My infinity train season 4 theory protagonist
Okay, so I know that the future of Infinity Train is up in the air (support it on hbo max if you can!). But, assuming it does happen, I have a sort of out-there theory for who could be the next book protagonist. Most people think that it will be Hazel and Amelia, but I don’t think it will be.
Why Not Hazel and Amelia?
The seasons have very loosely connected protags. This is sort of a hallmark of the show, because we can explore wider parts of the infinity train by following the stories of sort of unrelated people. Lake and Tulip crossed over briefly, but then their narratives were completely different, so we could explore new aspects of the world. Following Amelia and Hazel would essentially be a straight continuation of season 2, because Hazel and Grace’s story lines were so related.
I think it’s gonna be...... Lucy!
Lucy was a member of the Apex in season 3 of IT. She was one of the younger members of the group and strangely, very sympathetic towards the “nulls”. She still saw them as exotic pets, but that could be addressed as she grows and develops.
Why Do I Think She’s Significant?
She is given a lot of character during season 2. Despite being what I would call a side-side character, she has some pretty complex emotions for a random child character.
“however Lucy expresses interest in keeping the light person. After Grace reminds Lucy of the Apex's position on denizens being "Nulls,"”
She needs to be reminded to see the denizens of the train as nulls, which is a pretty complex characterization we don’t see from any other the other characters (besides Grace and Simon) in the Apex.
“Simon confronts Grace with a broom while calling her a "Void," although she shows obvious discomfort at treating her former leader this way. She later witnesses Simon condemning Grace to be wheeled, but watches in horror when the two start to fight”
This moment is what really made me take notice of Lucy. She is given an awful lot of focus during the final climax of season 3, despite seemingly being a random side character. For a little bit, I thought she was going to be a Chekhov's Gun, and that maybe she’d accidentally push Simon off the train to save Grace, which nicely parallels her refusal to throw the light person to the wheels. But obviously that didn’t happen. But I think the significant tone given to Lucy still means something, and she will be more significant than expected. And, she nicely fits the theme of being loosely related to the prior season.
While she is unusually significant in the show, she’s also unusually significant to the creators.
She was actually foreshadowed in season 2 when Grace tells Jesse to not point the train-hopping machine at his face
Her character design is actually based on a childhood photo of an IT writer.
She was going to be in the season 2 episode that introduced the Apex, but was cut for time. This suggests that the writers have had some plans for Lucy for a long time.
If you have any more evidence, or any disproving evidence, please let me know! I would love to hear everyone else’s theories.
(yes I know that the next season’s protag has so far only been introduced in the 7th episode of the last season, and episode 7 of season 3 did reintroduce Amelia, I can’t refute that lmao)