I watched TLJ and I changed my mind a little bit (mild spoilers ahead)
I posted a rant before when I read the spoilers. I was decided to not watch the movie in the cinema (I’m that averse to spend money on something I think I will hate) but last night I ended up watching for free! I received a cinema ticket as compensation because the theatre I went could not show Coco in English due to a malfunction (they also gave me a refund. I don’t speak the local language of the country I’m right now, so I could not watch the dubbed version. I’m sad because I have not been able to watch Coco yet, but that’s another story). So, I watched TLJ waiting to hate it... I did not...not completely at least.
I think is a good movie. Not close to being a masterpiece, but a good movie. Rey is a good protagonist. Ridley, Driver and Hamill acting was great!...T
The problem with TLJ is that it doesn’t exist in a vacuum and at the end of the day, it does not fit into the story of the 7 previous movies in a harmonious way.
In comparison, while TFA was a simple not an outstanding movie (I really liked Rey and Finn as new protagonists, but I disliked the setting with a failed Republic and the bad copy of the Empire), it was ok, it fitted in the overall saga and it ended with a promise of a better follow-up in the future. You still could watch the eps. 1 to 7 and feel you were on the same path to complete the saga. In a way, TLJ is more interesting and better made, but it tries to bring change not with a smooth transition, but with a forceful move that ends up feeling like a foreign attack to the things I loved and the story I have been following.
I think TLJ tramples over some of the core parts of the Star Wars story that episodes 1-6 told. By removing the Skywalker family from the center of the story and giving Luke the ending they did I think TLJ breaks the flow of the movies and ends up destroying the continuity of the saga (I believe that Kylo is irredeemable and with him, the Skywalker bloodline will die. Of course they always can make him redeem himself next movie in some ass pull way, and making someone pregnant with his baby to continue but honestly I’m not sure that will work). While episodes 1-6 still are consistent as parts of the same story. With TLJ, TFA was sent to be lost in space since it doesn’t work anymore as a bridge between the old movies and the new ones and TLJ because it .