((Sorry for the rambling)
Tbh the more I think about it- The more the real question isn’t who’s the best leader out of the 3 but who’s the worst lol (I’d say the prototype but poppy is a close second)
The prototypes horrendous bc I think he just wants to be??? Like I’m sorry after everything he can do I just can’t buy that he wouldn’t be a good leader if he genuinely wanted to.
And I’ll be honest- maybe it’s just bc I don’t care for doomed siblings tropes but I don’t really like the writing direction the prototypes character has taken in his obsession around poppy? Making his end goal/motivations being that of all things feels…a little lame? (At least to me) especially when there are so many other things it could’ve been that would’ve been but I digress-
And honestly a lot of the reveal Because it cheapens a lot of stuff and almost feels like a completely different character from the one we were told about in the earlier chapters
A lot of his complexity feels lost and Sure he did bad things but it didn’t feel like it was out of a short sighted selfishness??
Now he almost feels like a stereotypical one dimensional control freak tyrant who’s just crazy selfish and abusive to henchmen like what is there to like about the prototype in game? Why would anyone want to willingly follow him?
He went from being a mysterious person who did bad in the ‘lesser of two evils’ kinda way to someone who’s just being bad for the sake of being bad because he can be bad-
And then on the other hand
Poppy is pretty bad bc she doesn’t have what it takes to be a leader (she admits it herself) but won’t open up to the people around her, withholds info which is so unfair to the people who genuinely help you at the cost of their own lives???
It’s almost exploitative if you can trust people to risk and sacrifice for you but can’t give them the honesty of the situation that they arguably deserve to hear/know
Like you want me to believe that if she’d been honest with doey about her being overwhelmed as a leader, running away during the toy war and then getting imprisoned that he wouldn’t have had a shred of empathy and understanding towards her???
Doey at the very least deserved a good explanation especially since he’d proved himself capable, reliable and reasonable in many such instances.
I also agree on your point with poppy- but honestly at this point I do think the story has done her dirty- she gets very little screen time and sometimes the writing for her is just??? Off???
Like the presentation doesn’t match the complexity of the concept of her character- but once again that’s another can of worms
And I’m not saying this to hate on her because I’m like- yeah she’s pitiful and sad but am I the only one who understands why people both in and out game would be annoyed/frustrated with her?
Like you said any crash out Doey (and I’d argue the player or anyone in safe haven) would have against poppy is justified especially when the game more or less has giblet pretty much repeat Doeys point to poppy- which feels like rubbing salt in the wound???
I genuinely think if one character deserved redemption than it was doey