Whatâs the biggest mistake that you made?
Catherine: Hmm⊠seems fine. Butâ(leans in)âI want to ask you something. And I want you to be honest.
Gary: (half-smiles) Iâll try my best.
Catherine: Whatâs the biggest mistake youâve made⊠one you actually regret? Andâif it happened againâwhat would you do differently?
Gary: (lets out a low whistle) Whoa⊠thatâs a heavy one.
Catherine: (laughs softly) I know. But stillâbe honest.
Gary: (sighs, takes a moment) Okay. There was this girl once⊠someone I liked, adored, cared for. Maybe the closest thing to love Iâve felt so far. She was beautiful, a little wild, had this sparkling giggle that could light up a room⊠just ridiculously cute.
Her trust in me, the way she leaned on meâit felt good, meaningful. I loved spending time with her. And honestly, I think⊠maybe she felt something too. Even today, some of those memories make me smile.
Catherine: She sounds wonderful. She mustâve been lucky to have that effect on you.
Gary: (shrugs) Maybe. But luck hasnât exactly been on my side in love. Iâve lost people, drifted away from others⊠and each time, I lose a piece of myself too.
Catherine: Waitâ(leans forward)âyou lost her? When everything was that good?
Gary: (nods slowly) Yeah. And thatâs where the mistake lies.
Gary: Everything was fineâuntil I told her how I felt. From that moment, it was likeâsuddenly, I wasnât enough anymore. My efforts? Not enough. The way I dressed? Not enough. The way I walked, the way I satâ(shakes head)ânot enough. My kindness? Not enough. Even my smile was âtoo plain.â
And her verdict? I was âtoo nice.â
Catherine: (frowns) That mustâve stung.
Gary: At first, I laughed it off. But slowly, it ate at me. And when youâre under that kind of constant nitpicking, you react one of two waysâyou either bend yourself to fit, or you snap and start resenting them until the feelings rot away.
Catherine: (softly) That sounds awful.
Gary: (waves hand) No need for sympathy. I did it to myself. I donât even know why, but I kept trying. I forced myself into someone I wasnât. Changed the way I dressed, spoke, even thoughtâjust to be âenoughâ for her. And the irony? That fake version of me actually impressed her more.
Catherine: (shakes head) Thatâs rough.
Gary: Inside though, I was falling apart. I was exhausted. Sleeping way too much. Sometimes Iâd randomly crash for ten minutes in the middle of the day. The mental toll was⊠heavy. And despite all that, there were still times she disrespected me.
Catherine: Damn⊠I get it. Doing things you donât want to, just for someoneâand still not being valuedâthatâs painful.
Gary: (nods) Exactly. And then⊠I cracked. My patience snapped. My tone changed. Words came out wrong. The âtoo nice guyâ suddenly becameâ(air quotes)âârude.â
(sighs) And then came the real punch. One day, I did something simple, genuine, a little romantic⊠and she called it creepy.
Catherine: (eyes widen) What?
Gary: (laughs bitterly) Yeah. That broke me. For someone like meâwhoâd never even imagined being seen that wayâhearing that word⊠it was crushing. Honestly, it messed me up badly.
And the irony? All this time, she acted as if I were her boyfriendâtook all the care, all the attention, all the supportâbut never gave back what a real relationship should.
Catherine: (shakes head slowly) Thatâs just⊠sad.
Gary: After a short break, we reconnected. And I told myselfâdonât spoil the time left, just make the most of it. Then came another, longer break. But this time, something changed. I found myself again. My composure, my confidenceâthey came back. The scars were there, sure. But at least I wasnât messing things up anymore.
When we met again, she noticed the change. She was surprised. Suddenly, she started texting againâsomething she hadnât bothered to do during that long silence. But me? I was calm. Detached almost.
Then one day, I overheard her friend say, âThat guy is too nice.â And she replied, âItâs not that heâs too niceâsometimes, because of how weâve been treated in the past, we donât know how to appreciate nice people.â
Catherine: (raises brows) And?
Gary: (chuckles quietly) I couldnât help itâI laughed under my breath. She noticed. That day⊠was the last time I saw her or in fact interacted with her.
Catherine: Whoa⊠what a rollercoaster. Soâwas liking her the mistake?
Gary: (shakes head) No. The mistake was believing her charade about the âdream guyâ she wanted. The truth isâthereâs no point in losing yourself just to earn someoneâs validation.
(sits back, firmly) Losing yourself is never worth it.
Know who you are. Do what you canâbut only if it fits naturally into your life. Because if it costs your peace, your balance, your sense of selfâitâs too much.
Change yourself too much for someoneâwhether they appreciate it or notâand eventually, itâll break you. And when it does, youâll end up right back where you started.
Catherine: (quietly) Oâ