Before sheâs even made her point about Sirius, Jamesâ mouth is open, ready to come to his best friendâs defense whole-heartedly. Sirius is the bravest person heâs ever met, heâs had to make the hardest choices just to be good, and he wonât ever let anyone tell him otherwise, not even Lily. But because this is her, and because she seems to be willing to listen to him, he listens before answering (a very rare occurrence, if you ask anyone whoâs ever met him). He huffs; of course he loves Sirius. But then he frowns, because Sirius would never, and Lily predicts this reaction too, so he decides to just stop reacting and start listening to what sheâs trying to say. Sheâs too smart for him, this conversation feels like like a constant challenge, one where she matches him every step of the way, and he doesnât know if he likes it, but that may simply be because heâs so used to having the last word.
And obviously sheâs so smart she finds the one way to put things that shows him just how exactly it must feel, and maybe explains why she seems to be arguing and arguing for the worth of someone heâs never seen as anything other than despicable. âAre you saying Snape is your Sirius? Because Iâm sorry for you, in that case,â he answers, but his tone is light, almost joking. He still wants to argue that itâs not the same; but something about their fragile dynamic makes him hesitate. âI understand, I do. I do,â he repeats, maybe trying to convince himself more than her. âI can see why you might be the one person, against all common sense, whoâll always find an excuse for his behavior. And I wonât push you, not because I agree with you, but because I think this might a case of letâs agree to disagree - which Iâm definitely not used to, in case you didnât know. But I still donât think Sirius and Snape are comparable in any way. Because Sni-Snape was always that way, whether or not you could see it. I canât begin to imagine what you must have felt when he called you that word. But you and I both know heâd been doing it to others long before. And so the betrayal isnât so chocking if the guy youâve always liked, or Merlin forbid, loved, was always a twat,â he says looking down at his hands, which he still doesnât know what to do with. âMaybe thereâs a part of me thatâs angry at you, too, for being friends with him,â he adds while his voice lowers, almost shyly. âMaybe I hold you to a higher standard, but I feel like I wouldnât forgive anyone if they were friends with a guy like that. Because it means youâre complicit in his bullshit, if youâre letting him say those things. Doesnât it?â he looks up at her, hopefully, almost hoping sheâll prove him wrong because he doesnât like the conclusions heâs coming to.Â
He doesnât know what is it that makes him do it - doesnât know if thereâs a single thought going through his mind, or just his body acting on pure instinct, fully expecting to receive a hex in response. But in that moment he grabs her hand, lightly, and looks straight into her eyes. âHey, donât. I wonât spend a minute listening to you find a way to twist his prejudice as somehow being your fault. Or as somehow making you a bad person too. No way, no. Youâre human, Evans, oh no, big reveal! Youâre human and you cared about someone and he treated you alright for a while, until he didnât. Thatâs all there is to it, now as hard as it is, all youâve got to do is stop making excuses.â Also, I donât blame you for thinking that; you are pretty dang special indeed, he thinks to himself, barely catching the words in his throat before they make it out.
Feeling drained and more vulnerable he ever has or ever wants to feel again, James leans back into his chair, dropping her hand back on the table, and tries to smile along with her. âThat you do - I have bruises to attest to that,â he says with a grin. With a joking frown, he decides that this nonchalant, humorous territory feels much safer than the road they were headed down with this conversation. âI mean, are you sure? According to you, I sound pretty âperfectâ indeed. What was it you called me again? âGryffindorâs golden boy,â âtalented,â âlovedâ? Oh, and I forgot the best oneâ handsome, was it?â he answers with glee. âSounds like I might be worth those higher standards after all. So donât worry about that one bit, Iâll just have to try and live up to themâ he finishes, extending his arm over the chair next to him. @lilyxcvansâ
She rolls her eyes a bit at his feigned sympathy, but thereâs no malice behind it. Sheâs starting to understand that thatâs just how James Potter handles serious conversations, by injecting a little bit of humor into them. Honestly, sheâs a little grateful for it in this moment. This whole thing has gotten more deep and complicated than she ever intended, and she needs the dose of levity right now. Still, something he says makes her pause, and she feels the need to defend herself. âBut thatâs the thing,â she swears, âIâm not excusing his behavior. What heâs chosen to believe is wrong, and I know that. There is no excuse for it. But that doesnât change the fact that he was my best friend, and that I canât hate him completely. Trust me, I know that it would be easier if I could. I know you do,â she says, âBut you canât expect me to feel about him the same way you do, any more than I can expect you to feel the way I do.â
She shakes her head. âIâm not comparing Sirius and Severus.â A little smile of amusement quirks her lips, and she says, âLord knows theyâd both take offense to it if I did. Iâm comparing the relationship. Sirius is your best friend, Severus was mine. And maybe he didnât change overnight, but youâre wrong about him always being this way,â she protests. She considers for a moment before deciding to confess, âI knew him from before Hogwarts, you know. He was the first person to tell me that I was a witch. Finally, all the things that I thought were wrong with me, that made me a freak, someone could explain. I was different, but not in a bad way. He was the first person to make me see that.â Her eyes turn wistful as she gets caught back up in the memories. âAnd he didnât care one bit back then that I was a muggleborn, never cared anything about the blood purity nonsense that he and his friends go on about now.â She thinks of a little boy with bruises that never seemed to fade, and sad eyes that only seemed to light up when they saw her, and she has to turn away again. âHe was the first person to think that there was something special about me. And obviously over the years things have changed; heâs gotten caught up more with the blood purists, heâs become far too interested in dark magic. But that wasnât always who he was. And again, Iâm not excusing him, or making justifications for it. Iâm just saying that people can change, and when you donât change together, letting go is hard.â
Sheâs surprised when he takes her hand, but she doesnât pull away. She finds that she appreciates the gesture. She listens to him, wishing she could believe that he was right, but something holds her back. âBut isnât it like you said? By being friends with him, wasnât I âcomplicit in his bullshit,â as you put it?â she asks, not sure she wants to know the answer. âHe was careful to never say those things around me, but I knew the company he kept, and they were never shy about making it clear what they thought of me, or Mary or Ted. I donât blame myself for his prejudice,â sheâs quick to reassure. âI just...I wonder if I was willfully ignorant, if I only saw what I wanted to see. And if I was, did I stand by while injustice was being done, purely because I didnât want to see it. I donât...I donât like to think that about myself,â she says in a small voice.
She rolls her eyes again as he throws he own words back at her, but sheâs laughing, so she hopes he doesnât take offense. âYouâre impossible,â she protests, still laughing. âAnd for the record, if you ever tell anyone I said any of those things, I will deny it to my grave, so donât even think about it.â Shaking her head with a fond smile, she finds that when heâs not making her question everything sheâs ever believed about herself, she actually enjoys his company. Itâs nice to laugh again, even of the moment is brief. For a while there, she was afraid she had forgotten how.Â