It’s been a little while since I last posted anything on here, and I haven’t really wanted to ‘make a statement’ on social media about the whole EU referendum (not for any particular reason, I just felt it wasn’t necessary), but in light of the vote’s result this morning and the implications this has on my future, the future of Wales and the future of the United Kingdom, I felt that it was an appropriate time to do so.
For the purposes of context, I have been - unsurprisingly, I hope - a firm supporter of the notion that we should stay a part of the European Union. Not for any economic reason, certainly not because David Cameron thought it a good idea. My reasons for voting to remain yesterday were primarily based on what my relationship is with the EU and how it interacts with my life - I fully accept that as it currently is, the EU is not a great system and is not as democratic as people would have us believe, but I think the telling difference between myself and others who voted to leave is that I firmly believed (and still do) that the EU can be reformed with the involvement of other European countries.
What it does allow, though, is unrestricted travel across the member states - anyone from this country could pick up their life, move to anywhere in Europe and all they would have to do to become a resident of that country is notify the local authority. That’s it. I appreciate that’s not going to be of importance to a lot of people, but the fact is that it’s still a perk of the EU.
It also contributes massively - and I fear the Welsh people really haven’t grasped quite how frighteningly massive the EU’s contribution to us is - to supporting Wales, unreservedly across the land: the farmers in Wales are heavily subsidized, there are EU initiatives that have resulted in new facilities being built and funded without any direct affect on the people of Wales, the bulk of the funding for arts and cultural programs comes from the EU in Wales. It’s inescapable that we are the biggest net beneficiary of all the United Kingdom when it comes to the EU, and if any Welsh person honestly believes that a Conservative government, under the leadership of Boris Johnson (or whoever it turns out to be), will work tirelessly to ensure that Wales will not miss out on “a single penny” as a result of our leaving, then I question that person’s judgement.
To most, that might read as purely anti-English cynicism, but considering this Conservative government - whilst still leashed to the EU - has already presided over some of the biggest cuts to welfare and social care, what on this good earth makes anyone think they’re about to buck that trend? Not a single person have I met who voted for Conservative in the most recent general election now thinks they made the right decision. And now we’re on the brink of being governed by a Conservative government, unshackled from any measures put in place by the EU, that is likely to be lead by someone who allied himself with spreaders of paranoia and fear.
Honestly, my greatest problem with how this campaign has been fought is to do with the way that the leave side have tackled immigration. By which I mean they have done seemingly everything in their power to dehumanize immigrants and create an atmosphere of fear and resentment towards them. The leaders of the leave campaign have tried to moderate and calm these accusations by saying, almost as if they’re doing everybody a favour, that they’re actually in favour of immigration - provided it’s “controlled”, whatever that will show itself to mean.
Personally, this referendum has proven to be quite divisive among my family; I’m the only person in clan Ford, that I know of, who voted for us to remain. Everybody else - parents and sister - voted for us to leave, albeit their reasoning I understand (though still disagree with), and the subject of immigration has come up as quite a heated topic of conversation. Not because any of my family - that I know of - have developed into ardent xenophobes, but because they have aligned themselves with a campaign that has deliberately set out misleading information which has, and it kills me as a Welsh and British person to say this, resonated with the fear in the British public.
On the BBC Wales EU debate that was broadcast on Wednesday evening, the leader of Wales’ nationalist party (perhaps a rarity in the context of nationalist parties, in that there has never been a connotation of racism associated with Plaid Cymru, unless it’s towards the English - equally inexcusable and tribalistic of them) said that some of the rhetoric being used by the leave campaign on the subject of immigrants wasn’t too far off what was being said at the beginning of the 1930s in Germany. The response from the pro-leave section of the audience and its panellists was to laugh this comment off as rude and hysterical.
Is it rational behaviour to put out posters that openly advertise an anti-EU immigrant message, and yet make use of pictures of Syrian refugees seeking shelter on the European continent? Is it right that people call for our borders to be secured to prevent more European people coming into this country, when the total level of EU immigrants living here compared to our total population is something pathetically small like 0.25% and the vast majority of immigrants come from countries outside of the EU, i.e. immigration that we can control and don’t?
There has not been any direct persecution of “the immigrant”, not by those that have enough power to cause serious damage (though I do not excuse UKIP and its members for their behaviour), but then the same was true back then in Germany. There was no open, inflammatory declaration that all Jews were to be put to the sword, because that approach - quite fucking rightly - only reveals the wielder of those words to be what they really are, but there was a gradual building on a national feeling of resentment following a period of recession.
Is it a surprise that across Europe, where there are countries that don’t have the scale of economy that we fortunately do, there’s been a rise in the far-right parties? It shouldn’t be, there’s a pattern in history of those on the far-right gathering momentum in times of economic difficulty. I don’t know why this happens, because it’s precisely during these times that we should be coming together as a society, rather than finding someone else to blame for the problems caused by the government, regardless of which colour’s in the hot-seat.
In the interest of fairness, I acknowledge whole-heartedly and unreservedly that this is not a fair representation of everybody who supported the leave campaign; as I said, my family all voted to leave and I know that none of my family are racist.
What’s important now, at least in my mind, is that the result of this decision is roundly accepted by both sides. Ultimately this was a democratic exercise and, regardless of the result, a decision has been made as a direct result of the question being put to the people. I don’t have to - nor will I ever - like the outcome, but I will not be one of these people promoting petitions for a second referendum, advertising how bleak the world will be now as a result. Bollocks to that, they might have won the vote, but that’s no excuse to become bitter and isolated.
Whatever the outcome is from all of this, there’s no doubting that the European relationship is now forever transformed and, objectively at least, the prospect of knowing that we, as a nation, are about to enter the unknown is exciting, if a little concerning.
The way we’ve come to this decision leaves a lot to be desired of us as a people, and it’s exposed the truth that we really aren’t even close to being the tolerant British public we like to make ourselves out to be - it’s my absolute hope that we fix that as soon as possible, because the Wales and the Britain that I’ve grown up in is better than what we’ve shown of ourselves in the past few weeks. We’re better than succumbing to fear-mongering, we’re better than the “little island” mentality, we’re better when we engage with the rest of the world. We just need to remember that.