[the half of it: spoilers]
am i the only one who doesn’t like paul? the ‘you’re going to hell thing’ just hit too hard, since i already hear that, and the fact that it happened right after he tried to kiss ellie was... not it. the thing i was excited about for ellie and paul’s friendship was his reaction to finding out ellie has the same crush as him- the trailer made it seem as though he respected it, and the difficulties she faced being a closeted lesbian. but that didn’t happen. despite him coming to terms with that, despite the fact that “people are products of the environment they grew up in” (which is, by the way, not an excuse), despite the fact that he ran after the train- his mother had a better reaction to thinking he was gay than he did to ellie.
ellie and astrid, on the other hand, are kindred spirits. whether or not they end up together romantically, it’s so obvious from their conversations in their letters and their interaction at the end of the movie that this is the start of a great friendship (if not more). when ellie says, “do you know what it’s like to finally meet someone your age who gets you?” she isn’t talking about paul. she’s talking about astrid- she created abstract graffiti with astrid! all she did with paul was stalk the girl they both liked and go shopping.
maybe it’s the impression i got personally from him, but paul isn’t the guy that i had hoped he would be, and their friendship is not that amazing tumblr post (if u know, u know).






















