Name: Madeline Benson Age: 27 Sexuality: Heterosexual Gender: Female Portrayed By: Troian Bellisario (not negotiable) Availability: Closed
“Annie was okay… most of the time. She could get a bit weird, though…”
Madeline Benson has always been a good friend to have. She’s loyal, witty, and good at giving advice. She’s another of the older girls Annie used to hang out with in the shopping centre or behind the bike sheds, and has always seemed to love her life. Her friends were her whole world, no question about it. She, Lacey, Abigail, and Dakota were considered cool, though not up there with the likes of Annie Pierce and her crew, but that stuff didn’t really matter to Maddie. She just liked having her mates to laugh and joke around with. She smoked, though not excessively, and spent most of her time at the shopping centre with her four best friends.
When Annie Pierce started hanging with them, she didn’t really mind at first, but as soon as Annie discovered her biggest secret things started to change between them. However, Maddie was always too nice to tell Annie to back off so she put up with it for a long time. It kind of caused a rift between her and her friends, probably because it felt like they could feel there was something being hidden and concealed from them. Annie tended to try and play them all off against each other and nobody seemed to have it in them to tell her to back off, which was frustrating. Of course, Annie’s body being discovered was a shock. Maddie had felt terrible when the girl had disappeared because it was such a horrible situation. When the police hadn’t found Annie at first, Maddie thought she’d perhaps been kidnapped. It was awful that she’d been buried in the woods this entire time. Just hit in the back of the head with a rock and left to rot. Still… this meant her secret was safe, right? It was a gruesome thought that she always felt guilty for but she was sure she wasn’t the only one who thought it.
After Annie disappeared and was found again, Maddie had a simple enough life, living alone in a little flat and working at Spice. She was fairly happy with the way things have turned out and feels like her life is finally getting back on track, and it felt like it was about time. She drifted from her friends a little but she reconnected with them again eventually. Seemed like the four of them just couldn’t stay apart, even when Abi disappeared with her boyfriend Ben and came back alone, and then skipped town again a while later. After that, Maddie started dating Abi’s ex boyfriend Ryan. Of course she had no idea that Ryan was the reason that Abi even left town, or that he was abusive. She soon found out though, and what followed was a horrible situation. She suffered through the abuse at his hands because she loved him, she really did, she wanted to believe in the good in him. Even after they visited his parents and they were awfulto her, ending up making her cry by asking for her parents and making a joke about them being dead… he was so nice. So good. So through the attacks, the self harm, and a suicide attempt… Maddie stayed.
Until she just.. couldn’t. He promised he would change when he found out she was pregnant… but Maddie tragically lost their baby and she went to London to stay with her uncle for a while. When she came back, they tried again, but nothing changed and eventually Maddie just couldn’t take it anymore. She left town for good, going once again to her uncle’s place, staying with him until she got back on her feet. She did her best to recover and start her life over, but nothing ever quite felt right again. Maddie wasn’t sure why she came back home. Maybe she wanted to face her demons. Maybe she wanted to punish herself. Regardless, her uncle came with her this time, and she felt a bit better. Stronger in some sense… but Maddie is more than a bit anxious and she just hopes she can find it in herself to cope and get on with life. Finally move on and find some happiness.
Maddie’s father used to be physically abusive when he got angry. It didn’t really start happening until her mother got into a terrible car accident and wound up in a coma. Annie found out about it and used to come round to the house and sleep over, under the pretence of helping. Madeline’s father wouldn’t do anything to her with a friend in the house, after all, but as time went on it became apparent that Annie was only there because she wanted to see something happen. She used to try and wind Maddie’s father up, testing the limit to see how far he was willing to let her go until he just snapped and perhaps even hit them both. Maybe Annie wanted him to hit her - she did love a drama, after all. Being the victim. Nothing worked, he would just wait until Annie was gone the next morning and Maddie would get the full brunt of his wrath.
Just weeks before Annie disappeared, she walked into the house uninvited and came face to face with a terrible scene. Maddie was standing in the living room sobbing, blood running down her face from a bad cut on her head, her father standing in the middle of the room glaring at her. Annie had easily put it together and moved towards him, which had angered him. He screamed at Annie to get out but she refused, grabbing a gymnastics trophy from the mantelpiece and swinging it round. Hard. He’d fallen and Annie had hit him again, and again… until Maddie had pulled her back, screaming at her to stop. But it was too late. Madeline’s father was on the floor, blood pooling on the carpet. “He had to feel exactly the amount of pain he inflicted on you.” were Annie’s cold words.
Then Annie called the police, saying it was the right thing to do, but that she would help her through it. Maddie should have protested when Annie lied to the police, saying she walked in on Maddie’s father attacking her and that Madeline had hit him in self defence but she didn’t… she didn’t want to get Annie in trouble by calling her out on the lie. And it all worked out, anyway, the police took pity on Maddie. After all, the blood on her face, her bruised eye, sold the story pretty well and Annie had put the trophy into her hand while she called the police. Since Maddie was a minor, the police put out a story about Mr Benson committing suicide, overcome with grief after switching his wife’s life support off just days before, and Annie got away with murder. Maddie swore she would never let any of this get out. Lying to the police was a serious thing, how could she have been so stupid?