For the most recent au if you can call it that with the kids dreaming and stuff, how would their attitudes and treatment of Alfred change? Would they get more protective of Bruce? Lash out at Alfred? Please friend I need to know
grouping these together since they're basically the same question: It's a mix of different things. Not all of them are confrontational and up in Alfred's face. But there's a lot of hurt, a lot of broken trust, a lot of anger.
Dick has known Alfred the longest, had bonded with Alfred before he bonded w Bruce. Alfred was the one who'd initially supported Dick w the very sudden shift in his life. With how similar the tragedies Bruce and Dick suffered, Dick is utterly confused on how Alfred could have ever treated Bruce the way he did, the way he does. So Dick tries, he really fucking tries, to keep a calm demeanor when asking Alfred for more details, but Dick being the person that he is, with such strong and, at times, uncontrollable, feelings, it's difficult to remain calm. Dick, "He was grieving, Alfred." Alfred, "As was I." Dick, "He was eight! He was a child! His parents were dead and all he had was you!" Alfred, "Master Di-" Dick, "No. No! Don't make excuses! How is it that you could be so kind to me? But with the boy you were actually entrusted w, the one who you were supposed to love, you treated him like...like some kind of assignment? Something you could turn your back on at any moment?" Alfred, "I didn't. I stayed, I kept him alive." Dick, "No you didn't. I did. Not only that, I fucking made him happy! Because before me, he was living w a man who judged his every goddamn breath. Did you ever care, or are you just here for a paycheck?"
Bruce steps in mid-argument, preventing it from escalating any further, but Dick is still absolutely fuming. He refuses to be in Alfred's presence after that, refuses to speak to him, and despite Bruce's urgings, refuses to apologize. Jason felt the closest to Alfred, had spent a lot of time with the man prior to his death. Jason had this need in him to be useful, to prove that he deserved to take up space, to prevent himself from ever being kicked out despite Bruce telling him often that he only wanted Jason to be himself. But he couldn't do that, so he offered to help Alfred cook and clean, take care of the garden, any kind of task or chore. To know that a man who was so kind to him is capable of such cruelty?
Alfred, "Are you here to express your anger as well?" Jason, "Is that what you expect?" Alfred, "After Master Dick's outburst-" Jason, "I'm not Dickie, and it wasn't an outburst. He's angry." Alfred, "...right. And are you?" Jason, huffing out a laugh, "Am I angry? Alfred, I'm seething."
Jason's relationship w Bruce is...complicated. But as much as he denies it, in his very heart of hearts, Jason loves Bruce. It's a strange love, something twisted with thorns and jagged edges, but at the very base, it still is love.
Jason, "I'm not going to yell at you, or threaten you. You're a grown ass man, Alfred, and so is Bruce now. If he has problems, he can take care of them himself." Alfred, "I see." Jason, "But that doesn't mean I'm letting this go. Not for a long time. Possibly never. See, Alfred, a lot of shit makes sense now." Alfred, "Such as?" Jason, "I know you never really cared about me. The kid picked up off the street and turned into a soldier. I was convenient, a tool. Only, I was wrong about who thought about me that way. It was never Bruce. It was you."
Unlike Dick, Jason doesn't avoid Alfred, but he doesn't speak to him either. Turns away any offers of help, support, or conversation. He acts like Alfred isn't there at all. Cass has mixed feelings, because part of her feels as though she should have known this already. She had always seen the hurt in Bruce, the pain and heartbreak, but she was unable to put together the full picture because Alfred was kind. She hadn't realized his kindness didn't exist for the one person who wanted, needed it the most.
Alfred, "Miss Cassandra..." Cass, "I don't want to talk to you." Alfred, "Of all people, I thought you'd understand." Cass, "Understand what?" Alfred, "Why I acted as I did. You can clearly see that I loved him. Love him. But there are ways an employee is meant to be." Cass, "Bruce thinks of you as more than that." Alfred, "And he shouldn't." Cass, "But he does. And you hurt him by shutting him out. By being professional. He didn't need that."
Cass continues on almost like normal. She knows Alfred was telling the truth, that he does love Bruce, and she also knows that treating Alfred coldly would only hurt Bruce more. He doesn't want change, he wants things to go back to how they were. That's impossible, but hopefully Cass can help, even in such a small way.
Tim is...the least surprised. He'd seen Bruce at his lowest, and he'd also witnessed the way Alfred never stepped in to help. At least, not the way family should. He'd even overheard some of the scathing words Alfred had for Bruce, for letting himself spiral so far after Jason's death. The admonishment, the judgement. But to know it had started far earlier? Before Bruce had built up any sort of defenses, the thick skin he prides himself on having?
Tim, "Are you proud of yourself?" Alfred, "Not at all." Tim, "Good."
Tim leaves it at that. There's no teaching an old dog new tricks, no way to change Alfred's behavior. The fact that he's aware of the pain he's caused and yet he never thought to correct his actions... In Tim's eyes, Alfred is beyond help. He'll never earn Tim's forgiveness for letting a grieving boy suffocate beneath his own pain.
Damian...Damian has come so far. He's learned so much, experienced so much. He thought he was past being the angry boy that first showed up at the Manor, the one who was quick to judge, the fight, to argue. All that work and efforts, and it seems like it was for nothing because he is so...so angry. It burns, threatens to nearly engulf him. Damian is well aware of how strong his father is. He never needed to know the details, he could see it in how Bruce holds himself now. Damian knows pain and sorrow, and Bruce had been dealt that in spades, yet he continues to be the man he is despite it all. Damian had attributed some of his father's strength to the support provided by Alfred. Now, he knows he was wrong. Bruce isn't who he is because of Alfred. He is who he is despite Alfred.
Damian, "You're fired." Alfred, "..." Damian, "Don't look at me like that. You're fired, Pennyworth. Leave. Your employment has been terminated." Alfred, "I'm sure your father would not approve." Damian, "Do not speak of him. You do not have the right!" Alfred, "Do correct your tone, Master Dami-" Damian, "Shut up. Shut up shut up shut up! How could you? How dare you?
Damian doesn't get much more than that out because he's fighting back tears, scrubbing at his face as the words get stuck in his throat. He wants to scream, he wants to throw things, he wants to hurt Alfred, but as soon as he steps towards the man, he's scooped up and his balled up hands end up banging against the solid chest of his father who only shushes him gently. Damian is too old to be soothed like this, but he cries and he clings to Bruce, trying to imagine how a man so good could have ever been treated like that.
---
Overall, things are...tense. There's a lot of arguments, most of which Bruce breaks up. Sometimes he has to drag his children away, and sometimes they're the ones to drag him away. There's no stopping Bruce from interacting w Alfred, but any of his free time, they try to spend w him, try and convince him that what Alfred did was wrong. Bruce listens, even if he doesn't agree. All he can think about is the fact that Alfred stayed when he didn't have to, that even if Alfred's love was cold, it was warmer than the potential loneliness of not having him at all.
The children vow to teach Bruce what love without conditions is like, to offer it to him so that maybe one day he'll finally understand that he was never the one at fault. He never deserved to be hurt like that.


















