Why Charles isn’t A
This is my first theory about pll and Charles so please be a little gentle with me, haha! Came up with it al by myself!
Don’t you think its strange Charles is A? A had been torturing those girls for years and years and all of a sudden he wants to meet Alison? Why did he suddenly change his mind? The cops aren’t any closer to catching him so why would he show his identity? It just doesn’t make any sense.
I don’t think Charles is A. He might be on the A-team for a while and maybe he is fed up with A. Maybe he joined the A-team to get to know more about the liars. And maybe it finally became clear Big A will never stop torturing the liars. So Charles wants to meet Alison and steps out of the A-game. Just like Mona did.
Btw, Mona is still involved with A. In the promopictures of next week episode she is wearing a red cape, just like all of A’s helpers.
A always ends its messages with -A or Kisses A.
But when Charles texted Alison he ended the text with xo Charles.
In the promo we see Charles standing on the edge of a building and assuming by the reactions of the liars, he jumps. Maybe he knows he will die anyway because he betrayed Big A so in his mind, jumping is the best option. I dont believe he will go trough all this trouble to meet Alison and a few moments later he voluntarily jumps of the building. And also, if the police catch him, he will be in jail for a looooong time.
So i guess, after this episode we know Charles used to be part of the a-team before he left but he isnt Big A. I still believe Aria has something to do with being Big A. I would love that! There are over thousand theories about her being A, so check them out!
