosted across his lips.
"Letâs go before you change your mind."
Strahm nodded in agreement, shoving his wallet back in his pocket before standing, straightening out his top with his hands. It was so weird that he suddenly felt a need to look... cleaner around Hoffman.
"Do you want me to drive?" He asked as he began to walk to the front door of the building, reaching a hand into the opposite pocket of his wallet to grip onto his keys, ready for an answer to his question.
Peter tried to walk slightly fast, trying to avoid anyone really seeing him walk outside the building while having an active and normal conversation with Mark.
He didn't want people to think he suddenly grew fond of Hoffman because, if he was being completely honest, he didn't really like the thought of beginning to grow fond of him.
Peter spent all of these years hating Mark just for that to change from one interaction. It felt stupid to him. He felt stupid.
Hoffman followed steadily, letting Strahm put some distance between them. It wasnât hard to pick up on the way Peter was rushing. Like it meant something.
Hoffman didnât call attention to it, but he noticed. He noticed the way Strahmâs fingers curled tightly around his keys, the way he held himself just a little straighter, as if heâd suddenly started caring about how he looked. It was subtle, but it was there.
And for some reason, it was... alluring.
There was a new kind of tension in Strahm, not the usual barely-contained aggression Hoffman was used to. This was something else, something more restrained. He wasnât sure what to make of it yet, but he had the patience to figure it out.
âIâll let you drive,â he finally said, watching Strahm with something just shy of amusement. His voice was even, casual, but his smirk gave away more than he probably intended. He let the moment stretch just a little longer before adding, âJust try not to kill us before we get there.â
A joke, but one that carried weight. A small push. A test.
He walked ahead of Strahm and put a hand in his pocket as he walked.
"I'll try, but it might be hard with you in the car." Peter said, hiding back a smirk as he spoke. He pulled the keys out of his pocket, gripping them tightly in his hand as if someone was going to steal them from him.
As he entered the cold weather outside, his whole body tightened. Strahm had always hated the cold.
He unlocked his car, quickly shoving himself in to try and escape the weather. He switched on the heat in his car before blowing warm air into his hands, waiting patiently for Mark to say something that gave him the idea he was ready for him to start driving.
Peter really hated driving with a person in his car. His road rage usually killed any good energy moving throughout his car in a matter of seconds. Sure, Mark has seen him angry, but not the type of anger he gets while driving.
Plus, he'd really hate to ruin what they had going on at the moment...
Hoffman let out a short chuckle at Strahmâs response, low and almost under his breath. There was something oddly satisfying about the way Peter shot back without missing a beatâlike he was starting to get comfortable with this, whether he wanted to or not.
The cold bit at his skin as he followed Strahm outside, but he barely registered it, too focused on watching the other man move. The tension in his shoulders, the way he practically threw himself into the car to escape the chillâit was little things like that that made Hoffman feel like he was getting a read on him.
He slid into the passenger seat with an easy, unbothered motion, his gaze settling on Strahm as the heat kicked in. The way Peter hunched over his hands, rubbing warmth back into them, was oddly... humanizing. A rare moment where he looked like more than just a sharp edge waiting to cut.
Hoffman leaned back, making himself comfortable before finally breaking the silence. âYou gonna warm up before we get moving, or do I have to listen to you bitch about the cold the whole drive?â His tone was teasing, but his eyes lingered a little too longâtaking in the way Strahmâs lips were still slightly parted from the rush of warm air, the way his fingers flexed against his palms.
Another small test. Another moment to gauge how far this push-and-pull would go.
Strahm smiled, pulling his hands away from his mouth. "You'll have to hear me bitch about a lot during this car ride. The traffic is bad right now." He said as he put his hand on the steering wheel, gripping it tightly.
He started to drive, his attention suddenly going to the road with a straight, serious face. He always took driving very serious, for some strange reason.
Peter tried to seem calm with Mark in the car, but seeing all the cars lined up in the street already made his blood boil. He didn't want to yell at all, but he just knew that would be hard.
"Holy fuck, that's a lot of cars..." He commented, speaking in a low voice that seemed like a grumble or a growl. His voice always sounded so demanding or angry, no matter what mood he was in.
Hoffman settled into his seat, letting his gaze drift lazily over the dashboard before inevitably landing on Strahmâs hands. He had a firm grip on the wheel, fingers tense, knuckles just shy of turning white.
Hoffman had seen Strahmâs hands in plenty of different settingsâclutching a gun, flipping through case files, clenched into fistsâbut there was something about watching them now, wrapped around the wheel with that quiet intensity, that held his attention a little too long.
The way his fingers flexed slightly every time he muttered under his breath, the subtle tremor of agitation when traffic didnât move fast enoughâit was strangely captivating. It made Hoffman wonder, just for a second, how that tension would feel if it werenât directed at the steering wheel.
âTry not to take it personally,â he said finally, tearing his gaze away and shifting in his seat. âPretty sure the traffic isnât out to get you.â His tone was light, almost mocking, but his fingers tapped idly against his own thighâlike he was keeping himself from saying something else.
"It's just so annoying. If people actually knew how to drive then we-" He suddenly stopped himself from talking, giving himself a moment to collect his thoughts. He couldn't go on a stupid rant about people driving. At leastânot in front of Mark.
His eyes slowly drifted towards Hoffman's fingers tapping against his thigh, picking up on the rhythm in his head quickly. He watched as if it was a mind blowing thing, like something he's never seen before. Obviously, he wasn't focused on the rhythm, he was focused on Mark.
The way he tapped so calmly like he was waiting to say something, the way his focus was on the grip of his hand, the way he was somehow so calm and collected on the outside, everything. All of it just seemed so perfect. Too perfect.
Peter soon snapped out of it as soon as he realized the cars around him were moving, and soon became fixated back on the road.
"This place better be good. If I drove in this traffic for no reason, I'll be pissed." He said, beginning to quietly tap the rhythm Mark had been tapping, using it as a way to calm down.
Suddenly, it hit him. He was driving Mark Hoffmanâthe guy who has been driving him insane all dayâout to eat with him. Sure, it wasn't fancy, but it was still something. The thought of this made him go back to biting his lip, leaving a dent over the previous one that just started going away.
Hoffmanâs fingers kept up their steady rhythm against his thigh, but his focus wasnât really on it anymore. His eyes had drifted back to Strahm, watching the way his jaw tensed, the way his grip tightened on the steering wheelâand most of all, the way he kept biting his lip, almost absentmindedly.
He let the moment stretch for a beat longer than necessary before speaking, voice smooth but just pointed enough to be intentional.
"Didn't take you for a nervous habit kind of guy, Strahm. Be careful there."
The words hung in the air, but the way Hoffmanâs gaze lingeredâjust for a secondâmade it clear heâd noticed. He settled back against the seat, watching for a reaction, wondering if Strahm would brush it off or if the slight shift in energy would throw him off course.
Strahm stopped tapping his fingers, looking over to Mark with a confused expression. It took him a moment to realize he was biting down on his lip. Again.
He quickly corrected himself, wiping his lip to see more blood transfer onto his hand. "Fuck..." He whispered to himself, staring down at the wipe of blood on the side of his hand before sighing and simply putting his hand back onto the wheel.
Peter never understood why he did stuff like this knowing it would later on hurt. And he especially didn't understand why he was doing it even more than usual. Normally, he would bite his lip while checking out a crime scene, or holding a gun, but never while simply being around a person.
He soon realized how much power Hoffman held when it came to himself. He could simple say something cocky and it would mess up his whole shift, or even the rest of his day.
"God fucking damn it." He said as he punched the steering wheel, causing his car to honk to the car in front of them.
Great, he did the one thing he was trying not to do. Get mad over a simple thing while in the car.
Hoffmanâs smirk faltered. Just for a second.
He hadnât expected that reactionâhadnât expected Strahm to actually hit the wheel like that. The sharp sound of the horn rang in his ears, but it was the frustration in Strahmâs voice that really caught him off guard.
For all the ways he liked to push, this wasnât what heâd been aiming for.
Hoffman shifted slightly, pulling his gaze away, tapping his fingers against his thigh againâbut this time, it wasnât intentional. It was just something to do. Something to focus on instead of the way Strahmâs knuckles were going white against the steering wheel.
"Forget it," he muttered, quieter than before. "Didnât mean anything by it."
For once, he let the moment pass without another remark. No teasing, no smug little comments. Just silenceâsave for the hum of the car engine and the faint, rhythmic tapping of his fingers.
Was this guilt? He felt guilty for that remark, and Hoffman rarely cares about others like that.
He suddenly felt anxious. He tried to remain suave but his hands shook ever so slightly as he loosened his tie. It was getting slightly hard to breathe.
Strahm had gone completely silent at this point, taking all his anger out by gripping the wheel. If he knew that he would've fucked up the stuff they had going, he would've tried to prevent it.
But he couldn't.
He soon saw the sandwich shop, realizing it was closed. He went through all of this for it to be closed. He sighed and turned into the parking lot anyway, parking the car to think of another place they could go to.
"So... the shop is closed today, I guess." Peter said, his voice quiet and low as if he was confessing something. He felt somewhat bad. He felt bad for taking Hoffman out of work just to find out their plans wouldn't even end up working.
"We could... go somewhere else. Or go back." He paused as he thought of more ideas. "Or we could sit here and talk about the case." He said as a last choice.
Instead of looking over to Hoffman, he stared down at his lap. It didn't feel right to look at him after what just happened. He felt... embarrassed in a way. He knew that if he reacted to something with anger, it would've changed everything. Yet, he did it anyways. He just let it happen.
Hoffman stayed quiet for a moment, letting his eyes settle on Strahm. Really looking at him.
The way his shoulders were still tense, the way his fingers flexed against the steering wheel like he was holding himself back.
Hoffman tapped his fingers one last time before letting his hand still in a gentle grasp against his thigh. He wasnât in a rush to speak.
Instead, he just watched.
There was a strange feeling in Hoffmanâs chest, something he didnât quite have the words for.
After another beat of silence, he finally spoke. "Well," he drawled, tilting his head slightly, "weâve already wasted this much time. Might as well make it worth it."
His voice was even, but there was an edge of something unreadable in it.
Hoffman wasnât sure what he expected Strahm to say next. But he was sure of one thingâhe wasnât ready to leave yet.
"Mhm.." Peter hummed in response, taking his hands off the wheel to try and seem more calm and relaxed. His attention turned to Mark very soon, his eyes hovering over his whole body before meeting his eyes.
He had a strange feeling in his chest every time he looked at Mark. It suddenly felt heavy and felt it got harder to breathe.
The tension in the car was so much more in the office. The way they were much closer than before, the way they had no where else to look but each other, it was all too much. Peter removed his jacket, folding it neatly before setting it down in his lap. Though, he never broke eye contact.
"Have you got anything about the case? Any suspects, any leads, anything? Have you heard anything from the DNA test yet?" Peter decided it would be best to ask a good amount of questions. Then, it would be easier for him to seem less.. awkward and nervous.
Work seemed to be the only thing keeping him sane right now.
Hoffman didnât miss the way Strahm folded his jacketâcareful, deliberate, like he needed to keep his hands occupied. It was almost amusing, the way he tried to seem at ease when everything about him screamed tightly wound.
He let the moment stretch, saying nothing at first. Just watching.
âCouple of things,â he said finally, voice level, unreadable, clearing his throat. âDNA test came back inconclusive. No solid matches.â
Hoffman let that sit between them, waiting to see how Strahm would react.
Mark shifted in his seatâ just enough to take up more space, his arm settling on the center console. Closer.
âThereâs one lead,â Hoffman continued, deliberately unhurried. âGuy who fits the profileâex-con, history of violence, used to work in mechanical engineering.â
Another pause. Then, finally, Hoffman turned his head, meeting his gaze fully.
âYou all right, Strahm?â His voice was smooth, casual, but he knew exactly what he was doing.
Hoffman could feel itâthe tension, the weight pressing down on the space between them. And he liked it.
At first his maintained eye contact, but that proved to be too much for him so he backed off, clearing his throat again.
âIâm not trying to make you nervous.â A lie, and also deflecting some of his own feelings.
"What? I'm fine. I'm not nervous at all, Hoffman." Peter responded, his words sharp and aggressive. He didn't realize until now how tense and nervous his body language was. He shoulder tensed, his jaw clenched, his hands always forming a fist, everything was not normal.
He hated the power Mark held over him. It made him so angry to the point of nausea. Every time Mark did anything better than him, he got jealousâangry. Every time Mark looked at him, he got nervous. He hated the way he just let this happen.
Strahm took a deep breath, placing his arm right next to Hoffman's. "Well, at least we've got something. It's better than what we had before." He said, his voice was very monotoneâdry even.
"I should probably call Perez soon and tell her about this..." Peter said, tapping his finger to a different rhythm than before. It was more aggressive and repetitive, showing both his anger and anxiety in one rhythm.
The way his and Mark's arms were so close made him feel something he couldn't explain. It made it hard to breathe, as if someone were to suck all the air out of his lungs.
[ ooc text : i wrote the second part of this while listening to jealousy, jealousy by olivia rodrigo. feels important to share. ]
Hoffman watched him carefully, his expression unreadable. Strahmâs words were sharp, but they didnât match the way his body was betraying himâso tense he looked ready to snap. Hoffman could practically feel the heat radiating off him, the way his energy buzzed with something dangerously close to frustration. Or something else.
His eyes flicked down to their arms, barely a breath apart. It would take nothing to close that distance. To shift just slightly and press against him, just to see what Strahm would do.
Then Strahm mentioned Perez.
Hoffmanâs fingers, which had been resting idly against his thigh, curled inward before he abruptly moved his arm away, leaning slightly toward the car door. His expression didnât change, but something in his body language didâsomething colder.
"Yeah," he muttered. "You probably should."
Hoffman clenched his jaw, staring straight ahead as if the windshield suddenly held something more interesting than Strahm beside him. The mention of Perez shouldnât bother him, but it did. He knew how much Strahm trusted herâhow easily they worked together, how she could read him in ways Hoffman couldnât.
He didnât like it.
His fingers twitched against his leg, resisting the urge to match Strahmâs rhythm like before. Instead, he let the silence stretch, letting the distance he created sit heavy between them.
âWant some space to call her?â
Strahm noticed how Hoffman tensed as soon as he mentioned Perez, a look of confusion quickly forming on his face. Why did Mark get so weird every time he mentioned Lindsey? Why did he act so weird whenever she was at his desk? It made no sense.
He looked down to see his arm moved away, a feeling of defeat washing over him. They were so close, it was perfect. But clearly, he messed something up to changed the tension they had going for them.
"Uhm, no... I'll just call her later today. She's probably busy anyway, and I don't want to interrupt her." Peter said, slowly removing his arm and placing it onto his lap. He stared at Hoffman, noticing how he would rather stare at nothing then stare at him. Why did it change so quickly?
He coughed, trying to stop the silence between the two. "What should we do?" He asked, trying to use a tone that suggested that he was open to anything, work related or not. At this point, he'd be willing to do anything to get out of this uncomfortable situation.
Strahm started to pick at the sides of his fingernails, messing up his already rough looking fingers. He watched as a small amount of blood formed on his finger once he peeled some skin off, watching it build up but not drip.
It was better to watch than continuing to watch Mark stare out the windshield as if it was much more interesting.
Hoffman exhaled, letting the tension ease from his shoulders as he settled back into his seat. His arm found its way back to the consoleânot quite touching Strahmâs, but close enough that it wasnât a full retreat anymore.
"Alright," he said, tilting his head slightly as if considering their options. "We could hit up that shitty diner a few blocks over. The one with the terrible coffee but decent fries." He shot Strahm a sideways glance, a ghost of a smirk tugging at his lips. "Unless youâre too good for a place that serves their food on plastic trays."
It wasnât just about food anymore, and they both knew it. Hoffmanâs posture was more open again, his voice lacking the sharp edge from earlier.
"And hey," he added, his smirk sharpening just slightly, "maybe if you're lucky, the waitress will think weâre on a date and give you the check. Since, y'know, you were so eager to take me out in the first place."
It was a joke, but not a denial. And the way he looked at Strahm when he said itâsteady, watching for a reactionâmade it clear he wasnât just filling the silence.
âOr maybe one of us can flash our badge and make her feel bad.â He winked. A soft, brief action.
A smirk appeared on Strahm's face, looking up from his hand and back to Hoffman. "I'm fine with the shitty diner, I guess." He said with a hint of sarcasm in his voice at the end.
"And I think we should go with the second idea. Flashing our badges is better than her thinking we're a gay couple." Peter said as he began to start driving, but this time only with one arm. Keeping his arm next to Mark's felt... right.
He began driving out of the parking space, making a promise in his mind that he wouldn't get visibly angry at the people on the road. He would hate to ruin the tension for the hundredth time today. Peter bit down on his lip slightly, mainly doing it to keep his focus on the road.
Peter took a deep breath as soon as he got on the road, trying to seem like he didn't even care about the traffic, but he did. He really did. He actually cared about everything right now. The traffic, the way Hoffman's arm was right next to his, the fact he was driving him to a diner, everything. It all was so much more than it would normally be, but he stayed calm.
At least, he tried to stay calm.
Hoffman stood just outside the diner's entrance, the neon light flickering against his skin, casting him in a glow of red and gold. He flexed his fingers at his sides, still feeling the lingering warmth from where their arms had brushed in the car. It was stupidâinsignificant, really. But it had made something stir deep in his chest, something he wasnât ready to acknowledge.
He glanced over his shoulder, watching Strahm still sitting in the driverâs seat, his fingers tapping against the wheel. For a moment, Hoffman just⊠looked at him. The usual irritation was there, sure, but it was layered with something else, something heavier. He exhaled, shaking his head to himself before rapping his knuckles lightly against the glass door.
"You coming?" His voice was lower than he intended, softer, almost coaxing. He hesitated, then let a smirk tug at his lips. "Or do you just like staring at me from a distance?"
He turned before he could catch Strahmâs expression, stepping inside the diner. The scent of coffee and fryer grease wrapped around him, familiar and grounding. Still, that warmth from the car lingered, settling deep in his chest. As much as he tried to ignore it, deny it, there was no shaking the truthâsomething between them had shifted. And for once, Hoffman wasnât sure if he wanted to fight it.
Peter sighed before slipping his coat on, finally leaving his car. He made sure to lock his car before walking over to the diner with the neon flickering lights. This is not where he exactly wanted to take Mark, but guess that's what he had to deal with for now.
He stepped inside, walking past Hoffman to a small booth all the way in the corner of the diner. He sat in the seat against the wall, waiting patiently for Mark to sit across from him.
It was weird to think about. Taking the man he hated out to get food. Sure, he invited him to talk about 'work' , but they both knew that wasn't going to actually happen. At least, not the whole time.
"I don't really know if I'll eat anything here. Hell, they probably cook dead rats into the food based on what people say about it." Peter said, looking around to see most employees sitting on their phones or talking. Sure, this wasn't ideal, but it would work just fine.
After all, he didn't want things to seem romantic. Peter didn't like Mark that way.
At least, that's what he told himself.
Hoffman leaned back against the cracked vinyl seat, drumming his fingers against the tabletop as he glanced over the laminated menu. It was sticky. Of course it was. He barely looked at the options before setting it aside.
"Dead rats or not, Iâm getting a shake," he said, flagging down a half-interested waitress. "Chocolate. Extra thick." His voice was smooth, deliberate, like he was making a point. He didn't care if the place was a dumpâhe was here, and he was going to enjoy something.
Once the waitress walked off, he leaned forward slightly, resting his forearms on the table. His gaze flicked over Strahm, taking in the tension in his shoulders, the way he was still pretending like this wasnât something. It was almost endearing.
"You know, if you keep looking that uncomfortable, people are gonna think I dragged you here against your will." His smirk was slow, knowing. "Or worse, that this actually is a date and you're just playing hard to get."
He let that sit between them, watching for the reaction. Strahm always had a tell, no matter how much he tried to hide it. And Hoffman? He lived for it.
Peter hummed in response to Mark, quickly shaking his head once the waiter looked at him with a look of boredom and impatience, waiting for an order. He sighed as soon as the waiter walked off, shutting his eyes for a moment before opening them to meet Mark leaned more towards him.
"I would way rather have them think you kidnapped me or something. I don't want people to think we're on a date. Or that I'm gay." As soon as he spoke those last four words, it hurt something in him. He didn't understand why though. He wasn't gay. That's what he's been telling everyone for years.
These feelings were so confusing. He hated Hoffman, he knew he did. Something was... different. Usually, he would be tearing his hair out by nowâbut it was different now. He was less angry.
Strahm tried to relax his shoulder, but failed. He hated how much he seemed so nervous and shut off when he wanted to seem relaxed. He wanted to seem more normal, but that was hard when he wasn't normal even when hating Mark.
Hoffman let out a quiet snort, shaking his head slightly as he leaned back again, giving Strahm just a bit more spaceâbut not much.
âRelax, Strahm,â he muttered, voice low and edged with amusement. âNo one in here gives a shit about what you are.â His fingers drummed idly against the table as he watched the way Peterâs shoulders stayed locked in place, the tension rolling off of him in waves.
That reactionâthat was interesting. It wasnât just irritation or the usual disdain that Strahm carried whenever he was around him. This was something else. Hoffman bit his lip in thought.
Hoffman tilted his head slightly, his eyes scanning Strahmâs face, catching the way his mouth pressed into a tight line, the way his fingers curled against his thigh like he was trying to hold something back.
He could push. It would be easy. A well-placed comment, a teasing smirk, just enough of a prod to see what would happen if he hit the right nerve.
But, for once, he didnât.
Instead, he exhaled, shaking his head as he reached for his glass of water, taking a slow sip before setting it back down. âBesides, if I did kidnap you, Iâd make sure you at least got something better than a damn sandwich out of it.â
The words were casual, thrown out with just enough humor to make it unclear whether he was joking or not. But underneath, it was a testâa different kind of test. Would Strahm push back? Laugh it off? Or would he keep unraveling right in front of him?
Peter felt like he was melting away. He was so focused on what other people around him thought. People he would most likely never even see again. The idea of a random stranger thinking something that wasn't true made him freak out. What if he actually saw them again and they thought he was something he wasn't? What if that made people avoid him? He hated it.
"Yeah. Sure." He mumbled, looking over Mark's shoulder for a second to scan the whole diner and all the workers. Another habit he had to avoid a situation. This time, the situation was right in front of himâstaring with a smirk that showed that he was clearly interested by Peter's reactions to things.
He looked down at his lap, fixing the previous creases he made in his pants from gripping them. It was weird, he felt a sudden need to look nice. Normally, if he was at work, he never cared. It was just work after all. Today thoughâit was different. Very different.
"Oh, so if you were to kidnap someone, you would cook them a full meal?" Strahm asked with a hint of sarcasm in his voice, trying to come across as more calm and relaxed. His tone was calm, but his body language was completely different. His body language resembled a stray cat whenever you try to pet it. Tense, intimidating, aggressive.
He didn't mean to come off like this, but it was better than coming off nice, or worseâromantic. Which sucked, because deep down there was something going on. Something other than hate or anger. But different from what he felt around Lindsey...
Hoffman let out a low chuckle, shaking his head as he leaned back slightly, arms crossing over his chest. âWhat, you think Iâd half-ass it?â His smirk remained, but his gaze was steady, watching every nervous shift, every flicker of hesitation in Strahmâs expression.
Hoffman tilted his head slightly. âIâm just saying, if I were the kind of guy to kidnap someone, Iâd at least put in the effort. Full meal. Maybe some wine. Make it a whole experience.â His voice was even, casual, but the weight behind his words lingered in the space between them.
He let the thought settle for a moment before reaching for his drink, taking another slow sip. âNot that youâd appreciate it,â he added, tone bordering on dry amusement. âYou strike me as the type to complain about the wine pairing.â
He was still testing, still pushingâjust enough to see how Strahm would react.
"Well, I believe that it would be a bit stupid to make a full meal. You don't want the person you kidnapped to get attached to you. That'll just cause so many more problems." Strahm said as if he had experience in stuff like this. Obviously, he didn't. It was more of the fact that he's dealt with multiple situations like this.
Peter's voice was less aggressive, finally showing that some of the tension and stress had left his body. It felt like heavy sandbags being lifted off his shoulders, giving him the ability to finally seem a bit more confinement rather than stuck in his own skin.
"Of course I complain about wine pairing. It's basically everything when it comes to a nice meal! Tell me, would you pair a glass of Pinot Noir with a steak? No. You would pair something like Cabernet Sauvignon." It was obvious he was good at this subject. Which you probably wouldn't guess by getting one simple look at him.
Peter checked his watch, quickly looking back up to Mark. "We should probably head back soon." He said, putting his coat over his arms as quickly, basically preparing himself to leave in a quick amount of time.
Hoffman raised an eyebrow, watching Strahm with something between amusement and intrigue. The shift in his demeanor didnât go unnoticedâhis voice had lost some of that earlier edge, his posture a little less rigid. It was subtle, but it was there.
âDidnât take you for a wine guy,â Hoffman mused, tilting his head slightly. âThatâs a real specific take for someone who spends most of his days running on burnt coffee.â His smirk lingered, but there was something else in his gaze nowâsomething considering.
He didnât know why it was so damn fascinating, watching Strahm loosen up, even just a little. Maybe it was because he knew how rare it was. Strahm was all sharp edges and tension, always coiled like a spring. Seeing him talk about something so mundane, something he actually seemed passionate about, was... different.
Hoffman exhaled through his nose, glancing at his own watch before rolling his shoulders back. âYeah, wouldnât want anyone thinking we actually enjoyed this.â The words were teasing, but there was an undertone to themâsomething unspoken but lingering.
As Strahm pulled on his coat with that same urgency, Hoffman just watched him for a moment before finally moving to stand. He didnât rush. He didnât need to. Strahm was already rattled enough without him adding to it.
But still, as they stepped outside into the cold, he let the silence settle just long enough to make Strahm wonder what he was thinkingâbefore finally breaking it with a low, amused murmur:
âYou talk a big game about wine pairings, but next time, Iâm picking the place.â
He paused for a moment, thinking if he should even offer but he did, anyways: âWant me to drive the way back?â He asked, staring ahead.
"Really? I'm a pretty big wine guy. Me and Perez tend to talk about it a lot, I guess you just don't hear us." He found himself bringing up Lindsey again. He knew that it wasn't a good idea. He knew that everything would shift once again after bringing her up. Yet, he still did it.
He sighed before walking over to the waiter, putting down a random ten dollar bill from his wallet before walking outside into the cold with Hoffman. The cold hit him like a punch, causing him to exhale a deep breath.
"Well, I wasn't going to bring you to a place where they pair wine to discuss work, Mark." The comment was supposed to come off playful, but instead came off harsh. He always struggled to control his tone, which was the reason he spoke with such a monotone, bored voice.
Peter unlocked the car doors, looking over to Mark. "Yeah, sure. It'll be better for you to drive anyway." He said, getting in the car before discussing anything else. He would rather die than stand a moment longer in the cold weather.
Hoffmanâs jaw tightened at the mention of Perez. Of course, Strahm had to bring her up. He always did, like it was some kind of reflex. And every time, it hit Hoffman the same wayâan irritating little twist in his gut that he couldn't quite shake.
He didnât say anything right away, just let his eyes linger on Strahm as they stepped out into the cold. The wind bit at his skin, but he barely registered it. He was too busy watching the way Strahm hunched his shoulders, the way he exhaled sharply like the cold was trying to rip the breath from his lungs.
Hoffman scoffed at the comment about work, catching the way Strahm avoided looking directly at him. Yeah, sure. You werenât gonna bring me to a place like that for work. But youâd bring Perez, wouldnât you?
He didnât voice the thought. Instead, he followed Strahm into the car, sliding into the driverâs seat with a little more force than necessary. The second he started the engine, the heater kicked on, filling the space with warmthâbut Hoffman still felt that simmering irritation sitting low in his chest.
He glanced at Strahm. Something about him made his fingers tighten on the steering wheel. âYou talk about wine like some expert, but I bet if Perez were here, youâd have some bullshit poetic thing to say about it,â he muttered, keeping his voice level, but there was an unmistakable sharpness to it.
He wasnât sure what he wanted out of that commentâmaybe just to see Strahmâs reaction, to make him squirm the way Hoffman felt himself doing internally. Because for all his control, for all his carefully placed remarks, something about Strahm had a way of slipping under his skin. And it pissed him off. Well, he didn't know if he was more pissed off at that or the fact that he didn't understand why he was pissed off in the first place.
Peter put his hands between his knees in an attempt to warm them up, staring down as he did. He couldn't bring himself to look at Mark. He couldn't bring himself to even quickly glance at him. He already felt everything shift as soon as he brought up Lindsey.
Just as he was in his thoughts, Mark spoke.
The words stabbed him, causing his stomach to turn. Not out of anxiety, but rather anger. It made him so angry knowing that Hoffman hated Perez for no real reason. It made his blood boil. She wasn't a bad detective, she was kind, she never came off as aggressive, she was so perfect. Yet, Mark found a way to hate her.
"What do you mean, Hoffman? What is that supposed to mean." The first time was a question. The second time was in demand. A demand for answers. He was tired of how he always found a way to get mad at Lindsey when she has never done anything to him.
Strahm still avoided eye contact, but it was clear that he was angry. Even without the look of rage and hatred in his eyes, anyone could still tell he was angry. The way his words became sharp and intense again, the way his body tensed up when he spoke, the way his hands turned into fist in seconds.
It was all too obvious.
Hoffman didnât answer right away. He just drummed his fingers against the steering wheel, exhaling through his nose as if Strahmâs reaction wasnât exactly what he was hoping for.
But it was.
The sharpness in his voice, the way his body locked upâHoffman knew that anger well. He knew how it made Strahmâs breath come a little quicker, how it made him grip at things too tightly. And maybe it was fucked up, but he liked knowing he could pull that reaction from him so easily.
âWhat do I mean?â Hoffman repeated, dragging the words out slow, testing the weight of them on his tongue. His gaze flicked toward Strahm, watching the way he kept his eyes pointed anywhere but at him. Coward.
âI mean exactly what I said. You donât talk about me the way you talk about her.â His voice was even, but there was something under itâsomething Strahm wasnât going to like if he looked too closely.
His grip on the wheel tightened. âAnd donât pretend like you donât know what I mean,â he added, lower this time, but more pointed. âEvery time she comes up, you get allââ He waved a hand vaguely, knowing Strahm would get it. âLike sheâs so perfect. Like she can do no wrong. So yeah, maybe I donât like her, Strahm. Maybe I donât like the way you talk about her.â
His jaw clenched. He hadnât meant to say that last part, but now it was out there, sitting in the space between them. And for once, he was the one who looked away first.
Peter's breathing was quick and heavy, as if he was holding back so many things. Which, he was. Instead of yelling, he let Mark finish. He let him finish his ranting while holding eye contact. His eyes were angry, hateful, and disappointed. His eyes held a look that was almost unreadable, yet so readable at the same time.
He hated hearing these words. He hated hearing about someone not liking Lindsey. He hated listening to someone not thinking she was perfect. He hated hearing that Mark hated her. He hated Mark.
He felt his head began to hurt from the rage and all the thoughts piling up at once. He couldn't keep them hidden much longer. He had to express them somehow.
"What's the true reason you can't handle me talking about someone else? What is it, Hoffman? What makes you, a grown man who I haven't known most of my life, crave the attention I give to someone else? What makes you feel the need to act like an angry pathetic dog who craves attention? What is it?" He spoke, his words spilling out. He couldn't stop now.
"Why would I need to talk about you the way I talk about her? Do you believe you are more important than Lindsey in my mind? Do you truly believe you are better than her?" He thought for a moment, collecting his ability to breathe before continuing.
"I talk about her that way because she is perfect. She does no wrong. When has she ever wronged you? When has she wronged me? When has she wronged anyone? You can't think of a single example, can you? That's because she hasn't wronged anyone. You have no real reason to hate her other than jealousy, which doesn't even make sense because I could've sworn you hated me just yesterday. Why are you suddenly so jealous over someone I've known for years?"
He stopped himself, but his body language showed how angry he still was. His eyes, his hands, his shoulders, everything. It just showed how angry he was. Even then, that didn't do it justice.
Hoffmanâs grip on the steering wheel was so tight that his knuckles were white, the leather groaning under his fingers as he tried to force the anger back down. The air between them was thick with the tension, and it only got worse as Strahmâs wordsâsharp, biting, full of that damn righteous angerâsettled in the car, suffocating everything else.
Every word from Strahm twisted something inside him, but it wasnât just anger. It was jealousy.
Hoffman could feel the heat radiating from him, the sharpness in his voice, his body practically vibrating with the intensity of it. Jealous of Lindsey. Thatâs what it was, isnât it? But no. He couldnât admit that. Not out loud. Not even to himself.
His jaw locked so tight that it hurt, and it was taking all his self-control not to lash out. But as much as he hated admitting it, he wasnât just angry. No, it was more complicated than that.
"Really, Strahm?" Hoffmanâs voice was low, too low. It felt like it came from somewhere deep inside him, almost like he was letting something slip without meaning to. âYou wanna act like Iâm just throwing a fit, like Iâm jealous?â His words came out rough, but there was something else thereâsomething softer. A pull, just beneath the anger. âYou think I care about her more than you?â
He took a slow breath, still staring at the road, forcing himself to focus on the sound of his heartbeat. It wasnât enough to calm the storm inside him. His eyes flickered briefly to Strahm, watching the way he held himself, how tense and wound up he was. That tightness in his jaw, those clenched fists. Hoffman hated it. But he also liked it. Too much.
âIf I cared about her that much,â Hoffman continued, his voice a little quieter now, almost to the point where Strahm had to lean in to hear him, âI wouldnât be here. Wouldnât be here with you, would I?â
His pulse quickened as he said it, that same rush of heat climbing up his neck. He hated how it soundedâtoo much like he was admitting something, too much like he was being vulnerable when heâd never let anyone see that side of him.
His hands tightened on the wheel again, but it wasnât just anger this time. His thoughts were swirling, clouded with the weight of what he couldnât say. Couldnât admit.
He glanced at Strahm again, eyes narrowing, but this time it was different. He couldnât look away. There was something else there nowâsomething raw, something almost intimate in the way Strahm looked at him.
âIs that what you want, Peter?â Hoffmanâs voice was softer now, barely a whisper, a challenge. âYou really think Iâm jealous of her? Or is it that you just canât handle the idea of me being here instead of her?â
His heart thudded in his chest, the words spilling out before he could stop them. His stomach twisted. Why couldnât he stop? Why did it feel like something had shifted, like the whole conversation was moving toward something else entirely?
The silence between them stretched out, the only sound the hum of the engine and the beating of their hearts. Hoffman wasnât sure if Strahm could feel it tooâthe way the air had thickened with unspoken words. The way it felt like they were suddenly standing at the edge of something they werenât quite ready for.
But it was too late. The tension was already there, and Hoffman knew, without a doubt, that it wasnât just about Lindsey anymore.
And he hated himself for that.
Peter suddenly felt the tension for once, actually backing off. Something told him he needed to back off this situation before he said anything else or anything worse. He suddenly, for some reason, felt bad. It didn't make sense though. He shouldn't feel bad. He had a point, Mark did seem jealous of Lindsey. But did he maybe take it too far?
He took a breath through his nose and out his mouth. "Mark, I'm not saying you're jealous, I'm saying it seems like it. Every time I mention Lindsey, you act like it's the end of the damn world. You get all tense and angry as if you hate her for simply being in my life."
He spoke as if he hated the idea of Hoffman being jealous, but he really didn't. He enjoyed the idea of how he could ruin someones mood just by simply bringing up one person.
"All I want to know is why. Why does your mood change? Why do you get so tense? Why do you hate the idea that I think she's perfect?" Strahm poured out his words as if his mouth was a faucet for his brain.
The air between them was too much. It was thick, it was overwhelming. It drove him so insane how angry they both were. All he could hear was his own heartbeat in his ears.
"I just need to know. Why don't you like Lindsey?" He wasn't demanding anymore. He was pleading. He wanted to know why because he couldn't handle watching how he looked at her with such anger and jealousy every time they spoke at work.
Hoffmanâs grip on the steering wheel was relentless as Strahmâs words hung in the air, thick and heavy, pressing down on him like a weight he couldnât shake off. The space between them felt suffocating, as if every word Strahm said was just making the tension worse. But something in the way Strahm spoke caught him off guardâthere was a vulnerability there, a softness to his tone that Mark wasnât used to. Pleading. It had always been anger before, but now it was something else. Something that made Hoffman feel like he was walking a razorâs edge.
"You really wanna know, Peter?" Hoffmanâs voice was low, rough with something that wasnât anger anymore. It was too much to admit, too much to say, but it was right there, clawing at the back of his throat.
He took a breath, feeling the heat of Strahmâs words pressing into him. Mark wasnât ready to give in, not yet. He couldnât be. But damn, it was hard to ignore how his chest tightened when Strahm spoke with that tone. Pleading, vulnerable, asking for answers he couldnât give. Hoffman couldnât explain it, but there was something in Strahmâs eyesâthe way he looked at him, the way his words tangled up like a question and a challenge all in oneâthat made him want to say everything. To tell him the truth, to finally admit what had been gnawing at him all this time.
Markâs eyes flickered to Strahm, a quick glance that lingered too long. He tried to look away, but couldnât. He just... couldnât.
âI donât hate her,â Hoffman finally muttered, voice laced with frustration, but there was something deeper in it too. Something that was hard for him to articulate. âItâs not about her. Itâs not about her at all.â
The words came out harsher than he meant, but it wasnât about Lindsey, was it? It was about Peter. And that was something Hoffman wasnât ready to face.
âYou wanna know why my mood changes when you talk about her?â Hoffmanâs voice dropped even lower, almost a growl. âItâs because Iâm hereâwith youâand I hear you talk about her like sheâs some saint. Like sheâs perfect. Like sheâs everything you need, everything you want. And I canât stand it.â
The words slipped out before he could stop them, raw and unfiltered. His chest heaved, and his heart was beating too fast, like it was trying to escape. He could feel the shift, the intensity of the moment pulling them both into a place neither of them were ready for. But Hoffman couldnât help it. He couldnât keep it in any longer.
He turned his head slowly, eyes locking with Strahmâs, searching for somethingâanythingâin his face that would tell him he was still in control, that he hadnât just said too much.
âYou think Iâm jealous of her? Maybe... maybe Iâm just jealous that she gets to have you, and I donât.â
There it was. The words that were always just beneath the surface. He could feel the heat rising in his face, the tightness in his chest, and the way his hands were trembling ever so slightly. He hated how weak it made him feel, how vulnerable.
âBut you donât get it, do you?â Hoffman continued, his voice almost a whisper now, the anger simmering just beneath the surface. âI donât care if sheâs perfect, Peter. Itâs you. Itâs you I canât stand when you talk about her like that. Because itâs not about her. Itâs about... us.â
The words hung in the air, fragile and heavy. He hated how much they revealed, how much of himself he had just let slip. But there was no taking them back now. And as much as he tried to hold it all together, his chest still ached with that unspoken truthâhe had crossed a line he wasnât sure he could walk back from.
The silence stretched between them, thick and suffocating, until it felt like they were both drowning in it. Hoffman wasnât sure what came next. He wasnât sure if he wanted to know. But it was too late to pull back now.
Strahm stared blankly at Hoffman, his angry gaze soon becoming soft. Instead of cutting him off, he listened quietly. He didn't react in any form, though. It didn't feel right. Even a simple nod felt wrong. That would make it seem like he agreed with his feelings, but he didn't. He hadn't connected those feelings inside him just yet.
He wanted until he was silent and the silence was basically drowning the both of them before finally speaking. "Mark... I- I don't know what to say." He said, his mind not fully grasping everything that was said. It still hung in the air, driving him to insanity every second. He wasn't gay. He knew it.
"I'm not... well, I'm not gay. And Lindsey doesn't have me, no one has me." His words came off more aggressive than he wished. "Not even you, Hoffman. You don't have me." Those words weren't supposed to come out. He didn't want to come off as mean. The emotions were just too much to handle, though. Too much to care about how his words came across.
"There is no us. The only us we have going on is a work situation, Mark." He hesitated saying his name. "There can't be any of us. I'm sorry, but that's not who I am. And I'm not going to lead you on and pretend that's who I am. I clearly already lead you on enough..."
The last part came out as a whisper, like he was ashamed. Embarrassed even. He never felt bad, but he did this time. He didn't know why, but he did. He felt horrible, actually. It sat so uncomfortably in his stomach he couldn't help but almost gag. Why did he feel so bad?
Why did he regret everything he said?
Hoffmanâs chest tightened as Strahm spoke, each word hitting him like a physical blow. He hadnât expected Peter to say any of thatâhe hadnât expected any of it, really. But the sting of the words, the sharpness in Peterâs voice, felt like a blade to his gut. He hadnât thought that hearing Peter reject him would hurt this much. But it did. It hurt more than he ever thought possible.
When Strahm said those words, âIâm not gayâ, it felt like the ground beneath Mark's feet shifted. It felt like everything he had just laid out, all the things he had been thinking, sayingâfeelingâwas being slammed down in front of him like some hard truth he wasnât ready to hear.
And then the next partââNot even you, Hoffmanââstung deeper. The way Peter said it wasnât meant to be cruel, but it felt like it. Markâs hand clenched into a fist on the steering wheel, knuckles white, as if the tension in his body might somehow find an outlet through sheer force.
But it didnât.
He felt the weight of Peterâs words sitting heavily in the car between them, suffocating him, making him feel smaller than he ever had before. He didnât know what to say to thatâhow to fight back against something so⊠absolute. So final.
Still, there was something in Peterâs tone that shifted, something quieter, something almost⊠regretful. Embarrassed.
Hoffmanâs heart slammed in his chest as Peter whispered the last part, âI clearly already lead you on enough.â
For a moment, Mark couldnât breathe. It was like the air itself had been sucked out of the car, and he was left grasping at whatever was left.
No, Peter didnât want him. He didnât want this.
But there was that whisper of regret that stayed with Hoffman, swirling in his mind. He could see it in Peterâs eyesâthe way they shifted away from him, unable to meet his gaze. And the way he apologized, despite not wanting to admit anything, despite the layers of denial. There was something there. Something Mark wasnât sure if he wanted to understand, but he had to. It ate at him.
He slowly turned his head, his jaw clenching as he held Peterâs gaze, searching for the truth beneath his words.
âI donât need you to lead me on, Peter,â Hoffman said, his voice softer, almost gentle in a way that didnât quite fit the angry edge he usually carried. âIâm not asking for that. But you canât just pretend like I donât see whatâs going on. You donât get to throw this all away just because itâs easier for you.â
The words came out before he could stop them, and though they werenât meant to sound desperate, something in his voice cracked. Something in him trembled under the weight of what he was saying.
âIâm not gonna lie to you, Peter.â He paused, trying to catch his breath, his chest tight. âI... I donât know what the hellâs going on either. But I know Iâm not just some... work colleague to you. Not anymore.â His voice dropped lower. âI see it in the way you act around me. I feel it. Hell, Iâve felt it for a while now.â
He hesitated, staring out the windshield, before glancing back at Peter. His eyes were darker now, a fire simmering beneath them. He couldnât stop himself. He was burning up inside.
âIâm not perfect either, Peter,â he continued, the vulnerability creeping in. âBut donât sit there and pretend like thereâs nothing between us. Youâre not as cold as you think you are.â
It was out before he could stop it, his voice barely above a whisper, but there was a finality to it that lingered in the air.
The silence hung between them again, but this time, it was different. It wasnât just an empty, suffocating thing. It was charged. And as much as Mark hated to admit it, the way Peter wouldnât meet his eyesâthe way he avoided him nowâtold him everything he needed to know.
Peter stared down at his lap, picking at his cuticles to try and distract himself. That was working until Mark said the words. The words that killed everything inside of him. The words that stabbed him in the stomach. The words that made his blood boil.
' You donât get to throw this all away just because itâs easier for you. '
These words pained him. But not in a way that upset him, but in a way that angered him. He wasn't throwing anything away. He tried being nice, but clearly that didn't work. He wasn't gay.
"Listen, Hoffman. I've already told you, I'm not gay. I've never been gay, I've never though I was gay, I'm not gay. I'm not going to let yourself continue to believe that I am. It's not only hurting me, but also hurting you. At this point, it feels like you're leading yourself on."
The words came out in a harsh tone, his words aggressive and mean. He barked back like a dog. In this situation, he was like an angry, lost dog. A dog who needed comfort deep down.
He didn't want to make the situation worse, but it was hard with everything Mark said. the words ' But donât sit there and pretend like thereâs nothing between us. Youâre not as cold as you think you are. ' echoed throughout his head, causing his blood to just boil more.
Soon, he got to a point in anger where he wasn't even angry at Mark as much anymore, it was mostly anger towards himself.
He looked up to look out the windshield, sighing before opening his mouth to speak. His words came out in a low whisper as if he was checking in with himself.
"I'm not gay..."
Mark's eyes locked onto Peter's face, searching for somethingâanythingâto tell him that this wasnât over. But it was clear Peter wasnât giving him anything, just sitting there, picking at his cuticles, trying to hold it all together. The tension in the air was suffocating, and Mark could feel every inch of it tightening around him, his chest growing heavier with each passing second.
When Peter spoke, his voice was sharp, the words like a slap to the face. âIâm not gay. Iâve never been gay, Iâve never thought I was gay, Iâm not gay.â The rapid fire of it made Mark flinch, even though heâd expected it. But it still hurt, hearing Peter say it like that. Like it was something to be ashamed of.
Hoffmanâs jaw clenched, and he leaned forward slightly, his voice low but cutting. âIâm not asking you to be anything youâre not, Peter. But you canât sit there and act like thereâs nothing between us when you know damn well there is.â
Peterâs wordsâthe harshness in his tone, the way he barked back, like a wounded animalâhit a nerve that Mark didnât know existed. But then something else shifted in Peterâs voice, something softer, quieter, that Mark almost didnât catch. Peter looked out the windshield, and Mark could see the way his shoulders slumped slightly, like the anger was draining out of him, replaced with something else. Something less certain.
Mark leaned back in his seat, eyes narrowing, not willing to let Peter get away with this. "Youâre not fooling me, Strahm. Youâre not as cold as you act. You can say all you want that youâre not interested in meâIâm not stupid, I get it. But donât act like I donât see whatâs going on when you look at me like that." His voice cracked with frustration, but he didnât stop. He couldnât. "Youâre running from something. And I donât know what it is, but I see it in the way you pull away, in the way you shut down every time we get close." His eyes flickered toward Peter. "Youâre lying to yourself, Peter. And itâs not just about me. Itâs about you."
The silence that followed was heavier than anything before it, thick with unspoken words and tangled emotions. Mark's heart was hammering in his chest, but he didnât know what to do with it. He wanted to reach over, shake Peter, make him see the truth, but he couldnât. He wasnât sure if Peter was even listening anymore, if the words were getting through to him.
When Peter finally spoke again, his voice was a whisper, almost as if he was saying it more to himself than Mark. "Iâm not gay..."
Markâs eyes softened at the quiet admission. There was a crack in Peterâs façade, a fracture that Mark hadnât expected to see. Heâd seen the anger, the cold detachment, the resistance. But thisâthis was different. This was something raw. Something that made Markâs heart stutter, even if he didnât want it to.
âYou donât have to keep telling me that,â Mark said quietly, his voice surprisingly gentle, as though trying to reach something inside Peter. He leaned forward again, just a little. âI know. I know youâre not âgay,â Peter. But thatâs not what Iâm asking for.â His voice caught on the last word. âIâm asking you to stop running. From me. From whatever the hell it is thatâs scaring you.â
There was a long pause as Mark let the words settle in the air between them. He didnât know what would happen next, or if Peter would even listen. But there was no going back now. He had to say it. He had to give Peter the chance to decide. Whether they could move past all of this or if it would just tear them apart.
Peter still wouldnât meet his eyes, his gaze fixed on the windshield, but Mark didnât look away. He couldnât. Not when there was still a chance. Not when the weight of everything between them was still there, waiting for a spark to set it off.
Strahm felt himself breaking, but hid it. He hid it to the best of his abilities. But if you looked closely, very closely, you'd see a wounded man with glossy eyes. Eyes that weren't helping hide the fact he was upset. Eyes that held so much more emotion than his own words. Eyes you would see on an animal being hunted. Eyes that held fear.
"I'm not-" His voice cracked, but he quickly covered it with a cough. "I'm not running. I'm not scared of anything." No matter how much he tried to hide how he was really feeling, you could still slightly see it. His hands were now shaking and his leg began to bounce up and down quickly, making a faint but noticeable tapping sound.
"I'm not hiding from you." He said, but something in his mind told him he was hiding from Hoffman. Something told him he was hiding from everything. It had gotten to a point that he couldn't hide his feelings anymore. His whole body was tensed up as if protecting himself from words, his eyes fixated on the cars ahead of them more than anything, his leg continued to bounce but at a faster pace, and finally, his lip. He hadn't even noticed, but his lip began to drip blood again. This time though, he didn't wipe it away. He didn't want any hands near his face, even his own.
"And I shut down when we're close because I don't like you, Hoffman. You do nothing but-" He stopped himself, realizing what he said. It was too late. He can't just go back in time and stop himself. These words were stuck in the car.
All of their words were stuck in the car, along with his heart.
Mark could feel it, the tension in the air thick and almost suffocating. Every breath Peter took seemed heavy, labored, and every movement of his hands, his leg bouncing, told Mark something was wrong. The words caught in the air, stuck between them like a wall, and Mark was starting to feel like he was trapped on the other side of it.
Peterâs voice cracked, and Markâs heart skipped. He saw it. The way Peterâs hands shook, the way his leg tapped frantically, the slight gloss in his eyes that Peter tried so hard to hide. Peter was on the edge of breaking down, but he was doing everything in his power to keep it together, to keep his walls up. Mark knew that feeling. He recognized it. It was the same one he wore every damn day.
When Peter spoke, his words were harsh, almost defensive, but Mark could hear the cracks underneath. "I'm not running. I'm not scared of anything." But Mark saw it. That wasnât the truth. The shaking, the trembling lip, the way Peterâs eyes kept avoiding him. The truth was slipping through the cracks in his defenses.
Peter said he wasnât scared, but Mark could hear it in his voice, see it in the way his body tensed up. He could almost smell itâfear. Fear of something bigger than either of them could handle.
âIâm not hiding from you,â Peter said, and the words didnât even make it out like they were supposed to. Mark could hear the hesitation. The vulnerability. Peter was lying to himself. But Mark wasnât about to call him out on itânot yet, anyway. Heâd been there before, too. He understood what it was like to keep those walls up, to lock everything inside until it made you want to suffocate.
But then Peter spoke again. His words cut through the thick air like a knife, too sharp to ignore. "And I shut down when we're close because I don't like you, Hoffman. You do nothing but-"
Peter stopped himself, and Mark felt the weight of the words that hadn't been finished. The ones that lingered like a shadow, threatening to reveal something deeper than just anger or confusion. Something that could change everything.
Markâs pulse raced. He wanted to push him further, demand to know what Peter had really meant, but he knew better than to rush it. It wasnât the time for that. Still, the words hung in the air, heavy, suffocating. You do nothing but... what?
Markâs eyes softened just slightly as he watched Peter's lip, the blood starting to drip again. Peter didnât wipe it away, didnât even move his hand. It was like he wanted to bleed, wanted to feel it. Wanted to show Mark that he wasnât as cold as he kept pretending to be.
Mark knew the feeling too well. It was a strange sort of comfort to know that Peter was hurting, too. As fucked up as it sounded, it was a relief to know Peter wasnât the stone wall he tried so hard to be. And maybe, just maybe, Mark could find a way in. Even if it scared the hell out of him.
âPeterâŠâ Markâs voice was softer now, almost hesitant, as if he was treading carefully through the words. He didnât want to break Peter any more than he already was, but he couldnât stand watching him fight this on his own.
Mark reached out by putting his arm on the centre console, just slightly, his fingers brushing the air near Peterâs hand, though he didnât touch him. He wasnât sure if Peter would pull away or not. He wasnât sure if Peter even wanted him near.
But the words that followed from Peter hit Mark like a punch to the gut. âI donât like you.â And it stung more than anything Mark could have expected. He knew Peter wasnât ready for anything else, but that hurt. Hurt more than he wanted to admit.
Mark leaned back in his seat, his heart pounding in his chest. He couldnât let Peter see the effect those words had on him, but it felt like a thousand knives had pierced through his chest all at once.
âRight.â Markâs voice was tight, holding back something deep inside. No, Peter. You donât just shut down and say you donât like me and expect me to walk away.
But Mark didnât say that. He didnât push. He couldnât. Not yet. The words Peter had left unfinished were eating away at him, though. The silence was deafening.
And in that silence, Mark could feel itâthe shift, the crack in Peterâs armor. Peter might not have been ready to admit anything, but Mark could see it now. He could see the truth bleeding through, and he wasnât going anywhere.
Not yet.
They drove in silence for a few more moments, the tension between them almost unbearable. Then, finally, they pulled into the parking lot of the station. The headlights cut through the night, casting long shadows across the concrete. The sound of the engine slowing to a stop filled the car, but neither of them made a move to get out immediately.
Mark just sat there for a second, his eyes still on Peter. He could feel the weight of the moment hanging between them, almost like it was going to shatter if either of them spoke again.
After what felt like an eternity, Mark exhaled quietly and opened the door. "Weâre here," he said, his voice barely above a whisper. He didnât know what else to say. He didnât know how to fix what had been broken, or if it could even be fixed at all. All he knew was that he wasnât leaving yet.
Peter noticed his arm on the center console, moving his arm away quickly. Quicker than he'd ever moved away from Mark. His movements were like a scared injured animal. Quick to escape the touch that could save him. The touch that could fix him.
Strahm completely dissociated, staring out to the cars. The blood continued down his chin, reaching the bottom before he finally wiped it off with a quick movement of his arm. The arm farthest from Mark. Seeming like he was trying to hide he could move at all.
He stayed in his thoughts, trying his best to breathe through his walls finally breaking. They couldn't break. He couldn't let a new person into his mind, anything could happen.
His brain flooded with thoughts. They were all about Hoffman. What if he was starting to hate him? What if he was right? He's only trying to help. For once, he's being a good person and I just can't soak it in. Maybe I'm just a horrible person. He's probably beginning to hate me now. He probably-
Suddenly, Mark's voice pulled him out of the thoughts.
He looked at Hoffman and quickly nodded, leaving his car and locking it before speed walking to the office. As soon as he made it inside, he packed up everything at his desk he brought in. He had to leave, and he had to leave now.
Hoffman sat there for a second, watching Strahmâs back as he disappeared inside. He could still see the tension in his posture, the way his shoulders curled in like he was trying to shrink himself down, trying to vanish into the walls.
Mark exhaled, shaking his head as he rubbed his hand over his mouth.
This was spiraling. Fast.
He should just let him go. Let Strahm run himself ragged, let him pack up, let him storm out of the office and pretend none of this ever happened. Itâd be the easy thing to do. Itâd be the smart thing to do.
But Mark was shit at doing the smart thing when it came to Peter.
With a grunt, he pushed open the car door and got out, walking toward the building. His steps were heavy, purposeful, his jaw set as he shoved through the front doors.
Strahm was already at his desk, movements frantic, throwing his stuff into his bag like he was trying to outrun something. Maybe himself.
Mark lingered in the doorway for a moment before finally stepping forward.
âYou leaving or running?â His voice was level, but there was an edge beneath it.
Mark scoffed, stepping closer. âYou text me, drag me over here, and now youâre bolting? What the hell was this, Peter?â
He wasnât even sure what he wanted Strahm to say. He just wanted him to say something. Anything.
Mark clenched his jaw. Fine. If Strahm wanted to run, let him. But Mark wasnât going to stand there like an idiot, waiting for an answer that would never come.
âForget it,â he muttered, turning on his heel to leave.
Strahm put his bag over his shoulder, rushing to stand next to Hoffman. "Listen... I want to talk to you about.." He thought about how to word what they had going. "This. About me running. Just follow me so we can get it over with."
Peter said as he pulled a cigarette out of his pocket, placing it in my mouth as he searched for a lighter while he walked. He never smoked. He hadn't smoked in awhile, actually. He always just... carried one around. It was a habit from years ago he never let go.
As soon as he stepped out, he lit the cigarette.
What was he going to say? Sorry for being confused? Sorry for letting his anger get the best of him? Sorry for being the man Hoffman fell in love with? He couldn't wrap his head around an idea.
He stood with his jaw clenched in the cold as he waited for Mark who soon followed behind him. It was time to confront his emotions for once in his life.
For once, he almost felt in control of his emotions.
Hoffman watched Strahm fumbling for a lighter, his movements sharp, tense. He never smokedâMark knew that. At least, not anymore. So why now?
With a sigh, Mark reached into his jacket pocket, pulling out his own cigarette and lighter. He flicked it open, the flame casting a small, flickering glow between them. Instead of lighting his own first, he held it out toward Strahm, his gaze steady.
âHere.â.
The small gesture felt heavier than it should have, almost like a truce.
Mark lit his own cigarette next, inhaling deeply before exhaling a slow stream of smoke into the cold night air. He leaned against the hood of a nearby car, watching Peter through the haze.
âSo,â he exhaled. âTalk.â
His voice was even, but there was something else beneath itâsomething unreadable.
Mark shuffled in place, taking a long drag like the nicotine would give him the words he couldnât find. His fingers twitched slightly as he held the cigarette, the cold air making the smoke curl around them like a ghost of something unspoken.
He wasnât going to let Peter run from thisânot this time.
Peter took a long drag of the cigarette that was just handed to him, longer than he should have. He began to cough, smoke coming out of his mouth as smoothly as he prayed his words would.
Once he calmed down he sighed, staring down at his lit cigarette like it was the most interesting thing in the world at the moment.
"Mark, I..." He felt his face get hot despite the freezing weather they were standing in. "I don't know why I'm running from this. From you. I spent years after college building the person I am today that it hurts to break my walls. I've been trying so hard to change from how I was so many years ago that I can't even try to go back." He took a moment, taking another long drag from his cigarette.
"The person I was years ago wasn't... accepted." He said, hoping Hoffman would somehow catch onto what he was saying. "I don't want to run from you, but it feels like I need to." Peter's voice began to crack, which he tried to cover with a cough.
"I don't... hate you. I don't know how I feel about you. I know that it isn't hatred, though. I know it's something far different from that."
He took a moment before speaking again, hoping the silence would speak the words he couldn't.
"I haven't hated you in years..."
Mark watched him, really watched him. The way his fingers trembled slightly around the cigarette, the way his shoulders curled inward like he was trying to make himself smaller, like he didnât want to be seen. It was a look Mark recognized. A feeling he understood.
He exhaled slowly, letting the cold night air carry the smoke away before he spoke.
"You donât have to explain yourself to me, you know." His voice was softer than usual, lacking its usual sharpness. "Not if youâre not ready."
Mark hesitated for a moment, then stepped closerânot enough to crowd him, just enough that the space between them wasnât so cold.
âI get it,â he continued, voice steady but gentle. "Trying to outrun the past... trying to be something different. Something people expect you to be. Itâs easier than letting yourself go back to something that hurt.â
âIâm not gonna push you," Mark said. "You donât owe me some big confession. But I want you to knowâwhatever this is, whatever youâre trying to figure outâyou donât have to do it alone."
Mark took another slow drag, watching the way the streetlights cast shadows over Peterâs face. He wanted to reach out, wanted to do something, but he didnât. Not yet.
Instead, he just said, "I havenât hated you in years either."
And he let the words settle, giving Peter the space to decide what he wanted to do with them.
Peter let out a quiet sigh of relief, his breath shaking as he did. He felt so much... lighter. Like the weight of a boat was just lifted off his shoulders. He could finally relax. He could finally slowly start breaking down the wall he kept around himself.
He watched Mark step closer, his eyes widening slightly. He took a moment before stepping closer to him.
Their arms were touching. Fully this time.
Strahm took one last drag of the cigarette before dropping in on the ground, stomping it out with the front of his foot. The look of the dark red turning into different shades of grey made him calm down a bit.
He soaked in Hoffman's body warmth, his body warming up shortly after their bodies made contact. He wished for more. He hoped for more. He... prayed for more. Something other than a simple arm touch.
"Just saying, I don't think I'll ever hate you the way I hated you before again. If that means anything." You could hear it in his voice that he was smiling, and the fact that he was trying to hide it.
For once, he felt like himself.
Mark huffed out something that almost sounded like a laughâsmall, quiet, barely there.
âYeah?â Mark murmured, the corner of his mouth twitching up, though he still kept his eyes forward. âGuess Iâll have to live with that, then.â
He didnât move away. Didnât pull back like he usually might have. Instead, he let Peter lean in, let their arms stay pressed together, let the warmth between them settle.
It was stupid how much it affected him. How much he wanted to close the last bit of space between them. But he didnât push. Not yet.
And for once, Mark didnât feel the need to ruin it.
He took one last drag from his own cigarette before flicking it to the ground, crushing it under his boot.
âMeans something,â he admitted, his voice quieter now.
It was the closest heâd get to saying it means everything.
Peter walked into the station holding a laptop bag and a big silver cup of coffee. It was very obvious he didn't get much sleep, like usual.
[ - @detstrahm ]
[ ooc text : i've never done an rp on tumblr so sorry if this starter sucks !!! ]
Mark Hoffman stands near his desk, eyes narrowing as Strahm enters the room. He takes in the sight of the tired detective, the coffee in his hand, and the laptop bag slung over his shoulder. Hoffman straightens slightly, his face betraying no emotion as he watches Strahm move to his desk.
"You look like you haven't slept in days, Strahm. Tiredness isn't a badge of honor. Itâs a weakness."
He leans back in his chair, his arms folding across his chest, his gaze unwavering as he watches Strahmâs every move.
"If youâre planning to continue running on fumes, itâs only a matter of time before it catches up to you. You should know better than anyone what happens when you lose focus."
His tone is harsh, but there's an edge to it, as if he's quietly daring Strahm to respond, or perhaps waiting for a crack in the other man's usually composed demeanor.
[NO I LOVE IT!! LMK IF THIS IS TOO MUCH HEJEEJEJEJ]
"Not that it's any of your concern, but I'm fine."
Strahm stopped walking as he spoke, looking back to Hoffman over his shoulder with a cold gaze that could definitely kill him if looks really could kill.
"Your snarky comments aren't going to affect me, I'm not a child."
His voice was firm yet calm, making it obvious that he wasn't trying to cause a scene this early into his shift. It was so hard to do anything with Hoffman just a couple steps away from him.
Hoffman smirked to himself, tapping his pen idly against a stack of paperwork before finally dragging his gaze up to meet Strahmâs glare.
"You sure about that?" His voice was slow, almost amused. "Because Iâve seen you get flustered over a lot less."
He leaned back in his chair, letting the words settle, watching for the inevitable reaction. Hoffman raised a brow, the corner of his mouth twitching like he was resisting the urge to really twist the knife. "Not that itâs any of my concern, of course."
And just like that, he went back to his paperwork, acting like the conversation was already over, though he was more than ready for whatever Strahm had to say next-- almost if in anticipation.
Peter took a deep breath as he walked over to Hoffman's desk, leaning over to whisper in his ear instead of yelling. It seemed like the most mature choice.
"Listen here, asshole. I am in no mood to deal with your shit today."
His tone was sharp as if he was an angry dog barking back at Mark. No matter how hard he tried to ignore Hoffman, he always came up with something to say that just pushed his limits.
He tugged on the collar of the other male's shirt, pulling him closer so his mouth was almost touching his ear.
"Leave me the fuck alone, Hoffman."
He growled in Mark's ear, pushing himself away from him with a stern look on his face.
Hoffman barely reacted as Strahm yanked him closer, his breath hot against his ear, voice laced with frustration. The smirk that tugged at the corner of his mouth was slow, deliberateâbecause this was interesting.
For a moment, he didnât say anything, just let the tension settle between them. Then, in a voice just low enough for only Peter to hear, he finally spoke.
"Careful, Strahm." Smooth, almost teasing. "You keep getting this close, people might start talking."
His gaze flickered downâjust brieflyâto where Strahmâs fingers had gripped his collar. Then, just as lazily, he reached for the cup sitting next to him. It wasnât the usual station sludge, but something sweeter, something indulgent, the faint scent of caramel mixing with the deeper, familiar notes of his cologneâcedarwood, leather, something subtly sharp beneath it all.
He took a slow sip, his smirk deepening just slightly as he finally met Strahmâs glare again.
"But heyâmessage received." His tone was light, almost amused. But there was something else beneath it, something unreadable.
[not me sprinkling in some hoffman hcs lol.]
The more Mark spoke, the more it seemed to anger Strahm. He hated how easy it was for Mark to anger him with just a tone of voice or a simple sentence.
"God, fuck off." Peter basically stormed off to his desk, throwing himself into the chair. As he logged into his computer to actually start working, he couldn't stop thinking about Hoffman.
Usually, that would be normal. Today it was different though. Instead of thinking about how much he hated him, he started thinking about these small details about him. Like how his hair looked more brushed through then normally, or how the scent stuck on his body was weirdly calming.
It was weird, but he couldn't stop thinking about it.
It's like Hoffman put a spell on him.
Hoffman watched Strahm go, lifting his cup to his lips again, taking an unhurried sip. The taste of caramel lingered, mixing with the sharper bitterness beneath it.
That was too easy.
Strahm could throw himself into his chair all he wanted, could scowl at his screen and pretend to focus, but Hoffman knew. He knew. Because that reaction? That wasnât just anger. That was something else, something tangled up in frustration and confusion and whatever the hell was flickering behind those glares.
He swirled the drink absently in his cup, gaze flicking toward Strahmâs desk. Then, without looking directly at him, he spokeâjust loud enough to carry across the room.
"You sure you want me to fuck off, or do you just like telling me what to do?"
Hoffman smirked against the rim of his cup, taking another slow sip, letting his pursed lips linger on the rim. Letting the words settle.
Peter's hands froze and his computer as he took a moment to let himself process what Mark just said. Instead of freaking out, or yelling, or even getting out of his seat, he responded calmly. He hated to egg Hoffman on with his emotions.
"Do your damn work, Hoffman. Might do you some good."
Strahm placed his head in his hands for a moment to recollect himself before continuing to work in silence, using his screen to hide from looking at anyone even near him.
He didn't understand this feeling. It was a strange mixture of so many things and emotions he hasn't felt since early college. Whatever it was, Hoffman was enjoying using it against him.
The teasing worked, but god he wish it didn't.
Hoffman finally, finally turned his attention to the files on his desk, though his focus was shot to hell. His eyes moved over the words, but they barely registered. The conversationâthat look Strahm had given him before burying himself in his screenâwas still fresh, playing in his mind like a puzzle he hadnât quite solved yet.
He tapped his fingers against the desk, considering. There was something satisfying about watching Strahm try so hard to keep himself in check, to act like none of this was getting to him. Hoffman knew better.
The corner of his mouth twitched as he flipped a page, not bothering to hide the smirk creeping in. He took another sip of his drink, the sweetness coating his tongue, lingering.
Maybe he should get back to work.
Or maybe he should push just a little moreâjust to see how long Strahm could keep pretending.
Strahm tapped his pen on his desk to a rhythm he had just made up in his mind since that seemed to be the only thing that could replace his thoughts about Hoffman.
Everything reminded him of Mark, it's like he couldn't escape him. He couldn't even focus on his work, which really bothered him. Usually, his work was the one distraction that always worked, but clearly not today.
Peter sighed before standing up and dropping his pen down onto his desk. He ran his hands down his outfit before walking away to the bathroom with his head down the whole time.
He needed an escape. He needed a way to get away from Mark, even just for a couple minutes.
He opened the door to the bathroom, making sure nobody was in there before walking to the sink and turning on cold water. Strahm collected a small amount of water on his hands and splashed it on his face, staring at himself in the mirror. Why was this happening now?
Hoffman didnât look up right away, but he felt the shift. The absence. The way the air around him suddenly felt⊠quieter.
Strahm was gone.
No presence lingering just a few feet away, no rhythmic tapping of a pen, no barely restrained exhale of frustration. The space he left behind felt noticeable in a way Hoffman didnât care to dwell on.
His fingers drummed idly against the desk as he stared at the open file in front of him. He wasnât reading it. His focus was elsewhere, stuck on somethingâor someoneâthat wasnât even in the damn room anymore.
Hoffman sighed, rolling his shoulders before forcing himself back to his work. Strahm would be back.
And when he was, Hoffman wasnât sure if heâd say anything at allâjust that heâd be aware, too aware, of the moment Strahm walked back through that door.
Strahm continued to stare at himself, a look of confusion forming on his face as he stared.
Who was he right now?
He could normally focus on his work with no struggle, but today was just so different. The tension that formed drove him mad. It didn't make any sense, he didn't feel these things last week, so what's so different now?
Peter began to get angry at everything, especially his thoughts. The water still running, the footsteps outside, the talking of his coworkers, the door to the females restroom opening and closing, everything.
He couldn't take it. Strahm punched the bathroom counter, turning the sink off before storming out of the bathroom and back to his seat.
He tried so hard to get on task but with Hoffman around, it would be hard.
The sound of Strahmâs chair scraping against the floor pulled Hoffmanâs attention before he even meant to look at the other man.
Back already.
He didnât watch himânot openly, at least. Whatever that little break had been, it clearly hadnât helped.
Hoffman finally, finally turned his attention to the files in front of him, though his focus was still half elsewhere. He flipped a page, then spoke, his tone casual.
âYou see the new evidence on the Jigsaw case yet?â A beat. Then, with a glint of playfulness in his eyes, he added, âLooks like our guyâs getting smarter.â
Strahm coughed, opening one of the many files on his desk and writing something quick down in pen. "I heard they found a small strand of hair at a scene. They sent it in to get it tested and a DNA read." He sighed. "Seems useless though. It's a strand of hair that was next to a victim, it was probably theirs."
He wasn't doing very well at trying to seem like he calmed down. Peter never denied small things like this unless he was just talking to talk.
He didn't understand how Hoffman was so casual right now. Does he not feel the tension right now? is he really that dumb?
Hoffman didnât look up right away. He turned a page in his file, scanning the words like they mattered more than Strahmâs obvious frustration. âCould be useless,â he said, almost offhandedly. âOr it could be exactly what we need.â
There was no real argument in his toneâjust something thoughtful, maybe even knowing, like he wasnât as dismissive of the lead as Strahm was.
He finally shifted, glancing at Strahm as if noticing him for the first time since he sat back down. His gaze flicked over him brieflyâtaking in the tension still lingering in his shoulders, the way his grip on his pen was just a little too tight.
And then, something caught his attention. The way the dim overhead light hit just right, outlining the sharp line of Strahmâs jaw, the faintest crease between his brows. Had he always clenched his jaw like that when he was thinking? It wasnât just irritationâit was focus, frustration, something deeper that Hoffman couldnât quite pin down.
For a second, he nearly forgot what he was about to say. He forced himself to look back down at his file, masking the moment with an easy shrug.
âLong morning?â His voice was low, almost conversational. But there was something in the way he said itâsomething that made it impossible to tell if he was just making small talk or if he already knew the answer.
Strahm aggressively wrote stuff down in the files, taking small breaks to collect his thought before continuing to write.
"Bad traffic. Bad night." His tone was firm and aggressive, but not on purpose. He spoke quickly which made it obvious it was a lie to get off the topic of anything but work.
He glanced up at Hoffman and froze, using this moment to soak in everything about him. The way he looked so calm while focused on his work, the way his hand gently pushed the pen down on the paper, the way his lips looked when he was focused...
Peter bit down onto his bottom lip roughly, definitely leaving small teeth marks on his lip. Simply looking at Mark made him anxious.
Hoffman didnât react right away. He let Strahmâs words sit between them, as if deciding whether or not to be snide.
He kept his focus on the file in front of him, but his mind was elsewhereâstuck on something he couldnât quite shake. The way Strahmâs voice had that edge to it. The way his pen practically carved into the paper, like he needed the distraction.
Then, in his periphery, he caught itâStrahm biting his lip, hard.
Hoffmanâs grip on his pen tightened for a fraction of a second before he forced himself to relax, dragging his eyes back to his work.
He exhaled through his nose, pretending to stay focused on his paperwork, but his mind was already elsewhere. The way Strahm bit his lipâthat sharp press of teeth against skinâwasnât something he shouldâve noticed.
Wasnât something he shouldâve cared about.
But he did.
His jaw tensed as he forced his attention back to the file in front of him, masking any sign of distraction. After a beat of silence, he finally spoke, his voice lower than before.
"Yeah⊠not like sleep does much good anyway."
"I stayed up practically all night trying to put together why they would test that fucking-" He took a deep breath, looking down at his papers. "that damn strand of hair. It just doesn't make much sense."
As much as he tried to focus on his papers, he couldn't. The way his jaw tensed just drew in his attention even more as if it was magic.
Peter continued to bite at his lip, feeling an impending doom for what Hoffman would say next. His voice was just so smooth, it felt like torture in the best way possible.
He tried to pretend to do his work, but it was hard when his eyes couldn't get off of Mark. He felt helpless in this moment and he hated it.
He was supposed to have all the power.
Hoffman didnât need to look up to know Strahm was still watching him. He could feel itâthose damn eyes, like heat searing into the side of his face, making it almost impossible to focus on anything else.
"Yeah," Hoffman murmured, his voice gravelly but calm, "doesnât add up, does it?"
He wasnât just talking about the case. The frustration in Strahmâs toneâit hit something deeper, something Hoffman didnât feel like addressing, not right now.
He finally looked up, his gaze meeting Strahm's, but only for a brief moment. "But thatâs the thing with this case, Strahm. Sometimes itâs not about making sense." His words carried an almost unsettling weight, though he wasnât sure if Strahm would catch on.
His hand paused mid-motion as he noticed Strahmâs biting, that subtle, almost unconscious action. Hoffmanâs brow furrowed slightly, but he quickly dismissed the thought, shaking it off. He had work to do.
"Try to stay focused," he added, his tone unexpectedly softer, though he meant it more to himself than Strahm.
Strahm let out a deep sigh, closing his eyes and swinging his head back for a moment. This was his best attempt at clearing his mind.
"I just hate when they do things without running it past me or Perez first." He whispered, picking his pen back up and beginning to actually work on the case.
He felt like a idiot. For once, he didn't want to be at work. He regretted coming in today, especially because Lindsey wouldn't be here because her family was in town and wanted one day with them.
Peter picked back up the rhythm from earlier with his pen, tapping it more aggressively than before without realizing. At this point, he was just trying to drown out any of his thoughts, even about work.
Hoffman let the comment hang in the air, though something shifted in his posture at the mention of Lindsey. He didnât outwardly show it, but the thought gnawed at him for a split second.
He leaned back in his chair, the sound of Strahmâs aggressive pen tapping filling the otherwise quiet space. The irritation in Strahmâs actions wasn't lost on Hoffman, but the mention of Lindsey caught him off guard. It wasnât like him to care, not like this.
"Youâre right," Hoffman said, his voice controlled, though there was a slight edge to it, "Youâd think they'd at least consult you. But," he paused, the faintest of smirks pulling at the corners of his lips, "youâre better off without distractions anyway."
He didnât know if Strahm would pick up on the shift in his tone, but Hoffman had a feeling his partner wouldn't miss the faint jealousy that had crept in. He wasnât sure why it bothered him, but it did.
His eyes flicked to Strahm for a brief moment, then back to the file in front of him, trying to focus.
"Guess youâre stuck here with me," he added, his tone slipping just enough to hint at something more personal beneath the professional surface.
Peter suddenly stopped tapping his pen at the last comment Mark added, pausing everything he was doing. Something with the tone he used made him feel something different. Something he hasn't felt yet today.
He couldn't sit here with Hoffman with those words just replaying in his head, he had to escape somewhere.
"I'll be back." Strahm said, his words slightly slurring together. He shot up from his seat, speed walking back to the bathroom. There was one other person in there, but he could care less at the moment.
Peter paced back and forth in the bathroom while waiting for the other man to leave the restroom. Luckily, the pacing must've rushed him out. He continued to pace around, pinching at the bridge of the nose.
There's no way Mark hasn't noticed his weird behavior, there's just no way. He didn't understand why he couldn't just suppress his emotions like he normally did. He has been hiding his emotions with ease for years, so what was so different today?
Hoffman stood up by the windowsill, his back leaning against the cool glass, eyes staring at the outside but not really seeing it. His mind kept drifting back to Strahm, and the way heâd snapped, his frustration practically hanging in the air. There was something about it, something that felt... off. He couldnât quite put his finger on it, but it bothered him.
He rubbed a hand over his face, sighing, trying to clear the thoughts clouding his head. His gaze flicked back to Strahmâs empty deskâ God, why was it so unsettling?
Mark didnât let distractions get to him. He wasnât someone who let emotions or anything else interfere with the job. But thisâwhatever this wasâ was messing with his usual routine.
The door creaked slightly, and his eyes darted toward it, but no one was there. Mark was surprised by how much heâd noticed Peterâs absence. He shifted uncomfortably, his fingers curling into a fist around the edge of the windowsill. What the hell was wrong with him? It wasnât like Strahm to just leave like that, and it wasnât like him either to feel... unsettled by it.
âJust focus,â Mark muttered to himself, but his gaze lingered on the door a second longer than necessary. He hadnât realized how much he had started to notice the little things about Strahmâhis sharp movements, his short temper, the way his jaw tensed when he was angry. And then the way heâd left, so abruptly, like he couldnât even get out of the room fast enough.
Mark rubbed the back of his neck and shook his head, pursing his lips in thought.
He wasnât someone who gave a damn about these things. But today felt... different
And that made him uneasy.
Peter leaned up against the bathroom wall, placing his face in his hands. He wanted to stay in the bathroom until he died but sadly, he knew he couldn't. Strahm continued to bite down on his lip until he tasted blood.
"Fucking hell..." He whispered, taking his hands off his face to wipe his lip. He stared down at his hand, looking at the blood that covered a small part of the side of his hand.
Strahm walked over to the sink and rinsed his hand off, watching the water turn a slight red before slipping down the drain. It was a weirdly calming sight.
He soon left the bathroom, avoiding looking at Hoffman the best he could. "I'm going to refill my coffee." Strahm said firmly as he reached for his cup, rushing away from his desk before he could even hear a response.
If he was being completely honest, he was embarrassed. He was embarrassed that he couldn't hide his feelings this time. It was such a weird thing to feel something other than anger or calmness.
Peter grabbed the old coffee pot from the staff room, filling his large silver cup up with the lukewarm coffee. He hated how he couldn't confront Mark about these feelings.
Hoffman noticed it immediatelyâhow Strahm wouldnât look at him, how his movements were just a little too quick, like he couldnât get away fast enough.
He grabbed his cup and rushed off before Hoffman could so much as blink.
He didnât know what heâd expected, but it wasnât⊠that.
For the first time, something about Strahmâs reaction made him hesitate. He knew how to read peopleâhe had toâbut this wasnât the usual sharp-edged frustration he was used to prying out of Strahm. This wasnât Strahm picking a fight or snapping back. It was avoidance.
And for some reason, Hoffman didnât like that.
His fingers drummed against the desk, watching the spot Strahm had just vacated. Part of himâsome small, stupid partâwondered if heâd actually hurt him. The thought unsettled him more than it should have.
He let out a quiet exhale, dragging his focus back to his paperwork. It was nothing. It had to be nothing.
So why did it sit so strangely in his chest?
Peter took a deep breath in the small but strangely calming staff room. Why couldn't he just man up and go do his work? Why was Hoffman such a distraction? There were all these whys in his head with no answer.
He took a swig of the lukewarm coffee, swishing it around his mouth as he let his mind wander some more. He felt so stupid for avoiding Mark. For some strange reason, he felt bad for avoiding Hoffman.
Strahm looked at the shut door and debated ever leaving this room, but sadly he knew he had to. He had to face his problems.
Peter left the staff room with his head up this time, trying his best to look put together and confident. As he walked to his desk he wondered if everyone else in the building could tell he was breaking on the inside.
Hoffman didnât acknowledge Strahmâs return, keeping his eyes trained on the file in front of him. He wasnât really reading itâhis focus was shot to hell.
He was letting his body speak for him in ways he couldnât control. His leg bounced beneath the desk, a steady, impatient rhythm. His fingers tapped soundlessly against the edge of his paper, the only betrayal of his restlessness.
He wanted to look at Strahm. Watch for any flicker of emotion. See if there was still tension in his jaw, if his lip was still raw from biting down too hard. But he didnât. Not yet.
He just waited. If Strahm wanted to pretend nothing happened, fine. But if there was a crackâany sign of itâHoffman would be there, ready to catch it.
Strahm coughed as if trying to warn Hoffman he was back in his seat, pulling open a completely new file to maybe try and focus on something new.
He read every word on the paper, but nothing made sense in his head at the moment. It was weird, but it felt strange without Hoffman's eyes on him. If he was being honest, he missed being looked at from a distance.
"So, have you heard anything about the Jigsaw case?" Peter asked with his face still buried in the case files on his desk. The silence became too much for him to handle and he needed to break it.
He eagerly waited for a response as if his life depended on it, nervously biting his lip once again and continuing to tap his pen to a different rhythm from before.
Hoffman exhaled slowly, dragging his eyes from his paperwork like he was indulging Strahm by giving him attention.
"Nothing new," he said, his voice even. "Just the same dead ends."
He finally glanced at Strahm, taking in the way his lip was caught between his teeth again, the quick, restless tapping of his pen.
He leaned back slightly, studying Strahm a little longer than necessary before forcing himself to look away. As Hoffman finally looked at him, his gaze snagged on something small but noticeableâthe faint trace of dried blood at the corner of Strahmâs lip. It was barely there, but it was enough.
Hoffmanâs fingers twitched slightly, his grip on his pen tightening before he forced himself to loosen it. He shouldnât care. Shouldnât even be looking. But the sight of it made something uneasy settle in his chest. Had Strahm bitten down that hard?
His jaw tensed as he dragged his eyes away. His breath hitched before he could stop it.
The sight of itâsubtle, unintentional, self-inflictedâsent something sharp and hot running through his veins. His fingers curled around his pen, gripping it just a little too tight. He shouldnât be reacting to this. Shouldnât feel the way his pulse quickened, the way his body betrayed him with that sudden, insidious heat curling in his gut.
His composure threatened to slip.
Hoffman exhaled through his nose, his jaw clenching as he forced his expression to stay neutral. His gaze flicked away, back to his paperwork, even though the words on the page were meaningless now.
âWhy?â His voice came out steadyâthankfullyâbut just a fraction lower than before. âYou onto something?â
He kept his head down, pen skimming over the paper in a weak attempt at normalcy, but the damage was already done. He felt it. And worseâhe liked it.
"Not yet. It's getting annoying how we can't get any new leads..." Strahm put his pen down onto his desk, leaning his head back as he let out a long sigh of exhaustion.
Suddenly, he had gotten an idea. Something that would probably calm down the thoughts about Hoffman in his head, but would probably be seen as weird.
At this point, that was the least of his concerns.
"Hey, wanna go somewhere for lunch? We can discuss the case some more." Peter said, his voice was low with a hint of embarrassment. He didn't want to give Mark any ideas of what he actually meant but instead an idea that he actually cared about the Jigsaw case at this moment.
Strahm held his breath while waiting for a response, keeping his eyes focused on the papers on his desk rather than Hoffman to seem relaxed.
He really hoped he was pulling off the whole 'chill' act...
Hoffman didnât answer right away. He sat with it, rolling the idea over in his head, his pen idly tapping against the desk.
Lunch. Alone. With him.
It was easy to pretend that was a normal suggestion. Just two law enforcement officers talking shop. But Strahm had hesitated before asking, and that hesitation stuck with him.
His eyes flicked toward the other man, watching the way he stayed locked onto the papers in front of him like they held the answer to something more than just their case. His fingers curled around his pen a little tighter.
Hoffman wasnât sure why that detail bothered him.
He exhaled through his nose, feigning indifference. âYeah, sure.â His voice was steady, neutral. As if he hadnât spent the last minute overthinking this.
He leaned back in his chair, stretching his legs out, the tension in his muscles betraying his otherwise relaxed posture. His knee bounced once before he stilled it. He didnât like feeling caught off guard.
He finally looked at Strahm again. âWhere?â It wasnât an enthusiastic acceptance, but it also wasnât a rejection. It was something in between.
Peter let out a quiet sigh as soon as Mark answered, gripping at the bridge of his nose as he tried to think of a place nearby that was nice enough to take Hoffman to, but not too nice.
"Well, I heard there's this nice sandwich place that recently opened... we could go there." Strahm suggested, pulling himself out of his work to actually make eye contact with Hoffman.
He noticed small details very quickly. The way a couple strands of hair fell out of his styled hair, the way his eyes were naturally tired looking in such a good way, the way his hand gripped onto his pen, the way he had to stop his leg from bouncing... everything was so perfect it made him sick.
He tried to pull his eyes off of Mark, but he just couldn't. For once, he had an actual excuse to stare at Hoffman. He shouldn't have been as grateful as he was.
Hoffman let a beat of silence pass before tilting his head slightly, finally meeting Strahmâs eyes with something that almost resembled amusement.
âA sandwich place, huh?â he said, tapping his fingers idly against the desk. âDidnât peg you as the type to branch out. Thought you survived purely off burnt coffee and spite.â
There was a slight smirk at the corner of his mouth, but his tone was just casual enough to keep Strahm guessing. It wasnât an outright challenge, but it wasnât nothing, either. Just enough to test the watersâto see if Strahm would roll his eyes, snap back, or keep looking at him like that.
His leg bounced once before he forced it still again, fingers tightening around his pen.
Peter's breathing quickly became regular as soon as Hoffman made eye contact with him, causing him to stumble over his words.
"Well- I-" He paused, collecting his thoughts. "I mostly survive off of cheap burnt coffee, but I'm switching it up for once." A slight smile appeared on his face for the first time today once he realized if he just kept up this calm, non-angry act up, he might survive this shift.
Or, at least he'll try to keep it up. It's hard when he's around Mark.
Strahm reached into his pocket and searched for his card, flipping through random twenties and tens before finally finding it. "I heard it's pretty cheap so I might as well pay for yours." He said, not even noticing how nice he was being.
He was never nice to anyone other than Lindsey really, so this must've been a rare sighting to anyone listening in to the conversation.
"But I'm only paying because it's cheap. I'm not trying to be all nice and shit, so don't get that idea." Of course, he had to ruin the one moment he seemed slightly kind.
Hoffman let out a quiet chuckle, shaking his head as he watched Strahm fumble with his wallet. There was something oddly endearing about itâhow he offered without thinking, only to immediately try to walk it back. It wasnât often that Strahm let something slip through the cracks.
"Generous and cheap. Quite the combination," Hoffman murmured, his voice dipping into something almost warm, almost teasing. He let the words hang between them for a moment before exhaling, running a hand down the sleeve of his jacket as he stood.
His gaze lingered on Strahm just a little longer than necessary, taking in the way he still wouldn't quite meet his eyes. There was a rare ease in the moment, a shift from the usual sharp edges they threw at each other. Hoffman felt it more than he wanted to acknowledge.
"If youâre so insistent," he said, his tone softer now, something almost amused beneath it, "Iâll let you buy me lunch. Just donât expect me to be nice about it."
It wasnât a joke, not really. But it was something. A quiet acceptance, an unspoken truce. And when he stepped just a little closerâjust enough to catch the faintest tension in Strahmâs shouldersâhe couldn't quite fight the smirk that ghosted across his lips.
"Letâs go before you change your mind."
Strahm nodded in agreement, shoving his wallet back in his pocket before standing, straightening out his top with his hands. It was so weird that he suddenly felt a need to look... cleaner around Hoffman.
"Do you want me to drive?" He asked as he began to walk to the front door of the building, reaching a hand into the opposite pocket of his wallet to grip onto his keys, ready for an answer to his question.
Peter tried to walk slightly fast, trying to avoid anyone really seeing him walk outside the building while having an active and normal conversation with Mark.
He didn't want people to think he suddenly grew fond of Hoffman because, if he was being completely honest, he didn't really like the thought of beginning to grow fond of him.
Peter spent all of these years hating Mark just for that to change from one interaction. It felt stupid to him. He felt stupid.
Hoffman followed steadily, letting Strahm put some distance between them. It wasnât hard to pick up on the way Peter was rushing. Like it meant something.
Hoffman didnât call attention to it, but he noticed. He noticed the way Strahmâs fingers curled tightly around his keys, the way he held himself just a little straighter, as if heâd suddenly started caring about how he looked. It was subtle, but it was there.
And for some reason, it was... alluring.
There was a new kind of tension in Strahm, not the usual barely-contained aggression Hoffman was used to. This was something else, something more restrained. He wasnât sure what to make of it yet, but he had the patience to figure it out.
âIâll let you drive,â he finally said, watching Strahm with something just shy of amusement. His voice was even, casual, but his smirk gave away more than he probably intended. He let the moment stretch just a little longer before adding, âJust try not to kill us before we get there.â
A joke, but one that carried weight. A small push. A test.
He walked ahead of Strahm and put a hand in his pocket as he walked.
"I'll try, but it might be hard with you in the car." Peter said, hiding back a smirk as he spoke. He pulled the keys out of his pocket, gripping them tightly in his hand as if someone was going to steal them from him.
As he entered the cold weather outside, his whole body tightened. Strahm had always hated the cold.
He unlocked his car, quickly shoving himself in to try and escape the weather. He switched on the heat in his car before blowing warm air into his hands, waiting patiently for Mark to say something that gave him the idea he was ready for him to start driving.
Peter really hated driving with a person in his car. His road rage usually killed any good energy moving throughout his car in a matter of seconds. Sure, Mark has seen him angry, but not the type of anger he gets while driving.
Plus, he'd really hate to ruin what they had going on at the moment...
Hoffman let out a short chuckle at Strahmâs response, low and almost under his breath. There was something oddly satisfying about the way Peter shot back without missing a beatâlike he was starting to get comfortable with this, whether he wanted to or not.
The cold bit at his skin as he followed Strahm outside, but he barely registered it, too focused on watching the other man move. The tension in his shoulders, the way he practically threw himself into the car to escape the chillâit was little things like that that made Hoffman feel like he was getting a read on him.
He slid into the passenger seat with an easy, unbothered motion, his gaze settling on Strahm as the heat kicked in. The way Peter hunched over his hands, rubbing warmth back into them, was oddly... humanizing. A rare moment where he looked like more than just a sharp edge waiting to cut.
Hoffman leaned back, making himself comfortable before finally breaking the silence. âYou gonna warm up before we get moving, or do I have to listen to you bitch about the cold the whole drive?â His tone was teasing, but his eyes lingered a little too longâtaking in the way Strahmâs lips were still slightly parted from the rush of warm air, the way his fingers flexed against his palms.
Another small test. Another moment to gauge how far this push-and-pull would go.
Strahm smiled, pulling his hands away from his mouth. "You'll have to hear me bitch about a lot during this car ride. The traffic is bad right now." He said as he put his hand on the steering wheel, gripping it tightly.
He started to drive, his attention suddenly going to the road with a straight, serious face. He always took driving very serious, for some strange reason.
Peter tried to seem calm with Mark in the car, but seeing all the cars lined up in the street already made his blood boil. He didn't want to yell at all, but he just knew that would be hard.
"Holy fuck, that's a lot of cars..." He commented, speaking in a low voice that seemed like a grumble or a growl. His voice always sounded so demanding or angry, no matter what mood he was in.
Hoffman settled into his seat, letting his gaze drift lazily over the dashboard before inevitably landing on Strahmâs hands. He had a firm grip on the wheel, fingers tense, knuckles just shy of turning white.
Hoffman had seen Strahmâs hands in plenty of different settingsâclutching a gun, flipping through case files, clenched into fistsâbut there was something about watching them now, wrapped around the wheel with that quiet intensity, that held his attention a little too long.
The way his fingers flexed slightly every time he muttered under his breath, the subtle tremor of agitation when traffic didnât move fast enoughâit was strangely captivating. It made Hoffman wonder, just for a second, how that tension would feel if it werenât directed at the steering wheel.
âTry not to take it personally,â he said finally, tearing his gaze away and shifting in his seat. âPretty sure the traffic isnât out to get you.â His tone was light, almost mocking, but his fingers tapped idly against his own thighâlike he was keeping himself from saying something else.
"It's just so annoying. If people actually knew how to drive then we-" He suddenly stopped himself from talking, giving himself a moment to collect his thoughts. He couldn't go on a stupid rant about people driving. At leastânot in front of Mark.
His eyes slowly drifted towards Hoffman's fingers tapping against his thigh, picking up on the rhythm in his head quickly. He watched as if it was a mind blowing thing, like something he's never seen before. Obviously, he wasn't focused on the rhythm, he was focused on Mark.
The way he tapped so calmly like he was waiting to say something, the way his focus was on the grip of his hand, the way he was somehow so calm and collected on the outside, everything. All of it just seemed so perfect. Too perfect.
Peter soon snapped out of it as soon as he realized the cars around him were moving, and soon became fixated back on the road.
"This place better be good. If I drove in this traffic for no reason, I'll be pissed." He said, beginning to quietly tap the rhythm Mark had been tapping, using it as a way to calm down.
Suddenly, it hit him. He was driving Mark Hoffmanâthe guy who has been driving him insane all dayâout to eat with him. Sure, it wasn't fancy, but it was still something. The thought of this made him go back to biting his lip, leaving a dent over the previous one that just started going away.
Hoffmanâs fingers kept up their steady rhythm against his thigh, but his focus wasnât really on it anymore. His eyes had drifted back to Strahm, watching the way his jaw tensed, the way his grip tightened on the steering wheelâand most of all, the way he kept biting his lip, almost absentmindedly.
He let the moment stretch for a beat longer than necessary before speaking, voice smooth but just pointed enough to be intentional.
"Didn't take you for a nervous habit kind of guy, Strahm. Be careful there."
The words hung in the air, but the way Hoffmanâs gaze lingeredâjust for a secondâmade it clear heâd noticed. He settled back against the seat, watching for a reaction, wondering if Strahm would brush it off or if the slight shift in energy would throw him off course.
Strahm stopped tapping his fingers, looking over to Mark with a confused expression. It took him a moment to realize he was biting down on his lip. Again.
He quickly corrected himself, wiping his lip to see more blood transfer onto his hand. "Fuck..." He whispered to himself, staring down at the wipe of blood on the side of his hand before sighing and simply putting his hand back onto the wheel.
Peter never understood why he did stuff like this knowing it would later on hurt. And he especially didn't understand why he was doing it even more than usual. Normally, he would bite his lip while checking out a crime scene, or holding a gun, but never while simply being around a person.
He soon realized how much power Hoffman held when it came to himself. He could simple say something cocky and it would mess up his whole shift, or even the rest of his day.
"God fucking damn it." He said as he punched the steering wheel, causing his car to honk to the car in front of them.
Great, he did the one thing he was trying not to do. Get mad over a simple thing while in the car.
Hoffmanâs smirk faltered. Just for a second.
He hadnât expected that reactionâhadnât expected Strahm to actually hit the wheel like that. The sharp sound of the horn rang in his ears, but it was the frustration in Strahmâs voice that really caught him off guard.
For all the ways he liked to push, this wasnât what heâd been aiming for.
Hoffman shifted slightly, pulling his gaze away, tapping his fingers against his thigh againâbut this time, it wasnât intentional. It was just something to do. Something to focus on instead of the way Strahmâs knuckles were going white against the steering wheel.
"Forget it," he muttered, quieter than before. "Didnât mean anything by it."
For once, he let the moment pass without another remark. No teasing, no smug little comments. Just silenceâsave for the hum of the car engine and the faint, rhythmic tapping of his fingers.
Was this guilt? He felt guilty for that remark, and Hoffman rarely cares about others like that.
He suddenly felt anxious. He tried to remain suave but his hands shook ever so slightly as he loosened his tie. It was getting slightly hard to breathe.
Strahm had gone completely silent at this point, taking all his anger out by gripping the wheel. If he knew that he would've fucked up the stuff they had going, he would've tried to prevent it.
But he couldn't.
He soon saw the sandwich shop, realizing it was closed. He went through all of this for it to be closed. He sighed and turned into the parking lot anyway, parking the car to think of another place they could go to.
"So... the shop is closed today, I guess." Peter said, his voice quiet and low as if he was confessing something. He felt somewhat bad. He felt bad for taking Hoffman out of work just to find out their plans wouldn't even end up working.
"We could... go somewhere else. Or go back." He paused as he thought of more ideas. "Or we could sit here and talk about the case." He said as a last choice.
Instead of looking over to Hoffman, he stared down at his lap. It didn't feel right to look at him after what just happened. He felt... embarrassed in a way. He knew that if he reacted to something with anger, it would've changed everything. Yet, he did it anyways. He just let it happen.
Hoffman stayed quiet for a moment, letting his eyes settle on Strahm. Really looking at him.
The way his shoulders were still tense, the way his fingers flexed against the steering wheel like he was holding himself back.
Hoffman tapped his fingers one last time before letting his hand still in a gentle grasp against his thigh. He wasnât in a rush to speak.
Instead, he just watched.
There was a strange feeling in Hoffmanâs chest, something he didnât quite have the words for.
After another beat of silence, he finally spoke. "Well," he drawled, tilting his head slightly, "weâve already wasted this much time. Might as well make it worth it."
His voice was even, but there was an edge of something unreadable in it.
Hoffman wasnât sure what he expected Strahm to say next. But he was sure of one thingâhe wasnât ready to leave yet.
"Mhm.." Peter hummed in response, taking his hands off the wheel to try and seem more calm and relaxed. His attention turned to Mark very soon, his eyes hovering over his whole body before meeting his eyes.
He had a strange feeling in his chest every time he looked at Mark. It suddenly felt heavy and felt it got harder to breathe.
The tension in the car was so much more in the office. The way they were much closer than before, the way they had no where else to look but each other, it was all too much. Peter removed his jacket, folding it neatly before setting it down in his lap. Though, he never broke eye contact.
"Have you got anything about the case? Any suspects, any leads, anything? Have you heard anything from the DNA test yet?" Peter decided it would be best to ask a good amount of questions. Then, it would be easier for him to seem less.. awkward and nervous.
Work seemed to be the only thing keeping him sane right now.
Hoffman didnât miss the way Strahm folded his jacketâcareful, deliberate, like he needed to keep his hands occupied. It was almost amusing, the way he tried to seem at ease when everything about him screamed tightly wound.
He let the moment stretch, saying nothing at first. Just watching.
âCouple of things,â he said finally, voice level, unreadable, clearing his throat. âDNA test came back inconclusive. No solid matches.â
Hoffman let that sit between them, waiting to see how Strahm would react.
Mark shifted in his seatâ just enough to take up more space, his arm settling on the center console. Closer.
âThereâs one lead,â Hoffman continued, deliberately unhurried. âGuy who fits the profileâex-con, history of violence, used to work in mechanical engineering.â
Another pause. Then, finally, Hoffman turned his head, meeting his gaze fully.
âYou all right, Strahm?â His voice was smooth, casual, but he knew exactly what he was doing.
Hoffman could feel itâthe tension, the weight pressing down on the space between them. And he liked it.
At first his maintained eye contact, but that proved to be too much for him so he backed off, clearing his throat again.
âIâm not trying to make you nervous.â A lie, and also deflecting some of his own feelings.
"What? I'm fine. I'm not nervous at all, Hoffman." Peter responded, his words sharp and aggressive. He didn't realize until now how tense and nervous his body language was. He shoulder tensed, his jaw clenched, his hands always forming a fist, everything was not normal.
He hated the power Mark held over him. It made him so angry to the point of nausea. Every time Mark did anything better than him, he got jealousâangry. Every time Mark looked at him, he got nervous. He hated the way he just let this happen.
Strahm took a deep breath, placing his arm right next to Hoffman's. "Well, at least we've got something. It's better than what we had before." He said, his voice was very monotoneâdry even.
"I should probably call Perez soon and tell her about this..." Peter said, tapping his finger to a different rhythm than before. It was more aggressive and repetitive, showing both his anger and anxiety in one rhythm.
The way his and Mark's arms were so close made him feel something he couldn't explain. It made it hard to breathe, as if someone were to suck all the air out of his lungs.
[ ooc text : i wrote the second part of this while listening to jealousy, jealousy by olivia rodrigo. feels important to share. ]
Hoffman watched him carefully, his expression unreadable. Strahmâs words were sharp, but they didnât match the way his body was betraying himâso tense he looked ready to snap. Hoffman could practically feel the heat radiating off him, the way his energy buzzed with something dangerously close to frustration. Or something else.
His eyes flicked down to their arms, barely a breath apart. It would take nothing to close that distance. To shift just slightly and press against him, just to see what Strahm would do.
Then Strahm mentioned Perez.
Hoffmanâs fingers, which had been resting idly against his thigh, curled inward before he abruptly moved his arm away, leaning slightly toward the car door. His expression didnât change, but something in his body language didâsomething colder.
"Yeah," he muttered. "You probably should."
Hoffman clenched his jaw, staring straight ahead as if the windshield suddenly held something more interesting than Strahm beside him. The mention of Perez shouldnât bother him, but it did. He knew how much Strahm trusted herâhow easily they worked together, how she could read him in ways Hoffman couldnât.
He didnât like it.
His fingers twitched against his leg, resisting the urge to match Strahmâs rhythm like before. Instead, he let the silence stretch, letting the distance he created sit heavy between them.
âWant some space to call her?â
Strahm noticed how Hoffman tensed as soon as he mentioned Perez, a look of confusion quickly forming on his face. Why did Mark get so weird every time he mentioned Lindsey? Why did he act so weird whenever she was at his desk? It made no sense.
He looked down to see his arm moved away, a feeling of defeat washing over him. They were so close, it was perfect. But clearly, he messed something up to changed the tension they had going for them.
"Uhm, no... I'll just call her later today. She's probably busy anyway, and I don't want to interrupt her." Peter said, slowly removing his arm and placing it onto his lap. He stared at Hoffman, noticing how he would rather stare at nothing then stare at him. Why did it change so quickly?
He coughed, trying to stop the silence between the two. "What should we do?" He asked, trying to use a tone that suggested that he was open to anything, work related or not. At this point, he'd be willing to do anything to get out of this uncomfortable situation.
Strahm started to pick at the sides of his fingernails, messing up his already rough looking fingers. He watched as a small amount of blood formed on his finger once he peeled some skin off, watching it build up but not drip.
It was better to watch than continuing to watch Mark stare out the windshield as if it was much more interesting.
Hoffman exhaled, letting the tension ease from his shoulders as he settled back into his seat. His arm found its way back to the consoleânot quite touching Strahmâs, but close enough that it wasnât a full retreat anymore.
"Alright," he said, tilting his head slightly as if considering their options. "We could hit up that shitty diner a few blocks over. The one with the terrible coffee but decent fries." He shot Strahm a sideways glance, a ghost of a smirk tugging at his lips. "Unless youâre too good for a place that serves their food on plastic trays."
It wasnât just about food anymore, and they both knew it. Hoffmanâs posture was more open again, his voice lacking the sharp edge from earlier.
"And hey," he added, his smirk sharpening just slightly, "maybe if you're lucky, the waitress will think weâre on a date and give you the check. Since, y'know, you were so eager to take me out in the first place."
It was a joke, but not a denial. And the way he looked at Strahm when he said itâsteady, watching for a reactionâmade it clear he wasnât just filling the silence.
âOr maybe one of us can flash our badge and make her feel bad.â He winked. A soft, brief action.
A smirk appeared on Strahm's face, looking up from his hand and back to Hoffman. "I'm fine with the shitty diner, I guess." He said with a hint of sarcasm in his voice at the end.
"And I think we should go with the second idea. Flashing our badges is better than her thinking we're a gay couple." Peter said as he began to start driving, but this time only with one arm. Keeping his arm next to Mark's felt... right.
He began driving out of the parking space, making a promise in his mind that he wouldn't get visibly angry at the people on the road. He would hate to ruin the tension for the hundredth time today. Peter bit down on his lip slightly, mainly doing it to keep his focus on the road.
Peter took a deep breath as soon as he got on the road, trying to seem like he didn't even care about the traffic, but he did. He really did. He actually cared about everything right now. The traffic, the way Hoffman's arm was right next to his, the fact he was driving him to a diner, everything. It all was so much more than it would normally be, but he stayed calm.
At least, he tried to stay calm.
Hoffman stood just outside the diner's entrance, the neon light flickering against his skin, casting him in a glow of red and gold. He flexed his fingers at his sides, still feeling the lingering warmth from where their arms had brushed in the car. It was stupidâinsignificant, really. But it had made something stir deep in his chest, something he wasnât ready to acknowledge.
He glanced over his shoulder, watching Strahm still sitting in the driverâs seat, his fingers tapping against the wheel. For a moment, Hoffman just⊠looked at him. The usual irritation was there, sure, but it was layered with something else, something heavier. He exhaled, shaking his head to himself before rapping his knuckles lightly against the glass door.
"You coming?" His voice was lower than he intended, softer, almost coaxing. He hesitated, then let a smirk tug at his lips. "Or do you just like staring at me from a distance?"
He turned before he could catch Strahmâs expression, stepping inside the diner. The scent of coffee and fryer grease wrapped around him, familiar and grounding. Still, that warmth from the car lingered, settling deep in his chest. As much as he tried to ignore it, deny it, there was no shaking the truthâsomething between them had shifted. And for once, Hoffman wasnât sure if he wanted to fight it.
Peter sighed before slipping his coat on, finally leaving his car. He made sure to lock his car before walking over to the diner with the neon flickering lights. This is not where he exactly wanted to take Mark, but guess that's what he had to deal with for now.
He stepped inside, walking past Hoffman to a small booth all the way in the corner of the diner. He sat in the seat against the wall, waiting patiently for Mark to sit across from him.
It was weird to think about. Taking the man he hated out to get food. Sure, he invited him to talk about 'work' , but they both knew that wasn't going to actually happen. At least, not the whole time.
"I don't really know if I'll eat anything here. Hell, they probably cook dead rats into the food based on what people say about it." Peter said, looking around to see most employees sitting on their phones or talking. Sure, this wasn't ideal, but it would work just fine.
After all, he didn't want things to seem romantic. Peter didn't like Mark that way.
At least, that's what he told himself.
Hoffman leaned back against the cracked vinyl seat, drumming his fingers against the tabletop as he glanced over the laminated menu. It was sticky. Of course it was. He barely looked at the options before setting it aside.
"Dead rats or not, Iâm getting a shake," he said, flagging down a half-interested waitress. "Chocolate. Extra thick." His voice was smooth, deliberate, like he was making a point. He didn't care if the place was a dumpâhe was here, and he was going to enjoy something.
Once the waitress walked off, he leaned forward slightly, resting his forearms on the table. His gaze flicked over Strahm, taking in the tension in his shoulders, the way he was still pretending like this wasnât something. It was almost endearing.
"You know, if you keep looking that uncomfortable, people are gonna think I dragged you here against your will." His smirk was slow, knowing. "Or worse, that this actually is a date and you're just playing hard to get."
He let that sit between them, watching for the reaction. Strahm always had a tell, no matter how much he tried to hide it. And Hoffman? He lived for it.
Peter hummed in response to Mark, quickly shaking his head once the waiter looked at him with a look of boredom and impatience, waiting for an order. He sighed as soon as the waiter walked off, shutting his eyes for a moment before opening them to meet Mark leaned more towards him.
"I would way rather have them think you kidnapped me or something. I don't want people to think we're on a date. Or that I'm gay." As soon as he spoke those last four words, it hurt something in him. He didn't understand why though. He wasn't gay. That's what he's been telling everyone for years.
These feelings were so confusing. He hated Hoffman, he knew he did. Something was... different. Usually, he would be tearing his hair out by nowâbut it was different now. He was less angry.
Strahm tried to relax his shoulder, but failed. He hated how much he seemed so nervous and shut off when he wanted to seem relaxed. He wanted to seem more normal, but that was hard when he wasn't normal even when hating Mark.
Hoffman let out a quiet snort, shaking his head slightly as he leaned back again, giving Strahm just a bit more spaceâbut not much.
âRelax, Strahm,â he muttered, voice low and edged with amusement. âNo one in here gives a shit about what you are.â His fingers drummed idly against the table as he watched the way Peterâs shoulders stayed locked in place, the tension rolling off of him in waves.
That reactionâthat was interesting. It wasnât just irritation or the usual disdain that Strahm carried whenever he was around him. This was something else. Hoffman bit his lip in thought.
Hoffman tilted his head slightly, his eyes scanning Strahmâs face, catching the way his mouth pressed into a tight line, the way his fingers curled against his thigh like he was trying to hold something back.
He could push. It would be easy. A well-placed comment, a teasing smirk, just enough of a prod to see what would happen if he hit the right nerve.
But, for once, he didnât.
Instead, he exhaled, shaking his head as he reached for his glass of water, taking a slow sip before setting it back down. âBesides, if I did kidnap you, Iâd make sure you at least got something better than a damn sandwich out of it.â
The words were casual, thrown out with just enough humor to make it unclear whether he was joking or not. But underneath, it was a testâa different kind of test. Would Strahm push back? Laugh it off? Or would he keep unraveling right in front of him?
Peter felt like he was melting away. He was so focused on what other people around him thought. People he would most likely never even see again. The idea of a random stranger thinking something that wasn't true made him freak out. What if he actually saw them again and they thought he was something he wasn't? What if that made people avoid him? He hated it.
"Yeah. Sure." He mumbled, looking over Mark's shoulder for a second to scan the whole diner and all the workers. Another habit he had to avoid a situation. This time, the situation was right in front of himâstaring with a smirk that showed that he was clearly interested by Peter's reactions to things.
He looked down at his lap, fixing the previous creases he made in his pants from gripping them. It was weird, he felt a sudden need to look nice. Normally, if he was at work, he never cared. It was just work after all. Today thoughâit was different. Very different.
"Oh, so if you were to kidnap someone, you would cook them a full meal?" Strahm asked with a hint of sarcasm in his voice, trying to come across as more calm and relaxed. His tone was calm, but his body language was completely different. His body language resembled a stray cat whenever you try to pet it. Tense, intimidating, aggressive.
He didn't mean to come off like this, but it was better than coming off nice, or worseâromantic. Which sucked, because deep down there was something going on. Something other than hate or anger. But different from what he felt around Lindsey...
Hoffman let out a low chuckle, shaking his head as he leaned back slightly, arms crossing over his chest. âWhat, you think Iâd half-ass it?â His smirk remained, but his gaze was steady, watching every nervous shift, every flicker of hesitation in Strahmâs expression.
Hoffman tilted his head slightly. âIâm just saying, if I were the kind of guy to kidnap someone, Iâd at least put in the effort. Full meal. Maybe some wine. Make it a whole experience.â His voice was even, casual, but the weight behind his words lingered in the space between them.
He let the thought settle for a moment before reaching for his drink, taking another slow sip. âNot that youâd appreciate it,â he added, tone bordering on dry amusement. âYou strike me as the type to complain about the wine pairing.â
He was still testing, still pushingâjust enough to see how Strahm would react.
"Well, I believe that it would be a bit stupid to make a full meal. You don't want the person you kidnapped to get attached to you. That'll just cause so many more problems." Strahm said as if he had experience in stuff like this. Obviously, he didn't. It was more of the fact that he's dealt with multiple situations like this.
Peter's voice was less aggressive, finally showing that some of the tension and stress had left his body. It felt like heavy sandbags being lifted off his shoulders, giving him the ability to finally seem a bit more confinement rather than stuck in his own skin.
"Of course I complain about wine pairing. It's basically everything when it comes to a nice meal! Tell me, would you pair a glass of Pinot Noir with a steak? No. You would pair something like Cabernet Sauvignon." It was obvious he was good at this subject. Which you probably wouldn't guess by getting one simple look at him.
Peter checked his watch, quickly looking back up to Mark. "We should probably head back soon." He said, putting his coat over his arms as quickly, basically preparing himself to leave in a quick amount of time.
Hoffman raised an eyebrow, watching Strahm with something between amusement and intrigue. The shift in his demeanor didnât go unnoticedâhis voice had lost some of that earlier edge, his posture a little less rigid. It was subtle, but it was there.
âDidnât take you for a wine guy,â Hoffman mused, tilting his head slightly. âThatâs a real specific take for someone who spends most of his days running on burnt coffee.â His smirk lingered, but there was something else in his gaze nowâsomething considering.
He didnât know why it was so damn fascinating, watching Strahm loosen up, even just a little. Maybe it was because he knew how rare it was. Strahm was all sharp edges and tension, always coiled like a spring. Seeing him talk about something so mundane, something he actually seemed passionate about, was... different.
Hoffman exhaled through his nose, glancing at his own watch before rolling his shoulders back. âYeah, wouldnât want anyone thinking we actually enjoyed this.â The words were teasing, but there was an undertone to themâsomething unspoken but lingering.
As Strahm pulled on his coat with that same urgency, Hoffman just watched him for a moment before finally moving to stand. He didnât rush. He didnât need to. Strahm was already rattled enough without him adding to it.
But still, as they stepped outside into the cold, he let the silence settle just long enough to make Strahm wonder what he was thinkingâbefore finally breaking it with a low, amused murmur:
âYou talk a big game about wine pairings, but next time, Iâm picking the place.â
He paused for a moment, thinking if he should even offer but he did, anyways: âWant me to drive the way back?â He asked, staring ahead.
"Really? I'm a pretty big wine guy. Me and Perez tend to talk about it a lot, I guess you just don't hear us." He found himself bringing up Lindsey again. He knew that it wasn't a good idea. He knew that everything would shift once again after bringing her up. Yet, he still did it.
He sighed before walking over to the waiter, putting down a random ten dollar bill from his wallet before walking outside into the cold with Hoffman. The cold hit him like a punch, causing him to exhale a deep breath.
"Well, I wasn't going to bring you to a place where they pair wine to discuss work, Mark." The comment was supposed to come off playful, but instead came off harsh. He always struggled to control his tone, which was the reason he spoke with such a monotone, bored voice.
Peter unlocked the car doors, looking over to Mark. "Yeah, sure. It'll be better for you to drive anyway." He said, getting in the car before discussing anything else. He would rather die than stand a moment longer in the cold weather.
Hoffmanâs jaw tightened at the mention of Perez. Of course, Strahm had to bring her up. He always did, like it was some kind of reflex. And every time, it hit Hoffman the same wayâan irritating little twist in his gut that he couldn't quite shake.
He didnât say anything right away, just let his eyes linger on Strahm as they stepped out into the cold. The wind bit at his skin, but he barely registered it. He was too busy watching the way Strahm hunched his shoulders, the way he exhaled sharply like the cold was trying to rip the breath from his lungs.
Hoffman scoffed at the comment about work, catching the way Strahm avoided looking directly at him. Yeah, sure. You werenât gonna bring me to a place like that for work. But youâd bring Perez, wouldnât you?
He didnât voice the thought. Instead, he followed Strahm into the car, sliding into the driverâs seat with a little more force than necessary. The second he started the engine, the heater kicked on, filling the space with warmthâbut Hoffman still felt that simmering irritation sitting low in his chest.
He glanced at Strahm. Something about him made his fingers tighten on the steering wheel. âYou talk about wine like some expert, but I bet if Perez were here, youâd have some bullshit poetic thing to say about it,â he muttered, keeping his voice level, but there was an unmistakable sharpness to it.
He wasnât sure what he wanted out of that commentâmaybe just to see Strahmâs reaction, to make him squirm the way Hoffman felt himself doing internally. Because for all his control, for all his carefully placed remarks, something about Strahm had a way of slipping under his skin. And it pissed him off. Well, he didn't know if he was more pissed off at that or the fact that he didn't understand why he was pissed off in the first place.
Peter put his hands between his knees in an attempt to warm them up, staring down as he did. He couldn't bring himself to look at Mark. He couldn't bring himself to even quickly glance at him. He already felt everything shift as soon as he brought up Lindsey.
Just as he was in his thoughts, Mark spoke.
The words stabbed him, causing his stomach to turn. Not out of anxiety, but rather anger. It made him so angry knowing that Hoffman hated Perez for no real reason. It made his blood boil. She wasn't a bad detective, she was kind, she never came off as aggressive, she was so perfect. Yet, Mark found a way to hate her.
"What do you mean, Hoffman? What is that supposed to mean." The first time was a question. The second time was in demand. A demand for answers. He was tired of how he always found a way to get mad at Lindsey when she has never done anything to him.
Strahm still avoided eye contact, but it was clear that he was angry. Even without the look of rage and hatred in his eyes, anyone could still tell he was angry. The way his words became sharp and intense again, the way his body tensed up when he spoke, the way his hands turned into fist in seconds.
It was all too obvious.
Hoffman didnât answer right away. He just drummed his fingers against the steering wheel, exhaling through his nose as if Strahmâs reaction wasnât exactly what he was hoping for.
But it was.
The sharpness in his voice, the way his body locked upâHoffman knew that anger well. He knew how it made Strahmâs breath come a little quicker, how it made him grip at things too tightly. And maybe it was fucked up, but he liked knowing he could pull that reaction from him so easily.
âWhat do I mean?â Hoffman repeated, dragging the words out slow, testing the weight of them on his tongue. His gaze flicked toward Strahm, watching the way he kept his eyes pointed anywhere but at him. Coward.
âI mean exactly what I said. You donât talk about me the way you talk about her.â His voice was even, but there was something under itâsomething Strahm wasnât going to like if he looked too closely.
His grip on the wheel tightened. âAnd donât pretend like you donât know what I mean,â he added, lower this time, but more pointed. âEvery time she comes up, you get allââ He waved a hand vaguely, knowing Strahm would get it. âLike sheâs so perfect. Like she can do no wrong. So yeah, maybe I donât like her, Strahm. Maybe I donât like the way you talk about her.â
His jaw clenched. He hadnât meant to say that last part, but now it was out there, sitting in the space between them. And for once, he was the one who looked away first.
Peter's breathing was quick and heavy, as if he was holding back so many things. Which, he was. Instead of yelling, he let Mark finish. He let him finish his ranting while holding eye contact. His eyes were angry, hateful, and disappointed. His eyes held a look that was almost unreadable, yet so readable at the same time.
He hated hearing these words. He hated hearing about someone not liking Lindsey. He hated listening to someone not thinking she was perfect. He hated hearing that Mark hated her. He hated Mark.
He felt his head began to hurt from the rage and all the thoughts piling up at once. He couldn't keep them hidden much longer. He had to express them somehow.
"What's the true reason you can't handle me talking about someone else? What is it, Hoffman? What makes you, a grown man who I haven't known most of my life, crave the attention I give to someone else? What makes you feel the need to act like an angry pathetic dog who craves attention? What is it?" He spoke, his words spilling out. He couldn't stop now.
"Why would I need to talk about you the way I talk about her? Do you believe you are more important than Lindsey in my mind? Do you truly believe you are better than her?" He thought for a moment, collecting his ability to breathe before continuing.
"I talk about her that way because she is perfect. She does no wrong. When has she ever wronged you? When has she wronged me? When has she wronged anyone? You can't think of a single example, can you? That's because she hasn't wronged anyone. You have no real reason to hate her other than jealousy, which doesn't even make sense because I could've sworn you hated me just yesterday. Why are you suddenly so jealous over someone I've known for years?"
He stopped himself, but his body language showed how angry he still was. His eyes, his hands, his shoulders, everything. It just showed how angry he was. Even then, that didn't do it justice.
Hoffmanâs grip on the steering wheel was so tight that his knuckles were white, the leather groaning under his fingers as he tried to force the anger back down. The air between them was thick with the tension, and it only got worse as Strahmâs wordsâsharp, biting, full of that damn righteous angerâsettled in the car, suffocating everything else.
Every word from Strahm twisted something inside him, but it wasnât just anger. It was jealousy.
Hoffman could feel the heat radiating from him, the sharpness in his voice, his body practically vibrating with the intensity of it. Jealous of Lindsey. Thatâs what it was, isnât it? But no. He couldnât admit that. Not out loud. Not even to himself.
His jaw locked so tight that it hurt, and it was taking all his self-control not to lash out. But as much as he hated admitting it, he wasnât just angry. No, it was more complicated than that.
"Really, Strahm?" Hoffmanâs voice was low, too low. It felt like it came from somewhere deep inside him, almost like he was letting something slip without meaning to. âYou wanna act like Iâm just throwing a fit, like Iâm jealous?â His words came out rough, but there was something else thereâsomething softer. A pull, just beneath the anger. âYou think I care about her more than you?â
He took a slow breath, still staring at the road, forcing himself to focus on the sound of his heartbeat. It wasnât enough to calm the storm inside him. His eyes flickered briefly to Strahm, watching the way he held himself, how tense and wound up he was. That tightness in his jaw, those clenched fists. Hoffman hated it. But he also liked it. Too much.
âIf I cared about her that much,â Hoffman continued, his voice a little quieter now, almost to the point where Strahm had to lean in to hear him, âI wouldnât be here. Wouldnât be here with you, would I?â
His pulse quickened as he said it, that same rush of heat climbing up his neck. He hated how it soundedâtoo much like he was admitting something, too much like he was being vulnerable when heâd never let anyone see that side of him.
His hands tightened on the wheel again, but it wasnât just anger this time. His thoughts were swirling, clouded with the weight of what he couldnât say. Couldnât admit.
He glanced at Strahm again, eyes narrowing, but this time it was different. He couldnât look away. There was something else there nowâsomething raw, something almost intimate in the way Strahm looked at him.
âIs that what you want, Peter?â Hoffmanâs voice was softer now, barely a whisper, a challenge. âYou really think Iâm jealous of her? Or is it that you just canât handle the idea of me being here instead of her?â
His heart thudded in his chest, the words spilling out before he could stop them. His stomach twisted. Why couldnât he stop? Why did it feel like something had shifted, like the whole conversation was moving toward something else entirely?
The silence between them stretched out, the only sound the hum of the engine and the beating of their hearts. Hoffman wasnât sure if Strahm could feel it tooâthe way the air had thickened with unspoken words. The way it felt like they were suddenly standing at the edge of something they werenât quite ready for.
But it was too late. The tension was already there, and Hoffman knew, without a doubt, that it wasnât just about Lindsey anymore.
And he hated himself for that.
Peter suddenly felt the tension for once, actually backing off. Something told him he needed to back off this situation before he said anything else or anything worse. He suddenly, for some reason, felt bad. It didn't make sense though. He shouldn't feel bad. He had a point, Mark did seem jealous of Lindsey. But did he maybe take it too far?
He took a breath through his nose and out his mouth. "Mark, I'm not saying you're jealous, I'm saying it seems like it. Every time I mention Lindsey, you act like it's the end of the damn world. You get all tense and angry as if you hate her for simply being in my life."
He spoke as if he hated the idea of Hoffman being jealous, but he really didn't. He enjoyed the idea of how he could ruin someones mood just by simply bringing up one person.
"All I want to know is why. Why does your mood change? Why do you get so tense? Why do you hate the idea that I think she's perfect?" Strahm poured out his words as if his mouth was a faucet for his brain.
The air between them was too much. It was thick, it was overwhelming. It drove him so insane how angry they both were. All he could hear was his own heartbeat in his ears.
"I just need to know. Why don't you like Lindsey?" He wasn't demanding anymore. He was pleading. He wanted to know why because he couldn't handle watching how he looked at her with such anger and jealousy every time they spoke at work.
Hoffmanâs grip on the steering wheel was relentless as Strahmâs words hung in the air, thick and heavy, pressing down on him like a weight he couldnât shake off. The space between them felt suffocating, as if every word Strahm said was just making the tension worse. But something in the way Strahm spoke caught him off guardâthere was a vulnerability there, a softness to his tone that Mark wasnât used to. Pleading. It had always been anger before, but now it was something else. Something that made Hoffman feel like he was walking a razorâs edge.
"You really wanna know, Peter?" Hoffmanâs voice was low, rough with something that wasnât anger anymore. It was too much to admit, too much to say, but it was right there, clawing at the back of his throat.
He took a breath, feeling the heat of Strahmâs words pressing into him. Mark wasnât ready to give in, not yet. He couldnât be. But damn, it was hard to ignore how his chest tightened when Strahm spoke with that tone. Pleading, vulnerable, asking for answers he couldnât give. Hoffman couldnât explain it, but there was something in Strahmâs eyesâthe way he looked at him, the way his words tangled up like a question and a challenge all in oneâthat made him want to say everything. To tell him the truth, to finally admit what had been gnawing at him all this time.
Markâs eyes flickered to Strahm, a quick glance that lingered too long. He tried to look away, but couldnât. He just... couldnât.
âI donât hate her,â Hoffman finally muttered, voice laced with frustration, but there was something deeper in it too. Something that was hard for him to articulate. âItâs not about her. Itâs not about her at all.â
The words came out harsher than he meant, but it wasnât about Lindsey, was it? It was about Peter. And that was something Hoffman wasnât ready to face.
âYou wanna know why my mood changes when you talk about her?â Hoffmanâs voice dropped even lower, almost a growl. âItâs because Iâm hereâwith youâand I hear you talk about her like sheâs some saint. Like sheâs perfect. Like sheâs everything you need, everything you want. And I canât stand it.â
The words slipped out before he could stop them, raw and unfiltered. His chest heaved, and his heart was beating too fast, like it was trying to escape. He could feel the shift, the intensity of the moment pulling them both into a place neither of them were ready for. But Hoffman couldnât help it. He couldnât keep it in any longer.
He turned his head slowly, eyes locking with Strahmâs, searching for somethingâanythingâin his face that would tell him he was still in control, that he hadnât just said too much.
âYou think Iâm jealous of her? Maybe... maybe Iâm just jealous that she gets to have you, and I donât.â
There it was. The words that were always just beneath the surface. He could feel the heat rising in his face, the tightness in his chest, and the way his hands were trembling ever so slightly. He hated how weak it made him feel, how vulnerable.
âBut you donât get it, do you?â Hoffman continued, his voice almost a whisper now, the anger simmering just beneath the surface. âI donât care if sheâs perfect, Peter. Itâs you. Itâs you I canât stand when you talk about her like that. Because itâs not about her. Itâs about... us.â
The words hung in the air, fragile and heavy. He hated how much they revealed, how much of himself he had just let slip. But there was no taking them back now. And as much as he tried to hold it all together, his chest still ached with that unspoken truthâhe had crossed a line he wasnât sure he could walk back from.
The silence stretched between them, thick and suffocating, until it felt like they were both drowning in it. Hoffman wasnât sure what came next. He wasnât sure if he wanted to know. But it was too late to pull back now.
Strahm stared blankly at Hoffman, his angry gaze soon becoming soft. Instead of cutting him off, he listened quietly. He didn't react in any form, though. It didn't feel right. Even a simple nod felt wrong. That would make it seem like he agreed with his feelings, but he didn't. He hadn't connected those feelings inside him just yet.
He wanted until he was silent and the silence was basically drowning the both of them before finally speaking. "Mark... I- I don't know what to say." He said, his mind not fully grasping everything that was said. It still hung in the air, driving him to insanity every second. He wasn't gay. He knew it.
"I'm not... well, I'm not gay. And Lindsey doesn't have me, no one has me." His words came off more aggressive than he wished. "Not even you, Hoffman. You don't have me." Those words weren't supposed to come out. He didn't want to come off as mean. The emotions were just too much to handle, though. Too much to care about how his words came across.
"There is no us. The only us we have going on is a work situation, Mark." He hesitated saying his name. "There can't be any of us. I'm sorry, but that's not who I am. And I'm not going to lead you on and pretend that's who I am. I clearly already lead you on enough..."
The last part came out as a whisper, like he was ashamed. Embarrassed even. He never felt bad, but he did this time. He didn't know why, but he did. He felt horrible, actually. It sat so uncomfortably in his stomach he couldn't help but almost gag. Why did he feel so bad?
Why did he regret everything he said?
Hoffmanâs chest tightened as Strahm spoke, each word hitting him like a physical blow. He hadnât expected Peter to say any of thatâhe hadnât expected any of it, really. But the sting of the words, the sharpness in Peterâs voice, felt like a blade to his gut. He hadnât thought that hearing Peter reject him would hurt this much. But it did. It hurt more than he ever thought possible.
When Strahm said those words, âIâm not gayâ, it felt like the ground beneath Mark's feet shifted. It felt like everything he had just laid out, all the things he had been thinking, sayingâfeelingâwas being slammed down in front of him like some hard truth he wasnât ready to hear.
And then the next partââNot even you, Hoffmanââstung deeper. The way Peter said it wasnât meant to be cruel, but it felt like it. Markâs hand clenched into a fist on the steering wheel, knuckles white, as if the tension in his body might somehow find an outlet through sheer force.
But it didnât.
He felt the weight of Peterâs words sitting heavily in the car between them, suffocating him, making him feel smaller than he ever had before. He didnât know what to say to thatâhow to fight back against something so⊠absolute. So final.
Still, there was something in Peterâs tone that shifted, something quieter, something almost⊠regretful. Embarrassed.
Hoffmanâs heart slammed in his chest as Peter whispered the last part, âI clearly already lead you on enough.â
For a moment, Mark couldnât breathe. It was like the air itself had been sucked out of the car, and he was left grasping at whatever was left.
No, Peter didnât want him. He didnât want this.
But there was that whisper of regret that stayed with Hoffman, swirling in his mind. He could see it in Peterâs eyesâthe way they shifted away from him, unable to meet his gaze. And the way he apologized, despite not wanting to admit anything, despite the layers of denial. There was something there. Something Mark wasnât sure if he wanted to understand, but he had to. It ate at him.
He slowly turned his head, his jaw clenching as he held Peterâs gaze, searching for the truth beneath his words.
âI donât need you to lead me on, Peter,â Hoffman said, his voice softer, almost gentle in a way that didnât quite fit the angry edge he usually carried. âIâm not asking for that. But you canât just pretend like I donât see whatâs going on. You donât get to throw this all away just because itâs easier for you.â
The words came out before he could stop them, and though they werenât meant to sound desperate, something in his voice cracked. Something in him trembled under the weight of what he was saying.
âIâm not gonna lie to you, Peter.â He paused, trying to catch his breath, his chest tight. âI... I donât know what the hellâs going on either. But I know Iâm not just some... work colleague to you. Not anymore.â His voice dropped lower. âI see it in the way you act around me. I feel it. Hell, Iâve felt it for a while now.â
He hesitated, staring out the windshield, before glancing back at Peter. His eyes were darker now, a fire simmering beneath them. He couldnât stop himself. He was burning up inside.
âIâm not perfect either, Peter,â he continued, the vulnerability creeping in. âBut donât sit there and pretend like thereâs nothing between us. Youâre not as cold as you think you are.â
It was out before he could stop it, his voice barely above a whisper, but there was a finality to it that lingered in the air.
The silence hung between them again, but this time, it was different. It wasnât just an empty, suffocating thing. It was charged. And as much as Mark hated to admit it, the way Peter wouldnât meet his eyesâthe way he avoided him nowâtold him everything he needed to know.
Peter stared down at his lap, picking at his cuticles to try and distract himself. That was working until Mark said the words. The words that killed everything inside of him. The words that stabbed him in the stomach. The words that made his blood boil.
' You donât get to throw this all away just because itâs easier for you. '
These words pained him. But not in a way that upset him, but in a way that angered him. He wasn't throwing anything away. He tried being nice, but clearly that didn't work. He wasn't gay.
"Listen, Hoffman. I've already told you, I'm not gay. I've never been gay, I've never though I was gay, I'm not gay. I'm not going to let yourself continue to believe that I am. It's not only hurting me, but also hurting you. At this point, it feels like you're leading yourself on."
The words came out in a harsh tone, his words aggressive and mean. He barked back like a dog. In this situation, he was like an angry, lost dog. A dog who needed comfort deep down.
He didn't want to make the situation worse, but it was hard with everything Mark said. the words ' But donât sit there and pretend like thereâs nothing between us. Youâre not as cold as you think you are. ' echoed throughout his head, causing his blood to just boil more.
Soon, he got to a point in anger where he wasn't even angry at Mark as much anymore, it was mostly anger towards himself.
He looked up to look out the windshield, sighing before opening his mouth to speak. His words came out in a low whisper as if he was checking in with himself.
"I'm not gay..."
Mark's eyes locked onto Peter's face, searching for somethingâanythingâto tell him that this wasnât over. But it was clear Peter wasnât giving him anything, just sitting there, picking at his cuticles, trying to hold it all together. The tension in the air was suffocating, and Mark could feel every inch of it tightening around him, his chest growing heavier with each passing second.
When Peter spoke, his voice was sharp, the words like a slap to the face. âIâm not gay. Iâve never been gay, Iâve never thought I was gay, Iâm not gay.â The rapid fire of it made Mark flinch, even though heâd expected it. But it still hurt, hearing Peter say it like that. Like it was something to be ashamed of.
Hoffmanâs jaw clenched, and he leaned forward slightly, his voice low but cutting. âIâm not asking you to be anything youâre not, Peter. But you canât sit there and act like thereâs nothing between us when you know damn well there is.â
Peterâs wordsâthe harshness in his tone, the way he barked back, like a wounded animalâhit a nerve that Mark didnât know existed. But then something else shifted in Peterâs voice, something softer, quieter, that Mark almost didnât catch. Peter looked out the windshield, and Mark could see the way his shoulders slumped slightly, like the anger was draining out of him, replaced with something else. Something less certain.
Mark leaned back in his seat, eyes narrowing, not willing to let Peter get away with this. "Youâre not fooling me, Strahm. Youâre not as cold as you act. You can say all you want that youâre not interested in meâIâm not stupid, I get it. But donât act like I donât see whatâs going on when you look at me like that." His voice cracked with frustration, but he didnât stop. He couldnât. "Youâre running from something. And I donât know what it is, but I see it in the way you pull away, in the way you shut down every time we get close." His eyes flickered toward Peter. "Youâre lying to yourself, Peter. And itâs not just about me. Itâs about you."
The silence that followed was heavier than anything before it, thick with unspoken words and tangled emotions. Mark's heart was hammering in his chest, but he didnât know what to do with it. He wanted to reach over, shake Peter, make him see the truth, but he couldnât. He wasnât sure if Peter was even listening anymore, if the words were getting through to him.
When Peter finally spoke again, his voice was a whisper, almost as if he was saying it more to himself than Mark. "Iâm not gay..."
Markâs eyes softened at the quiet admission. There was a crack in Peterâs façade, a fracture that Mark hadnât expected to see. Heâd seen the anger, the cold detachment, the resistance. But thisâthis was different. This was something raw. Something that made Markâs heart stutter, even if he didnât want it to.
âYou donât have to keep telling me that,â Mark said quietly, his voice surprisingly gentle, as though trying to reach something inside Peter. He leaned forward again, just a little. âI know. I know youâre not âgay,â Peter. But thatâs not what Iâm asking for.â His voice caught on the last word. âIâm asking you to stop running. From me. From whatever the hell it is thatâs scaring you.â
There was a long pause as Mark let the words settle in the air between them. He didnât know what would happen next, or if Peter would even listen. But there was no going back now. He had to say it. He had to give Peter the chance to decide. Whether they could move past all of this or if it would just tear them apart.
Peter still wouldnât meet his eyes, his gaze fixed on the windshield, but Mark didnât look away. He couldnât. Not when there was still a chance. Not when the weight of everything between them was still there, waiting for a spark to set it off.
Strahm felt himself breaking, but hid it. He hid it to the best of his abilities. But if you looked closely, very closely, you'd see a wounded man with glossy eyes. Eyes that weren't helping hide the fact he was upset. Eyes that held so much more emotion than his own words. Eyes you would see on an animal being hunted. Eyes that held fear.
"I'm not-" His voice cracked, but he quickly covered it with a cough. "I'm not running. I'm not scared of anything." No matter how much he tried to hide how he was really feeling, you could still slightly see it. His hands were now shaking and his leg began to bounce up and down quickly, making a faint but noticeable tapping sound.
"I'm not hiding from you." He said, but something in his mind told him he was hiding from Hoffman. Something told him he was hiding from everything. It had gotten to a point that he couldn't hide his feelings anymore. His whole body was tensed up as if protecting himself from words, his eyes fixated on the cars ahead of them more than anything, his leg continued to bounce but at a faster pace, and finally, his lip. He hadn't even noticed, but his lip began to drip blood again. This time though, he didn't wipe it away. He didn't want any hands near his face, even his own.
"And I shut down when we're close because I don't like you, Hoffman. You do nothing but-" He stopped himself, realizing what he said. It was too late. He can't just go back in time and stop himself. These words were stuck in the car.
All of their words were stuck in the car, along with his heart.
Mark could feel it, the tension in the air thick and almost suffocating. Every breath Peter took seemed heavy, labored, and every movement of his hands, his leg bouncing, told Mark something was wrong. The words caught in the air, stuck between them like a wall, and Mark was starting to feel like he was trapped on the other side of it.
Peterâs voice cracked, and Markâs heart skipped. He saw it. The way Peterâs hands shook, the way his leg tapped frantically, the slight gloss in his eyes that Peter tried so hard to hide. Peter was on the edge of breaking down, but he was doing everything in his power to keep it together, to keep his walls up. Mark knew that feeling. He recognized it. It was the same one he wore every damn day.
When Peter spoke, his words were harsh, almost defensive, but Mark could hear the cracks underneath. "I'm not running. I'm not scared of anything." But Mark saw it. That wasnât the truth. The shaking, the trembling lip, the way Peterâs eyes kept avoiding him. The truth was slipping through the cracks in his defenses.
Peter said he wasnât scared, but Mark could hear it in his voice, see it in the way his body tensed up. He could almost smell itâfear. Fear of something bigger than either of them could handle.
âIâm not hiding from you,â Peter said, and the words didnât even make it out like they were supposed to. Mark could hear the hesitation. The vulnerability. Peter was lying to himself. But Mark wasnât about to call him out on itânot yet, anyway. Heâd been there before, too. He understood what it was like to keep those walls up, to lock everything inside until it made you want to suffocate.
But then Peter spoke again. His words cut through the thick air like a knife, too sharp to ignore. "And I shut down when we're close because I don't like you, Hoffman. You do nothing but-"
Peter stopped himself, and Mark felt the weight of the words that hadn't been finished. The ones that lingered like a shadow, threatening to reveal something deeper than just anger or confusion. Something that could change everything.
Markâs pulse raced. He wanted to push him further, demand to know what Peter had really meant, but he knew better than to rush it. It wasnât the time for that. Still, the words hung in the air, heavy, suffocating. You do nothing but... what?
Markâs eyes softened just slightly as he watched Peter's lip, the blood starting to drip again. Peter didnât wipe it away, didnât even move his hand. It was like he wanted to bleed, wanted to feel it. Wanted to show Mark that he wasnât as cold as he kept pretending to be.
Mark knew the feeling too well. It was a strange sort of comfort to know that Peter was hurting, too. As fucked up as it sounded, it was a relief to know Peter wasnât the stone wall he tried so hard to be. And maybe, just maybe, Mark could find a way in. Even if it scared the hell out of him.
âPeterâŠâ Markâs voice was softer now, almost hesitant, as if he was treading carefully through the words. He didnât want to break Peter any more than he already was, but he couldnât stand watching him fight this on his own.
Mark reached out by putting his arm on the centre console, just slightly, his fingers brushing the air near Peterâs hand, though he didnât touch him. He wasnât sure if Peter would pull away or not. He wasnât sure if Peter even wanted him near.
But the words that followed from Peter hit Mark like a punch to the gut. âI donât like you.â And it stung more than anything Mark could have expected. He knew Peter wasnât ready for anything else, but that hurt. Hurt more than he wanted to admit.
Mark leaned back in his seat, his heart pounding in his chest. He couldnât let Peter see the effect those words had on him, but it felt like a thousand knives had pierced through his chest all at once.
âRight.â Markâs voice was tight, holding back something deep inside. No, Peter. You donât just shut down and say you donât like me and expect me to walk away.
But Mark didnât say that. He didnât push. He couldnât. Not yet. The words Peter had left unfinished were eating away at him, though. The silence was deafening.
And in that silence, Mark could feel itâthe shift, the crack in Peterâs armor. Peter might not have been ready to admit anything, but Mark could see it now. He could see the truth bleeding through, and he wasnât going anywhere.
Not yet.
They drove in silence for a few more moments, the tension between them almost unbearable. Then, finally, they pulled into the parking lot of the station. The headlights cut through the night, casting long shadows across the concrete. The sound of the engine slowing to a stop filled the car, but neither of them made a move to get out immediately.
Mark just sat there for a second, his eyes still on Peter. He could feel the weight of the moment hanging between them, almost like it was going to shatter if either of them spoke again.
After what felt like an eternity, Mark exhaled quietly and opened the door. "Weâre here," he said, his voice barely above a whisper. He didnât know what else to say. He didnât know how to fix what had been broken, or if it could even be fixed at all. All he knew was that he wasnât leaving yet.
Peter noticed his arm on the center console, moving his arm away quickly. Quicker than he'd ever moved away from Mark. His movements were like a scared injured animal. Quick to escape the touch that could save him. The touch that could fix him.
Strahm completely dissociated, staring out to the cars. The blood continued down his chin, reaching the bottom before he finally wiped it off with a quick movement of his arm. The arm farthest from Mark. Seeming like he was trying to hide he could move at all.
He stayed in his thoughts, trying his best to breathe through his walls finally breaking. They couldn't break. He couldn't let a new person into his mind, anything could happen.
His brain flooded with thoughts. They were all about Hoffman. What if he was starting to hate him? What if he was right? He's only trying to help. For once, he's being a good person and I just can't soak it in. Maybe I'm just a horrible person. He's probably beginning to hate me now. He probably-
Suddenly, Mark's voice pulled him out of the thoughts.
He looked at Hoffman and quickly nodded, leaving his car and locking it before speed walking to the office. As soon as he made it inside, he packed up everything at his desk he brought in. He had to leave, and he had to leave now.
Hoffman sat there for a second, watching Strahmâs back as he disappeared inside. He could still see the tension in his posture, the way his shoulders curled in like he was trying to shrink himself down, trying to vanish into the walls.
Mark exhaled, shaking his head as he rubbed his hand over his mouth.
This was spiraling. Fast.
He should just let him go. Let Strahm run himself ragged, let him pack up, let him storm out of the office and pretend none of this ever happened. Itâd be the easy thing to do. Itâd be the smart thing to do.
But Mark was shit at doing the smart thing when it came to Peter.
With a grunt, he pushed open the car door and got out, walking toward the building. His steps were heavy, purposeful, his jaw set as he shoved through the front doors.
Strahm was already at his desk, movements frantic, throwing his stuff into his bag like he was trying to outrun something. Maybe himself.
Mark lingered in the doorway for a moment before finally stepping forward.
âYou leaving or running?â His voice was level, but there was an edge beneath it.
Mark scoffed, stepping closer. âYou text me, drag me over here, and now youâre bolting? What the hell was this, Peter?â
He wasnât even sure what he wanted Strahm to say. He just wanted him to say something. Anything.
Mark clenched his jaw. Fine. If Strahm wanted to run, let him. But Mark wasnât going to stand there like an idiot, waiting for an answer that would never come.
âForget it,â he muttered, turning on his heel to leave.
Strahm put his bag over his shoulder, rushing to stand next to Hoffman. "Listen... I want to talk to you about.." He thought about how to word what they had going. "This. About me running. Just follow me so we can get it over with."
Peter said as he pulled a cigarette out of his pocket, placing it in my mouth as he searched for a lighter while he walked. He never smoked. He hadn't smoked in awhile, actually. He always just... carried one around. It was a habit from years ago he never let go.
As soon as he stepped out, he lit the cigarette.
What was he going to say? Sorry for being confused? Sorry for letting his anger get the best of him? Sorry for being the man Hoffman fell in love with? He couldn't wrap his head around an idea.
He stood with his jaw clenched in the cold as he waited for Mark who soon followed behind him. It was time to confront his emotions for once in his life.
For once, he almost felt in control of his emotions.
Hoffman watched Strahm fumbling for a lighter, his movements sharp, tense. He never smokedâMark knew that. At least, not anymore. So why now?
With a sigh, Mark reached into his jacket pocket, pulling out his own cigarette and lighter. He flicked it open, the flame casting a small, flickering glow between them. Instead of lighting his own first, he held it out toward Strahm, his gaze steady.
âHere.â.
The small gesture felt heavier than it should have, almost like a truce.
Mark lit his own cigarette next, inhaling deeply before exhaling a slow stream of smoke into the cold night air. He leaned against the hood of a nearby car, watching Peter through the haze.
âSo,â he exhaled. âTalk.â
His voice was even, but there was something else beneath itâsomething unreadable.
Mark shuffled in place, taking a long drag like the nicotine would give him the words he couldnât find. His fingers twitched slightly as he held the cigarette, the cold air making the smoke curl around them like a ghost of something unspoken.
He wasnât going to let Peter run from thisânot this time.
Peter took a long drag of the cigarette that was just handed to him, longer than he should have. He began to cough, smoke coming out of his mouth as smoothly as he prayed his words would.
Once he calmed down he sighed, staring down at his lit cigarette like it was the most interesting thing in the world at the moment.
"Mark, I..." He felt his face get hot despite the freezing weather they were standing in. "I don't know why I'm running from this. From you. I spent years after college building the person I am today that it hurts to break my walls. I've been trying so hard to change from how I was so many years ago that I can't even try to go back." He took a moment, taking another long drag from his cigarette.
"The person I was years ago wasn't... accepted." He said, hoping Hoffman would somehow catch onto what he was saying. "I don't want to run from you, but it feels like I need to." Peter's voice began to crack, which he tried to cover with a cough.
"I don't... hate you. I don't know how I feel about you. I know that it isn't hatred, though. I know it's something far different from that."
He took a moment before speaking again, hoping the silence would speak the words he couldn't.
"I haven't hated you in years..."
Mark watched him, really watched him. The way his fingers trembled slightly around the cigarette, the way his shoulders curled inward like he was trying to make himself smaller, like he didnât want to be seen. It was a look Mark recognized. A feeling he understood.
He exhaled slowly, letting the cold night air carry the smoke away before he spoke.
"You donât have to explain yourself to me, you know." His voice was softer than usual, lacking its usual sharpness. "Not if youâre not ready."
Mark hesitated for a moment, then stepped closerânot enough to crowd him, just enough that the space between them wasnât so cold.
âI get it,â he continued, voice steady but gentle. "Trying to outrun the past... trying to be something different. Something people expect you to be. Itâs easier than letting yourself go back to something that hurt.â
âIâm not gonna push you," Mark said. "You donât owe me some big confession. But I want you to knowâwhatever this is, whatever youâre trying to figure outâyou donât have to do it alone."
Mark took another slow drag, watching the way the streetlights cast shadows over Peterâs face. He wanted to reach out, wanted to do something, but he didnât. Not yet.
Instead, he just said, "I havenât hated you in years either."
And he let the words settle, giving Peter the space to decide what he wanted to do with them.
Peter walked into the station holding a laptop bag and a big silver cup of coffee. It was very obvious he didn't get much sleep, like usual.
[ - @detstrahm ]
[ ooc text : i've never done an rp on tumblr so sorry if this starter sucks !!! ]
Mark Hoffman stands near his desk, eyes narrowing as Strahm enters the room. He takes in the sight of the tired detective, the coffee in his hand, and the laptop bag slung over his shoulder. Hoffman straightens slightly, his face betraying no emotion as he watches Strahm move to his desk.
"You look like you haven't slept in days, Strahm. Tiredness isn't a badge of honor. Itâs a weakness."
He leans back in his chair, his arms folding across his chest, his gaze unwavering as he watches Strahmâs every move.
"If youâre planning to continue running on fumes, itâs only a matter of time before it catches up to you. You should know better than anyone what happens when you lose focus."
His tone is harsh, but there's an edge to it, as if he's quietly daring Strahm to respond, or perhaps waiting for a crack in the other man's usually composed demeanor.
[NO I LOVE IT!! LMK IF THIS IS TOO MUCH HEJEEJEJEJ]
"Not that it's any of your concern, but I'm fine."
Strahm stopped walking as he spoke, looking back to Hoffman over his shoulder with a cold gaze that could definitely kill him if looks really could kill.
"Your snarky comments aren't going to affect me, I'm not a child."
His voice was firm yet calm, making it obvious that he wasn't trying to cause a scene this early into his shift. It was so hard to do anything with Hoffman just a couple steps away from him.
Hoffman smirked to himself, tapping his pen idly against a stack of paperwork before finally dragging his gaze up to meet Strahmâs glare.
"You sure about that?" His voice was slow, almost amused. "Because Iâve seen you get flustered over a lot less."
He leaned back in his chair, letting the words settle, watching for the inevitable reaction. Hoffman raised a brow, the corner of his mouth twitching like he was resisting the urge to really twist the knife. "Not that itâs any of my concern, of course."
And just like that, he went back to his paperwork, acting like the conversation was already over, though he was more than ready for whatever Strahm had to say next-- almost if in anticipation.
Peter took a deep breath as he walked over to Hoffman's desk, leaning over to whisper in his ear instead of yelling. It seemed like the most mature choice.
"Listen here, asshole. I am in no mood to deal with your shit today."
His tone was sharp as if he was an angry dog barking back at Mark. No matter how hard he tried to ignore Hoffman, he always came up with something to say that just pushed his limits.
He tugged on the collar of the other male's shirt, pulling him closer so his mouth was almost touching his ear.
"Leave me the fuck alone, Hoffman."
He growled in Mark's ear, pushing himself away from him with a stern look on his face.
Hoffman barely reacted as Strahm yanked him closer, his breath hot against his ear, voice laced with frustration. The smirk that tugged at the corner of his mouth was slow, deliberateâbecause this was interesting.
For a moment, he didnât say anything, just let the tension settle between them. Then, in a voice just low enough for only Peter to hear, he finally spoke.
"Careful, Strahm." Smooth, almost teasing. "You keep getting this close, people might start talking."
His gaze flickered downâjust brieflyâto where Strahmâs fingers had gripped his collar. Then, just as lazily, he reached for the cup sitting next to him. It wasnât the usual station sludge, but something sweeter, something indulgent, the faint scent of caramel mixing with the deeper, familiar notes of his cologneâcedarwood, leather, something subtly sharp beneath it all.
He took a slow sip, his smirk deepening just slightly as he finally met Strahmâs glare again.
"But heyâmessage received." His tone was light, almost amused. But there was something else beneath it, something unreadable.
[not me sprinkling in some hoffman hcs lol.]
The more Mark spoke, the more it seemed to anger Strahm. He hated how easy it was for Mark to anger him with just a tone of voice or a simple sentence.
"God, fuck off." Peter basically stormed off to his desk, throwing himself into the chair. As he logged into his computer to actually start working, he couldn't stop thinking about Hoffman.
Usually, that would be normal. Today it was different though. Instead of thinking about how much he hated him, he started thinking about these small details about him. Like how his hair looked more brushed through then normally, or how the scent stuck on his body was weirdly calming.
It was weird, but he couldn't stop thinking about it.
It's like Hoffman put a spell on him.
Hoffman watched Strahm go, lifting his cup to his lips again, taking an unhurried sip. The taste of caramel lingered, mixing with the sharper bitterness beneath it.
That was too easy.
Strahm could throw himself into his chair all he wanted, could scowl at his screen and pretend to focus, but Hoffman knew. He knew. Because that reaction? That wasnât just anger. That was something else, something tangled up in frustration and confusion and whatever the hell was flickering behind those glares.
He swirled the drink absently in his cup, gaze flicking toward Strahmâs desk. Then, without looking directly at him, he spokeâjust loud enough to carry across the room.
"You sure you want me to fuck off, or do you just like telling me what to do?"
Hoffman smirked against the rim of his cup, taking another slow sip, letting his pursed lips linger on the rim. Letting the words settle.
Peter's hands froze and his computer as he took a moment to let himself process what Mark just said. Instead of freaking out, or yelling, or even getting out of his seat, he responded calmly. He hated to egg Hoffman on with his emotions.
"Do your damn work, Hoffman. Might do you some good."
Strahm placed his head in his hands for a moment to recollect himself before continuing to work in silence, using his screen to hide from looking at anyone even near him.
He didn't understand this feeling. It was a strange mixture of so many things and emotions he hasn't felt since early college. Whatever it was, Hoffman was enjoying using it against him.
The teasing worked, but god he wish it didn't.
Hoffman finally, finally turned his attention to the files on his desk, though his focus was shot to hell. His eyes moved over the words, but they barely registered. The conversationâthat look Strahm had given him before burying himself in his screenâwas still fresh, playing in his mind like a puzzle he hadnât quite solved yet.
He tapped his fingers against the desk, considering. There was something satisfying about watching Strahm try so hard to keep himself in check, to act like none of this was getting to him. Hoffman knew better.
The corner of his mouth twitched as he flipped a page, not bothering to hide the smirk creeping in. He took another sip of his drink, the sweetness coating his tongue, lingering.
Maybe he should get back to work.
Or maybe he should push just a little moreâjust to see how long Strahm could keep pretending.
Strahm tapped his pen on his desk to a rhythm he had just made up in his mind since that seemed to be the only thing that could replace his thoughts about Hoffman.
Everything reminded him of Mark, it's like he couldn't escape him. He couldn't even focus on his work, which really bothered him. Usually, his work was the one distraction that always worked, but clearly not today.
Peter sighed before standing up and dropping his pen down onto his desk. He ran his hands down his outfit before walking away to the bathroom with his head down the whole time.
He needed an escape. He needed a way to get away from Mark, even just for a couple minutes.
He opened the door to the bathroom, making sure nobody was in there before walking to the sink and turning on cold water. Strahm collected a small amount of water on his hands and splashed it on his face, staring at himself in the mirror. Why was this happening now?
Hoffman didnât look up right away, but he felt the shift. The absence. The way the air around him suddenly felt⊠quieter.
Strahm was gone.
No presence lingering just a few feet away, no rhythmic tapping of a pen, no barely restrained exhale of frustration. The space he left behind felt noticeable in a way Hoffman didnât care to dwell on.
His fingers drummed idly against the desk as he stared at the open file in front of him. He wasnât reading it. His focus was elsewhere, stuck on somethingâor someoneâthat wasnât even in the damn room anymore.
Hoffman sighed, rolling his shoulders before forcing himself back to his work. Strahm would be back.
And when he was, Hoffman wasnât sure if heâd say anything at allâjust that heâd be aware, too aware, of the moment Strahm walked back through that door.
Strahm continued to stare at himself, a look of confusion forming on his face as he stared.
Who was he right now?
He could normally focus on his work with no struggle, but today was just so different. The tension that formed drove him mad. It didn't make any sense, he didn't feel these things last week, so what's so different now?
Peter began to get angry at everything, especially his thoughts. The water still running, the footsteps outside, the talking of his coworkers, the door to the females restroom opening and closing, everything.
He couldn't take it. Strahm punched the bathroom counter, turning the sink off before storming out of the bathroom and back to his seat.
He tried so hard to get on task but with Hoffman around, it would be hard.
The sound of Strahmâs chair scraping against the floor pulled Hoffmanâs attention before he even meant to look at the other man.
Back already.
He didnât watch himânot openly, at least. Whatever that little break had been, it clearly hadnât helped.
Hoffman finally, finally turned his attention to the files in front of him, though his focus was still half elsewhere. He flipped a page, then spoke, his tone casual.
âYou see the new evidence on the Jigsaw case yet?â A beat. Then, with a glint of playfulness in his eyes, he added, âLooks like our guyâs getting smarter.â
Strahm coughed, opening one of the many files on his desk and writing something quick down in pen. "I heard they found a small strand of hair at a scene. They sent it in to get it tested and a DNA read." He sighed. "Seems useless though. It's a strand of hair that was next to a victim, it was probably theirs."
He wasn't doing very well at trying to seem like he calmed down. Peter never denied small things like this unless he was just talking to talk.
He didn't understand how Hoffman was so casual right now. Does he not feel the tension right now? is he really that dumb?
Hoffman didnât look up right away. He turned a page in his file, scanning the words like they mattered more than Strahmâs obvious frustration. âCould be useless,â he said, almost offhandedly. âOr it could be exactly what we need.â
There was no real argument in his toneâjust something thoughtful, maybe even knowing, like he wasnât as dismissive of the lead as Strahm was.
He finally shifted, glancing at Strahm as if noticing him for the first time since he sat back down. His gaze flicked over him brieflyâtaking in the tension still lingering in his shoulders, the way his grip on his pen was just a little too tight.
And then, something caught his attention. The way the dim overhead light hit just right, outlining the sharp line of Strahmâs jaw, the faintest crease between his brows. Had he always clenched his jaw like that when he was thinking? It wasnât just irritationâit was focus, frustration, something deeper that Hoffman couldnât quite pin down.
For a second, he nearly forgot what he was about to say. He forced himself to look back down at his file, masking the moment with an easy shrug.
âLong morning?â His voice was low, almost conversational. But there was something in the way he said itâsomething that made it impossible to tell if he was just making small talk or if he already knew the answer.
Strahm aggressively wrote stuff down in the files, taking small breaks to collect his thought before continuing to write.
"Bad traffic. Bad night." His tone was firm and aggressive, but not on purpose. He spoke quickly which made it obvious it was a lie to get off the topic of anything but work.
He glanced up at Hoffman and froze, using this moment to soak in everything about him. The way he looked so calm while focused on his work, the way his hand gently pushed the pen down on the paper, the way his lips looked when he was focused...
Peter bit down onto his bottom lip roughly, definitely leaving small teeth marks on his lip. Simply looking at Mark made him anxious.
Hoffman didnât react right away. He let Strahmâs words sit between them, as if deciding whether or not to be snide.
He kept his focus on the file in front of him, but his mind was elsewhereâstuck on something he couldnât quite shake. The way Strahmâs voice had that edge to it. The way his pen practically carved into the paper, like he needed the distraction.
Then, in his periphery, he caught itâStrahm biting his lip, hard.
Hoffmanâs grip on his pen tightened for a fraction of a second before he forced himself to relax, dragging his eyes back to his work.
He exhaled through his nose, pretending to stay focused on his paperwork, but his mind was already elsewhere. The way Strahm bit his lipâthat sharp press of teeth against skinâwasnât something he shouldâve noticed.
Wasnât something he shouldâve cared about.
But he did.
His jaw tensed as he forced his attention back to the file in front of him, masking any sign of distraction. After a beat of silence, he finally spoke, his voice lower than before.
"Yeah⊠not like sleep does much good anyway."
"I stayed up practically all night trying to put together why they would test that fucking-" He took a deep breath, looking down at his papers. "that damn strand of hair. It just doesn't make much sense."
As much as he tried to focus on his papers, he couldn't. The way his jaw tensed just drew in his attention even more as if it was magic.
Peter continued to bite at his lip, feeling an impending doom for what Hoffman would say next. His voice was just so smooth, it felt like torture in the best way possible.
He tried to pretend to do his work, but it was hard when his eyes couldn't get off of Mark. He felt helpless in this moment and he hated it.
He was supposed to have all the power.
Hoffman didnât need to look up to know Strahm was still watching him. He could feel itâthose damn eyes, like heat searing into the side of his face, making it almost impossible to focus on anything else.
"Yeah," Hoffman murmured, his voice gravelly but calm, "doesnât add up, does it?"
He wasnât just talking about the case. The frustration in Strahmâs toneâit hit something deeper, something Hoffman didnât feel like addressing, not right now.
He finally looked up, his gaze meeting Strahm's, but only for a brief moment. "But thatâs the thing with this case, Strahm. Sometimes itâs not about making sense." His words carried an almost unsettling weight, though he wasnât sure if Strahm would catch on.
His hand paused mid-motion as he noticed Strahmâs biting, that subtle, almost unconscious action. Hoffmanâs brow furrowed slightly, but he quickly dismissed the thought, shaking it off. He had work to do.
"Try to stay focused," he added, his tone unexpectedly softer, though he meant it more to himself than Strahm.
Strahm let out a deep sigh, closing his eyes and swinging his head back for a moment. This was his best attempt at clearing his mind.
"I just hate when they do things without running it past me or Perez first." He whispered, picking his pen back up and beginning to actually work on the case.
He felt like a idiot. For once, he didn't want to be at work. He regretted coming in today, especially because Lindsey wouldn't be here because her family was in town and wanted one day with them.
Peter picked back up the rhythm from earlier with his pen, tapping it more aggressively than before without realizing. At this point, he was just trying to drown out any of his thoughts, even about work.
Hoffman let the comment hang in the air, though something shifted in his posture at the mention of Lindsey. He didnât outwardly show it, but the thought gnawed at him for a split second.
He leaned back in his chair, the sound of Strahmâs aggressive pen tapping filling the otherwise quiet space. The irritation in Strahmâs actions wasn't lost on Hoffman, but the mention of Lindsey caught him off guard. It wasnât like him to care, not like this.
"Youâre right," Hoffman said, his voice controlled, though there was a slight edge to it, "Youâd think they'd at least consult you. But," he paused, the faintest of smirks pulling at the corners of his lips, "youâre better off without distractions anyway."
He didnât know if Strahm would pick up on the shift in his tone, but Hoffman had a feeling his partner wouldn't miss the faint jealousy that had crept in. He wasnât sure why it bothered him, but it did.
His eyes flicked to Strahm for a brief moment, then back to the file in front of him, trying to focus.
"Guess youâre stuck here with me," he added, his tone slipping just enough to hint at something more personal beneath the professional surface.
Peter suddenly stopped tapping his pen at the last comment Mark added, pausing everything he was doing. Something with the tone he used made him feel something different. Something he hasn't felt yet today.
He couldn't sit here with Hoffman with those words just replaying in his head, he had to escape somewhere.
"I'll be back." Strahm said, his words slightly slurring together. He shot up from his seat, speed walking back to the bathroom. There was one other person in there, but he could care less at the moment.
Peter paced back and forth in the bathroom while waiting for the other man to leave the restroom. Luckily, the pacing must've rushed him out. He continued to pace around, pinching at the bridge of the nose.
There's no way Mark hasn't noticed his weird behavior, there's just no way. He didn't understand why he couldn't just suppress his emotions like he normally did. He has been hiding his emotions with ease for years, so what was so different today?
Hoffman stood up by the windowsill, his back leaning against the cool glass, eyes staring at the outside but not really seeing it. His mind kept drifting back to Strahm, and the way heâd snapped, his frustration practically hanging in the air. There was something about it, something that felt... off. He couldnât quite put his finger on it, but it bothered him.
He rubbed a hand over his face, sighing, trying to clear the thoughts clouding his head. His gaze flicked back to Strahmâs empty deskâ God, why was it so unsettling?
Mark didnât let distractions get to him. He wasnât someone who let emotions or anything else interfere with the job. But thisâwhatever this wasâ was messing with his usual routine.
The door creaked slightly, and his eyes darted toward it, but no one was there. Mark was surprised by how much heâd noticed Peterâs absence. He shifted uncomfortably, his fingers curling into a fist around the edge of the windowsill. What the hell was wrong with him? It wasnât like Strahm to just leave like that, and it wasnât like him either to feel... unsettled by it.
âJust focus,â Mark muttered to himself, but his gaze lingered on the door a second longer than necessary. He hadnât realized how much he had started to notice the little things about Strahmâhis sharp movements, his short temper, the way his jaw tensed when he was angry. And then the way heâd left, so abruptly, like he couldnât even get out of the room fast enough.
Mark rubbed the back of his neck and shook his head, pursing his lips in thought.
He wasnât someone who gave a damn about these things. But today felt... different
And that made him uneasy.
Peter leaned up against the bathroom wall, placing his face in his hands. He wanted to stay in the bathroom until he died but sadly, he knew he couldn't. Strahm continued to bite down on his lip until he tasted blood.
"Fucking hell..." He whispered, taking his hands off his face to wipe his lip. He stared down at his hand, looking at the blood that covered a small part of the side of his hand.
Strahm walked over to the sink and rinsed his hand off, watching the water turn a slight red before slipping down the drain. It was a weirdly calming sight.
He soon left the bathroom, avoiding looking at Hoffman the best he could. "I'm going to refill my coffee." Strahm said firmly as he reached for his cup, rushing away from his desk before he could even hear a response.
If he was being completely honest, he was embarrassed. He was embarrassed that he couldn't hide his feelings this time. It was such a weird thing to feel something other than anger or calmness.
Peter grabbed the old coffee pot from the staff room, filling his large silver cup up with the lukewarm coffee. He hated how he couldn't confront Mark about these feelings.
Hoffman noticed it immediatelyâhow Strahm wouldnât look at him, how his movements were just a little too quick, like he couldnât get away fast enough.
He grabbed his cup and rushed off before Hoffman could so much as blink.
He didnât know what heâd expected, but it wasnât⊠that.
For the first time, something about Strahmâs reaction made him hesitate. He knew how to read peopleâhe had toâbut this wasnât the usual sharp-edged frustration he was used to prying out of Strahm. This wasnât Strahm picking a fight or snapping back. It was avoidance.
And for some reason, Hoffman didnât like that.
His fingers drummed against the desk, watching the spot Strahm had just vacated. Part of himâsome small, stupid partâwondered if heâd actually hurt him. The thought unsettled him more than it should have.
He let out a quiet exhale, dragging his focus back to his paperwork. It was nothing. It had to be nothing.
So why did it sit so strangely in his chest?
Peter took a deep breath in the small but strangely calming staff room. Why couldn't he just man up and go do his work? Why was Hoffman such a distraction? There were all these whys in his head with no answer.
He took a swig of the lukewarm coffee, swishing it around his mouth as he let his mind wander some more. He felt so stupid for avoiding Mark. For some strange reason, he felt bad for avoiding Hoffman.
Strahm looked at the shut door and debated ever leaving this room, but sadly he knew he had to. He had to face his problems.
Peter left the staff room with his head up this time, trying his best to look put together and confident. As he walked to his desk he wondered if everyone else in the building could tell he was breaking on the inside.
Hoffman didnât acknowledge Strahmâs return, keeping his eyes trained on the file in front of him. He wasnât really reading itâhis focus was shot to hell.
He was letting his body speak for him in ways he couldnât control. His leg bounced beneath the desk, a steady, impatient rhythm. His fingers tapped soundlessly against the edge of his paper, the only betrayal of his restlessness.
He wanted to look at Strahm. Watch for any flicker of emotion. See if there was still tension in his jaw, if his lip was still raw from biting down too hard. But he didnât. Not yet.
He just waited. If Strahm wanted to pretend nothing happened, fine. But if there was a crackâany sign of itâHoffman would be there, ready to catch it.
Strahm coughed as if trying to warn Hoffman he was back in his seat, pulling open a completely new file to maybe try and focus on something new.
He read every word on the paper, but nothing made sense in his head at the moment. It was weird, but it felt strange without Hoffman's eyes on him. If he was being honest, he missed being looked at from a distance.
"So, have you heard anything about the Jigsaw case?" Peter asked with his face still buried in the case files on his desk. The silence became too much for him to handle and he needed to break it.
He eagerly waited for a response as if his life depended on it, nervously biting his lip once again and continuing to tap his pen to a different rhythm from before.
Hoffman exhaled slowly, dragging his eyes from his paperwork like he was indulging Strahm by giving him attention.
"Nothing new," he said, his voice even. "Just the same dead ends."
He finally glanced at Strahm, taking in the way his lip was caught between his teeth again, the quick, restless tapping of his pen.
He leaned back slightly, studying Strahm a little longer than necessary before forcing himself to look away. As Hoffman finally looked at him, his gaze snagged on something small but noticeableâthe faint trace of dried blood at the corner of Strahmâs lip. It was barely there, but it was enough.
Hoffmanâs fingers twitched slightly, his grip on his pen tightening before he forced himself to loosen it. He shouldnât care. Shouldnât even be looking. But the sight of it made something uneasy settle in his chest. Had Strahm bitten down that hard?
His jaw tensed as he dragged his eyes away. His breath hitched before he could stop it.
The sight of itâsubtle, unintentional, self-inflictedâsent something sharp and hot running through his veins. His fingers curled around his pen, gripping it just a little too tight. He shouldnât be reacting to this. Shouldnât feel the way his pulse quickened, the way his body betrayed him with that sudden, insidious heat curling in his gut.
His composure threatened to slip.
Hoffman exhaled through his nose, his jaw clenching as he forced his expression to stay neutral. His gaze flicked away, back to his paperwork, even though the words on the page were meaningless now.
âWhy?â His voice came out steadyâthankfullyâbut just a fraction lower than before. âYou onto something?â
He kept his head down, pen skimming over the paper in a weak attempt at normalcy, but the damage was already done. He felt it. And worseâhe liked it.
"Not yet. It's getting annoying how we can't get any new leads..." Strahm put his pen down onto his desk, leaning his head back as he let out a long sigh of exhaustion.
Suddenly, he had gotten an idea. Something that would probably calm down the thoughts about Hoffman in his head, but would probably be seen as weird.
At this point, that was the least of his concerns.
"Hey, wanna go somewhere for lunch? We can discuss the case some more." Peter said, his voice was low with a hint of embarrassment. He didn't want to give Mark any ideas of what he actually meant but instead an idea that he actually cared about the Jigsaw case at this moment.
Strahm held his breath while waiting for a response, keeping his eyes focused on the papers on his desk rather than Hoffman to seem relaxed.
He really hoped he was pulling off the whole 'chill' act...
Hoffman didnât answer right away. He sat with it, rolling the idea over in his head, his pen idly tapping against the desk.
Lunch. Alone. With him.
It was easy to pretend that was a normal suggestion. Just two law enforcement officers talking shop. But Strahm had hesitated before asking, and that hesitation stuck with him.
His eyes flicked toward the other man, watching the way he stayed locked onto the papers in front of him like they held the answer to something more than just their case. His fingers curled around his pen a little tighter.
Hoffman wasnât sure why that detail bothered him.
He exhaled through his nose, feigning indifference. âYeah, sure.â His voice was steady, neutral. As if he hadnât spent the last minute overthinking this.
He leaned back in his chair, stretching his legs out, the tension in his muscles betraying his otherwise relaxed posture. His knee bounced once before he stilled it. He didnât like feeling caught off guard.
He finally looked at Strahm again. âWhere?â It wasnât an enthusiastic acceptance, but it also wasnât a rejection. It was something in between.
Peter let out a quiet sigh as soon as Mark answered, gripping at the bridge of his nose as he tried to think of a place nearby that was nice enough to take Hoffman to, but not too nice.
"Well, I heard there's this nice sandwich place that recently opened... we could go there." Strahm suggested, pulling himself out of his work to actually make eye contact with Hoffman.
He noticed small details very quickly. The way a couple strands of hair fell out of his styled hair, the way his eyes were naturally tired looking in such a good way, the way his hand gripped onto his pen, the way he had to stop his leg from bouncing... everything was so perfect it made him sick.
He tried to pull his eyes off of Mark, but he just couldn't. For once, he had an actual excuse to stare at Hoffman. He shouldn't have been as grateful as he was.
Hoffman let a beat of silence pass before tilting his head slightly, finally meeting Strahmâs eyes with something that almost resembled amusement.
âA sandwich place, huh?â he said, tapping his fingers idly against the desk. âDidnât peg you as the type to branch out. Thought you survived purely off burnt coffee and spite.â
There was a slight smirk at the corner of his mouth, but his tone was just casual enough to keep Strahm guessing. It wasnât an outright challenge, but it wasnât nothing, either. Just enough to test the watersâto see if Strahm would roll his eyes, snap back, or keep looking at him like that.
His leg bounced once before he forced it still again, fingers tightening around his pen.
Peter's breathing quickly became regular as soon as Hoffman made eye contact with him, causing him to stumble over his words.
"Well- I-" He paused, collecting his thoughts. "I mostly survive off of cheap burnt coffee, but I'm switching it up for once." A slight smile appeared on his face for the first time today once he realized if he just kept up this calm, non-angry act up, he might survive this shift.
Or, at least he'll try to keep it up. It's hard when he's around Mark.
Strahm reached into his pocket and searched for his card, flipping through random twenties and tens before finally finding it. "I heard it's pretty cheap so I might as well pay for yours." He said, not even noticing how nice he was being.
He was never nice to anyone other than Lindsey really, so this must've been a rare sighting to anyone listening in to the conversation.
"But I'm only paying because it's cheap. I'm not trying to be all nice and shit, so don't get that idea." Of course, he had to ruin the one moment he seemed slightly kind.
Hoffman let out a quiet chuckle, shaking his head as he watched Strahm fumble with his wallet. There was something oddly endearing about itâhow he offered without thinking, only to immediately try to walk it back. It wasnât often that Strahm let something slip through the cracks.
"Generous and cheap. Quite the combination," Hoffman murmured, his voice dipping into something almost warm, almost teasing. He let the words hang between them for a moment before exhaling, running a hand down the sleeve of his jacket as he stood.
His gaze lingered on Strahm just a little longer than necessary, taking in the way he still wouldn't quite meet his eyes. There was a rare ease in the moment, a shift from the usual sharp edges they threw at each other. Hoffman felt it more than he wanted to acknowledge.
"If youâre so insistent," he said, his tone softer now, something almost amused beneath it, "Iâll let you buy me lunch. Just donât expect me to be nice about it."
It wasnât a joke, not really. But it was something. A quiet acceptance, an unspoken truce. And when he stepped just a little closerâjust enough to catch the faintest tension in Strahmâs shouldersâhe couldn't quite fight the smirk that ghosted across his lips.
"Letâs go before you change your mind."
Strahm nodded in agreement, shoving his wallet back in his pocket before standing, straightening out his top with his hands. It was so weird that he suddenly felt a need to look... cleaner around Hoffman.
"Do you want me to drive?" He asked as he began to walk to the front door of the building, reaching a hand into the opposite pocket of his wallet to grip onto his keys, ready for an answer to his question.
Peter tried to walk slightly fast, trying to avoid anyone really seeing him walk outside the building while having an active and normal conversation with Mark.
He didn't want people to think he suddenly grew fond of Hoffman because, if he was being completely honest, he didn't really like the thought of beginning to grow fond of him.
Peter spent all of these years hating Mark just for that to change from one interaction. It felt stupid to him. He felt stupid.
Hoffman followed steadily, letting Strahm put some distance between them. It wasnât hard to pick up on the way Peter was rushing. Like it meant something.
Hoffman didnât call attention to it, but he noticed. He noticed the way Strahmâs fingers curled tightly around his keys, the way he held himself just a little straighter, as if heâd suddenly started caring about how he looked. It was subtle, but it was there.
And for some reason, it was... alluring.
There was a new kind of tension in Strahm, not the usual barely-contained aggression Hoffman was used to. This was something else, something more restrained. He wasnât sure what to make of it yet, but he had the patience to figure it out.
âIâll let you drive,â he finally said, watching Strahm with something just shy of amusement. His voice was even, casual, but his smirk gave away more than he probably intended. He let the moment stretch just a little longer before adding, âJust try not to kill us before we get there.â
A joke, but one that carried weight. A small push. A test.
He walked ahead of Strahm and put a hand in his pocket as he walked.
"I'll try, but it might be hard with you in the car." Peter said, hiding back a smirk as he spoke. He pulled the keys out of his pocket, gripping them tightly in his hand as if someone was going to steal them from him.
As he entered the cold weather outside, his whole body tightened. Strahm had always hated the cold.
He unlocked his car, quickly shoving himself in to try and escape the weather. He switched on the heat in his car before blowing warm air into his hands, waiting patiently for Mark to say something that gave him the idea he was ready for him to start driving.
Peter really hated driving with a person in his car. His road rage usually killed any good energy moving throughout his car in a matter of seconds. Sure, Mark has seen him angry, but not the type of anger he gets while driving.
Plus, he'd really hate to ruin what they had going on at the moment...
Hoffman let out a short chuckle at Strahmâs response, low and almost under his breath. There was something oddly satisfying about the way Peter shot back without missing a beatâlike he was starting to get comfortable with this, whether he wanted to or not.
The cold bit at his skin as he followed Strahm outside, but he barely registered it, too focused on watching the other man move. The tension in his shoulders, the way he practically threw himself into the car to escape the chillâit was little things like that that made Hoffman feel like he was getting a read on him.
He slid into the passenger seat with an easy, unbothered motion, his gaze settling on Strahm as the heat kicked in. The way Peter hunched over his hands, rubbing warmth back into them, was oddly... humanizing. A rare moment where he looked like more than just a sharp edge waiting to cut.
Hoffman leaned back, making himself comfortable before finally breaking the silence. âYou gonna warm up before we get moving, or do I have to listen to you bitch about the cold the whole drive?â His tone was teasing, but his eyes lingered a little too longâtaking in the way Strahmâs lips were still slightly parted from the rush of warm air, the way his fingers flexed against his palms.
Another small test. Another moment to gauge how far this push-and-pull would go.
Strahm smiled, pulling his hands away from his mouth. "You'll have to hear me bitch about a lot during this car ride. The traffic is bad right now." He said as he put his hand on the steering wheel, gripping it tightly.
He started to drive, his attention suddenly going to the road with a straight, serious face. He always took driving very serious, for some strange reason.
Peter tried to seem calm with Mark in the car, but seeing all the cars lined up in the street already made his blood boil. He didn't want to yell at all, but he just knew that would be hard.
"Holy fuck, that's a lot of cars..." He commented, speaking in a low voice that seemed like a grumble or a growl. His voice always sounded so demanding or angry, no matter what mood he was in.
Hoffman settled into his seat, letting his gaze drift lazily over the dashboard before inevitably landing on Strahmâs hands. He had a firm grip on the wheel, fingers tense, knuckles just shy of turning white.
Hoffman had seen Strahmâs hands in plenty of different settingsâclutching a gun, flipping through case files, clenched into fistsâbut there was something about watching them now, wrapped around the wheel with that quiet intensity, that held his attention a little too long.
The way his fingers flexed slightly every time he muttered under his breath, the subtle tremor of agitation when traffic didnât move fast enoughâit was strangely captivating. It made Hoffman wonder, just for a second, how that tension would feel if it werenât directed at the steering wheel.
âTry not to take it personally,â he said finally, tearing his gaze away and shifting in his seat. âPretty sure the traffic isnât out to get you.â His tone was light, almost mocking, but his fingers tapped idly against his own thighâlike he was keeping himself from saying something else.
"It's just so annoying. If people actually knew how to drive then we-" He suddenly stopped himself from talking, giving himself a moment to collect his thoughts. He couldn't go on a stupid rant about people driving. At leastânot in front of Mark.
His eyes slowly drifted towards Hoffman's fingers tapping against his thigh, picking up on the rhythm in his head quickly. He watched as if it was a mind blowing thing, like something he's never seen before. Obviously, he wasn't focused on the rhythm, he was focused on Mark.
The way he tapped so calmly like he was waiting to say something, the way his focus was on the grip of his hand, the way he was somehow so calm and collected on the outside, everything. All of it just seemed so perfect. Too perfect.
Peter soon snapped out of it as soon as he realized the cars around him were moving, and soon became fixated back on the road.
"This place better be good. If I drove in this traffic for no reason, I'll be pissed." He said, beginning to quietly tap the rhythm Mark had been tapping, using it as a way to calm down.
Suddenly, it hit him. He was driving Mark Hoffmanâthe guy who has been driving him insane all dayâout to eat with him. Sure, it wasn't fancy, but it was still something. The thought of this made him go back to biting his lip, leaving a dent over the previous one that just started going away.
Hoffmanâs fingers kept up their steady rhythm against his thigh, but his focus wasnât really on it anymore. His eyes had drifted back to Strahm, watching the way his jaw tensed, the way his grip tightened on the steering wheelâand most of all, the way he kept biting his lip, almost absentmindedly.
He let the moment stretch for a beat longer than necessary before speaking, voice smooth but just pointed enough to be intentional.
"Didn't take you for a nervous habit kind of guy, Strahm. Be careful there."
The words hung in the air, but the way Hoffmanâs gaze lingeredâjust for a secondâmade it clear heâd noticed. He settled back against the seat, watching for a reaction, wondering if Strahm would brush it off or if the slight shift in energy would throw him off course.
Strahm stopped tapping his fingers, looking over to Mark with a confused expression. It took him a moment to realize he was biting down on his lip. Again.
He quickly corrected himself, wiping his lip to see more blood transfer onto his hand. "Fuck..." He whispered to himself, staring down at the wipe of blood on the side of his hand before sighing and simply putting his hand back onto the wheel.
Peter never understood why he did stuff like this knowing it would later on hurt. And he especially didn't understand why he was doing it even more than usual. Normally, he would bite his lip while checking out a crime scene, or holding a gun, but never while simply being around a person.
He soon realized how much power Hoffman held when it came to himself. He could simple say something cocky and it would mess up his whole shift, or even the rest of his day.
"God fucking damn it." He said as he punched the steering wheel, causing his car to honk to the car in front of them.
Great, he did the one thing he was trying not to do. Get mad over a simple thing while in the car.
Hoffmanâs smirk faltered. Just for a second.
He hadnât expected that reactionâhadnât expected Strahm to actually hit the wheel like that. The sharp sound of the horn rang in his ears, but it was the frustration in Strahmâs voice that really caught him off guard.
For all the ways he liked to push, this wasnât what heâd been aiming for.
Hoffman shifted slightly, pulling his gaze away, tapping his fingers against his thigh againâbut this time, it wasnât intentional. It was just something to do. Something to focus on instead of the way Strahmâs knuckles were going white against the steering wheel.
"Forget it," he muttered, quieter than before. "Didnât mean anything by it."
For once, he let the moment pass without another remark. No teasing, no smug little comments. Just silenceâsave for the hum of the car engine and the faint, rhythmic tapping of his fingers.
Was this guilt? He felt guilty for that remark, and Hoffman rarely cares about others like that.
He suddenly felt anxious. He tried to remain suave but his hands shook ever so slightly as he loosened his tie. It was getting slightly hard to breathe.
Strahm had gone completely silent at this point, taking all his anger out by gripping the wheel. If he knew that he would've fucked up the stuff they had going, he would've tried to prevent it.
But he couldn't.
He soon saw the sandwich shop, realizing it was closed. He went through all of this for it to be closed. He sighed and turned into the parking lot anyway, parking the car to think of another place they could go to.
"So... the shop is closed today, I guess." Peter said, his voice quiet and low as if he was confessing something. He felt somewhat bad. He felt bad for taking Hoffman out of work just to find out their plans wouldn't even end up working.
"We could... go somewhere else. Or go back." He paused as he thought of more ideas. "Or we could sit here and talk about the case." He said as a last choice.
Instead of looking over to Hoffman, he stared down at his lap. It didn't feel right to look at him after what just happened. He felt... embarrassed in a way. He knew that if he reacted to something with anger, it would've changed everything. Yet, he did it anyways. He just let it happen.
Hoffman stayed quiet for a moment, letting his eyes settle on Strahm. Really looking at him.
The way his shoulders were still tense, the way his fingers flexed against the steering wheel like he was holding himself back.
Hoffman tapped his fingers one last time before letting his hand still in a gentle grasp against his thigh. He wasnât in a rush to speak.
Instead, he just watched.
There was a strange feeling in Hoffmanâs chest, something he didnât quite have the words for.
After another beat of silence, he finally spoke. "Well," he drawled, tilting his head slightly, "weâve already wasted this much time. Might as well make it worth it."
His voice was even, but there was an edge of something unreadable in it.
Hoffman wasnât sure what he expected Strahm to say next. But he was sure of one thingâhe wasnât ready to leave yet.
"Mhm.." Peter hummed in response, taking his hands off the wheel to try and seem more calm and relaxed. His attention turned to Mark very soon, his eyes hovering over his whole body before meeting his eyes.
He had a strange feeling in his chest every time he looked at Mark. It suddenly felt heavy and felt it got harder to breathe.
The tension in the car was so much more in the office. The way they were much closer than before, the way they had no where else to look but each other, it was all too much. Peter removed his jacket, folding it neatly before setting it down in his lap. Though, he never broke eye contact.
"Have you got anything about the case? Any suspects, any leads, anything? Have you heard anything from the DNA test yet?" Peter decided it would be best to ask a good amount of questions. Then, it would be easier for him to seem less.. awkward and nervous.
Work seemed to be the only thing keeping him sane right now.
Hoffman didnât miss the way Strahm folded his jacketâcareful, deliberate, like he needed to keep his hands occupied. It was almost amusing, the way he tried to seem at ease when everything about him screamed tightly wound.
He let the moment stretch, saying nothing at first. Just watching.
âCouple of things,â he said finally, voice level, unreadable, clearing his throat. âDNA test came back inconclusive. No solid matches.â
Hoffman let that sit between them, waiting to see how Strahm would react.
Mark shifted in his seatâ just enough to take up more space, his arm settling on the center console. Closer.
âThereâs one lead,â Hoffman continued, deliberately unhurried. âGuy who fits the profileâex-con, history of violence, used to work in mechanical engineering.â
Another pause. Then, finally, Hoffman turned his head, meeting his gaze fully.
âYou all right, Strahm?â His voice was smooth, casual, but he knew exactly what he was doing.
Hoffman could feel itâthe tension, the weight pressing down on the space between them. And he liked it.
At first his maintained eye contact, but that proved to be too much for him so he backed off, clearing his throat again.
âIâm not trying to make you nervous.â A lie, and also deflecting some of his own feelings.
"What? I'm fine. I'm not nervous at all, Hoffman." Peter responded, his words sharp and aggressive. He didn't realize until now how tense and nervous his body language was. He shoulder tensed, his jaw clenched, his hands always forming a fist, everything was not normal.
He hated the power Mark held over him. It made him so angry to the point of nausea. Every time Mark did anything better than him, he got jealousâangry. Every time Mark looked at him, he got nervous. He hated the way he just let this happen.
Strahm took a deep breath, placing his arm right next to Hoffman's. "Well, at least we've got something. It's better than what we had before." He said, his voice was very monotoneâdry even.
"I should probably call Perez soon and tell her about this..." Peter said, tapping his finger to a different rhythm than before. It was more aggressive and repetitive, showing both his anger and anxiety in one rhythm.
The way his and Mark's arms were so close made him feel something he couldn't explain. It made it hard to breathe, as if someone were to suck all the air out of his lungs.
[ ooc text : i wrote the second part of this while listening to jealousy, jealousy by olivia rodrigo. feels important to share. ]
Hoffman watched him carefully, his expression unreadable. Strahmâs words were sharp, but they didnât match the way his body was betraying himâso tense he looked ready to snap. Hoffman could practically feel the heat radiating off him, the way his energy buzzed with something dangerously close to frustration. Or something else.
His eyes flicked down to their arms, barely a breath apart. It would take nothing to close that distance. To shift just slightly and press against him, just to see what Strahm would do.
Then Strahm mentioned Perez.
Hoffmanâs fingers, which had been resting idly against his thigh, curled inward before he abruptly moved his arm away, leaning slightly toward the car door. His expression didnât change, but something in his body language didâsomething colder.
"Yeah," he muttered. "You probably should."
Hoffman clenched his jaw, staring straight ahead as if the windshield suddenly held something more interesting than Strahm beside him. The mention of Perez shouldnât bother him, but it did. He knew how much Strahm trusted herâhow easily they worked together, how she could read him in ways Hoffman couldnât.
He didnât like it.
His fingers twitched against his leg, resisting the urge to match Strahmâs rhythm like before. Instead, he let the silence stretch, letting the distance he created sit heavy between them.
âWant some space to call her?â
Strahm noticed how Hoffman tensed as soon as he mentioned Perez, a look of confusion quickly forming on his face. Why did Mark get so weird every time he mentioned Lindsey? Why did he act so weird whenever she was at his desk? It made no sense.
He looked down to see his arm moved away, a feeling of defeat washing over him. They were so close, it was perfect. But clearly, he messed something up to changed the tension they had going for them.
"Uhm, no... I'll just call her later today. She's probably busy anyway, and I don't want to interrupt her." Peter said, slowly removing his arm and placing it onto his lap. He stared at Hoffman, noticing how he would rather stare at nothing then stare at him. Why did it change so quickly?
He coughed, trying to stop the silence between the two. "What should we do?" He asked, trying to use a tone that suggested that he was open to anything, work related or not. At this point, he'd be willing to do anything to get out of this uncomfortable situation.
Strahm started to pick at the sides of his fingernails, messing up his already rough looking fingers. He watched as a small amount of blood formed on his finger once he peeled some skin off, watching it build up but not drip.
It was better to watch than continuing to watch Mark stare out the windshield as if it was much more interesting.
Hoffman exhaled, letting the tension ease from his shoulders as he settled back into his seat. His arm found its way back to the consoleânot quite touching Strahmâs, but close enough that it wasnât a full retreat anymore.
"Alright," he said, tilting his head slightly as if considering their options. "We could hit up that shitty diner a few blocks over. The one with the terrible coffee but decent fries." He shot Strahm a sideways glance, a ghost of a smirk tugging at his lips. "Unless youâre too good for a place that serves their food on plastic trays."
It wasnât just about food anymore, and they both knew it. Hoffmanâs posture was more open again, his voice lacking the sharp edge from earlier.
"And hey," he added, his smirk sharpening just slightly, "maybe if you're lucky, the waitress will think weâre on a date and give you the check. Since, y'know, you were so eager to take me out in the first place."
It was a joke, but not a denial. And the way he looked at Strahm when he said itâsteady, watching for a reactionâmade it clear he wasnât just filling the silence.
âOr maybe one of us can flash our badge and make her feel bad.â He winked. A soft, brief action.
A smirk appeared on Strahm's face, looking up from his hand and back to Hoffman. "I'm fine with the shitty diner, I guess." He said with a hint of sarcasm in his voice at the end.
"And I think we should go with the second idea. Flashing our badges is better than her thinking we're a gay couple." Peter said as he began to start driving, but this time only with one arm. Keeping his arm next to Mark's felt... right.
He began driving out of the parking space, making a promise in his mind that he wouldn't get visibly angry at the people on the road. He would hate to ruin the tension for the hundredth time today. Peter bit down on his lip slightly, mainly doing it to keep his focus on the road.
Peter took a deep breath as soon as he got on the road, trying to seem like he didn't even care about the traffic, but he did. He really did. He actually cared about everything right now. The traffic, the way Hoffman's arm was right next to his, the fact he was driving him to a diner, everything. It all was so much more than it would normally be, but he stayed calm.
At least, he tried to stay calm.
Hoffman stood just outside the diner's entrance, the neon light flickering against his skin, casting him in a glow of red and gold. He flexed his fingers at his sides, still feeling the lingering warmth from where their arms had brushed in the car. It was stupidâinsignificant, really. But it had made something stir deep in his chest, something he wasnât ready to acknowledge.
He glanced over his shoulder, watching Strahm still sitting in the driverâs seat, his fingers tapping against the wheel. For a moment, Hoffman just⊠looked at him. The usual irritation was there, sure, but it was layered with something else, something heavier. He exhaled, shaking his head to himself before rapping his knuckles lightly against the glass door.
"You coming?" His voice was lower than he intended, softer, almost coaxing. He hesitated, then let a smirk tug at his lips. "Or do you just like staring at me from a distance?"
He turned before he could catch Strahmâs expression, stepping inside the diner. The scent of coffee and fryer grease wrapped around him, familiar and grounding. Still, that warmth from the car lingered, settling deep in his chest. As much as he tried to ignore it, deny it, there was no shaking the truthâsomething between them had shifted. And for once, Hoffman wasnât sure if he wanted to fight it.
Peter sighed before slipping his coat on, finally leaving his car. He made sure to lock his car before walking over to the diner with the neon flickering lights. This is not where he exactly wanted to take Mark, but guess that's what he had to deal with for now.
He stepped inside, walking past Hoffman to a small booth all the way in the corner of the diner. He sat in the seat against the wall, waiting patiently for Mark to sit across from him.
It was weird to think about. Taking the man he hated out to get food. Sure, he invited him to talk about 'work' , but they both knew that wasn't going to actually happen. At least, not the whole time.
"I don't really know if I'll eat anything here. Hell, they probably cook dead rats into the food based on what people say about it." Peter said, looking around to see most employees sitting on their phones or talking. Sure, this wasn't ideal, but it would work just fine.
After all, he didn't want things to seem romantic. Peter didn't like Mark that way.
At least, that's what he told himself.
Hoffman leaned back against the cracked vinyl seat, drumming his fingers against the tabletop as he glanced over the laminated menu. It was sticky. Of course it was. He barely looked at the options before setting it aside.
"Dead rats or not, Iâm getting a shake," he said, flagging down a half-interested waitress. "Chocolate. Extra thick." His voice was smooth, deliberate, like he was making a point. He didn't care if the place was a dumpâhe was here, and he was going to enjoy something.
Once the waitress walked off, he leaned forward slightly, resting his forearms on the table. His gaze flicked over Strahm, taking in the tension in his shoulders, the way he was still pretending like this wasnât something. It was almost endearing.
"You know, if you keep looking that uncomfortable, people are gonna think I dragged you here against your will." His smirk was slow, knowing. "Or worse, that this actually is a date and you're just playing hard to get."
He let that sit between them, watching for the reaction. Strahm always had a tell, no matter how much he tried to hide it. And Hoffman? He lived for it.
Peter hummed in response to Mark, quickly shaking his head once the waiter looked at him with a look of boredom and impatience, waiting for an order. He sighed as soon as the waiter walked off, shutting his eyes for a moment before opening them to meet Mark leaned more towards him.
"I would way rather have them think you kidnapped me or something. I don't want people to think we're on a date. Or that I'm gay." As soon as he spoke those last four words, it hurt something in him. He didn't understand why though. He wasn't gay. That's what he's been telling everyone for years.
These feelings were so confusing. He hated Hoffman, he knew he did. Something was... different. Usually, he would be tearing his hair out by nowâbut it was different now. He was less angry.
Strahm tried to relax his shoulder, but failed. He hated how much he seemed so nervous and shut off when he wanted to seem relaxed. He wanted to seem more normal, but that was hard when he wasn't normal even when hating Mark.
Hoffman let out a quiet snort, shaking his head slightly as he leaned back again, giving Strahm just a bit more spaceâbut not much.
âRelax, Strahm,â he muttered, voice low and edged with amusement. âNo one in here gives a shit about what you are.â His fingers drummed idly against the table as he watched the way Peterâs shoulders stayed locked in place, the tension rolling off of him in waves.
That reactionâthat was interesting. It wasnât just irritation or the usual disdain that Strahm carried whenever he was around him. This was something else. Hoffman bit his lip in thought.
Hoffman tilted his head slightly, his eyes scanning Strahmâs face, catching the way his mouth pressed into a tight line, the way his fingers curled against his thigh like he was trying to hold something back.
He could push. It would be easy. A well-placed comment, a teasing smirk, just enough of a prod to see what would happen if he hit the right nerve.
But, for once, he didnât.
Instead, he exhaled, shaking his head as he reached for his glass of water, taking a slow sip before setting it back down. âBesides, if I did kidnap you, Iâd make sure you at least got something better than a damn sandwich out of it.â
The words were casual, thrown out with just enough humor to make it unclear whether he was joking or not. But underneath, it was a testâa different kind of test. Would Strahm push back? Laugh it off? Or would he keep unraveling right in front of him?
Peter felt like he was melting away. He was so focused on what other people around him thought. People he would most likely never even see again. The idea of a random stranger thinking something that wasn't true made him freak out. What if he actually saw them again and they thought he was something he wasn't? What if that made people avoid him? He hated it.
"Yeah. Sure." He mumbled, looking over Mark's shoulder for a second to scan the whole diner and all the workers. Another habit he had to avoid a situation. This time, the situation was right in front of himâstaring with a smirk that showed that he was clearly interested by Peter's reactions to things.
He looked down at his lap, fixing the previous creases he made in his pants from gripping them. It was weird, he felt a sudden need to look nice. Normally, if he was at work, he never cared. It was just work after all. Today thoughâit was different. Very different.
"Oh, so if you were to kidnap someone, you would cook them a full meal?" Strahm asked with a hint of sarcasm in his voice, trying to come across as more calm and relaxed. His tone was calm, but his body language was completely different. His body language resembled a stray cat whenever you try to pet it. Tense, intimidating, aggressive.
He didn't mean to come off like this, but it was better than coming off nice, or worseâromantic. Which sucked, because deep down there was something going on. Something other than hate or anger. But different from what he felt around Lindsey...
Hoffman let out a low chuckle, shaking his head as he leaned back slightly, arms crossing over his chest. âWhat, you think Iâd half-ass it?â His smirk remained, but his gaze was steady, watching every nervous shift, every flicker of hesitation in Strahmâs expression.
Hoffman tilted his head slightly. âIâm just saying, if I were the kind of guy to kidnap someone, Iâd at least put in the effort. Full meal. Maybe some wine. Make it a whole experience.â His voice was even, casual, but the weight behind his words lingered in the space between them.
He let the thought settle for a moment before reaching for his drink, taking another slow sip. âNot that youâd appreciate it,â he added, tone bordering on dry amusement. âYou strike me as the type to complain about the wine pairing.â
He was still testing, still pushingâjust enough to see how Strahm would react.
"Well, I believe that it would be a bit stupid to make a full meal. You don't want the person you kidnapped to get attached to you. That'll just cause so many more problems." Strahm said as if he had experience in stuff like this. Obviously, he didn't. It was more of the fact that he's dealt with multiple situations like this.
Peter's voice was less aggressive, finally showing that some of the tension and stress had left his body. It felt like heavy sandbags being lifted off his shoulders, giving him the ability to finally seem a bit more confinement rather than stuck in his own skin.
"Of course I complain about wine pairing. It's basically everything when it comes to a nice meal! Tell me, would you pair a glass of Pinot Noir with a steak? No. You would pair something like Cabernet Sauvignon." It was obvious he was good at this subject. Which you probably wouldn't guess by getting one simple look at him.
Peter checked his watch, quickly looking back up to Mark. "We should probably head back soon." He said, putting his coat over his arms as quickly, basically preparing himself to leave in a quick amount of time.
Hoffman raised an eyebrow, watching Strahm with something between amusement and intrigue. The shift in his demeanor didnât go unnoticedâhis voice had lost some of that earlier edge, his posture a little less rigid. It was subtle, but it was there.
âDidnât take you for a wine guy,â Hoffman mused, tilting his head slightly. âThatâs a real specific take for someone who spends most of his days running on burnt coffee.â His smirk lingered, but there was something else in his gaze nowâsomething considering.
He didnât know why it was so damn fascinating, watching Strahm loosen up, even just a little. Maybe it was because he knew how rare it was. Strahm was all sharp edges and tension, always coiled like a spring. Seeing him talk about something so mundane, something he actually seemed passionate about, was... different.
Hoffman exhaled through his nose, glancing at his own watch before rolling his shoulders back. âYeah, wouldnât want anyone thinking we actually enjoyed this.â The words were teasing, but there was an undertone to themâsomething unspoken but lingering.
As Strahm pulled on his coat with that same urgency, Hoffman just watched him for a moment before finally moving to stand. He didnât rush. He didnât need to. Strahm was already rattled enough without him adding to it.
But still, as they stepped outside into the cold, he let the silence settle just long enough to make Strahm wonder what he was thinkingâbefore finally breaking it with a low, amused murmur:
âYou talk a big game about wine pairings, but next time, Iâm picking the place.â
He paused for a moment, thinking if he should even offer but he did, anyways: âWant me to drive the way back?â He asked, staring ahead.
"Really? I'm a pretty big wine guy. Me and Perez tend to talk about it a lot, I guess you just don't hear us." He found himself bringing up Lindsey again. He knew that it wasn't a good idea. He knew that everything would shift once again after bringing her up. Yet, he still did it.
He sighed before walking over to the waiter, putting down a random ten dollar bill from his wallet before walking outside into the cold with Hoffman. The cold hit him like a punch, causing him to exhale a deep breath.
"Well, I wasn't going to bring you to a place where they pair wine to discuss work, Mark." The comment was supposed to come off playful, but instead came off harsh. He always struggled to control his tone, which was the reason he spoke with such a monotone, bored voice.
Peter unlocked the car doors, looking over to Mark. "Yeah, sure. It'll be better for you to drive anyway." He said, getting in the car before discussing anything else. He would rather die than stand a moment longer in the cold weather.
Hoffmanâs jaw tightened at the mention of Perez. Of course, Strahm had to bring her up. He always did, like it was some kind of reflex. And every time, it hit Hoffman the same wayâan irritating little twist in his gut that he couldn't quite shake.
He didnât say anything right away, just let his eyes linger on Strahm as they stepped out into the cold. The wind bit at his skin, but he barely registered it. He was too busy watching the way Strahm hunched his shoulders, the way he exhaled sharply like the cold was trying to rip the breath from his lungs.
Hoffman scoffed at the comment about work, catching the way Strahm avoided looking directly at him. Yeah, sure. You werenât gonna bring me to a place like that for work. But youâd bring Perez, wouldnât you?
He didnât voice the thought. Instead, he followed Strahm into the car, sliding into the driverâs seat with a little more force than necessary. The second he started the engine, the heater kicked on, filling the space with warmthâbut Hoffman still felt that simmering irritation sitting low in his chest.
He glanced at Strahm. Something about him made his fingers tighten on the steering wheel. âYou talk about wine like some expert, but I bet if Perez were here, youâd have some bullshit poetic thing to say about it,â he muttered, keeping his voice level, but there was an unmistakable sharpness to it.
He wasnât sure what he wanted out of that commentâmaybe just to see Strahmâs reaction, to make him squirm the way Hoffman felt himself doing internally. Because for all his control, for all his carefully placed remarks, something about Strahm had a way of slipping under his skin. And it pissed him off. Well, he didn't know if he was more pissed off at that or the fact that he didn't understand why he was pissed off in the first place.
Peter put his hands between his knees in an attempt to warm them up, staring down as he did. He couldn't bring himself to look at Mark. He couldn't bring himself to even quickly glance at him. He already felt everything shift as soon as he brought up Lindsey.
Just as he was in his thoughts, Mark spoke.
The words stabbed him, causing his stomach to turn. Not out of anxiety, but rather anger. It made him so angry knowing that Hoffman hated Perez for no real reason. It made his blood boil. She wasn't a bad detective, she was kind, she never came off as aggressive, she was so perfect. Yet, Mark found a way to hate her.
"What do you mean, Hoffman? What is that supposed to mean." The first time was a question. The second time was in demand. A demand for answers. He was tired of how he always found a way to get mad at Lindsey when she has never done anything to him.
Strahm still avoided eye contact, but it was clear that he was angry. Even without the look of rage and hatred in his eyes, anyone could still tell he was angry. The way his words became sharp and intense again, the way his body tensed up when he spoke, the way his hands turned into fist in seconds.
It was all too obvious.
Hoffman didnât answer right away. He just drummed his fingers against the steering wheel, exhaling through his nose as if Strahmâs reaction wasnât exactly what he was hoping for.
But it was.
The sharpness in his voice, the way his body locked upâHoffman knew that anger well. He knew how it made Strahmâs breath come a little quicker, how it made him grip at things too tightly. And maybe it was fucked up, but he liked knowing he could pull that reaction from him so easily.
âWhat do I mean?â Hoffman repeated, dragging the words out slow, testing the weight of them on his tongue. His gaze flicked toward Strahm, watching the way he kept his eyes pointed anywhere but at him. Coward.
âI mean exactly what I said. You donât talk about me the way you talk about her.â His voice was even, but there was something under itâsomething Strahm wasnât going to like if he looked too closely.
His grip on the wheel tightened. âAnd donât pretend like you donât know what I mean,â he added, lower this time, but more pointed. âEvery time she comes up, you get allââ He waved a hand vaguely, knowing Strahm would get it. âLike sheâs so perfect. Like she can do no wrong. So yeah, maybe I donât like her, Strahm. Maybe I donât like the way you talk about her.â
His jaw clenched. He hadnât meant to say that last part, but now it was out there, sitting in the space between them. And for once, he was the one who looked away first.
Peter's breathing was quick and heavy, as if he was holding back so many things. Which, he was. Instead of yelling, he let Mark finish. He let him finish his ranting while holding eye contact. His eyes were angry, hateful, and disappointed. His eyes held a look that was almost unreadable, yet so readable at the same time.
He hated hearing these words. He hated hearing about someone not liking Lindsey. He hated listening to someone not thinking she was perfect. He hated hearing that Mark hated her. He hated Mark.
He felt his head began to hurt from the rage and all the thoughts piling up at once. He couldn't keep them hidden much longer. He had to express them somehow.
"What's the true reason you can't handle me talking about someone else? What is it, Hoffman? What makes you, a grown man who I haven't known most of my life, crave the attention I give to someone else? What makes you feel the need to act like an angry pathetic dog who craves attention? What is it?" He spoke, his words spilling out. He couldn't stop now.
"Why would I need to talk about you the way I talk about her? Do you believe you are more important than Lindsey in my mind? Do you truly believe you are better than her?" He thought for a moment, collecting his ability to breathe before continuing.
"I talk about her that way because she is perfect. She does no wrong. When has she ever wronged you? When has she wronged me? When has she wronged anyone? You can't think of a single example, can you? That's because she hasn't wronged anyone. You have no real reason to hate her other than jealousy, which doesn't even make sense because I could've sworn you hated me just yesterday. Why are you suddenly so jealous over someone I've known for years?"
He stopped himself, but his body language showed how angry he still was. His eyes, his hands, his shoulders, everything. It just showed how angry he was. Even then, that didn't do it justice.
Hoffmanâs grip on the steering wheel was so tight that his knuckles were white, the leather groaning under his fingers as he tried to force the anger back down. The air between them was thick with the tension, and it only got worse as Strahmâs wordsâsharp, biting, full of that damn righteous angerâsettled in the car, suffocating everything else.
Every word from Strahm twisted something inside him, but it wasnât just anger. It was jealousy.
Hoffman could feel the heat radiating from him, the sharpness in his voice, his body practically vibrating with the intensity of it. Jealous of Lindsey. Thatâs what it was, isnât it? But no. He couldnât admit that. Not out loud. Not even to himself.
His jaw locked so tight that it hurt, and it was taking all his self-control not to lash out. But as much as he hated admitting it, he wasnât just angry. No, it was more complicated than that.
"Really, Strahm?" Hoffmanâs voice was low, too low. It felt like it came from somewhere deep inside him, almost like he was letting something slip without meaning to. âYou wanna act like Iâm just throwing a fit, like Iâm jealous?â His words came out rough, but there was something else thereâsomething softer. A pull, just beneath the anger. âYou think I care about her more than you?â
He took a slow breath, still staring at the road, forcing himself to focus on the sound of his heartbeat. It wasnât enough to calm the storm inside him. His eyes flickered briefly to Strahm, watching the way he held himself, how tense and wound up he was. That tightness in his jaw, those clenched fists. Hoffman hated it. But he also liked it. Too much.
âIf I cared about her that much,â Hoffman continued, his voice a little quieter now, almost to the point where Strahm had to lean in to hear him, âI wouldnât be here. Wouldnât be here with you, would I?â
His pulse quickened as he said it, that same rush of heat climbing up his neck. He hated how it soundedâtoo much like he was admitting something, too much like he was being vulnerable when heâd never let anyone see that side of him.
His hands tightened on the wheel again, but it wasnât just anger this time. His thoughts were swirling, clouded with the weight of what he couldnât say. Couldnât admit.
He glanced at Strahm again, eyes narrowing, but this time it was different. He couldnât look away. There was something else there nowâsomething raw, something almost intimate in the way Strahm looked at him.
âIs that what you want, Peter?â Hoffmanâs voice was softer now, barely a whisper, a challenge. âYou really think Iâm jealous of her? Or is it that you just canât handle the idea of me being here instead of her?â
His heart thudded in his chest, the words spilling out before he could stop them. His stomach twisted. Why couldnât he stop? Why did it feel like something had shifted, like the whole conversation was moving toward something else entirely?
The silence between them stretched out, the only sound the hum of the engine and the beating of their hearts. Hoffman wasnât sure if Strahm could feel it tooâthe way the air had thickened with unspoken words. The way it felt like they were suddenly standing at the edge of something they werenât quite ready for.
But it was too late. The tension was already there, and Hoffman knew, without a doubt, that it wasnât just about Lindsey anymore.
And he hated himself for that.
Peter suddenly felt the tension for once, actually backing off. Something told him he needed to back off this situation before he said anything else or anything worse. He suddenly, for some reason, felt bad. It didn't make sense though. He shouldn't feel bad. He had a point, Mark did seem jealous of Lindsey. But did he maybe take it too far?
He took a breath through his nose and out his mouth. "Mark, I'm not saying you're jealous, I'm saying it seems like it. Every time I mention Lindsey, you act like it's the end of the damn world. You get all tense and angry as if you hate her for simply being in my life."
He spoke as if he hated the idea of Hoffman being jealous, but he really didn't. He enjoyed the idea of how he could ruin someones mood just by simply bringing up one person.
"All I want to know is why. Why does your mood change? Why do you get so tense? Why do you hate the idea that I think she's perfect?" Strahm poured out his words as if his mouth was a faucet for his brain.
The air between them was too much. It was thick, it was overwhelming. It drove him so insane how angry they both were. All he could hear was his own heartbeat in his ears.
"I just need to know. Why don't you like Lindsey?" He wasn't demanding anymore. He was pleading. He wanted to know why because he couldn't handle watching how he looked at her with such anger and jealousy every time they spoke at work.
Hoffmanâs grip on the steering wheel was relentless as Strahmâs words hung in the air, thick and heavy, pressing down on him like a weight he couldnât shake off. The space between them felt suffocating, as if every word Strahm said was just making the tension worse. But something in the way Strahm spoke caught him off guardâthere was a vulnerability there, a softness to his tone that Mark wasnât used to. Pleading. It had always been anger before, but now it was something else. Something that made Hoffman feel like he was walking a razorâs edge.
"You really wanna know, Peter?" Hoffmanâs voice was low, rough with something that wasnât anger anymore. It was too much to admit, too much to say, but it was right there, clawing at the back of his throat.
He took a breath, feeling the heat of Strahmâs words pressing into him. Mark wasnât ready to give in, not yet. He couldnât be. But damn, it was hard to ignore how his chest tightened when Strahm spoke with that tone. Pleading, vulnerable, asking for answers he couldnât give. Hoffman couldnât explain it, but there was something in Strahmâs eyesâthe way he looked at him, the way his words tangled up like a question and a challenge all in oneâthat made him want to say everything. To tell him the truth, to finally admit what had been gnawing at him all this time.
Markâs eyes flickered to Strahm, a quick glance that lingered too long. He tried to look away, but couldnât. He just... couldnât.
âI donât hate her,â Hoffman finally muttered, voice laced with frustration, but there was something deeper in it too. Something that was hard for him to articulate. âItâs not about her. Itâs not about her at all.â
The words came out harsher than he meant, but it wasnât about Lindsey, was it? It was about Peter. And that was something Hoffman wasnât ready to face.
âYou wanna know why my mood changes when you talk about her?â Hoffmanâs voice dropped even lower, almost a growl. âItâs because Iâm hereâwith youâand I hear you talk about her like sheâs some saint. Like sheâs perfect. Like sheâs everything you need, everything you want. And I canât stand it.â
The words slipped out before he could stop them, raw and unfiltered. His chest heaved, and his heart was beating too fast, like it was trying to escape. He could feel the shift, the intensity of the moment pulling them both into a place neither of them were ready for. But Hoffman couldnât help it. He couldnât keep it in any longer.
He turned his head slowly, eyes locking with Strahmâs, searching for somethingâanythingâin his face that would tell him he was still in control, that he hadnât just said too much.
âYou think Iâm jealous of her? Maybe... maybe Iâm just jealous that she gets to have you, and I donât.â
There it was. The words that were always just beneath the surface. He could feel the heat rising in his face, the tightness in his chest, and the way his hands were trembling ever so slightly. He hated how weak it made him feel, how vulnerable.
âBut you donât get it, do you?â Hoffman continued, his voice almost a whisper now, the anger simmering just beneath the surface. âI donât care if sheâs perfect, Peter. Itâs you. Itâs you I canât stand when you talk about her like that. Because itâs not about her. Itâs about... us.â
The words hung in the air, fragile and heavy. He hated how much they revealed, how much of himself he had just let slip. But there was no taking them back now. And as much as he tried to hold it all together, his chest still ached with that unspoken truthâhe had crossed a line he wasnât sure he could walk back from.
The silence stretched between them, thick and suffocating, until it felt like they were both drowning in it. Hoffman wasnât sure what came next. He wasnât sure if he wanted to know. But it was too late to pull back now.
Strahm stared blankly at Hoffman, his angry gaze soon becoming soft. Instead of cutting him off, he listened quietly. He didn't react in any form, though. It didn't feel right. Even a simple nod felt wrong. That would make it seem like he agreed with his feelings, but he didn't. He hadn't connected those feelings inside him just yet.
He wanted until he was silent and the silence was basically drowning the both of them before finally speaking. "Mark... I- I don't know what to say." He said, his mind not fully grasping everything that was said. It still hung in the air, driving him to insanity every second. He wasn't gay. He knew it.
"I'm not... well, I'm not gay. And Lindsey doesn't have me, no one has me." His words came off more aggressive than he wished. "Not even you, Hoffman. You don't have me." Those words weren't supposed to come out. He didn't want to come off as mean. The emotions were just too much to handle, though. Too much to care about how his words came across.
"There is no us. The only us we have going on is a work situation, Mark." He hesitated saying his name. "There can't be any of us. I'm sorry, but that's not who I am. And I'm not going to lead you on and pretend that's who I am. I clearly already lead you on enough..."
The last part came out as a whisper, like he was ashamed. Embarrassed even. He never felt bad, but he did this time. He didn't know why, but he did. He felt horrible, actually. It sat so uncomfortably in his stomach he couldn't help but almost gag. Why did he feel so bad?
Why did he regret everything he said?
Hoffmanâs chest tightened as Strahm spoke, each word hitting him like a physical blow. He hadnât expected Peter to say any of thatâhe hadnât expected any of it, really. But the sting of the words, the sharpness in Peterâs voice, felt like a blade to his gut. He hadnât thought that hearing Peter reject him would hurt this much. But it did. It hurt more than he ever thought possible.
When Strahm said those words, âIâm not gayâ, it felt like the ground beneath Mark's feet shifted. It felt like everything he had just laid out, all the things he had been thinking, sayingâfeelingâwas being slammed down in front of him like some hard truth he wasnât ready to hear.
And then the next partââNot even you, Hoffmanââstung deeper. The way Peter said it wasnât meant to be cruel, but it felt like it. Markâs hand clenched into a fist on the steering wheel, knuckles white, as if the tension in his body might somehow find an outlet through sheer force.
But it didnât.
He felt the weight of Peterâs words sitting heavily in the car between them, suffocating him, making him feel smaller than he ever had before. He didnât know what to say to thatâhow to fight back against something so⊠absolute. So final.
Still, there was something in Peterâs tone that shifted, something quieter, something almost⊠regretful. Embarrassed.
Hoffmanâs heart slammed in his chest as Peter whispered the last part, âI clearly already lead you on enough.â
For a moment, Mark couldnât breathe. It was like the air itself had been sucked out of the car, and he was left grasping at whatever was left.
No, Peter didnât want him. He didnât want this.
But there was that whisper of regret that stayed with Hoffman, swirling in his mind. He could see it in Peterâs eyesâthe way they shifted away from him, unable to meet his gaze. And the way he apologized, despite not wanting to admit anything, despite the layers of denial. There was something there. Something Mark wasnât sure if he wanted to understand, but he had to. It ate at him.
He slowly turned his head, his jaw clenching as he held Peterâs gaze, searching for the truth beneath his words.
âI donât need you to lead me on, Peter,â Hoffman said, his voice softer, almost gentle in a way that didnât quite fit the angry edge he usually carried. âIâm not asking for that. But you canât just pretend like I donât see whatâs going on. You donât get to throw this all away just because itâs easier for you.â
The words came out before he could stop them, and though they werenât meant to sound desperate, something in his voice cracked. Something in him trembled under the weight of what he was saying.
âIâm not gonna lie to you, Peter.â He paused, trying to catch his breath, his chest tight. âI... I donât know what the hellâs going on either. But I know Iâm not just some... work colleague to you. Not anymore.â His voice dropped lower. âI see it in the way you act around me. I feel it. Hell, Iâve felt it for a while now.â
He hesitated, staring out the windshield, before glancing back at Peter. His eyes were darker now, a fire simmering beneath them. He couldnât stop himself. He was burning up inside.
âIâm not perfect either, Peter,â he continued, the vulnerability creeping in. âBut donât sit there and pretend like thereâs nothing between us. Youâre not as cold as you think you are.â
It was out before he could stop it, his voice barely above a whisper, but there was a finality to it that lingered in the air.
The silence hung between them again, but this time, it was different. It wasnât just an empty, suffocating thing. It was charged. And as much as Mark hated to admit it, the way Peter wouldnât meet his eyesâthe way he avoided him nowâtold him everything he needed to know.
Peter stared down at his lap, picking at his cuticles to try and distract himself. That was working until Mark said the words. The words that killed everything inside of him. The words that stabbed him in the stomach. The words that made his blood boil.
' You donât get to throw this all away just because itâs easier for you. '
These words pained him. But not in a way that upset him, but in a way that angered him. He wasn't throwing anything away. He tried being nice, but clearly that didn't work. He wasn't gay.
"Listen, Hoffman. I've already told you, I'm not gay. I've never been gay, I've never though I was gay, I'm not gay. I'm not going to let yourself continue to believe that I am. It's not only hurting me, but also hurting you. At this point, it feels like you're leading yourself on."
The words came out in a harsh tone, his words aggressive and mean. He barked back like a dog. In this situation, he was like an angry, lost dog. A dog who needed comfort deep down.
He didn't want to make the situation worse, but it was hard with everything Mark said. the words ' But donât sit there and pretend like thereâs nothing between us. Youâre not as cold as you think you are. ' echoed throughout his head, causing his blood to just boil more.
Soon, he got to a point in anger where he wasn't even angry at Mark as much anymore, it was mostly anger towards himself.
He looked up to look out the windshield, sighing before opening his mouth to speak. His words came out in a low whisper as if he was checking in with himself.
"I'm not gay..."
Mark's eyes locked onto Peter's face, searching for somethingâanythingâto tell him that this wasnât over. But it was clear Peter wasnât giving him anything, just sitting there, picking at his cuticles, trying to hold it all together. The tension in the air was suffocating, and Mark could feel every inch of it tightening around him, his chest growing heavier with each passing second.
When Peter spoke, his voice was sharp, the words like a slap to the face. âIâm not gay. Iâve never been gay, Iâve never thought I was gay, Iâm not gay.â The rapid fire of it made Mark flinch, even though heâd expected it. But it still hurt, hearing Peter say it like that. Like it was something to be ashamed of.
Hoffmanâs jaw clenched, and he leaned forward slightly, his voice low but cutting. âIâm not asking you to be anything youâre not, Peter. But you canât sit there and act like thereâs nothing between us when you know damn well there is.â
Peterâs wordsâthe harshness in his tone, the way he barked back, like a wounded animalâhit a nerve that Mark didnât know existed. But then something else shifted in Peterâs voice, something softer, quieter, that Mark almost didnât catch. Peter looked out the windshield, and Mark could see the way his shoulders slumped slightly, like the anger was draining out of him, replaced with something else. Something less certain.
Mark leaned back in his seat, eyes narrowing, not willing to let Peter get away with this. "Youâre not fooling me, Strahm. Youâre not as cold as you act. You can say all you want that youâre not interested in meâIâm not stupid, I get it. But donât act like I donât see whatâs going on when you look at me like that." His voice cracked with frustration, but he didnât stop. He couldnât. "Youâre running from something. And I donât know what it is, but I see it in the way you pull away, in the way you shut down every time we get close." His eyes flickered toward Peter. "Youâre lying to yourself, Peter. And itâs not just about me. Itâs about you."
The silence that followed was heavier than anything before it, thick with unspoken words and tangled emotions. Mark's heart was hammering in his chest, but he didnât know what to do with it. He wanted to reach over, shake Peter, make him see the truth, but he couldnât. He wasnât sure if Peter was even listening anymore, if the words were getting through to him.
When Peter finally spoke again, his voice was a whisper, almost as if he was saying it more to himself than Mark. "Iâm not gay..."
Markâs eyes softened at the quiet admission. There was a crack in Peterâs façade, a fracture that Mark hadnât expected to see. Heâd seen the anger, the cold detachment, the resistance. But thisâthis was different. This was something raw. Something that made Markâs heart stutter, even if he didnât want it to.
âYou donât have to keep telling me that,â Mark said quietly, his voice surprisingly gentle, as though trying to reach something inside Peter. He leaned forward again, just a little. âI know. I know youâre not âgay,â Peter. But thatâs not what Iâm asking for.â His voice caught on the last word. âIâm asking you to stop running. From me. From whatever the hell it is thatâs scaring you.â
There was a long pause as Mark let the words settle in the air between them. He didnât know what would happen next, or if Peter would even listen. But there was no going back now. He had to say it. He had to give Peter the chance to decide. Whether they could move past all of this or if it would just tear them apart.
Peter still wouldnât meet his eyes, his gaze fixed on the windshield, but Mark didnât look away. He couldnât. Not when there was still a chance. Not when the weight of everything between them was still there, waiting for a spark to set it off.
Strahm felt himself breaking, but hid it. He hid it to the best of his abilities. But if you looked closely, very closely, you'd see a wounded man with glossy eyes. Eyes that weren't helping hide the fact he was upset. Eyes that held so much more emotion than his own words. Eyes you would see on an animal being hunted. Eyes that held fear.
"I'm not-" His voice cracked, but he quickly covered it with a cough. "I'm not running. I'm not scared of anything." No matter how much he tried to hide how he was really feeling, you could still slightly see it. His hands were now shaking and his leg began to bounce up and down quickly, making a faint but noticeable tapping sound.
"I'm not hiding from you." He said, but something in his mind told him he was hiding from Hoffman. Something told him he was hiding from everything. It had gotten to a point that he couldn't hide his feelings anymore. His whole body was tensed up as if protecting himself from words, his eyes fixated on the cars ahead of them more than anything, his leg continued to bounce but at a faster pace, and finally, his lip. He hadn't even noticed, but his lip began to drip blood again. This time though, he didn't wipe it away. He didn't want any hands near his face, even his own.
"And I shut down when we're close because I don't like you, Hoffman. You do nothing but-" He stopped himself, realizing what he said. It was too late. He can't just go back in time and stop himself. These words were stuck in the car.
All of their words were stuck in the car, along with his heart.
Mark could feel it, the tension in the air thick and almost suffocating. Every breath Peter took seemed heavy, labored, and every movement of his hands, his leg bouncing, told Mark something was wrong. The words caught in the air, stuck between them like a wall, and Mark was starting to feel like he was trapped on the other side of it.
Peterâs voice cracked, and Markâs heart skipped. He saw it. The way Peterâs hands shook, the way his leg tapped frantically, the slight gloss in his eyes that Peter tried so hard to hide. Peter was on the edge of breaking down, but he was doing everything in his power to keep it together, to keep his walls up. Mark knew that feeling. He recognized it. It was the same one he wore every damn day.
When Peter spoke, his words were harsh, almost defensive, but Mark could hear the cracks underneath. "I'm not running. I'm not scared of anything." But Mark saw it. That wasnât the truth. The shaking, the trembling lip, the way Peterâs eyes kept avoiding him. The truth was slipping through the cracks in his defenses.
Peter said he wasnât scared, but Mark could hear it in his voice, see it in the way his body tensed up. He could almost smell itâfear. Fear of something bigger than either of them could handle.
âIâm not hiding from you,â Peter said, and the words didnât even make it out like they were supposed to. Mark could hear the hesitation. The vulnerability. Peter was lying to himself. But Mark wasnât about to call him out on itânot yet, anyway. Heâd been there before, too. He understood what it was like to keep those walls up, to lock everything inside until it made you want to suffocate.
But then Peter spoke again. His words cut through the thick air like a knife, too sharp to ignore. "And I shut down when we're close because I don't like you, Hoffman. You do nothing but-"
Peter stopped himself, and Mark felt the weight of the words that hadn't been finished. The ones that lingered like a shadow, threatening to reveal something deeper than just anger or confusion. Something that could change everything.
Markâs pulse raced. He wanted to push him further, demand to know what Peter had really meant, but he knew better than to rush it. It wasnât the time for that. Still, the words hung in the air, heavy, suffocating. You do nothing but... what?
Markâs eyes softened just slightly as he watched Peter's lip, the blood starting to drip again. Peter didnât wipe it away, didnât even move his hand. It was like he wanted to bleed, wanted to feel it. Wanted to show Mark that he wasnât as cold as he kept pretending to be.
Mark knew the feeling too well. It was a strange sort of comfort to know that Peter was hurting, too. As fucked up as it sounded, it was a relief to know Peter wasnât the stone wall he tried so hard to be. And maybe, just maybe, Mark could find a way in. Even if it scared the hell out of him.
âPeterâŠâ Markâs voice was softer now, almost hesitant, as if he was treading carefully through the words. He didnât want to break Peter any more than he already was, but he couldnât stand watching him fight this on his own.
Mark reached out by putting his arm on the centre console, just slightly, his fingers brushing the air near Peterâs hand, though he didnât touch him. He wasnât sure if Peter would pull away or not. He wasnât sure if Peter even wanted him near.
But the words that followed from Peter hit Mark like a punch to the gut. âI donât like you.â And it stung more than anything Mark could have expected. He knew Peter wasnât ready for anything else, but that hurt. Hurt more than he wanted to admit.
Mark leaned back in his seat, his heart pounding in his chest. He couldnât let Peter see the effect those words had on him, but it felt like a thousand knives had pierced through his chest all at once.
âRight.â Markâs voice was tight, holding back something deep inside. No, Peter. You donât just shut down and say you donât like me and expect me to walk away.
But Mark didnât say that. He didnât push. He couldnât. Not yet. The words Peter had left unfinished were eating away at him, though. The silence was deafening.
And in that silence, Mark could feel itâthe shift, the crack in Peterâs armor. Peter might not have been ready to admit anything, but Mark could see it now. He could see the truth bleeding through, and he wasnât going anywhere.
Not yet.
They drove in silence for a few more moments, the tension between them almost unbearable. Then, finally, they pulled into the parking lot of the station. The headlights cut through the night, casting long shadows across the concrete. The sound of the engine slowing to a stop filled the car, but neither of them made a move to get out immediately.
Mark just sat there for a second, his eyes still on Peter. He could feel the weight of the moment hanging between them, almost like it was going to shatter if either of them spoke again.
After what felt like an eternity, Mark exhaled quietly and opened the door. "Weâre here," he said, his voice barely above a whisper. He didnât know what else to say. He didnât know how to fix what had been broken, or if it could even be fixed at all. All he knew was that he wasnât leaving yet.
Peter noticed his arm on the center console, moving his arm away quickly. Quicker than he'd ever moved away from Mark. His movements were like a scared injured animal. Quick to escape the touch that could save him. The touch that could fix him.
Strahm completely dissociated, staring out to the cars. The blood continued down his chin, reaching the bottom before he finally wiped it off with a quick movement of his arm. The arm farthest from Mark. Seeming like he was trying to hide he could move at all.
He stayed in his thoughts, trying his best to breathe through his walls finally breaking. They couldn't break. He couldn't let a new person into his mind, anything could happen.
His brain flooded with thoughts. They were all about Hoffman. What if he was starting to hate him? What if he was right? He's only trying to help. For once, he's being a good person and I just can't soak it in. Maybe I'm just a horrible person. He's probably beginning to hate me now. He probably-
Suddenly, Mark's voice pulled him out of the thoughts.
He looked at Hoffman and quickly nodded, leaving his car and locking it before speed walking to the office. As soon as he made it inside, he packed up everything at his desk he brought in. He had to leave, and he had to leave now.
Hoffman sat there for a second, watching Strahmâs back as he disappeared inside. He could still see the tension in his posture, the way his shoulders curled in like he was trying to shrink himself down, trying to vanish into the walls.
Mark exhaled, shaking his head as he rubbed his hand over his mouth.
This was spiraling. Fast.
He should just let him go. Let Strahm run himself ragged, let him pack up, let him storm out of the office and pretend none of this ever happened. Itâd be the easy thing to do. Itâd be the smart thing to do.
But Mark was shit at doing the smart thing when it came to Peter.
With a grunt, he pushed open the car door and got out, walking toward the building. His steps were heavy, purposeful, his jaw set as he shoved through the front doors.
Strahm was already at his desk, movements frantic, throwing his stuff into his bag like he was trying to outrun something. Maybe himself.
Mark lingered in the doorway for a moment before finally stepping forward.
âYou leaving or running?â His voice was level, but there was an edge beneath it.
Mark scoffed, stepping closer. âYou text me, drag me over here, and now youâre bolting? What the hell was this, Peter?â
He wasnât even sure what he wanted Strahm to say. He just wanted him to say something. Anything.
Mark clenched his jaw. Fine. If Strahm wanted to run, let him. But Mark wasnât going to stand there like an idiot, waiting for an answer that would never come.
âForget it,â he muttered, turning on his heel to leave.
Strahm put his bag over his shoulder, rushing to stand next to Hoffman. "Listen... I want to talk to you about.." He thought about how to word what they had going. "This. About me running. Just follow me so we can get it over with."
Peter said as he pulled a cigarette out of his pocket, placing it in my mouth as he searched for a lighter while he walked. He never smoked. He hadn't smoked in awhile, actually. He always just... carried one around. It was a habit from years ago he never let go.
As soon as he stepped out, he lit the cigarette.
What was he going to say? Sorry for being confused? Sorry for letting his anger get the best of him? Sorry for being the man Hoffman fell in love with? He couldn't wrap his head around an idea.
He stood with his jaw clenched in the cold as he waited for Mark who soon followed behind him. It was time to confront his emotions for once in his life.
For once, he almost felt in control of his emotions.
Hoffman watched Strahm fumbling for a lighter, his movements sharp, tense. He never smokedâMark knew that. At least, not anymore. So why now?
With a sigh, Mark reached into his jacket pocket, pulling out his own cigarette and lighter. He flicked it open, the flame casting a small, flickering glow between them. Instead of lighting his own first, he held it out toward Strahm, his gaze steady.
âHere.â.
The small gesture felt heavier than it should have, almost like a truce.
Mark lit his own cigarette next, inhaling deeply before exhaling a slow stream of smoke into the cold night air. He leaned against the hood of a nearby car, watching Peter through the haze.
âSo,â he exhaled. âTalk.â
His voice was even, but there was something else beneath itâsomething unreadable.
Mark shuffled in place, taking a long drag like the nicotine would give him the words he couldnât find. His fingers twitched slightly as he held the cigarette, the cold air making the smoke curl around them like a ghost of something unspoken.
He wasnât going to let Peter run from thisânot this time.
dear hoffman
are you okay. mentally. like how are you man.
mentally? could be worse. physically? also could be worse.
Mark. if you were stuck in a closet with Peter for ten minutes what would happen.
would it get sexual or would someone die.
ten minutes? thatâs a lot of time to get creative. why not both?
let's just say Strahm wouldn't walk out the same.
every time i see u i lick the screen
didnât realize i was that irresistible. carefulâyou might wear out your screen.
Peter walked into the station holding a laptop bag and a big silver cup of coffee. It was very obvious he didn't get much sleep, like usual.
[ - @detstrahm ]
[ ooc text : i've never done an rp on tumblr so sorry if this starter sucks !!! ]
Mark Hoffman stands near his desk, eyes narrowing as Strahm enters the room. He takes in the sight of the tired detective, the coffee in his hand, and the laptop bag slung over his shoulder. Hoffman straightens slightly, his face betraying no emotion as he watches Strahm move to his desk.
"You look like you haven't slept in days, Strahm. Tiredness isn't a badge of honor. Itâs a weakness."
He leans back in his chair, his arms folding across his chest, his gaze unwavering as he watches Strahmâs every move.
"If youâre planning to continue running on fumes, itâs only a matter of time before it catches up to you. You should know better than anyone what happens when you lose focus."
His tone is harsh, but there's an edge to it, as if he's quietly daring Strahm to respond, or perhaps waiting for a crack in the other man's usually composed demeanor.
[NO I LOVE IT!! LMK IF THIS IS TOO MUCH HEJEEJEJEJ]
"Not that it's any of your concern, but I'm fine."
Strahm stopped walking as he spoke, looking back to Hoffman over his shoulder with a cold gaze that could definitely kill him if looks really could kill.
"Your snarky comments aren't going to affect me, I'm not a child."
His voice was firm yet calm, making it obvious that he wasn't trying to cause a scene this early into his shift. It was so hard to do anything with Hoffman just a couple steps away from him.
Hoffman smirked to himself, tapping his pen idly against a stack of paperwork before finally dragging his gaze up to meet Strahmâs glare.
"You sure about that?" His voice was slow, almost amused. "Because Iâve seen you get flustered over a lot less."
He leaned back in his chair, letting the words settle, watching for the inevitable reaction. Hoffman raised a brow, the corner of his mouth twitching like he was resisting the urge to really twist the knife. "Not that itâs any of my concern, of course."
And just like that, he went back to his paperwork, acting like the conversation was already over, though he was more than ready for whatever Strahm had to say next-- almost if in anticipation.
Peter took a deep breath as he walked over to Hoffman's desk, leaning over to whisper in his ear instead of yelling. It seemed like the most mature choice.
"Listen here, asshole. I am in no mood to deal with your shit today."
His tone was sharp as if he was an angry dog barking back at Mark. No matter how hard he tried to ignore Hoffman, he always came up with something to say that just pushed his limits.
He tugged on the collar of the other male's shirt, pulling him closer so his mouth was almost touching his ear.
"Leave me the fuck alone, Hoffman."
He growled in Mark's ear, pushing himself away from him with a stern look on his face.
Hoffman barely reacted as Strahm yanked him closer, his breath hot against his ear, voice laced with frustration. The smirk that tugged at the corner of his mouth was slow, deliberateâbecause this was interesting.
For a moment, he didnât say anything, just let the tension settle between them. Then, in a voice just low enough for only Peter to hear, he finally spoke.
"Careful, Strahm." Smooth, almost teasing. "You keep getting this close, people might start talking."
His gaze flickered downâjust brieflyâto where Strahmâs fingers had gripped his collar. Then, just as lazily, he reached for the cup sitting next to him. It wasnât the usual station sludge, but something sweeter, something indulgent, the faint scent of caramel mixing with the deeper, familiar notes of his cologneâcedarwood, leather, something subtly sharp beneath it all.
He took a slow sip, his smirk deepening just slightly as he finally met Strahmâs glare again.
"But heyâmessage received." His tone was light, almost amused. But there was something else beneath it, something unreadable.
[not me sprinkling in some hoffman hcs lol.]
The more Mark spoke, the more it seemed to anger Strahm. He hated how easy it was for Mark to anger him with just a tone of voice or a simple sentence.
"God, fuck off." Peter basically stormed off to his desk, throwing himself into the chair. As he logged into his computer to actually start working, he couldn't stop thinking about Hoffman.
Usually, that would be normal. Today it was different though. Instead of thinking about how much he hated him, he started thinking about these small details about him. Like how his hair looked more brushed through then normally, or how the scent stuck on his body was weirdly calming.
It was weird, but he couldn't stop thinking about it.
It's like Hoffman put a spell on him.
Hoffman watched Strahm go, lifting his cup to his lips again, taking an unhurried sip. The taste of caramel lingered, mixing with the sharper bitterness beneath it.
That was too easy.
Strahm could throw himself into his chair all he wanted, could scowl at his screen and pretend to focus, but Hoffman knew. He knew. Because that reaction? That wasnât just anger. That was something else, something tangled up in frustration and confusion and whatever the hell was flickering behind those glares.
He swirled the drink absently in his cup, gaze flicking toward Strahmâs desk. Then, without looking directly at him, he spokeâjust loud enough to carry across the room.
"You sure you want me to fuck off, or do you just like telling me what to do?"
Hoffman smirked against the rim of his cup, taking another slow sip, letting his pursed lips linger on the rim. Letting the words settle.
Peter's hands froze and his computer as he took a moment to let himself process what Mark just said. Instead of freaking out, or yelling, or even getting out of his seat, he responded calmly. He hated to egg Hoffman on with his emotions.
"Do your damn work, Hoffman. Might do you some good."
Strahm placed his head in his hands for a moment to recollect himself before continuing to work in silence, using his screen to hide from looking at anyone even near him.
He didn't understand this feeling. It was a strange mixture of so many things and emotions he hasn't felt since early college. Whatever it was, Hoffman was enjoying using it against him.
The teasing worked, but god he wish it didn't.
Hoffman finally, finally turned his attention to the files on his desk, though his focus was shot to hell. His eyes moved over the words, but they barely registered. The conversationâthat look Strahm had given him before burying himself in his screenâwas still fresh, playing in his mind like a puzzle he hadnât quite solved yet.
He tapped his fingers against the desk, considering. There was something satisfying about watching Strahm try so hard to keep himself in check, to act like none of this was getting to him. Hoffman knew better.
The corner of his mouth twitched as he flipped a page, not bothering to hide the smirk creeping in. He took another sip of his drink, the sweetness coating his tongue, lingering.
Maybe he should get back to work.
Or maybe he should push just a little moreâjust to see how long Strahm could keep pretending.
Strahm tapped his pen on his desk to a rhythm he had just made up in his mind since that seemed to be the only thing that could replace his thoughts about Hoffman.
Everything reminded him of Mark, it's like he couldn't escape him. He couldn't even focus on his work, which really bothered him. Usually, his work was the one distraction that always worked, but clearly not today.
Peter sighed before standing up and dropping his pen down onto his desk. He ran his hands down his outfit before walking away to the bathroom with his head down the whole time.
He needed an escape. He needed a way to get away from Mark, even just for a couple minutes.
He opened the door to the bathroom, making sure nobody was in there before walking to the sink and turning on cold water. Strahm collected a small amount of water on his hands and splashed it on his face, staring at himself in the mirror. Why was this happening now?
Hoffman didnât look up right away, but he felt the shift. The absence. The way the air around him suddenly felt⊠quieter.
Strahm was gone.
No presence lingering just a few feet away, no rhythmic tapping of a pen, no barely restrained exhale of frustration. The space he left behind felt noticeable in a way Hoffman didnât care to dwell on.
His fingers drummed idly against the desk as he stared at the open file in front of him. He wasnât reading it. His focus was elsewhere, stuck on somethingâor someoneâthat wasnât even in the damn room anymore.
Hoffman sighed, rolling his shoulders before forcing himself back to his work. Strahm would be back.
And when he was, Hoffman wasnât sure if heâd say anything at allâjust that heâd be aware, too aware, of the moment Strahm walked back through that door.
Strahm continued to stare at himself, a look of confusion forming on his face as he stared.
Who was he right now?
He could normally focus on his work with no struggle, but today was just so different. The tension that formed drove him mad. It didn't make any sense, he didn't feel these things last week, so what's so different now?
Peter began to get angry at everything, especially his thoughts. The water still running, the footsteps outside, the talking of his coworkers, the door to the females restroom opening and closing, everything.
He couldn't take it. Strahm punched the bathroom counter, turning the sink off before storming out of the bathroom and back to his seat.
He tried so hard to get on task but with Hoffman around, it would be hard.
The sound of Strahmâs chair scraping against the floor pulled Hoffmanâs attention before he even meant to look at the other man.
Back already.
He didnât watch himânot openly, at least. Whatever that little break had been, it clearly hadnât helped.
Hoffman finally, finally turned his attention to the files in front of him, though his focus was still half elsewhere. He flipped a page, then spoke, his tone casual.
âYou see the new evidence on the Jigsaw case yet?â A beat. Then, with a glint of playfulness in his eyes, he added, âLooks like our guyâs getting smarter.â
Strahm coughed, opening one of the many files on his desk and writing something quick down in pen. "I heard they found a small strand of hair at a scene. They sent it in to get it tested and a DNA read." He sighed. "Seems useless though. It's a strand of hair that was next to a victim, it was probably theirs."
He wasn't doing very well at trying to seem like he calmed down. Peter never denied small things like this unless he was just talking to talk.
He didn't understand how Hoffman was so casual right now. Does he not feel the tension right now? is he really that dumb?
Hoffman didnât look up right away. He turned a page in his file, scanning the words like they mattered more than Strahmâs obvious frustration. âCould be useless,â he said, almost offhandedly. âOr it could be exactly what we need.â
There was no real argument in his toneâjust something thoughtful, maybe even knowing, like he wasnât as dismissive of the lead as Strahm was.
He finally shifted, glancing at Strahm as if noticing him for the first time since he sat back down. His gaze flicked over him brieflyâtaking in the tension still lingering in his shoulders, the way his grip on his pen was just a little too tight.
And then, something caught his attention. The way the dim overhead light hit just right, outlining the sharp line of Strahmâs jaw, the faintest crease between his brows. Had he always clenched his jaw like that when he was thinking? It wasnât just irritationâit was focus, frustration, something deeper that Hoffman couldnât quite pin down.
For a second, he nearly forgot what he was about to say. He forced himself to look back down at his file, masking the moment with an easy shrug.
âLong morning?â His voice was low, almost conversational. But there was something in the way he said itâsomething that made it impossible to tell if he was just making small talk or if he already knew the answer.
Strahm aggressively wrote stuff down in the files, taking small breaks to collect his thought before continuing to write.
"Bad traffic. Bad night." His tone was firm and aggressive, but not on purpose. He spoke quickly which made it obvious it was a lie to get off the topic of anything but work.
He glanced up at Hoffman and froze, using this moment to soak in everything about him. The way he looked so calm while focused on his work, the way his hand gently pushed the pen down on the paper, the way his lips looked when he was focused...
Peter bit down onto his bottom lip roughly, definitely leaving small teeth marks on his lip. Simply looking at Mark made him anxious.
Hoffman didnât react right away. He let Strahmâs words sit between them, as if deciding whether or not to be snide.
He kept his focus on the file in front of him, but his mind was elsewhereâstuck on something he couldnât quite shake. The way Strahmâs voice had that edge to it. The way his pen practically carved into the paper, like he needed the distraction.
Then, in his periphery, he caught itâStrahm biting his lip, hard.
Hoffmanâs grip on his pen tightened for a fraction of a second before he forced himself to relax, dragging his eyes back to his work.
He exhaled through his nose, pretending to stay focused on his paperwork, but his mind was already elsewhere. The way Strahm bit his lipâthat sharp press of teeth against skinâwasnât something he shouldâve noticed.
Wasnât something he shouldâve cared about.
But he did.
His jaw tensed as he forced his attention back to the file in front of him, masking any sign of distraction. After a beat of silence, he finally spoke, his voice lower than before.
"Yeah⊠not like sleep does much good anyway."
"I stayed up practically all night trying to put together why they would test that fucking-" He took a deep breath, looking down at his papers. "that damn strand of hair. It just doesn't make much sense."
As much as he tried to focus on his papers, he couldn't. The way his jaw tensed just drew in his attention even more as if it was magic.
Peter continued to bite at his lip, feeling an impending doom for what Hoffman would say next. His voice was just so smooth, it felt like torture in the best way possible.
He tried to pretend to do his work, but it was hard when his eyes couldn't get off of Mark. He felt helpless in this moment and he hated it.
He was supposed to have all the power.
Hoffman didnât need to look up to know Strahm was still watching him. He could feel itâthose damn eyes, like heat searing into the side of his face, making it almost impossible to focus on anything else.
"Yeah," Hoffman murmured, his voice gravelly but calm, "doesnât add up, does it?"
He wasnât just talking about the case. The frustration in Strahmâs toneâit hit something deeper, something Hoffman didnât feel like addressing, not right now.
He finally looked up, his gaze meeting Strahm's, but only for a brief moment. "But thatâs the thing with this case, Strahm. Sometimes itâs not about making sense." His words carried an almost unsettling weight, though he wasnât sure if Strahm would catch on.
His hand paused mid-motion as he noticed Strahmâs biting, that subtle, almost unconscious action. Hoffmanâs brow furrowed slightly, but he quickly dismissed the thought, shaking it off. He had work to do.
"Try to stay focused," he added, his tone unexpectedly softer, though he meant it more to himself than Strahm.
Strahm let out a deep sigh, closing his eyes and swinging his head back for a moment. This was his best attempt at clearing his mind.
"I just hate when they do things without running it past me or Perez first." He whispered, picking his pen back up and beginning to actually work on the case.
He felt like a idiot. For once, he didn't want to be at work. He regretted coming in today, especially because Lindsey wouldn't be here because her family was in town and wanted one day with them.
Peter picked back up the rhythm from earlier with his pen, tapping it more aggressively than before without realizing. At this point, he was just trying to drown out any of his thoughts, even about work.
Hoffman let the comment hang in the air, though something shifted in his posture at the mention of Lindsey. He didnât outwardly show it, but the thought gnawed at him for a split second.
He leaned back in his chair, the sound of Strahmâs aggressive pen tapping filling the otherwise quiet space. The irritation in Strahmâs actions wasn't lost on Hoffman, but the mention of Lindsey caught him off guard. It wasnât like him to care, not like this.
"Youâre right," Hoffman said, his voice controlled, though there was a slight edge to it, "Youâd think they'd at least consult you. But," he paused, the faintest of smirks pulling at the corners of his lips, "youâre better off without distractions anyway."
He didnât know if Strahm would pick up on the shift in his tone, but Hoffman had a feeling his partner wouldn't miss the faint jealousy that had crept in. He wasnât sure why it bothered him, but it did.
His eyes flicked to Strahm for a brief moment, then back to the file in front of him, trying to focus.
"Guess youâre stuck here with me," he added, his tone slipping just enough to hint at something more personal beneath the professional surface.
Peter suddenly stopped tapping his pen at the last comment Mark added, pausing everything he was doing. Something with the tone he used made him feel something different. Something he hasn't felt yet today.
He couldn't sit here with Hoffman with those words just replaying in his head, he had to escape somewhere.
"I'll be back." Strahm said, his words slightly slurring together. He shot up from his seat, speed walking back to the bathroom. There was one other person in there, but he could care less at the moment.
Peter paced back and forth in the bathroom while waiting for the other man to leave the restroom. Luckily, the pacing must've rushed him out. He continued to pace around, pinching at the bridge of the nose.
There's no way Mark hasn't noticed his weird behavior, there's just no way. He didn't understand why he couldn't just suppress his emotions like he normally did. He has been hiding his emotions with ease for years, so what was so different today?
Hoffman stood up by the windowsill, his back leaning against the cool glass, eyes staring at the outside but not really seeing it. His mind kept drifting back to Strahm, and the way heâd snapped, his frustration practically hanging in the air. There was something about it, something that felt... off. He couldnât quite put his finger on it, but it bothered him.
He rubbed a hand over his face, sighing, trying to clear the thoughts clouding his head. His gaze flicked back to Strahmâs empty deskâ God, why was it so unsettling?
Mark didnât let distractions get to him. He wasnât someone who let emotions or anything else interfere with the job. But thisâwhatever this wasâ was messing with his usual routine.
The door creaked slightly, and his eyes darted toward it, but no one was there. Mark was surprised by how much heâd noticed Peterâs absence. He shifted uncomfortably, his fingers curling into a fist around the edge of the windowsill. What the hell was wrong with him? It wasnât like Strahm to just leave like that, and it wasnât like him either to feel... unsettled by it.
âJust focus,â Mark muttered to himself, but his gaze lingered on the door a second longer than necessary. He hadnât realized how much he had started to notice the little things about Strahmâhis sharp movements, his short temper, the way his jaw tensed when he was angry. And then the way heâd left, so abruptly, like he couldnât even get out of the room fast enough.
Mark rubbed the back of his neck and shook his head, pursing his lips in thought.
He wasnât someone who gave a damn about these things. But today felt... different
And that made him uneasy.
Peter leaned up against the bathroom wall, placing his face in his hands. He wanted to stay in the bathroom until he died but sadly, he knew he couldn't. Strahm continued to bite down on his lip until he tasted blood.
"Fucking hell..." He whispered, taking his hands off his face to wipe his lip. He stared down at his hand, looking at the blood that covered a small part of the side of his hand.
Strahm walked over to the sink and rinsed his hand off, watching the water turn a slight red before slipping down the drain. It was a weirdly calming sight.
He soon left the bathroom, avoiding looking at Hoffman the best he could. "I'm going to refill my coffee." Strahm said firmly as he reached for his cup, rushing away from his desk before he could even hear a response.
If he was being completely honest, he was embarrassed. He was embarrassed that he couldn't hide his feelings this time. It was such a weird thing to feel something other than anger or calmness.
Peter grabbed the old coffee pot from the staff room, filling his large silver cup up with the lukewarm coffee. He hated how he couldn't confront Mark about these feelings.
Hoffman noticed it immediatelyâhow Strahm wouldnât look at him, how his movements were just a little too quick, like he couldnât get away fast enough.
He grabbed his cup and rushed off before Hoffman could so much as blink.
He didnât know what heâd expected, but it wasnât⊠that.
For the first time, something about Strahmâs reaction made him hesitate. He knew how to read peopleâhe had toâbut this wasnât the usual sharp-edged frustration he was used to prying out of Strahm. This wasnât Strahm picking a fight or snapping back. It was avoidance.
And for some reason, Hoffman didnât like that.
His fingers drummed against the desk, watching the spot Strahm had just vacated. Part of himâsome small, stupid partâwondered if heâd actually hurt him. The thought unsettled him more than it should have.
He let out a quiet exhale, dragging his focus back to his paperwork. It was nothing. It had to be nothing.
So why did it sit so strangely in his chest?
Peter took a deep breath in the small but strangely calming staff room. Why couldn't he just man up and go do his work? Why was Hoffman such a distraction? There were all these whys in his head with no answer.
He took a swig of the lukewarm coffee, swishing it around his mouth as he let his mind wander some more. He felt so stupid for avoiding Mark. For some strange reason, he felt bad for avoiding Hoffman.
Strahm looked at the shut door and debated ever leaving this room, but sadly he knew he had to. He had to face his problems.
Peter left the staff room with his head up this time, trying his best to look put together and confident. As he walked to his desk he wondered if everyone else in the building could tell he was breaking on the inside.
Hoffman didnât acknowledge Strahmâs return, keeping his eyes trained on the file in front of him. He wasnât really reading itâhis focus was shot to hell.
He was letting his body speak for him in ways he couldnât control. His leg bounced beneath the desk, a steady, impatient rhythm. His fingers tapped soundlessly against the edge of his paper, the only betrayal of his restlessness.
He wanted to look at Strahm. Watch for any flicker of emotion. See if there was still tension in his jaw, if his lip was still raw from biting down too hard. But he didnât. Not yet.
He just waited. If Strahm wanted to pretend nothing happened, fine. But if there was a crackâany sign of itâHoffman would be there, ready to catch it.
Strahm coughed as if trying to warn Hoffman he was back in his seat, pulling open a completely new file to maybe try and focus on something new.
He read every word on the paper, but nothing made sense in his head at the moment. It was weird, but it felt strange without Hoffman's eyes on him. If he was being honest, he missed being looked at from a distance.
"So, have you heard anything about the Jigsaw case?" Peter asked with his face still buried in the case files on his desk. The silence became too much for him to handle and he needed to break it.
He eagerly waited for a response as if his life depended on it, nervously biting his lip once again and continuing to tap his pen to a different rhythm from before.
Hoffman exhaled slowly, dragging his eyes from his paperwork like he was indulging Strahm by giving him attention.
"Nothing new," he said, his voice even. "Just the same dead ends."
He finally glanced at Strahm, taking in the way his lip was caught between his teeth again, the quick, restless tapping of his pen.
He leaned back slightly, studying Strahm a little longer than necessary before forcing himself to look away. As Hoffman finally looked at him, his gaze snagged on something small but noticeableâthe faint trace of dried blood at the corner of Strahmâs lip. It was barely there, but it was enough.
Hoffmanâs fingers twitched slightly, his grip on his pen tightening before he forced himself to loosen it. He shouldnât care. Shouldnât even be looking. But the sight of it made something uneasy settle in his chest. Had Strahm bitten down that hard?
His jaw tensed as he dragged his eyes away. His breath hitched before he could stop it.
The sight of itâsubtle, unintentional, self-inflictedâsent something sharp and hot running through his veins. His fingers curled around his pen, gripping it just a little too tight. He shouldnât be reacting to this. Shouldnât feel the way his pulse quickened, the way his body betrayed him with that sudden, insidious heat curling in his gut.
His composure threatened to slip.
Hoffman exhaled through his nose, his jaw clenching as he forced his expression to stay neutral. His gaze flicked away, back to his paperwork, even though the words on the page were meaningless now.
âWhy?â His voice came out steadyâthankfullyâbut just a fraction lower than before. âYou onto something?â
He kept his head down, pen skimming over the paper in a weak attempt at normalcy, but the damage was already done. He felt it. And worseâhe liked it.
"Not yet. It's getting annoying how we can't get any new leads..." Strahm put his pen down onto his desk, leaning his head back as he let out a long sigh of exhaustion.
Suddenly, he had gotten an idea. Something that would probably calm down the thoughts about Hoffman in his head, but would probably be seen as weird.
At this point, that was the least of his concerns.
"Hey, wanna go somewhere for lunch? We can discuss the case some more." Peter said, his voice was low with a hint of embarrassment. He didn't want to give Mark any ideas of what he actually meant but instead an idea that he actually cared about the Jigsaw case at this moment.
Strahm held his breath while waiting for a response, keeping his eyes focused on the papers on his desk rather than Hoffman to seem relaxed.
He really hoped he was pulling off the whole 'chill' act...
Hoffman didnât answer right away. He sat with it, rolling the idea over in his head, his pen idly tapping against the desk.
Lunch. Alone. With him.
It was easy to pretend that was a normal suggestion. Just two law enforcement officers talking shop. But Strahm had hesitated before asking, and that hesitation stuck with him.
His eyes flicked toward the other man, watching the way he stayed locked onto the papers in front of him like they held the answer to something more than just their case. His fingers curled around his pen a little tighter.
Hoffman wasnât sure why that detail bothered him.
He exhaled through his nose, feigning indifference. âYeah, sure.â His voice was steady, neutral. As if he hadnât spent the last minute overthinking this.
He leaned back in his chair, stretching his legs out, the tension in his muscles betraying his otherwise relaxed posture. His knee bounced once before he stilled it. He didnât like feeling caught off guard.
He finally looked at Strahm again. âWhere?â It wasnât an enthusiastic acceptance, but it also wasnât a rejection. It was something in between.
Peter let out a quiet sigh as soon as Mark answered, gripping at the bridge of his nose as he tried to think of a place nearby that was nice enough to take Hoffman to, but not too nice.
"Well, I heard there's this nice sandwich place that recently opened... we could go there." Strahm suggested, pulling himself out of his work to actually make eye contact with Hoffman.
He noticed small details very quickly. The way a couple strands of hair fell out of his styled hair, the way his eyes were naturally tired looking in such a good way, the way his hand gripped onto his pen, the way he had to stop his leg from bouncing... everything was so perfect it made him sick.
He tried to pull his eyes off of Mark, but he just couldn't. For once, he had an actual excuse to stare at Hoffman. He shouldn't have been as grateful as he was.
Hoffman let a beat of silence pass before tilting his head slightly, finally meeting Strahmâs eyes with something that almost resembled amusement.
âA sandwich place, huh?â he said, tapping his fingers idly against the desk. âDidnât peg you as the type to branch out. Thought you survived purely off burnt coffee and spite.â
There was a slight smirk at the corner of his mouth, but his tone was just casual enough to keep Strahm guessing. It wasnât an outright challenge, but it wasnât nothing, either. Just enough to test the watersâto see if Strahm would roll his eyes, snap back, or keep looking at him like that.
His leg bounced once before he forced it still again, fingers tightening around his pen.
Peter's breathing quickly became regular as soon as Hoffman made eye contact with him, causing him to stumble over his words.
"Well- I-" He paused, collecting his thoughts. "I mostly survive off of cheap burnt coffee, but I'm switching it up for once." A slight smile appeared on his face for the first time today once he realized if he just kept up this calm, non-angry act up, he might survive this shift.
Or, at least he'll try to keep it up. It's hard when he's around Mark.
Strahm reached into his pocket and searched for his card, flipping through random twenties and tens before finally finding it. "I heard it's pretty cheap so I might as well pay for yours." He said, not even noticing how nice he was being.
He was never nice to anyone other than Lindsey really, so this must've been a rare sighting to anyone listening in to the conversation.
"But I'm only paying because it's cheap. I'm not trying to be all nice and shit, so don't get that idea." Of course, he had to ruin the one moment he seemed slightly kind.
Hoffman let out a quiet chuckle, shaking his head as he watched Strahm fumble with his wallet. There was something oddly endearing about itâhow he offered without thinking, only to immediately try to walk it back. It wasnât often that Strahm let something slip through the cracks.
"Generous and cheap. Quite the combination," Hoffman murmured, his voice dipping into something almost warm, almost teasing. He let the words hang between them for a moment before exhaling, running a hand down the sleeve of his jacket as he stood.
His gaze lingered on Strahm just a little longer than necessary, taking in the way he still wouldn't quite meet his eyes. There was a rare ease in the moment, a shift from the usual sharp edges they threw at each other. Hoffman felt it more than he wanted to acknowledge.
"If youâre so insistent," he said, his tone softer now, something almost amused beneath it, "Iâll let you buy me lunch. Just donât expect me to be nice about it."
It wasnât a joke, not really. But it was something. A quiet acceptance, an unspoken truce. And when he stepped just a little closerâjust enough to catch the faintest tension in Strahmâs shouldersâhe couldn't quite fight the smirk that ghosted across his lips.
"Letâs go before you change your mind."
Strahm nodded in agreement, shoving his wallet back in his pocket before standing, straightening out his top with his hands. It was so weird that he suddenly felt a need to look... cleaner around Hoffman.
"Do you want me to drive?" He asked as he began to walk to the front door of the building, reaching a hand into the opposite pocket of his wallet to grip onto his keys, ready for an answer to his question.
Peter tried to walk slightly fast, trying to avoid anyone really seeing him walk outside the building while having an active and normal conversation with Mark.
He didn't want people to think he suddenly grew fond of Hoffman because, if he was being completely honest, he didn't really like the thought of beginning to grow fond of him.
Peter spent all of these years hating Mark just for that to change from one interaction. It felt stupid to him. He felt stupid.
Hoffman followed steadily, letting Strahm put some distance between them. It wasnât hard to pick up on the way Peter was rushing. Like it meant something.
Hoffman didnât call attention to it, but he noticed. He noticed the way Strahmâs fingers curled tightly around his keys, the way he held himself just a little straighter, as if heâd suddenly started caring about how he looked. It was subtle, but it was there.
And for some reason, it was... alluring.
There was a new kind of tension in Strahm, not the usual barely-contained aggression Hoffman was used to. This was something else, something more restrained. He wasnât sure what to make of it yet, but he had the patience to figure it out.
âIâll let you drive,â he finally said, watching Strahm with something just shy of amusement. His voice was even, casual, but his smirk gave away more than he probably intended. He let the moment stretch just a little longer before adding, âJust try not to kill us before we get there.â
A joke, but one that carried weight. A small push. A test.
He walked ahead of Strahm and put a hand in his pocket as he walked.
"I'll try, but it might be hard with you in the car." Peter said, hiding back a smirk as he spoke. He pulled the keys out of his pocket, gripping them tightly in his hand as if someone was going to steal them from him.
As he entered the cold weather outside, his whole body tightened. Strahm had always hated the cold.
He unlocked his car, quickly shoving himself in to try and escape the weather. He switched on the heat in his car before blowing warm air into his hands, waiting patiently for Mark to say something that gave him the idea he was ready for him to start driving.
Peter really hated driving with a person in his car. His road rage usually killed any good energy moving throughout his car in a matter of seconds. Sure, Mark has seen him angry, but not the type of anger he gets while driving.
Plus, he'd really hate to ruin what they had going on at the moment...
Hoffman let out a short chuckle at Strahmâs response, low and almost under his breath. There was something oddly satisfying about the way Peter shot back without missing a beatâlike he was starting to get comfortable with this, whether he wanted to or not.
The cold bit at his skin as he followed Strahm outside, but he barely registered it, too focused on watching the other man move. The tension in his shoulders, the way he practically threw himself into the car to escape the chillâit was little things like that that made Hoffman feel like he was getting a read on him.
He slid into the passenger seat with an easy, unbothered motion, his gaze settling on Strahm as the heat kicked in. The way Peter hunched over his hands, rubbing warmth back into them, was oddly... humanizing. A rare moment where he looked like more than just a sharp edge waiting to cut.
Hoffman leaned back, making himself comfortable before finally breaking the silence. âYou gonna warm up before we get moving, or do I have to listen to you bitch about the cold the whole drive?â His tone was teasing, but his eyes lingered a little too longâtaking in the way Strahmâs lips were still slightly parted from the rush of warm air, the way his fingers flexed against his palms.
Another small test. Another moment to gauge how far this push-and-pull would go.
Strahm smiled, pulling his hands away from his mouth. "You'll have to hear me bitch about a lot during this car ride. The traffic is bad right now." He said as he put his hand on the steering wheel, gripping it tightly.
He started to drive, his attention suddenly going to the road with a straight, serious face. He always took driving very serious, for some strange reason.
Peter tried to seem calm with Mark in the car, but seeing all the cars lined up in the street already made his blood boil. He didn't want to yell at all, but he just knew that would be hard.
"Holy fuck, that's a lot of cars..." He commented, speaking in a low voice that seemed like a grumble or a growl. His voice always sounded so demanding or angry, no matter what mood he was in.
Hoffman settled into his seat, letting his gaze drift lazily over the dashboard before inevitably landing on Strahmâs hands. He had a firm grip on the wheel, fingers tense, knuckles just shy of turning white.
Hoffman had seen Strahmâs hands in plenty of different settingsâclutching a gun, flipping through case files, clenched into fistsâbut there was something about watching them now, wrapped around the wheel with that quiet intensity, that held his attention a little too long.
The way his fingers flexed slightly every time he muttered under his breath, the subtle tremor of agitation when traffic didnât move fast enoughâit was strangely captivating. It made Hoffman wonder, just for a second, how that tension would feel if it werenât directed at the steering wheel.
âTry not to take it personally,â he said finally, tearing his gaze away and shifting in his seat. âPretty sure the traffic isnât out to get you.â His tone was light, almost mocking, but his fingers tapped idly against his own thighâlike he was keeping himself from saying something else.
"It's just so annoying. If people actually knew how to drive then we-" He suddenly stopped himself from talking, giving himself a moment to collect his thoughts. He couldn't go on a stupid rant about people driving. At leastânot in front of Mark.
His eyes slowly drifted towards Hoffman's fingers tapping against his thigh, picking up on the rhythm in his head quickly. He watched as if it was a mind blowing thing, like something he's never seen before. Obviously, he wasn't focused on the rhythm, he was focused on Mark.
The way he tapped so calmly like he was waiting to say something, the way his focus was on the grip of his hand, the way he was somehow so calm and collected on the outside, everything. All of it just seemed so perfect. Too perfect.
Peter soon snapped out of it as soon as he realized the cars around him were moving, and soon became fixated back on the road.
"This place better be good. If I drove in this traffic for no reason, I'll be pissed." He said, beginning to quietly tap the rhythm Mark had been tapping, using it as a way to calm down.
Suddenly, it hit him. He was driving Mark Hoffmanâthe guy who has been driving him insane all dayâout to eat with him. Sure, it wasn't fancy, but it was still something. The thought of this made him go back to biting his lip, leaving a dent over the previous one that just started going away.
Hoffmanâs fingers kept up their steady rhythm against his thigh, but his focus wasnât really on it anymore. His eyes had drifted back to Strahm, watching the way his jaw tensed, the way his grip tightened on the steering wheelâand most of all, the way he kept biting his lip, almost absentmindedly.
He let the moment stretch for a beat longer than necessary before speaking, voice smooth but just pointed enough to be intentional.
"Didn't take you for a nervous habit kind of guy, Strahm. Be careful there."
The words hung in the air, but the way Hoffmanâs gaze lingeredâjust for a secondâmade it clear heâd noticed. He settled back against the seat, watching for a reaction, wondering if Strahm would brush it off or if the slight shift in energy would throw him off course.
Strahm stopped tapping his fingers, looking over to Mark with a confused expression. It took him a moment to realize he was biting down on his lip. Again.
He quickly corrected himself, wiping his lip to see more blood transfer onto his hand. "Fuck..." He whispered to himself, staring down at the wipe of blood on the side of his hand before sighing and simply putting his hand back onto the wheel.
Peter never understood why he did stuff like this knowing it would later on hurt. And he especially didn't understand why he was doing it even more than usual. Normally, he would bite his lip while checking out a crime scene, or holding a gun, but never while simply being around a person.
He soon realized how much power Hoffman held when it came to himself. He could simple say something cocky and it would mess up his whole shift, or even the rest of his day.
"God fucking damn it." He said as he punched the steering wheel, causing his car to honk to the car in front of them.
Great, he did the one thing he was trying not to do. Get mad over a simple thing while in the car.
Hoffmanâs smirk faltered. Just for a second.
He hadnât expected that reactionâhadnât expected Strahm to actually hit the wheel like that. The sharp sound of the horn rang in his ears, but it was the frustration in Strahmâs voice that really caught him off guard.
For all the ways he liked to push, this wasnât what heâd been aiming for.
Hoffman shifted slightly, pulling his gaze away, tapping his fingers against his thigh againâbut this time, it wasnât intentional. It was just something to do. Something to focus on instead of the way Strahmâs knuckles were going white against the steering wheel.
"Forget it," he muttered, quieter than before. "Didnât mean anything by it."
For once, he let the moment pass without another remark. No teasing, no smug little comments. Just silenceâsave for the hum of the car engine and the faint, rhythmic tapping of his fingers.
Was this guilt? He felt guilty for that remark, and Hoffman rarely cares about others like that.
He suddenly felt anxious. He tried to remain suave but his hands shook ever so slightly as he loosened his tie. It was getting slightly hard to breathe.
Strahm had gone completely silent at this point, taking all his anger out by gripping the wheel. If he knew that he would've fucked up the stuff they had going, he would've tried to prevent it.
But he couldn't.
He soon saw the sandwich shop, realizing it was closed. He went through all of this for it to be closed. He sighed and turned into the parking lot anyway, parking the car to think of another place they could go to.
"So... the shop is closed today, I guess." Peter said, his voice quiet and low as if he was confessing something. He felt somewhat bad. He felt bad for taking Hoffman out of work just to find out their plans wouldn't even end up working.
"We could... go somewhere else. Or go back." He paused as he thought of more ideas. "Or we could sit here and talk about the case." He said as a last choice.
Instead of looking over to Hoffman, he stared down at his lap. It didn't feel right to look at him after what just happened. He felt... embarrassed in a way. He knew that if he reacted to something with anger, it would've changed everything. Yet, he did it anyways. He just let it happen.
Hoffman stayed quiet for a moment, letting his eyes settle on Strahm. Really looking at him.
The way his shoulders were still tense, the way his fingers flexed against the steering wheel like he was holding himself back.
Hoffman tapped his fingers one last time before letting his hand still in a gentle grasp against his thigh. He wasnât in a rush to speak.
Instead, he just watched.
There was a strange feeling in Hoffmanâs chest, something he didnât quite have the words for.
After another beat of silence, he finally spoke. "Well," he drawled, tilting his head slightly, "weâve already wasted this much time. Might as well make it worth it."
His voice was even, but there was an edge of something unreadable in it.
Hoffman wasnât sure what he expected Strahm to say next. But he was sure of one thingâhe wasnât ready to leave yet.
"Mhm.." Peter hummed in response, taking his hands off the wheel to try and seem more calm and relaxed. His attention turned to Mark very soon, his eyes hovering over his whole body before meeting his eyes.
He had a strange feeling in his chest every time he looked at Mark. It suddenly felt heavy and felt it got harder to breathe.
The tension in the car was so much more in the office. The way they were much closer than before, the way they had no where else to look but each other, it was all too much. Peter removed his jacket, folding it neatly before setting it down in his lap. Though, he never broke eye contact.
"Have you got anything about the case? Any suspects, any leads, anything? Have you heard anything from the DNA test yet?" Peter decided it would be best to ask a good amount of questions. Then, it would be easier for him to seem less.. awkward and nervous.
Work seemed to be the only thing keeping him sane right now.
Hoffman didnât miss the way Strahm folded his jacketâcareful, deliberate, like he needed to keep his hands occupied. It was almost amusing, the way he tried to seem at ease when everything about him screamed tightly wound.
He let the moment stretch, saying nothing at first. Just watching.
âCouple of things,â he said finally, voice level, unreadable, clearing his throat. âDNA test came back inconclusive. No solid matches.â
Hoffman let that sit between them, waiting to see how Strahm would react.
Mark shifted in his seatâ just enough to take up more space, his arm settling on the center console. Closer.
âThereâs one lead,â Hoffman continued, deliberately unhurried. âGuy who fits the profileâex-con, history of violence, used to work in mechanical engineering.â
Another pause. Then, finally, Hoffman turned his head, meeting his gaze fully.
âYou all right, Strahm?â His voice was smooth, casual, but he knew exactly what he was doing.
Hoffman could feel itâthe tension, the weight pressing down on the space between them. And he liked it.
At first his maintained eye contact, but that proved to be too much for him so he backed off, clearing his throat again.
âIâm not trying to make you nervous.â A lie, and also deflecting some of his own feelings.
"What? I'm fine. I'm not nervous at all, Hoffman." Peter responded, his words sharp and aggressive. He didn't realize until now how tense and nervous his body language was. He shoulder tensed, his jaw clenched, his hands always forming a fist, everything was not normal.
He hated the power Mark held over him. It made him so angry to the point of nausea. Every time Mark did anything better than him, he got jealousâangry. Every time Mark looked at him, he got nervous. He hated the way he just let this happen.
Strahm took a deep breath, placing his arm right next to Hoffman's. "Well, at least we've got something. It's better than what we had before." He said, his voice was very monotoneâdry even.
"I should probably call Perez soon and tell her about this..." Peter said, tapping his finger to a different rhythm than before. It was more aggressive and repetitive, showing both his anger and anxiety in one rhythm.
The way his and Mark's arms were so close made him feel something he couldn't explain. It made it hard to breathe, as if someone were to suck all the air out of his lungs.
[ ooc text : i wrote the second part of this while listening to jealousy, jealousy by olivia rodrigo. feels important to share. ]
Hoffman watched him carefully, his expression unreadable. Strahmâs words were sharp, but they didnât match the way his body was betraying himâso tense he looked ready to snap. Hoffman could practically feel the heat radiating off him, the way his energy buzzed with something dangerously close to frustration. Or something else.
His eyes flicked down to their arms, barely a breath apart. It would take nothing to close that distance. To shift just slightly and press against him, just to see what Strahm would do.
Then Strahm mentioned Perez.
Hoffmanâs fingers, which had been resting idly against his thigh, curled inward before he abruptly moved his arm away, leaning slightly toward the car door. His expression didnât change, but something in his body language didâsomething colder.
"Yeah," he muttered. "You probably should."
Hoffman clenched his jaw, staring straight ahead as if the windshield suddenly held something more interesting than Strahm beside him. The mention of Perez shouldnât bother him, but it did. He knew how much Strahm trusted herâhow easily they worked together, how she could read him in ways Hoffman couldnât.
He didnât like it.
His fingers twitched against his leg, resisting the urge to match Strahmâs rhythm like before. Instead, he let the silence stretch, letting the distance he created sit heavy between them.
âWant some space to call her?â
Strahm noticed how Hoffman tensed as soon as he mentioned Perez, a look of confusion quickly forming on his face. Why did Mark get so weird every time he mentioned Lindsey? Why did he act so weird whenever she was at his desk? It made no sense.
He looked down to see his arm moved away, a feeling of defeat washing over him. They were so close, it was perfect. But clearly, he messed something up to changed the tension they had going for them.
"Uhm, no... I'll just call her later today. She's probably busy anyway, and I don't want to interrupt her." Peter said, slowly removing his arm and placing it onto his lap. He stared at Hoffman, noticing how he would rather stare at nothing then stare at him. Why did it change so quickly?
He coughed, trying to stop the silence between the two. "What should we do?" He asked, trying to use a tone that suggested that he was open to anything, work related or not. At this point, he'd be willing to do anything to get out of this uncomfortable situation.
Strahm started to pick at the sides of his fingernails, messing up his already rough looking fingers. He watched as a small amount of blood formed on his finger once he peeled some skin off, watching it build up but not drip.
It was better to watch than continuing to watch Mark stare out the windshield as if it was much more interesting.
Hoffman exhaled, letting the tension ease from his shoulders as he settled back into his seat. His arm found its way back to the consoleânot quite touching Strahmâs, but close enough that it wasnât a full retreat anymore.
"Alright," he said, tilting his head slightly as if considering their options. "We could hit up that shitty diner a few blocks over. The one with the terrible coffee but decent fries." He shot Strahm a sideways glance, a ghost of a smirk tugging at his lips. "Unless youâre too good for a place that serves their food on plastic trays."
It wasnât just about food anymore, and they both knew it. Hoffmanâs posture was more open again, his voice lacking the sharp edge from earlier.
"And hey," he added, his smirk sharpening just slightly, "maybe if you're lucky, the waitress will think weâre on a date and give you the check. Since, y'know, you were so eager to take me out in the first place."
It was a joke, but not a denial. And the way he looked at Strahm when he said itâsteady, watching for a reactionâmade it clear he wasnât just filling the silence.
âOr maybe one of us can flash our badge and make her feel bad.â He winked. A soft, brief action.
A smirk appeared on Strahm's face, looking up from his hand and back to Hoffman. "I'm fine with the shitty diner, I guess." He said with a hint of sarcasm in his voice at the end.
"And I think we should go with the second idea. Flashing our badges is better than her thinking we're a gay couple." Peter said as he began to start driving, but this time only with one arm. Keeping his arm next to Mark's felt... right.
He began driving out of the parking space, making a promise in his mind that he wouldn't get visibly angry at the people on the road. He would hate to ruin the tension for the hundredth time today. Peter bit down on his lip slightly, mainly doing it to keep his focus on the road.
Peter took a deep breath as soon as he got on the road, trying to seem like he didn't even care about the traffic, but he did. He really did. He actually cared about everything right now. The traffic, the way Hoffman's arm was right next to his, the fact he was driving him to a diner, everything. It all was so much more than it would normally be, but he stayed calm.
At least, he tried to stay calm.
Hoffman stood just outside the diner's entrance, the neon light flickering against his skin, casting him in a glow of red and gold. He flexed his fingers at his sides, still feeling the lingering warmth from where their arms had brushed in the car. It was stupidâinsignificant, really. But it had made something stir deep in his chest, something he wasnât ready to acknowledge.
He glanced over his shoulder, watching Strahm still sitting in the driverâs seat, his fingers tapping against the wheel. For a moment, Hoffman just⊠looked at him. The usual irritation was there, sure, but it was layered with something else, something heavier. He exhaled, shaking his head to himself before rapping his knuckles lightly against the glass door.
"You coming?" His voice was lower than he intended, softer, almost coaxing. He hesitated, then let a smirk tug at his lips. "Or do you just like staring at me from a distance?"
He turned before he could catch Strahmâs expression, stepping inside the diner. The scent of coffee and fryer grease wrapped around him, familiar and grounding. Still, that warmth from the car lingered, settling deep in his chest. As much as he tried to ignore it, deny it, there was no shaking the truthâsomething between them had shifted. And for once, Hoffman wasnât sure if he wanted to fight it.
Peter sighed before slipping his coat on, finally leaving his car. He made sure to lock his car before walking over to the diner with the neon flickering lights. This is not where he exactly wanted to take Mark, but guess that's what he had to deal with for now.
He stepped inside, walking past Hoffman to a small booth all the way in the corner of the diner. He sat in the seat against the wall, waiting patiently for Mark to sit across from him.
It was weird to think about. Taking the man he hated out to get food. Sure, he invited him to talk about 'work' , but they both knew that wasn't going to actually happen. At least, not the whole time.
"I don't really know if I'll eat anything here. Hell, they probably cook dead rats into the food based on what people say about it." Peter said, looking around to see most employees sitting on their phones or talking. Sure, this wasn't ideal, but it would work just fine.
After all, he didn't want things to seem romantic. Peter didn't like Mark that way.
At least, that's what he told himself.
Hoffman leaned back against the cracked vinyl seat, drumming his fingers against the tabletop as he glanced over the laminated menu. It was sticky. Of course it was. He barely looked at the options before setting it aside.
"Dead rats or not, Iâm getting a shake," he said, flagging down a half-interested waitress. "Chocolate. Extra thick." His voice was smooth, deliberate, like he was making a point. He didn't care if the place was a dumpâhe was here, and he was going to enjoy something.
Once the waitress walked off, he leaned forward slightly, resting his forearms on the table. His gaze flicked over Strahm, taking in the tension in his shoulders, the way he was still pretending like this wasnât something. It was almost endearing.
"You know, if you keep looking that uncomfortable, people are gonna think I dragged you here against your will." His smirk was slow, knowing. "Or worse, that this actually is a date and you're just playing hard to get."
He let that sit between them, watching for the reaction. Strahm always had a tell, no matter how much he tried to hide it. And Hoffman? He lived for it.
Peter hummed in response to Mark, quickly shaking his head once the waiter looked at him with a look of boredom and impatience, waiting for an order. He sighed as soon as the waiter walked off, shutting his eyes for a moment before opening them to meet Mark leaned more towards him.
"I would way rather have them think you kidnapped me or something. I don't want people to think we're on a date. Or that I'm gay." As soon as he spoke those last four words, it hurt something in him. He didn't understand why though. He wasn't gay. That's what he's been telling everyone for years.
These feelings were so confusing. He hated Hoffman, he knew he did. Something was... different. Usually, he would be tearing his hair out by nowâbut it was different now. He was less angry.
Strahm tried to relax his shoulder, but failed. He hated how much he seemed so nervous and shut off when he wanted to seem relaxed. He wanted to seem more normal, but that was hard when he wasn't normal even when hating Mark.
Hoffman let out a quiet snort, shaking his head slightly as he leaned back again, giving Strahm just a bit more spaceâbut not much.
âRelax, Strahm,â he muttered, voice low and edged with amusement. âNo one in here gives a shit about what you are.â His fingers drummed idly against the table as he watched the way Peterâs shoulders stayed locked in place, the tension rolling off of him in waves.
That reactionâthat was interesting. It wasnât just irritation or the usual disdain that Strahm carried whenever he was around him. This was something else. Hoffman bit his lip in thought.
Hoffman tilted his head slightly, his eyes scanning Strahmâs face, catching the way his mouth pressed into a tight line, the way his fingers curled against his thigh like he was trying to hold something back.
He could push. It would be easy. A well-placed comment, a teasing smirk, just enough of a prod to see what would happen if he hit the right nerve.
But, for once, he didnât.
Instead, he exhaled, shaking his head as he reached for his glass of water, taking a slow sip before setting it back down. âBesides, if I did kidnap you, Iâd make sure you at least got something better than a damn sandwich out of it.â
The words were casual, thrown out with just enough humor to make it unclear whether he was joking or not. But underneath, it was a testâa different kind of test. Would Strahm push back? Laugh it off? Or would he keep unraveling right in front of him?
Peter felt like he was melting away. He was so focused on what other people around him thought. People he would most likely never even see again. The idea of a random stranger thinking something that wasn't true made him freak out. What if he actually saw them again and they thought he was something he wasn't? What if that made people avoid him? He hated it.
"Yeah. Sure." He mumbled, looking over Mark's shoulder for a second to scan the whole diner and all the workers. Another habit he had to avoid a situation. This time, the situation was right in front of himâstaring with a smirk that showed that he was clearly interested by Peter's reactions to things.
He looked down at his lap, fixing the previous creases he made in his pants from gripping them. It was weird, he felt a sudden need to look nice. Normally, if he was at work, he never cared. It was just work after all. Today thoughâit was different. Very different.
"Oh, so if you were to kidnap someone, you would cook them a full meal?" Strahm asked with a hint of sarcasm in his voice, trying to come across as more calm and relaxed. His tone was calm, but his body language was completely different. His body language resembled a stray cat whenever you try to pet it. Tense, intimidating, aggressive.
He didn't mean to come off like this, but it was better than coming off nice, or worseâromantic. Which sucked, because deep down there was something going on. Something other than hate or anger. But different from what he felt around Lindsey...
Hoffman let out a low chuckle, shaking his head as he leaned back slightly, arms crossing over his chest. âWhat, you think Iâd half-ass it?â His smirk remained, but his gaze was steady, watching every nervous shift, every flicker of hesitation in Strahmâs expression.
Hoffman tilted his head slightly. âIâm just saying, if I were the kind of guy to kidnap someone, Iâd at least put in the effort. Full meal. Maybe some wine. Make it a whole experience.â His voice was even, casual, but the weight behind his words lingered in the space between them.
He let the thought settle for a moment before reaching for his drink, taking another slow sip. âNot that youâd appreciate it,â he added, tone bordering on dry amusement. âYou strike me as the type to complain about the wine pairing.â
He was still testing, still pushingâjust enough to see how Strahm would react.
"Well, I believe that it would be a bit stupid to make a full meal. You don't want the person you kidnapped to get attached to you. That'll just cause so many more problems." Strahm said as if he had experience in stuff like this. Obviously, he didn't. It was more of the fact that he's dealt with multiple situations like this.
Peter's voice was less aggressive, finally showing that some of the tension and stress had left his body. It felt like heavy sandbags being lifted off his shoulders, giving him the ability to finally seem a bit more confinement rather than stuck in his own skin.
"Of course I complain about wine pairing. It's basically everything when it comes to a nice meal! Tell me, would you pair a glass of Pinot Noir with a steak? No. You would pair something like Cabernet Sauvignon." It was obvious he was good at this subject. Which you probably wouldn't guess by getting one simple look at him.
Peter checked his watch, quickly looking back up to Mark. "We should probably head back soon." He said, putting his coat over his arms as quickly, basically preparing himself to leave in a quick amount of time.
Hoffman raised an eyebrow, watching Strahm with something between amusement and intrigue. The shift in his demeanor didnât go unnoticedâhis voice had lost some of that earlier edge, his posture a little less rigid. It was subtle, but it was there.
âDidnât take you for a wine guy,â Hoffman mused, tilting his head slightly. âThatâs a real specific take for someone who spends most of his days running on burnt coffee.â His smirk lingered, but there was something else in his gaze nowâsomething considering.
He didnât know why it was so damn fascinating, watching Strahm loosen up, even just a little. Maybe it was because he knew how rare it was. Strahm was all sharp edges and tension, always coiled like a spring. Seeing him talk about something so mundane, something he actually seemed passionate about, was... different.
Hoffman exhaled through his nose, glancing at his own watch before rolling his shoulders back. âYeah, wouldnât want anyone thinking we actually enjoyed this.â The words were teasing, but there was an undertone to themâsomething unspoken but lingering.
As Strahm pulled on his coat with that same urgency, Hoffman just watched him for a moment before finally moving to stand. He didnât rush. He didnât need to. Strahm was already rattled enough without him adding to it.
But still, as they stepped outside into the cold, he let the silence settle just long enough to make Strahm wonder what he was thinkingâbefore finally breaking it with a low, amused murmur:
âYou talk a big game about wine pairings, but next time, Iâm picking the place.â
He paused for a moment, thinking if he should even offer but he did, anyways: âWant me to drive the way back?â He asked, staring ahead.
"Really? I'm a pretty big wine guy. Me and Perez tend to talk about it a lot, I guess you just don't hear us." He found himself bringing up Lindsey again. He knew that it wasn't a good idea. He knew that everything would shift once again after bringing her up. Yet, he still did it.
He sighed before walking over to the waiter, putting down a random ten dollar bill from his wallet before walking outside into the cold with Hoffman. The cold hit him like a punch, causing him to exhale a deep breath.
"Well, I wasn't going to bring you to a place where they pair wine to discuss work, Mark." The comment was supposed to come off playful, but instead came off harsh. He always struggled to control his tone, which was the reason he spoke with such a monotone, bored voice.
Peter unlocked the car doors, looking over to Mark. "Yeah, sure. It'll be better for you to drive anyway." He said, getting in the car before discussing anything else. He would rather die than stand a moment longer in the cold weather.
Hoffmanâs jaw tightened at the mention of Perez. Of course, Strahm had to bring her up. He always did, like it was some kind of reflex. And every time, it hit Hoffman the same wayâan irritating little twist in his gut that he couldn't quite shake.
He didnât say anything right away, just let his eyes linger on Strahm as they stepped out into the cold. The wind bit at his skin, but he barely registered it. He was too busy watching the way Strahm hunched his shoulders, the way he exhaled sharply like the cold was trying to rip the breath from his lungs.
Hoffman scoffed at the comment about work, catching the way Strahm avoided looking directly at him. Yeah, sure. You werenât gonna bring me to a place like that for work. But youâd bring Perez, wouldnât you?
He didnât voice the thought. Instead, he followed Strahm into the car, sliding into the driverâs seat with a little more force than necessary. The second he started the engine, the heater kicked on, filling the space with warmthâbut Hoffman still felt that simmering irritation sitting low in his chest.
He glanced at Strahm. Something about him made his fingers tighten on the steering wheel. âYou talk about wine like some expert, but I bet if Perez were here, youâd have some bullshit poetic thing to say about it,â he muttered, keeping his voice level, but there was an unmistakable sharpness to it.
He wasnât sure what he wanted out of that commentâmaybe just to see Strahmâs reaction, to make him squirm the way Hoffman felt himself doing internally. Because for all his control, for all his carefully placed remarks, something about Strahm had a way of slipping under his skin. And it pissed him off. Well, he didn't know if he was more pissed off at that or the fact that he didn't understand why he was pissed off in the first place.
Peter put his hands between his knees in an attempt to warm them up, staring down as he did. He couldn't bring himself to look at Mark. He couldn't bring himself to even quickly glance at him. He already felt everything shift as soon as he brought up Lindsey.
Just as he was in his thoughts, Mark spoke.
The words stabbed him, causing his stomach to turn. Not out of anxiety, but rather anger. It made him so angry knowing that Hoffman hated Perez for no real reason. It made his blood boil. She wasn't a bad detective, she was kind, she never came off as aggressive, she was so perfect. Yet, Mark found a way to hate her.
"What do you mean, Hoffman? What is that supposed to mean." The first time was a question. The second time was in demand. A demand for answers. He was tired of how he always found a way to get mad at Lindsey when she has never done anything to him.
Strahm still avoided eye contact, but it was clear that he was angry. Even without the look of rage and hatred in his eyes, anyone could still tell he was angry. The way his words became sharp and intense again, the way his body tensed up when he spoke, the way his hands turned into fist in seconds.
It was all too obvious.
Hoffman didnât answer right away. He just drummed his fingers against the steering wheel, exhaling through his nose as if Strahmâs reaction wasnât exactly what he was hoping for.
But it was.
The sharpness in his voice, the way his body locked upâHoffman knew that anger well. He knew how it made Strahmâs breath come a little quicker, how it made him grip at things too tightly. And maybe it was fucked up, but he liked knowing he could pull that reaction from him so easily.
âWhat do I mean?â Hoffman repeated, dragging the words out slow, testing the weight of them on his tongue. His gaze flicked toward Strahm, watching the way he kept his eyes pointed anywhere but at him. Coward.
âI mean exactly what I said. You donât talk about me the way you talk about her.â His voice was even, but there was something under itâsomething Strahm wasnât going to like if he looked too closely.
His grip on the wheel tightened. âAnd donât pretend like you donât know what I mean,â he added, lower this time, but more pointed. âEvery time she comes up, you get allââ He waved a hand vaguely, knowing Strahm would get it. âLike sheâs so perfect. Like she can do no wrong. So yeah, maybe I donât like her, Strahm. Maybe I donât like the way you talk about her.â
His jaw clenched. He hadnât meant to say that last part, but now it was out there, sitting in the space between them. And for once, he was the one who looked away first.
Peter's breathing was quick and heavy, as if he was holding back so many things. Which, he was. Instead of yelling, he let Mark finish. He let him finish his ranting while holding eye contact. His eyes were angry, hateful, and disappointed. His eyes held a look that was almost unreadable, yet so readable at the same time.
He hated hearing these words. He hated hearing about someone not liking Lindsey. He hated listening to someone not thinking she was perfect. He hated hearing that Mark hated her. He hated Mark.
He felt his head began to hurt from the rage and all the thoughts piling up at once. He couldn't keep them hidden much longer. He had to express them somehow.
"What's the true reason you can't handle me talking about someone else? What is it, Hoffman? What makes you, a grown man who I haven't known most of my life, crave the attention I give to someone else? What makes you feel the need to act like an angry pathetic dog who craves attention? What is it?" He spoke, his words spilling out. He couldn't stop now.
"Why would I need to talk about you the way I talk about her? Do you believe you are more important than Lindsey in my mind? Do you truly believe you are better than her?" He thought for a moment, collecting his ability to breathe before continuing.
"I talk about her that way because she is perfect. She does no wrong. When has she ever wronged you? When has she wronged me? When has she wronged anyone? You can't think of a single example, can you? That's because she hasn't wronged anyone. You have no real reason to hate her other than jealousy, which doesn't even make sense because I could've sworn you hated me just yesterday. Why are you suddenly so jealous over someone I've known for years?"
He stopped himself, but his body language showed how angry he still was. His eyes, his hands, his shoulders, everything. It just showed how angry he was. Even then, that didn't do it justice.
Hoffmanâs grip on the steering wheel was so tight that his knuckles were white, the leather groaning under his fingers as he tried to force the anger back down. The air between them was thick with the tension, and it only got worse as Strahmâs wordsâsharp, biting, full of that damn righteous angerâsettled in the car, suffocating everything else.
Every word from Strahm twisted something inside him, but it wasnât just anger. It was jealousy.
Hoffman could feel the heat radiating from him, the sharpness in his voice, his body practically vibrating with the intensity of it. Jealous of Lindsey. Thatâs what it was, isnât it? But no. He couldnât admit that. Not out loud. Not even to himself.
His jaw locked so tight that it hurt, and it was taking all his self-control not to lash out. But as much as he hated admitting it, he wasnât just angry. No, it was more complicated than that.
"Really, Strahm?" Hoffmanâs voice was low, too low. It felt like it came from somewhere deep inside him, almost like he was letting something slip without meaning to. âYou wanna act like Iâm just throwing a fit, like Iâm jealous?â His words came out rough, but there was something else thereâsomething softer. A pull, just beneath the anger. âYou think I care about her more than you?â
He took a slow breath, still staring at the road, forcing himself to focus on the sound of his heartbeat. It wasnât enough to calm the storm inside him. His eyes flickered briefly to Strahm, watching the way he held himself, how tense and wound up he was. That tightness in his jaw, those clenched fists. Hoffman hated it. But he also liked it. Too much.
âIf I cared about her that much,â Hoffman continued, his voice a little quieter now, almost to the point where Strahm had to lean in to hear him, âI wouldnât be here. Wouldnât be here with you, would I?â
His pulse quickened as he said it, that same rush of heat climbing up his neck. He hated how it soundedâtoo much like he was admitting something, too much like he was being vulnerable when heâd never let anyone see that side of him.
His hands tightened on the wheel again, but it wasnât just anger this time. His thoughts were swirling, clouded with the weight of what he couldnât say. Couldnât admit.
He glanced at Strahm again, eyes narrowing, but this time it was different. He couldnât look away. There was something else there nowâsomething raw, something almost intimate in the way Strahm looked at him.
âIs that what you want, Peter?â Hoffmanâs voice was softer now, barely a whisper, a challenge. âYou really think Iâm jealous of her? Or is it that you just canât handle the idea of me being here instead of her?â
His heart thudded in his chest, the words spilling out before he could stop them. His stomach twisted. Why couldnât he stop? Why did it feel like something had shifted, like the whole conversation was moving toward something else entirely?
The silence between them stretched out, the only sound the hum of the engine and the beating of their hearts. Hoffman wasnât sure if Strahm could feel it tooâthe way the air had thickened with unspoken words. The way it felt like they were suddenly standing at the edge of something they werenât quite ready for.
But it was too late. The tension was already there, and Hoffman knew, without a doubt, that it wasnât just about Lindsey anymore.
And he hated himself for that.
Peter suddenly felt the tension for once, actually backing off. Something told him he needed to back off this situation before he said anything else or anything worse. He suddenly, for some reason, felt bad. It didn't make sense though. He shouldn't feel bad. He had a point, Mark did seem jealous of Lindsey. But did he maybe take it too far?
He took a breath through his nose and out his mouth. "Mark, I'm not saying you're jealous, I'm saying it seems like it. Every time I mention Lindsey, you act like it's the end of the damn world. You get all tense and angry as if you hate her for simply being in my life."
He spoke as if he hated the idea of Hoffman being jealous, but he really didn't. He enjoyed the idea of how he could ruin someones mood just by simply bringing up one person.
"All I want to know is why. Why does your mood change? Why do you get so tense? Why do you hate the idea that I think she's perfect?" Strahm poured out his words as if his mouth was a faucet for his brain.
The air between them was too much. It was thick, it was overwhelming. It drove him so insane how angry they both were. All he could hear was his own heartbeat in his ears.
"I just need to know. Why don't you like Lindsey?" He wasn't demanding anymore. He was pleading. He wanted to know why because he couldn't handle watching how he looked at her with such anger and jealousy every time they spoke at work.
Hoffmanâs grip on the steering wheel was relentless as Strahmâs words hung in the air, thick and heavy, pressing down on him like a weight he couldnât shake off. The space between them felt suffocating, as if every word Strahm said was just making the tension worse. But something in the way Strahm spoke caught him off guardâthere was a vulnerability there, a softness to his tone that Mark wasnât used to. Pleading. It had always been anger before, but now it was something else. Something that made Hoffman feel like he was walking a razorâs edge.
"You really wanna know, Peter?" Hoffmanâs voice was low, rough with something that wasnât anger anymore. It was too much to admit, too much to say, but it was right there, clawing at the back of his throat.
He took a breath, feeling the heat of Strahmâs words pressing into him. Mark wasnât ready to give in, not yet. He couldnât be. But damn, it was hard to ignore how his chest tightened when Strahm spoke with that tone. Pleading, vulnerable, asking for answers he couldnât give. Hoffman couldnât explain it, but there was something in Strahmâs eyesâthe way he looked at him, the way his words tangled up like a question and a challenge all in oneâthat made him want to say everything. To tell him the truth, to finally admit what had been gnawing at him all this time.
Markâs eyes flickered to Strahm, a quick glance that lingered too long. He tried to look away, but couldnât. He just... couldnât.
âI donât hate her,â Hoffman finally muttered, voice laced with frustration, but there was something deeper in it too. Something that was hard for him to articulate. âItâs not about her. Itâs not about her at all.â
The words came out harsher than he meant, but it wasnât about Lindsey, was it? It was about Peter. And that was something Hoffman wasnât ready to face.
âYou wanna know why my mood changes when you talk about her?â Hoffmanâs voice dropped even lower, almost a growl. âItâs because Iâm hereâwith youâand I hear you talk about her like sheâs some saint. Like sheâs perfect. Like sheâs everything you need, everything you want. And I canât stand it.â
The words slipped out before he could stop them, raw and unfiltered. His chest heaved, and his heart was beating too fast, like it was trying to escape. He could feel the shift, the intensity of the moment pulling them both into a place neither of them were ready for. But Hoffman couldnât help it. He couldnât keep it in any longer.
He turned his head slowly, eyes locking with Strahmâs, searching for somethingâanythingâin his face that would tell him he was still in control, that he hadnât just said too much.
âYou think Iâm jealous of her? Maybe... maybe Iâm just jealous that she gets to have you, and I donât.â
There it was. The words that were always just beneath the surface. He could feel the heat rising in his face, the tightness in his chest, and the way his hands were trembling ever so slightly. He hated how weak it made him feel, how vulnerable.
âBut you donât get it, do you?â Hoffman continued, his voice almost a whisper now, the anger simmering just beneath the surface. âI donât care if sheâs perfect, Peter. Itâs you. Itâs you I canât stand when you talk about her like that. Because itâs not about her. Itâs about... us.â
The words hung in the air, fragile and heavy. He hated how much they revealed, how much of himself he had just let slip. But there was no taking them back now. And as much as he tried to hold it all together, his chest still ached with that unspoken truthâhe had crossed a line he wasnât sure he could walk back from.
The silence stretched between them, thick and suffocating, until it felt like they were both drowning in it. Hoffman wasnât sure what came next. He wasnât sure if he wanted to know. But it was too late to pull back now.
Strahm stared blankly at Hoffman, his angry gaze soon becoming soft. Instead of cutting him off, he listened quietly. He didn't react in any form, though. It didn't feel right. Even a simple nod felt wrong. That would make it seem like he agreed with his feelings, but he didn't. He hadn't connected those feelings inside him just yet.
He wanted until he was silent and the silence was basically drowning the both of them before finally speaking. "Mark... I- I don't know what to say." He said, his mind not fully grasping everything that was said. It still hung in the air, driving him to insanity every second. He wasn't gay. He knew it.
"I'm not... well, I'm not gay. And Lindsey doesn't have me, no one has me." His words came off more aggressive than he wished. "Not even you, Hoffman. You don't have me." Those words weren't supposed to come out. He didn't want to come off as mean. The emotions were just too much to handle, though. Too much to care about how his words came across.
"There is no us. The only us we have going on is a work situation, Mark." He hesitated saying his name. "There can't be any of us. I'm sorry, but that's not who I am. And I'm not going to lead you on and pretend that's who I am. I clearly already lead you on enough..."
The last part came out as a whisper, like he was ashamed. Embarrassed even. He never felt bad, but he did this time. He didn't know why, but he did. He felt horrible, actually. It sat so uncomfortably in his stomach he couldn't help but almost gag. Why did he feel so bad?
Why did he regret everything he said?
Hoffmanâs chest tightened as Strahm spoke, each word hitting him like a physical blow. He hadnât expected Peter to say any of thatâhe hadnât expected any of it, really. But the sting of the words, the sharpness in Peterâs voice, felt like a blade to his gut. He hadnât thought that hearing Peter reject him would hurt this much. But it did. It hurt more than he ever thought possible.
When Strahm said those words, âIâm not gayâ, it felt like the ground beneath Mark's feet shifted. It felt like everything he had just laid out, all the things he had been thinking, sayingâfeelingâwas being slammed down in front of him like some hard truth he wasnât ready to hear.
And then the next partââNot even you, Hoffmanââstung deeper. The way Peter said it wasnât meant to be cruel, but it felt like it. Markâs hand clenched into a fist on the steering wheel, knuckles white, as if the tension in his body might somehow find an outlet through sheer force.
But it didnât.
He felt the weight of Peterâs words sitting heavily in the car between them, suffocating him, making him feel smaller than he ever had before. He didnât know what to say to thatâhow to fight back against something so⊠absolute. So final.
Still, there was something in Peterâs tone that shifted, something quieter, something almost⊠regretful. Embarrassed.
Hoffmanâs heart slammed in his chest as Peter whispered the last part, âI clearly already lead you on enough.â
For a moment, Mark couldnât breathe. It was like the air itself had been sucked out of the car, and he was left grasping at whatever was left.
No, Peter didnât want him. He didnât want this.
But there was that whisper of regret that stayed with Hoffman, swirling in his mind. He could see it in Peterâs eyesâthe way they shifted away from him, unable to meet his gaze. And the way he apologized, despite not wanting to admit anything, despite the layers of denial. There was something there. Something Mark wasnât sure if he wanted to understand, but he had to. It ate at him.
He slowly turned his head, his jaw clenching as he held Peterâs gaze, searching for the truth beneath his words.
âI donât need you to lead me on, Peter,â Hoffman said, his voice softer, almost gentle in a way that didnât quite fit the angry edge he usually carried. âIâm not asking for that. But you canât just pretend like I donât see whatâs going on. You donât get to throw this all away just because itâs easier for you.â
The words came out before he could stop them, and though they werenât meant to sound desperate, something in his voice cracked. Something in him trembled under the weight of what he was saying.
âIâm not gonna lie to you, Peter.â He paused, trying to catch his breath, his chest tight. âI... I donât know what the hellâs going on either. But I know Iâm not just some... work colleague to you. Not anymore.â His voice dropped lower. âI see it in the way you act around me. I feel it. Hell, Iâve felt it for a while now.â
He hesitated, staring out the windshield, before glancing back at Peter. His eyes were darker now, a fire simmering beneath them. He couldnât stop himself. He was burning up inside.
âIâm not perfect either, Peter,â he continued, the vulnerability creeping in. âBut donât sit there and pretend like thereâs nothing between us. Youâre not as cold as you think you are.â
It was out before he could stop it, his voice barely above a whisper, but there was a finality to it that lingered in the air.
The silence hung between them again, but this time, it was different. It wasnât just an empty, suffocating thing. It was charged. And as much as Mark hated to admit it, the way Peter wouldnât meet his eyesâthe way he avoided him nowâtold him everything he needed to know.
Peter stared down at his lap, picking at his cuticles to try and distract himself. That was working until Mark said the words. The words that killed everything inside of him. The words that stabbed him in the stomach. The words that made his blood boil.
' You donât get to throw this all away just because itâs easier for you. '
These words pained him. But not in a way that upset him, but in a way that angered him. He wasn't throwing anything away. He tried being nice, but clearly that didn't work. He wasn't gay.
"Listen, Hoffman. I've already told you, I'm not gay. I've never been gay, I've never though I was gay, I'm not gay. I'm not going to let yourself continue to believe that I am. It's not only hurting me, but also hurting you. At this point, it feels like you're leading yourself on."
The words came out in a harsh tone, his words aggressive and mean. He barked back like a dog. In this situation, he was like an angry, lost dog. A dog who needed comfort deep down.
He didn't want to make the situation worse, but it was hard with everything Mark said. the words ' But donât sit there and pretend like thereâs nothing between us. Youâre not as cold as you think you are. ' echoed throughout his head, causing his blood to just boil more.
Soon, he got to a point in anger where he wasn't even angry at Mark as much anymore, it was mostly anger towards himself.
He looked up to look out the windshield, sighing before opening his mouth to speak. His words came out in a low whisper as if he was checking in with himself.
"I'm not gay..."
Mark's eyes locked onto Peter's face, searching for somethingâanythingâto tell him that this wasnât over. But it was clear Peter wasnât giving him anything, just sitting there, picking at his cuticles, trying to hold it all together. The tension in the air was suffocating, and Mark could feel every inch of it tightening around him, his chest growing heavier with each passing second.
When Peter spoke, his voice was sharp, the words like a slap to the face. âIâm not gay. Iâve never been gay, Iâve never thought I was gay, Iâm not gay.â The rapid fire of it made Mark flinch, even though heâd expected it. But it still hurt, hearing Peter say it like that. Like it was something to be ashamed of.
Hoffmanâs jaw clenched, and he leaned forward slightly, his voice low but cutting. âIâm not asking you to be anything youâre not, Peter. But you canât sit there and act like thereâs nothing between us when you know damn well there is.â
Peterâs wordsâthe harshness in his tone, the way he barked back, like a wounded animalâhit a nerve that Mark didnât know existed. But then something else shifted in Peterâs voice, something softer, quieter, that Mark almost didnât catch. Peter looked out the windshield, and Mark could see the way his shoulders slumped slightly, like the anger was draining out of him, replaced with something else. Something less certain.
Mark leaned back in his seat, eyes narrowing, not willing to let Peter get away with this. "Youâre not fooling me, Strahm. Youâre not as cold as you act. You can say all you want that youâre not interested in meâIâm not stupid, I get it. But donât act like I donât see whatâs going on when you look at me like that." His voice cracked with frustration, but he didnât stop. He couldnât. "Youâre running from something. And I donât know what it is, but I see it in the way you pull away, in the way you shut down every time we get close." His eyes flickered toward Peter. "Youâre lying to yourself, Peter. And itâs not just about me. Itâs about you."
The silence that followed was heavier than anything before it, thick with unspoken words and tangled emotions. Mark's heart was hammering in his chest, but he didnât know what to do with it. He wanted to reach over, shake Peter, make him see the truth, but he couldnât. He wasnât sure if Peter was even listening anymore, if the words were getting through to him.
When Peter finally spoke again, his voice was a whisper, almost as if he was saying it more to himself than Mark. "Iâm not gay..."
Markâs eyes softened at the quiet admission. There was a crack in Peterâs façade, a fracture that Mark hadnât expected to see. Heâd seen the anger, the cold detachment, the resistance. But thisâthis was different. This was something raw. Something that made Markâs heart stutter, even if he didnât want it to.
âYou donât have to keep telling me that,â Mark said quietly, his voice surprisingly gentle, as though trying to reach something inside Peter. He leaned forward again, just a little. âI know. I know youâre not âgay,â Peter. But thatâs not what Iâm asking for.â His voice caught on the last word. âIâm asking you to stop running. From me. From whatever the hell it is thatâs scaring you.â
There was a long pause as Mark let the words settle in the air between them. He didnât know what would happen next, or if Peter would even listen. But there was no going back now. He had to say it. He had to give Peter the chance to decide. Whether they could move past all of this or if it would just tear them apart.
Peter still wouldnât meet his eyes, his gaze fixed on the windshield, but Mark didnât look away. He couldnât. Not when there was still a chance. Not when the weight of everything between them was still there, waiting for a spark to set it off.
Strahm felt himself breaking, but hid it. He hid it to the best of his abilities. But if you looked closely, very closely, you'd see a wounded man with glossy eyes. Eyes that weren't helping hide the fact he was upset. Eyes that held so much more emotion than his own words. Eyes you would see on an animal being hunted. Eyes that held fear.
"I'm not-" His voice cracked, but he quickly covered it with a cough. "I'm not running. I'm not scared of anything." No matter how much he tried to hide how he was really feeling, you could still slightly see it. His hands were now shaking and his leg began to bounce up and down quickly, making a faint but noticeable tapping sound.
"I'm not hiding from you." He said, but something in his mind told him he was hiding from Hoffman. Something told him he was hiding from everything. It had gotten to a point that he couldn't hide his feelings anymore. His whole body was tensed up as if protecting himself from words, his eyes fixated on the cars ahead of them more than anything, his leg continued to bounce but at a faster pace, and finally, his lip. He hadn't even noticed, but his lip began to drip blood again. This time though, he didn't wipe it away. He didn't want any hands near his face, even his own.
"And I shut down when we're close because I don't like you, Hoffman. You do nothing but-" He stopped himself, realizing what he said. It was too late. He can't just go back in time and stop himself. These words were stuck in the car.
All of their words were stuck in the car, along with his heart.
Mark could feel it, the tension in the air thick and almost suffocating. Every breath Peter took seemed heavy, labored, and every movement of his hands, his leg bouncing, told Mark something was wrong. The words caught in the air, stuck between them like a wall, and Mark was starting to feel like he was trapped on the other side of it.
Peterâs voice cracked, and Markâs heart skipped. He saw it. The way Peterâs hands shook, the way his leg tapped frantically, the slight gloss in his eyes that Peter tried so hard to hide. Peter was on the edge of breaking down, but he was doing everything in his power to keep it together, to keep his walls up. Mark knew that feeling. He recognized it. It was the same one he wore every damn day.
When Peter spoke, his words were harsh, almost defensive, but Mark could hear the cracks underneath. "I'm not running. I'm not scared of anything." But Mark saw it. That wasnât the truth. The shaking, the trembling lip, the way Peterâs eyes kept avoiding him. The truth was slipping through the cracks in his defenses.
Peter said he wasnât scared, but Mark could hear it in his voice, see it in the way his body tensed up. He could almost smell itâfear. Fear of something bigger than either of them could handle.
âIâm not hiding from you,â Peter said, and the words didnât even make it out like they were supposed to. Mark could hear the hesitation. The vulnerability. Peter was lying to himself. But Mark wasnât about to call him out on itânot yet, anyway. Heâd been there before, too. He understood what it was like to keep those walls up, to lock everything inside until it made you want to suffocate.
But then Peter spoke again. His words cut through the thick air like a knife, too sharp to ignore. "And I shut down when we're close because I don't like you, Hoffman. You do nothing but-"
Peter stopped himself, and Mark felt the weight of the words that hadn't been finished. The ones that lingered like a shadow, threatening to reveal something deeper than just anger or confusion. Something that could change everything.
Markâs pulse raced. He wanted to push him further, demand to know what Peter had really meant, but he knew better than to rush it. It wasnât the time for that. Still, the words hung in the air, heavy, suffocating. You do nothing but... what?
Markâs eyes softened just slightly as he watched Peter's lip, the blood starting to drip again. Peter didnât wipe it away, didnât even move his hand. It was like he wanted to bleed, wanted to feel it. Wanted to show Mark that he wasnât as cold as he kept pretending to be.
Mark knew the feeling too well. It was a strange sort of comfort to know that Peter was hurting, too. As fucked up as it sounded, it was a relief to know Peter wasnât the stone wall he tried so hard to be. And maybe, just maybe, Mark could find a way in. Even if it scared the hell out of him.
âPeterâŠâ Markâs voice was softer now, almost hesitant, as if he was treading carefully through the words. He didnât want to break Peter any more than he already was, but he couldnât stand watching him fight this on his own.
Mark reached out by putting his arm on the centre console, just slightly, his fingers brushing the air near Peterâs hand, though he didnât touch him. He wasnât sure if Peter would pull away or not. He wasnât sure if Peter even wanted him near.
But the words that followed from Peter hit Mark like a punch to the gut. âI donât like you.â And it stung more than anything Mark could have expected. He knew Peter wasnât ready for anything else, but that hurt. Hurt more than he wanted to admit.
Mark leaned back in his seat, his heart pounding in his chest. He couldnât let Peter see the effect those words had on him, but it felt like a thousand knives had pierced through his chest all at once.
âRight.â Markâs voice was tight, holding back something deep inside. No, Peter. You donât just shut down and say you donât like me and expect me to walk away.
But Mark didnât say that. He didnât push. He couldnât. Not yet. The words Peter had left unfinished were eating away at him, though. The silence was deafening.
And in that silence, Mark could feel itâthe shift, the crack in Peterâs armor. Peter might not have been ready to admit anything, but Mark could see it now. He could see the truth bleeding through, and he wasnât going anywhere.
Not yet.
They drove in silence for a few more moments, the tension between them almost unbearable. Then, finally, they pulled into the parking lot of the station. The headlights cut through the night, casting long shadows across the concrete. The sound of the engine slowing to a stop filled the car, but neither of them made a move to get out immediately.
Mark just sat there for a second, his eyes still on Peter. He could feel the weight of the moment hanging between them, almost like it was going to shatter if either of them spoke again.
After what felt like an eternity, Mark exhaled quietly and opened the door. "Weâre here," he said, his voice barely above a whisper. He didnât know what else to say. He didnât know how to fix what had been broken, or if it could even be fixed at all. All he knew was that he wasnât leaving yet.
Peter noticed his arm on the center console, moving his arm away quickly. Quicker than he'd ever moved away from Mark. His movements were like a scared injured animal. Quick to escape the touch that could save him. The touch that could fix him.
Strahm completely dissociated, staring out to the cars. The blood continued down his chin, reaching the bottom before he finally wiped it off with a quick movement of his arm. The arm farthest from Mark. Seeming like he was trying to hide he could move at all.
He stayed in his thoughts, trying his best to breathe through his walls finally breaking. They couldn't break. He couldn't let a new person into his mind, anything could happen.
His brain flooded with thoughts. They were all about Hoffman. What if he was starting to hate him? What if he was right? He's only trying to help. For once, he's being a good person and I just can't soak it in. Maybe I'm just a horrible person. He's probably beginning to hate me now. He probably-
Suddenly, Mark's voice pulled him out of the thoughts.
He looked at Hoffman and quickly nodded, leaving his car and locking it before speed walking to the office. As soon as he made it inside, he packed up everything at his desk he brought in. He had to leave, and he had to leave now.
Hoffman sat there for a second, watching Strahmâs back as he disappeared inside. He could still see the tension in his posture, the way his shoulders curled in like he was trying to shrink himself down, trying to vanish into the walls.
Mark exhaled, shaking his head as he rubbed his hand over his mouth.
This was spiraling. Fast.
He should just let him go. Let Strahm run himself ragged, let him pack up, let him storm out of the office and pretend none of this ever happened. Itâd be the easy thing to do. Itâd be the smart thing to do.
But Mark was shit at doing the smart thing when it came to Peter.
With a grunt, he pushed open the car door and got out, walking toward the building. His steps were heavy, purposeful, his jaw set as he shoved through the front doors.
Strahm was already at his desk, movements frantic, throwing his stuff into his bag like he was trying to outrun something. Maybe himself.
Mark lingered in the doorway for a moment before finally stepping forward.
âYou leaving or running?â His voice was level, but there was an edge beneath it.
Mark scoffed, stepping closer. âYou text me, drag me over here, and now youâre bolting? What the hell was this, Peter?â
He wasnât even sure what he wanted Strahm to say. He just wanted him to say something. Anything.
Mark clenched his jaw. Fine. If Strahm wanted to run, let him. But Mark wasnât going to stand there like an idiot, waiting for an answer that would never come.
âForget it,â he muttered, turning on his heel to leave.