The second DeLuca's name leaves her mouth, Rafe's expression goes flat. Not in anger or amusement. But, in something worse. Because unlike the stranger she'd been entertaining all night, DeLuca isn't some harmless idiot from accounting. DeLuca would know exactly what he was doing. And Shay knows exactly what she's doing simply by bringing him up.
A low breath escapes through Rafe's nose, dangerous. It’s the same kind of breath that precedes broken noses and bad decisions. Behind him, he can practically feel the attention shifting. Feel the way conversations nearby begin to dull as people sense something unfolding. Not a fight—nobody's stupid enough to start one of those tonight—but something close enough to make for decent entertainment.
As Shay's fingers leave his jaw, he remains perfectly still for a moment. Then after a moment he laughs.... one sharp, humorless sound. "That's your play?" Slowly, he turns. Not toward the guy she'd been flirting with for the better part of twenty minutes. But, toward her. Amber eyes lock onto hers. For a second, the rest of the casino disappears. The noise, the music, the people. All of it... gone. Until, there's just her. Just that infuriating smile she wears whenever she's trying to get under his skin.
Mission accomplished. "You know," he says quietly, "for someone claiming this isn't about me, you've spent an awful lot of time trying to make me jealous tonight." What's that about? His gaze flicks briefly toward the stranger then. The poor bastard looks like he's contemplating whether the nearest exit is close enough. Smart man.
Then Rafe's attention returns to Shay. "By the way?" His mouth curves into something that isn't quite a smile. "If DeLuca was actually your type," if either of them were really, "you'd already be halfway upstairs making terrible decisions, waiting for the moment I barge in to stop you." A beat. "But you're still standing here. With me." The harsh truth lands exactly where he intends it to.
Because for all their years of this dance, for all the arguments and slammed doors and weeks spent pretending they don't care, one thing has remained stubbornly unchanged between them: they always end up right back here. Orbiting, colliding, some would even say... clashing. Refusing to let go.
Rafe takes a step forward. Not enough to corner her. But enough to remind her how little space exists between them. "Besides," he continues, voice dropping lower, "we both know DeLuca wouldn't survive you." His eyes drift deliberately toward the table of Jackals she'd pointed out moments ago. Then back to her. "And neither would your friend." The stranger immediately decides he has somewhere else to be. Interesting.
Rafe watches him retreat into the crowd before shaking his head. "Well." Another glance toward the disappearing man. "There goes your date." His gaze settles on her again. Slow, and unapologetic... but most of all? Victorious. And, possessive in a way he has absolutely no right to be anymore. Yet somehow always is.
"And before you start," he adds, already seeing the argument forming behind her eyes, "save it." One corner of his mouth lifts. "You and I both know he wasn't the one you wanted a reaction from." The words are irritatingly calm. Certain in their delivery. Because that vulnerable flash she'd shown him earlier? He saw it. Just like she saw every crack in his armor. Just like she always does.
"Question is..." His head tilts slightly. "What exactly were you hoping I'd do, Shay?" The use of her actual name lands softer than everything else had, and more dangerous, too. There's no more teasing nicknames. No more sarcasm. No more games. Just her name. And all the history attached to it. "What would've made you happy?" For the first time all night, the jealousy gives way to something rawer. Something tired and honest. His eyes search hers. "Me walking away?" A pause. "Or me staying?"
For a moment, Rafe thinks she might actually answer him. Not with one of her knives disguised as words or with a smirk, or with another challenge thrown directly at his feet. But, just an answer. However, that would require both of them admitting things they've spent years avoiding. And neither of them has ever been particularly brave when it comes to each other. His gaze lingers on her face, on the anger, on the hurt buried underneath it. The stubbornness that has always matched his own. God help him, she's beautiful when she's furious. Maybe that's part of the problem. Maybe it's always been the problem.
The distance between them suddenly feels impossible. Not because it's large. But because it's small. Because one step closes it. And one touch changes everything.
Rafe's jaw flexes. He should leave it alone. He should let her keep swinging, should let her keep pretending she doesn't care and continue pretending he doesn't know better. Instead, he does the only thing he can think of. The thing he's been wanting to do since she walked into the casino. Slowly, deliberately, he reaches for her. The back of his fingers brush her arm first, barely there. Almost like a question, or a warning. Or most of all.. an invitation. Then his hand settles against her waist. Firm, certain, like it belongs there. Like it remembers exactly how she feels underneath all the clothes.
The contact isn't possessive this time. It's worse. Gentler. The kind of touch that strips away all the games they've been playing tonight.
His thumb moves once against her side, a small motion. Almost absentminded. Except neither of them is likely to miss what it means. Because Rafe knows. Knows exactly what she's asking for every time she pushes him, every time she picks a fight. Every time she turns her attention toward some poor bastard across a bar and waits for him to react.
This. This thing they've spent years dancing around, this thing she keeps reaching for whenever she thinks he isn't looking. It's not jealousy, it's ownership.
His eyes never leave hers. "That's the problem, isn't it?" The words come out quieter now. The rough edge now gone. "You keep dangling all these other names in front of me." His hand remains where it is. Steady, warm, familiar. "DeLuca. Brad. Whoever the hell that guy was." A faint smile touches one corner of his mouth. "You don't want them."
The casino noise seems distant now, muted beneath the weight of everything sitting between them. Rafe swallows, his gaze dropping briefly to her mouth before returning to her eyes. "And that's what makes this so damn unfair." His thumb strokes once more against her side. Just once. Enough to remind her what she's been missing. Enough to remind himself. Because if he wanted to, he could pull her closer, could stop this ridiculous game for all of five minutes, could give her exactly what she's been asking for. What they've both been asking for. A raunchy fuck in some private corner, that’s meant to drown out all the noise and reclaim what’s theirs.
The realization settles heavily between them. His voice lowers. "Because you know exactly what happens when you look at me like that." A beat. "And you know, I'd fold for you." For the first time all night, there isn't a trace of jealousy in his expression. Just honesty.
His hand remains at her waist. Not holding her there, just offering. A glimpse of what it would be like if he finally stopped letting her walk away. “Is that what you want?” Better yet— is it he, who she wants? Because if that’s the case, that’s all she has to say.