l. evans
Her stomach twisted into a combination of fear and nerves, her sudden urge to confess dissipating as quickly as the mist she’d managed using the Charm, at the tone Moody was using. Disapproval, disappointment. Lily hated letting people down, it was her sorest point, associating conflict with rejection. For that she could probably thank Petunia. It made her feel guilty relief that he had taken her quick and desperate subject change so much to heart.
Lily relished giving complete honesty on this matter at least, speaking quickly in her eagerness to relieve some of her bad feelings, “We were checking on the inmates and it swooped down on us. Well, on me mostly. The Senior Healer I was with, she said that it had never happened before. Do you think it’s possible that they’re out of the Ministry’s control?” Lily asked, genuinely fearful about it. It had been terrifying, seeing the creatures that guarded Azkaban and the effects that came from being close to them, even before one had attacked her. “There were so many of them there.” They were already outnumbered by Death Eaters.
That meant she needed to get this Charm. She never wanted to be under their power again, it had been bad enough once. Being forced to hear Bellatrix’s voice … that had left her weak and doubting, as she’d been ever since the encounter with Lestrange.
What had she just said? I suppose it’s like this spell. You need conviction, to believe in something strongly enough that doubts can’t affect you. Lily had been shaken, she didn’t believe anymore, not in herself. That image, the perfect Lily Evans, something she clung to when she was reminded of her sister’s hate, of half the wizarding world’s hate - that it wasn’t her fault. It had taken a beating here, because she hadn’t been faultless. And that was far more dificult a position for her to take than the one in judgement of others.
She had confessed this before, to James, to Marlene. This wasn’t a confession. “I lied before. Or misled. I think the Dementor came to me because it could sense it. Blood magic. I saved someone’s life with it. A Death Eater. At least I think she is. I made a bad choice. I regret it. But I know I did only what I thought was right, that it wasn’t for bad motives. And so I’m not going to apologise for it anymore. I’m going to make up for it.”
Lily suddenly remembered who she was talking to, the Auror, the senior Order member, the man she respected nearly as much as Professor Dumbledore or McGonagall and froze, her declaration which had all the solemnity and self-righteousness of a vow quickly brushed aside in panic, “I mean, I don’t mean to yell at you, sir. Alastor. Moody. I know you’re right that it’s a serious issue. And that Dumbledore certainly isn’t the last word of the law. I don’t mean to put you in a difficult position.”
It didn’t mean all her guilt was gone. But she had to believe. There would be no point to any of this, no way she could fight if she didn’t. And there was a future worth fighting for. Her wand was right there, she itched to try the spell again, certain that she was capable of it right here, right now, with this confidence burning in her heart. “And so, anything you want to say to me, you can. I promise I’ll listen. But I’d really like to do this first. Expecto Patronum.” Lily wasn’t waiting for the corporal form to take shape this time. She knew it would. For a moment she thought, Prongs, in startled but not surprised confusion before seeing the subtle difference, the doe rather than the stag.
Whichever guesses Moody had foolishly made inside his head in an attempt to soften the looming blow were quickly proven to be surprisingly and utterly wrong. Impulsively, he had opened his mouth to reply but found himself at a loss for words. It felt as though he had been walking down a staircase, in a pitch-black room, then missed a step.
At first, Moody was hesitant, the disbelief still nibbling at him. But he was willing to listen ----- something entirely uncharacteristic of him, but done so out of an overpowering intrigue that he feared could spiral into paranoia if this turned out to be more serious a matter than previously expected.
“Out of the Ministry’s control?” he felt like an utter idiot for simply echoing every other of Lily’s word. There was almost a childlike frustration that surfaced at the lack of answers, the lack of explanations. “Such thing has never happened in the past. Not to my knowledge. Now...” now, as terrifying of a possibility as it was, it did not sound incredibly far-fetched. “Now I don’t know. I don’t know,” sure, he knew there was bravery in admitting defeat or ignorance, but not now, not when the need of a definite answer was so strong. “I’ll talk to Cresswell. He’s got connections in the Ministry - the kind that could help with this. But the simple act of asking would make us look insane... not only that, but it could draw a lot of attention to us, Evans. Maybe we’re dealing with something entirely new.”
He had almost -- ALMOST -- forgotten the Patronus spell altogether. To be fair, he did not expect this whirlwind to unfold during the lesson either.
But just as he drove himself back to the instruction, he felt taken aback by yet another fearful revelation. And at first, Moody could do little but to eye Lily. He wondered if James’ affinity for humor had resonated with her, if this were all but an elaborate joke to test him or drive him to the extreme. He couldn’t ignore how outlandish but unexpectedly odd the scenario told by Lily was. He couldn’t envision her making up such tale either.
And, as had become a common occurrence only recently, Moody did not know what to think.
He closed his mouth for both of their sakes, feeling compelled by her determination and willingness to stand up for herself. Not that he was a formidable figure, but she had guts revealing such worrying secret and carrying on in such a straightforward fashion.
So, if only for a moment, Moody waited. He frowned, looking at Lily and how her wand sprouted the bright strings that soon morphed into the detailed outline of a doe. He stared in secluded awe and suffocated admiration at the sharpness of the figure and cleanliness of the spellwork itself. The words he’d heard from so many became visible amidst his thoughts -- Lily Evans was indeed a remarkable witch, achieving such complicated spell when countless others were driven to fits upon failing to do cast the aforementioned charm.
But, Alastor Moody thought, that didn’t take away the shock and annoyance he felt at the display of poor common sense.
“Now, that’s impressive, Evans. Really impressive,” he began, somewhat carefully as if he were debating whether or not to even bring the matter up. Merlin, his insides boiled, irritated, at how he wanted but to bask in the pride and satisfaction ordinarily derived from this but could and would not. Not yet, at least.
“Evans--” Alastor queried, his tone clearly begging to be proven wrong, to be corrected, for all to be clarified or debunked as a prank-- “tell me you didn’t really save one of those bastards’ life using blood magic.” He was beginning to sound like a broken record, and he loathed it, but not as much as he loathed cases of impulsive decision-making that were becoming frequent amid the younger Order members.



















