Writer’s Quandary
I just had an editorial assessment of my manuscript completed and I have a gay dilemma. By that, I do not mean I have a fun dilemma. Not a ‘do I really need to tuck my jumpers into my jeans just to prove I’m a bisaster’ dilemma. I have gay characters throwing rainbow confetti over my serious WWI psychological drama.
My book focuses on three brothers. I inadvertently made one of them gay. It was not intentional, he just came out that way like any other baby. A minor character also ended up being gay because I don’t like my boys being lonely.
I tried my darndest to reign in the romance for three main reasons:
Lack of historical information about LGBTQIA+ communities during WWI. I have a background in history. This is a work of fiction but oof my heart is covered in elbow patches and being inaccurate tears the seams apart.
WWI books and films often add romantic subplots (and it would be a subplot) to lighten the war front sections. I don’t want it to be a cliché.
For the sake of THE PLOT™, one of them has to die for the ending to make sense. I hate the “bury your gays” trope with passion, even though I also love angst.
My editor came back and apparently the tension is still there. She suggested I either remove the minor character completely or lean in and make them have a torrid love affair in the middle of the deadliest war in human history. I have to do a whole rewrite anyway, so the workload isn’t an issue.
The three issues above is the issue.
So, people of Tumblr. Please, for the love of all that is good and rainbow covered help me make this decision.
What should I do?
Pick the boys up, put them side by side and make them kiss
Keep the minor character gay but remove the romance
Keep the main character gay but remove the romance
Remove the whole plot, no gays will be buried here















