I have,,, a legitimate theory. It is of course for the Seeker. I am a Seeker stan.
Okay, things we know, the evidence:
-Humans only stay conscious if they're taken as adults and knew what was gonna happen to them, so later into the occupation.
-The Seeker hasn't been to another planet. This is her first.
-She thinks Fords Deep Waters would have reacted poorly to the early years of the occupation, suggesting she was there for it.
-She tells Wanderer that she agrees that childhood is "extraordinarily tedious."
-The Seeker is not a skipper.
-The souls have known about Earth and had it slated for full scale occupation for over a century, as there are souls on the planet during canon, who came from planets over a century away.
So, for the seeker to have a strong enough opinion of childhood to call it "extraordinarily tedious", I would think she would have to have been a child here on Earth herself, not just seeing it though her host, but either way that couldn't have been Lacey, or Lacey would not have remained conscious.
So Lacey cannot be The Seeker's first host. The seeker had to have been inserted into Lacey during the occupation, after the death or near death of her previous host.
That just leaves the questions of,,,, how many previous hosts? How long has she been here, Seeker-ing? What happened to her previous host? Was it death by old age? Or, being that it happened in the middle of a war we suspect she was participating in from the beginning, something more violent?
What if- and that was the crux of the theory, that Lacey isnt the Seekers fist host, the rest of this is just what can't technically be disproven by the narrative- Lacey, Wild Human that she was, nearly killed our seeker in an escape attempt that failed, and so other seekers or souls present, preformed emergency surgery on the spot and put The Seeker into Lacey, the only avaliable host in the moment, to save her life?
Could you imagine, not just being stuck in the body of your would-be murderer, but stuck with her screaming in you head?
Could you imagine not just having your would-be murderer piloting your body, but not being able to retaliate in any way but your words and thoughts?!!?!?
And even if it wasn't Lacey, she still might have been amost-killed by a wild human, and then she woke up in a host that was screaming at her just like Wanderer.
Maybe our Seeker, having been with Lacey for years, HAS managed to pick Laceys brain for her rebel pockets secrets. What if Lacey had to watch as all her friend and family were caught, seeing her but not HER chasing them down!?
Also, if Lacey had previously been hiding out either on her own or with others, she might have been complaining about the caves because her hideout was like, in the city with electricity and plumming, like I never really thought about it, like why would you be ungrateful to be safe, but her safety might have been better, we don't know.
And isn't that the tragedy!?
And of course going back to the number of hosts, if we Assume low and Lacey is only second, but give the previous host, Idk a healthy 45 years, she would have seen every human tragedy from like the 70s to the early 2000s of we assume the novel takes place in its publishing year of 08
Of we Assume high, third or fourth, hell she could have seen world War 1 and 2.
@whydoistilllikethehost @onespacedown @ld-link-sixteen @manonbeakblack to continue the sequal/prequel discussion, this has just been in my drafts a minute.