To be honest, this whole “there is no point in comparing the show and the books when they are two completely different mediums” thing is a very overused and jarring excuse that I’ve literally only encountered in the Game of Thrones discussion forums.
People in the LOTR fandom don’t attack Tolkien fans because they wish they’d had Tom Bombardil in the movies. And yet every time there’s some serious and fact-based discussion about how problematic some of D&D’s choices are, there are always people going “Well then why are you watching?” or “Shut up they’re different mediums they can’t do X”.
It’s just an easy way to shut down critics, at this point. Because at the end of the day, the Tom Bombardil comparison I made is a very mild comparison. Most LOTR/Tolkien people agree that it would have been anticlimatic and weird to have Tom in the movies, in spite of how fascinating he is in the book.
But what would the Tolkien people say if Peter Jackson had decided to make Faramir take the ring? Or Eowyn be graphically sexually assaulted by Grima? Or cut Galadriel’s involvement in the story to profit Celeborn’s character?
Because this is what it feels like to be an ASOIAF fan right now












