Pike Trickfoot did terrible things, and that's wonderful.
In this essay, I will..
Ahahahaha alright alright alright, the last three episodes of season 4 were a lot and I wanna talk about the various reactions I've been seeing to Pike. Also included are my thoughts (that nobody asked for) on why her terrible, immoral choices are actually a great thing for her character.
Let's first recap what Pike's been dealing with since the season began: 1. Felt abandoned by friends who (as far as we know) made no attempt to contact her or Grog for a year.
2. Sees first-hand the damage caused by the Chroma Conclave and blames herself (and to an extent Vox Machina) for not stopping it faster (Survivor's guilt! Get your fresh survivor's guilt over here! It's so in character for Pike to carry the guilt of suffering she "could have stopped.")
3. Encounters a former mentor/priestess of the Everlight who mysteriously turned completely fucking evil (and necrotic). Let's not pretend that seeing one of the most devoted followers to your god turn over to an evil god didn't impact her in the slightest.
4. Starts having weird visions about an ancestor no one told her about who is somehow connected to sealing away the Whispered Prick.
5. Loses her grandpa in a horribly traumatic way.
6. Not only can't convince Scanlan to join them but overhears him say that leaving the team was the best decision he'd ever made. Rejected, indeed! I'd put good money on that particular moment of BL playing out in Pike's head when things got dark.
7. Loses Grog - the one person she could count on to be by her side.
Throughout all of this, she receives NO help from the Everlight. Whether this was because Pike cut herself off (like in season 1) or the Everlight was cut off from her by other means, we don't know. What we do know is that this is a lot. I wouldn't expect ANYONE to be thinking rationally by this point.
And even then, it took THIS MUCH for Pike to reach that point where she became broken and hopeless an vulnerable enough to be manipulated by the WO.
I'm not gonna argue Pike's innocence. She brought the WO back by willingly giving her blood. Fought her friends. Stopped them from getting to the WO. Hurt Grog. Put the entire world in danger. NONE OF THAT IS OKAY. No matter how she was manipulated or how her mental state was or what she had going on, that doesn't make her actions excusable. They are, however, understandable - even as understandable as Keyleth risking the entire realm for the hope of saving Vax.
But I've seen posts saying Pike should have been stronger or "helped herself" or that her actions were disappointing or that she's blaming everyone for her problems and I think that's completely missing the point. Plus, it gets addressed BY HER IN HER OWN LAMENT:
"Who heals me?"
She's already been strong - for way too long! Pike is always the one to help and heal. She helped Scanlan find a solution to being with Kaylie. Played a huge role in bringing Percy back to life. Forgave Grog for listening to Craven Edge. Just this once, she's ALLOWED to be weak, angry, and even cruel. Her grief, helplessness, and depression skewed her entire world. It cast everything through a negative lens and made her genuinely believe her friends didn't care about her aside from what she could do for them.
So...Pike did bad things when bad things happened to her, and it makes her such a realistic character whose redemption is going to be all the brighter for it. Because the Everlight is the goddess of...say it with me...
*REDEMPTION*
That's the thing with dynamic characters...they have arcs. They make horrible choices that have lasting consequences. They grieve in unhealthy ways. They do things that we, without the trauma and grief that they've been through, would never do. I cannot imagine how dull it would have been if Pike had just been a-okay this entire time. If she hadn't felt abandoned by VM or had no survivor's guilt or got over herself and talked with the Everlight or didn't feel compelled to drown herself in copious amounts of alcohol just to cope.
And I also wanna point out that Gideon/the WO didn't get to her at first. She walked into Thar Amphala, mace and Mythcarver drawn, and the first thing she did was try to smash Gideon's face in. It was only when she saw Grog - when she had a CHANCE of getting back something dear that had been lost to her - that she made her choice to listen. And she made her choices. She fucked up.
And now she gets to make it right because she is Pike Motherfucking Trickfoot and that is what she does.










