HelIoo, can I request A Muggle reader and Theodore? One day the boys, or only him, decide to go to the Muggle world to explore, and Theo falls in love with a girl??
Pairing: Theodore Nott x Muggle Reader
Summary: Theodore only meant to watch a Spider-Man movie in the muggle world, until he met you. Between comic book discussions and milkshake dates, you both fell in love. When you finally found out he was a wizard… you realised you were dating a real-life Doctor Strange.
Warnings: Nothing! Fluffy flustered Theo!
A/N: I COMBINED MARVEL AND HARRY POTTER I'M SO HAPPY! Thanks for the request @justpaucaro!
Lorenzo wanted to see some ridiculous film about a boy who got bitten by a radioactive spider.
Muggles were absolutely mad.
Who looked at a spider and thought, You know what? That should give someone superpowers.
And then, somehow, turned that idea into a bestselling comic.
Theodore remained thoroughly unconvinced.
He couldn't deny he was curious.
As a pure-blood, he'd never spent any real time in the Muggle world. His father had always dismissed Muggles as beneath them-people who stumbled through life without magic, relying on crude inventions to compensate.
"They're uncomfortable," Mattheo muttered, tugging irritably at the waistband of his jeans.
"They're called clothes, Mattheo," Lorenzo replied with an exaggerated sigh. "And we're wearing them so we blend in. Now hurry up-the cinema's this way."
He strode confidently down the pavement, clearly the only one who knew where he was going.
Theo, Mattheo, Draco and Blaise followed behind, each looking varying degrees of unimpressed.
Theo's attention wandered.
Everything around him felt strangely fascinating.
Cars rushed past in neat rows, lights flashing as they disappeared into the distance.
He watched one disappear around a corner.
"They built all of this without magic," he murmured.
"They don't even have Floo Powder."
"They use aeroplanes instead," Lorenzo said over his shoulder. "Massive metal things that fly through the sky."
"Takes hours," Mattheo added dramatically.
"What an appalling way to travel," Draco scoffed.
Blaise glanced sideways at him.
"So what does Granger think about your opinion of Muggles?"
Draco's ears immediately turned pink.
Blaise burst into laughter while Theo quietly tuned them out, taking in the unfamiliar streets instead.
There were no enchanted shop windows.
No witches bustling between cafés.
Everything was different.
People milled around the lobby wearing bright red shirts decorated with black webs and enormous white eyes.
"They seem awfully committed to this spider boy."
Lorenzo pinched the bridge of his nose.
"How is he a man if he's only seventeen?"
"It's a superhero film, Nott."
"That doesn't answer my question."
Theo hummed thoughtfully.
Lorenzo stared at him for a long moment before shaking his head.
"I'm buying the tickets."
He pointed a warning finger at the group.
He disappeared towards the ticket counter, leaving the others standing in the middle of the lobby.
Mattheo had already started arguing with Draco over something called popcorn.
"I refuse to spend eight pounds on corn," Draco declared.
"It's not just corn," Lorenzo called back from the queue.
Theo decided he wanted no part in whatever argument that was.
Instead, he slipped his hands into the pockets of the borrowed jacket Lorenzo had insisted he wear and looked around.
Children ran past with oversized drinks.
Music drifted from unseen speakers overhead.
No one glanced at anyone else.
No one cared who came from an old family.
No one whispered about blood status.
For the first time in a long while...
Everything felt wonderfully ordinary.
Someone suddenly collided with him.
"Oh my God-I'm so sorry!"
A stack of paper cups slipped from your arms.
Before they could hit the floor, Theo instinctively caught them.
For a moment, neither of you spoke.
"You've got amazing reflexes."
You carefully took the cups back.
"My manager would've killed me if I'd dropped those."
You smiled politely, apparently assuming he'd been joking.
"You guys here for Spider-Man?"
His mind had gone completely blank.
Behind him, Mattheo snorted.
"He doesn't know what Spider-Man is."
Theo shot him an unimpressed look.
"You literally just called him Spider-Boy."
Theo chose not to dignify that with a response.
You laughed so hard you had to cover your mouth.
"You seriously don't know Spider-Man?"
"...Do you at least know Marvel?"
You looked genuinely horrified.
Theo had the distinct feeling he'd somehow failed a test he hadn't realised he was taking.
"What exactly did you watch growing up?" you asked dramatically.
"Your parents should be arrested."
"For depriving you of the greatest superhero franchise ever created."
He glanced helplessly towards Lorenzo.
"...don't know what that means."
You pressed a hand to your chest as though personally wounded.
You thought for a moment before reaching into your pocket.
"I work at a comic book shop after this shift."
"...Actually, explaining it won't help."
Pulling out a receipt, you scribbled an address on the back before handing it to him.
Theo looked down at the paper.
"You don't even know me."
"You've somehow survived seventeen years without Marvel."
A grin spread across your face.
"That's a problem I can fix."
Someone called your name from behind the concession stand.
You glanced over your shoulder.
Looking back at Theo, you smiled apologetically.
"Sorry-I have to get back to work."
You started walking away before turning around again.
Then you disappeared behind the counter.
Theo stared after you for a moment before carefully folding the receipt and slipping it into his jacket pocket.
Mattheo noticed immediately.
"...You're actually thinking about going?"
"You spent the entire walk here complaining about this film."
"I was complaining about the premise."
Theo glanced towards the counter where you'd vanished.
"...Now it seems educational."
Mattheo barked out a laugh.
"I simply wish to understand this... Marvel."
Theo ignored him and turned towards Lorenzo, who had finally returned carrying an absurdly large bucket of popcorn.
"I need you to come somewhere with me after the film."
Theo hesitated for half a second.
"You know more about... Marvel."
A slow grin spread across Lorenzo's face.
The grin only grew wider.
"You just happen to need me because I know about superheroes."
"I need someone capable of explaining them."
"And," Theo added reluctantly, "you have Muggle money."
Mattheo doubled over laughing.
"Nott, you're unbelievable."
Theo looked genuinely offended.
"I don't get what's so funny"
"You've spoken to one girl for five minutes and suddenly you're voluntarily visiting a comic book shop."
"It is an educational trip."
By the time the film ended, Theo was already halfway to the exit.
He barely waited for the credits to finish before unfolding the receipt from his jacket pocket.
Mattheo noticed immediately.
"You also stood up before the post-credit scene."
Lorenzo gasped in horror.
"You left before the post-credit scene?"
"I've never watched a Marvel film before. How was I supposed to know there was another scene?"
Lorenzo sighed dramatically.
"I've failed you already."
Theo ignored him and continued walking.
A few streets later, a small shop came into view.
The display window was packed with colourful comics, superhero figurines, posters and memorabilia. Every inch seemed covered in bright reds, blues and golds.
Nothing like Flourish and Blotts.
A little bell chimed as they stepped inside.
Theo's eyes wandered across the shelves.
Just impossibly colourful covers filled with people flying through the sky.
You were standing behind the till, your hair now tied into two messy space buns. Gone was the red cinema uniform. Instead, you wore a faded black T-shirt with what looked like an angry raccoon holding a gun beside an oddly cheerful tree.
The shirt somehow suited you.
The moment your eyes landed on him, your face lit up.
"I honestly thought you were just being polite."
Before Theo could answer, you hurried around the counter.
"You've got excellent timing. It's completely dead in here."
Your eyes shifted to Lorenzo.
"...Is he your emotional support friend?"
"He came because he knows more about Marvel than I do."
"I distinctly remember asking."
You waved a dismissive hand.
"Whatever the reason, you're both here."
You clapped your hands together.
Without warning, you caught Theo's wrist.
Theo stiffened almost imperceptibly.
He wasn't accustomed to people touching him so casually.
Especially not people he'd known for less than a day.
You led him towards an entire wall labelled MARVEL, finally stopping in front of rows upon rows of comics.
"So," you said, folding your arms, "rule number one."
"Don't start with the complicated stuff."
You reached up and pulled out a comic.
You gestured at the shelf.
"This is barely scratching the surface."
Your hand wandered towards another section.
"If you end up liking these, we'll move on to the Avengers, Guardians of the Galaxy, X-Men, Fantastic Four-"
"You'll need someone to explain everything."
"And that someone is you?"
"Unless you happen to know another Marvel nerd."
Theo couldn't quite stop the tiny smile tugging at the corner of his mouth.
"I guess I'll have questions."
Across the aisle, Lorenzo leaned towards Mattheo.
"And I don't think he even realises it."
Back at the till, you carefully scanned each comic before placing them into a paper bag.
Sliding it across the counter, you smiled.
"When you're done, come back."
"And if I don't enjoy them?"
You gasped as though he'd committed a crime.
"I'll assume you read them wrong."
Ignoring him entirely, you pointed a finger at Theo.
"When you finish Spider-Man, I expect a full review."
"You'll quickly discover comic fans never shut up."
Theo looked down at the bag before meeting your eyes again.
"I guess I can manage that."
By the time Theo returned to Hogwarts that evening, the paper bag was tucked safely beneath his arm.
Mattheo looked over from his bed.
"You are actually going to read those?"
Mattheo threw a pillow over his face.
"It's one in the morning."
Theo turned another page.
"You've been reading for hours."
He still wasn't entirely convinced by Marvel.
How exactly had a spider bite turned a scrawny teenager into a superhero?
And Captain America made even less sense.
One injection and suddenly the man had muscles?
Even Polyjuice Potion didn't work like that.
You had asked for his opinion.
He refused to disappoint you.
One chapter became another.
Without quite noticing, he reached the final page.
"...Well," he murmured to himself.
"...That wasn't that bad."
Theo read every comic twice.
He made mental notes of every question that came to mind.
He memorised character names, storylines and villains.
He even cornered Lorenzo on multiple occasions.
"Why does everyone like Tony Stark so much?"
"Because he's Tony Stark."
"That's hardly an explanation."
Theo was beginning to suspect Marvel fans were impossible.
He refused to return looking uninformed.
The bell above the comic shop door chimed.
You looked up from organising a shelf.
A smile spread across your face.
Today your T-shirt featured an enormous grape man wearing golden armour.
You leaned across the counter excitedly.
Theo took a measured breath.
"I have... a lot pf thoughts."
"Oh, this is going to be good."
You hurried him towards a small table tucked into the corner of the shop.
You rested your chin in your hands.
"I enjoyed Spider-Man. A lot"
"I don't get why everything thinks Captain America is so perfect."
You stared at him in mock horror.
"Steven Grant Rogers is practically husband material."
Theo frowned thoughtfully.
You pretended to consider it.
Theo couldn't help laughing with you.
He still wasn't entirely sure what it meant.
But hearing you laugh made him want to keep asking questions.
By the time you'd enthusiastically explained another dozen Marvel characters, you disappeared between the shelves before returning with yet another stack of comics.
"Oh, we're just getting started."
"I've spent the last two weeks reading these."
He accepted the comics anyway.
"You asked something from me."
You tilted your head curiously.
Theo nodded towards the café across the street.
"...Are you asking me out?"
"Whether you're saying yes."
A grin slowly spread across your face.
"I was beginning to wonder if you'd ever ask."
"You've been looking at me like you wanted to for at least ten minutes."
He looked away for the briefest second.
You pretended to think it over.
"Only because I like your accent."
Theo's answering smile came effortlessly.
Weeks slipped quietly into months.
Somewhere between comic books, milkshakes, and endless debates over superheroes...
Theodore Nott fell in love.
It happened so gradually he never noticed the exact moment.
Maybe it was when he realised he could identify your footsteps before you reached the comic shop door.
Or when he started bringing enough chips because he knew you'd steal half of them despite insisting you weren't hungry.
Or perhaps it was the afternoon you spent nearly twenty minutes trying to rescue a pigeon that had become trapped behind a rubbish bin.
He'd found that strangely endearing.
He learned that you wore mismatched socks simply because you thought matching ones were "boring."
That you couldn't walk past a bookshop without wandering inside.
That you cried whenever an old dog appeared in a film.
That you somehow knew every song playing on the radio.
That you talked with your hands so enthusiastically he occasionally worried you'd accidentally hit someone in the face.
He always opened doors for you.
Always walked on the side closest to the road.
And no matter how many times you protested...
"I literally have money."
"I don't want you to, cara."
He learned your favourite milkshake was chocolate.
That you preferred rainy afternoons over sunny ones.
That you absent-mindedly reached for his hand whenever you crossed a busy road.
At first, holding your hand had made him acutely aware of every brush of your fingers.
Like it had always belonged there.
The first time he kissed you, the two of you were sitting on a bench overlooking the Thames.
The sun had begun to dip below the skyline, painting the water in streaks of gold and amber.
You'd somehow spent the better part of three hours arguing over whether Superman could defeat Thor.
Theo was firmly convinced the debate had become absurd nearly an hour ago.
You, apparently, disagreed.
"No, listen," you insisted, gesturing wildly. "Thor's literally a god."
"So flying is rather useful."
"I don't think that's how power scaling works."
"You've said that phrase six times."
"Because you keep making terrible arguments."
"I believe mine are perfectly reasonable."
"They're objectively wrong."
The conversation drifted into comfortable silence.
You leaned back against the bench, watching the river.
After a few moments, you looked at him.
"I've turned you into a complete nerd."
"I think you'll find the correct term is well-informed."
"You assigned me homework."
"I can't believe I accidentally converted Theodore Nott into a Marvel fan."
"I wouldn't go that far."
"I still think the serum is scientifically questionable."
You smiled so brightly it almost made him forget what he'd been saying.
"I like this version of you."
Theo's expression softened.
For a moment, neither of you spoke.
Then, quietly, you reached up and rested your hand against his cheek.
"I'm really glad you walked into that cinema."
"I believe you walked into me."
No sweeping declarations.
Just a gentle, tentative kiss that somehow said everything neither of you quite knew how to put into words.
When he pulled away, you were still smiling.
"You smile differently around me."
"You get this little..." You pointed to the corner of your own mouth. "...smirk."
"You are literally smirking right now."
Theo let out another quiet laugh.
"I think you're imagining things."
"You've been staring at me for the past five minutes."
"I'm admiring my boyfriend."
"You've never called me that before."
He intertwined your fingers with his.
As autumn settled over London, one question continued to resurface.
"What school do you actually go to?"
"We're doing this again?"
"You dodge the question every single time."
"You tell me you go to Hogwarts."
"You are so committed to this joke."
Theo rubbed a hand across his face.
"My homework genuinely consists of Potions essays."
"They're remarkably efficient."
You laughed so hard you had to wipe tears from your eyes.
"You've expanded the lore."
"This whole wizard story."
You looked so utterly convinced he was teasing you that he almost laughed himself.
"I like your stories, Theo."
Something in his chest sank.
Even more, he hated that the truth sounded impossible.
The conversation lingered as the two of you wandered through the evening streets.
Shops were beginning to close.
Streetlights flickered to life overhead.
You were in the middle of telling him about a new comic series when-
A deafening crack split the air.
A section of scaffolding had broken loose from the building above.
You were still looking at him.
His wand was in his hand before he even realised he'd drawn it.
A shimmering barrier burst into existence.
The scaffolding slammed into it with a deafening crash.
For one impossible heartbeat, it hung suspended in the air.
Then it toppled harmlessly onto the pavement beside you.
Not towards the wreckage.
His arm was still raised.
His wand still pointed forward.
Every trace of colour had drained from his face.
Your gaze dropped to the wand.
Then to the shattered scaffolding.
"...You're actually a wizard."
Theo gave the smallest nod.
"MY BOYFRIEND IS REAL-LIFE DOCTOR STRANGE!"
"...That's your first thought?"
You pointed accusingly at him.
"You've been carrying around actual magic this whole time!"
"And you never thought to lead with that?"
Theo let out a quiet laugh, shaking his head.
"Merlin... I tell you I'm a wizard, and the first thing you think is Doctor Strange?"
"...he's the only wizard I know."
Theo smiled-a small, fond smile that was reserved entirely for you.
He gently tugged you closer.
Tag list - @pbjts @bunnieeegohop @mooniez @ithinkaboutyouuu @yourstargirlyyy