Knight's Identity is STUPID
Let me Explain.
SPOILERS AHEAD
Since the Release of Chapter 5 a new Theory have emerged regarding Knight's Identity
Kris and Noelle Amalgam Knight or as i like to call it Kriselle Knight. i recomend to check out this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JT97Fy-vszQ&list=LL&index=16&t=2s they dive much better into the whole ordeal
But as a recap:
Noelle and Kris drown during the Weird route somehow fusing into an amalgamate
the Sound that Knight makes souding similar to Noelle i literally them being Noelle.
similar with Knight making Kris' poses, them literally being Kris.
Knight's Flavour text is eerily similar describing what happends during Ch5 weird route. With the only Act in the Fight being Hold Breath.
Noelle wants to break free from her Role, as plenty of Secret Bosses have shown.
Thematically ties to the Grander Narrative of the game, Suggesting that there is a time loop that the Knight causes and that the 1 Ending Deltarune promises so much, is us Killing the Knight. Those are the main points from the theory, Again check out the Video to see more details.
But now for why this Theory is Bullshit
Kriselle theory begins to fall Apart first of all because of the Baseball iconography.
The knight have been shown to have multiple Baseball themed things.
That one sprite of their sword looking like a bat
Knight Looking like a Baseball in their ball Form
WHY WOULD THE MOON BE A BASEBALL IN CYBER WORLD IF THE KNIGHT DOESN'T HAS ANY CONNECTION TO BASEBALL???
We Know Dess absolutley have a connection to baseball
The Bat in Dess' room
and Noelle says this in chapter 1: * So Dess smacked you with a wiffle bat 'til you stopped lying.
And then there's Old Man
Now as we all know... Gerson Boom appears as a darkner in Church's dark world during Chapter 4, In a very much mentor figure like state. WE KNOW that Darkners Patterned after memories of Love appear in very specific Darknesses.
AND WE KNOW That Kris Never had Gerson as their teacher. And Since Kris and Noelle are the same age, it's safe to assume Noelle also Didn't came across Gerson as a teacher.
RIDDLE ME THIS BATMAN
How can Gerson appear as a Darkner in chapter 4, if Kris and Noelle never had a proper memory of him?
It's Not to say that Dess Knight is a perfect theory too. It has Holes which can't be properly filled.
What is her Motive?
Isn't she Trapped in the Code?
Yeah Yeah we know that
All i'm saying is that Knight's Identity is Self Contradicting.
it's like a gearbox. A Set of gears mesh with each other but the whole Mechanism Jam because of other gears you can't ignore.
Unless the Knight is SOMEHOW Dess Kris and Noelle all at the same time WHICH IS RIDICULOUS SOUNDING The Knight's Identity Remains a mystery.
Anyway
i think this is what people did on long posts in Once Upon a Time
