Goodnight Moon: A Critical Analysis
I love reading to Baby S. My wife and I read the same books to her at bedtime most nights. And because sheâs only 5 months old, weâve decided that Go The F*ck to Sleep isnât age-appropriate, Goodnight Moon is a go-to for us.
Donât get me wrong, I love Goodnight Moon. Itâs a classic. Â
But can we agree that almost all of the objects in that room are strange? Â
Within the room in question, there is:
A telephone (What child needs a landline phone in their room?)
A red balloon (Was it the childâs birthday recently and this was left over? It must have been recent, otherwise it would have started to deflate and would no longer float.)
A picture of a cow jumping over the moon (Not my particular taste in paintings, but I suppose art is subjective.)
Three little bears, sitting on chairs (See above.)
Two little kittens (Weâll get back to these later.)
A pair of mittens (Fine - kids play in the snow, get their mittens wet, and they need to be hung up to dry. But shouldnât there also be a hat on the drying rack? Snow pants? Other winter gear?)
A toy house (Totally normal for a kidâs room. No issues here for once.)
A young mouse (Really? A rodent just sitting there? Why arenât the kittens taking care of that? Seems unsanitary to me? Isnât that how the bubonic plague started?)
A comb and a brush and a bowl full of mush (Does a kid really need both a comb and a brush? Wouldnât one or the other do the trick? And whatâs the deal with food just sitting out in a bowl? Wouldnât this attract the mouse? Especially since the cats are clearly ineffectual at keeping critters at bay ...)
A quiet old lady who was whispering âhushâ (So many questions. Who is this lady? A babysitter? A nanny? The childâs mother? Another relative? A stranger who broke in and who is likely freaking the heck out of the poor child?)
A light (No issue here, but if itâs bedtime, why is the light on and shining on the balloon? That would cast a shadow that would probably look like a ghost and freak out the kid!)
Two clocks (Why two clocks? Is the kid obsessed with time? Is the kid worried about being late? Seems like a recipe for anxiety to me. And these are the old-fashioned wind-up clocks by the looks of them. Imagine the ticking! No wonder the kid canât sleep and just keeps talking to all the objects in the room!)
And donât get me started on the âGoodnight nobodyâ page - Iâm going to start telling people I provided the illustration for that one. Â
Itâs possible that this may be exhibit A in the case of âWhy Mattâs childless friends fake seizures to get out of conversations with him.â