I've Lost Patience With the Nalu Fandom
Leave it the the Nalu fandom to get me out of another hiatus.
I wasn’t planning to make a post about this particular drama. This was part of another post I was already working on for some other time.
However, Mashima’s been to France again and did another interview over the weekend. In response to a question, he said that Natsu and Lucy consider each other to be more than friends. If you were only listening to most of fandom, you’d think that Mashima confirmed that Nalu was absolutely going to happen. All he did was say that Natsu and Lucy consider each other to be friends.
I know that sounds like a big deal, but it shouldn’t be. Mashima’s already said as much in the past. Someone pointed out that he said that in the same afterword he mentioned not writing Nalu as romantic. He likes writing them as more than friends, but not necessarily romantic. In fact, he clarified that as his vew a few days later.
I appreciate Mashima’s consistency about Natsu and Lucy’s relationship. In fact, I’ve come to appreciate it over the years. Nalu was always going to be popular as a romantic ship. However, I’ve had fun playing with the idea of them working together, without having to consider romance.
To be honest, I don’t blame fandom for going crazy over this kind of thing. Mashima will draw Natsu and Lucy looking at each other, and fans will wait for their proposal in the upcoming chapter. This is something I’ve come to expect from fandom.
For now, though, excuse my skepticism over this translating into Nalu becoming a canon couple. Until Mashima changes course in canon, I’m not budging on my views or expectations on the ship.
“Now you're just being ridiculous. Mashima has made it obvious that he's going to make Nalu happen. You're so in denial if you think he won't.”
Fine, let's run through the list.
Has either Natsu or Lucy had a moment in canon where they acknowledge genuine enthusiastic romantic feelings for each other?
We've gotten moments fans have argued hint towards the ship happening. Obviously, fandom is going to skew towards those moments showing Mashima favoring their ship.
However, I'm losing patience with fandom over this point.
This series is two decades old. We've gotten more chapters of Fairy Tail material than most normal shonen series run for.
Has Nalu gotten a moment like Orihime’s five lives speech in Bleach?
Has Nalu gotten a moment like Hinata saying she's saving Naruto because she loves him?
Has Nalu gotten a moment like Benio losing herself to corruption but being centered by realizing she loves Rokuro?
Has Nalu gotten a moment like Haru realizing the reason he still fights is that he loves Elie?
Has Nalu gotten a moment like Gajeel saying he wants to protect Levy?
I could go on, but you get the point.
Admittedly, every ship doesn't need to have a moment like this to be canon. Bluebell happened without a moment like this. However, I'm sick and tired of hearing that Nalu is a surefire ship when we're still waiting for either to outright say they even like the other person twenty years into the series.
I can't be convinced that Mashima, who is hyper sensitive to fandom’s wishes in multiple other aspects, isn't making a conscious decision not to confirm Nalu. In the same interview, he said that he’s aware of what fans want, but that isn’t affecting how he’s writing them. That’s a bigger stain on Nalu than fans might want to give credit. Especially considering he was fine ending the original series without giving them that kind of catharsis.
I can imagine a world where Nalu happens. However, it wouldn't be the grand fantasy fans want or expect. It would happen without incident. It certainly won't be the well developed ship fandom has deluded itself into believing Nalu is or will be.
Could we get another sequel to further extend this whole thing? It's not out of the cards. It's not like we expected the sequel we got. However, it would be foolish to assume such a sequel is a given. Even more to assume that it will absolutely confirm a ship ten or more years after the end of the current sequel.













